w w w . e l s e v ie r . c o m / l o c a t e / b j i d
The
Brazilian
Journal
of
INFECTIOUS
DISEASES
Original
article
Hepatitis
E
virus
prevalence
in
Egyptian
children
with
transfusion-dependent
thalassemia
Doaa
Abdelmawla
a,
Dalia
Moemen
a,∗,
Ahmad
Darwish
b,
Wafaa
Mowafy
aaMansouraUniversity,FacultyofMedicine,DepartmentofMedicalMicrobiologyandImmunology,Mansoura,Egypt bMansouraUniversity,FacultyofMedicine,DepartmentofPediatrics,Mansoura,Egypt
a
r
t
i
c
l
e
i
n
f
o
Articlehistory:
Received22October2018 Accepted3January2019 Availableonline28February2019
Keywords:
HepatitisEvirus(HEV) Prevalence
Thalassemia Transfusion
a
b
s
t
r
a
c
t
HepatitisEvirus(HEV)infectionisoneofthemajorpublichealthproblemsin develop-ingcountries.HEVcancausechronicinfectionsinimmunocompromisedindividualse.g. thalassemicpatientswithincreasedriskofmorbidityandmortality.Inadditionthereis possibilityofHEVtransmissionthroughbloodtransfusion.Therefore,thepresentstudy aimedtoinvestigatetheseroprevalenceandriskfactorsofHEVinfectionin-thalassemic children.
Methods:Thiscross-sectionalstudywasconductedon140Egyptianchildrensufferingfrom -thalassemia, attendingthe hematology outpatientclinic fromApril toOctober 2016. Serumsamplesfrompatientswerecollectedandanti-HEVantibodies;ImmunoglobulinG (IgG)andImmunoglobulinM(IgM)
weremeasuredbyenzyme-linkedimmunosorbentassay(ELISA).
Results:TheseroprevalenceofHEVin-thalassemicchidrenwasrelativelyhigh(27.15%). Anti-HEVIgGprevalencewas24.29%whilethatofIgMwas2.86%.Therewassignificant associationbetweenHEVinfectionandage,residence,liverenzymesandamountofblood transfusionperyear.
Conclusions:Thalasemicpatientsarevulnerabletochronicityandincreasedriskof morbid-ityandmortalityfromHEVinfection.Frequentassessmentofliverenzymesinthalassemic patientstomonitorsubclinicalHEVisrecommended.ClosemonitoringandHEVscreening ofblooddonationsshouldbetakeninconsideration.PublicawarenessaboutHEV endemi-city,modesoftransmission,andriskhazardsespeciallyinhighriskgroupshouldbedone toreducethediseaseburden.
©2019SociedadeBrasileiradeInfectologia.PublishedbyElsevierEspa ˜na,S.L.U.Thisis anopenaccessarticleundertheCCBY-NC-NDlicense(http://creativecommons.org/ licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Introduction
Hepatitis E virus infection is endemic in many develop-ingcountrieswhilesporadicHEVinfections havealsobeen
∗ Correspondingauthor.
E-mailaddress:drdaliamoemen@yahoo.com(D.Moemen).
reportedinsomedevelopedcountries.1AlthoughHEV
infec-tion isusuallyassociatedwith acute self-limitedhepatitis, fulminanthepaticfailurewithmorbidityandmortalitymay occurespeciallyinimmunocompromisedhosts.2High
preva-lence ofHEV infection wasreported inAfrica,Central and SoutheastAsia,and Mexico.3 InFrance,the seroprevalence of HEV (anti-HEVimmunoglobulin G (IgG) and IgM) varied from 21.9% to 71.3%, according to geographic distribution,
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bjid.2019.01.007
1413-8670/©2019SociedadeBrasileiradeInfectologia.PublishedbyElsevierEspa ˜na,S.L.U.ThisisanopenaccessarticleundertheCC BY-NC-NDlicense(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
withaverage39.1%.4 Peoplewithloweducationallevelmay
beatahigherriskofexposureandinfectionthanthosewith highereducationallevel.InEgypt,loweducationalleveland socioeconomic status resulted in lack of knowledge about avoidablepossibleriskfactorsassociatedwithHEVinfection. ThusHEVwashighlyendemicinEgyptianruralcommunities withgenotype1subtype3mostcirculating.5,6Therearefour
documentedroutesoftransmissionofHEVincluding fecal-oralroute,vehicle-borneincludingwater-borneandzoonotic foodborne,bloodbornetransmissionthroughparenteralblood transfusion, and perinatal via vertical transmission from mother-to-infant.7,8 ChronicHEVinfection was acquired in
1.4%ofpatientsfollowinglivertransplantion which subse-quently resulted in persistent damage of the liver graft.9
Thalassemiais one ofthe most common genetic diseases worldwide.Itisamajorpublichealthproblem,causingmuch morbidity,earlymortality,andgreatfinancialandemotional burdenforafamily.Thalassemiaisthemostcommonform ofinheritedanemia aroundtheworld.10 -thalassemia
fre-quenciesarecommoninalmostallArabcountries.11InEgypt,
-thalassemiaisthe mostcommontypewithacarrierrate ranging from 5.3% to ≥9%. It was estimatedthat 1000/1.5 million live births/year suffer from thalassemia disease in Egypt.12Manythalassemiapatientsdevelopchronicliver
dis-ease(CLD)likechronichepatitisC.HAVandHEVinfections showmoresevereclinicalcoursesintheCLDpatients.13Some
authorsdocumentedHEVseropositivityamonghemodialysis andthalassemiapatients.14,15 ItwasreportedthatHEVRNA
detectedinblooddonationsthroughstudiesbybloodbanks inseveral Europeancountries.16 Therefore, somecountries
began HEV RNA screening of blood donations and others selectivelyappliedbloodscreeningforhighriskpatients.17A
previousstudyconductedonpatientswithacuteviral hep-atitisinEgyptreportedHEVinfectioninabout12–42%ofall cases.18Anotherstudycarriedoutonbloodsamplescollected
from134jaundicedpatientsinEgypt,revealedthat51(38.1%) patientswerepositiveforanti-HEVIgG.19Also,studyon chil-drenwithacuteviralhepatitisinAssiut,Egypt,detected30.9% HEVinfectioninchildren.20Thepresentstudyaimedtodetect
theseroprevalenceofHEVinfectioninthalassemicchildren toassesstheroleofbloodtransfusionasariskfactorforHEV infection.
Patients
and
methods
PatientsThiscross-sectional study was conductedon 140 Egyptian childrensufferingfrom-thalassemia,attendingthe hema-tology outpatient clinic in Mansoura University Children’s Hospital (MUCH) from April 2016 through October 2016. Patients included in this study were patients with beta-thalassemia aged up to 18 years who frequently received bloodtransfusion.However,patientswithhemolyticanemia otherthanthalassemia,patientswithalpha-thalassemia,and patientswithlessthan10bloodtransfusionswereexcluded from the study. This study was approved by the Medical Research Ethics Committee, Mansoura University (IRB no. MS/16/03/82).
Datacollectedfrompatients
Data collected from patients included age, sex, residence, amountofbloodtransfusedperyear,abdominalexamination ofliverandspleen,serumferritin,liverfunctiontests(ALTand AST),andviralhepatitismarkers(HBsAgandHCVAbs).
Samplecollectionandprocessing
Two milliliters of venous blood were obtained from each selected patient and collected in a sterile tube, cen-trifugedimmediately forserum separation. Serumsamples were stored at −20◦C. Presence of anti-HEV antibodies
(anti-HEV IgG indicating past infection and anti-HEV IgM indicating recent infection) in the patients’ sera were measured by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay; HEV-IGMElisa (Immunospec, USA,BL147710) andHEV-IGG Elisa (Immunospec,USA,BL147709).
Statisticalanalysis
Thecollecteddatawascoded,processedandanalyzedusing SPSS (Statistical package for social science) version 23 for windows.Descriptivestatisticswerecalculatedbyfrequency (number-percent). Chisquaretestwasused forinter-group comparisonofcategoricaldata.p-Value lessthan 0.05 (5%) wasconsideredstatisticallysignificant.Significantvariables onunivariateanalysiswereenteredintoalogisticregression model to determine which of thesefactors were indepen-dentlyassociatedwithHEVinfection,followedbymultivariate analysis.
Results
The seroprevalence of HEV antibodies in -thalassemic patients was 27.15%(38/140 patients); 34 (24.29%) patients were positive for anti-HEV IgG, and four (2.86%) patients were positiveforanti-HEVIgM.Asshown inTable1,there was significant association between age and anti-HEV IgG andIgMseropositivity(p=0.004,and0.044,respectively).HEV seropositivityincreasedwithage.Therewassignificant asso-ciationbetweenruralresidenceandanti-HEVIgG(p<0.001). Regarding clinical data, there was significant association between liver enzymes and anti-HEV IgG. No patients in our study had HBV infection.Splenectomy andHCV infec-tionwerenotsignificantlyassociatedwithHEVseropositivity (Table 2). Table 3. In Univariate analysis, there was sig-nificantassociation betweenAge,residence, liverenzymes, and amount of blood transfusions per with HEV seropos-itivity. On multivariate analysis only rural residence and elevatedALTlevelswereindependentlyassociatedwithHEV seropositivity.
Discussion
TheprevalenceofHEVantibodies amongthalassemic chil-dreninourstudy was27.15%,24.29%anti-HEVIgGpositive and 2.86% anti-HEVIgM positive.Resultsofprevious stud-ies showed seroprevalence of HEV antibodies of 2.4% in
Table1–DemographicdataassociatedwithHEVseropositivityinthalassemicchildren.
Demographicdata Anti-HEVIgG Anti-HEVIgM
Positive(n=34) Negative(n=106) p-Value Positive(n=4) Negative(n=136) p-Value
Agerange(years) 2–6 5(14.7%) 33(31.1%) 0.004a 0(0.0%) 38(27.9%) 0.044a
6–12 14(41.2%) 55(51.9%) 1(25.0%) 68(50.0%) 12–18 15(44.1%) 18(17.0%) 3(75.0%) 30(22.1%) Sex Female 16(47.1%) 49(46.2%) 0.933 1(25.0%) 64(47.1%) 0.383 Male 18(52.9%) 57(53.8%) 3(75.0%) 72(52.9%) Residence Rural 28(82.4%) 51(48.1%) <0.001b 3(75.0%) 76(55.9%) 0.447 Urban 6(17.6%) 55(51.9%) 1(25.0%) 60(44.1%) n,number. a Significance<0.05. b Highsignificance.
Table2–ClinicalparametersassociatedwithHEVseropositivityinthalessemicchildren.
Clinicaldata Anti-HEVIgG Anti-HEVIgM
Positive(n=34) Negative(n=106) p-Value Positive(n=4) Negative(n=136) p-Value
Splen-ectomy Yes 16(47.1%) 42(39.6%) 0.444 2(50.0%) 56(41.2%) 0.724 No 18(52.9%) 64(60.4%) 2(50.0%) 80(58.8%) HCV Positive 11(32.4%) 25(23.6%) 0.309 1(25.0%) 35(25.7%) 0.974 Negative 23(67.6%) 81(76.4%) 3(75.0%) 101(74.3%) HBV Positive 0(0.0%) 0(0.0%) – 0(0.0%) 0(0.0%) – Negative 34(100.0%) 106(100.0%) 4(100.0%) 136(100.0%) ALT Elevated 28(82.4%) 47(44.3%) <0.001b 4(100.0%) 71(52.2%) 0.059 Normal 6(17.6%) 59(55.7%) 0(0.0%) 65(47.8%) AST Elevated 23(67.6%) 39(36.8%) 0.002a 3(75.0%) 59(43.4%) 0.210 Normal 11(32.4%) 67(63.2%) 1(25.0%) 77(56.6%) ALT,alaninetransaminase;AST,aspartatetransaminase;n,number.
a Significance<0.05. b Highsignificance.
Table3–UnivariateandmultivariateanalysesoffactorsassociatedwithHEVseropositivityinthalassemicchildren.
Univariateanalysis Multivariateanalysis
pValue OR 95%C.I. pValue OR 95%C.I.
Age(years) 0.001a 1.18 1.07–1.29 Malesex 0.807 1.098 0.52–2.32 RuralResidence 0.001a 4.98 2.01–12.35 0.003a 4.277 1.65–11.09 Splenectomy 0.385 1.39 0.66–2.96 AbnormalAST 0.001a 3.97 1.79–8.80 AbnormalALT <0.001a 7.32 2.81–19.04 <0.001b 6.486 2.43–17.32
Amountofbloodtransfused(mL/year) 0.008a 1.00 1.00–1.00
Serumferritin(g/L) 0.313 1.00 1.00–1.00
ALT,Alaninetransaminase;AST,Aspartatetransaminase;p,probability;OR,odd’sratio;CI,confidenceinterval.
a Significance<0.05. b Highsignificance.
thalassemic patients in Scandinavia21 and 10.7% in Saudi
Arabia.22 In Iran, the seroprevalence of HEV IgG and HEV
IgMwere10%and1.8%,respectively.15 Reasonssuchas
dif-ferences in socioeconomic, cultural, hygienic, and climatic factorsacrossgeographicalareasmayexplainthelower preva-lencerates indevelopedcountriescomparedto developing countries.24Inourstudy,agewassignificantlyassociatedwith
HEVantibodies. ThehighestHEVprevalence ratefound in the age group 12–18 years indicated that the risk of HEV infectionincreasedwithage.Previousstudiescarriedoutin
Egypt25 andinother geographic regionsreportedthe same
finding.26–28 Thiscould beexplained bythefact that older
childrenhadlikelyreceivedmoretransfusedblood,in addi-tiontohavebeenmoreexposed tocontaminatedjunkfood than youngerchildren.Inthisstudy,the prevalenceofHEV antibodies in ruralareas (81.6%) washigher than inurban areas(18.4%).InruralEgypt,morethan60%ofchildrenwith agedover10yearshadpositiveanti-HEVIgG.29 Onthe
con-trary,anotherstudyconductedonHCVinfectedthalassemic patients in Iranreported higher HEV seropositivity in
tha-lassemicpatientsfromurbanregionsthanthosefromrural areas.6Regardingliverenzymes,84.2%ofpatientswithHEV
seropositivityshowedelevatedALTlevels,comparedto68.4% ofelevated AST levels. Liver enzymes were higher among thosewithnon-HEVantibodiescomparedtothosewithHEV antibodies.Thismaybeduetopresenceofother causesof hepatitiseitherviralcauses,mostlyHCV,ornon-viralcauses. Although100%and75%ofanti-HEVIgMpositivepatientshad elevatedALT andASTlevels,respectively,therewasno sig-nificantassociationbetweenliverenzymesandanti-HEVIgM seropositivity,probablyduetosmallnumberofanti-HEVIgM positivepatients. Previousstudiesreported thatsubclinical HEVinfectionmightbethecause ofelevatedALT.30
There-fore, in casesof unexplained ALT and AST elevation, HEV may bethe reasonablecause.In two studiesconducted in Japanon voluntary blood donorswith elevated ALT levels, anti-HEVIgGwaspositivein3.7%and7.1%ofparticipants.31,32
Thesefindingssuggestthat patientswithongoing subclini-calHEVinfectionhadthepotentialtotransmitHEVthrough bloodtransfusion.Ourstudyrevealedthattherewas signifi-cantassociationbetweentheamountofbloodtransfusedper year and HEV seropositivity (p=0.008).On the other hand, apreviousstudyshowednosignificantassociationbetween theamountofbloodtransfusedandanti-HEVseropositivity inthalassemicpatients.21Thisdifferencemaybedueto
geo-graphicdifferenceanduseofassayswithlowsensitivitythat couldunderestimateHEVprevalence.33Studiesconductedin
bloodbanksofseveralEuropeancountriesreportedthatabout 0.02–0.14%ofblooddonationswereHEVRNApositive.16,34This
findingsupportsthepossibilityofHEVtransmissionthrough bloodtransfusion.SincerecentlyinIreland,blooddonations are routinely screenedforHEV RNA.Also in2017, the UK, andNetherlandsbegan HEVRNAscreeninginblood dona-tions.In France and Germany,screening selectively occurs inhigh-riskpatients,whilebloodauthoritiesinItaly,Spain, Portugal and Greece are assessing whether HEV screening shouldbeimplementedornot.17Apreviousstudyconducted
inEgyptshowedthatabout0.45%ofblooddonorshave ongo-ingsubclinicalHEVinfection.35Itwasreportedthattheriskof
transmissionthroughbloodtransfusionisincreasedin high-riskpatientsindevelopingregionsthaninotherlocations.23
HEVisendemicinEgyptandbesidesthepossibilityofHEV transmission through blood, our study showed significant association between amount of blood transfused and HEV seropositivity. Therefore, further studies should be carried outtodetectHEVinfectioninriskgrouppatientsandblood donors.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the seroprevalence ofHEV in -thalassemic patientswasrelatively high.Therefore, closemonitoringof thesepatientsinadditiontoHEVscreeningofblooddonations shouldbetakenintoconsideration.Frequentassessmentof liverenzymesin-thalassemicpatientstomonitor subclini-calHEVinfectionsandotherviralinfectionsisrecommended. PublicawarenessaboutHEVendemicity,modesof transmis-sion,andriskhazards,especiallyinhigh-riskgroupsshould bedonetoreducethediseaseburden.
Funding
Theauthorsreceivednospecificfundingforthiswork.
Conflicts
of
interest
Theauthorsdeclarenoconflictsofinterest.
r
e
f
e
r
e
n
c
e
s
1.Romano’L,PaladiniS,TagliacarneC,CanutiM,BianchiS, ZanettiAR.HepatitisEinItaly:along-termprospectivestudy. JHepatol.2011;54:34–40.
2.ArendsJE,GhisettiV,IrvingW,etal.HepatitisE:anemerging infectioninhighincomecountries.JClinVirol.2014;59:81–8.
3.BalayanMS.EpidemiologyofhepatitisEvirusinfection.JViral Hepatitis.1997;4:155–65.
4.ClementeCasaresP,RamosRomeroC,RamirezGonzalezE, MasA.HepatitisEvirusinindustrializedcountries:thesilent threat.BioMedResInt.2016:9838041.
5.AmerAF,ZakiSA,NagatiAM,DarwishMA.HepatitisE antibodiesinEgyptianadolescentfemales:theirprevalence andpossiblerelevance.JEgyptPublicHealthAssoc. 1996;71:273–84.
6.ElizeePK,AlavianSM,MiriSM,etal.Theseroprevalenceof entricallytransmittedviralhepatitisinHCVinfected thalassemiaandhemophiliapatientsinIran.JundishapurJ Microbiol.2013;6:e9091.
7.MushahwarIK.HepatitisEvirus:molecularvirologyclinical features,diagnosis,transmission,epidemiology,and prevention.JMedVirol.2008;80:646–58.
8.LewisHC,WichmannO,DuizerE.Transmissionroutesand riskfactorsforautochthonoushepatitisEvirusinfectionin Europe:asystematicreview.EpidemiolInfect.
2010;138:145–66.
9.FerayC,PawlotskyJM,Roque-AfonsoAM,SamuelD,
DhumeauxD.ShouldwescreenbloodproductsforhepatitisE virusRNA?Lancet.2014;383:218.
10.QuekL,TheinSL.Moleculartherapiesinbeta-thalassaemia. BrJHaematol.2007;136:353–65.
11.HamamyHA,Al-AllawiNA.Epidemiologicalprofileof commonhaemoglobinopathiesinArabcountries.JCommun Genet.2013;4:147–67.
12.El-BeshlawyA,YoussryI.Preventionofhemoglobinopathies inEgypt.Hemoglobin.2009;33Suppl1:S14–20.
13.ChoHC,PaikSW,KimYJ,etal.Seroprevalenceofanti-HAV amongpatientswithchronicviralliverdisease.WorldJ Gastroenterol.2011;17:236–41.
14.MortezaP,AbdolRezaS,HamidN.HepatitisEvirusinfection inhemodialysispatients:aseroepidemiologicalsurveyin Jahrom,SouthernIran.HepatitisMon.2009;3(Summer):232–5.
15.JahromiAS,Ahmadi-VasmehjaniA,ZabetianH,etal. Sero-epidemiologicalstudyofhepatitisEvirusamong Thalassemiaashighriskpatients:across-sectionalsurveyin Jahrom,SouthernIran.GlobalJHealthSci.2016;8:245–50.
16.GallianP,CouchouronA,DupontI,etal.Comparisonof hepatitisEvirusnucleicacidtestscreeningplatformsand RNAprevalenceinFrenchblooddonors.Transfusion. 2017;57:223–4.
17.DomanovicD,TedderR,BlumelJ,etal.HepatitisEandblood donationsafetyinselectedEuropeancountries:ashiftto screening?EuroSurveill.2017;22:30514.
18.ZakariaS,FouadR,ShakerO,etal.Changingpatternsof acuteviralhepatitisatamajorurbanreferralcenterinEgypt. ClinInfectDis.2007;44:e30–6.
19.El-TrasWF,TayelAA,El-KadyNN.Seroprevalenceofhepatitis Evirusinhumansandgeographicallymatchedfoodanimals inEgypt.ZoonosesPublicHealth.2013;60:244–51.
20.HasanG,AssiriA,MarzuukN,etal.Incidenceand characteristicsofhepatitisEvirusinfectioninchildrenin AssiutUpperEgypt.JIntMedRes.2016;44:1115–22.
21.PsichogiouM,TzalaE,BoletisJ,etal.HepatitisEvirus infectioninindividualsathighriskoftransmissionofnon-A, non-Bhepatitisandsexuallytransmitteddiseases.ScandJ InfectDis.1996;28:443–5.
22.Al-FawazI,Al-RasheedS,Al-MugeirenM,Al-SalloumA, Al-SohaibaniM,RamiaS.HepatitisEvirusinfectionin patientsfromSaudiArabiawithsicklecellanaemiaand beta-thalassemiamajor:possibletransmissionbyblood transfusion.JViralHepatitis.1996;3:203–5.
24.JunaidSA,AginaSE,AbubakarKA.Epidemiologyand associatedriskfactorsofhepatitisevirusinfectioninplateau stateNigeria.Virology(Auckl).2014;5:15–26.
25.StoszekSK,EngleRE,Abdel-HamidM,etal.HepatitisE antibodyseroconversionwithoutdiseaseinhighlyendemic ruralEgyptiancommunities.TransRSocTropMedHyg. 2006;100:89–94.
26.DongC,DaiX,ShaoJS,HuK,MengJH.Identificationof geneticdiversityofhepatitisEvirus(HEV)anddetermination oftheseroprevalenceofHEVineasternChina.ArchVirol. 2007;152:739–46.
27.TaremiM,MohammadAlizadehAH,ArdalanA,AnsariS,Zali MR.SeroprevalenceofhepatitisEinNahavandIslamic
RepublicofIran:apopulation-basedstudy.EastMediterr HealthJ.2008;14:157–62.
28.AndersonDA7th.HepatitisEvirus.In:AndersonDA7th, editor.Mandell,Douglas,andBennett’sprinciplesand practiceofinfectiousdiseases.ChurchillLivingstoneElsevier; 2010.p.2411–23.
29.FixAD,Abdel-HamidM,PurcellRH,etal.Prevalenceof antibodiestohepatitisEintworuralEgyptiancommunities. AmJTropMedHyg.2000;62:519–23.
30.GaoD,PengG,ZhuJ,SunL,ZhengY,ZhangJ.Investigationof sub-clinicalinfectionofhepatitisEvirusinblooddonors. ChinJHepatol.2004;12:11–2.
31.FukudaS,SunagaJ,SaitoN,etal.Prevalenceofantibodiesto hepatitisEvirusamongJapaneseblooddonors:identification ofthreeblooddonorsinfectedwithagenotype3hepatitisE virus.JMedVirol.2004;73:554–61.
32.GotandaY,IwataA,OhnumaH,etal.Ongoingsubclinical infectionofhepatitisEvirusamongblooddonorswithan elevatedalanineaminotransferaselevelinJapan.JMedVirol. 2007;79:734–42.
33.AvellonA,MoragoL,Garcia-GaleradelCarmenM,MunozM, EchevarriaJM.Comparativesensitivityofcommercialtests forhepatitisEgenotype3virusantibodydetection.JMed Virol.2015;87:1934–9.
34.HogemaBM,MolierM,SjerpsM,etal.Incidenceandduration ofhepatitisEvirusinfectioninDutchblooddonors.
Transfusion.2016;56:722–8.
35.IbrahimEH,AbdelwahabSF,NadyS,etal.Prevalenceof anti-HEVIgMamongblooddonorsinEgypt.EgyptJImmunol. 2011;18:47–58.