Animais em aulas práticas: podemos substituí-los com a mesma qualidade de ensino? .

Texto

(1)

! "#$ %%&

! "#$ %%&

! "#$ %%&

'% () * '! . -! + %%,

0(:

&/;

(%(<#'#=(.

(:

, '

)*'

-

,

/01*

.784598+

.<::22:283 32+

.2:7:28

=>0?*

.78:8<+

.3<2:H<::2+

.:7:28<

8$3*'%#!!#%%&

83@3*%,#%'#%%,

A3*&#%-#%%,

( 9

( 1 * ! 9 1 ( + 9 ! + 0 ( ! J 0 0@ ? 4 4 4 0 4 4 0 K ( ! ( 0 4( / 0 4 !

(2)

'% () * '! . -! + %%,

#2@ (# $#$@ (!&2 * 2'# 3'N'(&8'$@$# '8($'#6B#2@(##'('()G(2C#2(

2'$#'(##' (&$(=2'$(

(@ 3 (#B 2' # ' (#' $)*S#':@*4$('(2'(($# #@ (A $( (@ !#( ' ( 252 8'(2'2'#(2$$)*'( (@28(2C(=#2(N'(#A'( ##( (#@'22)*=#2(#B('! @$!'($(&#(#!(( 8'(((&#

252(#'##(8&$'52&$(7& 2= (2#(@N'&N'(*#3 $@##@2:((#((@' #'#((@452(2'=(&$:(2 ((((=2(1$:#@7(N'(2 #C&2(#'##('22#K

6'@#(=2'$H@2)('! #(#((22(#(E(#(#((#$ !'(##$('2'3'232#2 #C&2@2'(##2((N'((=2@N' ((((((!'('(#8$3(

H"@3$(F'&''(2(#;& 0$Q$&8(2#&2#N'( #*=#2(8'((@'8$2(#$ " L018$"#B@ 3A'!&5252(( 08#7+2'(@#*@8(#$ 2$S8!#2#(#(&B#2( &(( (@ F' &'. UE N' 8(# $2(=((('2(228)(&(2 )G(N'#(@((&#(( 2'(B#2($B$(V

'#$:)*('((@(' (N'(@ ( ! $( %2C( F'#B( 4#)*$@#((!$((@'( ($'23@&(2%2C((. H L'#$:)* =#( $##( ((C$M]

HL')*-(#=(B$

((##C(#2$#4#$N'(M]H" L##=22(#)*2)* $3!(((2C&2(@2((!52(M

#52'$#((2$(=2(=8 '((('$(B#2(N'('$ #@ AB (# $##' 2#C&2@ = (# $!'( C((@ 2 (#( (@ B@ $3

+#B$@('((AB8$'(''(/#

((@((AB(('8(##'C(@#2 #(2'(A'C::I

E( =#( $##( (* 2#( N' ':'('8(##''(((&# $!&''(&#$($!'

((((28#'($##((@& N'#(#=22(*':##(( 2#( 2)G( 2#( '#$:)* ' $ @ AB N' * (# W2 #)* # ( ((#( #'@ : (#( $( &2 ' 8 (* ( 2#(@ ((8$# ( !') N' # (#')* $@ 2$# $)* S( 2'!(@ ( $' # ' -:(

(#(((()G((C(@')* - ( ( = $#@ $# &$#232#(2#($)*S(#=2 2($##(@82#'#(#B$(+(( &$##2#$'@ABN' &((=2$#((($('2)*

4(#B($##((## 2'!(@('#'(@#(#(!(&2$7!2(4 #(&($!@#'#("!'#3J2$

8(@ $)* ( $( 2'#:(@ 3B #5( 2#!( 2(. (" '(@ (#( !(228)G(#4#@!B&2(@(@& #( ' )*] ( &#( B#2( #!(@ 2'A( !((*28(((#('('(]'@ @$#'$@(2#((*(#( #2(*@'(72'$((2(@ (#$!('*N'#(N'&$#( (8$

('8(##')*(((C(@$==#2@ #8==N'(#*$!$$&$H"I H5$

(L#5((('(*@$='$#M '((4#(N'$@( N' 3' =#( $##( $= ((@ 8A)* 2(252@((!'$(##')*@('#$: !#(#('(($'(N'(! (((#'#2'$(N''#$:(

B9CDE7&F.&BBG

T0(8#(@N'2$@((2 #8#LC#'$M

(3)

'% () * '! . -! + %%, mT+2((((N'$:452

$( ' 2'$ $ @ N' &( B#2('2#C&2(@N'4(#2'(($# #(

m T = '# ' (4# ' #)@ (

2#$

F'2#;&#3###(HLFM('

$##' 2#C&2 &# (# (('# 2#' I #8$3( N' $'( (#( '$( 2 =#( $##((#$3(3N'N' $(2=#(#2(@#8$3(N'(# N'$52 ( ( =#( ( ( N' & (' ( =#( 22( 2)*($##(E$3(3(= #($##($!'(#8$3((B(& #(@2@4$@((8$#)*( (( 2 #@ AB N' * 2((# )* ( 4#( ( '#( 2((@ 2#=22(2-!2(@2#('(2W2 ##(3'((@$=((8$ ' (((8$:)* ( (#'#(@ ( 2# 2C=2($(

#(52(N'('8(##')*( '$( = ((C$@ ' $3@ 2((B@ (!' ' #52'$#)*((@N'(&$# ($#B($##(S((2)*@(# #8$3 2 ( !'( (##( $'( '$ B#2@2((@&2!' :!(##(($'(()$(

A

C$:!($'(( !'((##(@2('#$:)*($8 #7'$B#2(##$(((# #((#($'($)*S()$'$ B#2

:

(##8$3&:#A#U(=#2( (2V@('8#$ #5 #2 %(N'( F(#$ >'$3 ,$@ #(L%M

E(#'#2'$)*$ 2'( 2 # (#B 0'(C L $'(M@#(@I1$(($'(@ ('(#'(LM#3(($3#(

(#8$2'('#2$'$B#2( #=22(2#$7!2(@(2$F(#$!E2 #- 8A#( '$ 5#2( ( '( #'(@ 2&)((#)*#=22('$( B#2( & $:( ( @ 2 )* 3B (/3S(I3/@($'(#''#$: 2#=222#$7!2($3#2=$'$('2 ( $@ $( 7( 6 '$ #' @ ( "3 S( J3/@ #=22 2#$7!2 ! & 7 !*(@N'('#$:''2'!IJ $" ##=$'(

'$B#22$&$((* #2(($'('$#C2 2('$:)*$!$7@(!' 84$)*(8('(=2$3!9 8=((2$2'N'$'(222)G(#((22 (#(#()&2'$##@(3'(8(# '$E$&#$8#72(2 (2&2=2#B($4@$ !($3(($'(@2(42(((#=(2 $#$8#7@AB(22-8#($@ $&((2'(&(((() ( $'(@ ('( C(2( & 4(#(@ 2 (# (#8')*&!#(2&2)*($W(

9( ( (#)G( B#2(@ ( $'( 2 8'N'(#BL4M$((#=22( &2 8 ('$:)* 2#$7!2@ 8 2 C$ :!$2#'(($'(N'2((#5( (##(@ ( $(#(@ N' 2((( ( 2(()('$(B#2(

( &)G( 2#( ( N'(#B( & ( ('82(22(($((

N'###N'$##@2('(#'(2 ((#)*(4

##$ $'( ( N'(#B ( ( '( #'( L M@ 8('( N'@ ("$'(#'@//(*(4&L"H@aM H@(2'$L@aM]#'@2(##'C"I$' (@ / (* (4 & L"@aM /@ (2'$ L"@HaM6#(@((@'C'$3(2'( 2@ 2( ##$ $'( (4 &L"J@IaM/(4(2'$L@IaM

(4)

'% () * '! . -! + %%,

/

& 1)-H0 +'(( a i r á t E a x i a

F TURMAA TURMAB TURMASAeB

s o n u l a e d º

n % nºdealunos % nºdealunos %

0 2 -| 7

1 26 41,3 37 56,9 63 49,2

3 2 -| 0

2 35 55,5 23 35,4 58 45,3

6 2 -| 3

2 2 3,2 4 6,1 6 4,7

9 2 | -| 6

2 0 0,0 1 1,5 1 0,8

l a t o

T 63 100,0 65 100,0 128 100,0

98$ (# ( (##( 4#( $( $'(N'(#('$(N''#$:(E( #5( (##( ( 2(@ #( (4 '

#'@2(2#@&.2'(@( #NO$E((##(&$2!'$3 *&2#( S O T N E M I T N E S A A M R U

T TURMAB

o n i n i m e F o x e S s a n u l a 4 4 e d % o n i l u c s a M o x e S s o n u l a 9 1 e d % o n i n i m e F o x e S s o n u l a 1 4 e d % o n i l u c s a M o x e S s o n u l a 4 2 e d % o ã ç a r i m d

A 2,5 8,5 4,3 11,3

a i n o g

A 5,8 0,0 15,4 3,2

e d a d i v i s s e r g

A 0,0 0,0 0,8 0,0

a i t s ú g n

A 10,8 0,0 9,4 3,2

e d a d e i s n

A 14,2 8,5 9,4 14,5

r a t s e -m e

B 0,0 4,3 0,8 1,6

a p l u

C 6,7 2,1 8,5 6,4

e d a d i s o i r u

C 28,3 36,2 22,2 29,0

o ã ç a r t n e c n o c e d e d a d l u c i f i

D 1,7 2,1 3,4 0,0

e d a d i c i l e

F 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0

a ç n e r e f i d n

I 2,5 12,8 1,7 9,7

e d a d i l i b a t i r r

I 2,5 0,0 1,7 0,0

o h l u g r

O 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0

a t l o v e

R 2,5 0,0 2,6 0,0

o ã ç a f s i t a

S 0,0 2,1 2,6 4,8

a i c a m e r p u

S 0,0 0,0 0,0 3,2

e d a d i l i ü q n a r

T 10,8 14,9 2,6 11,3

a z e t s i r

T 10,8 8,5 13,7 1,6

s o r t u

O 0,8 0,0 0,8 0,0

l a t o

T 100,0 100,0 100,0 100,0

R@

F

(5)

'% () * '! . -! + %%,

I

((98$&$8((1!'(@ E((##(&!'((#(@!# (@2'(&)(##((( ##((#(@'()*@(#(&)*@!' $3@8(#@&$2@('2#NO$]( ##(!#(@(@!@!-(#@#8$ @2'$@&2'$22#)*@!((@$#@ #(#:'#(@2

1!'(#(#8')*((((##( @ 8(( 2$(( 2 ' #@ 2(( ( #'( @ (4 (2'$ & 6#( N' Ia ( $'( $# (##( !#(@ $2( '(('$($(((4((@ 8@&2('C(##(!#( #('$3(@(N'8L"@aM@2)* ( Ja ( 3( 6(#(@ ( (##( (#( L@"aM &) L@aM 2# ( @a @a@(2##@('$3(6((2((@&2 # &) #52@ (# 8 2(22:((!'@$##S2 #! ( 3(

(1!'((#((##(4# ($($'((#'(@(2##@(# 2##'$8#7(#*('((

((8((#*($3# 1!'@N'3'C((##(!# ((#((*#(#('$3( ###'L1!'(M]#(3(@ ((##((#(&)L1!'(8 8M

?'#S(N'(#G(8A#(@!'#(& C$52N'2#=22(#'@&# 2)* 6 #' @ J@a ( $'( $# ( 8#('52@N'#@#' @I@a&(

98$(#(3($'((N'(#G( (2C&2(&2)*:!6#(N' &NO52$'(N'2##((N'(#G(=( $('(#'(@=#'(#''-$!# ( $ N' 2 S #' L"H@a"@a(2##M@((&)(!& 2# 6 B$( ( N'(#G( (@ ('$# (#' N'$52 # ( #'(@ * 3 (2 W2 # ( ( ' 2#( 6 2( N'(#* @ #'(#'N'$)*$)*-2#(]AB(N'(#G(/I@&#'N'(#' - 2#( (#( ('$#( * (# &)((##C(#2((!&2#(

K

'+L 3*+(@(+.()-+5/'

a m r u

T Númerodealunos

s o t r e c a e d ) % ( m e g a t n e c r o P

s e õ t s e u q s a s a d o

T Questão3 Questão4 Questão5

B e A s a m r u

T 128 64,8 93,7 73,4 89,1

A a m r u

T 63 62,3 100,0 69,8 84,1

B a m r u

(6)

'% () * '! . -! + %%,

"

"/&T##(4#($'((#2##'$8#7(*'((((

(7)

'% () * '! . -! + %%,

J

"/FT##(4#($($'(#'(#2##'$8#7(*'((

(8)

'% () * '! . -! + %%,

"/K T ##( 4#( $( $'( #' (# 2## ' $8#7 (* '((

(9)

'% () * '! . -! + %%,

H

'8$2)*$B%$'3$( P@IH@(!'#($:)*(N'( 2((&#$2#$')*&2'8 ((2('(((2=#N'()* 232#3@':N'(#8$2( (('(#(C2'$4(###(&#((=2( (@'2(($'#-2 (#&@# P((8$#'4#$((8#($( (((3'(((@(N'$=2@3'

'(2(*'((4#)*@ $$@&(!'(&((((

%$#"@$'@!&($!(#@'# $:'223(#)*('&$3'$('( $'(#(#@('((&''((2)* &((($8#7E&($!(#& &:#(#'2#(#(&#(& #(($8#7E8((((#8

$3 ' 2# # ( (##( ( ( (4(. (2'$@&#C((##((# (@((S&)@&:/@/a@2#$ @Ha(4&

!'$3@(2&$#(=#2(((B(*#B

(@((:((&#:(#W 2(232#(!(24#)*$ !((252('$2)*8&C2 (3'@@(((!'(N'#((#'((*2 ':(##($(((C$=#2

E(4#((*(*$:((2 8A#('!'#2#C&2@(#8= (#)*'&#AB2@2$# $'((2'(($!@2#B

'#( :(@ ( ##( ( 28 N' #)*$:4#*=(AA' (3'('252@(@(@8#('#&2 '$)*&(($2(N'(##

(2#8((#'(@##(4@ &2'((2#'#-$'( 22'(LI@"aM&8(#'@&# N' 22 2 ( # (((# S (#)* #=222($8#7@(#C2( N'()((#'$(''(@#$:$8A #&2)*(E'(((252 #$)*#@ABN'=8#'(#BN'( &(!((N'((((@(#$ (4(#(!')*E(3'((

##52:((('7(=2.23 (2(H

E($#(2$(212$!@94 2$!+'$!'#''(((=2'$/

?'('#$:(=#(#2(@(=2: (#)G(B#2(2(# #38$('(2'(#C'$ :!#=(29=22-!2@12$!1( $!@#'#(@('8(##')*((&#( A'C:($(((=#($##(4(##(@2 (# P3'(#I1P"#'@(#&

2)*#$!23$##+(((2( NO52&252'&$#232#&((( ((B(@82&$##2$!('#&2 #(')(

2#)*'(=#($##($(&((( (#'&(#(#SS ((@22(7(#('(($b'23@ (2C((((2(# #N'$&2)*((#'#((252(8=2(

6(##8$3@(#'(N'*3B&)#( =#($##((#2(8((#=22(& N'(('$:)*2$'$@ABN'#(*$2 )'!'52('Ia$)* :@&2(N'(#G(8A#(@*3'& )2##(#'(@('!N'('$# :!('(#'(&($@## #=22'#$:

6($@$&$N'!'$((2)*="" JHJ 22$@#(8'((

'$(B#2(()($3N'(#

(@2')*&4#B('(#B(8($ (@$(*(8(#B#26(##8$3@&2( A(#$'(#'N'$:''$B#2( '((@N'((($'(#3((

?'#S$')*'((4#)*@ '/$#N'@=2HJ@-4

#(2(@!$@&(2#7(((C@ 3''2$C@!(#B3''#@ #'!)*(!#2#&2(

'/(#N'@#'$#@(a((

'#$:((('&$'22$N'((=2(( '#$:((*#2'!B(C((7* '#$:)*((@$!'('((@2 F@#&#(3$'8@(#!( ('('8(##')*

(10)

'% () * '! . -! + %%,

/

S( $##(@ N' N' ' (## 2$@ = '2 '#)*

#'$#@ ( $( ( (* 2(( 2 #((#2(8&C2((#(('(& #$@:(2C(=#2( 4#)*?'(#(#8=(*($ '2@$=(#=22(22#(2#C&2(@ ':$((#'(=#2(($'(

F' ' (3 ($3# # ( '( #' ($)*S:!@(#N'('8(# #')*('$(=((C$@#(( N'$(

E(2#(B=2($#((8 2(($('#$!(@ABN'3B 52(N'@((#')G(@232# (8#2'#(&#(@#((&# $':$(=#2(($'(

:

6$(94@##(#B0' (C@$2#42')*(#(N'(

&49'$8(@&((((2 12'$2(*%'$ &((##'$#(#B0'(C@#(L%M@ $2$8)*(*#8$3

6-2$'#)*#C&2$'(@ (2$1`'&&8(@$$8)*( !B&2(#8$((##8$3@0#C2%232( #@$((G($C!'#'!'(!$(

"!

0'2@$4@N'(9@':60@'(( 0@6(%'$#=22(8#(n *%'$.Q>3]HH"

@@E$L!M($8 #7.2)*4#)*.12':] &; #32$ (2#( & $ 4## +. 9'&&;LM08#;$(.#'2#& P4#(6Pd<.3Q$;b(]HJ / +#623 ($ (C$ . Y3##.

PPP#238($! Z L2(( . / !(# IM

I $2893'(&$(3!3'2#%8$(@ $##( b 2#( Q(3!#. F' 2#;%((]

" '<(6@3'1>'%!#'#'(. $###3(&!((3''2# 02(#.$(]

J #3@1((@ P3'(# @#3`'2#$('$# $(#382$(22(+0HHJ]LM. ($0H"I@&HH (G(8((

)G(((##((2'#(# ($((8#@B'#(52( B E&2$*@(C$@&HH

H F'2#;&#3###(LFM# #'(& ((2#E#3$(( (C$. Y 3 # # . P P P 3 ( ' ( ! $ ( ^ ^ ( 2 3 $(^^'2# 2#^(#'(^&^((2#^ ^#3^$^'((3#$ZL2((./!(#IM ##&#@+2##2L#$;(((&#P(;(#M@( J (C$.3##. PPP(##(&#2L2((. IM

$314#)*2(.=#2$!($)* F%]LM.I

'(2393($Q$&T2&$2##3P; &P09o@@L('$ M."J"

1A7#$:)*=#($##((N'( '2)*('8(##')*((*3'( %]LM./HI"

/ '((&$(4#$(23.#32$ $>93;/]."/"

I P3'(# >@F2(#$ %9@ #'# ( & 2'#('$#!##$$8#; 2#2$2$((&#23!#32$(&#(#$8(# %3;($'2HH/]"J.HI/

" 1P0@23@9#3@0@8#(9@2<## 2(&#2#(2(#'2#P#3$ $$8#(%3;($HH]IH./

J ($0""@HJH(#8$2( B#2B#22#C&2(()*(# '#(52( BE&2$*@(C$@ HJH

E#!*(#'&$#+#(((

) + (+2(

#(#B0'(C$'( '$$(E$@I IJ#(%

Imagem

Referências

temas relacionados :