www.jped.com.br
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
High frequency of methicillin-susceptible and
methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus in children under 1 year old with skin and soft tissue infections 夽
Lorena Salazar-Ospina, Judy Natalia Jiménez
∗UniversidaddeAntioquia,EscueladeMicrobiología,GrupodeInvestigaciónenMicrobiologíaBásicayAplicada(MICROBA), Medellín,Colombia
Received14March2017;accepted31May2017 Availableonline21September2017
KEYWORDS Staphylococcus aureus;
MSSA;
MRSA;
Pediatric;
Epidemiology;
Molecularbiology
Abstract
Objective: Staphylococcusaureusisresponsibleforalargenumberofinfectionsinpediatric population;however, informationaboutthebehaviorofsuchinfectionsinthispopulationis limited.Theaimofthestudywastodescribetheclinical,epidemiological,andmolecularchar- acteristicsofinfectionscausedbymethicillin-susceptibleandresistantS.aureus(MSSA---MRSA) inapediatricpopulation.
Method: Across-sectionaldescriptivestudyinpatientsfrombirthto14yearsofagefromthree high-complexityinstitutionswasconducted(2008---2010).Allpatientsinfectedwithmethicillin- resistantS.aureusandarepresentativesampleofpatientsinfectedwithmethicillin-susceptible S.aureuswereincluded.Clinicalandepidemiologicalinformationwasobtainedfrommedical recordsandmolecularcharacterization includedspatyping, pulsed-fieldgel electrophoresis (PFGE),andmultilocussequencetyping(MLST).Inaddition,staphylococcalcassettechromo- somemec(SCCmec)andvirulencefactorgenesweredetected.
Results: Atotalof182patients,65withmethicillin-susceptibleS.aureusinfectionsand117 withmethicillin-resistantS.aureusinfections,wereincludedinthestudy;41.4%ofthepatients beingunder1year.Themostfrequentinfectionswereoftheskinandsofttissues.Backgrounds suchashavingstayedindaycarecentersandprevioususeofantibioticsweremorecommon inpatientswithmethicillin-resistantS.aureusinfections(p≤0.05).Sixteenclonalcomplexes wereidentifiedandmethicillin-susceptibleS.aureusstrainsweremorediverse.Themostcom- moncassettewas staphylococcalcassette chromosomemec IVc(70.8%),whichwaslinkedto Panton---Valentineleukocidin(pvl).
Conclusions: Incontrastwithotherlocations,aprevalenceofinfectionsinchildren under1 yearofageinthecitycouldbeobserved;thisemphasizestheimportanceofepidemiological knowledgeatthelocallevel.
©2017SociedadeBrasileiradePediatria.PublishedbyElsevierEditoraLtda.Thisisanopen accessarticleundertheCCBY-NC-NDlicense(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/
4.0/).
夽 Pleasecitethisarticleas:Salazar-OspinaL,JiménezJN.Highfrequencyofmethicillin-susceptibleandmethicillin-resistantStaphylo- coccusaureusinchildrenunder1yearoldwithskinandsofttissueinfections.JPediatr(RioJ).2018;94:380---9.
∗Correspondingauthor.
E-mails:nataliajiudea@gmail.com,jnatalia.jimenez@udea.edu.co(J.N.Jiménez).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jped.2017.06.020
0021-7557/©2017SociedadeBrasileiradePediatria.PublishedbyElsevierEditoraLtda.ThisisanopenaccessarticleundertheCCBY-NC-ND license(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
S.aureusinfectionsinchildrenunder1yearold 381
PALAVRAS-CHAVE Staphylococcus aureus;
MSSA;
MRSA;
Pediatria;
Epidemiologia;
Biologiamolecular
AltafrequênciadeS.aureus(MSSA-MRSA)emcrianc¸ascommenosdeumanode idadecominfecc¸õesdepeleedotecidomole
Resumo
Objetivo: O Staphylococcus aureus é responsável por um grande número de infecc¸ões na populac¸ãopediátrica;contudo,asinformac¸õessobreocomportamentodessasinfecc¸õesnessa populac¸ão sãolimitadas.Oobjetivodo estudofoidescrever ascaracterísticas clínicas,epi- demiológicas e moleculares deinfecc¸ões causadas porStaphylococcus aureus suscetíveis e resistentesàmeticilina(MSSA-MSRA)emumapopulac¸ãopediátrica.
Método: Umestudotransversaldescritivofoirealizadoempacientesentre0e14anosdeidade detrêsinstituic¸õesdealtacomplexidade(2008-2010).TodosospacientesinfectadoscomS.
aureusresistentesàmeticilinaeumaamostrarepresentativadepacientesinfectadoscomS.
aureussuscetíveisàmeticilinaforamincluídos.Asinformac¸õesclínicaseepidemiológicasforam obtidasdeprontuáriosmédicos,eacaracterizac¸ãomolecularincluiutipagemspa,Eletroforese em GeldeCampoPulsado(PFGE)eTipagemdesequênciasmultilocus(MLST).Alémdisso, o Cassete Cromossômico Estafilocócicomec (SCCmec) egenes de fatores devirulência foram detectados.
Resultados: 182pacientes,65cominfecc¸õesporS.aureussuscetíveisàmeticilinae117com infecc¸õesporS.aureusresistentesàmeticilina,foramincluídosnoestudo;41,4%dospacientes commenosdeumanodeidade.Asinfecc¸õesmaisfrequentesforamdapeleedostecidosmoles.
Oshistóricoscomointernac¸õesemcentrosdeatendimentoeousopréviodeantibióticosforam maiscomunsem pacientescominfecc¸õesporS.aureusresistentesàmeticilina(p≤0,05).
Dezesseiscomplexosclonaisforamidentificados,eascepasdeS.aureussuscetíveisàmeticilina forammaisdiversificadas.OcassetemaiscomumfoioCasseteCromossômicoEstafilocócicomec IVc(70,8%),relacionadoàleucocidinadepanton-valentine(pvl).
Conclusões: Em comparac¸ão aoutros locais, observamos uma prevalência deinfecc¸ões em crianc¸ascommenosdeumanodeidadenacidade;oqueenfatizaaimportânciadeconhecer aepidemiologiaemnívellocal.
©2017SociedadeBrasileiradePediatria.PublicadoporElsevierEditoraLtda.Este ´eumartigo OpenAccesssobumalicenc¸aCCBY-NC-ND(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.
0/).
Introduction
ThecomplexsituationofworldwideStaphylococcusaureus resistancetomethicillinhasledtoitscurrentmanagement, representing a priority for the World Health Organization (WHO)andachallengeforhumanpublichealthindifferent regions;however,bothmethicillin-susceptibleandresistant S.aureus (MSSAandMRSA)strainspossessavirulenceand pathogeniccapacitythatallowsthemtoreachhighinfection rates.
SomepopulationgroupsaremoresusceptibletoS.aureus infections; in particular, the pediatric population hasless effective immunologicalfunction,persistentlyhigh bacte- rial colonization rates, poor hygiene habits, and constant exposuretoschoolenvironmentsthatfavortheacquisition ofinfectionandthedisseminationofthemicroorganism.1,2 The epidemiology of S. aureus infections in this popula- tionisdiverse,andthefrequenciesofMRSAinfectiondiffer betweengeographicregions,rangingfrom6%3to69.9%4;in Colombia,frequenciesupto47.4%havebeenfound.5
InMedellin,althoughS.aureusisoneofthemainagents responsibleforinfectionsinthepediatricpopulation,both inhospitals andin thecommunity,thereis littleinforma- tiononthecharacteristicsoftheinfectionscausedbythis microorganisminthispopulation.Thisstudyaimstodescribe theclinical,epidemiological,andmolecularcharacteristics ofS.aureusinfections(MSSA---MRSA)inapediatricpopula- tionofthecity.
Methods
Studypopulation
Anobservationalcross-sectionalstudywasconductedfrom February 2008 to June 2010, at three tertiary care hos- pitalsfromMedellin,the second largest city inColombia.
Patientsbetweenbirthand14yearsinfectedwithS.aureus (MSSA---MRSA) were recruited prospectively; only the first isolatefromeachindividualwasevaluated.Allpatientswith MRSAisolatesobtainedduringthe timeofthe studywere included, and considering that the prevalence of MSSA is higher,asample wasdefined.The sample size wascalcu- latedbasedontheMSSAprevalenceduring2007withineach institution,whichnumbered65isolates.TheMSSA isolates includedwererandomlyselectedeachmonth,fromFebru- ary2008 toJune 2010, using a table of random numbers accordingtorecordsofeachparticipatinginstitution.
The research protocol and informed consent (signed by parents or guardians) were approved by the Bioethics CommitteeforHumanResearchoftheUniversityResearch CenteratUniversidaddeAntioquia(approvalno.0841150) andbythebioethicscommitteeofeachhospital.
Clinicalandepidemiologicaldata
Clinical and epidemiological data for each patient were obtained from medical records. Information included
clinicalanddemographiccharacteristics,antimicrobialuse, risk factors,co-morbidities, typeof infection, treatment, lengthofhospitalstay,andoutcome.AccordingtotheCen- tersfor Disease Control andPrevention (CDC) criteria, an infectionwasconsideredpresentonadmission(POA)ifthe date of the event occurred on the day of admission to an inpatient location, twodays before admission, or the calendardayafteradmission.An infectionwasconsidered healthcare-associated(HAI) ifthe dateofeventoccurred onorafterthethirdcalendardayofadmissiontoaninpa- tient location. Patients with surgical site infections and ventilator-associatedeventwereexcluded.6
Identificationandantibioticsusceptibility
IdentificationofS.aureuswasconductedbystandardlabo- ratorymethodsbasedoncolonymorphologyinsheepblood agar and positive catalase and coagulase tests. Antibi- otic susceptibilities of S. aureus isolates were assessed in accordance with Clinical Laboratory Standards Insti- tute guidelines (CLSI, 2009) using the VITEK® 2 system (BioMérieux,Inc.,NC,EUA).Theantibioticstestedincluded clindamycin, erythromycin, gentamycin, linezolid, mox- ifloxacin, oxacillin, rifampicin, tetracycline, tigecycline, trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole, and vancomycin. The S.
aureusstrainATCC29213wasusedforqualitycontrol.
Polymerasechainreaction(PCR)confirmationofS.
aureusandmethicillinresistance
Thepresenceofthespecies-specificnucandfemAgenesas wellasthemecAgenewereverifiedbyPCR,aspreviously described.7,8
Moleculartyping:spatyping(spa),multilocus sequencetyping(MLST)andpulsedfieldgel electrophoresis(PFGE)
In all isolates, the polymorphic X region of the pro- tein A gene (spa) was amplified and sequenced as previously described.9 Corresponding spa types were assigned using eGenomics software9,10 and Ridom spa- types were subsequently assigned using the spa typing website (http://www.spaserver.ridom.de/) developed by Ridom GmbH and curated by SeqNet.org (http://www.
SeqNet.org/).11MLSTwasperformedonasubsetofteniso- latesrepresentingthe morefrequentspa types,usingthe methodologydescribed by Enright et al.12 Allele numbers andsequencetypes(ST)wereassignedusingthedatabase maintained at http://saureus.mlst.net/while clonal com- plexes (CC)were inferredusing eBURSTanalysis.13 Clonal complexes for all remaining strains were inferred by spa repeatpatternanalysis,10orbyreferringtotheRidomspa serverwebsite.
PFGE,followingSmaIdigestion,wasperformedaccording to a protocol described elsewhere.14 DNA fragment pat- ternswere normalized using S. aureus strain NCTC 8325.
ClusteranalysiswasperformedusingtheDicecoefficientin BioNumericssoftware(BioNumerics®,softwareversion6.0, Belgium).Dendrogramsweregeneratedbytheunweighted
pairgroupmethodusingaveragelinkages(UPGMA).Similar- itycut-offsof80% and95%wereusedtodefine typesand subtypes,respectively.14
SCCmectyping
ForMRSAisolates,SCCmectypesandsubtypesweredeter- minedusingsetsofmultiplexPCR reactions,aspreviously described.15,16 MRSAstrainswereincludedaspositivecon- trolsforSCCmectypesandsubtypes.
Detectionofstaphylococcalvirulencefactors Allisolateswerescreenedforthegenesencodingstaphylo- coccalenterotoxins(sea,seb,sec,sed,see),toxicshocksyn- drometoxin1(tst),andexfoliativetoxinsaandb(eta,etb), usingtheprotocolsandprimersdescribedbyMehrotraetal.8 ThelukS/F-PVgenes,encodingPanton-Valentineleukocidin (PVL); and the arcA gene, associated arginine catabolic mobileelement(ACME),werealsoassessedbyPCR.17,18 Statisticalanalyses
Comparisons of clinical, epidemiological, and molecular characteristics were conducted between MSSA and MRSA infectedpatients,andamongthedifferentgroupsofinfec- tionsobtainedafterapplyingCDCcriteria.
Categorical variables were compared using the chi- squared test or Fisher’s exact test; Student’s t- and Mann---WhitneyUtestswereusedforcontinuousvariables.p values≤0.05wereconsideredstatisticallysignificant.Sta- tisticalanalyseswerecarriedoutusingthesoftwarepackage inSPSS® (IBMSPSSStatisticsforWindows,version21.0,NY, USA).
Results
Clinicalandepidemiologicaldata
Therewere182pediatricpatientswithS.aureusinfections included;ofthese,65hadMSSAinfectionsand117hadMRSA infections;119patientscamefromhospitalA,51fromhos- pitalB,and12fromhospitalC.
Intheselectedstudy population,theratioof boysand girlswas2:1andthemedianagewas2years;however,41.2%
(n=75)oftheinfectionsoccurredinpatientsbetweenbirth and1yearof age,inwhichahigh frequencyofMRSAand MSSAinfectionswasobserved(Fig.1).
AccordingtotheCDCcriteria,62.7%(n=101)oftheinfec- tions were POA, and 37.3% (n=60) corresponded to HAI (p=0.391). Infection type showed statistically significant differences by hospital. In hospitals A and B therewas a predominanceofPOAinfections;inhospitalCtherewasa predominanceofHAI(p=0.029).Twenty-one(11.5%)surgi- calsiteinfectionswereidentified,whichwerenotincluded inthisclassification.
The clinical---epidemiological characteristics of the patientsevaluatedinthestudyaredescribedinTable1.In general,aprevioushistoryofhospitalizationwasthemost frequentantecedentamongpatients,with51.65%(n=94);
S.aureusinfectionsinchildrenunder1yearold 383
50
45
30
20
MRSA MSSA
% of isolates
Age in years 10
0
<1 2-4 5-8 9-12 13-14
35
25
15
5 40
Figure 1 Frequency of infection by age group. MSSA, methicillin-susceptible Staphylococcus aureus (n=65); MRSA, methicillin-resistant Staphylococcusaureus (n=117). The fig- ureshowstheagedistributionofpatientsinfectedbyMSSAand MRSAstrains. A higherfrequencyofinfectionsis observedin childrenunder1year.
furthermore,havingstayedindaycarecenters(MRSA11.1%, n=13 vs. MSSA 1.5%, n=1; p=0.020) and previous use of antibiotics (MRSA 55%, n=60 vs. MSSA 32.8%, n=20;
p=0.005)wasthemostfrequentantecedentinpatientswith MRSAinfections.
InHAI,aprevioushistoryofintensivecareunit(ICU)stay (MRSA21.4%,n=9vs.MSSA0%;p=0.047)andpriorantibiotic useinthelastsixmonths(MRSA64.1%,n=25vs.MSSA29.4%, n=5;p=0.017)weremorefrequentinpatientswithMRSA infections.
However, thehospital stay waslongerin patients with HAI,withasignificant differenceinfavor ofpatientswith MRSAinfections (MRSA 0---434days, Me=14 vs.MSSA 2---43 days,Me=5.5;p=0.038).
The mostfrequentsites ofinfectionwereskin andsoft tissue,with41.21%(n=75),andthemostcommonmedical servicewasinternalmedicine,with64.84%(n=110).
The frequency of co-morbiditiesin the population was 74.1%(n=135),morefrequentinpatients withPOAinfec- tions causedby MSSA(MSSA 81.1%, n=30vs.MRSA 54.7%, n=35;p=0.008).
Ofthepopulation,57.6%requiredsurgicaltreatmentand healingwasthemostfrequent outcome;especiallyinPOA infections caused by MSSA (MSSA 56.8%, n=21 vs. MRSA 34.4%,n=22;p=0.028).Sixofthepatientsincludedinthe studydied;however,thiswasthecrudemortalityandnot attributedtoS.aureusinfection.
Resistanceprofile
TheMSSAisolateshadsixresistanceprofiles;61.5%(n=40) weresusceptibletoallantibioticsevaluated,16.9%(n=11)
Figure2 ResistanceprofilesofthemainMRSAclones.MRSA, methicillin-resistantStaphylococcusaureus. Figureshows the profile of antimicrobial resistance of the main MRSA clones foundinthestudy.Antibioticsassessed:oxacillin(Oxa),tetracy- cline(Tet),clindamycin(Clin),erythromycin(Eri),gentamycin (Gen). Dark column: isolates belonging to CC5-SCCmec-I (n=22); clearcolumn: isolates belonging to CC8-SCCmec-IVc (n=75).
wereresistanttotetracycline,and9.2%(n=6)toerythromy- cinandclindamycin.TheMRSAisolateshadeightresistance profiles;44.4%(n=52)wereresistantonlytooxacillin,fol- lowed by 28.2% (n=33) with resistance to oxacillin and tetracycline. All of the isolates were susceptible to van- comycin,linezolid,andtigecycline.
Moleculartyping
Amongalltheisolates,16clonalcomplexes(CC)wereiden- tified.MSSA strainswere the morediverse, with ahigher numberofCCs;themostcommonwereCC8(29.2%,n=19), CC45(16.9%,n=11),andCC1(10.8%,n=7),whereasinthe MRSAstrainsthemostcommonCCswereCC8(70.9%,n=83) andCC5(22.2%,n=26).
The presence of mecA gene wasconfirmed in the 117 selectedMRSAstrains.Ofthese,itwaspossibletoidentify the SCCmec type in 113 strains; four isolates were non- typeable.OftheMSRAisolates,70.8%harboredSCCmecIVc (n=80), followedbySCCmecI(20.3%,n=23),SCCmecIVa (5.3%,n=6),andSCCmecV(2.7%,n=3).Anisolatewasiden- tifiedwithSCCmecIV,butitssubtypewasnotidentifiable (0.9%;n=1).
Among patients with POA infections, 87.1% (n=54) of MRSAisolatesharboredSCCmecIVc,followedbySCCmecI (8.1%,n=5)andSCCmecIVa(4.8%,n=3).Meanwhile,MRSA isolates from HAI patients harbored SCCmec type IVc in 56.1%(n=23),followedbySCCmectypeI(26.8%;n=11),IVa (7.3%;n=3),V(7.3%,n=3),andIV(2.43%,n=1).SCCmec IVcwasthemostfrequenttypeinbothtypesofinfection.
TheresistanceprofilesofthemostimportantMRSAclones areshowninFig.2.
Forty different spa types were identified in MSSA and MRSAstrains.Themost commontypes weret1610(17.6%, n=32),t008(17%,n=31),t149(11%,n=20),andt024(9.9%;
n=18).InMSSAisolatesbelongingtoCC8,typest1635and
Salazar-OspinaL,JiménezJN Table1 ClinicalandepidemiologicalcharacteristicsofpatientswithStaphylococcusaureus(MSSA---MRSA)infections.
POA-I(n=101)n(%) HAI(n=60)n(%) Total(n=182)n(%)
MSSA MRSA p-Value MSSA MRSA p-Value MSSA MRSA p-Value
n=37(36.6) n=64(63.4) n=18(30.0) n=42(70.0) n=65 n=117
Gender
Male 25(67.6) 41(64.1)
0.721 11(61.1) 32(76.2)
0.235 43(66.2) 78(66.7)
0.944
Female 12(32.4) 23(35.9) 7(38.9) 10(23.8) 22(33.8) 39(33.3)
Age(years)
Median 4 4
0.534b 3.5 1 0.141b 3 2
0.330b
Range 0---14 0---14 0---12 0---14 0---14 0---14
≤1years 10(27.0) 21(32.8)
0.601
5(27.8) 22(52.4) 0.130 23(35.4) 52(44.5)
0.826
2---4years 12(32.4) 16(25.0) 5(27.8) 10(23.8) 18(27.7) 27(23.1)
5---8years 3(8.1) 8(12.5) 3(16.7) 2(4.8) 7(10.8) 11(9.5)
9---12years 7(18.9) 15(23.4) 5(27.8) 5(11.9) 12(18.5) 20(17.1)
13---14years 5(13.5) 4(6.3) 0(0) 3(7.1) 5(7.7) 7(6.0)
Previoushistory
Hospitalizationinthepastyear 21(56.8) 29(45.3) 0.268 5(27.8) 23(54.8) 0.055 33(50.8) 61(52.1) 0.860
StayinICUinthepastyear 3(8.1) 1(1.6) 0.138a 0(0) 9(21.4) 0.047a 5(7.7) 14(12.0) 0.366
Surgeryinthepastyear 11(29.7) 11(17.2) 0.141 4(22.2) 14(33.3) 0.389 25(38.5) 36(30.8) 0.292
Dialysisinthepastyear 4(10.8) 1(1.6) 0.059a 1(5.6) 4(9.5) 1.000 5(7.7) 5(4.3) 0.333a
MRSAisolationinthepastyear 1(2.7) 2(3.1) 1.000a 0(0) 4(9.5) 0.306a 1(1.5) 7(6.0) 0.262a
Antimicrobialsuseinpastsix months
11(31.4) 27(45.8) 0.171 5(29.4) 25(64.1) 0.017 20(32.8) 60(55.0) 0.005
Traumainpastsixmonths 9(24.3) 10(15.6) 0.281 7(38.9) 8(19.0) 0.118a 16(24.6) 19(16.2) 0.169
Stayinachildren’sdaycare centersinthepastyear
1(2.7) 6(9.4) 0.418a 0(0) 5(11.9) 0.309a 1(1.5) 13(11.1) 0.020
Familyinfectioninthepastyear 5(21.7) 10(21.7) 1.000 2(15.4) 7(19.4) 1.000a 9(21.4%) 17(18.3) 0.668 Sportsparticipationinthepast
year
8(27.6) 16(32.7) 0.639 2(14.3) 3(7.9) 0.602a 10(19.6) 20(20.4) 0.908
Hospitalstay(days)
Median 0 0 0.098
b
5.50 14 0.038
b
0 0 0.309
Range 0---1 0---1 (2---43) (0---434) (0---50) (0---434) b
S.aureusinfectionsinchildrenunder1yearold385 Table1 (Continued)
POA-I(n=101)n(%) HAI(n=60)n(%) Total(n=182)n(%)
MSSA MRSA p-Value MSSA MRSA p-Value MSSA MRSA p-Value
n=37(36.6) n=64(63.4) n=18(30.0) n=42(70.0) n=65 n=117
Service
Internalmedicine 28(75.7) 42(65.6)
0.264
10(55.6) 27(64.3)
0.369
43(66.1) 75(64.1)
0.388
PediatricICU 2(5.4) 5(7.8) 2(11.1) 9(21.4) 5(7.7) 15(12.8)
Orthopedics 3(8.1) 14(21.9) 1(5.6) 0(0) 4(6.2) 15(12.8)
Surgery 1(2.7) 0(0) 3(16.7) 5(11.9) 7(10.8) 8(6.8)
Emergency 1(2.7) 2(3.1) 1(5.6) 0(0) 3(4.6) 2(1.7)
Other 2(5.4) 1(1.6) 1(5.6) 1(2.4) 3(4.6) 2(1.7)
Infectiontype
Skinandsofttissue 18(48.6) 32(50.0)
0.011
9(50) 16(38.1)
0.329
27(41.5) 48(41.0)
0.155
Pneumonia 1(2.7) 13(20.3) 2(11.1) 7(16.7) 3(4.6) 20(17.1)
Bloodstream 4(10.8) 5(7.8) 4(22.2) 3(7.1) 8(12.3) 8(6.8)
Catheter-relatedbloodstream 4(10.8) 0(0) 3(16.7) 11(26.2) 7(10.8) 11(9.4)
Osteomyelitis 1(2.7) 6(9.4) 0(0) 0(0) 1(1.5) 6(5.1)
Arthritis 1(2.7) 3(4.7) 0(0) 1(2.4) 1(1.5) 4(3.4)
Intra-abdominal 1(2.7) 0(0) 0(0) 0(0) 1(1.5) 0(0)
Surgicalsite – – – – 10(15.4) 11(9.4)
Other 7(18.9) 5(7.8) 0(0) 4(9.5) 7(10.8) 9(7.7)
Comorbidities
Co-morbidities 30(81.1) 35(54.7) 0.008 15(83.3) 38(90.5) 0.419 53(81.5) 82(70.1) 0.091
Atopy 7(18.9) 8(12.5) 0.382 1(5.6) 8(19.0) 0.255a 9(13.8) 16(13.71) 0.974
Immunosuppression 6(16.2) 5(7.8) 0.204a 3(16.7) 3(7.1) 0.352a 9(13.8) 9(7.7) 0.183
Chronicrenaldisease 3(8.1) 2(3.1) 0.353a 1(5.6) 3(7.1) 1.000a 4(6.2) 5(4.3) 0.493a
Neoplasia 3(8.1) 1(1.6) 0.138a 0(0) 2(4.8) 1.000a 3(4.6) 4(3.4) 0.702a
Otherco-morbidityc 12(32.4) 13(20.3) 0.174 6(33.3) 24(57.1) 0.091 26(40.0) 45(38.5) 0.838
Cardiovasculardisease 3(8.1) 1(1.6) 0.138a 1(5.6) 5(11.9) 0.658a 11(16.9) 11(9.4) 0.136
Lungdisease 1(2.7) 1(1.6) 1.000a 0(0) 8(19.0) 0.091a 1(1.5) 9(7.7) 0.099a
Treatment
Surgicaltreatment 22(59.5) 43(67.2) 0.435 8(44.4) 20(47.6) 0.821 34(52.3) 71(60.7) 0.273
Outcome
Healing 21(56.8) 22(34.4) 0.028 14(77.8) 35(83.3) 0.719a 41(63.1) 62(53.0) 0.188
Improvement 16(43.2) 40(62.5) 0.061 4(22.2) 5(11.9) 0.431a 24(36.9) 49(41.9) 0.513
Death 0(0) 2(3.1)a 0.531a 0(0) 2(4.8) 1.000a 0(0) 6(5.1) 0.090a
POA-I,presentonadmissioninfection;HAI,healthcare-associatedinfection;MSSA,methicillin-susceptibleStaphylococcusaureus;MRSA,methicillin-resistantStaphylococcusaureus;ICU, intensivecareunit.
Significantdifferences(p-values≤0.05)areshowninbold.
a Fisher’sexacttest.
b Mann---WhitneyU-test.
c Otherco-morbidities:cardiovasculardisease,chroniclungdisease,nervoussystemdiseases,skindiseases,malnutrition,cholestaticsyndrome,subglotticstenosis,snakebite,Rh-ABO incompatibility,shortbowelsyndrome,nesidioblastosis,laryngealandlungpapillomatosis,hemophiliaB,chronicosteomyelitis,congenitalmalformations,nephropathy,andothers.
t008, each with 9.2% (n=6) were the most frequent and t922,with6.2%(n=4),belongingtoCC1,werehighlighted.
MostimportantstrainsofMRSAwerethosebelongingtoCC8, andthemostfrequentwereCC8-SCCmecIVc-t1610(27.43%, n=31),CC8-SCCmecIVc-t008(19.47%,n=22),CC5-SCCmec I-t149(16.81%,n=19), andCC8-SCCmecIVc-t024(15.04%, n=17).
Duringthestudy period,achange wasobserved inthe mostimportantclonal complexes,both in MSSAandMRSA isolates. CC5 almost completely disappeared, while CC8 andCC45 remainedconstant. Inaddition, theincrease of otherCCswasevident,althoughnoneofthemwerespecifi- callypredominant.Duringthethreeyearsofthestudy,the clonebelongingtoCC8-SCCmecIVcofMRSAwasincreasing, representingthe most prevalent,while the CC5-SCCmec I disappearedinthethirdyear.
SixteenisolatesofMSSAwereanalyzedusingPFGE,anda greatdiversitywasfoundintheresults(Fig.3A).Analysisof MRSAbyPFGEwasperformedon26isolatesandfourrelated groupswere identified.Thelargest grouphad15 isolates, which belonged to CC8, and harbored SCCmec IVc; 14 of themwerepositiveforpvlandhaddifferentspatypes(t008, 7/15;t1610,4/15;t024,3/15;t2031,1/15;Fig.3B).
Virulencefactors
Eight virulencefactor geneswere detected,both in MSSA and MRSA strains; however, higher gene prevalence was observedin MSSAcomparedtoMRSAisolates.Statistically significant differences were observed between MSSA and MRSAstrains regarding the pvl genes (MRSA 76.9%, n=90 vs.MSSA32.3%,n=21;p=0.000),sed(MSSA33.8%,n=8vs.
MRSA10.3%,n=12;p=0.000),andsee(MSSA12.3%,n=8vs.
MRSA2.6%,n=3;p=0.018).
The presenceofpvl showedstatisticallysignificantdif- ferences between isolates with SCCmec IVc and other typesofSCCmec(SCCmecIVc95%,n=76vs.otherSCCmec 30.3%, n=10; p=0.000); It suggests that the pvl gene is morefrequentlyassociated withisolates withSCCmecIVc than SCCmec I. Genes such as sed and tst were associ- atedwithSCCmecIVa(sed,p=0.001;tst,p=0.012),while the eta gene was associated with SCCmec V (p=0.027).
No etb and arcA (ACME) genes were found in any of the isolates.
Discussion
InfectionscausedbyS.aureus(MSSA---MRSA)inchildpopula- tionscontinuetobeamajorconcern,bothinthecommunity and the hospital environment. In general, studies in the pediatric population are few, and some have limitations:
many of them focus on certain infection types and most donot present informationon infections caused by MSSA strains,whichremainrelevantandhavenotbeendisplaced byMRSAstrains.
Inthisstudy,asignificantnumberofinfectionsoccurred onpatients betweenbirthand1 yearofage (41.2%),who mainlyhadskinandsofttissueinfectionscausedbyMRSA.
Interestingly,fewstudiesonS.aureusinfectionsinchildren populationagreewiththesefindings,asreportedin China byWuetal.in2010;theyfoundthat37.6%ofskinandsoft
tissueinfectionsoccurredinchildrenyoungerthan1year.19 Likewise,morbidityandmortalityreportsbytheCDCinthe United States have described an important prevalence of skinandsofttissueinfectionsinneonatalpatients.20 How- ever, other publications differon infectiontypes; authors suchasIlczyszynetal.inPoland21andQiaoetal.inChina22 have shown that S.aureus infections in children between birthand1yeararemainlyoftheinvasivetype(bacteremia andpneumonia).22
Likewise, results of other studies contrast with the present study regarding age; studies in Brazil23 and Argentina,24forexample,haveshownahighprevalenceofS.
aureusinfectionsinpatientsbetween2and5yearsofage, andotherstudiescarriedoutinColombia,incitiessuchas Bucaramanga25 andCartagena,5describeahighprevalence of S. aureus infections in children agedbetween 4 and 5 yearsandbetween10and17years,respectively.
Infectionsindifferentagegroupsaredeterminedbythe particularitiesofeachpopulationandbytheriskfactorsto whichinfantsareexposed;furthermore,theinfantpopula- tionhasalessadaptedimmunesystem,whichallowsgreater colonization,morereadilydevelopedclinicalpresentations, andmorecomplications.1,2
Inthisregard,apreviousstudy,carriedoutinMedellin during2011,revealedcolonizationfrequenciesbyS.aureus (MSSAandMRSA)of45.9%inchildrenunder2years.26This is an important aspect taking into account the relation- shipbetweencolonizationandthedevelopmentofS.aureus infections,sinceitispossiblethatthefrequenciesofinfec- tion found in pediatric patientsare related,amongother aspects,tothefrequenciesofcolonizationreportedinthe city.
In particular, in this study a relationship between the antecedentofhavingstayedindaycarecentersandMRSA infectionswasfound,whichcouldbeduetothefrequency ofcolonizationpreviouslyreportedinchildrenfromMedel- líndaycarecenters.Rodríguezetal.wereabletoestablish thatthecolonizingstrainswerecloselyrelatedtothestrains causinginfectioninthecity.26 Daycarecentershavebeen describedasanimportantreservoir ofthemicroorganism, becomingfavorableplacesforitsdissemination.Theseenvi- ronmentsallowtheswappingobjectsbetweenchildrenwho have poorhygienehabits, whichthereforemakesdissemi- nationmorelikely.2
According to a previous study published on S. aureus infectionsintheadultpopulationfromMedellín,27thisstudy foundthatS.aureusstrainsharboringSCCmecIVc,usually associatedwiththecommunityenvironment,predominated as etiological agents of HAIs, displacing the traditional strains with the SCCmec type I that dominated in hospi- tals.Further,frequenciesofSCCmecIVcwerehigherinthe infantpopulationcomparedtothosereportedintheadult population(58.7%adultvs.70.8%pediatric).27
This discovery shows the success of SCCmec IVc in the child population, which is a cause of great concern becauseit facilitates themaintaining of virulencefactors like Panton-Valentine leukocidin (PVL) and its dissemina- tion may be greater in this population. As described, SCCmecIVissmaller;therefore,thebiologicalcostofresis- tancedecreases,favoringitspropagationoverotherstrains.
Spreadoccursmainlyinstrainsbelongingtospecificclonal
S.aureusinfectionsinchildrenunder1yearold 387 PFGE
Strain ID Strain ID MSSA H339
MRSA P80 MRSA H135
MRSA P171
MRSA H229 MRSA H384
MRSA HP54 MRSA H324 MRSA C25 MRSA C66 MRSA P96 MRSA H287 MRSA H276 MRSA P244 MRSA H286 MRSA P219 MRSA H422 MRSA P78 MRSA P221 MRSA H271 MRSA C47 MRSA C23 MRSA H474 MRSA H426 MRSA H417 MRSA H347 MRSA H314
t008 ; YHGFMB.
t008 ; YHGFMBQBLO
t024 ; YGFMBQBLO t024 ; YGFMBQBLO t008 ; YHGFMBQBLO
8 8 8 8 8 8 8
8 8 8 8 8 8/72
5 I
IVc IVc
V V V NT NT
I IVc IVc IVc IVc IVc IVc IVc IVc IVc IVc IVc IVc
+ + + +
+ + + + + + + + +
+ + +
IVc IVc IVc
IVc
I 5 5 30 9 59 8 8 8 8 8 8 8
t1610 ; YHGFMBQBBLO t1610 ; YHGFMBQBBLO t008 ; YHGFMBQBLO
t1610 ; YHGFMBQBBLO t1610 ; YHGFMBQBBLO t008 ; YHGFMBQBLO
t008 ; YHGFMBQBLO
t008 ; YHGFMBQBLO t008 ; YHGFMBQBLO t008 ; YHGFMBQBLO
442 (t149) 1273 (t7279) 442 (t149) 43 (t021) 37 (t209) 17 (t216) 451 (t324) 366 (t068) 1037 (t1635) t024 ; YGFMBQBLO t008 ; YHGFMBQBLO 873 (t2031)
8 1 12 97 1/188 15
45 121
unk unk unk 45 45 45 45 152 105 (t2:67)
122 (t1:89)
207 (t3:55) 263 (t2:143)
715 (t6:30) 715 (t6:30)
411 (t6:45) 1264 (t:1445)
400 (t7:463) 400 (t7:463) 263 (t2:143) 1260 (t:5211) 151 (t2:28) 110 (t2:13) 175 (19:22) MSSA H369
MSSA H326 MSSA H430 MSSA H445
MSSA P137 MSSA H402 MSSA P228
MSSA H289 MSSA P156 MSSA H475
MSSA H309 MSSA P152 MSSA H525 MSSA C19 MSSA H493
CC
CC
spa type SCCmec pvl
spa type
40 50 60 70
70 75 80 90 10085 95
80 90 100
PFGE
A
B
Figure 3 Genetic relatedness in MSSA and MRSA isolates. UPGMA dendrogram showing genetic relatedness in a sample of methicillin-susceptibleStaphylococcusaureus(MSSA)(A)andmethicillin-resistantStaphylococcusaureus(MRSA)(B)isolates.Dotted lineindicatesthecut-offpoint,ortheDicecoefficientof80%;thisisusedtodefinePFGEclones.Clustersabovethispercentage areconsideredtobegeneticallyrelated.IsolatesidentifiedwiththeletterHbelongtohospitalA,isolatesidentifiedwiththeletter PbelongtohospitalB,andisolatesidentifiedwiththeletterCbelongtohospitalC.
complexes such asCC8, which could beevidenced in the PFGEresults,aswasreportedpreviously.28
Nonetheless, the spa types predominant in this study;
t1610, t008, t149, and t024 have been previously identi- fied,mainly in MRSAstrains infecting pediatric andadult
patients,notonlyinColombiaandLatinAmericanbutalso inmanycountriesaroundtheworld.29,30Thesefindingsshow the wide circulation among the general populations, and suggest thepathogenic capacity and disseminationability ofthesestrains.
Withregardtotheresistanceprofiles, adifferencewas observedbetweenthisstudyandothers,whichmaybedue todifferencesinuseofantimicrobials,eitherintheclinical setting or elsewhere. Heterogeneity confirms the impor- tanceofknowing thebehaviorof theseinfectionsin each regionandinstitution.Further,thedifferencesbetweenthe resistanceprofilesofthemainMRSAclonesreportedinthe study allow a clinical approach tothe recognition of the predominantclones,withouttheneedformoleculartyping.
Inthe present studya predominance ofPOAinfections wereobserved;however,health-careassociatedinfections continuebeingveryimportantinthepediatricpopulation.
At the same time, MSSA strains constitute an important sourceof infections;in thiscase, theyharbored avariety ofvirulencefactorsgenesincontrastwiththeMRSAstrains, anaspectpreviouslydescribed.
Theresultsofthepresentstudyrepresentvaluableinfor- mation for the knowledge of local epidemiology and the controlofpediatricinfectionsinthecity.Inaddition,they demonstratethattheepidemiologyofthismicroorganismis diverseandthat,duetotheparticularitiesofeachregion, the data cannot be extrapolated. In general, the study demonstrateda higher prevalence of SCCmec IVc in chil- drenthanadults,whichcouldindicateagreaterspreadof thechromosomalcassetteinthispopulationgroupandmay requireadditionalstudies.
Althoughthestudygroupdoesnotconstituteacomplete cohort,thepatientsandtheevaluatedisolatesaretheresult ofcarefullydesignedsampling.
Funding
Sustainabilitystrategyconsolidation processCODI(Comitê de Desenvolvimento e Pesquisa). University of Antioquia, researchGrouponBasicandAppliedMicrobiology.MICROBA (Grupo de Pesquisa em Microbiologia Básica e Aplicada) 2016---2017.
Conflicts of interest
Theauthorsdeclarenoconflictsofinterest.
References
1.Rodríguez EA, Jiménez JN. Factores relacionados con la colonización por Staphylococcus aureus. IATREIA (Medellín).
2015;28:66---77.
2.Lamaro-Cardoso J, De Lencastre H, Kipnis A, Pimenta FC, OliveiraLS,OliveiraRM,etal.Molecularepidemiologyandrisk factorsfornasalcarriageofStaphylococcusaureusandmethi- cillinresistantS.aureusininfantsattendingdaycarecenterin Brazil.JClinMicrobiol.2009;47:3991---7.
3.VanderMeeMarquetN,PoissonDM,LavigneJP,FranciaT,Tris- tanA, Vandenesch F,etal. Theincidence ofStaphylococcus aureusST8-USA300amongFrenchpediatricinpatientsisrising.
EurJClinMicrobiolInfectDis.2015;34:935---42.
4.Jimenez-Truque N, Saye EJ, Thomsen I,Herrera ML, Creech CB. Molecularepidemiologyofmethicillin-resistantStaphylo- coccus aureus in Costa Rican children. Pediatr Infect Dis J.
2014;33:e180---2.
5.Correa-JiménezO,Pinzón-RedondoH,ReyesN.Highfrequency ofPanton-ValentineleukocidininStaphylococcusaureuscausing
pediatricinfectionsinthecityofCartagena-Colombia.JInfect PublicHealth.2016;9:415---20.
6.Centerfor DiseaseControl and Prevention(CDC).Identifying healthcare-associatedinfections(HAI)forNHSNSurveillance;
2016. Available from: https://www.cdc.gov/nhsn/pdfs/
pscmanual/2pscidentifyinghaisnhsncurrent.pdf [cited 05.04.16].
7.BrakstadOG,AasbakkK,MaelandJA.DetectionofStaphylococ- cusaureusbypolymerasechainreactionamplificationofthe nucgene.JClinMicrobiol.1992;30:1654---60.
8.MehrotraM,WangG,JohnsonWM.MultiplexPCRfordetection ofgenes for Staphylococcus aureusenterotoxins, exfoliative toxins,toxicshocksyndrometoxin1,andmethicillinresistance.
JClinMicrobiol.2000;38:1032---5.
9.ShopsinB,GomezM,MontgomerySO,Smith DH,Waddington M, Dodge DE, et al. Evaluation of protein A gene polymor- phicregionDNAsequencingfortypingofStaphylococcusaureus strains.JClinMicrobiol.1999;37:3556---63.
10.MathemaB,MediavillaJ,KreiswirthBN.Sequenceanalysisof thevariablenumbertandemrepeatinStaphylococcusaureus proteinAgen:spatyping.MethodsMolBiol.2008;431:285---305.
11.HarmsenD,ClausH,WitteW,RothgängerJ,ClausH,Turnwald D,etal.Typingofmethicillin-resistantStaphylococcusaureus inauniversityhospitalsettingbyusingnovelsoftwareforspa repeatdeterminationanddatabasemanagement.JClinMicro- biol.2003;41:5443---8.
12.EnrightMC,DayNP,DaviesCE,PeacockSJ.MultilocusSequence typingforcharacterizationofmethicillin-resistantmethicillin- susceptibleclonesofStaphylococcusaureus.JClinMicrobiol.
2000;38:1008---15.
13.FeilEJ, LiBC,AanensenDM,Hanage WP,SprattBG.eBURST:
inferringpatterns ofevolutionary descentamong clustersof relatedbacterialgenotypes frommultilocus sequence typing data.JBacteriol.2004;186:1518---30.
14.MulveyMR,ChuiL,IsmailJ,LouieL,MurphyC,ChangN,etal.
DevelopmentofaCanadianstandardizedprotocolforsubtyping methicillin-resistant Staphylococcusaureususing pulsed-field gelelectrophoresis.JClinMicrobiol.2001;39:3481---5.
15.KondoY,ItoT,MaXX,WatanabeS,KreiswirthBN,EtienneJ, etal.Combination ofmultiplexPCRsforstaphylococcalcas- sette chromosomemectype assignment:rapididentification systemformec,ccr,andmajordifferencesinjunkyardregions.
AntimicrobAgentsChemother.2007;51:264---74.
16.MilheiricoC,OliveiraDC,deLencastreH.MultiplexPCRstrategy forsubtypingthestaphylococcalcassettechromosomemectype IVinmethicillin-resistantStaphylococcusaureus:‘‘SCCmecIV multiplex’’.JAntimicrobChemother.2007;60:42---8.
17.DiepBA,GillSR,ChangRF, PhanTH,ChenJH,DavidsonMG, et al. Complete genome sequence of USA300, an epidemic cloneofcommunity-acquiredmethicillin-resistantStaphylococ- cusaureus.Lancet.2006;367:731---9.
18.McclureJ,ConlyJM,LauV,ElsayedS,LouieT,HutchinsW,etal.
NovelmultiplexPCRassayfordetectionofthestaphylococcal virulencemarkerPanton-Velentineleukocidingenesandsimul- taneousdiscriminationofMethicillin-susceptiblefromresistant Staphylococci.JClinMicrobiol.2006;44:1141---4.
19.Wu D, Wang Q, Yang Y, Geng W, Wang Q, Yu S, et al.
Epidemiology and molecular characteristics of community- associatedmethicillin-resistant and methicillin --- susceptible Staphylococcusaureusfromskin/softtissueinfectionsinachil- dren’shospital in Beijing, China. DiagnMicrobiol Infect Dis.
2010;67:1---8.
20.CenterforDiseasesControlandPrevention(CDC).Community- associated methicillin-resistant and Staphylococcus aureus infection among healthy newborns. Morb Mortal Wkly Rep.
2006;55:329---32.
21.IlczyszynMW,SabatAJ,AkkerboomV,SzkarlatA,KlepackaJ, Sowa-SierantI,etal.Clonalstructureandcharacterizationof
S.aureusinfectionsinchildrenunder1yearold 389 Staphylococcusaureusstrainsfrominvasiveinfectionsinpedi-
atric patients from South Poland: association between age, spatypes,clonalcomplexes,andgeneticMarkers.PLOSONE.
2016;11:e0151937.
22.Qiao Y, Ning X, Chen Q, Zhao R, Song W, Zheng Y, et al.
Clinicalandmolecularcharacteristicsofinvasivecommunity- acquiredStaphylococcusaureusinfectionsinChinesechildren.
BMCInfectDis.2014;14:582.
23.Gomes RT, Lyra TG, Alvez NN, Caldas RM, Barberino MG, Nascimento-CarvalhoCM.Methicillin-resistantandmethicillin- susceptibleStaphylococcus aureus infection amongchildren.
BrazJInfectDis.2013;17:573---8.
24.PaganiniH,VerdaguerV,RodriguezAC,DellaLattaP,Hernán- dezC,BerberianG, etal. Aclinicaland riskfactor analysis of methicillin-resistant community-acquired infections. Arch ArgentPediatr.2006;104:295---300.
25.ForeroMJ.Infecciones porStaphylococcus aureusadquiridas en la comunidad. Diferenciación clínica según sensibilidad y resistencia a la meticilina en el servicio de infectología pediátricadelHospitalUniversitariodeSantander.2006---2008.
Santander:UniversidaddeSantander;2009.
26.RodríguezEA,CorreaMM,OspinaS,AtehortúaSL,JiménezJN.
Differencesinepidemiologicalandmolecularcharacteristicsof nasalcolonizationwithStaphylococcusaureus(MSSA---MRSA)in childrenfromauniversityhospitalanddaycarecenters.PLoS ONE.2014;9:e101417.
27.JiménezJN,OcampoAM,VanegasJM,RodríguezEA,Mediav- illa JR, Chen L, et al. CC8 MRSA strains harboring SCCmec typeIVc arepredominant inColombian hospitals.PLoSONE.
2012;7:e38576.
28.ChambersHF, DeLeo FR. Waves ofresistance: Staphylococ- cus aureus inthe antibiotic era. NatRev Microbiol. 2009;7:
629---41.
29.MachucaMA,SosaLM,GonzálezCI.Moleculartypingandvir- ulence characteristic of methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureusisolatesfrompediatricpatientsinBucaramanga,Colom- bia.PLoSONE.2013;8:e73434.
30.SolaC,PaganiniH,EgeaAL,MoyanoAJ,GarneroA,KevricI, etal.SpreadofepidemicMRSA-ST5-IVcloneencodingPVLas amajorcauseofcommunityonsetstaphylococcalinfectionsin Argentineanchildren.PLoSONE.2012;7:e30487.