• Nenhum resultado encontrado

Deep genealogy and the dilution of risk.


Academic year: 2017

Share "Deep genealogy and the dilution of risk."

Mostrar mais ( páginas)




Deep Genealogy and the Dilution of Risk

Roland G. Roberts*

Public Library of Science, Cambridge, United Kingdom

We now know that many of the common diseases that afflict human pop-ulations are at least partly caused by the genes we inherit. In contrast to the classic rare ‘‘Mendelian’’ genetic diseases, where inheritance of rare but severe mutations at a single gene can make the difference between sickness and health, the genetic risk of getting common maladies like, for example, Alzheimer disease, diabetes, or depression is altogether fuzzier in nature. Here, common and individually mild mutations in many genes combine to raise our personal susceptibility to the point at which they might connive with environ-mental factors to trigger the disease state. It’s obviously much harder to pin down this distributed kind of genetic risk than it is to identify the mutations responsible for a Mendelian disease, but the last decade and a half has seen the rise of a clever solution—the Genome-Wide Association Study or GWAS, a triumph of technology, statistics, and sheer ambition. To do a typical case-control GWAS you first need blood samples from hundreds or thou-sands of individuals, divided into two groups—one with and one without a particular disease or trait. You then need to check the genotype—that is, the genetic variants—at hundreds of thousands of sites across the genome in each sample (these variable sites are called single nucleotide polymorphisms or SNPs). Finally you use some sophisticated statistical tools to see whether a given SNP is ‘‘associated’’ with the disease state, i.e., whether one variant is significantly more common in people who have the disease than in those who don’t. Typically this association is subtle, with most GWAS ‘‘hits’’ affecting risk by less than a factor of two. A significant association between a SNP and a disease indicates that some other variant near the SNP in the genome (the ‘‘functional variant’’) directly affects a person’s biolog-ical function in a way that raises or lowers their risk of that disease.

This brings us to an uncomfortable truth. It’s clear from the above that to even

attempt a GWAS you need a lot of money, some serious kit, and a robust medical infrastructure. Presumably as a result of this, the vast majority of GWASs have been done on individuals of European ancestry, mostly in Western Europe and Northern America. However, there are seven billion of us on this planet, and most of us don’t share this ancestry. To what extent can we simply extrapolate the results of these hundreds of GWASs to the rest of the world’s population?

This is the question directly posed in a

PLOS Biology paper by Christopher Carl-son, Charles Kooperberg, and colleagues. They used DNA samples from more than 73,000 people describing themselves as

having a range of ancestries (50% Euro-pean, 20% African American, 11% His-panic, 8% Native American, and so on). For each of the 73,000 individuals the authors then checked the genotype of 68 SNPs known (from studies of Europeans) to be associated with body mass index (BMI), type 2 diabetes, or levels of fats in the bloodstream.

To ensure that they were making a fair comparison, the authors first checked that these previously reported associations are seen in their own European cohort. They then assessed the so called direction (see below) of effect of each SNP in individuals of non-European ancestry. For almost all associations between a SNP and a trait,

SelectedPLOS Biologyresearch articles are accom-panied by a synopsis written for a general audience to provide non-experts with insight into the significance of the published work.

Citation:Roberts RG (2013) Deep Genealogy and the Dilution of Risk. PLoS Biol 11(9): e1001660. doi:10.1371/ journal.pbio.1001660

PublishedSeptember 17, 2013

Copyright: ß2013 Roland G. Roberts. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.

Competing Interests:The author has declared that no competing interests exist.

* E-mail: rroberts@plos.org

Most genetic studies of common diseases have been performed in populations with European ancestry; the genetic effects that they identify are progressively diluted in people from other continents.



the effect direction is the same in other populations; thus a genotype that’s associ-ated with increased risk of a disease (or related trait) in Europeans will also tend to be associated with an increased (rather than decreased) risk in people from other ancestries. However, this study found that thesize of the effect differed substantially between continental populations, with the most profound effects seen in African Americans, where a quarter of the associ-ations were appreciably weaker, often to the point of disappearing altogether (see Figure).

What’s the reason for this? Remember that when we’re studying genetic associa-tions, what we’re usually looking at is an intrinsically innocuous SNP that’s merely a proxy for the functional variant. And although these genetic loci are physically close to each other in the genome, the genetic shuffling or recombination that occurs in each generation can, over time, separate them from each other. There’s also the possibility that different functional

variants exist in different populations, and that functional variants depend on other genetic or environmental factors (which might in turn differ between populations) to have their effect.

The authors then used some addition-al high-resolution genetic data on their European and African American popu-lations to distinguish between these possibilities, and they find that much of the dilution is due to the genetic scrambling that happens as SNPs and causal variants are passed from parents to offspring; the more generations that separate two individuals from each other, the worse the SNP is at tagging the functional variant. Indeed, in half of those diluted associations, the authors see evidence that African populations never-theless have the same underlying func-tional variant, with the same strength of association, but tagged by a different SNP.

Few will be surprised by these results, but this study does several important

things. First (the bad news), it clinches and quantifies the problem of extending current genetic risk models, based on associations from European populations, to humans whose origins lie in other continents. Second (the good news), it suggests that in a future sun-blessed time when we’ve identified all the functional variants (a non-trivial achievement)— rather than their potentially deceptive SNP stand-ins—genetic models will be more readily transferrable across all of humanity. Third, it makes a strong and specific case for carrying out genetic association studies in non-European populations, with those of African an-cestry being the single most beneficial target.

Carlson CS, Matise TC, North KE, Haiman CA, Fesinmeyer MD, et al. (2013) Generaliza-tion and DiluGeneraliza-tion of AssociaGeneraliza-tion Results from European GWAS in Populations of Non-Euro-pean Ancestry: The PAGE Study. doi:10.1371/ journal.pbio.1001661


Documentos relacionados

The aim of this study was to establish the relationship between content of reducing sugar of honey and some physicochemical parameters and possibilities of using

Some authors also argue that students do not find division much different from multiplication and that they are naturally able to adapt their

In their paper, the authors showed some of the contributions and developments of risk analysis as applied to petroleum exploration, appraising and developing fields,

The single item measure of perceived risk was supe- rior to SW’s instrument with regard to its association with standard measures of risk and return, and it had a weaker

The probability of attending school four our group of interest in this region increased by 6.5 percentage points after the expansion of the Bolsa Família program in 2007 and

a high-resolution genetic linkage map of Iw1 (Table 3; Fig. All 11 EST markers mapped to the Iw1 genomic region, and 8 of these could be used simultaneously to find orthologous

was used to analyze the differences in the expression of active and total Src in cytoplasm and membrane between normal ducts and cancer tissue, between African American and

A high resolution climatology of precipitation and deep convection over the Mediterranean region from operational satellite microwave data: development and application to the

The structure of the remelting zone of the steel C90 steel be- fore conventional tempering consitute cells, dendritic cells, sur- rounded with the cementite, inside of

These results indicated high genetic diver- sity in the Amerindian and African lineage groups, suggesting that the Brazilian Amazonian African-descendant pop- ulations reflect

The eight American genera fall into three broad distributional categories: widely distri- buted throughout the neotropics, limited to northern South America, and disjunct between

Se quiséssemos um resultado mais preciso, preci- saríamos estudar as características de cada atleta em par- ticular: quão intensa é a força que consegue fazer quando há

New York becomes, then, the preferred destination and, according to Mitchell, “a central location for African-Americans” and hence, “the center of African- American culture

O instrumento de coleta foi dividido em três partes: 1- Estrutura Física onde se procurou conhecer a qualidade dos equipamentos esportivos de uso dos alunos

5 CONCLUSÕES De acordo com os resultados obtidos neste trabalho conclui-se que: a O simulador desenvolvido pode ser utilizado para prognosticar os parâmetros de crescimento,

This study analyzed the specificities of over-regulation when compared with under-regulation (maladaptive) and adaptive regulation by testing its association with attachment,

pela CNEN.. This paper, besides presenting some characteristics of the spectrometer, discusses the method o f calibrating and determining the resolution o f slow neutron

The dairy production potential for grazing livestock was estimated with basis on the NLE data of the bromatological analysis of grasses, which was based on the RGB image

In the hinterland (Lika region) they are partly permeable but on higher positions at Velebit Mt. calcareous breccias are highly permeable. The best prove for the mentioned is

It is stored in numerous caves, in the hard disks of the Quaternary and in the continental and marine sediments of Aegean Archipelago wider area.. We are still

É nesta mudança, abruptamente solicitada e muitas das vezes legislada, que nos vão impondo, neste contexto de sociedades sem emprego; a ordem para a flexibilização como

OBJETIVO: Verificar a percepção das mulheres com câncer do colo do útero sobre a incapacidade/deficiência tendo como referência a estrutura e a linguagem biopsicossocial

Abordamos teoricamente a colisão com o ‘efeito estilingue’ onde um corpo transfere momentum linear e energia cinética para um segundo corpo de massa menor, fazendo com que a