Nulidades e limitação do poder de punir : análise de discurso de acórdãos do tribunal de justiça do Rio Grande do Sul

$

'((" )*+ ), "("- ).) / 0 "12'(' ,) /')! ,) ) 3 "-*+ . # )2 ." "( " ,"! # )0) ." 4(

).2)*+ "0 '5-/')( '0'-)'( .) )/2!.)." ." ' "' .) - '67/') -'8" ('.)." ) 4!'/) . '

)-." . 2!9

'"- ). 69 9 )! ." ) 8)!:

<

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

. ' )-." . 2!9 ( .). ( 3 '. ( ."0 -( )0 20) "!) '8) / "(, -.5-/') .)(

:',4 "("( "4 '/)( / 0 ( /)( ( "D)0'-). (A 12" '-.'/) 12" "D'( " 20) 0"- )!'.)." :"#"0E-'/) - , ." 2.'/'C ' 12" ? "!2 )- " "0 ). ) "0 ("2( , ('/' -)0"- ( ) )D' ! #') '0, ( ) ,"!) -( ' 2'*+ .) ",F3!'/) ." G&&9 )! "!2 H-/') "6!" " (" "0 20

)20"- . '0,)/ ,2-' '8 . ('( "0) ,"-)!A 12" -+ 3(" 8) )( , 4, ')( 3)!'B)(

- 0) '8)( 12" / -6 0)09 )3)!: / - "0,!) )'-.) 20 0 0"- , , (' '8 A - 12)!

? (2#" '.) 20) 2, 2 ) ,) ).'#0C '/) -) " ') ." -2!'.)."(A / 0 8'( )( ) , , /' -) ) (2," )*+ . 0 ."! 8'#"- "9

0 62-*+ .) )3 .)#"0 ")!'B).)A )3)!: '-(" " (" -) ") ." -/"- )*+ '( "0) "-)! ' !5-/') . "( ). "0 '5-/')( '0'-)'( .) - '67/') -'8" ('.)." ) 4!'/) .

' )-." . 2!A )0 !.)-. (" > '-:) ." "(12'() '0'- ! #') " - !" /')!9

I

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

- "#) . :" ."8"! ,,". ),, )/:A :" K L '( '-(" ". '- :" -/"- ) ' - ") 6 '0'-)! J( "0 )-. ' !"-/" 6 :" '0'-)! /'"-/"( )( " ( # )0 6 :" - '67/') -'8" ('.)." ) 4!'/) . ' )-." . 2!A 3"! -#'-# :" "(") /: '-" 6 '0'- ! #J

)-. /')! - !9

P

999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 %

9 Q R

99999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 ; 9 9 -('." )*="( , "!'0'-) "(999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 ; 9$9 -('." )*="( )/" /) .)( '.?')( 12" / -6 0)0 ) , C '/) @2.'/')! 3 )('!"' ) 9999999999 < 9$9 9 -+ (2," )*+ . '-12'(' 4 ' 9999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 < 9$9$9 ,)!" '-12'(' 4 ' ) '-12'(' 4 ' "6 0). ) ", "-/')!'B)*+ . ('( "0) 99999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 P

9$9;9 0'(" "- (/S-" ." ), !"+ ) ", "-/')!'B)*+ . '-12'(' 4 ' 9999999999999999999 G 9$9<9 " /"' ."(. 3 )0"- . '-12'(' 4 ' ) , " "-() / -( ' 2/' -)!'B)*+ . , /"(( ,"-)! 3 )('!"' 9999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999$$ 9;9 0)!'(0 @2.'/')! " (2) 2 '!'.)." , !7 '/)99999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999$I 9<9 )!'B)*+ .'( /'8) .) " ') #" )! . , /"(( 9999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999; 9I9 " ') 2-' C ') " (2)( 8) ')- "(9999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999;;

9I9 9 ','/'.)." , /"((2)! 99999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999;< 9I9$9 )D) '8'.)." 9999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999;I 9I9;9 !2 )!'.)." ." " 0 ( ."(/ "8"-. ) 0) ? ')99999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999;T 9I9<9 0, "/'(+ ( 3 " / -/"' ." -2!'.)." " -2!'.)." / 0 ()-*+ . )

'0," 6"' 999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999;T 9I9I9 2!'.)." .) 6 0) , /"((2)! / 0 -2!'.)." . ) @2 7.'/ 999999999999999999999999999;G 9P9 2-.)0"- ( ,) ) 20) 2, 2 ) / 0 ) " ') ).'/' -)! ." -2!'.)."( 999999999999999999999<% $9

9999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999<; $9 9 ) :',4 "(" > ,"(12'() ." /)0, 999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999<; $9$9 " )!:)0"- ?/-'/ .) ,"(12'() ." /)0, 999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999<< $9;9 -C!'(" , "!'0'-) . ( .). ( 3 '. (999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999<P $9<9 "-('6'/)*+ .) )-C!'(" .'(/2 ( ( " ', ! #')( , .2B'.)(9 9999999999999999999999999999999999999I; $9<9 9 (,?/'"( ." -2!'.)."( ) #U'.)( " (2)( /!)(('6'/)*+ 999999999999999999999999999999999999999999I; $9<9$9 #20"- ( .)( ."/'(="( @2.'/')'( ( 3 " )( '-8 /)*="( ." -2!'.)."99999999999999999IG $9I9 -('." )*="( ) ,) ' .) ,"(12'() 12)- ' ) '8) 99999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999PP $9P9 "(12'() 12)!' ) '8) /)( ( ,) ).'#0) 999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999P& $9P9 9 !"#)!'(0 6 0)!'( ) /)( .) )3( !8'*+ )- "/',).) 9999999999999999999999999999999999PG $9P9$9 , '0)B') .) !"' .'-C ') ( 3 " , "/"' ( / -( ' 2/' -)'( )2(5-/') ."

T

$9T9 -/)0'-:)0"- ( .) ,"(12'() "0,7 '/) 999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999&%

;9 9999999999999999999999999999999999&

;9 9 0,"-. / 0 ) " ') 2-' C ')99999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999&$ ;9$9 " ') #) )- '( ) .)( -2!'.)."( 62-*="( .) 6 0) , /"((2)! 9999999999999999999999999999999&< ;9;9 (,?/'"( ." 87/' ( .)( ' "#2!) '.)."( '-('#-'6'/)- "( ) ( ."6"' ( (23( )-/')'(99999&& ;9<9 (,?/'"( ." "(, ( )( ) ( ) ( ."6"' 2 ( ( ()-")0"- A / -8)!'.)*+ A , "/!2(+ " -2!'.)." 9999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999G

;9<9 9 ()-")0"- 99999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999G ;9<9$9 / -8)!'.)*+ (2," )-. ) .'( '-*+ "- " -2!'.)."( )3( !2 )( " "!) '8)( 9999G< ;9<9;9 , "/!2(+ 999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999GT ;9<9<9 -2!'.)." 9999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999GG ;9I9 ',) '*+ .)( 6 0)( , /"((2)'( 99999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 %

;9I9 9 , "*+ . ('( "0) ." #) )- ')( 999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 % ;9I9$9 , "*+ . )/2(). " ) / 8" () 12"( + . , "@27B ) @2 '(, 2.5/') -('( "0) 3 )('!"' '-8" (+ . E-2( , 3) 4 ' 999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 %$

;9I9;9 62-*+ .)( 6 0)( , /"((2)'( / 0 "#2!). )( . )/2(). "( ) )!999999999 %I

&

3@" ."( ) ,"(12'() /"- ) (" -) " ') .)( -2!'.)."( - , /"(( ,"-)! 3 )('!"' A

( 3 , '(0) ." (2) "," /2((+ - , ." ." ,2-' 9 , 3!"0) 12" 0 8" ) '-8"( '#)*+ ? )

62( '#)*+ ." #) )- ')( . '0,2 ). ."/ "- " .) ),!'/)*+ . 0 ."! ." -2!'.)."( 8'#"- "9

V ,'-'+ / "- " ." )!#2-( )2 "( 12" 20 . ( 0)' "( "- )8"( ) '-/ "0"- ."

)/2() '".)." . ('( "0) , /"((2)! 3 )('!"' / -('( " - ."6)(). ('( "0) ." -2!'.)."(A

12" ," 0' " 12" ) ( , /"((2)'( "0 ."(/ -6 0'.)." / 0 )( 3)!'B)( / -( ' 2/' -)'( " !"#)'(

(2 )0 "6"' ( / 0 (" 8C!'. ( 6 (("09

/)0, .)( -2!'.)."( , /"((2)'( "( C 8'-/2!). ) 20) 8" '6'/)*+ .) / -6 0'.)."

. ) , /"((2)! / 0 ."-)0"- @2 7.'/ ). ). 9 " 20 ) "D ), !) ( !'0' "(

'0, ( ( ,"! ) /)3 2* - 0) '8 12" (".'0"- )A "( " ."8" " ("2( "6"' ( / '3'. (9

, D'0)-. (" "0) .) 8'(+ ." ) -"!2 ' ." , /"(( / 0 @ # A (" 0 8'0"- ." 20

@ #). 8' ! 2 )( "# )( . @ # A "( " ."8" (" "6"' 2 )-2!). A 0)( -+ , ." (" )/"'

/ 0 20 ) "#2!) 9 )( / - C ' A (" , /"(( ,"-)! -+ (" ,)2 ) ,"!)( - 0)( -)( 12)'(

"!" , 4, ' (" 62-.)A ) ( , 2/ ( (2) !"#' '0'.)." (" "(8)B') C ) ? )!/)-*) "( C#' ." ,2

"D" /7/' ." , ." )32('8 9

"- " )( ."-('6'/)*="( "4 '/)( ."("-8 !8'.)( - )3)!: A ) )-C!'(" . '."C ' )12'

."- 0'-). -) , C '/) . ( '32-)'( 3 )('!"' ( , ((2' ,),"! /"- )!9

!'-:) ." ) #20"- . )3)!: ? ."(. 3 ).) ) ,) ' . 6 0)!'(0 / 0 "6" "-/')! . (

0)#'( ). ( 3 )('!"' ( " 12" / -("1U5-/')( )! ,"-()0"- "-/" ) C -) / -( !'.)*+ .

('( "0) ." -2!'.)."(9 !?0 . 6 0)!'(0 A )03?0 ) / 7 '/) ) 0 ."! '-12'(' ')! / -('( "

G

."( )( " 2 )( '." ! #')( 12" (" ,!)(0)0 - /)!. /2! 2 )! . ( 0)#'( ). (A /2! )-. (" ( 3

),) "- "0"- " '-(7,'. .'(/2 ( ?/-'/ .) 6 0) , /"((2)!9

0 "6"' A 20) .)( :',4 "("( . )3)!: ? 12" 6 0)!'(0 @2.'/')! , ((2' . '(

"'D ( , 20 !). ? 3 2( " ).'/)!0"- " !"#)!'( ) 12)- >( 8' !)*="( 6 0)'( " , 2

6!"D'3'!'B) )( "# )( / -6 0" (2)( / -8"-'5-/')(9 !'). ) ( ) #20"- ( '2-. ( .) ?/-'/)

, /"((2)!A ) 6 0) , /"((2)! (" )-(6 0) "0 20 . ( '-( 20"- ( 0)'( "6'/)B"( ,) )

)* .)0"- ." #) )- ')( . ( )/2(). (9 "( " ("- '. A ) "D'#5-/') ." ."0 -( )*+ ."

, "@27B ." '8). . ."6"' ,"!) "6"() / -('( " "0 ) '67/' " 4 '/ ." 12" 02' )( ."/'(="(

!)-*)0 0+ A , 12)- )-(,) "/" 20) ),) "- " -"2 )!'.)." "/-'/'( )A -) 8" .)." '0327.

.) 0"- )!'.)." ." "D)/" 3) B"! ,"!) 6 0) , /"((2)! ,) ) )20"- ) "D" /7/' - /'8

." , ." 9

0 '- 2' ." )*) ( ,) )!"! ( "- " /)!. ." /2! 2 ) @2.'/')! " (2)(

/ -("1U5-/')( -) '-) 6 "-("A , 2 (" , ' )!?0 ." 0" ) "8'(+ 3'3!' # C6'/) 87/' .

@2 '( ) O " 32(/) -) ,"(12'() ." /)0, "!"0"- ( 12" 8'"(("0 ) / -6' 0) 2 '!'.' )(

, "0'(()( .) .'((" )*+ 9 (('3'!' 2 (" )(('0 20 /: 12" )-(.'(/',!'-) -) '-8"( '#)*+ A

'0, "(/'-.78"! > ,"(12'() ( 3 20) 4 '/) .) / 0,!"D'.)."A , )- "(/),)-. (" .)(

!'0' )*="( ), "("- ).)( ,"!) . #0C '/) , /"((2)! ,"-)!9 . ) (" , '( 20) ," (,"/ '8)

/ '0'- !4#'/) ,) ) "( 2.) 0 ."! ." -2!'.)."(A / 0 20 8'?( 6 " -) ( /' ! #') @2 7.'/)

,) ) , 0 8" / " '- " .'(/',!'-) ,"! 12)! ."0)-.) 20 "D)0" 12" -+ (" , " "-.) )( 9

) ) !"8)- )0"- ." )/4 .+ ( , " "-.'. A ) ?/-'/) ." ,"(12'() / -('( '2 "0

, /2 ) " ." 2 '(, 2.5-/') . '32-)! ." 2( '*) . ' )-." . 2!A / 0

, ,4(' ." / '#' "8"- 2)'( '0," 6"'*="( 12" ) / -(2! ) ." @2 '(, 2.5-/') 8') '- " -"

,2."((" ), "("- ) 9 "( " , - ? , 2- ()!'"- ) ) 6)/'!'.)." ." )/"(( . (" 8'* ."

/ -(2! ) ." 12" '32-)! .'(,="A 12" ? )3" ) ,F3!'/ " . 12)! "(2! ) 20 !"8)- )0"-

.) 0) ? ') 3)( )- " )/2 ). 9 ,) H0" 32(/). 6 ' " A ,) ) "8' )

12" (2 #'(("0 /)( ( ." -2!'.)."( "0 )*="( /78"'( " 6 ' "( ',2!). 20 '- " 8)! "0, )!

)!") 4 ' A ." %$ ." 6"8" "' ." $%%< ) $& ." (" "03 ." $%%P9 ( )3"!"/'. ( "( "( 0) / (

6 )0 ! /)!'B). ( <$I )/4 .+ ( ." .)( )( H0) )( '0'-)'( . '32-)!9 / !:"' ) ."

.). ( -+ '-/!2'2 )/4 .+ ( , 6" '. ( ,"!)( 2 0)( "/2 ()'( '0'-)'( . ( 2'B). (

%

( @2!#). ( / !:'. ( 6 )0 )-)!'(). ( ( 3 .'8" ( ( 12"(' (A , "D"0,! (2@"'

, /"((2)! 12" (2(/' 2 ) -2!'.)."A (" ) -2!'.)." 6 ' ."/!) ).) 2 -+ A 12)! 3@" .)

(2(/' )*+ A ) #20"- - 12)! ), ' 2 (" ) ."/'(+ " /9 ,*+ ,"!) 0" ) "8'(+ ."

3'3!' # )6') "0 -).) / - '32' ') / 0 ) D'#"-)*+ ." 12" /) "/" ) "0C '/)9 ( (" )6)( ) ')

. "(/ , ." 20) '-8"( '#)*+ /'"- 76'/) / 0 20 8'?( )-(.'(/',!'-) W !:" , "("- "

)3)!: .) '-8"( '#)*+ "0,7 '/) )/)3) ') , "(2! ) -) , .2*+ ." 0)'( 20 "D "4 '/

"0 20) 0) ? ') @C + ",'().)9 0 ) )/2'.)." 12" !:" ? ,"/2!') A )(("8" ) '00 ." 2B)

+ .'(, 0 (A "0 " 0 ( ! " # $ %% %&

" # % % %& ' () # &) %*# % % + , & #

) % % & &) # " % - &

#. . % & ) % )% /% % . . % ) % ) . - &

# # & # 0 & #. . % % & % 12" - ( )B ("2

02-. ." "6" 5-/')(A (2) !'-#2)#"0A (2)( "6" 5-/')( 02' )( 8"B"( / 0,!" )0"- " .'6" "- "( .)( - (()(A ("2( ."("@ ( " "D,"/ ) '8)(9 V -"/"((C ' 12" )((20)0 ( , ('*="( , 4, ')(A ,) ) 12" )( , ('*="( . ( 2 ( , (()0 (" / 0, ""-.'.)(9

"'( 20 .). 62-.)0"- )! .) / - "0, )-"'.)."9 X("0 # '6 ( - '#'-)!Y

)(().) )( )-C!'("( " / -('." )*="( ( 3 " ) ,"(12'() "0,7 '/)A )3)!: , ((2' 20

0 0"- , , (' '8 A - 12)! (" ,"-() -)( 8)- )#"-( .) ). *+ ." 20) - 8) " ') ."

-2!'.)."(A "03)().) - ( "-('-)0"- ( ." !3" '-." A )2 . 12)! "-/)0'-:)0"-

. ) #20"- )12' "D,"-.'. ? !"#) C ' '-"D C8"!9 0 (" 8" '6'/)-. ) , "0'(() ." 12"

0 ."! 8'#"- " ." -2!'.)."( ? 20 0)D'0'B). . , ." ,2-' '8 A '-/ 0,) 78"! / 0 20

0 ."! / -( ' 2/' -)!'B). ." , /"(( A -+ :C )! " -) '8) ("-+ 20) 2, 2 ) ")! / 0

'."C ' 12" '"- ) ) , C '/) @2.'/')!9 "( ) " ) , , ('*+ '-(,' ).) "0 '-." '- "- ) C

"(('#-'6'/) ) 6 0) - / - "D . , /"(( ,"-)! 3 )('!"' 9

( ) .'((" )*+ "( C 8'-/2!).) > '-:) ." "(12'() '0'- ! #') " - !" /')!A )

12)! ." '8) .) ") ." -/"- )*+ '( "0) "-)! " ' !5-/') . "( ). "0 '5-/')(

'0'-)'( .) 9 )!'"- ) (" 12" ) '-8"( '#)*+ )0 !.) (" > '-:) ." "(12'() -) 12)!

(" '-(" " , "/'()0"- " , )-(/"-." > )-C!'(" . #0C '/) . ( '-( ' 2 ( , /"((2)'( ,"-)'(A

) ")!'B) )-C!'(" / '0'- !4#'/) .) , CD'( @2.'/'C ') "0 -2!'.)."( " ." (2) '03 '/)*+ / 0

, ." ,2-' '8 9

1 2

7 2! ." (" 6)B" 20) / -/) "-)*+ .)( '.?')( "D, ( )(A / -8?0 ('- " 'B) )!#2-(

. ( , - ( 62!/ )'( 12" 6 )0 "(()! ). ( -"( ) '03 '/)*+

12" ? /" -" ."( " )3)!: 9 + ? -"/"((C ' 20 "( 2. )/).50'/

), 62-.). ,) ) / -( ) ) 0 0"- ." / '(" 12" ," 0"') , /"(( ,"-)! ." - (( ,)7(9

,),"! 12" ) ."6)().) " ') ." -2!'.)."( /20, " -"(() / '(" ? 20 . ( , - ( /:)8" ,) )

[

\$9

+ 3( )- "A ) / '(" 12" ,"-." ( 3 " , /"(( ,"-)! 3 )('!"' , ((2' 20 )(,"/ ."

/ -( 2*+ . - 8 A 12" ? ('- " 'B). ," (,'/)B0"- " , '/) . '00 ." 2B)

[ '("\ ('#-'6'/) )(('0A )- "(A 20) (' 2)*+ ) "(,"' .) 12)! 20) ." " 0'-).) ."/'(+ "0 ." (" 0).)W ('#-'6'/) 0,'0"- / 0 ) !4#'/) . ,)((). " "12)/' -)0"- " '- " , " )*+ , "/'( ( .)( / -.'*="( . , "("- "W ('#-'6'/) ) , (('3'!'.)." ." .'(/" -' ( "!"0"- ( . ,)((). " . , "("- " - ("- '. .) / -( 2*+ . 62 2 9;

.?6'/' . ('( "0) ." -2!'.)."( , ." ", "("- ) ) , (('3'!'.)." ." (" / -( 2' )!#

12" 62@) > 0)-2 "-*+ " " )!'0"- )*+ . 9 0 "D'( '-. 20 "'D '-12'(' ')!

12" )'-.) ," 0"') ) ," ("/2*+ / '0'-)! - /'."- "A ) ," /",*+ .) 6)!5-/') . 0 ."! , ."

(" 8' ,) ) , 8 /) ("2 )3)-. - A / 0 ) / -( 2*+ ." 20 ."-)0"- 3)!'B). , 20)

)D' ! #') '- 8). )A / 0 ('( "0) ." #) )- ')(A , "D"0,! 9 "((" )(,"/ A ) / '(" , ."

" / -("1U5-/')( , (' '8)(9

$

] N A )2B' ])(()-9 ! " " / 0"- C ' ( / -( !'.). ( " / 7 '/) @2 '(, 2."-/')!9 ' ." )-"' 20"- 2 '(A $%%I9 ,9 TIT9

;

$

"- )- A -+ (" , ( 2!) 12" ('0,!"( "6 0) !"#'(!) '8) ("@) (26'/'"- " ,) ) ," ) )

(2," )*+ . 0 ."! , ( 9 "6 0) . ('( "0) ." -2!'.)."( (" ') '-4/2) (" -+ 6 (("

)/ 0,)-:).) , 20) , 62-.) 02.)-*) . '."C ' 12" '"- ) ( ),!'/). "(9

-( ' 2'*+ .) ",F3!'/) ." && ? "D"0,! / -/ " ." 12" - 0)( ." 8)-#2) .)

."()/ 0,)-:).)( ." ),!'/). "( / 0, 0" '. ( / 0 ("2 "(/ , -+ (+ (26'/'"- "( ,) ) )

"6" '8)*+ ." .' "' ( " #) )- ')(9 -6 0" (" 32(/ 2 ."0 -( ) A ) ).'*+ @2 7.'/) 12"

(".'0"- ) ) , C '/) . ( 0)#'( ). ( 3 )('!"' ( -+ (" ."() )'# 2 . 6 0)!'(0 @2.'/')!A

)0, 2/ ." 20) !4#'/) '-12'(' '8)9

,"(12'() "0,7 '/) , " "-."2 ."!'-") "( "( / - - ( '." !4#'/ ( " )(

/ -("1U5-/')( / -/ " )( ."( )( 8' ).)( .'(/2 ('8)(9 0)-"' ) 0)'( )."12).) ." " ) ) (

"- )8"( ",'( "0 !4#'/ ( .) " ') 8'#"- " ? , /2 ) ("2( "6!"D ( , C '/ (A )'-.) 12"

3(/2 "/'. ( , 20) (2, ( ) )((",(') ?/-'/)9 "-/)( "!)0"- . @2 '( ) "0 ("2 !'03

"4 '/ 6)8 "/" ) , 62(+ ." )3)!: ( )/).50'/ ( 12" -+ , ((2"0 / 0 : 'B - " )

),!'/)*+ , C '/) . ( / -/"' ( " /) "# ')( , .2B'. (9

(('0A -+ (" 8'(!203 ) 2 ) 0)-"' ) ." (2," )*+ . 0 ."! 2-' C ' ." -2!'.)."(

."8" (" , .2B'.) ." 0)-"' ) ."/'('8)A / 0 )3)-. - .) ",'( "0 ! #') @2.'/')! 8'#"- "9

( ) 2, 2 ) , ((2' 3@" '8 ." ."() )'#) 0 ."! ." ",) )*+ ." ) ( , /"((2)'( ."

("2 /)!. /2! 2 )!A ,) ) ("0") )( 3)("( ." 20 ('( "0) "6" '8)0"- " "- 8). A /)!/). "0

20) 4 '/) / -( ' 2/' -)!'B).) ." , /"(( ,"-)!9

+ ? , 2 0 '8 ) "(/ !:) ." '-." / 0 , - ." ,) '.)9 - " ( 8) '). (

)2 "( 12" ) )0 . "0)A ) #"- '- ? 0)'( 2(). A , '( "/:)*) ( / -/"' ( 0)'(

/ 0"B'-: ( "0 -2!'.)."(A ","-()-. ( 20 ) 209 2) , , ( )A )'-.) 12" )3 ) "(,)* ,) )

/" )( / 7 '/)(A , ((2' 8)! ." 2! ),)(() )( / -/!2(="( .) . #0C '/) . 0'-)- "9 "2

/ -/'( "-()' A )- )( 8"B"( "6" '. -"( ) .'((" )*+ A ? 20 0) / ." '/ - /!)( ') " ."8" ("

"-6 "- ). , 12"0 , " "-.) ."3 2*) (" ( 3 " "( " 3@" ." ,"(12'()9

0 "6"' A -+ (" ') / -.'B"- " / 0 )( " ')( 12" - "')0 ) ('( "0) 'B)*+ ."( )

'-8"( '#)*+ ) , " "-(+ ." "(# )0"- . "0)9 62-.)0"- )*+ )D' !4#'/) ). ).)A )(

)-C!'("( ")!'B).)( ( 3 " ( .). ( / !:'. ( -) ,"(12'() ." /)0, " "(3 * ." , , ('*+

;

20 "0) + / 0,!"D 9 ! /)! ." 6)!) 0). / 0 , "((2, ( ? .) /'5-/') ." 12" -+

"D'( " "(, ( ) F-'/) " '-"1278 /) ,) ) ( , 3!"0)( 12" '-( ) )0 ) ,"(12'()9

(," ) (" 12" "( ) .'((" )*+ , (() / - '32' ." )!#20) 6 0) ,) ) "( '02!) (

."3) "( 12" (" , .2B"0 -) '- '-/).) "0C '/) .)( -2!'.)."( , /"((2)'( ,"-)'(9 "-() ("

12" ? -) ,"(12'() )/).50'/) 12" , ." (" )3 ' 20) 8') ." 8"- '!)*+ 12" , (() 0," / 0