Earnings Losses of Displaced Workers: Evidence from a Matched Employer-employee Data Set

DP 2006 – 07

Earnings Losses of Displaced Workers: Evidence from a Matched

Employer-employee Data Set

Anabela Carneiro Pedro Portugal

July 2006

CETE − Centro de Estudos de Economia Industrial, do Trabalho e da Empresa Research Center on Industrial, Labour and Managerial Economics

Research Center supported by Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia, Programa de Financiamento Plurianual through the Programa Operacional Ciência, Tecnologia e Inovação (POCTI)/Programa Operacional Ciência e Inovação 2010 (POCI) of the III Quadro Comunitário de Apoio, which is financed

by FEDER and Portuguese funds.

Faculdade de Economia, Universidade do Porto http://www.fep.up.pt /investigacao/cete/papers/dp0607.pdf

!

"

#

"

"

$

"

!

%

&

'(()

& #* * + , -. / # 0 1 "2 #34 24567894::;* # * < * < 8'(( 8)8 " = " > * 567 '' 6697'57> , 567 '' 66(6(6(> ? * * * < = 97= 776( 7)6 = " > * 567 '7 57'@87(> A ? * * 7

# , B " = * # B B :C 1B ; 7'C 1 ; B , * # B B 0 = , = 0 * = B B , D A * = E B = D B B D 0 * 3 *

& 0 &57> &)5> &)6

F B > > 0

A , B *7 _{# A 1 ;} 1 ; A * 7:@( G B E B !* * H1 = = " B 17:@9;= F 17:@@;= " 17:@:;= F G 17:@:= 7::7;I*' _{$ = B} = 0 D B B * # G B D J B * K B = = B B = B = B B A * B B L * # & 17::5; D B * $ = B B B A * = B * # B B * 3 = , !* * B 0 B B * !* * B , = = 7( '6C 1< = 7::7> & 7::5> = 7::9;* = * * , = B , B * 3 = B = * B B 0 B A D 1$ = 7:::> M & = '((7> = '((';* B = B = B B * # 7 _{= 0} B A B 1 * * ;* B 0 B G * ' _{K 17:@:;= 17::); F G 17::@; *} 5

B , 1'((5;= B G B B !* * * K B B B B 1 7( 76C;= B A D * 3 = 0 0 = B !* *= A * 3 , B B B B B * 17::);= , * = 0 0 * # , = B E B A * = * 3 = * # = J A B B 0 * 3 = A 0 B A *5 _{A J B} 0 B 4 B = B B A * 3 = " 17:@:; F G 17:@:= 7::7; B A B = N B * = , 0 E 4 B = B B B = L B D * = 0 B , * 3 B B 1" = 7:9'> " = 7::';* 2 = B B = = = 1 B = 7::7;* # G B * B " D B O 3 = B O O #B A B * # 0 A G B " * 5 _{= = 17:@9= 7:@@;= A} 17:@9;= # 17::7; 17:::;* 8

B , * # B B B * # B B = B B B E B E B 1 = , = % B = 7::(> $ N B = 7::(> K 2 B = 7::9;* = J B 0 B E B * # A 4 * # B * 3 ' * 5 * # 8 6* # B A 7::8= 7::6 7::) 0 B * 3 = B B 0 1 ; * B 0 B * $ B 0 B B * " = 0 " *8 _{# 0 0 1} = 1 3 ;= = B = = = B ; B 1 = B J 0 = = = = B = *;* = B B G 0 E , * 0 J 0 D 0 * ! 0 0 , * 3 = , 0 8_{K = B B} * " , * 6

*6 _{# B 0 E} J = B , B B B A *) _# , G '(C* 3 B B 0 1 ; 4 B B B B 0 * # G D A * # 0 * = B B 0 G J = B = B= B * 3 = * # B 0 B B 0 *9 _# B 0 B B * 3 = A B B B B * 2 = * # B B B * 3 = B B , = = B A * # , B 0 A B * # = B 0 , 1 B 0 B ; J * = B * 6_{# = B = = 0} , * , = B B B * , B = 0 * 3 = B B , * # = 0 0 , 0 = = * )_{3 = , = B E 7::8 1 ;} B B A 7::' = 1 ; , * 9 _{= 7::7 7::@= B *} )

= B B = A J * B * 3 A * B B 7@ 6: 0 * , B , B , B 1(*7C ;* , = B 7()=68: B B B 7::8 :) 0 * # B B B * B 5((=((( B B B 0 *@ _{# B B} 7::@* # 7::8 B 7::5 0 7::8* # B B B 7::7 :@ B * # 7::6 B 7::8 0 7::6* # B B B 7::' :@ * = 7::) B 7::6 0 7::)* # B B B 7::5 :@ B * # B 0 * 3 B B B = B B E 0 * 3 B B B * 3 B B = B 1 * * & = 7:9:;* # B = B B B 0 1 ;* # B B B 7@ 6: * , @_{# B B *} 9

B , , B = B 79'=)'8 B *

!

# 7 B * # B = B * 0 B * 3 6 1 ; 7( 1 B ; B * # 7= B = = 0 B B B * # B * = D B B B , * # B B = B * # B B B * K B = B B B B B B * B J 0 B B B B , * # ' 5 B = B * B = B B = 0 1 B ; B * 2 B * = B = 89C 0 B 1 # 8;* 2 B 0 = 5(C B * # ''C B B 0 B * # B * 3 B B B 0 B D* 3 = = B B * = = 6@C , 8C B 1 # 6;* = 56C *: :_{K 0 * " 0} @

= ''C A 17:C 5C B ;* = = 88C B = ')C = 79C B = :C 8C 1 # );* # = B B B 7::8 7::)= 86C B *7( _# B = = A 0 " B 0 1 " = '((5;*77 % = * B B G B * 3 = E B P" 0 * J B = J , B *7' 1 ;= * 0 = 7::6 B * 7 (_{$ 7::@= B B} 6= 8= 5 = * % 86C= B * # B , B * 7 7_{3 " 0 , )6 B} , * # 0 , 7( '6 , 5( 66 * , 0 = B B 76 * 7 ' = B B 1 = '((';* 3 = B K 0 = K = * :

! " # ! " # $ % $&% ! " # ! " # $'% $(%

$ % $)% $&% $*% $+% $'% $,% $(% $-% $ .%

& *) # &((+. +' #. ,+-+* .#,+ &))#) )((*+ &--#( *+*+- .#(.'

) *&+#& &,** +(&#, (- . .#,*' &&)#- )(()- * -#- ++&&. .#,-&

*&.#( & ),' +-,#. .++.' .#,)) &&,#, )+* *& #, ', ( .#,()

**(#& '**) ')&#) .++.' .#, - &*(#& **&& *+ #. ', ( .#,,)

**+# .&.) '*'#& ((--* .#'(- &*'# ,''. *'+# ++&)+ .#,**

) *'.#, ).,, ',+#' (&+*( .#'() &+'# ((-, *(+#' + ,-. .#,&&

& *,+#. -*)) '()#. *-')' .#'-, &'(#) , '( *(+#( )--)* .#,+(

* +..#, +',- '-*#& )&&, .#,) &,-#* *+ . *-,#( &',, .#,')

! /0 ! $ %1 !2 )..#*() 0 !3# 405 6 $ 7 -- %#

)

8 $ %1

8

9 : # # : # # : # # : # #

$ % &+#+)' .#-' &,#-'( .#),- &'#+ ( -#-'- *.#(+( .#),,

! $ % +#,&( )#(.. '# (. &# ' '#, ( )#-)* '#*&& &# -'

$ % ,#&.( ,#,-& .#,&' (#+(. #)'& #)*) &#,+ (#+'+

0 ; .#... .#... .#.') .#.&.

" .#... .#... .#+). .#...

4 ; .#... .#... .# *' .#...

4 .#... .#... .#&+- .#...

: < $ % &#&) #' *#(-) )# .* &#+) #(*, *#(*- )# ..

: = > $ % (#**' # -& (#-)& #.&' (#+,* # '+ (#-() #.+*

$ % +#- - .#*,& '# -& .#+*- '#. - .#*&+ '#&., .#++*

&

8 $ %1 =

8

9 : # # : # # : # # : # #

$ % &)#,'. -#(+& &*#) ) -#'., &&#*.& (#'(, &,#)*- -#+-)

! $ % +#-++ )#(., '#&,& &#.+' '#-*& )#(&( '#'*& &# +'

$ % '#-&. ,#),- -#) ) ,#-., #)-. #)*& )#&.'

,#-(-0 ; $?% .#... .#... .#.(. .#.*&

" $?% .#... .#... .#+ , .#...

4 ; $?% .#... .#... .# ), .#...

4 $?% .#... .#... .#)(, .#...

: < $ % &#* , #''. *#+(& #-'& &#' ) #-), *#+- #--)

: = > $ % (# .& # *' (#+), #.(. (#.(' #))- (#+,- #.(&

$ % +#'-) .#&-' +#(( .#*-, +#,(, .#&,& +#--& .#+.,

!"# $% $&"' ( )*+%

' ',,! ( )*+% '"##& (#,*+%

- . . - . .

#',# (''*+ &!"$ ()&*+ )$ ' (,!*+ &" " ()!*+

# - / !"# $% - , &'#% 0 1/ 2 . 1/ ' ' '!, (#&*+ '' ( *+ "" ( $*+ ! " (,*+ ' ## (,#*+ " !"# $% - , &'#% . ' , #'", ( *+ &&$" ('"*+ "!#) ( )*+ ,'#) ($*+ ,#' ( *+ ,

/ 3 ( $$,+ 4 ( $$$+. 5 / 6 / / / / / . 5 / 7 / / / . , _{5 /} 8 / 1 9 : ; (19:< $$ +. / / . / / 7 / / / / = . / / . / 8 / 6 / . > ? / . / / / / / ; (= / +. / 6 / / ; . / 7 6 . / / / = . ( + / (@AB+ / . / / / / / / / / / / / . : / / / 2 ; (7 + / . : / 6 / / ? @AB ( + . : / / 7 ; . : / / / ? / C / / 7 6 . / ? ? / / / C / , _{? 7 .} B / ; / / / 7 $$ $$" / ? / / / . / ? / / / .

? ? ? / / 7 6 . : ) & / @AB ( + ? . 1 ) & 7 / / / / ( + / / / / / 2 ? / ( + . 7 / / . / . 0 / / / / 2 / (= / +? / / / / / / 7 / (= / +. 5 / . 5 / )? / = ? / ? .&* / / ? ? ? . # : / &.,* ( &+. / / / / ; / . / ? 9 ''.!* / / ? ).#* . 0 / . : ? / D 6 / ( . .+ D 6 & . .? / / 6 / . " / ? ? / . > ? / / / 6 ? / 6 / / ; = / . / C / 6 = . / / # _{/ / / /} . "_{: 5. 5 ; 5 / 7 /} 7 7; 6 . : / / / 7; 6 / C / / / / ? / C / / . / ? / 7; 6 ;/ 7 6 / . #

/ / ? / / 6 / / / / 7 / . ) 6 ; 6 / / / . : / / 7 / / ( / = + / 6 / / . : / 6 D 6 . : = / ; / 6 / ? / ' ) &. / 7 = ? / / / / 7 . B 7 / ( +. E ? / ( + ; / . / 6 = / / / 7 . / / / 6 ; 6 / . / / / 6 = (F . * F .'* +. : ? 7 D / ? / . 5 ? / ( ' ) &+. ? / / 6 / ' . . ! . . ( / / / / / 7 +. / / D / / = / 6 . : ? 7 D / / = / 7 ? / / / . ) _{/ ) &} / / ; . / / / ? / ( +. "

) @ / )), ! ( + ('+ (,+ ( + : 1 . 1 . 1 . 1 . !. '" ( .!+ !.! G ( .#+ !.!! G (!.#+ !.! !G ( .,+ !. # ( ).)+ !.!!"G ( !.$+ !.! 'G ( .)+ !.!!)G ( .!+ !. $, ( ''.$+ !.!'$ ( . + !.!'$ ( .!+ !.!'" ( ,.&+ !.'!, ( !.&+ !.!), ( ."+ !.!,$G ( '.,+ !.! !G (!."+ !.', ( #."+ !.!&) ( ).!+ !.! ' ( ,.!+ !.!!&G (!."+ !.' & ( ).&+ !. !$ ( $. + !.!#' ( ,.)+ !.!!!'G (!.!+ !.'# ( ".'+ !. ( &.)+ !.!#' ( ,.,+ !.!!'G (!. + !.'#' ( '."+ !. , ( ".)+ !.! "G ( '. + !.!!$G (!. + 5 !.!"" ( $#.,+ !.! " ( " .&+ !.! " ( " .&+ !.! , ( . + 5 !.!#$ ( . + !.! ' ( '!. + !.! ' ( '!. + !.! ' ( .!+ !. !, (")$. + !.!"$ ( )$. + !.!"$ ( )$. + !.!) ( &&."+ 9 2 !. ! (').)+ !.!$ ('$.$+ !.!$ (,!.!+ !.!$' (,!. + !.! 'G ( . + !.!'# ( ,. + !.! G ( .#+ !.!!$G ( .'+ B = !.!", ('# .#+ !.!", ('# .#+ !.!#) (''".'+ B !. , ('# .$+ !. , ('# .$+ !. ('#&.'+ 0 ( + !.!"" ( #.'+ !.!"! ( .)+ 31 (2 / + !.! 'G ( !.)+ !.! G ( !."+ 1: ( / + !.!"' ( .$+ !.!"" ( #.,+ !.!!" (,#."+ !.!! G ( '.#+ 1 ,.$)! ("! . + ,.,$$ (#' . + ,.,$$ (#' .'+ ,. , (#''.)+ !. !." !." !."' / . 5 7 . B 7 ('+? (,+ ( + . !!. 5 7 *? ; / / G. )

& @ / #! $ ( + ('+ (,+ ( + : 1 . 1 . 1 . 1 . !.!&) ( $.)+ !.! 'G ( .)+ !.!!"G (!.)+ !.! "G ('. + !. !, ( '.'+ !.!! G (!."+ !.!! G ( !.'+ !.!!&G ( . + !. ,! ( #.&+ !.!!"G ( !.$+ !.!!"G ( !.$+ !.!!,G ( !. + !. # ( ).#+ !.! ( '.)+ !.!! G ( !. + !.!"& ( . + !. ) ( . + !.!#" ( .#+ !.!!#G ( !. + !.!" ( .)+ !. $' ( ,.#+ !.!& ( ).'+ !.!''G ( ."+ !.! ) (,.#+ !. $ ( '. + !.!&$ ( ".$+ !.! &G ( .'+ !.!# (,.,+ !. &# ( $. + !.!&, ( #. + !.! G ( !."+ !.!#) (,.!+ 5 !.! ! ( !&.'+ !.!'" (&#.&+ !.!'" (&#.&+ !.! $ (#)."+

5 !.!, ( ",. + !.!'! ( #!.'+ !.!'! ( #!.'+ !.! ( ,'.#+

!. !' (#&).&+ !.!"$ ( !&. + !.!"$ ( !&. + !.!)! ( ). +

9 2 !. ( .&+ !. !& (,&.!+ !. !& (,&.'+ !. ! (,$. +

!.! G ( .'+ !.!'" ( ,.#+ !.! 'G ( .#+ !.!!$G ( . + B = !.!#$ (', .,+ !.!#$ (', . + !.!# ('!$.,+ B !.!$& ('!!. + !.!$) ('!!. + !.!$# ( $". + 0 ( + !.! $ ( ,.&+ !.!, ( '."+ 31 (2 / + !.! &G ( .!+ !.! G ( !."+ 1: ( / + !. , ( $.)+ !. ,' ( $.$+ !.! , (",."+ !.!'# ( ,&.!+ 1 .',$ ("''."+ ,.) , (###.,+ ,.) , (###. + ,.&#! (#"". + !. " !.", !.", !." B ). &

: , ) & 7 '. / 0 / / / / ; . 5 ? ; / . & B / / 2 ? / / 6 / 2 ( +. 5 ; 2 / / 7 / 6 / 7 / . / 31 / / 2 / / ? / / 2 . 7 2 / 2 / ( / +. E ? / ,. / 1: / / / / ( / +. / , ) & / / / ; 6 . : ? ? / 8 / 6 / / / / ; . E / ? / / " , . . ? . 4 / ; / / "." . . .$ . . / / 9 8 2 6 / / 7 2 / / . / / / H ( $$$+ 4 ( $$$+ I E . E / ? / / / 6 . : ? / / ".'* ,. * . / / / 5 9 ( $&$+? 3 ( $$,+? 1 ( $$,+ B ( $$)+? / / / / / J.B ; . E ? / C / 31 6 = . 9 / 7 7 / K L M 2 /. : ) & D 7 ,. / / / . / & _{/ / 7} / / 7 . $

/ / ; / / / 7 7 K / / /. / / / / / 6 . 5 ; ? / 6 / ( # ) . .+ / 2 / . 5 ? 7 ? 6 / / . / / / / 7 / / ? / / / . : ? / / ( + / / / 2 < ( + / / < ( + / / / . : / / / / / / 7 ('+ ) & ( / 31 + = / / / / / ( +? (0 + / (1: + / . $ / / / / . $ $ B A 4 @ 3 ! "* # #'* 3 ,, ,* " , * : 1/ ' * " , * 0 ? / / / / ( / + / ' . . / / 2 2 . 5 ? ! "* / / 2 ,, ,*. 1/ ; ' * / / . E ? / / ! . . / ( # #'*+? 2 " , * / / " , *. $_{5 / / / / / /} 7 ? / $ / . : 5 ; H / / / / 7 / / / . '!

: / B / ; 6 / . J / ? / / 6 / / / / / ; / ; / 6 / / / / . ! / 7 ' ). / . / ! /? #! / $! /. / C / / / 7 . 5 ! ? / / / 6 / 6 ? / / / / ? / . : ? / ? / / ? / 6 / / . . / 7 / ! . . / . E ? / & . . / 7 ? ) . . / $ . . / . / / / / 6 / / . N ? 2 / ? 6 ? . 5 ' !? 7 ? 6 ; / ! / #! / . 5 / . 5 / $! / ? / ? 6 2 / .'! _{/ / 2 7 /} / / / / ? / 2 . 0 / ? / / / / .' : ? / / / / / / / 6 ? / / 6 '!_{5 " ! / C /} 6 = / #* 7 . ' _{B 4 / 4 ( $$&+ /} 9 $&' $$ . '

/ . @/ ? / / 7 / ; / ; / ? / / / / ( + K / / / . 1/ / / / . E / / / 6 ? / / / . E / ? ? / ? 6 ( + / . : / ? / ? / 6 / ( +. 0 ? / / @AB / B ? / / / 6 . A / / 6 ? ? 2 . / ; / 6 2 . E / 7 2 ? / 2 / . E / / ? / 2 / ? / / . 0 / / / / / 2 . ''

! " # $ " # $ " # $ " # $ " # $ " # $

% $ & $ & & $ & $ & ' &

% $ $ $ $ $ & $ $ $ ( $ $ $ & $ % $ $ $ $ $ & $ $ ( $ $ $ $ & $ % $ ( $ $ ' $ ( $ ' $ & ' $ & $ % $ $ $ ( $ $ $ ( '& ( ' $ & $ % $ $ $ $ $ ' $ ( ( ( $ & $ % $ $ $ $ ' $ $' & $ & $ % $ $' $ $ ( $ ' $ & ' $ & $ ) ( ' ( ' ) * $ $ ( $ $ ' $ $ $ $ ' $ $ $ + , ' ' ( ' ( ' ' - $ . $ & $ & ' + /$ ! $ $' ( $ $ (& $ $ $ $ & 0 1 ' ' ' ' ' ' ' 0 2 3 ' ( 4+ # / $ $ $ $ $ ' $ 5" . ,6 $ & $ $ $ & " % ,6 / $ $ $ $ ( $ $ ( ' & ' * $ ' $( $ $ " ' ( ' ( ( ( ' % ! # ! 6 / ) , 7, , # /8 ! ! / ) 7, 98 :, 6 2 6 &

2

! " # $ " # $ " # $ " # $ " # $ " # $

% $ & $ ( & & '&

% & $ $ & & $ & $ & (

% $ & $ $ $ & $ & $ $ $ &

% $ $ ' $ ( $ ' $ & $ '' ' % $ '' $ $ $ $ & $ '' % $ ( $ $ '' $ ( $ $ & ( & % $ $ $ $ $ ' $ & ' & % $ ( $ $ ' $ ( ' $ $ (& ' ' & ) ( ( ' ' ) * $ $ $ $ ( $ $( $ $ $ $ $ $( + , ' ( ' ( ' ' - $ . $ & $ ( ' $ & $ ' '

+ /$ ! $ $ $ $ $ & $ $ & $ $ $' & '

0 1 ' ( ( ( 0 2 3 ' ( ' ' ' ( ( ( 4+ # / $ & $ $ ( $ $ & $ 5" 5 ,6 $ & $ $ $ '& ( " % ,6 / $ $ ( $ $ $ $ (' * $ $ $ $ $ '& $ " ' ( ( ( ' ( ' ' ' ' 0

! "# "$ % & ' ' ( ) * + , ) ) ( - . ) ( /# /.0 1 ) -- /-0 1 "/ $/0 ( % /2 2$0 1 ) ". -/01 ( ". -"0 ( * "# + $2

% " ( 3 *4566-"#/+ 7 *452#"/8/+ 9 9 : # #"#; *" <+ # ##6; *" "+ : # ##/; * # 6+ # ##-; * # /+ : # #$8 * 2 "+ # #"6 * $ .+ : # #/- * . <+ # #$8 * / #+ : # #/2 * 6 /+ # #-" * / .+ : # #2# * < -+ # #-. * 2 -+ : # #28 * 8 .+ # #-8 * 2 6+ : # #.< * "# .+ # #-6 * 2 $+ % ! # #/8 * <$ .+ # #-. * /. -+ = # ##/ *< .+ # ##. *"$ #+ ) # "$. *.2 6+ # "$2 *.$ <+ = # #$/; *" 6+ # #"-; * # <+ # << # <. : > % "## % "0 ( ; $.

? "> : ' = @ = @ -? 9 9 9 ' A= 9 4: @ 3 # ""2 # #.8 # #$. # ##< # "#6 0 /-0 /# $0 ". <0 "##0 7 # #8$ # #$8 B# ##8 B# #-. # "$< 0 /8 $0 $8 60 $" "0 "##0 ? $> : ' = @ = @ -? 9 9 9 ' 9 4: A= @ 3 # ""2 # #.8 # #/- # ##< # "#6 0 /-0 $/ -0 -$ 60 "##0 7 # #8$ # #$8 B# #"2 B# #-. # "$< 0 /8 $0 ". /0 -/ /0 "##0 ? -> : ' = @ = @ -? 9 9 9 ' A= 9 4: @ 3 # ""2 # #.8 # #$. # ##< # "#6 0 /-0 /# $0 ". <0 "##0 7 # #8$ # #/< B# ##8 B# #-. # "$< 0 -/ /0 // 20 $" "0 "##0 $6

? /> : ' = @ = @ -? 9 9 9 ' A= 9 4: @ 3 # ""2 # #.8 # #2/ # ##< # "#6 0 /-0 "/0 /-0 "##0 7 # #8$ # #/< # #$- B# #-. # "$< 0 -/ /0 "8 20 /. "0 "##0 ? 2> : ' = @ = @ -? 9 9 9 ' 9 4: A= @ 3 # ""2 # #8$ # #/- # ##< # "#6 0 $" 20 /2 <0 -$ 60 "##0 7 # #8$ # #2$ B# #"2 B# #-. # "$< 0 -" -0 2$ -0 ". /0 "##0 ? .> : ' = @ = @ -? 9 9 9 ' 9 4: A= @ 3 # ""2 # #8$ # #2/ # ##< # "#6 0 $" 20 -2 20 /-0 "##0 7 # #8$ # #2$ # #$- B# #-. # "$< 0 -# 20 $- /0 /. "0 "##0 $<

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

C-"D ' % "886 ) >

) G @ = "2 ".2 "<<

C-$D H "88" ' > )

G = 88 "/2 "62