Democracia e controle externo da administração pública

(1)

!"#$%& #'! ("#)# *&+& ! ,- "& '#!* #. '#!# &/" ($%& )& 0!#- ) "! + ! "& )&

!&0!#+# ) 1 !#)-#$%& +

! "& )# #*-.)#) ) ! "& )# &(" 23* # ( 4 ! )#) #"1. *# )&

& !#() )& -.5

! ("#)&!6 !&25 !5 7 8

(2)

!"#$%& #'! ("#)# *&+& ! ,- "& '#!* #. '#!# &/" ($%& )& 0!#- ) "! + ! "& )&

!&0!#+# ) 1 !#)-#$%& +

! "& )# #*-.)#) ) ! "& )# &(" 23* # ( 4 ! )#) #"1. *# )&

& !#() )& -.5

'!&4#)& ' .# #(*# >#+ (#)&!# + ?< ) " +/!& ) ;<<=5

6

!&25 !5 7 8 ! ) ("

!&25 !5 @ #! " !/& #"& #("&. ( A : B !&25 !5 *#!)& !&((

(3)

(4)

(5)

J 8&+ + @ # + ) )# ) "&)# # *& # K5

(6)

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

)#) @) # @ -+ ' !3&)& + ,- & "#)& '!#" *#+ (" ) #'#! * O & * ("!& '&.3" *& @ & 2 -)&5

(# * ($# @ # @'&*# )& ! -!0 + ("& )& 4#.&! *.I *& O >#+ (# # +'&!"P(* # ) #,- #4 . *&+& & #'&.&0 "# ) -+ "#)& -( 2 *#)&9 .# *& #)+ ( "!#)& ' .& '!3(* ' 5

&- #-9 *&+& &."# ! &(" ,- -9 .#($# # )@ # ,- ! #+ #)&"#)# ' .# 4&.-$%& !#(* #9 ( * #()& # ) +&*!#* # +&) !(#9 ,- " !I (# &+-(# ) #! # '#!" * '#$%& ) 0!#() '#!* .# )# '&'-.#$%&9 *-H# ! 4 () *#$G (%& ! "! (0 + #' (# #& -2!I0 & D 2&!+# ! '-/. *#(#6 -# /#() !# %& *&(Q+ *# &* # 5 )@ # ) &*R 8&// %& "#+/@+ #/&!)#)# 9 '#!# ! .#* &(#! #-"&! *&+ & ' ( #+ ("& 2!#(*F 5

' ( #+ ("& &* #. "#9 *&+ #!>9 (0 . & #(#!,- "# 9 ) ! * &(# '#!# # +#(* '#$%& )# (# * (" *.# '!&. "I! #5 S -+# *&!! (" C-+#( "# ,- (*. (# '#!# # +# &! # )# &* )#) 6 & '!&)-"&! 5 0-()& & #( 2 "& ) ?TUT9 # . / !)#) # 0-#.)#) 1

!%& *&(*! "# ! #. )#) *&+ # #" 2#$%& )# ( * )#) 9 + ) #(" # *&(,- "# )& "#)& )# ) +&*!#* #5

) # &* #. "# %& *&.&*#)& + '!I" *# (# 4&.-$%& ) ?V?=9 ,- ( ' !# (# 2&!+#$%& )& &4 " (& > !*3* & )& '&) ! ) +&*!I" *&9 (# )@ # ) &- #-9 (# >' ! F(* # )# 4&.-$%& ) ?=TV (& *-!"& ' !3&)& )# &+-(#5

*!3" *# ) !#+ * #& +&) .& &4 @" *&9 ,- ! "&+# & ' ( #+ ("& &! 0 (#. +#!> #(& & #)#'"# D -# #"-#. )#) 9 ("!&)-E # " &/! /.&*& C 0 +Q( *&9 #. #($# '&.3" *# 9 & '#' . )& (" . *"-#. &!0P( *& # +'&!"P(* # )# )-*#$%& )# *-."-!# '&'-.#!5 S # ) +&*!#* # ) ("!& )# ! 4&.-$%&5

#!# & #(#!,- "# 9 # >' ! F(* # &*&!! (& *-!"& 4 !%& )# #(#!,- #9 )-!#(" # 0- !!# * 4 . '#(C&.#6 *&( .C& 9 2 ) !#. +&9 #-"&(&+ # .&*# 9 *&. " 4 E#$%& )# '!&'! )#) 0 "%& ) +&*!I" *#5

(7)

7

*&(*! " E#$%& )& ) ! "& &* # () 4 )-# 9 # '#!" * '#$%& (# 0 "%& # ) . / !#$%& *&( "#(" &/! # 0 "%& "#"#. & - *&("!&. 5

W-#("& #& *&("!&. 9 . > " ) ) & C /! - A@" *&B9 0! 0& A#-) "&! B !&+#(& A* ( &! BO (# )#) @) # -!0 + # *P+#!# ) *&("# "&!(#+ (&!+# *&(,- "#)# #)&"#)# (# *.#!#$G ) ?=TV + ) #(" 5 *&("!&. *&(" +'&!P( & @ 2!-"& )# 4&.-$%& !#(* # & +&) .& 2!#(*F + ) #(" -+ ! /-(#. ) &("# A?T<=B @ #)&"#)& ' .& !# . *&+ # ! 'M/. *#9 +/&!# (& !# . C&.#()F > " -+# *P+#!# ) *&("# 5

*! #$%& )& ! /-(#. ) &("# 9 # >'& $%& ) +&" 4& ) -X #!/& # & ) *! "& VYY %& # /# C "1! *# H-!3) *# )& " +# ) *&("!&. >" !(& /!# . !&5

" '& ) *&("!&. # *&+' "F(* # )& &) ! 0 .#" 4& )& ! /-(#. ) &("# 9 # ' *-. #! )#) 2 ) !#" 4# # " ) ,- & *&("!&. >" !(& @ ( " "- $%& ) +&*!I" *# ! '-/. *#(#9 ) " (#)# D ! #. E#$%& )# ) 0( )#) C-+#(#9 *&(*.- + # ) !"#$%&9 ! .#* &(#()& ) +&*!#* #9 ) ! "& C-+#(& *&("!&. *&+& -+ '!&* & C "1! *& ) #.@" *&5

(8)

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

C )). 0 Z ! # " + ZC ( "C "#" ( #!.X ) #'' #! O "C '&. " *#. *&! "C -)5

(# * (* Z# ZC ( "C *.# *#. 4#.- ! - * "#" )O

#,- #4 .[ +'&!"#(* Z# >#+ ( ) # # *&("!#) *"&! &2 # .# *#.9 -( 2 ) "#" 9 ZC *C Z# #)+ ( " ! ) /X "C ! (* 5

&- #-9 # Z .. # &."# ! #() &(" ,- - ("!&)-* ) ) # ZC *C Z&-.) / #)&'" ) /X "C ! (*C 4&.-" &(9 "C &( " &2 +&) !( ) +&*!#*X9 ZC *C Z&-.) C#4 9 ( "C #! &++-( 9 "C '#!" * '#" &( &2 .#!0 '&!" &( &2 "C '&'-.#" &(9 ZC& *.# + Z ! (&" &(.X ! "! *" ) "& -22!#0 #() "C ! '-/. *#( Z# 5 C ! *#- Z ! &* #. #() *&(&+ *#.5 &*R #() 8&// [ ) # #! #. & #''!&#*C ) ( #( #"" +'" "& ! .#" "C #-"C&! "& "C ! (*C . ( &2 "C&-0C5

&* #. " "C&-0C"9 Z "C #!>9 (0 . #() "C #(#!,- " 9 Z ! ) ! *" ) "&Z#!) "C +#(* '#" &( &2 "C '!&. "#! #( *.# 5 " # C-+#( " +&4 + (" ( 2#4&! &2 "C +#H&! "X &2 "C &* "X6 "C '!&)-* ! 5 &..&Z (0 "C +#( 2 "& &2 ?TUT9 . / !"X #() ,-#. "X Z .. &(.X / *&+ ! #. "X ZC ( ( * " #! 2-.2 .. )9 "C!&-0C 4#.- -*C # "#" #() ) +&*!#*X5

&* #. " ) #. #! '-" ("& '!#*" * ( "C ?V?= ! 4&.-" &(9 ZC *C Z# ( ' ! ) ( "C &4 " #() ( "C ) +&*!#" * '&Z !9 ( &- #-[

) # 9 ( "C ?=TV 4&.-" &(9 #() ( "C C&!" .# " (0 &++-( 5

!#+ * [ *! " * + "& "C &4 " +&) .9 ZC *C ! *&4 ! #() -')#" "C &! 0 (#. #!> + "C&-0C"9 ("!&)-* "C "C #/&-" "C C 0 +&( * +&4 + ("9 '&. " *#. #.. #(* 9 "C !&. &2 "C &!0#( *

(" .. *"-#.9 #() "C +'&!"#(* &2 )-*#" &( #() '&'-.#! *-."-! 5 " ) +&*!#*X Z "C ( "C 4&.-" &(5

&! "C #(#!,- " "C >' ! (* "#R '.#* ( "C C&!" -++ ! )-! (0 "C '#( C * 4 . Z#!6 #)4 &!X *&-(* . 9 2 ) !#. +9 .&*#. #-"&(&+ 9 '!&'! "X *&.. *" 4 E#" &(9 #() ) +&*!#" * +#(#0 + ("5

(9)

9

C *&("!&. C# > " ) (* "C 8 /! Z A "C * B9 ! R A#-) " (0B #() &+#( A* ( &! B5 C #**&-(" *C#+/ ! + !0 ( "C

)). 0 #() "C ( / *&+ #)&'" ) (&!+ 2!&+ "C ?=TV *.#!#" &( &(5 C *-!! (" *&("!&.9 # *&( ,- (* &2 "C ! (*C 4&.-" &( #() "C

! (*C +&) . "C!&-0C # &-!" &2 -) "&! A?T<VB9 #)&'" ) ( !#E . Z "C "C #!&- #. &2 "C '-/. *9 4 ( "C&-0C "C ! Z# &(* # &-!" &2

-) "&! ( "C -"*C !#E .5

C + !0 (* &2 "C &-!" &2 -) "&! 9 -X #!/& # J &" 4 >'& -! K #() "C VYY *! #! "C C "&! *#. #() H-! ) *#. /# &2 "C !#E . #( >" !(#. *&("!&. X " +5

C R () &2 *&("!&.9 "C 0 .#" 4 &Z ! #() "C &-!" &2 -) "&! *&+' " (* 9 "C 2 ) !#" 4 '#!" *-.#! "X #() "C "C "C#" "C >" !(#. *&("!&. # ) +&*!#" * #() ! '-/. *#( ( " "-" &(9 # + ) #" "C 2-.2 ..+ (" &2 "C C-+#( ) 0( "X9 Z () -' "C ) !"#" &(9 ! .#" (09 ) +&*!#*X9 C-+#( ! 0C" 9 #() *&("!&. # # ) #. *" *#. #() C "&! *#. '!&* 5

(10)

N

?]

? ?=

?5? ?=

?5?5? 8 /! - @" *# H- " $# ?=

?5?5; (" 0L )#) *.I *# 0! 0# ;;

?5; ;V

?5;5? #,- #4 . & " +'& & +&4 + ("& ;V

?5;5; 8&// &*R ]T

?5;5] ^5 ^5 &- #- '! 2I* & D 4&.-$%& !#(* # U;

?5;5U 4&.-$%& !#(* # # ) +&*!#* # +&) !(# @ > !* )#5 _< ?5;5_ &+-(# ) #! # 4&.-$%& )# 4&.-$%& ) ?=TV Y< ?5;5Y # ) +&*!#* # '&.3" *# D '&.3" *# ) +&*!I" *# =? ?5;5= \#!. #!> '! + !& #-"&! #"&! # ' ( #! #0 ! &/! &

"#)& &* #. # ) +&*!#* # ! #. =U

?5;5T #(#!,- "# & "#)& =V

?5;5V F( ( > +'.& C "1! *& )# &+-(# *&+& 0&4 !(& T?

?5;5?< 4 %& *!3" *# ) ("&( & !#+ * T_

; ` TV

;5?

9 a TV

;5?5? +&*!#* # '#!" * '#" 4# V?

;5?5; +&*!#* # ) . / !#" 4# V]

;5?5] +&*!#* # &* #. "# # >' ! F(* # &4 @" *# VY

;5; 8 VT

;5;5? +&*!#* # 'M/. *# VT

;5;5; # (" 0L )#) D #"-#. )#) ?<?

;5;5] &(* "& ) ) +&*!#* # *&(" +'&!P( # ?<Y

;5;5U + #$# D ) +&*!#* # *&(" +'&!P( # ???

;5;5_ *&(,- "# *&(Q+ *# 9 &* # ) +&*!I" *#

*&(" +'&!P( # -+# 4 %& 0 !#. ??T

;5;5Y +&*!#* # ! 4&.-$%& ?;_

;5;5= *&("!&. # ) +&*!#* # ?]]

] ?]_

]5? 8 ?]_

]5?5? *&("!&. @" *& )& C /! - ?]_

]5?5; *&("!&. ) +&*!I" *& ("! & 0! 0& ?U<

]5?5] *&("!&. ! '-/. *#(& + &+# ?UU

]5?5U *&("!&. (# )#) @) # ?U=

]5?5_ *&("!&. (# *.#!#$%& )# 4&.-$%& !#(* # ?UV

(11)

11

]5;5? *&("!&. >" !(& (& !# . 8&.#()F ?Y<

]5;5; *&("!&. >" !(& (& !# . 'M/. *# ?Y]

]5] 6 ?YT

]5]5? )+ ( "!#$%& 'M/. *# ?YV

]5]5; &(* "& ) *&("!&. ?=]

]5]5] '@* ) *&("!&. )# #)+ ( "!#$%& 'M/. *# ?== ]5]5U &(* "& ) *&("!&. >" !(& )# #)+ ( "!#$%& 'M/. *# ?=V ]5]5_ 2-($%& )& *&("!&. >" !(& )# #)+ ( "!#$%& 'M/. *# ?T;

]5U ?T_

]5_ ?T_

]5Y ?VTT ?TY

]5= ?VTT ?V?

U ?VU

U5? b

?VTT ?V_

U5; b 5

;?;

U5;5? -) "&! ( "@! & M/. *& ;?]

U5;5; +-( !#$%& ;?_

U5;5] W-#)!& '!1'! & ) ' &#. ;?_

U5;5U + .#! )#) *&+ ! /-(# ^-) * # ;?Y

U5] N

;?= U5]5? & $%& *&( " "-* &(#. )& ! /-(#. ) &("# )# ( %& ;;? U5]5; &+' "F(* # )& ! /-(#. ) &("# )# ( %& ;;] U5]5] *&+' "F(* # )& ! /-(#. ) &("# *&+ )

*&( " "-* &(#. ;;U

U5U b S ^

;;Y

U5U5? #! * ! '!@4 & ;;T

U5U5; ^-.0#+ ("& )# *&("# )& #)+ ( "!#)&! ) +#

! '&( I4 ;;V

U5U5] ) +# *&+' "F(* # *&( " "-* &(# ;]_

U5U5U -"!# 2-($G ;]V

U5U5_ W- "G ! .#" 4# D #$%& *&("!&.#)&!# ;U<

U5U5Y (" !4 ($%& (& "#)& ;U;

U5U5= &) ! ) '&.3* # ;U]

U5U5T 2-($%& &! ("#)&!# )& ! /-(#. ) &("# )# ( %&555 ;UU

U5U5V *#. E#$%& )& ! /-(#. ) &("# )# ( %& ;UY

U5_ ;UY

(12)

12

U5Y

b ;UV

U5Y5? $%& 2 *#. E#)&!# )& ! /-(#. ) &("# )& "#)& ;_;

U5Y5; -"!# *&+' "F(* # ;__

U5Y5] &("!&. (" !(& )& "#)& )& -( *3' & ;__ U5Y5U *#. E#$%& )& ! /-(#. ) &("# )& "#)& ;_Y

c ;_=

7 ;Y]

(13)

"# ) !"#$%& 4 # ! .#* &(#! *&(H-0#! ) +&*!#* # *&("!&. >" !(& )# #)+ ( "!#$%& 'M/. *#5

'! + !# "#! 2# ! .#* &(#! ( * # *&+ # C "1! # )# ) +&*!#* #9 ) ) - '! +1!) & ("! & '&4& #(" 0& 9 *&+ F(2# (& C /! - (# ! 2 !F(* # )# 3/. # C /!# *#9 9 * !"#+ (" 9 *&+ # +'&!"P(* # ! . 4& ,- & 0! 0& ) !#+ D ) +&*!#* #9 *&+& 2&!+# ) 0&4 !(&5 0- -+# 3(" '&! &+#9 (# * ($#9 @'&*# +&) !(# *&(" +'&!P( #5 !&'& "#)#+ (" 9 # ) +&*!#* # (# )#) @) # (&

"#)& ( )& @ #/&!)#)# #' (# (* ) ("#.+ (" 9 4 "& (%& "#! ! .#* &(#)# *&+ & " +# ) *&("!&. >" !(& #)&"#)& (& !# .5

- *# 9 '&!"#("&9 -+# 3(" C "1! *#9 # ()# ,- (%& H# &/H " 4& ) "# ) !"#$%&9 +# ,- !I -" . E#)# *&+& #(I. '#!# *&+'! () ! # ) +&*!#* #9 ' * #.+ (" ,-#("& #& '!&/. +# +&) !(& )& "#)& )# &* )#) *&(" +'&!P( # # ! '! ("#$%&

&/ !#(# )& '&4&5

#+/@+9 (" " *#+ (" 9 # ) !"#$%& #/&!)#!I -+# ,- "%& (* #. ,- 9 +/&!# (%& H# ( " )#+ (" H-!3) *#9 " + (&"#)# +'&!"P(* # (& ) # #"-# 9 &- H#9 # 4I! # '@* ) ) +&*!#* #9 (%& #' (# - " '& (&!+#" E#)& 9 +# # ) +&*!#* # *&+& 4#.&! & '!1'! & C&+ +5

(14)

14

! . 0 %&9 (& "!#/#.C&9 (# (2&!+#$%&9 (& ( "!-+ ("& ) '&) !9 (# *-."-!# (# ! .#$G &* # 9 + (" )& #+'.&5

4&.-$%& )# ) +&*!#* # &-9 + .C&! # ()#9 )# ! .#$G ) +&*!I" *# 9 @ "#+/@+ &/H "& ) #(I. ( " "!#/#.C&9 '! " () ()& +& "!#! + & '#!#)&>& ,- # ) +&*!#* # *! # '#!# & C&+ + +&) !(& (& '!&* & ) 0.&/#. E#$%&5

+ &-"!# 4 !" (" 9 ! #. )#) C&H '&-*& (4 " 0#)# (& + & #*#)F+ *& 9 +# +'&!"#(" *&+& )#)& )# ! #. )#) C "1! *#9 # ) !"#$%& '! " () ! 0#"#! #.0-+# )# " )# ) +&*!#* # ! 4&.-* &(I! #9 (%& #' (# (# '!I> )# ! 4&.-$%&9 +# (# -# '!1'! # " &! #9 # '#!" ! ) " >"& 2-()#+ ("# ) #!>9 (0 . !#+ * 9 #/&!)#()& #.0-( )& # ' *"& #"-# )# ) +&*!#* # )# ! 4&.-$%&5

W-#. # (" !) ' ()F(* # ("! ) +&*!#* #9 ) ! "& C-+#(& & *&("!&. >" !(& )# #)+ ( "!#$%& 'M/. *#d S " M." +& -+ . + ("& *C#4 )# ) +&*!#* #d

#)+ ( "!#$%& 'M/. *# @ ) +&*!I" *#d &) ! -" . E#)# *&+& ( "!-+ ("& #(" ) +&*!I" *&d W-# & *! "@! & # + ) )# 9 # + (%& 2&!9 '#!# ,- # #)+ ( "!#$%& 'M/. *# H# .# + +# ) +&*!I" *#9 &--+ > !*3* & )& 4#.&! ) +&*!I" *& 9 #& + +& " +'&9 *&(*! " E#$%& )# ) +&*!#* #d

! '& "# " ("#!I ! &/" )# #& .&(0& )# ) !"#$%&9 4 ! 2 *#()& *&+& ! #. E#+ & ) ! "& C-+#(& #"!#4@ )# #)+ ( "!#$%& 'M/. *#5

(15)

15

#)+ ( "!#$%& 'M/. *#d - . @ -+ 4#.&! () !!&0I4 . '&!,- #2 !+# # ) +&*!#* # *&(*! " E# & ) ! "& C-+#(& d

W-#("& #& *&("!&. >" !(& )# #)+ ( "!#$%& 'M/. *#9 # ) !"#$%& "#+/@+ #(#. #!I # -# C "1! # # -# 4&.-$%&5 -+# 0-()# '#!" 9 & -!0 + ("& )& *&("!&. >" !(&9 -# C "1! #9 4&.-$%& "#+/@+ -( "!-+ -("& C "1! *& #"-# 5

" '&("&9 ! #."# ,- # ) !"#$%& !I #/&!)#!9 ) ) & # ' *"& C "1! *&9 # > "F(* # ) -+ *&("!&. >" !(& + " !!# )& !# . &.Q( # ,-#()& )# &*-'#$%& C&.#() # (& &!) " 5 S -+ #*C#)& C "1! *&9 "#+/@+ #*#) + *#+ (" '&-*& >#+ (#)& + (& # ()# ! .#"#)&5

& " +# ) ! "& C-+#(& 9 # ) !"#$%& #)&"#!I & >#+ )# 4 !" (" C "1! *# 6 # (" 0L )#) A# 3/. # 8 /!# *#9 & '&4& #(" 0& B9 & * ("!& !!#) #)&! +&) !(&9 ,- @9 + )M4 )#9 & . 0#)& )# 4&.-$%& !#(* # -# #"-#. )#) 9 ' * 2 *#+ (" (& &!) (#+ ("& H-!3) *& /!# . !&5

&! 2 +9 (& )& " +# ) "# ) !"#$%&9 &- H#9 ) +&*!#* # *&("!&. >" !(& )# #)+ ( "!#$%& 'M/. *# C#4 !I -+ #'&!" ! .#" 4& #& " >"& *&( " "-* &(#. /!# . !&9 # + *&+& D H-! '!-)F(* # +# #"-#. E#)#9 (&"#)#+ (" )& -'! +& ! /-(#. ) !#. )& ! /-(#. .&*#.5

>'. *# 6 # )@ # )# ) !"#$%& @ ' !'# #! C "1! #9 * F(* # '&.3" *# ) ! "& (& (" )& ) ,- & ) ! "& @ *-."-!#.9 -+# *#" 0&! # C "1! *# "#+/@+ '&.3" *#5

(16)

16

0&!#9 ' !+ " #*! * !6 ! .#* &(#! *&(H-0#!5 &+ & 4 !/&9 (%& & -/ "#(" 4& &- #)H " 4& 4 # ) +&( "!#! & '!&* & ) #.@" *& ,- (4&.4 & )& " +# ) +&*!#* # *&("!&. )# #)+ ( "!#$%& 'M/. *# 9 *&+& -!0 !#+9 4&.-3!#+9 9 &/! "-)&9 *&+& %& ! -."#)& )# *! #$%& C-+#(#9 *&(,- "# + M." +# #(I. )& '!&* & * 4 . E#"1! & ) #. (#)&! )& C&+ +5

'!&* & C "1! *& '&.3" *& "I (* !!#)&d W-#. & ) #. C-+#(& ,-#("& #& )& " +# d

) !"#$%& " ("#!I ) +&( "!#! ,- (# -"1' *# ( * I! # &* )#) )& 2-"-!& & C&+ + (%& " !I (# ) +&*!#* # -+ ( "!-+ ("&9 +# + -+ +&)& ) 4 4 !9 # + *&+& & *&("!&. )# #)+ ( "!#$%& 'M/. *# *&(*! " E#!I *&+& -+# 2&!+# ) !&" (# *&" ) #(#5

&(C& )# C-+#( )#) (%& !#!& *&(4 !" !#+ + ' #) .& 9 +# & ' #) .& '# #!#+ '# #!%&5 "# ) !"#$%& "#+/@+ @ -+ &(C&6 & &(C& ) -+# -"&' #5 .# ! #. E#!I ,-#()& # . / !)#) 9 # 0-#.)#) 9 # 2!#" !( )#) # 2 . * )#) 9 (*.- 4 # '. (# #" 2#$%& )# ( * )#) *&. " 4# () 4 )-# (%& 2&! + #' (# /#() !# 9 (&!+# &- ) '-"# '&.3" *# 9 &* # &- H-) * # 5 %& C#4 !I -"&' *#+ (" +# *&("!#) $G "&)& !%& 0-# 5

W-#("& #& "#)&9 # -"&' # ) *"&! 8-0&6 J '-/. ,- -( 4 ! .. 9 "- ([ " '# (*&! ,-[-( * (" .. O ) +# ( "- !I . &. .K5

W-#("& #& C&+ ( 9 # '!&2 * # ) #3# 6 J .&/& *- )#!I )& *&!) !&O # '#)# *&(4 !" !%& + #!#)& K?5

1

(17)

17

c

) +&*!#* # @ -+ '!&* & C "1! *& ) #.@" *& (& ,-#. & '1.& ) *&("!#) $%& &'G + & '&) ! ) -+ .#)& & '&4& ) &-"!& .#)&5

" "!#/#.C&9 &'"&- '&! #/&!)#! ( * #.+ (" # *&(* '$%& ) +&*!I" *#9 (,-#("& @" *#9 &. )I! # ) H- " $# &* #. ("! & C /! - 9 &! 0 (#)# ) -+# *&(* '$%& ! . 0 & & (&!+#" 4# 0-()& # ,-#. & ! ) 4 ! # ! H- "&5 #!# & C /! - 9 # ) +&*!#* # (%& +'. *#4# & 4#.&! ) *&.C# )& 0&4 !(#(" &- # ) . / !#$G *&. " 4# 9 +# & *-+'! + ("& )# (&!+# A*&+ *#!I" ! ! . 0 & &B *&+ -+ (" )& @" *& 9 ,-#()& ! .#* &(#)# #& '&) !9 *&(" (C#+ # ) " !+ (#$%& ) *&()-E ! -+#

&* )#) 2!#" !(# H- "#5

#+/@+ '#!# & C /! - 9 ,-#()& & '!&2 "# A #3# @# B 2#.#4#+ #& '&4& &/! & ) 4 !"-#+ ("& @" *& )& 0&4 !(#(" )& *& "-+ & " (C# & 0( 2 *#)& ) -+# #)4 !"F(* #9 *&+ & ' & )# #+ #$# ! . 0 & #9 '#!# & ! "&!(& #& *P(&( (&!+#" E#)& 5

#!# & 0! 0& #" ( ( 9 # ) +&*!#* # !#9 &/! "-)&9 # . $%& )& +#0 "!#)& &- & &!" &9 # 4&"#$%& + # +/.@ # )# '! (* '# ) . / !#$G &/! # 4 )# (# * )#) 5 #!# & 0! 0& 9 # ) +&*!#* # !# # '#!" * '#$%& )& '&4& (& '!&* & ) ) * G (# N0&!# 9 + &-"!# + ) )#9 & *&("!&. > !* )& &/! & +#0 "!#)& 9 #"!#4@ )# 2 0-!# )& #-) "&! 9 *&+& > !*3* & ) +&*!I" *&5

(18)

18

# .&(0# 4&.-$%&9 *-H# 4 !" (" (*&("!# + #,- #4 . # ! "&+#)# ) )@ # *.I *# 9 &/! "-)& )& '&) ! & )& +'@! & !&+#(&9 !I " ! (# 4&.-$%& !#(* # & 2-()#+ ("& )# +&) !(# ) +&*!#* #9 ( * #.+ (" '&.3" *#9 *&+& ! '! ("#$%&9 '#!#$%& ) '&) ! 9 0-#.)#) 9 . / !)#) &. )#! )#) 9 9 #'1 9 *&+ # &+-(# *&+& *&(,- "# ) ) ! "& &* # *&(Q+ *& 5

)@ # &* #. "# 0 !+ (#+9 *&+ & #(#!,- "# +#!> #(& 9 (# -' !#$%& )# *&("!#) $G ) *.# 9 (# . + (#$%& )# '!&'! )#) '! 4#)# )& + & ) '!&)-$%& )# " &! # )# ! 'M/. *# ) +&*!I" *# *&+ & '&) ! * ("!#)& &/! & '&) ! . 0 .#" 4& & *&( .C& 9 *-H# '! + !# >' ! F(* # &*&!! + (# 4&.-$%& ) ?V?=9 *&+ # *!3" *# ) !#+ * 9 (&"#)#+ (" ,-#("& #& '#' . )& (" . *"-# 9 )# "!#) $%& *-."-!#.9 )& *#+ (C& '!1'! & )# -!&'# &* ) ("#. )# 2-($%& )& /.&*& C 0 +Q( *&5

) +&*!#* # (& @*-.& (%& @ +# #' (# & '!&* & C "1! *& ) .-"# ' .# ! '! ("#$%& '&.3" *#9 +# )# *&(,- "# &* # *&(Q+ *# # *! * (" '#!" * '#$%& ) . / !#$%& '&'-.#! (& # -("& )& "#)&5

#!#. .#+ (" 9 +/! &(I! & ("! & C /! - 9 0! 0& &- !&+#(& 9 *&+ #.0-+# >' ! F(* # C "1! *# )-!#(" # )#) @) # (# * (" (& !# . *&+ & C&.#() 9 & *&("!&. )# #)+ ( "!#$%& 'M/. *# @ -+ )& (&4& #"! /-"& )# ) +&*!#* #5

&(" +'&!#( #+ (" 9 & '!&* & ) +&*!I" *& (*.- # *#!#*" !3 " *# ! -."#(" ) -+ .&(0& '!&* & C "1! *&9 (& ,-#.

(19)

19

'M/. *# *&+ # *! #$%& )& - ! /-(#. ) &("# 9 ( ' !#)& (& +&) .& ("%& ( " "-3)& (# !#($#5

>#()& (& *# & /!# . !&9 # '#!" ! )& +&) .& #)&"#)& (# #!"# #0(# ) ?VTT9 & ! /-(#. ) &("# @ '! "#)&! ) #->3. & #& '&) ! . 0 .#" 4&9 # ,- + *&+' " 9 + '! + !& .-0#!9 & H-.0#+ ("& ) *&("# )& *C 2 ) '&) ! > *-" 4&9 +# # . 9 ! /-(#.9 *&(2 ! & "#"-"&

&.3" *&9 &-"!# *&+' "F(* # ,- %& #.C # D 2-($G ) *&.#/&!#$%& *&+ & '&) ! . 0 .#" 4&5

2-($%& *&( " "-* &(#. )& *&("!&. >" !(& )# #)+ ( "!#$%& 'M/. *# '& - )-'.# &!) + ) *&+' "F(* # 5 2-($%& ) *&("!&. "I #"! /-3)# #& &(0! & #* &(#. "#+/@+ #& ! /-(#. ) &("# )#

( %&5

'! + !# &!) + ) *&+' "F(* # ! ) (& '#!.#+ ("&O .# #!!&.#+ "! "#+ (" (& #!" 0& UV9 (* & 9 ) E + *&+ & H-.0#+ ("& )# *&("# #(-# '! "#)# ' .& ! ) (" )# 'M/. *#9 &2 ! * )# ' .& ! /-(#. ) &("# *&+ '#! * ! '!@4 &O # #'! * #$%& )& ! .#"1! & ) > *-$%& )& '.#(& ) 0&4 !(& # 2 *#. E#$%& *&("!&. )& #"& )& &) ! > *-" 4&9 (*.- 4 #)+ ( "!#$%& ) ! "#5 + *#( +& *&( " "-* &(#. (" !(& '#!# "# *&+' "F(* # %& # *&+ G "@*( *# & '!1'! & . (I! &5

& ! /-(#. ) &("# 9 # 2-($%& ) *&("!&. >" !(& *&!! '&() #& .&(0& . (*& )& #!" 0& =? )# #!"# #0(#9 #* +# #(#. #)&5

*&+' "F(* # %& ) " ("# &/ ) * + # )& 0!#-) 2 ! (* #0!#-)& & *&("!&. '#!.#+ ("#! @ '&.3" *& ) *&("3(-& &+ (" & H-.0#+ ("& )# *&("# @ ' ! 1) *&5

(20)

20

'!&0!#+# ) * #"@ # +'. * )#) )& #"& #)+ &(# &-(#" 4#"1! & 5

#!" )# *&+' "F(* # )& ! /-(#. ) &("# @ ) +' (C#)# + #->3. & #& &) ! 0 .#" 4&5 &+& HI &/ !4 # 2-($%& @ ) #->3. & &-*&.#/&!#$%& A# "&)& & &) ! #& ( "@! & M/. *&B9 +# & (%& "&!(# & ! /-(#. -+ 1!0%& #-> . #!5 &+& #2 !+#)&9 . @ ( " "- $%& ) "#)&9 (%& ( ! )& (& &) ! 0 .#" 4& *&+ & ,-#. A & ) +# B +#("@+ -# () ' ()F(* # #-"&(&+ # ! *3'!&*# 5 -# -/&!) (#$%& @ >*.- 4#+ (" D ! '&( #/ . )#) ,- # #!"# .C +'Q 5

& '&) #*! * ("#!9 *&+& #!0-+ ("&9 ,- # *&("# )# # )& (#)& )# P+#!# ) !#. "%& -/+ " )# #& '!1'! & ! /-(#. + *&+' "F(* # '#!# H-.0#+ ("& (%& '#!# & ! 2 ! )& '#! * ! ) #->3. &5

W- # *&+' "F(* # @ &' (#" 4#9 *&( -." 4#9 *&!! " 4#9 #(* &(#)&!# H-) *#(" HI 2& "#+/@+ &/ !4#)& #* +#5

^-.0#+ ("& ) -+ "! /-(#. e - 0 ( ! e9 +# *&+ *#!#*" !3 " *# '!1'! # ) H-! ) $%&9 '&!,- & H-.0#+ ("& ! #. E# &/! #"& 2#"& 0&4 !(#+ ("# (%& &/! # *&()-"# )& #0 (" ! ' *" 4& 5

H-.0#+ ("& *&+ *! "@! & &/H " 4& &- ) "@*( *# H-!3) *# '!1'! # @ ! #. E#)& *&+ # !! "!#"#/ . )#) ,- @ '!1'! # )# ) * G H-) * # ,-#()& & P+/ "& )& '!&* & (* ) ! &/! # 0 "G 2 (#(* !#9 '#"! +&( #.9 *&("I/ .9 &!$#+ ("I! #9 &' !#* &(#. 9 +# ! * (" + (" 9 2 *#. )& 1!0%& H-! ) * &(#)& 5

(21)

21

&("# #& "! /-(# H-) * I! & *&+ '! !!&0#" 4# () ' ( I4 #& *&("!&. )# ! 'M/. *#5

'! !!&0#" 4# (%& %& #' (# )# ( " "- $%&9 +# +&.)#)# D + .C#($# &- # + .#$%& ) + +/!& )& &) ! ^-) * I! &5

2 (Q+ (& '&.3" *& C "1! *& )& *&("!&. )# #)+ ( "!#$%& 'M/. *# @9 (& !# .9 (* #.+ (" *&( " "-* &(#.5 + -+# M( *# &'&!"-( )#) 9 # &( " "- $%& ! + " D . (2!#*&( " "-* &(#. (& ) + ( &(#+ ("& )# #($G 9 +#"@! # " *( *#+ (" #.C # #& " >"& +#0(&5

( " "- $%& ) "#)& *&( " "-* &(#. E#)#9 & ! /-(#. ) &("# (%& @ (0 .#+ (" #)+ ( "!#" 4&5 . @ * ("!#.+ (" *&( " "-* &(#.9 (& ) E ! ) #!.& X! ! ""&5

# * )& *&+ # 'M/. *# /!# . !# @ . ( " "- $%& ( * I! # D 'M/. *#5 *&("!&. )& *-+'! + ("& "! "& () '&(34 . )# #$%& #)+ ( "!#" 4# A# 2 !# &!$#+ ("I! # 9 2 (#(* !# 9 &' !#* &(# 9 *&("I/ '#"! +&( # %& (* #.+ (" #$G #)+ ( "!#" 4# 9 # ()# ,- '!&4 )# ) (&!+# '!1'! # B @ ! '&( #/ . )#) )& *&("!&. >" !(& )& '&) ! '! + ( (" )# ( " "- $%& *&(* "-#.+ (" '!1'! # '#!# "# 2-($%&5

' $# *C#4 ) *&+#()& *&( " "-* &(#. @ & ! /-(#. ) &("# 9 #& + " ! & '#! * ! &/! # *&("# )& C 2 ) "#)&9 H-.0#! "&)& & ) +# ! '&( I4 > !* ! # ! "#(" *&+' "F(* # ,- .C 2&!#+ ) 2 ! )# &/ !#(#+ (" ' .& '&4& +#()#"& () '&(34 .9 () . 0I4 .

() ' ( I4 . D 'M/. *#5

(22)

(&-22

) *-!"&9 + ,- & "#)& "!#( 2&!+#!#+ + ) +&*!I" *& (& ,-# # "!-"-!# " () + # #/ &!4 ! # -' !#$%& "@*( *#9 +# ( " "-* &(#.+ (" +#(" )#9 )# '#!#$%& )& '&) ! 5 ) )&/!#+ ("& "!-"-!#. )& "#)&9 &- )& - #'#!#"& ) ! " 4& + (" ( " "- $G 9 "&)& *&+ & + +& '!&'1 "&9 ,- @ # ) 0( )#) )# ' &# C-+#(#9 #* ("-#+ # > "F(* # ) -+ '&. * ("! +& ( " "-* &(#. ( * I! & #&

"#)& > " (* #. D &* )#) 5

+ *&( >%& C#!+&( #9 & (" "!-"-!# '&!"#+ 4#.&! 0#!#(" + &-"!& "#("& 4#.&! 9 "&)& +#(#)& )# &/ !#( # '&'-.#!5

' !*-! & C "1! *&9 ( * #)& *&+ # ! . 0 %& (&!+#" E#)# +'& "&!# ) *&()-"# @" *# *-H& &/H " 4& 2-()#+ ("#. !# # &. )#! )#) # H- " $#9 ,- '# &- ' .# >"!#&!) (I! # >' ! F(* # #" ( ( 9 " + -+ (&4& *&("&!(& +&) !(&5

"!-"-!# +&) !(# )& "#)& &* ) ("#. 2-()#+ ("# (& 4#.&! C "1! *& )# 4&.-$%& !#(* #5 -# *.#!#$%& @ & '! + !& "#"-"& # 0#!#(" ! #& C&+ + & *&("!&. )& #)+ ( "!#)&!5

4#.&! C "1! *& 9 4&.-3)& + '!&* & ) #.@" *&9 %& 2-()#+ ("& "!-"-!# )& "#)&9 #& ,-# . ) 4# !4 )%&5

'! + !# !4 )%& )& *&("!&. >" !(& )# #)+ ( "!#$%& 'M/. *#9 )& ,-#. & ! /-(#. ) &("# @ (" (* #.9 @ *&+ & C&+ + #

&* )#) 5

(23)

23

( ! )& (# "!-"-!# )& "#)&9 *&+ 2-($G ) *&("!&. >" !(&9 & ! /-(#. ) &("# '& - *&+' "F(* # '#!# + " ! '#! * ! &/! # *&("# )& ! ) (" )# 'M/. *# H-.0#! # *&("# )& *C 2 )& ) +# '&) ! + ( "@! & 'M/. *& *&+ # + .C#$%& #& "! /-(# H-) * I! & 5 ^#+# #.*#($&- "#"-"& C "1! *& !! "!&#" 4& ) # #+'. "-) 5