Soares
2, Eduardo Cupertino Ballester
2, Eduardo Marques Izeppi
2e Ronaldo Olivera Cavalli
21Programa de Pós-graduação em Aqüicultura, Centro de Aqüicultura, Universidade Estadual Paulista, Via de Acesso Professor
Paulo D. Castellane, s/n, 14884-900, Jaboticabal, São Paulo, Brasil. 2Programa de Pós-graduação em Aqüicultura Estação
Marinha de Aquacultura, Fundação Universidade Federal do Rio Grande, Rua do Hotel, 96210-030, Rio Grande, Rio Grande do Sul, Brasil. *Autor para correspondência. E-mail: mauricioemerenciano@hotmail.com
! "
# $! %! & &' & & (
! & ) *" + & ! " & $& &
% ± ' ," & & & - & & . $& &
/ " 0 & (& & (& )1 &2 " & ) !
! )3 %/4 5 6 7'8 " & & ) !
& ! )3 %/4 5' " " ! )3
% 5 6 7' & ! & " & & 3 & # &"
& & ( ! & )
! & & ) 3 & & # "
! " #! $ %
& ' ! # 9# ! # & & " : ; &
" # ! # # % ! &' # ; #
&" ! # " & : # & / + :& &
% ± ' ; - & <& # & : ! . &
9# & ; # # & # ; "& 2 # & !
! & ; # &" : %/4 5 6 7'8 # & & ! ! &
&" %/4 5'8 ; "& ; # &" : % 5 6 7' 9#
& ! ! & # & ! !! ; # &" # " & :
!
( & ! " & : < &# ; # !
= ! > & ?& & &
& ," @," > )
" ")3 1 & +
& %5"0 -' A > && ")3
& & && & &"& &
5 & ,B( & ! & &"
& & ?& & > 5 "
C? "& ? 9 " =D %C? "&
& ' & ! 0 & &
& "?0 & % < 8 4 #
A -8 =" & -'
& " & &" & & & &
," & & )3 " >& "
$ # $!
% " (&
! ( &" "
,B " " " *
"& " ," & "
" )3 &&3 ! " &
& ,B "0
)3 & & & & & " &
& " ,B " " & &
& & & &
> "0 & ")3
&& )3 ) & >
& & >& " "
& & & & % D &# 8
; : 8 && 8 #
8 E # 8 " ! +'
* & & " & F &
& )3 & & & & & &
> & & ! & ")3
%G < & .8 ; : '
>& " &
)3 & &&"& &3
! & " ")3 &
& "? & & ! 0 &
&," & & & & & & > &
0 & & " & J 0
! & & & &" &
& && 3 & &
& & & " " &
& " 0 & & &
" ! &" F && K
! )3 && & ! &
" > " 0 )3 &
& & ? " ," &
&" " "
!? & L & &
% && 8 ; : 8 #
-' % +' !
& ( & &" & M " "
I &" & " & "
# & & & ! # & " 0 ; :&
& "! & 7 E & &<: % N'
! " "
# $! % & &
# $! & >&
" ) O ( O!$&! '
" & " # ! & ! &
& & & & ( &
&" )3 # & &3
! & ) 0 & " 0 )3
& & )3 " & & &
& !
& ")3 1 & & &
& & & & ," & "
& ( # "
? " % " P+'
" 3 &
& " & & &
"& > & K& &
" & ," && " ? "
& > &&" "
&& && & & " & &
& ! & & & (
& ! & ) " " &
! "0 @& )3
# ," " " A ! &
# %@ ' 0 A 5 &&
%+ Q R . Q. RE' " ? 7 S
@& 7 S " K
/" )3 J & / 7 S
/J7S @& 7 S "
& $& & %A4&' " 0 &
% & > ±
P P+± & ' ! " &
& . A4 " + & &
>& && " " 0
@ > " &
# % N'
& & & "? 2 "
& ) ! !
)3 % A" T - M A '
%/4 5 6 7'8 " & ) ! &
! )3 %/4 5' " H " &
&I % " ! ! '
! )3 % 5 6 7' & & !
& " & ! )1 & & "
M &&
& A4& ! & "? & "
&" 0 (&
& (& )1 & & "
& "? " ," &
" " " U - &
% & &' )3
>& & & & " )3
. M A
" )3 " ! " ,"
0 4 & & " " "
& 1 & % '
# $! & " %& &
' &" &
= " " & & !
" 0 " & $ !
" U P & % M
' & " & &,"
" )3 &
0 " ," 0
& K ! )3 & & &
& " & & " &
" & - & & "
" )3 $ #
)3 . > % 4 -'
$& & ," !
" " )3 &
" & "& ! "
# $! ! 0 )3 F @&&
! 0 )3 " )3 !
) )U $ )3 !
& & ! " )3 %
& ' ( %5O=' + 2 &
&& )3 &"
& )3 $
9 & & 1 & ! & & ?
! % ) ?
"&T &3 ' / &
& & ! O
& ' & ! !
% ! >& ,"?
&3 ' && ! % &
! & ( ' # & % & !
& " & + & ?
' "
& & !?& ,"? & " G
& ( && ! &
L ! &! !
& & (& 0 & & ,"
&"& &3 % ? " & & ,"
-. V ' ! & & " 0
< A & &
% ' > && ! 0 & &
! ! & " "
F " & $ $
" 0 &
5 " ! & )3
$ & & " 0 &
! 0 )3 F )3 & ! & &
& & " % !
>& " &' & & & !
0 & 4 $ =" )3 4=
K J & / A &
J/A@4 @& 7 S " & " &
& 5 % P-'
& & ! &" & K & F
% = C " ' & )3 &
&& & & & ! ) & & ! &
% W .' ! & 9"< :
& & > & & & !?& ,"? &
& 3 && & 9 & &
& & & & & & >
A & # # % ' &
# % ' E & &<: % -' 9&"0"<
% ' E & &<: % '
/ 0 > & %X & 3 ' & & !?& ,"? &
" " 3 & ! &
) Y
/4 5 6 7 /4 5 5 6 7+
9 " %Q5' + N %X - ' + -N %X .' + .- %X N'
+N + %X N' +N %X +' +- .- %X . '
( && % 4 ' P %X ..' %X .+' %X .-'
G %X ' %X ' P + %X '
L % 4 ' %X N' - %X ' - %X '
= % 4 ' %X - ' + %X + ' - %X '
/ &! % 4 ' %X +' %X N ' P %X '
Y > & & # & 3 ! & ! & 9"< : % Z .' %/4 5 6 7' " & ) !
! )3 8 %/4 5' " & ) ! & ! )3 +% 5 6 7' " " ! )3
& G L ! &!
& ! ) & & ! & &
& % W .' & ! & &
& & ) & ! & &
%/4 5 /4 5 6 7'
)3 " K )3 G
& " & & & && & &
& & )3 &
& & )3
$ @& &" &
& &" & & 9
% ' E & &<: % N' = &
)1 & L ! &
" " & & % 5 6 7'
& & &" "
& " & > U " )3 3
&" & & ," !
&! L & & ) &
& " & )1 &
& & & & > %E & &<:
-' [ & " & &" & &
& & ) & &
K &
" & % )3 ! 0 & F &'
" & K "
& &&?
& " > &
! & && ? [ U " ! &!
& & & ! # & ! & &
& %/4 5 6 7' %/4 5' >
& " & %
," ! #
' &
& ! " && )3
" )3 & & &
! F > "
= 9 & 3 && & & &
& )3 $ & &
" 0 & ! 0 & F & ,"
0 !
! & " + -M
? " & & & $ & &
& & D &# % ' 9
% ' & % -' E & &<: % N'
/ ) A " > & % ' ? " %A ' &Y %5 ' > %@@' ! " %/ ' 0 & & & " 0 & ! 0 )3 F
," 0 !
D %M' A %M' 5 %M' @@ %M' / %M' 5 0 & %M'
/ 9 PP P N + N
) N . N P N- N
-* - + +. N + N
/ P + - - P+ +
Y @& ! )
* 9 + & &
)3 %/4 5 6 7' "
! )3 % 5 6 7' 3 !
& % Z .' )3 & ! &&
! # & %+ &' !
= & & &" &
&" & % W .' ," &
," & & ! " &
# $! & ! )3
%/4 5' & ( ," 3
& ! ) & & ?& & & ! &
& & % W .'
/ . > & 3 & ! && !
# & ! & ( $& &
3 & & " + &
& ! & &%
/4 5 6 7 /4 5 5 6 7+
&%%
A & ! % ' .. P+
%X '
-%X + P'
.
-%X N'
&& ! % ' N
%X '
-%X +'
. %X .P'
S # & % ' +N P+
%X '
+ %X + P'
-%X N'
5 !
% '
. +
%X .'
N
%X N ' %X P '
( %M' +
%X + N' P %X P . '
+ +
%X '
+N
Y > & & # & 3 ! & ! & 9"< : % Z .'YY& '=? & ! F %/4 5 6 7' " & ) !
! )3 8 %/4 5' " & ) ! & ! )3 +% 5 6 7' " " ! )3
& 3 ! & !
% Z .' & ( &
! )3 & ! &
& & " ! & &
%P M' ," ," ! & +
+ +M & & & ! &
! )3 "
! )3 & ' =
E & &<: % N' #
" & " # " & +
1 & & ! & &
? & & (
"&( )3 % N P M' " & & ! &
" & " & & & )3 "
," & & & " <
% +' & " ! &
& $& & %A4 '
& & ( P- -M &
+ 1 & & & & " & & [
[ & % N' & " ! )3
$ # &
1 & )
& & ( & . P- PM &
& & )3 $ #
& & & & " & 3
! ) & & ! & % Z .'
)3 & U & & !
& + &
* & & & $ &
! %/ " ' & "
&" "
& & " &
! )3 )3 &" & )3
$ & &&? 0 !" " & &"
)3 & & " &
# F > F
" &&? ! " & &
& & & & $!
& " & ? > N
% : " !! N+'
2 ' 0 & $ " !
! ! % " '
* & & " & & &
! & & & " " "
1 & # &
& > $ ? " # % D &#
8 ; : 8 9 8
&& 8 +8 #
-E & &<: N' " ! % -'
," & M
&" " # & &
! & # $!
@ & # & )
&& & & " 3 " "
# & # 0 > @&
! & "? # &
! K " &&
" ! ) & # % " ( '
& > & ! & " &
% -' & ! ( "
# & ! % "
& & && " 0 F
&" !? & &" & &' &
" ! # $ & & &
1 & & > & & &
!
& & &
@& " & & K
& & # & & ,"
" & ! & & & !
)1 & # & " "
! & $ & !?& ,"? &
& )3 && & )3
)3 &" !? &3 &
" & ) ! F
& )3 & & " & &3 & &
&&? & & && & )1 & %@ &
PN8 S & # < PP8
A : PP8 7 & 8 5 ;
\ < : -' J 0 &&
)3 "0 "
"0 " & > & &&
& " >
& " )
" &
? " & & && &" &&
@ )3 K & & ! &
& " &
&"& &3 % ? " & & ," -.
&' " " )3 ?
% & ? - 4
& ' & > PN ±
+ P 4 %/ " ' = 3 &
& " 0 )3 & ? " &
&"& &3 & & & & & "
1 & # & > & & "
! ," ! )3 & ! & "
& & "
&" &? & ," & & " &
? & ) & & > &&
" & )3 & &
& &&"& &3
& 0 & &" & 1 &
#
'
4
0
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350
dia 0 dia 5 dia 10 dia 15 dia 20 dia 25 dia 30
5
2 ' ) C & > & &"& &3 % 4 ' &
& ! & &
& "
/ >& % N' & ,"
" ( ?
" %A ' " $ & -.M A
[ % N' "? ," & ? &
& &" & " )3 ! #
! & & > N M &&
# & & > )3 K "
# ," &&" # & ?
& &" ," & ! & & &&
& " & " &
1 &
)3 F # & &
" ! & F & !?& ,"? & "
# & >
&" " 3 && &
& & # & & &&
& ) &
! & 3 ! " & #
" " ! & ) A > " &
& " & & "0 &
& ! & &
F && & &
& " & &
#
! ! ! !
& " & 5 & 5=A,
/ A@7S " ]"? 49* K /" )3
J & / 7 S
& " ? &," & Q " ! & &
& 5 & E E & &<: 7 5
&3 &," & & 5=A,
44*7@*S@ 4 8 S 9 5G 4\ 5 D & " &
# ! & ; " ( )
E ++ + ++ +. PP
@ A " & " )3 ! # !
& & & 3 &
% ' * + N % '
AJ* / * , (
- . D 2 @ /*@5 ," " " *
P+
5 && ! !! : 5# & &
) - ( 2 5
P-^4 7 @ 7 8 J954D//@ E G * &&
& ; & & " ! " !
" ( ) E P - +N +
N+
7S@ 4 & &"
! " & 3 "
# 3 & &
! & " & . / ]_D @75
- C $ C $ 2 D & " @ &
-D** =* 8 A @7 ^ 4 7
"& & ; D &" &&
-& ! - PP PP
7 9C 4* * 8 7 E*^ 5 4 @!! & ! &
& &" ! & % ," &9 '
" ; ," : :
& " # " " &:& 0
& . P
-7 5\ [ 7 & ;
! 9 " : ! / &# # & . 2
/4@S@4 9 E 8 57 @ D G %@ ' 1
0 ... 2 / &# G # &
/ &# & : .
P-7 E*^ 5 4 A & & # !
& &# " " &:& & . / 7 E*^ 5 4 8
[ 7^ * @ %@ ' $ 2 , 3 # & (
," " "
7 " 2 9# E ," " " :
+-J7/ 7* =" : &
# # & : 0 # &# & 0
0 & + + - +
J7/ 7* 9# " ! ! "
&# %" # ' "
# # & : 0 # &:& 0
& + . . .+
-5 E@= [ A # & " : !
&" &2 ! & - 4
! - P. .
5J` = S =" ! " #
<& & 0 & +.
. + ..
-@D * / " ! " ! &"&
& " & 2 5 + &
O+ P+ PN
/7a@ 5 = @! & & &
! & ? & ? " & (
& 3 &
%A> 0 / ! N ' 6 N % '
G A\D= [ @!! ! ; ! &
! & ; ," : " !
& &# & ; # " ; #
5 3 0 ! N + .
[@= @= 4 7 ! $ #
; # &" ! # &#
" & : <& 2 N
% '
4DSG9=@7 * C 8 A =9 [ 5 7 D ! "&
: & & %D ='2 5" & "& # :
! # # ! &
# & . //@= 5 = - = + = 2
55 -
-\@A\ ^ A @ A
: ! & - & !
+ + -
-75GD 7D 7 ( ( 89
# ( 9 & & :
7 S 2 /J7S N
@@ [ 9# "& ! # "& &
; : &:& & ! # &" & " !
! ;# &# " # # J
& 7 0 (# 4 " & N + - -+
+
D=9 G * 9# !! ! &"
# # # & : " " !" # ; #
; " < &:& ;
# 0 & .
S ! # " " 2 @!! &
; : & & &# " " . /
7 E*^ 5 4 8 [ 7^ * @ %@ ' $ 2 , 3 #
& (
," " " 7 " 2 9# E
," " " :
* : ! & "&
A &# ," " " . /4@@ 5 8 R 7^@=
A %@ ' - 0 ,
# ( 0 (
7 " 2 9# E ," " " : P
=J=@ [ A 5 " " ) 2 " &
& ! & & & C? "&
& D ! & %D =C' & 0; 7
[ - P+ + .
-A @7 5G 4 G 8 75GD 7D @!
( 3 & & A> 0
/ ! N . / @=5 =97 = 5D = 4 *@
]bD5J49J7 A "? A "? 2
&& )3 & ,B " " && )3
& A & & & & ," &
.
7D@ @ @44 J A "
D A#:& & & - & !
N + P
5G 9 * !
: & " &# "
# & ! 4 "& . / 7 E*^
5 4 8 [ 7^ * @ %@ ' $ 2 , 3 # & (
," " "
7 " 2 9# E ," " " :
N- .
5G 9 G # & ! !
&# " . //D/9G D=9@7= 9D = 4
5 =/@7@=5@ = 7@5D75J4 9D=S
]J 5J49J7@ 7 < - - -P
=9 G 8 75GD 7D @! G
& 3 &
%A 0 / ! N ' . / @=5 =97 = 5D = 4
*@ ]bD5J49J7 A "? A "? 2
&& )3 & ,B " " && )3 &
A & & & & ," & N
7@ 7 =" & ! ! "
0 # &:& ! &
( . / J 97 4D = ]J 5J49J7@ : :2
5 D7 ," " " - P
A@5\ 7 5 @! & &
& ( $& & & & A> 0
7 D4@D7 7@ 5J49DC *@ 5 7c
-[ 3 A && [ 3 A && 2 57 ," " " +
+N +P+
97D5\4 =* [ * G 8 A 7 = 9 7
( < , / &# & 7 & # !
5 ; 2 " N
9 5 = S [ @!! ! " " &:& #
" ; # ! ! A ! ;# &#
" # % ' ! !! & 0
2 ! P +
9 J`J\D ^ 9# !! & ! "
& : # &" !
& 5 3 0
! + -. -NP
E@D7D5G 5 7 A : # 0 !
: # &" & &#
" &:& . / D=9@7= 9D = 4
5 =/@7@=5@ = 7@5D75J4 9D=S
]J 5J49J7@ - <& " & ( d
<& " 2 C 9 # J & : ..
E D@4@ \^ E [ @! L &
$& & 3 & & A 0
/ ! N %* 2 A ' 2 7
S .
-E D@4@ \^ E [ # ( = # ( 9
>1 ( & ( ! ? (
" ( & / ( 6 9 &
%* " ! $ ' /" )3
J & / 7 S 7 S
E D@4@ \^ E [ @!! ! " "
0 # &"& ! & &"
& " " &:& ! ;# &# "
# 0 & .P + N - + N
+ # ( 2 # @A BCCA