The
Brazilian
Journal
of
INFECTIOUS
DISEASES
w w w . e l s e v i e r . c o m / l o c a t e / b j i d
Original
article
Cascade
of
access
to
interventions
to
prevent
HIV
mother
to
child
transmission
in
the
metropolitan
area
of
Rio
de
Janeiro,
Brazil
夽
Elaine
S.
Pires
Araujo
a,c,∗,
Ruth
Khalili
Friedman
a,
Luis
Antonio
Bastos
Camacho
b,
Monica
Derrico
a,
Ronaldo
Ismério
Moreira
a,
Guilherme
Amaral
Calvet
a,
Marília
Santini
de
Oliveira
a,
Valdilea
Gonc¸alves
Veloso
a,
José
Henrique
Pilotto
c,d,
Beatriz
Grinsztejn
aaLaboratóriodePesquisaemDST/AIDS,InstitutodePesquisaClínicaEvandroChagas,Fundac¸ãoOswaldoCruz(Fiocruz),RiodeJaneiro,
RJ,Brazil
bDepartamentodeEpidemiologiaeMétodosQuantitativosemSaúde,EscolaNacionaldeSaúdePublica,Fiocruz,RiodeJaneiro,RJ,Brazil cHospitalGeraldeNovaIguac¸u,Servic¸odeDST/HIV/AIDS,NovaIguac¸u,RiodeJaneiro,RJ,Brazil
dLaboratóriodeAIDSeImunologiaMolecular,InstitutoOswaldoCruz,Fiocruz,RiodeJaneiro,RJ,Brazil
a
r
t
i
c
l
e
i
n
f
o
Articlehistory: Received26May2013 Accepted3November2013 Availableonline2January2014
Keywords: HIV
HIVverticaltransmission Antiretroviralchemoprophylaxis Cohortstudies
Brazil
a
b
s
t
r
a
c
t
Objectives:TodescribetheaccesstotheinterventionsforthepreventionofHuman Immun-odeficiencyVirus(HIV)mothertochildtransmissionandmothertochildtransmissionrates intheoutskirtsofRiodeJaneiro,from1999to2009.
Methods:Thisisaretrospectivecohortstudy.PreventionofHIVmothertochildtransmission interventionswereaccessedandmothertochildtransmissionrateswerecalculated. Results:Thestudypopulationisyoung(median:26years;interquartilerange:22.0–31.0),with lowmonthlyfamilyincome(40.4%uptooneBrazilianminimumwage)andschooling(62.1% lessthan8years).Only47.1%(n=469)knewtheHIVstatusoftheirpartner;ofthesewomen, 39.9%hadanHIV-seronegativepartner.Amongthe1259newbornsevaluated,accesstothe antenatal,intrapartumandpostpartumpreventionofHIVmothertochildtransmission componentsoccurredin59.2%,74.2%,and97.5%respectively;91.0%ofthenewbornswere notbreastfed.Overall52.7%ofthenewbornshavebenefitedfromalltherecommended interventions.Insubsequentpregnancies(n=289),67.8%ofthenewbornsreceivedthefull packageofinterventions.TheoverallrateofHIVverticaltransmissionwas4.7%andthe highestannualrateoccurredin2005(7.4%),withnodefinitetrendintheperiod.
Conclusions:AccesstothefullpackageofinterventionsforthepreventionofHIVvertical transmissionwaslow,withnosignificanttrendofimprovementovertheyears.The verti-caltransmissionratesobservedwerehigherthanthosefoundinreferenceservicesinthe municipalityofRiodeJaneiroandintherichestregionsofthecountry.
©2014PublishedbyElsevierEditoraLtda.
夽This study was supported by Brazilian Ministry of Health, PN-DST/AIDS – SVS/Ministério da Saúde/BIRD/UNODC. Projeto
AD/BRA/03/H34.AcordodeEmpréstimoBIRD4713-BR.TC292/07.
∗ Correspondingauthorat:LaboratóriodePesquisaClinicaemDST/AIDS,InstitutodePesquisaClínicaEvandroChagas/IPEC,RiodeJaneiro,
RJ,Brazil.
E-mailaddresses:[email protected],[email protected](E.S.PiresAraujo). 1413-8670/$–seefrontmatter©2014PublishedbyElsevierEditoraLtda.
Introduction
Brazil was the first developing country to implement a nationalprogramtopreventHIVmothertochildtransmission (PMTCT).HIVCounselingandtesting,accesstoantiretroviral therapy (ART)and infantformula tosubstitute breastfeed-inghavebeenuniversallyprovidedfree-of-charge.Although PMTCT is considered as a high priority by the Brazilian MinistryofHealth (BMH),itremains arelevantproblem in the country1 with a significant number of new pediatric
casescontinuingtooccurannually.2InBrazil,between1980
and June 2011, 13,540 cases of vertical transmission were reported;fromJanuary2010toJune2011,457newcaseswere notified.2
In Brazil, initial studies showed a MTCT rate of 16%,3
buttherehasbeenasignificantdecreaseoverrecentyears. Inanationalmulticenterstudycovering2924children,4the
MTCTratewas8.6%in2000and7.1%in2001,with signifi-cantregionaldifferences,withlessantiretroviraluseduring pregnancy in the north and northeast regions leading to higherratesoftransmission.Studiesconductedintherecent yearsstillshowstrikingregionaldisparities,withMTCTrates of between 2.4% and 4.9% in the southern and southeast regions, the wealthiestparts ofBrazil,5–8 and transmission
ratesashigh as9.1and 9.9inthe northeastand northern regions.9–11
Theshortcomingsofthehealthsystemhighlyimpactthe successofinterventionsforMTCT12andthisisevenmore
crit-icalindevelopingcountries.Barrierstotheimplementation ofthe severalinterventionsthat arepart ofthe prevention packageforHIVMTCT(MTCT)aswellastheprogrammatic resultsobtainedvary regionallyacrossthe country.8Riode
JaneirorankssecondinthenumberofreportedAIDScasesin Brazil.
Althoughit islocatedin oneofthe mostindustrialized regionsofthecountry,alargedisparitystillexistsbetween therichareasandthepoorperipheralregionssurroundingthe capitalcity.ThehighestincidenceofAIDScasesinthestate isfoundinaregion calledBaixada Fluminense,an impov-erishedareaintheoutskirtsofRiodeJaneiro,inhabitedby fourmillionmarginalizedindividualswhoareplaguedby vio-lence, poverty,social injustice,and endemicand epidemic diseases.BaixadaFluminenseintegrates13municipalitiesof whichNovaIguac¸uhasthehighestpopulationdensityand territory.13Amongthe92,089individualsdiagnosedwithAIDS
inRiodeJaneiroStatebetween1982and 2012,18,903were fromBaixadaFluminense.14
This study describes the cascade of access to the rec-ommendedinterventionsforPMTCTandtheratesofMTCT amongHIV-infectedpregnantwomeninametropolitanarea ofRiodeJaneiro,Brazil.
Methodology
TheHIVFamilyCareClinic(HHFCC)operates within Hospi-talGeraldeNovaIguac¸u(HGNI),thelargest publichospital in Baixada Fluminense. HHFCC is the main referral cen-terforHIV-infectedpregnantwomenandtheirinfantsand
providesfreeaccesstoantiretrovirals(ARVs)andservicesfor the preventionofMTCT. Considering 0.59%the HIV preva-lence among womenbetween 15 and 49 years,15 rate that
hasbeenstablesince2004,2andthenumberofstillbirthsin
2011,16 weestimatedapproximately1300asthenumberof
HIVpregnantwomenassistedinRiodeJaneirointhatyear; amongthose,165(12.7%)receivedcareinHHFCC-HGNI.A ret-rospectivecohortofHIV-infectedpregnantwomenandtheir newbornswasestablishedattheHHFCC-HGNIin collabora-tionwiththeInstitutodePesquisaClinicaEvandroChagas– IPEC,Fiocruz.
Inthepresentstudy,allHIV-infectedpregnantwomenand their newborns who received care at the HHFCC between 01/01/1999and31/12/2009wereincluded.Retrospectivechart reviewusingastructuredcasereportformwasconducted.The projectwasapprovedbytheHGNI(CAAE:0005.1.316.000-07) EthicsinResearchCommittee.
Studydefinitions
Recommended package of interventions for HIV PMTCT according to the timing of HIV diagnosis in the pregnant women:
(a) HIV diagnosis before and during pregnancy: antenatal antiretroviraltherapy (ART)+intrapartum IVZidovudine (ZDV)+ZDVsyrup+formulaforthenewborn;
(b) HIVdiagnosisatlabor/delivery:intrapartumIVZDV+ZDV syrup+formulaforthenewborn;
(c) HIV diagnosis during the immediate postpartum: ZDV syrup+formulaforthenewborn.
HIV-positivenewbornsweredefinedasfollows:two pos-itive HIVdiagnostic tests(usingeitherthequantificationof plasmaHIVRNA(HIVviralload)ordetectionofproviralDNA) performedbetween1and6monthsofage,withoneofthem sampledafter4monthsofage.Forthosechildrenwithouta defineddiagnosiswhowereover18monthsofage,two pos-itive serologysamplesforanti-HIV-1and-2ortwopositive rapidtestsusingdifferentmethodologieswererequired.17,18
HIV-negativenewbornsweredefinedasfollows:two neg-ativeHIVdiagnostictests(usingeitherthequantificationof plasmaHIVviralloadorthedetectionofproviralDNA)were performedbetween1and6monthsofage,withoneofthem sampledafter4monthsofage,plusanon-reactiveanti-HIV serologytestafter12monthsofage.Forthosechildrenwithout adefineddiagnosiswhowereover18monthsofage,a nonre-activeHIVserologyoranegativeresultusingtworapidtests wasrequired.Indiscordantcases,athirdtestwasconsidered toreachadiagnosticconclusion.18
HIV-inconclusivenewbornsweredefinedasfollows: chil-dren who did not have one of above definitions were consideredasinconclusiveforHIVserostatus,andthereason maybeattributedtolosttofollow-uporincomplete informa-tioninmedicalcharts.
CD4+lymphocytecountatenrolment(cells/mm3):thefirst
resultobtainedattheentryinthecohort.
Skincolor:thiswasobtainedfromchartreviewandwas attributedbyhealthprofessionals.
Statisticalanalyses
Frequency, mean, standard deviation (SD), median and interquartile range (IQR) were used to describe the socio-demographic,behavioralandreproductivecharacteristics,as wellasthoserelatedtoHIV/AIDSinfectionofwomenatentry inthecohort(n=997)andalsotodescribethecharacteristics ofthe pregnancieswhichresultedindeliveryinthecohort (n=1269)betweenJanuary1999andDecember2009.
Wedescribedthemunicipalityofresidenceforallwomen includedinthestudyandforthesubgroupofwomenwhodid notreceiveprenatalcareusingmapsgeneratedbyESRI2011 softwareprogramonlyforillustrativepurpose.19
Descriptivestatisticswereusedtodescribeaccessto pro-phylactic interventions to reducethe risk of perinatal HIV transmissioninthispopulation,accordingtothemomentof maternalmotherHIVdiagnosis.Trendanalysiswascarried outinordertoevaluatetheaccesstorecommendedpackage ofinterventionsaccordingtothemomentofmaternalmother HIVdiagnosisovertime.Theoverallandannualratesof peri-natalHIVtransmissionwerealsocalculated.
Results
Overall,997womenwereincludedinthecohortwithatotalof 1326pregnanciesduringthestudyperiod(1999–2009):747of thewomenhadonlyonepregnancy,188hadtwopregnancies, 46hadthreepregnancies,15hadfourpregnanciesandonehad fivepregnancies.Intotal, 329subsequentpregnancieswere observedamong250women,ofwhich289resultedin live-birthinfants.
Ofall1326pregnanciesobservedinthecohort,1269(95.7%) resultedindelivery.Eighteendeliveriesweretwins,resulting inatotalof1287newborns. Ofthese,97.9% (n=1260)were live-birthinfantsforwhomthecascadeofPMTCT interven-tionswasevaluated.Losstofollow-upduringtheantenatal careperiodoccurredin0.5%ofallthepregnancies(Fig.1).
Thecharacteristicsofallwomen(n=997)attheentryinthe cohortarepresentedinTable1.Themajorityofthemresided inthemunicipalityofNovaIguac¸u(41.1%),whereHHFCCis located,followedbythemunicipalitiesofBelfordRoxo(12.4%), SãoJoãode Meriti(9.5%), Queimados(9.1%), Riode Janeiro (6.9%)andDuquedeCaxias(5.7%)(Fig.2).Themedianagewas 26years(IQR:22.0–31.0);39%ofthewomenwereyoungerthan 24yearsofage,72.9%werenon-white(Table1).Approximately 62%ofthemhadlessthan8yearsofschooling,and40.4%had afamilyincomeofuptooneBrazilianminimumwage(varied fromU$70.58toU$234.46duringthestudyperiod).
Most ofthe women (75.3%) lived with a partner atthe timeofcohortinclusion,butonly47.1%(n=469)wereaware of the partner’s HIV serostatus. An HIV-1-infected partner wasreported by60.1%,while39.9% wereinserodiscordant relationships. The mediannumber ofpregnancies prior to inclusioninthecohortwas2.0(IQR:1.0–3.0).Intotal,34.3% (n=342)ofthewomenreportedhavingatleastoneabortion priortoinclusion inthecohort. Tobacco,alcoholand illicit druguseduringpregnancywerereportedby24.0%,23.6%and 5.0%ofthewomen,respectively.Heterosexualtransmission wasthepredominantrouteofHIVinfectionacquisition;30%
Table1–Sociodemographic,clinicalandobstetric characteristicsofwomenandpregnanciesincludedin thestudy,1999–2009.
Variables n %
Characteristicsofpregnantwomen(n=997)a
Age(years) <18 43 4.3 18–24 346 34.7 25–35 515 51.7 >35 93 9.3 Skincolor White 270 27.1 Nonwhite 727 72.9 Schooling(years) <8 619 62.1 ≥8 352 35.3
Datanotavailable 26 2.6
SexualpartnerHIVserostatus
Nosexualpartner 24 2.4
Positive 282 28.3
Negative 187 18.8
Unknown 429 43.0
Datanotavailable 75 7.5
Numberofpreviouspregnancies
None 178 17.9
1 174 17.5
2 212 21.3
≥3 369 37.0
Datanotavailable 64 6.4
TimeofHIVtestingb
Beforepregnancy 199 20.0
Duringpregnancy 449 45.0
Intrapartum 177 17.8
Postpartum 171 17.2
Datanotavailable 1 0.1
AIDS-CDC1993
Yes 312 31.3
No 657 65.9
Datanotavailable 28 2.8
CD4+lymphocytecountatenrolment(cells/mm3)
<200 75 7.5
200–350 191 19.2
>350 511 51.3
Datanotavailable 220 22.0
Characteristicsofprenatalanddelivery(n=1269)a
Gestationalageatthebeginningofprenatal(weeks)
Noprenatalvisits 127 10.0
<14 227 17.9
14–28 507 40.0
>28 138 10.9
Datanotavailable 270 21.3
Numberofprenatalvisits
None 127 10.0 1–3 241 19.0 4–6 526 41.4 ≥7 311 24.5 Unknown 64 5.0 Maternityofdelivery HGNI 960 75.7 Otherinstitution 275 21.7
Table1(Continued)
Variables n %
Deliveryoutsidethematernity 22 1.7 Datanotavailable 12 0.9 Modeofdelivery
Electivecesarean 531 41.8
Vaginal 514 40.5
Emergencycesarean 203 16.0 Datanotavailable 21 1.7 Membranesatdelivery
Norupture 865 68.2
Rupturelessthan3h 88 6.9 Rupturebetween3–6h 81 6.4 Rupturemorethan6h 97 7.6 Rupturenotknowingtime 81 6.4 Datanotavailable 57 4.5 Gestationalageatdelivery(weeks)
<37 185 14.6
≥37 1010 79.6
Datanotavailable 74 5.8 a Totalnumberofwomenincludedinthecohort(n=997);Total numberofpregnanciesthatresultedindeliveryinthecohort (n=1269).
b TimeofHIVtesting:theinformationisrelatedtothefirst preg-nancy inthe cohort,e.g., thepregnancyat enrolmentin the cohort.
ofthewomenhadbeenpreviouslydiagnosedwithAIDS (CDC-1993)uponcohortenrolment.
ThemeanTCD4+lymphocytecountatenrolmentwas486.8
(SD:258.7)cells/mm3;65.8%ofwomenhadTCD4+lymphocyte countshigherthan 350cells/mm3 (Table1).Approximately 20%ofthewomenwereawareoftheirHIVserostatuswhen theybecame pregnant.Amongthosewho wereunawareof their HIV serostatuswhen they became pregnant (n=797), 56.3% were diagnosed during prenatal care, 22.2% during deliveryand21.5%duringtheimmediatepostpartumperiod (Table1).
Thecharacteristicsofallpregnanciesthatresultedin deliv-eryinthecohort(n=1269)arepresentedinTable1.Prenatal carewasprovidedfor90%ofthesepregnancies,mostlywithin
Spontaneous abortions – N=36 (2.7%) Induced abortions – N=11 (0.8%) Ectopic pregnancy – N=3 (0.2%) Lost follow-up – N=6 (0.5%) Maternal mortality – N=1 (0.1%) Twin birth N=18 Single birth N=1,251 Stillbirths N=27 Newborns N=1,260 Births N=1,269
Children enrolled in the cohort N=1,287 Pregnancies enrolled
N=1,326
Fig.1–Studyflowchart.
themunicipalityofNovaIguac¸u(65.4%).Themeangestational ageatthestartofprenatalcarewas19.9(SD=7.7)weeks;in 40.0%and10.9%ofthepregnancies,prenatalcarewasinitiated between14and28weeksandafterthe28thweek,respectively. Fourormoreprenatalcarevisitsweremadein65.9%ofthe pregnancies(Table1).
ThemajorityofdeliveriesoccurredatHGNI(75.7%). Elec-tivecesareandelivery(41.8%)andvaginaldelivery(40.5%)were themostcommondeliverymethods.Spontaneousmembrane ruptureoccurredin27.3%ofthedeliveriesthatlastedlonger than3handinatleast14%ofallthedeliveries.Pretermbirths occurredin14.6%ofthepregnancies(Table1).Onehundred and thirty-sixwomen, with 157 pregnancies, didnot have accesstoanyprenatalcareinatleastonepregnancyinthe cohort.Themajorityofthemresidedinthemunicipalityof NovaIguac¸u(36.8%),followedbythemunicipalitiesofRiode
Pregnant women who did not receive antenatal care (N=136) (on at least one pregnacy while followed in the cohort)
Total of pregnant women (N=997)
Paracambi 0.0% Itaguaí 0.0% Seropédica 0.0% Rio de janeiro 12.5% Queimados 5.15% Nova lguaçu 36.8% Belford Roxo 10.3% Mesquita 5.15% Nilópolis 1.47% Rio de janeiro 6.9% Mesquita 5.1% Nilópolis 2.4% Duque de caxias 11.8% Duque de caxias 5.7% Belford Roxo 12.4% Japeri 6.62% Paracambi 0.3% Itaguai 1.2% Queimados 9.1% Nova lguaçu 41.1% Japeri 5.4% 10 5 0 10 20Km 10 5 0 10Km Seropédica 0.8%
Fig.2–Distributionofallwomen(A)andwomenwhodidnotreceiveprenatalcare(B)accordingtothemunicipalityof
Table2–PMTCTinterventionsdeliveredtopregnantwomenandtheirnewborns,1999–2009(n=1259).
Interventionsreceivedby newborns,n(%)
TimingofHIVtesting Total Subsequentpregnancies
Beforepregnancy Duringpregnancy Labor Postpartum (n=1259)f (n=289)k,l
(n=482)e,g (n=435)h (n=172)i (n=170)j
ARVprophylaxisa+(IV)
ZDVb+formulac+ARVsyrupd
339(70.3) 324(74.5) – – 663(52.7) 196(67.8)
ARVprophylaxisa+(IV)
ZDVb+ARVsyrupd
8(1.7) 5(1.1) – – 13(1.0) 4(1.4)
ARVprophylaxisa+formulac+ARV
syrupd
44(9.1) 21(4.8) – – 65(5.2) 33(11.4)
ARVprophylaxisa+ARVsyrupd 2(0.4) 3(0.7) – 5(0.4) 1(0.3)
(IV)ZDVb+Formulac+ARVsyrupd 41(8.5) 63(14.5) 125(72.7) 229(18.2) 23(8.0)
(IV)ZDVb+Formulac – 1(0.2) – – 1(0.1) –
(IV)ZDVb+ARVsyrupd 1(0.2) 2(0.5) 5(2.9) 8(0.6) –
Formulac+ARVsyrupd 14(2.9) 1(0.2) 23(13.4) 116(68.2) 154(12.2) 8(2.8)
Onlyformulac 1(0.2) – – – 1(0.1) 1(0.3)
OnlyARVsyrupd 2(0.4) 1(0.2) 9(5.2) 49(28.8) 61(4.8) 1(0.3)
Noneoftheinterventions 1(0.2) – – 2(1.2) 3(0.2) 1(0.3)
a ARVprophylaxis–ARVuseduringpregnancy. b (IV)ZDV–intravenouszidovudine.
c Formula–newbornswhowerenotbreastfedandreceivedinfantformula. dARVsyrup–ARVsyrupadministeredtonewborns.
e Among482newbornswhowereborntowomendiagnosedwithHIVbeforepregnancy,289werebornfromsubsequentpregnanciesduring
thestudyperiod.
f Ofthe1260newborns,dataontimingofHIVtestingofthewomenwereavailablefor1259.Ofthe1260newborns,53hadmissingdatainat
leastoneinterventionandtheydonotappearinthetable,aswecouldnotdefinewhichsetofinterventionstheyreceived.
g Ofthe482newbornswhowereborntowomendiagnosedwithHIVbeforepregnancy,29hadmissingdatainatleastoneinterventionand
wecouldnotdefinewhichsetofinterventionstheyreceived.Amongthese29,atleast8received(IV)ZDV,14receivedformulaandatleast 17receivedARVsyrup.
h Ofthe435newbornswhowereborntowomendiagnosedwithHIVduringpregnancy,14hadmissingdatainatleastoneinterventionand
wecouldnotdefinewhichsetofinterventionstheyreceived.Amongthese14,allofthemreceivedARVprophylaxis,8received(IV)ZDV,11 receivedformulaand6receivedARVsyrup.
i Ofthe172newbornswhowereborntowomendiagnosedwithHIVduringdelivery,10hadmissingdatainatleastoneinterventionandwe
couldnotdefinewhichsetofinterventionstheyreceived.Amongthese10,atleast4received(IV)ZDV,5receivedformulaand6receivedARV syrup.
j Ofthe170newbornswhowereborntowomendiagnosedwithHIVduringthepostpartum period,3hadmissingdatainatleastone
interventionandwecouldnotdefinewhichsetofinterventionstheyreceived.Amongthese3,2receivedformulaandall3receivedARV syrup.
k Ofthe289newbornsfromsubsequentpregnanciesinthecohort,21hadmissingdatainatleastoneinterventionandwecouldnotdefine
whichsetofinterventionstheyreceived.
l OnenewborndiedanddidnotreceiveARVsyrup.Thedeathwasrelatedtoprematurityandhepatomegaly.
Janeiro(12.5%),DuquedeCaxias(11.8%),SãoJoãodeMeriti (10.3%)andBelfordRoxo(10.3%)(Fig.2).
Amongallnewbornsinthecohortwithavailabledataat the timingofmaternalHIVdiagnosis (n=1259),only47.6% benefitedfromtherecommendedpackageofinterventionsfor PMTCT.
The antenatal care (ANC) components of the package were usedby59.2% (n=746)ofall pregnancies(n=1259) in thiscohort.Theglobalcoverageofintrapartumintravenous zidovudine(IVZDV)componentwas74.1%(n=934),and97.5% (n=1230) ofthe newbornshad access toZDV syrup;85.5% (n=1077)wereonantiretrovirals(ARVs)syrupfor6weeks.Of those,10.1% hadnodataregardingdurationofARVssyrup exposure.Nobreastfeeding(duringtheirstayinthe mater-nityward)wasobservedin91.0%(n=1146)ofthenewborns (Table2).
Ofthenewbornswhowereborntowomendiagnosedwith HIVbeforeorduringpregnancy(n=917)andwhowould there-forehavehadtheopportunitytoreceivetheentirepackage
ofinterventionrecommendedforPMTCT,27.7%didnothave accesstoit.Approximately18%(n=138)hadnoaccesstothe antenatalcomponentofthepackageandatleast10.4%(n=95) hadnotreceivedintrapartumIVZDV.Thevastmajorityofthe newborns(95.3%)hadaccesstoinfantformula(Table2).
AmongthepregnantwomendiagnosedwithHIVduring deliveryandtheirnewborns(n=172),72.7%receivedallofthe recommendedinterventions(IVZDV,oralZDVandno breast-feeding)(Table2).Ofthenewbornswhowereborntowomen diagnosedwithHIVduringtheimmediatepostpartumperiod (n=171),only67.8%receivedtherecommendedinterventions. ARVssyrupwasusedfor6weeksby86%(n=147/171)ofthese newbornsandfor6.5%therewasnodataavailableonthe dura-tionofARVssyrupexposure.Onenewbornofamotherwhose HIVdiagnosisantedatedthecurrentpregnancyandtwo new-bornsofmothersdiagnosedwithHIVduringthepostpartum periodhavenotreceivedanyintervention(Table2).
Whenconsideringonlythesubsequentpregnanciesinthe cohort (n=289),inwhichall womenwere alreadyawareof
9.0 8.0 7.0 6.0 5.0 4.0 3.0 2.0 1.0 0.0 1999 (n=36) % 0.00.0 3.3 4.0 2.9 3.5 6.7 8.8 5.7 6.7 3.5 4.0 7.47.7 5.4 5.9 4.7 5.2 3.2 3.7 4.2 5.3 4.7 4.5 2000 (n=63) 2001 (n=72) 2002 (n=64) 2003 (n=93) 2004 (n=117) 2005 (n=160) Year 2006 (n=194) 2007 (n=201) 2008 (n=159) 2009 (n=99) Global (n=1258)
Vertical transmission rate Estimated vertical transmission rate Global and annual HIV vertical transmission rates. HGNI, 1999-2009
Fig.3–EstimatedoverallandannualMTCTrates,1999–2009.
theirHIVserostatusbeforebecomingpregnant,only67.8%of themhadaccesstotheentirepackageofinterventions recom-mendedforPMTCT;almost12%ofthemdidnothaveaccess totheantenatalcomponentsoftheinterventions(Table2).
Amongbreastfednewborns(n=91),informationon breast-feedingdurationwas availablefor62ofthem.Medianand meannumberofdaysofbreastfeedingwere1(IQR:1–2)and 5.3(SD12.6).
Regarding access to the recommended interventions according to the timing of maternal HIV diagnosis and according to the year of delivery, there was no apparent trendtowardsaccessing thecascadeofinterventionsalong the study period (before pregnancy: p=0.12; during preg-nancy:p=0.09;labor:p=0.499;postpartum:p=0.627)(datanot shown).Ofthelive-birthinfantswhosemothers were diag-nosedwithHIVatdeliveryandduringthepostpartumperiod in2009,thelastyearofinclusioninthestudy,accesstothe rec-ommendedinterventionsremainedunsatisfactory(80%and 67.7%,respectively)(datanotshown).
Theannual coverage ofIV ZDV administrationto new-bornsalsofluctuatedgloballyovertheyearsandaccordingto thetimeofmaternalHIVdiagnosis.In2009,ofthelive-birth infantswhosemotherswerediagnosedwithHIVbeforeor dur-ingpregnancyandatdelivery(n=96),22.9%hadnotreceived thisintrapartumcomponent.
TheoverallrateofHIVMTCTduringthestudyperiodwas 4.7%(CI95%:3.5–5.9)(n=1258).HIVserostatuscouldnotbe determinedin223(17.9%)newborns,duetolosttofollow-up. Whenthe MTCTratewas calculatedusingthe assumption thattheHIVinfectionratewasthesameforthosenewborns inwhomanHIVdiagnosiswasnotdetermined,theestimated overalltransmissionratewas5.3%(CI95%:4.1–6.5)(Fig.3).The highestannualrateoccurredin2005(7.4%;CI95%:3.3–11.5), withnodefinitetrendintheperiod(datanotshown).When consideringonlybreastfednewborns(n=91),theMTCTrate was12.1%(CI95%:5.4–18.8),significantlyhigherthanthe3.9%
(CI95%:2.8–5.0)rateobservedamongthenon-breastfed new-borns(n=1167)(p=0.0001).
Discussion
OurresultsshowsthattheHIVMTCTratesfrom1999to2009 remainedhighamongwomenwhoreceivedANCordelivered atthismajorreferralcenterforPMTCTintheoutskirtsofRio deJaneiro.
SeveralstudiesinBrazilhavereportedtransmissionrates that are consistentwith thedata foundinour study,3,20–25
althoughlowerMTCTrateshavebeenachievedinwealthier statessuchasSãoPaulo,8 asaresultofabetterstructured
healthcaresystem.Overall,theratesfoundinBrazilarehigher thanthosereportedfromdevelopedcountries,where prophy-lacticmeasuresareimplementedearlyinpregnancyresulting inMTCTratesaround1%.26
When considering all newbornsin the cohort(n=1259), only52.7%ofthembenefitedfromthecompletepackageof interventionsthatarerecommendedforPMTCT.Again,this resultissimilartothatobservedforBrazilasawhole(52%) butismuchlowerthanthatobservedinSãoPaulowherein arecentreporttherewas82%coveragefortheentire pack-ageofPMTCTinterventions.8Despitethebroadknowledgein
placeaboutthehigheffectivenessofARTduringpregnancy forPMTCT27 and the universalavailability ofARVsforthis
purpose inBrazil, access tothe antenatal component was observedinonly59.2%ofthefirstpregnanciesincludedinthis study.LatedetectionofHIVinfectionduringprenatalcare rep-resentsanopportunitytointervene,thuslimitingthenumber ofpediatriccasesasaresultofperinataltransmission.28
AccesstoHIVtesting,theentry pointforPMTCTduring antenatalcare,maybehamperedbyaseriesofevents,which result in a delayed HIV diagnosis,27,29 leading to a longer
deliveryorpostpartum30leadstounacceptablyhighriskof
HIV transmission. The lack of HIV diagnosis during preg-nancyrepresentsonlythefirst stepofacascadeofmissed opportunities. Ofnote, 26.6% ofpregnancies in which HIV infection was diagnosed before or during pregnancy have notevenreceivedoneofthecomponentsoftheprevention package.Amongthese,32.7%havenotreceivedtheantenatal component,and9.8%havereceivedtheintrapartum compo-nent.Furtherstudies are needed toidentifystrategiesand interventionstoovercomethebarriersinplaceanddecrease theinequalitiesinaccesstoPMTCTservices.
Evenmoreworrisomeisthefinding thatamongthe 289 subsequentpregnanciesthatresultedinlivebirthsduringthe studyperiod,only67.8%receivedthefullpackageofPMTCT interventions.Itisespeciallydisconcertingthatalmost20% ofthesesubsequentpregnancieshaveaccessedthe antena-talcomponent.Insufficientlinkagetocareafterdeliveryisa well-recognizedmatteramongHIV-infectedwomen,andnot infrequentlytheysolelyresumetheircontactwiththehealth servicesatthetimeofdeliveryofasubsequentpregnancy. Lackofintegrationofhealthservices,notablybetween prena-talandmaternitycare,mayhavealsoaccountedforpartof theprobleminregardtoaccesstotheintrapartumand post-partumcomponentsofthePMTCT interventionpackage.A studyconductedinRiodeJaneirohaveindicatedthat approx-imately30%ofpregnantwomenunsuccessfullyattemptedto beadmittedto oneor morehospitals duringlabor,31 prior
toadmissionfordelivery,highlightingthe fragileand frag-mentedhealthsysteminplace.
Breastfeedingwasobservedin9%ofthenewborns, simi-lartotheratereportedinastudy fromPernambuco,inthe NortheastregionofBrazil10andlowerthantheratereported
inSergipe, inthe same region,11 leading to a significantly
higherMTCTrateamongbreastfednewbornswhencompared tothose non-breastfed(12.1%vs.3.9%).Inacountry where formulahaslongbeenprovidedfreeofchargetoHIVinfected mothers,breastfeedingmay,infact,bemoreofamarkerof pooraccesstohealthcareingeneral.LateHIVdiagnosisofthe motherleadstoalostopportunityofadvisingagainst breast-feeding,whichisamajorfactorassociatedwithMTCT,32and
anyexposuretobreastmilkinitselfconstitutesariskfactor fortransmission.
Several studies have confirmed the strong relationship betweenthenumberofprenatalvisitsortheinitiationofearly prenatal care withsocioeconomic status and the mother’s education.27,33 Povertyisacriticaldeterminantofhealthin
individualsand populations, increasingthevulnerability to severaldiseases and is amajorbarrier toaccessto health services,informationandpreventivemeasures.34Incomeand
education are strongly associatedwith health outcomes,35
andtheeffectsoftheeducationlevelareexpressedindifferent ways,such asthe perceptionofhealth problems,the abil-itytounderstandhealthinformation,theadoptionofhealthy lifestyles,theconsumptionandutilizationofhealthservices, andtheadherencetotherapeuticprocedures.HIVinfection prevalenceamongpregnantwomenandtheincidenceof ver-tical transmission have been associated with lower urban quality of residential neighborhood in Brazil.36 Our study
population was characterized by low income and educa-tionlevels andahigh predominanceofnon-whitewomen,
accuratelyrepresentingtheimpoverishedpopulationof Baix-adaFluminense.Despitethesignificantdecreaseinpoverty intensityduringthelastyearsinBrazil,serioussocial, eco-nomicandculturalinequitiescontinuetoplaguethecountry. These inequities include disparities related to the quality ofhealthservices, whichare fairlyevidentinprenatal ser-vicesandarestillreflectedintheinsufficienteffectiveaccess to PMTCT interventions. In order to improve engagement tocare,PMTCT programsmay needtoevaluatealternative strategiessuchasincentivesandadditionalservices, includ-ingenhancededucationonPMTCTandsexualtransmission ofHIV.Interventionsthatimprovetheengagementof preg-nantwomeninHIVcareandtreatmentprogramsareurgently neededtoachievetheWHOgoalofzeromother-to-childHIV transmission.37
Importantly, ahigh prevalence ofmultiparity (75%) and abortion(36.6%)wasobservedinthiscohort,despitethehigh proportion of women under the age of 24, indicating the insufficiency ofadequate family planning services suitable forthispopulation.Accordingtodatafromthe2006National HouseholdSampleSurvey(PesquisaNacionalporAmostrade Domicílios–PNAD),theoverallfertilityratein2005was2.1 childrenperwomanofchildbearingage;itrangedfromfour (forwomenwithupto3yearsofschooling)to1.5(forthose whohadeightormore38yearsofschooling).Inthiscontext,
accesstocomprehensivefamilyplanningservicestailoredto thespecificneedsoftheHIV-infectedpopulationisakey com-ponentforeffectivePMTCT.
Notably,althoughthemajorityofthewomen(75.3%)were livingwiththeirpartnersatthetimeofinclusioninthecohort, only47.1%wereawareoftheirHIVserostatus,andofthese women, 39.9%had anHIV-uninfectedsexualpartner, high-lighting thesubstantial riskforHIVsexualtransmissionin these serodiscordant relationships and the critical needto implementearlyARTinthesesituations,giventhe96% reduc-tionintheriskofHIVtransmission.39Furthermore,untreated
HIVinfectionhasanegativeimpactonhealththroughoutthe courseoftheinfection.40Takentogether,thesedatasupport
therevisedPMTCTrecommendationsoftheBrazilianMinistry ofHealth,whichrecommendARTpostpartummaintenance for all women who started it duringpregnancy, regardless oftheCD4cellcounts.41 Theevidencethatpregnancy
dou-bles theriskofHIVtransmissionfrom pregnantwomento theirpartners42andthehighprevalenceofmultiparity(75%)
observedinthisstudypopulationfurtherreiteratethis strat-egy.
Thisstudyhasseverallimitations.Asthestudywas con-ductedatasinglecenter,thestudypopulationcouldnotbe representativeofchildrenexposedtoMTCTthroughoutthe stateofRiodeJaneiro. However,thismay beoffset,asthe chosencenter,HGNI,receivesthegreatestregionaldemand forHIV-exposedchildrenintheBaixadaFluminensearea.The retrospectivenatureofourstudyhasnotallowedfor captur-ingdataonthebarrierstoPMTCTandtominimizethelostto follow-up.Asourdatawerecollectedfromclinicalrecordsand registries,thereweremissingvalues,whichwebelievehave occurred randomly.Besides,wecouldnotcollect more reli-ableimportantdataasviralload;thus,wecouldnotaccess theassociationbetweenviralloadandmodeofdeliveryand itsappropriateness.
Theresultsfromthisstudyreflecttherealityoffragmented accesstoPMTCTinterventionsinBaixadaFluminense,where the municipalities with the lowest levels of development acrosstheRiodeJaneiroStatearelocated;approximately25% ofthe populationofNovaIguac¸u andDuquedeCaxiasare belowthepovertyline.
Our data provide critical insights to better understand Brazil’s low overall performance in PMTCT and may help explainsomeofthefactorsrelatedtothedisconcerting occur-renceofapproximately500casesofAIDSinchildrenunder theageoffiveinBrazil.2DespitethesuccessoftheBrazilian
programforuniversalaccesstoART,thePMTCTprogramhas encounteredcriticalhurdlesrelatedtothehealthcaresystem, whichisstilldeficientandmarredbyserioussocialinequities regardingaccesstoqualityhealthcare.33Inthiscontext,equal
accesstoqualifiedhealthservicesisessentialandwill posi-tivelyinfluencethecascadeofaccesstoPMTCTinterventions anddecreasethenumberofpediatricAIDScasesinBrazil.
Conflicts
of
interest
Theauthorsdeclarenoconflictsofinterest.
r
e
f
e
r
e
n
c
e
s
1. VelosoVG,PortelaMC,VasconcellosMT,etal.HIVtesting amongpregnantwomeninBrazil:ratesandpredictors.Rev SaudePublica.2008;42:859–67.
2. Brasil,MinistériodaSaúde,SecretariadeVigilânciaemSaúde, DepartamentodeDST,AIDSeHepatitesVirais.Boletim EpidemiológicoAIDS–DST.anoVIIIn◦01;2011.Availableat: http://www.aids.gov.br/sites/default/files/anexos/publicacao/ 2011/50652/boletimaids2011finalmpdf26659.pdf [accessed06.05.13].
3. TessBH,RodriguesLC,NewellML,DunnDT,LagoTD.Infant feedingandriskofmother-to-childtransmissionofHIV-1in SaoPauloState,BrazilSaoPauloCollaborativeStudyfor VerticalTransmissionofHIV-1.JAcquirImmuneDeficSyndr HumRetrovirol.1998;19:189–94.
4. SucciRCM.Mother-to-childtransmissionofHIVinBrazil duringtheyears2000and2001:resultsofamulti-centric study.CadSaudePublica.2007;23Suppl.:S379–89.
5. JoãoEC,CruzML,MenezesJA,etal.Verticaltransmissionof HIVinRiodeJaneiro,Brazil.AIDS.2003;17:1853–5.
6. KakehasiFM,PintoJA,RomanelliRM,etal.Determinantsand trendsinperinatalhumanimmunodeficiencyvirustype1 (HIV-1)transmissioninthemetropolitanareaofBelo Horizonte,Brazil:1998–2005.MemInstOswaldoCruz. 2008;103:351–7.
7. TornatoreM,GoncalvesCV,Mendoza-SassiRA,etal.HIV-1 verticaltransmissioninRioGrande,SouthernBrazil.IntJSTD AIDS.2010;21:351–5.
8. MatidaLH,SantosNJ,RamosJrAN,etal.Eliminatingvertical transmissionofHIVinSãoPauloBrazil:progressand challenges.JAcquirImmuneDeficSyndr.2011;57 Suppl.:S164–70.
9. SoeiroCM,MirandaAE,SaraceniV,LucenaNO,TalhariS, FerreiraLC.Mother-to-childtransmissionofHIVinfectionin Manaus,StateofAmazonas,Brazil.RevSocBrasMedTrop. 2011;44:537–41.
10.GouveiaPAC,SilvaGA,AlbuquerqueMFPM.Factors associatedwithmother-to-childtransmissionofthehuman
immunodeficiencyvirusinPernambuco,Brazil,2000–2009. TropMedIntHealth.2013;18:276–85.
11.LemosLM,LippiJ,RutherfordGW,etal.Maternalriskfactors forHIVinfectionininfantsinnortheasternBrazil.IntJInfect Dis.2013;17:e913–8.
12.DaoH,MofensonLM,EkpiniR,etal.International recommendationsonantiretroviraldrugsfortreatmentof HIV-infectedwomenandpreventionofmother-to-childHIV transmissioninresource-limitedsettings:2006update.AmJ ObstetGynecol.2007;197Suppl.:S42–55.
13.MinistériodoPlanejamento.Orc¸amentoeGestão,Instituto BrasileirodeGeografiaeEstatística–IBGECensoDemográfico 2010;2010.Availableat:http://www.censo2010.ibge.gov.br/ [accessed23.09.13].
14.Brasil,MinistériodaSaúde.DATASUS.Informac¸õesdeSaúde (TABNET);2013.Availableat:http://www2.aids.gov.br/cgi/ deftohtm.exe?tabnet/rj.def[accessed15.08.13].
15.SzwarcwaldCL,SouzaJúniorPR.Estimativadaprevalênciade HIVnapopulac¸ãobrasileirade15a49anos,2004.InBrasil. MinistériodaSaúde.BoletimEpidemiológico–AIDSeDST. AnoIII,n◦1,janeiroajunhode2006;2013.Availableat:http:// bvsms.saude.gov.br/bvs/periodicos/BOLETIM2006internet.pdf [accessed15.08.13].
16.Brasil,SistemadeInformac¸ãosobreNascidosVivos(SINASC). Availableat:
http://tabnet.datasus.gov.br/cgi/sinasc/dados/novindice.htm [accessed15.08.13].
17.Brasil,MinistériodaSaúde,SecretariadeVigilânciaem Saúde,ProgramaNacionaldeDSTeAids.Recomendac¸ões paraTerapiaAntirretroviralemCrianc¸aseAdolescentes InfectadospeloHIV;2009.Availableat:
http://www.aids.gov.br/sites/default/files/consenso pediatrico.pdf[accessed05.05.13].
18.ReadJS,CommitteeonPediatricAIDS,AmericanAcademyof Pediatrics.DiagnosisofHIV-1infectioninchildrenyounger than18monthsintheUnitedStates.Pediatrics.
2007;120:e1547–62.
19.ESRI.ArcGISDesktop:Release10.Redlands,CA: EnvironmentalSystemsResearchInstitute;2011.
20.KonopkaCK,BeckST,WiggersD,daSilvaAK,DiehlFP,Santos FG.ClinicalandepidemiologicalprofileofHIV-infected pregnantwomeninaserviceinsouthBrazil.RevBrasGinecol Obstet.2010;32:184–90.
21.Mussi-PinhataMM,KatoCM,DuarteG,PaschoiniMC,Bettiol H,QuintanaSM.FactorsassociatedwithverticalHIV transmissionduringtwodifferenttimeperiods:theimpactof zidovudineuseonclinicalpracticeataBrazilianreference centre.IntJSTDAIDS.2003;14:818–25.
22.FernandesRC,AraujoLC,Medina-AcostaE.Preventionof verticalHIVtransmissioninCamposdosGoytacazes,Riode Janeiro,Brazil.CadSaudePublica.2005;21:1153–9.
23.MirandaAE,SoaresRA,PradoBC,MonteiroRB,FigueiredoNC. MothertochildtransmissionofHIVinVitoria,Brazil:factors associatedwithlackofHIVprevention.AIDSCare.
2005;17:721–8.
24.DalFabbroMMFJ,CunhaRV,PaniagoAMM,LindenbergASC, FreitasGMB,NogueiraSA.Prospectivestudyonthe
preventionofverticaltransmissionofHIVinCampoGrande, MatoGrossodoSul,Brazil,from1996to2001.BrazJInfect Dis.2005;9:20–7.
25.TurchiMD,DuarteLS,MartelliCMT.Mother-to-child
transmissionofHIV:riskfactorsandmissedopportunitiesfor preventionamongpregnantwomenattendinghealthservices inGoiania,GoiasState,Brazil.CadSaudePublica.2007;23 Suppl.:S390–401.
26.TownsendCL,Cortina-BorjaM,PeckhamCS,deRuiterA,Lyall H,TookeyPA.Lowratesofmother-to-childtransmissionof HIVfollowingeffectivepregnancyinterventionsintheUnited
KingdomandIreland,2000–2006.AIDS.2008;22: 973–81.
27.BarcellosC,AcostaLMW,LisboaE,BastosFI.Surveillanceof mother-to-childHIVtransmission:socioeconomicandhealth carecoverageindicators.RevSaudePublica.2009;43:1006–14. 28.SouzaJuniorPR,SzwarcwaldCL,BarbosaJuniorA,Carvalho
MF,CastilhoEA.HIVinfectionduringpregnancy:theSentinel SurveillanceProjectBrazil,2002.RevSaudePublica.
2004;38:764–72.
29.AndradeMV,NoronhaK,SinghA,RodriguesCG,Padmadas SS.AntenatalcareuseinBrazilandIndia:scale,outreachand socioeconomicinequality.HealthPlace.2012;18:942–50. 30.VelosoVG,BastosFI,PortelaMC,etal.HIVrapidtestingasa
keystrategyforpreventionofmother-to-childtransmission inBrazil.RevSaudePublica.2010;44:803–11.
31.MenezesDC,LeiteIdaC,SchrammJM,LealMC.Evaluationof antenatalperegrinationinasampleofpostpartumwomenin RiodeJaneiro,Brazil,1999/2001.CadSaudePublica.
2006;22:553–9.
32.CoutsoudisA,DabisF,FawziW,etal.Latepostnatal transmissionofHIV-1inbreast-fedchildren:anindividual patientdatameta-analysis.JInfectDis.2004;189:2154–66. 33.MinistériodoPlanejamento,Orc¸amentoeGestão,Instituto
BrasileirodeGeografiaeEstatística–IBGE,Diretoriade Pesquisas,Coordenac¸ãodePopulac¸ãoeIndicadoresSociais. EstudosePesquisas,Informac¸ãoDemográficae
Socioeconômica.IndicadoresSociodemográficosedeSaúde noBrasil–Número25;2009.Availableat:
http://www.ibge.gov.br/home/estatistica/populacao/indic sociosaude/2009/indicsaude.pdf[accessed06.05.13].
34.FilippiV,RonsmansC,CampbellOM,etal.Maternalhealthin poorcountries:thebroadercontextandacallforaction. Lancet.2006;368:1535–41.
35.MessiasE.Incomeinequality,illiteracyrate,andlife expectancyinBrazil.AmJPublicHealth.2003;93:1294–6.
36.VieiraAC,MirandaAE,VargasPR,MacielEL.HIVprevalence inpregnantwomenandverticaltransmissioninaccordingto socioeconomicstatus,SoutheasternBrazil.RevSaude Publica.2011;45:644–51.
37.UNAIDS,Geneva,SwitzerlandCountdowntozero:globalplan towardstheeliminationofnewinfectionsamongchildrenby 2015andkeepingtheirmothersalive;2011.Availableat: http://www.unaids.org/en/media/unaids/contentassets/ documents/unaidspublication/2011/20110609JC2137 Global-Plan-Elimination-HIV-Children en.pdf[accessed13.08.13]. 38.MinistériodoPlanejamento,Orc¸amentoeGestão,Instituto
BrasileirodeGeografiaeEstatística–IBGE,Diretoriade Geociências,Coordenac¸ãodeRecursosNaturaiseEstudos Ambientais,Coordenac¸ãodeGeografia.EstudosePesquisas, Informac¸ãoGeográfica.IndicadoresdeDesenvolvimento Sustentável,número7;2010.Availableat:http://www.ibge. gov.br/home/geociencias/recursosnaturais/ids/ids2010.pdf [accessed06.05.13].
39.CohenMS,ChenYQ,McCauleyM,etal.PreventionofHIV-1 infectionwithearlyantiretroviraltherapy.NEnglJMed. 2011;365:493–505.
40.UNAIDS.Globalreport:UNAIDSreportontheglobalAIDS epidemic2010.Geneva,Switzerland:UnitedNations ProgrammeonHIV/AIDS;2010.Availableat:http://www. unaids.org/en/media/unaids/contentassets/documents/ unaidspublication/210/20101123 globalreporten.pdf [accessed13.05.13].
41.WorldHealthOrganization.Useofantiretroviraldrugsfor treatingpregnantwomenandpreventingHIVinfectionin infants:executivesummary;2013
http://whqlibdoc.who.int/hq/2012/WHOHIV2012.6eng.pdf [accessed13.05.13].
42.MugoNR,HeffronR,DonnellD,etal.IncreasedriskofHIV-1 transmissioninpregnancy:aprospectivestudyamong AfricanHIV-1-serodiscordantcouples.AIDS.2011;25:1887–95.