• Nenhum resultado encontrado

Ativismo judicial e a idéia política do Poder Judiciário perfil e limitações

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2018

Share "Ativismo judicial e a idéia política do Poder Judiciário perfil e limitações"

Copied!
118
0
0

Texto

(1)
(2)

!!"#$%&'( %)#"!"*$%+% ,(-( ". /0*, % )%#, %1 )%#% % (2$"*&'( +( /#%3 +" "!$#"

"- #" $( (*!$ $3, (*%1 )"1% %,31+%+"

+" #" $( +% * 4"#! +%+" "+"#%1 +(

"%#56 !(2 % (# "*$%&'( +( #(78 #8

340*, ( %!,(*,"1(! %*%8

(#$%1"9% "%#5

(3)

!!"#$%&'( +"7"*+ +% " %)#(4%+% "- ; : <:

===================================

#(78 #8 340*, ( %!,(*,"1(! %*%

====================================

#(7%8 #%8 "* !" 3,"*% %4%1,%*$"

====================================

(4)

(! -"3! %-%+(! )% ! > ? @3"6 %)"!%# +% -(+"!$% 7(#-%&'( "!,(1%#6 $ 4"#%- % !%2"+(# % +" -" *+ ,%# ( ,%- *A( +% "+3,%&'(8

B - *A% %-%+% "!)(!% *% %31%6 @3" ,(- )%, 0*, %6 ,%# *A( "6 !(2#"$3+(6 %-(#6

"!$"4" ,(- /( *"!$% C(#*%+% ,(- %)( ( -)#"!, *+D4"18

(! -"3! 7 1A(!6 1". ! " 1 !(*6 @3" -" !"#4 #%- +" *!) #%&'( " ,(#%/"- )%#% %$ */ # "!$" (2C"$ 4(8

(5)

"3!6 7(*$"6 ,%3!% " #%9'( )%#% $3+(8

( #8 340*, ( %!,(*,"1(! )"1% ,(*7 %*&%6 %)( ( " )%, 0*, % *"!$% "-)#" $%+%8

(! %- /(! #($% " ($A"6 !"-)#" )#"!"*$"! +"!+" ( *D, ( +% - *A% ,%- *A%+% *% !"*+% C3#D+ ,%8

( %- /( %#,(! % #$(*6 )"1( *,"*$ 4( *$"1",$3%1 " %)( ( 7#%$"#*(6 ,(-

@3"-,(-)%#$ 1A( % ".)"# 0*, % +% !3)"#%&'( +%! 4 , !! $3+"! +" 3-% (# /"- -(+"!$%8

( %- /( "#*%*+( E#%/% %-%!,"*(6 )"1% #"7"#0*, % )#"!$%+% )(# (,%! '( +%

!"1"&'( )%#% */#"!!( *( "!$#%+(8

(! ,(1"/%! " #(7"!!(#"! +( "!$#%+(6 )"1% %- 9%+" " 7(#&% *% 5#+3% - !!'( @3" %!!3- -(! )"#%*$" "!$% )#"!$ / (!% *!$ $3 &'( %,%+0- ,%8

(6)

!

(7)

!"/3*+% /3"##% -3*+ %1 )#(4(,(3 #%+ ,% ! $#%*!7(#-%&G"! *% (#+"- /1(2%16 7%9"*+( ",1(+ #6 3* 4"#!%1-"*$"6 #"71".G"! !(2#" )# *,D) (! " +"% ! A3-%* $5# (!8 !! -6 7(#$%1","#%- !" +H %! +" +"-(,#%, % " +" + #" $(! A3-%*(! 73*+%-"*$% !

,(- #"*(4%&'( +( )"*!%-"*$( ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 !$%8 %&G"! )%!!%#%- % #","2"#

*713.(! +" #"+"-(,#%$ 9%&'( " *!$ $3 &G"! 7(#%- #"7(#-31%+%!6 +"!)(*$%*+(6 +%D6

3- *(4( )%)"1 )%#% ( (+"# 3+ , 5# (8 *"!$" ,(*$".$( @3" ( 3+ , 5# ( )%!!% %6

,(*,#"$%-"*$"6 %+($%# 3-% )(!$3#% +" )%#$ , )%&'( %$ 4% *% ,(*!$#3&'( +( "!)%&( +"-(,#5$ ,(6 *$"#7"# *+( *$"*! 4%-"*$" *(! )#(,"!!(! )(1D$ ,(! +" +", !'(

2%!"%+(! *( )# *,D) ( -%C(# $5# (8 3#/"6 "*$'(6 ( @3" !" ,(*4"*, (*(3 ,A%-%#

%$ 4 !-( C3+ , %16 $"#-( @3"6 "*$#"$%*$(6 #"@3"# 3-% %*51 !" -% ! )#(73*+% +" ,(*," $(! ,(-( C3# !+ &'( ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 " *$"#)#"$%&'( ,(*!$ $3, (*%16 )%#% -"1A(#

,(-)#""*!'( +( !"3 #"%1 ! /* 7 ,%+(8 $"#-( % *+% !3!, $% +I4 +%! " + 4"#/0*, %!6

" !3% 3$ 1 9%&'( % *+% "!$5 " 4%+% +" -3 $% -)#", !'( "6 7#"@J"*$"-"*$"6 "!$5

%$#"1%+( % (3$#( 7"*K-"*( *'( -"*(! ,(*$#(4"#!(6 % " # $ 8

,"#$( H @3" 3- #"7 *%-"*$( +% ,(-)#""*!'( (*$(1L/ ,% +( 7"*K-"*( ,(*$# 23 6

,"#$%-"*$"6 )%#% ( %)"#7" &(%-"*$( +% %$3%&'( +( 3+ , 5# ( *3- ,(*$".$( +"

*$"#%&'( + *M- ,% ,(- (! +"-% ! (+"#"!6 *3-% )"#!)",$ 4% -% ! "1"4%+% +"

#"%1 9%&'( +" + #" $(! A3-%*(! 73*+%-"*$% ! " ,(*!(1 +%&'( +( +"%1 +"-(,#5$ ,(8

!" # $ !% (+"# 3+ , 5# (6 %$ 4 !-( C3+ , %16 C3# !+ &'( ,(*!$ $3, (*%16

*$"#)#"$%&'( ,(*!$ $3, (*%16 C3+ , %1 9%&'( +% )(1D$ ,%6 )# *,D) ( -%C(# $5# (6

(8)

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

(9)

R8 *$#(+3&'(8888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888SS888888 R

8 3# !+ &'( (*!$ $3, (*%18888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888 RT

8R 3# !+ &'( (*!$ $3, (*%1 " !$%+( "-(,#5$ ,( +" #" $(8888888888888 R<

;8 3+ , %1 9%&'( +% (1D$ ,% "*K-"*( 1(2%188888888888888888888888888888888888888888888 ;

U8 $ 4 !-( 3+ , %18888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888 UV

U6R +4"*$( A !$L# ,( +( $"#-( W%$ 4 !-( C3+ , %1X ,A1"! */"# #8888888 TR

U8 (*($%&'( )(! $ 4% +( $"#-(8888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888 TT

U8; !( %,%+0- ,( " C3+ , %1 +( $"#-( ,YA **"O888888888888888888888888S8888 TV

U8U "1 *"%&'( +( )"#7 1 $"L# ,(88888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888 V

U8T $ 4 !-( C3+ , %1 " *$"#)#"$%&'( ,(*!$ $3, (*%188888888888888888888888888888888 ZR

T8 $ 4 !-( 3+ , %1 *( + #" $( 2#%! 1" #(888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888 ZZ

T8R +H % +" %$ 4 !-( *( E#%! 188888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888 ZZ

T8 3# !+ &'( (*!$ $3, (*%1 *( E#%! 1 3)#"-( # 23*%1 "+"#%188

T8; " ( "/ !1%$ 4(8888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888 U

T8U " %! @3"!$G"! )(1D$ ,%!888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888 <;

T8T $ 4 !-( 3+ , %1 +( *( ,%!( +( 3!( +" %1/"-%!8888888888888888 R Z

V8 (*,13!G"!88888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888 RRR

(10)

R8 [

+H % +" !$%+( "4(13 3 !32!$%*, %1 " 4"#$ / *(!%-"*$" %( 1(*/(

+% A !$L# %6 *($%+%-"*$" *(! I1$ -(! $#0! !H,31(!8 $#"1%+( % !$( $%-2H- $(-(3

,(#)( % +H % +" ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 !-(6 @3" /3 *+(3 )%#% 3-% )(! &'( +" )",31 %# #"1"4( ( )%)"1 +% %$ 4 +%+" C3# !+ , (*%1 " !3% ,(##"!)(*+"*$" $%#"7% +" ,(*!(1 +%#6 "- %1 ,"#," 7 #-"6 ( +"5# ( ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 !$%8

!(, "+%+"6 )(#$%*$(6 %##"/1(3 3- %##%*C( *!$ $3, (*%1 ,(- ( +"! +"#%$( -% (# +" !(1 + 7 ,%# % ,(*,")&'( +" +"-(,#%, %6 !(2#"!!% *+( !" ,(-( ,(*!%/#%+% % 7L#-31% +% $# )%#$ &'( +" )(+"#"!6 *% @3%1 H +"!$%,%+% 3-% *!$ $3 &'( ,(- % *,3-20*, % )#",D)3% +" #"!(13&'( +%! 1 +"! " ,(*$#(4H#! %! C3#D+ ,%!6

"# / *+( ,(-( )%#%+ /-% -5. -( *( %+ -)1"-"*$( +" !3% $%#"7% % (*!$ $3 &'(8

*"!!" ,(*$".$(6 )(#$%*$(6 @3" ( (+"# 3+ , 5# ( %$#% 3 )%#% ! %

%$"*&'( +" "!$3+ (!(! +( #" $(6 @3" !" +"+ ,%#%- % %*%1 !5 1( !(2 (! !"3! -% !

4%# %+(! %!)",$(!6 !(2#"!!% *+( !" *"!$% %*51 !" % (2!"#4%&'( +" !3% %$3%&'( ,(-( "7"$ 4%+(# +" + #" $(! " /%#%*$ %! 73*+%-"*$% !6 *3-% #"1%&'( *!$ $3, (*%1

,(- (! +"-% ! ,(-)(*"*$"! +% "!$#3$3#% +( !$%+(8 )#"(,3)%&'( $ *A% ,(-(

7(,( %7"# # % )(!! 2 1 +%+" +" %$3%&'( +( 3+ , 5# ( *( ,3-)# -"*$( +" !3% - !!'( *!$ $3, (*%1 !"- +"!4 #$3%# % +H % +" "@3 1D2# ( "*$#" (! (+"#"! "6 %$#%4H! + !$(6

%!!"/3#%# + #" $(! *+ 4 +3% ! "- ,(*$#%)(! &'( \ %$3%&'( +( !$%+(8

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

,"+ &( @3" ( (+"# 3+ , 5# ( *,(#)(#% 3- )"#7 1 *!$ $3, (*%1 @3"

+"!)"#$% @3"!$ (*%-"*$(! *( @3" $%*/" \ !3% %3$(# +%+"6 !3% 1"/ $ - +%+"6

(11)

,(-+ -"*!'( ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 ,(-+" /#%*,(-+" -)%,$(6 *( %7' ,(-+" "7"$ 4%&'( ,(-+" ,(-+ #" $(! " /%#%*$ %! 73*+%-"*$% !6 ,(- #")"#,3!!'( *"4 $54"1 *( #"1%, (*%-"*$( ,(- %! +"-% ! *!$ $3 &G"! ,(-( ( "/ !1%$ 4( " ( .",3$ 4(8

"#%*$" $%1 )#(21"-5$ ,%6 )(#$%*$(6 H @3" %!!(-% ,(-( (2C"$( "!$ -31%*$" +" )"!@3 !% % + *M- ,% +% %$ 4 +%+" C3+ , %1 " !"3! ,(*!",$5# (! *%

-(1+3#% ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 +" "!$#3$3#%&'( +( !$%+(8 ]3"!$G"! -"+ %$%! !"

-)G"-*( +"2%$" $% ! ,(-( % ,(*,#"$% ". !$0*, % (3 *'( +" %1/( @3" !" )(!!% $ $31%# ,(-( W%$ 4 !-( C3+ , %1X " !" $%1 )(!$3#% )(+" !"# 4 !$% ,(-( 3- +"!4 #$3%-"*$( +%!

%$# 23 &G"! +( (+"# 3+ , 5# (6 *% -"+ +% "- @3" #"!4%1%# % )%#% 3-% %$ 4 +%+"

)(1D$ ,% @3" *'( !" ,(%+3*%# % ,(- % !3% 73*&'( )#",D)3% *( ,(*$".$( +" "@3 1D2# ( "*$#" (! (+"#"!8

I4 +%!6 )( !6 ,(-"&%- % +"!)(*$%#6 %,%##"$%*+( % *","!! +%+" +" !" ,(-)#""*+"# "- @3" ,(*! !$ # % 3-% %$ 4 +%+" )(1D$ ,%6 " !(2#" ( @3"6 %7 *%1 +" ,(*$%!6 "!$%# % %2#%*/ +( )"1% +H % +" /(4"#*(8 !$( )(#@3" !(% ,(-( )1%3!D4"1 %

,(*,")&'( +( 3+ , 5# ( ,(-( *!"# +( *( ,(*$".$( +" %$3%&'( +( !$%+(6 %/ *+(

,(-( )"&% 73*+%-"*$%1 *% #"%1 9%&'( +" 3-% %$ 4 +%+" )(1D$ ,%8 %$ 4 !-(6 +"!$%

7(#-%6 )(+"# % "*,(*$#%# (# /"*! *% ,(*!, 0*, % +" 3-% #"!)(*!%2 1 +%+" +( 3+ , 5# ( @3%*$( \ #"%1 9%&'( +" -3+%*&%! !(, % ! %$#%4H! +" 3-% %$3%1 9%&'(

)"#-%*"*$" +(! 4%1(#"! ,(*!$ $3, (*% ! 4 % *$"#)#"$%&'( +% %#$% (1D$ ,%8

"!$%#$"6 ( ".%-" +%! %$# 23 &G"! +( 3+ , 5# ( %!!3-" #"1"4M*, % "!)", %16 *($%+%-"*$" !(2 3- "*7(@3" +"(1L/ ,(6 )( ! (2!"#4% !" %$3%1-"*$" 3-%

+ *M- ,% +" ".)%*!'( +% %$3%&'( +"!!" (+"#8 3-% (#+"- -3*+ %1 (*+" (

+"5# ( *"(1 2"#%1 +(- *% ( ,(*$".$( /1(2%16 ( 3+ , 5# ( $"- !" ,(1(,%+( ,(-(

"!)%&( 1"/D$ -( +" @3"!$ (*%-"*$( +% %$3%&'( "!$%$%16 !"*+( )#($%/(* !$% +" 3-(3$#( 7"*K-"*( @3" $"- +"!)"#$%+( *$"#"!!" +" C3# !$%!6 !(, L1(/(! " , "*$ !$%!

)(1D$ ,(!6 ,A%-%+( +"" # $ 8

(12)

A%#-K* ,( *( +"! +"#%$( -% (# +% #"%1 9%&'( +" )# *,D) (! 2%! 1%#"!6 "!)", %1-"*$" ( +% + /* +%+" +% )"!!(% A3-%*%8

@3" !" $"*$%#5 ,(-)#""*+"#6 )( !6 H !" ( 3 96 %( "."#,"# !3% %$ 4 +%+" C3# !+ , (*%1 "- 3- )#(,"!!(6 #"%1 9% %$( )(1D$ ,( " !" !!(6 "-2(#% *'(

,(*!$ $3%6 *","!!%# %-"*$"6 3-% %-"%&% %( !$%+( "-(,#5$ ,( +" #" $(6

,%#%,$"# 9% ( @3" !" ,A%-% +" W%$ 4 !-( C3+ , %1X (36 ,(-( )#"7"# +( )(# (3$#(!6 3-W/(4"#*( +" C3D9"!X8 G" !" ,(-( -)"# (!% % 4"# 7 ,%&'( !(2#" %$H @3" )(*$( ( %$ 4 !-( C3+ , %1 #")#"!"*$% 3- # !,( % 3- -(+"1( ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 +" "@3 1D2# ( "*$#" )(+"#"!8

%#% +"!"*4(14 -"*$( +% )"!@3 !% %@3 )#()(!$%6 !"#5 7" $( "!$3+(

*% 1 $"#%$3#% *%, (*%1 " "!$#%*/" #%6 "-2(#% "!!" "!$3+( !" %)L "

)#"+(- *%*$"-"*$" *% +(3$# *% ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 +% 7%-D1 % C3#D+ ,% %*/1( !%.' > %?6 (*+" ( $"-% H +"2%$ +( -% ! 7#"@J"*$"-"*$" "6 )(# ,(*!"/3 *$"6 H )#(+39 +% 3-% @3%*$ +%+" -% (# +" (2#%! (*+" "!$'( ".)(!$%! %! + 4"#!%! )(! &G"! " ,(*,")&G"! !(2#" ( $"-%8 )"#7 1 A !$L# ,( +% ".)#"!!'( W%$ 4 !-( C3+ , %1X H 1"4%*$%+( " %1/3-%! %2(#+%/"*! $"L# ,%! !'( *($ , %+%! *( *$3 $( +" !" ,(1%, (*%# "1"-"*$(! @3" )"#- $%- 3-% ,(*7 /3#%&'( +" "1"-"*$(! ,%#%,$"#D!$ ,(!

@3" )(!! 2 1 $"- % +"*$ 7 ,%&'( +( %$ 4 !-( *( -3*+( 7"*(-0* ,(8 "*7(@3"6

)(#$%*$(6 H % %$ 4 +%+" +( 3+ , 5# (6 *($%+%-"*$" *( @3" $%*/" \ C3# !+ &'(

,(*!$ $3, (*%1 " !3% %$3%&'( *% 23!,% +% "7"$ 4%&'( +(! 4%1(#"! ,(*!$ $3, (*% !8

* , %1-"*$"6 !"#5 %2(#+%+% % $"-5$ ,% 4(1$%+% )%#% (

,(*!$ $3, (*%1 !-( -(+"#*( " ( )#(21"-% +% %$3%&'( +( 3+ , 5# (6 *($%+%-"*$"

*%! -)1 ,%&G"! ,(- %! *(&G"! +" +"-(,#%, % " 1"/ $ - +%+"8 + #" $(

,(*!$ $3, (*%1 ,(-)%#%+( )#() , %#5 ( -%$"# %1 $"L# ,( " )#5$ ,( -% ! 431$(!(6 A%C% 4 !$% % -% (# #",(##0*, % +% + !,3!!'( +( $"-% *( ".$"# (#6 (*+" %! +", !G"! -)(#$%*$"! +%! (#$"! !3)#"-%! #"4"#2"#%- -% ! *$"*!%-"*$" *% !(, "+%+"8

-)%D!"! ,(-( (! 6 )(# "."-)1(6 A5 3- 4 4( *$"#"!!" +( )I21 ,( *% *(-"%&'( +"

3D9"! )%#% (! $# 23*% ! #"!)(*!54" ! )"1% C3# !+ &'( ,(*!$ $3, (*%18

(13)

"-%*% +( *$"# (# +%! (#$"! #"!)(*!54" ! )"1( +"!1 *+" +" ,(*$#(4H#! %! ,(*!$ $3, (*% ! +" *$"*!% *7130*, % *% + *M- ,% !L, ( *!$ $3, (*%1 +" 3-% *%&'(8 6 L24 (6 7%9 !" *","!!5# % 3-% %2(#+%/"- A !$L# ,% %2#%*/"*+( % (# /"- " % "4(13&'( +( $"#-( W%$ 4 !-( C3+ , %1X " % !3% *$#(+3&'( *( !" ( C3#D+ ,( *%, (*%18

7"*K-"*( $%-2H- H %*%1 !%+( *( + #" $( )5$# ( %$#%4H! +( #"/ !$#(

+% %$3%&'( +( 3)#"-( # 23*%1 "+"#%16 ".%- *%*+( !"6 )(# "."-)1(6 ! $3%&G"!

,(*,#"$%! ,(- #")"#,3!!G"! *( #"1%, (*%-"*$( +%@3"1% (#$" ,(- ( "/ !1%$ 4( " (

.",3$ 4(8 ) !L+ (! #","*$"! +% C3# !)#3+0*, % +( !'( %*%1 !%+(! )%#% !"

+"$",$%# % (,(##0*, % +( @3" !" )(+"# % ,A%-%# %$ 4 !-(6 %*%1 !%*+( !" )%#%1"1%-"*$" % 7(#-% +" ,(-( !!( !" +5 " 23!,%*+( "*,% .%# ( 7%$( "!$3+%+( *% -(1+3#% $"L# ,% $#%&%+% )"1(! +(3$# *%+(#"! +( %!!3*$(8

"#@3 #" !"6 )(# L24 (6 % *(&'( +" 3# !+ &'( (*!$ $3, (*%1 )%#% !" (2$"# 3- "*$"*+ -"*$( -% ! )#(73*+( +( -(+"1( *( @3%1 !" 7%9 -)#"!, *+D4"1 %

". !$0*, % +" 3- )(+"# C3+ , 5# (8 (- "!$% ,(*,")&'(6 )%#$" !" )%#% ( "!$3+( +(

7"*K-"*( +% " # $ 6 (2C"$ 4%*+( ,(-)#""*+"# ,(-( % %$ 4 +%+"

C3+ , %1 -"1A(# !" %+%)$% % 3- ,(*$".$( C3#D+ ,( )(1D$ ,( "!$54"18

(- !!( "- -"*$"6 45# (! %!)",$(! +( ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 !-( -(+"#*( !'( %2(#+%+(!6 ,(-( )(# "."-)1(6 ( "*$"*+ -"*$( +% #"1%&'( "*$#" % *(&'( +"

!3)#"-%, % +% (*!$ $3 &'( " C3# !+ &'( ,(*!$ $3, (*%18 +"-% !6 *'( +" .%- +" !"#

%2(#+%+(! @3"!$ (*%-"*$(! A !$L# ,(! %( "."#,D, ( +" 3-% %$ 4 +%+" )(1D$ ,% )"1(

(+"# 3+ , 5# (6 -%! 23!,% !" +"-(*!$#%# % *%##"+54"1 73*&'( )(1D$ ,% +(

3+ , 5# (6 4"# 7 ,%*+( !" % *%$3#"9% +" !3%! *,3-20*, %! " %$# 23$(! " !3%

*!"#&'( *( ,(*$".$( "!$#3$3#%1 +" 3- !$%+( "-(,#5$ ,( +" #" $(8 '( !" (14 +%6

% *+%6 % *@3 # &'( !(2#" ( )%)"1 +( 3+ , 5# ( *( ,(*$".$( +"(1L/ ,( " ( 7"*K-"*( +% ".)%*!'( +" !"3 )(+"# *( -3*+( /1(2%1 9%+(6 (*+" )#"+(- *% ( )"*!%-"*$(

*"(1 2"#%16 !3!, $%*+( "!)",31%&G"! %,"#,% +% 7(#-% ,(-( +"4" %$3%# ( 3 9 *%

,(*!",3&'( +(! 7 *! -% (#"! +( !$%+(8

- !3-%6 ( $#%2%1A( !" )#()G" % )"#!"/3 # % ,(*!$%$%&'( !(2#" %

". !$0*, % (3 *'( +( ,A%-%+( W%$ 4 !-( C3+ , %1X8 % A )L$"!" +" !" ,(*!$%$%# !3%

(,(##0*, % *% + -"*!'( ,(*,#"$% +% %$3%&'( +( 3+ , 5# (6 ( @3"!$ (*%-"*$( !"

(14)

+" "@3 1D2# ( "*$#" (! )(+"#"!8 (#H-6 7%9 !" *","!!5# ( %-"%1A%# -% (#"! "!,1%#", -"*$(! !(2#" % %$ 4 +%+" )(1D$ ,% +( !$%+(6 1%*&%*+( -'( +" ,(*,")&G"!

$"L# ,%! ,(-( ( )#(,"+ -"*$%1 !-(8 )# *,D) ( -%C(# $5# ( $%-2H- H

7#"@J"*$"-"*$" #"7"# +( "- !3% #"1%&'( ,(- % +H % +" +"-(,#%, %6 *3-% $"*$%$ 4% +" !" "*$"*+"# -"1A(# ( ,(*," $( +" /(4"#*( " +" ,(-( *"1" !" *!"#" ( (+"#

3+ , 5# (8

7 *%16 ( %$ 4 !-( C3+ , %1 "4(,% % ,(-)#""*!'( +" 3- 3+ , 5# (

*!"# +( *( ,(*$".$( +" %$3%&'( +( !$%+( #"%1 9%*+( 3-% %$ 4 +%+" )(1D$ ,%6

!3#/ *+(6 +%D6 7(#$"! @3"!$ (*%-"*$(! #"1%, (*%+(! % %!)",$(! +" 1"/ $ - +%+"8 %!6

)(# (3$#( 1%+(6 )#(,3#% !" ,%)$%# !32!D+ (! @3" 1"4"- %( "*$"*+ -"*$( +" @3" H

)1%3!D4"1 !" ,(/ $%# +% ". !$0*, % +" 3-% #"!)(*!%2 1 +%+" +( 3+ , 5# ( *%

(15)

8 [

*+32 $%4"1-"*$"6 3- +(! -%#,(! +% "4(13&'( +( )"*!%-"*$(

(, +"*$%1 H % +H % +" ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 !-(8 " 7%$(6 "!$" H 3- 7"*K-"*( A !$L# ,(

"-,3C( *I,1"( #"! +" % *,%*!54"1 23!,% +( +"%1 +" 1 2"#+%+"6 ,%1,%+( *( #"!)" $(6 /%#%*$ % " )#"!"#4%&'( +" + #" $(! 73*+%-"*$% !8

*+ !!(, 54"1 +( #" $( (*!$ $3, (*%1 H % *(&'( +" !$%+(6 )( ! %!

#"/#%! 25! ,%! ,(*7(#-%+(#%! +( )"#7 1 "!$%$%16 ,(-( % )#"4 !'( +" #")%#$ &'( +( )(+"# )(1D$ ,( %$#%4H! +% +"7 * &'( +" ,(-)"$0*, %! " %$# 23 &'( +" 73*&G"! #"!

+"-$(+%! *% (*!$ $3 &'(8 ( "*$%*$(6 A(+ "#*%-"*$"6 % "!$#3$3#%&'( ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 +(

!$%+( 23!,% %$"*+"# % %$3%&'( +"!$" )"#%*$" *$"#"!!"! !(, % ! " *+ 4 +3% !6 )#"!$ / %*+( % +H % +% )#"4%10*, % +(! + #" $(! 73*+%-"*$% !6 ,3C% 7#3 &'( %,"!!D4"1

% $(+(! ,%#%,$"# 9% 3- !$%+( +"-(,#5$ ,( +" + #" $(8

"4(13&'( +( #" $( (*!$ $3, (*%1 !" +"3 *( %7' +" ,(*!%/#%&'(

+( +"5# ( 1 2"#%16 ,(*!32!$%*, %+( *% 13$% )"1% /%#%*$ % ,(*$#% 4 (1%&G"!6 )"1(

!$%+(6 +" + #" $(! 73*+%-"*$% !8 3 !"C%6 3- +(! ) 1%#"! +" $%1 "4(13&'( 7( %

1 - $%&'( +( )(+"# "!$%$%1 %( 1%+( +% /3%1-"*$" -)(#$%*$" )#"(,3)%&'( ,(- %

)"#-%*0*, % +% (*!$ $3 &'( ,(-( 2%!" !L1 +% +" 3- !$%+( +" #" $(6 )( ! !L

*3- ,(*$".$( %!! - H )(!!D4"1 -%/ *%# + #" $(! A3-%*(! 73*+%-"*$% ! /%#%*$ +(! " "7"$ 4%+(!R8

( "*$%*$(6 % )#"(,3)%&'( +" "!$3+ (!(! / #% "- $(#*( +% *+%/%&'( !(2#" @3%1 % 7(#-% "- @3" +"4" (,(##"# % $3$"1% +" + #" $(! A3-%*(!

73*+%-"*$% ! *( *$3 $( +" )#() , %# 1A"! "7"$ 4 +%+"8 .!3#/" +%D % )#"(,3)%&'(

1

#(78 Y 11 ! 3"##% 1A( 1"-2#% ,(- )"#$ *0*, % @3" W!!!

$ & '

$ $

! ( "

) #

# #

(16)

,(- +H %! ,(-( % !3)#"-%, % ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 "6 )(# ,(*!"/3 *$"6 ,(- % "1%2(#%&'( +" -",%* !-(! )#(,"!!3% ! +" 4 %2 1 9%&'( +% +"7"!% C3#D+ ,% +% (*!$ $3 &'(8

!13-2#% !" 3-% #"!)(!$% \@3"1% )#"(,3)%&'( %$#%4H! +(

)"*!%-"*$( +" 8 8 " #% +" *+#%+" 6 @3" 40 % ,(*,#"$ 9%&'( +% (*!$ $3 &'(6 *( @3" $%*/" %(! + #" $(! 73*+%-"*$% !6 +" +3%! -%*" #%! + !$ *$%!Q

!! -6 (! )#"," $(! #"1%$ 4(! %(! + #" $(!6 1 2"#+%+"! " /%#%*$ %! !'(6 $ ) ,%-"*$" " "- #"/#%6 )#"," $(! + #"$%-"*$" %)1 ,54" !6 @3" )(+"-" +)(+"-"4)(+"-"- !)(+"-"# (2C)(+"-"$( +)(+"-" 3-% # $ " Q ( !"3 ,(*$"I+( H !3!,"$D4"1 +" ,(*,#"$ 9%&'( %( *D4"1 ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 "6 )(#$%*$(6 H %,"!!D4"1 \ C3# !)#3+0*, % +( # 23*%1 (*!$ $3, (*%18

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

2!"#4% !" +( %, -% $#%*!,# $( (! )(*$(! +" + !,3!!'( "*7%$ 9%+(! @3%*+( !" %2(#+% % C3# !+ &'( ,(*!$ $3, (*%16 $% ! ,(-( % +"-(,#%, %6 ( )# *,D) ( +% -% (# %6 % A"#-"*03$ ,% ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 "6 ,1%#(6 ( !"*!D4"1 $"-% +% 1"/ $ - +%+" +"!!" $ )( +" C3# !+ &'(6 *($%+%-"*$" @3%*+( ! $3%+( *% + !,3!!'( !(2#" ( )# *,D) (

+% !")%#%&'( +" )(+"#"!8 )%#$ # +% ,%$"/(# 9%&'( +(! + #" $(!6 $#%&(3 !"

-)1 ,%&G"! + 7"#"*, %+%! @3%*$( \! 4 %! +" ,(*,#"$ 9%&'( +( @3" "!$5 ,(*! /*%+(

*( $".$( ,(*!$ $3, (*%18 ! + #" $(! !(, % ! ". / # %-6 !"/3*+( % $"!"6 3-% )(!$3#%

-% ! -(+"#%+% +(! # 23*% !6 C5 @3" "!$%# %- "- 7(,( ()&G"! )(1D$ ,%! ,3C( 1" $(

*%$3#%1 +" +"7 * &'( !"# % ( "/ !1%$ 4(6 %)( %+( *( )# *,D) ( +% -% (# % " *%

1"/ $ - +%+" +" !"3 )(+"#8 %2(#+%/"- %*$"40 % + !,3!!'( @3" !" $#%&%#5 %+ %*$"

#(7"!!(# +% %,31+%+" +" #" $( +% * 4"#! +%+" +" ( -2#%8

;

6 8 8 " #% +"8 + $ , - 6 *

+ + $ $ , > (1L@3 ( +( R _ %* 4"#!5# ( +( # 23*%1

(*!$ $3, (*%1?6 ( -2#% "+ $(#%6 R<<T6 )8 6 %)3+ E 6 %31(6 ,

. / . , 0

(17)

%,"#,% +( 7"*K-"*( +% C3+ , %1 9%&'( +% )(1D$ ,% "6 %$#"1%+( % "!$"6 +( %$ 4 !-(

C3+ , %18 C3+ , %1 9%&'( +% )(1D$ ,% !"#5 "!$3+%+% *( 2(C( +%! #"1%&G"! "*$#" %!

,A%-%+%! *!$ $3 &G"! -%C(# $5# %!6 "!$%! +( #%-( )(1D$ ,( > "/ !1%$ 4( " .",3$ 4(?6

" ( (+"# 3+ , 5# (6 *%@3"1"! *!$%*$"! "- @3" %! ,(*+ &G"! +" ,(*7 /3#%&'( *!$ $3, (*%1 )#(4(,%- % ,%*%1 9%&'( +%! + !,3!!G"!6 * , %1-"*$" -%/ *%+%! ,(-( +" *%$3#"9% )#L)# % +(! )#(,"!!(! -%C(# $5# (! +" +", !G"!6 )%#% ( 3+ , 5# (6 ,3C(! 4%1(#"! " )(! , (*%-"*$(! )(1D$ ,(!6 ,(-2 *%+( ,(- 3-% %$ $3+" %$ 4 !$%6 1"4%- *( % +", + # !(2#" % *","!! +%+" (3 *'( +" !" -%* 7"!$%# % #"!)" $( +" $% ! + !,3!!G"! +" *$"#"!!" +% !(, "+%+" "- /"#%18

(#$%*$(6 ,(-( %+39 ( "- *"*$" -"!$#" %31( E(*%4 +"!6 %

C3# !+ &'( ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 ,#"!," "- #"1"4M*, % ,(-( *!$#3-"*$( +" %7 %*&%-"*$( C3#D+ ,( +% 7(#&% 1"/ $ -%+(#% +%! *!$ $3 &G"!6 $(#*%*+( !" )#"- !!% +" 3-%

+"-(,#%, % C3#D+ ,% ,(- 1"/ $ - +%+"U8 ,(*7 #-% !"3 "*! *%-"*$( "- $%1

(#" #%6 @3" %!!"4"#%Q

". !$0*, % +" 3-% C3# !+ &'( ,(*!$ $3, (*%16 !(2#"$3+( !" ,(*7 %+% % 3- $# 23*%1 "!)",D7 ,(6 )%#"," $"# !" $(#*%+( *(! $"-)(! +" A(C" *3- #"@3 ! $( +" 1"/ $ -%&'( " +" ,#"+ 2 1 +%+" )(1D$ ,% +(! #"/ -"! ,(*!$ $3, (*% ! +"-(,#5$ ,(!8 C3# !+ &'( ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 )%!!(3 % !"# ,#"!,"*$"-"*$" ,(*! +"#%+% ,(-( "1"-"*$( *","!!5# ( +% )#L)# % +"7 * &'( +( !$%+( +" + #" $( +"-(,#5$ ,(8T

-)"*+"6 )( !6 !"C% 7" $( ( ".%-" +%@3 1( @3" !" ,(*A"," ,(-( %$ 4 !-( C3+ , %16 7"*K-"*( @3" !" %*%1 !%#5 ,(-( 4 *,31%+( %( "."#,D, ( +% C3# !+ &'( ,(*!$ $3, (*%16 %$#%4H! +% @3%1 !" 23!,%6 !(2#"$3+(6 % )#($"&'(6 )#"!"#4%&'( " "7"$ 4%&'( +" + #" $(! 73*+%-"*$% !8 ","!!5# (6 )( !6 !"#5

)#(!)",$%# ,(-( ( (+"# 3+ , 5# (6 *( - !$"# #"$#( -"*, (*%+(6 )(+" %$3%#

U

28 $86 )8 RRZ8

T

6 $%18 - , / + +

$ , 6 * + + $ $ , > (1L@3 ( +( R _

%* 4"#!5# ( +( # 23*%1 (*!$ $3, (*%1?6 ( -2#% "+ $(#%6 R<<T6 )8 RZZ6 %)3+ E 6 %31(6

, . / . ,

(18)

$#%*!)(# (! 1 - $"! *(! @3% ! #"!$%- %!!"/3#%+(! ( "@3 1D2# ( " % A%#-(* % "*$#" (! )(+"#"! "!$%$% !8

C3# !+ &'( ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 H "."#, +% %$#%4H! +" -",%* !-(! @3"

,(*!$ $3"- ( ,A%-%+( #" $( #(,"!!3%1 (*!$ $3, (*%16 ,3C(! $"-%! $D) ,(! !"# %-Q

% (#/%* 9%&'( +% "!$#3$3#% C3+ , %16 ,(- % + !$# 23 &'( +" ,(-)"$0*, % +(! + 4"#!(!

L#/'(! +% C3# !+ &'(S (! )# *,D) (! /"#% ! +( )#(,"!!( ,(*!%/#%+(! *% (*!$ $3 &'(

" %! %&G"! ,(*!$ $3, (*% ! +"!$ *%+%! % #"!/3%#+%# % *$"/# +%+" " -)1"-"*$%# (

)#L)# ( (#+"*%-"*$( ,(*!$ $3, (*%1V8 3 !"C%Q 1

' $ , $

" $ 8Z

7"*K-"*( +( %$ 4 !-( C3+ , %16 )(#$%*$(6 #"@3"#6 +"*$#" (3$#(! %!)",$(! #"1"4%*$"!6 % ,(-)#""*!'( +% C3# !+ &'( ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 " +% 7(#-% )"1% @3%1 "1% !" #"%1 9%6 *($%+%-"*$" % )%#$ # +( "*$"*+ -"*$( +"!$% ,(-( 3-% %$ 4 +%+" "!$%$%1 ,3C% - !!'( )#",D)3% H +"!1 *+%# ,(*$#(4H#! %! +" #")"#,3!!'( ,(*!$ $3, (*%1

#"1%, (*%+%! \ #"%1 9%&'( +" + #" $(! 73*+%-"*$% !8 3+( $"*+( ,(-( 2%!"6

"4 +"*$"-"*$"6 % ,(*,")&'( +" (*!$ $3 &'( ,(-( )#(4"+(#% +" + #" $(! " +" *!$#3-"*$(! ,(- (! @3% ! A%2 1 $% % !(, "+%+" )%#% % )#"!"#4%&'( +( %!)",$( )13#%1 @3" $(+% !(, "+%+" /"*3 *%-"*$" +"-(,#5$ ,% %)#"!"*$%8

*$#"$%*$(6 H 7(#&(!( !%1 "*$%# *"!$" -(-"*$( @3" ( %$ 4 !-( H 7"*K-"*( -% ! #",(##"*$"6 ,(-( (2C"$( +" + !,3!!'( " "!$3+(6 "- $#%+ &G"!

C3#D+ ,%! +% %8 %!6 *'( A5 *"/%# ( !3#/ -"*$( +" 3- @3"!$ (*%-"*$(

+" %2#%*/0*, % /1(2%1 !(2#" (3$#( 7"*K-"*( ,(##"1%$(6 4 !$( ,(-( 3- +(! /#%*+"! +"!%7 (! +( + #" $( -(+"#*(6 @3%1 !"C%6 % ".)%*!'( -3*+ %1 +% %$3%&'( +( C3+ , 5# ( *%! @3"!$G"! %$3% ! -% ! )#"-"*$"!6 1 /%+%! % )# *,D) (! 3* 4"#!% ! ,(-( (! @3"

!32C%9"- (! + #" $(! A3-%*(!8 !! -6 ( "!$3+( !(2#" ( %$ 4 !-( C3+ , %1 !" #"4"!$"

+% *%$3#"9% +" 3- + #" $( ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 ,(-)%#%+(6 ,(- (! ,3 +%+(! @3" $%1 "!$3+(

6

P 6 Y 11 ! %*$ %/(8 , . 2 8 ^ +8 '(

%31(Q "1!( E%!$(!6 R8 )8R; RU8

Z

6 -"#!(*8, 0 , 8 ( +" %*" #(Q I-"* I# !6 8 )8

(19)

#"@3"#8 ( !6 ( @3" !" $"*$%#5 +"*$ 7 ,%# !'( ,%#%,$"#D!$ ,%! ,(-3*! +% %$3%&'( +( 3+ , 5# ( )"#%*$" (! +"!%7 (! %$3% ! " ,%+% 4"9 -% ! ,(-)1".(! +% !(, "+%+"

-(+"#*%8 "!!" ,(*$".$(6 %! +"-(,#%, %! (, +"*$% ! %)#"!"*$%- 3-% "4(13&'(

,(*!$ $3, (*%1 ! - 1%#6 *'( A%4"*+( *(4 +%+"6 )(# "."-)1(6 *% *7130*, % +% $#%+ &'( C3#D+ ,% +" 3*! )%D!"! !(2#" (3$#(!6 *($%+%-"*$" +%@3"1"! @3" +"$ 4"#%- "6 +" ,"#$% 7(#-%6 % *+% +"$0- ( +(-D* ( "- !3%! -% ! 4%# %+%! 7(#-%! >,31$3#%16 ",(*K- ,% "$,8? "- 2(% )%#$" +( -3*+(8

(# !$(6 )%#"," !%1$%# %(! (1A(! +" %1/3*! "!$3+ (!(! ( 7%$( +" ( 3+ , 5# ( /1(2%1-"*$" ,%+% 4"9 -% ! )#(,3#%# -%#,%# !"3 "!)%&( ,(-( ,(*$#(1%+(# +%! %$ 4 +%+"! /(4"#*%-"*$% ! +" 7(#-31%&'( +" )(1D$ ,%! )I21 ,%!6 *!"# *+( !" ,(-( /3%#+ '( +(! *$"#"!!"! !(, % ! ,(*!$ $3, (*%1-"*$" %!!"/3#%+(!6 " 7 #-%*+( !" ,(-( ,(-)(*"*$" "!!"*, %1 *% !(1 + 7 ,%&'( +( "!)%&( +"-(,#5$ ,( *( @3%1 %$3%8 3-% +%! -%* 7"!$%&G"! +( 7"*K-"*( @3" 4"- #","2"*+( ( ")D$"$( +"

" # $ 8 %$ 4 !-( C3+ , %16 +"!$%#$"6 !"#5 "!$3+%+( ,(-(

3-7"*K-"*( +" *$"#%&'( 2%!"%+% *( )# *,D) ( +% !")%#%&'( +(! )(+"#"!6 "!$#3$3#% ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 1%#/%-"*$" %+($%+% *( (, +"*$"8

8R 3# !+ &'( (*!$ $3, (*%1 " !$%+( "-(,#5$ ,( +" #" $(

%#% "*$"*+"#-(! ,(- -% ! %,3 +%+" % @3"!$'( )(!$% "-+ !,3!!'( *( )#"!"*$" $#%2%1A(6 3#/" @3" $#%,"-(! 3- "!,(#&( "-+(! ,(*71 $(!

*!$ $3, (*% ! %$ *"*$"! \ +H % +" +"-(,#%, % ,(-( 73*+%-"*$( +" 3- !$%+(

"-(,#5$ ,( +" #" $(6 !"/3*+( %! 2%1 9%! 7 *,%+%! *% (*!$ $3 &'(8 % ! ,(*71 $(!

!3#/"- @3%*+( !" %1-"C% +"-%#,%#6 ( -% ! (2C"$ 4%-"*$" )(!!D4"16 %! 73*&G"! +(! )(+"#"! )(1D$ ,(! @3" ,(*,#"$ 9%- % %$3%&'( "!$%$%1 "- "!)%&( ,(*!(*%*$" ,(- ( +"%1 +"-(,#5$ ,(8

(20)

*% -"+ +% "- @3" ". /" % ,(-)#""*!'( %,3#%+% +" @3%1 % #"%1 + -"*!'( +%

%$3%&'( +( 3+ , 5# ( *3-% "!$#3$3#% +" (#/%* 9%&'( !(, %1 " )(1D$ ,% 7 *,%+%

"-2%!"! +"-(,#5$ ,%!8

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

- %!)",$( -)(#$%*$" % !"# )(*$3%+( *"!!" ,%-)( +" +H %! H % ,(##"1%&'( "*$#" +"-(,#%, % " ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 !-(6 % @3%1 "4(,% 3- !"*$ -"*$( +" ,(-)1"-"*$%# +%+" @3" ". /" *% )#5$ ,% % ,(*!$#3&'( +" 3- %#,%2(3&( )(1D$ ,( *!$ $3, (*%1 @3" "1 - *" )(*$(! +" %$# $( " )"#- $% 3-% ! *"#/ % @3" "7"$ 4" (! +"% !

+" 3-% !(, "+%+" C3!$% " /3%1 $5# %8 "/3*+( !,%# 1A"*% 6 % +"-(,#%, % !"

)#"(,3)% "- + !,3$ # ( 73*+%-"*$( " ( "."#,D, ( +( )(+"# )"1( )(4(6 #"%1 9%*+( % 4(*$%+" +"-(,#5$ ,% %$#%4H! +% #"/#% +% -% (# %6 %( )%!!( @3" ( ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 !-( -(+"#*( !" )#"(,3)% ,(- (! 1 - $"! +( )(+"#6 "."#, +( )(# @3"- @3"# @3" !"C%6 3$ 1 9%*+( )%#% $%*$( %! +H %! +" !")%#%&'( +(! )(+"#"! " 3-% ,%#$% +" + #" $(!8 #"/#% +% -% (# % (,3)% )(! &'( +" +"!$%@3" *( ,(*$".$( "- @3" ( )#(,"!!( +" 7(#-%&'( +% 4(*$%+" )(1D$ ,% H #"%1 9%+( )(# $(+(! (! , +%+'(! "- ,(*+ &'( +"

/3%1+%+" "- 4%1(#8 #"/#% +% -% (# %6 "*$#"$%*$(6 *'( H %2!(13$%6 )( ! *"- !"-)#"

,(*+39 %(! #"!31$%+(! ,(1 -%+(! )"1( 2"- ,(-3- "6 *,13! 4"6 )(+" )K# "- # !,(

(! )#L)# (! ) 1%#"! +( +"%1 +"-(,#5$ ,(8 (#$%*$(Q

%D % )"#,")&'( @3%!" A"/"-K* ,% *(! + %! +" A(C"6 +" @3" *'( !" )(+" $"# +"-(,#%, % !"- )#"!!3)(# 3- ,(*C3*$( +" + #" $(! ,%)%9"! +" %!!"/3#%# 3-% "!7"#% H$ ,% +" #"%1 9%&'( +% /3%1+%+" " +% + /* +%+"8 (/(6 @3" (! #"!31$%+(! +% #"/#% +% -% (# %

6 !,%# 1A"*%83 2 4 8 ^ "+8 '( %31(Q

(21)

)%!!%# )(# 3- $"!$" +" ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 +%+" )%#% @3" *'( %-"%,"-(! + #" $%-"%,"-(! 73*+%-"*$% !6 %-"%,"-(! -",%* !-%-"%,"-(! @3" %!!"/3#"- "!$"! + #" $(!6 2"- ,(-( (! )#L)# (! )#(,"+ -"*$(! @3" 4 %2 1 9%- % ,(*$ *3 +%+" +% +"-(,#%, %8 !$% % 73*&'( "!!"*, %1 +( ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 !-(6 %!!"/3#%# (! )#"!!3)(!$(! H$ ,(! +% +"-(,#%, %8<

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

"!$%#$"Q

]3%*$( -% ! )#"4%1","# % #"/#% +% -% (# % ,(-( 7(*$" +" ".)#"!!'( +% 4(*$%+" )(1D$ ,%6 -"*(#"! !"#'( %! %$# 23 &G"! +" 3- $# 23*%1 +" ,%#5$"# ,(*!$ $3, (*%18 - !"*$ +( *4"#!(6 @3%*$( -% (# 7(# ( #(1 +" )# *,D) (! " + #" $(! ,(1(,%+(! )"1% (*!$ $3 &'( % !%14( +%! +", !G"! -%C(# $5# %!6 -% ! %-)1%! !"#'( %! %$# 23 &G"! +" 3- $# 23*%1 ,(*!$ $3, (*%1S )(!$%*+( !"6 *"!$" ,%!(6 ,(-( 3-% *!$ $3 &'( )#", )3%-"*$" %*$ -%C(# $5# %8R

*$ -%C(# $5# %6 ".)1 ,% 1A"*%RR6 *'( ! /* 7 ,% *","!!%# %-"*$"

%*$ +"-(,#5$ ,%6 ,(*! +"#%*+( !" +"-(,#%, % "- !"*$ +( -% ! %-)1( "6 $%-2H-6 % %$3%&'( +% ,(#$" 1 - $%+% \ -%*3$"*&'( +% )#L)# % +"-(,#%, % " /%#%*$ % +(! + #" $(! "!!"*, % ! \ )%#$ , )%&'( )(1D$ ,% 1 4#" " /3%1 $5# %8 *"!$% )"#!)",$ 4% @3" !"#5 !(*+%+% % -%*" #% ,(-( !" +5 ( 7"*K-"*( +( %$ 4 !-( C3+ , %16 )( ! "!!" $"#-( !3!, $% *$"#)#"$%&G"! @3" $"*+"- % @3%1 7 ,%# % %$3%&'( +( 3+ , 5# ( ,(-(

+"!1"/ $ -%+% "6 )(# !$( -"!-(6 *%+"@3%+% *% "!$#3$3#% +"-(,#5$ ,%

,(*!$ $3, (*%1-"*$" $#%&%+%8 @3" !" $"*$%#5 "13, +%#6 )(#$%*$(6 H !" % %$3%&'( +%!

<

+8 )8 V.

10

Ibid. p. 27

11

(22)

,(#$"! ,(*!$ $3, (*% !6 *% 7(#-% )#",(* 9%+% %, -% )(# 1A"*%6 !" ,(*!$ $3 *3-,# $H# ( )%#% %4%1 %# % 7(#-% +" %$ 4 !-( !3)(#$54"1 *3-% +"-(*3-,#%, % ,(*!$ $3, (*%18

'( !" +"4" (14 +%# *"!!" ,(*$".$( @3" (! $# 23*% ! ,(*!$ $3, (*% ! "*,(*$#%- ( !"3 " .( +" %$3%&'( *( ,(*$#(1" +% A / +"9 +( (#+"*%-"*$( C3#D+ ,( +" %,(#+( ,(- (! 4%1(#"! " + #"$ 4%! *!,31) +%! *( ,(*C3*$( +" *(#-%! 73*+%-"*$% !

+% (*!$ $3 &'(8 '(6 % )#()L! $(6 "!!"! 4%1(#"! @3" (! $# 23*% !6 *( "."#,D, ( +%

C3# !+ &'( ,(*!$ $3, (*%16 ".$#% #'( +% (*!$ $3 &'( )%#% %7"# # % %+"@3%&'( +%!

*(#-%! *7"# (#"! @3" *$"/#%- ( (#+"*%-"*$( C3#D+ ,(8 H ".%$%-"*$" *"!!" )(*$( @3" !" $#%4% ( +"2%$" %,"#,% +" 3- !3)(!$( %$ 4 !-(6 *% -"+ +% "- @3" !" ,(*! +"#% % )#"##(/%$ 4% +(! $# 23*% ! ,(*!$ $3, (*% ! 3- !%14( ,(*+3$( )%#% !" - !,3 # *%! 5#"%! %1A" %! \ !3% ,(-)"$0*, %8 "!!" !"*$ +( H ( "*$"*+ -"*$( +"

-"#!(* %#, %Q

'( H )(# (3$#% #%9'( @3" % @3"!$'( +( ".,"!! 4( )(+"# +(! L#/'(! C3# !+ , (*% ! *"4 $%4"1-"*$" #"$(#*% \ (#+"- +( + %6 ( @3" ,(!$3-% (,(##"# !"-)#" @3" ( # 23*%1 (*!$ $3, (*%1 $#%*! $% +% %3$(,(*$"*&'( > ? )%#% 3-% )(!$3#% %$ 4 !$% > ?6 %4%*&%*+( "- -%$H# %! @3"6 $"(# ,%-"*$"6 )(+"# %- !"# "*@3%+#%+%! !(2 % ")D/#%7" +% 1 2"#+%+" )(1D$ ,% +(! L#/'(!

"/ !1%$ 4(! " %+- * !$#%$ 4(!8R

P5 @3" !" (2!"#4%# *% ,(*! +"#%&'( +( $"-% 3-% + #"$# 9 -% (#

,(*!32!$%*, %+% *% ,A%-%+% 5 +" 3-% (*!$ $3 &'(6 ,(*! !$"*$" *%

".)#"!!'( +"(1L/ ,% @3" (#/%* 9% % ,(*4 40*, % )(1D$ ,% "- 3-% "!$#3$3#% !(, %1R;6

!"#4 *+( +" 4"$(# +" (# "*$%&'( )%#% *$"#)#"$%&'( +%! *(#-%! ,(*!$ $3, (*% !8 6

)( !6 3- )#(/#%-% +" %&'( )%#$ 1A%+( )(# $(+( *$"/#%*$" +% ,(-3* +%+" )(1D$ ,%RU8

"!)(*$% + !!(6 ,(-( *7"#0*, % 1L/ ,%6 % -)(#$M*, % ,%) $%1 +( )#(,"!!( ,(*!$ $3, (*%16 ,(-( )#(,"+ -"*$( C3# !+ , (*%16 *% + *M- ,% ,(*!$#3&'( +(

12

Ob. Cit. p. 106.

13

6 %21( 3,%!6, . 6 4(18 6 %+# Q ",*(!6 R<ZZ6 )8 T; 6 %)3+ P 6

Y 11 ! %*$ %/( 3"##%6 (28 , $86 )8 8

14

(23)

!$%+( "-(,#5$ ,( +" #" $( "- ,(*7(#- +%+" ,(- 3-% 5 8 "!$"

!"*$ +(6 %!!"4"#% ,(- )#()# "+%+" ( #(78 Y 11 ! 3"##% 1A(Q

(!!% ,(-)#""*!'( +( @3%*$( ( !$%+( "-(,#5$ ,( +" #" $( +")"*+" +" 6 *'( !L "/ !1%$ 4(! " "1" $(#% !6 -%! "!)", %1-"*$" %@3"1"! C3+ , % !6 )%#% @3" !" +0 !3% #"%1 9%&'(6 %3-"*$% *% -"+ +% "-@3" )#", !"-(! -"1A(# ( ,(*$"I+( +"!!% 7L#-31% )(1D$ ,%8RT >/# 7( +( (# / *%1?

!! -6 *( !"*$ # +"!!" #"*(-%+( C3# !$%6 ( !$%+( "-(,#5$ ,(

$"-3- ,(-)#(- !!( 25! ,( +" A%#-(* 9%# *$"#"!!"! ! $3%+(! "- $#0! "!7"#%!6 % !%2"#Q

? * *% @3%1 !" ! $3% ( !$%+(S ? *% @3%1 !" 1(,%1 9% (

*+ 4D+3( " ? @3" ,(*!$ $3 # % 3- 21(,( *$"#-"+ 5# ( "- @3" (!

*+ 4D+3(! -%*"C%- *$"#"!!"! "*@3%*$( -"-2#(! +" /#3)(! !(, % !6 @3" 23!,%-(2C"$ 4(! ,(-3*! +" 45# (! -%$ 9"!RV8

( "."#,D, ( +" %!! - 1%&'( +% *(&'( +" !$%+( "-(,#5$ ,( +"

#" $(6 %7 /3#% !" #"%1&%+( ( )%)"1 +" 3-% C3# !+ &'( ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 @3" /#%+%$ 4%-"*$" !" ,(*!(1 +% ,(-( ,"*$#( +" +", !G"! )(1 $ ,%-"*$" #"1"4%*$"!6 $"*+"*+( % )#"4%1","#6 ,(-( $%16 !(2#" ( .",3$ 4( " ( "/ !1%$ 4(8 6 *"!!" ,(*$".$(6 ( )#(,"!!( ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 !" *($%2 1 9% ,(-( W888 *!$#3-"*$( )# 4 1"/ %+(

+" $ ' XRZ6 ,3C( -%*3!" (

*","!! $% +" 3-% *!$ $3 &'( \ %1$3#%6 *% -(1+3#% +" 3- !$%+( "-(,#5$ ,( +"

#" $(6 @3" )%#% ( #(78 Y 11 ! 1A( H %Q

888 (#$" (*!$ $3, (*%16 "*@3%*$( L#/'( + 7"#"*, %+( +% "!$#3$3#% +( C3+ , 5# ( " )1"*%-"*$" *+")"*+"*$" $%-2H- 7#"*$" %(! +"-% ! )(+"#"! "!$%$% !6 *$"/#%+( )(# -"-2#(! ,(- %! -"1A(#"! @3%1 7 ,%&G"! )%#% "."#,"# $ 5

15

+"-6 )8 U8

RV

+"-6 )8 T

17

(24)

" # $ ' + 8 >/# 7(! *". !$"*$"! *( (# / *%1?8

3- !$%+( "-(,#5$ ,( +" #" $( )3131%- ,(*$#(4H#! %!

#"1%, (*%+%! \ ,(*@3 !$%6 \ -%*3$"*&'(6 \ + !$# 23 &'( " %( 3!( +( )(+"# )(1D$ ,( *(

!" ( +% !(, "+%+"8 % ! ,(*$#(4H#! %! !'(6 )(# !!( -"!-(6 )(1D$ ,%! "

%!!3-"-,%#5$"# ,(*!$ $3, (*%16 A%C% 4 !$% $#%$%#"- +" 4 (1%&G"! +" 1 - $"!6 )"1(! $ $31%#"! +%@3"1" )(+"#6 +"1 *"%+(! *% (*!$ $3 &'( %( !"3 "."#,D, (R<8

!$%2"1"," !"6 )( !6 % *","!! +%+" +" 3- "!@3"-% +" "@3 1D2# ( " A%#-(* % "*$#" )(+"#"! ,(*!$ $3, (*%1-"*$" *!$ $3D+(!6 +" $%1 !(#$" @3" *"*A3-+"1"! !"C% "."#, +( !"- 1 - $"!8 - "!@3"-% %!! - H ,%#%,$"#D!$ ,( +" 3- !$%+( +" #" $( "- @3" $(+% 7(#-% +" )(+"# "!$5 !32-"$ +% *,(*+ , (*%1-"*$" \ " 8

(*!$ $3 &'(6 )( !6 !" "# /" ,(-( !32!$#%$( +%! + !,3!!G"! #"7"#"*$"! %( "."#,D, ( +( )(+"# )(1D$ ,(8 6 "- 73*&'( + !!(6 %!!(-% !" *%##"+54"1 % ,# %&'( +" -",%* !-(! C3#D+ ,( )#(,"!!3% ! +"!$ *%+(! % +"71%/#%# )#(,"+ -"*$(! +" )#(7 1%. % ,(*$#% 4 (1%&G"! +" ,(-%*+(! +% *(#-% ,(*!$ $3, (*%16 /%#%*$ *+( !3%

"7"$ 4 +%+" "- )#(1 +% ,(*!(1 +%&'( +( !$%+( "-(,#5$ ,( +" #" $(8 3 !"C%6

-)G" !" % +"7"!% +% (*!$ $3 &'( ,(-( ,%#$% +" 4%1(#"! @3" 7 .% 1 - $"! C3#D+ ,(! %( "."#,D, ( +( )(+"# ,(-( 7(#-% +" )#($"&'( +"1% -"!-%8

-%*"C( +(! -",%* !-(! !3)#%-"*, (*%+(! )#"!!3)G" %

". !$0*, % +" 3-% C3# !+ &'( ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 "*,%##"/%+% +" + # - # ,(*71 $(! %$ *"*$"!

\ %)1 ,%&'( +(! )#"," $(! ,(*!$ $3, (*% !8 C3# !+ &'( ,(*!$ $3, (*%16 "*$#"$%*$(6

"*,(*$#% ()(! $(#"!6 @3" 73*+%-"*$%- !3% +"!%)#(4%&'( % "!!" -" ( +" ,(*$#(1" +( "."#,D, ( +(! )(+"#"! )(1D$ ,(! +" 7(#-%! 4%# %+%!8

-% ,#D$ ,%6 +" ,3*A( ,(*!"#4%+(#6 @3"!$ (*% % )(!! 2 1 +%+" +" #"!(13&'( +" ,(*71 $(! ,(*!$ $3, (*% !6 @3" )(# !"#"- ,(*!$ $3, (*% ! /3%#+%-*%$3#"9% )(1D$ ,%6 3$ 1 9%*+( ,# $H# (! " -H$(+(! )#L)# (! +% %$ 4 +%+" C3# !+ , (*%18

18

+"-6 )8 V8

19

6 32H* P"#*5*+"98. , 18 R^ +8 %* (!H6 (!$% ,%Q + $(# %1

(25)

"3 -% (# +"7"*!(#6 %#1 ,A- $$6 ,(*! +"#% % C3# !+ &'( ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 3-%

,(*$#%+ &'( "- !"3! )#L)# (! $"#-(!6 )( ! "1% 1"4%# % % 3-% " # $

" % 3-% # $ " $ 8 !! -6 )%#% ( C3# !$% %1"-'(6 % +"7"!% +%

(*!$ $3 &'( +"4" !"# %$# 23 &'( +" 3- L#/'( +" ,%#5$"# )(1D$ ,( " *'( C3# !+ , (*%16 )( ! % +"$"#- *%&'( +( ,(*$"I+( +" 3- )#"," $( ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 H -%$H# % +" 1"/ !1%&'( " *'( +" C3!$ &% 8

3$#% ,# $ ,% !" 73*+%-"*$% *% ,(*4 ,&'( +" @3" !(-"*$" ( )%#1%-"*$( H +($%+( +" 1"/ $ - +%+" +"-(,#5$ ,%6 )( ! #")#"!"*$% % 4(*$%+" +(

)(4(8 !! -6 ( @3"!$ (*%-"*$( H !(2#" @3%1 !"# % % 7(*$" +" )(+"# )(1D$ ,( +(!

$# 23*% ! ,(*!$ $3, (*% ! " @3%1 !3% 1"/ $ - +%+"8 % 4 !'( +" 32H* %11" "!!"!

$# 23*% ! )#%$ ,%- 3- )(+"# +" #"4 !'( +% (*!$ $3 &'( @3" 1A"! )"#- $" ,# %# *(4(!

)#"," $(! @3" !"@3"# 7(#%- -%/ *%+(! )"1(! ,(*!$ $3 *$"! (# / *% !R8

P56 % *+%6 % ,#D$ ,% #"1"4%*$" +" @3" % C3# !+ &'( ,(*!$ $3, (*%1

*$#(+39 3-% %$ 4 +%+" @3" !" #"4"1% ,(-( 3- %3$0*$ ,( W " # X6 ( @3%1

!"# % +"!)#(4 +( +" 1"/ $ - +%+"6 #"!)(*!%2 1 +%+" " *'( !"# % ,%)%9 +" %$"*+"# %! +"-%*+%! +%! !(, "+%+"! %$3% !8

"!$% 1 *A%6 % A !$L# % ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 %-"# ,%*% #"/ !$#% 3- ,%!(

"-21"-5$ ,( +" ,(*71 $( "*$#" ( .",3$ 4( " ( C3+ , 5# (6 )(# (,%! '( +( /(4"#*( +(

)#"! +"*$" 8 8 ((!"4"1$ @3"6 *% 23!,% +" 1"4%*$%# % ",(*(- % +" !"3 )%D!

"-,(1%)!( %)L! ( 7%-(!( 6+% 2(1!% +" (4% (#@3"6 "- R< <6 A%4 % *!$ $3D+(

3-)#(/#%-% +" #",3)"#%&'( ",(*K- ,% ,A%-%+( W0 % . X8 ((!"4"1$ ,(*!"/3 3

%)#(4%# 3- )%,($" +" 1" ! @3" 4 !%4% % 3- -"1A(# "@3 1D2# ( "*$#" % %/# ,31$3#%6 (

$#%2%1A( " % *+I!$# %8 ,(##" @3" !!( ,(*$#%# %4% %1/3*! *$"#"!!"! "- ,D#,31(!

)(+"#(!(! +" *"/L, (!6 @3" *'( A"! $%#%- "- %#/J #6 C3+ , %1-"*$"6 %

*,(*!$ $3, (*%1 +%+" +% *(4"1 1"/ !1%&'(8

20

+"-6 )8 ZR8

21

2 +"-6 )8 ZR8 ( (# / *%1Q W!!! ' " 7

% 8 5 , 5

(26)

3)#"-% (#$" 731- *(3 ( )#(/#%-% +",1%#%*+( *,(*!$ $3, (*% !

(! )# *, )% ! + )1(-%! 1"/% ! @3" ( !3!$"*$%4%-8 (#H-6 ( #"! +"*$"6 ,(- %)( ( +(

(*/#"!!(6 #"%/ 3 )#(*$%-"*$"6 ,(1(,%*+( "- ,3#!( (3$#( )%,($" +" 1" !6 +"!$% 7" $%

#"(#/%* 9%*+( ( (+"# 3+ , 5# (6 (2C"$ 4%*+( +%# *(4% 7" &'( \ (#$" %$#%4H! +"

*(-"%&'( +" *(4(! %1 *A%+(! ,(- % + #"$# 9 /(4"#*%-"*$%18 )#()(!$%

)#(4(,(3 7(#$" )(10- ,% *( )%D!6 )(#H-6 +"!"*,%+"(36 $%-2H-6 3-% #"4 #%4(1$% *%

C3# !)#3+0*, % +% 3)#"-% (#$"6 @3" )%!!(3 % +", + # ,%!(! +" -%*" #% %

,(*$"-)1%# *$"#"!!"! +( /(4"#*(6 ,(-( % ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 +%+" +% 1" +( !%15# (

-D* -( *( !$# $( +" (1I-2 % " +%! 1" ! +( "/3#( (, %16 %1H- +(

#",(*A", -"*$( +% 3*$% %, (*%1 +%! "1%&G"! #%2%1A !$%!8 (- "!$" #",3( +%

(#$" 3)#"-%6 ( ,(*/#"!!( %)#(4(3 $'( !(-"*$" 1" ! +" #"7(#-% +( ! !$"-%

)#(,"!!3%16 $"*+( ! +( #"C" $%+( ( )#(C"$( +" %3-"*$( +" 3D9"! +% 3)#"-% (#$"8

!! -6 !"/3*+( 0+% E(",A%$ (+# /3"!Q

"*,"#% !" /#%4D!! -% ,# !"6 $'( (3 -% ! /#%4" @3" % "*7#"*$%+% )"1% (#$" +" %#!A%11 *( /(4"#*( +" "77"#!(*8 (#% % ,(#$" (2# /%+% % #",3%#6 -%! $%-2H- ( #"! +"*$" !(7#"3 % )# -" #% +"##($% )(1D$ ,%6 ,(- % )"#+% +" 3*%* - +%+" +" !"3 )%#$ +(8 % ! 3-% 4"96 )(#H-6 )#(4%4% ( ! !$"-% ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 %-"# ,%*( % !3% 71". 2 1 +%+" " -%1"%2 1 +%+"6 % !3% !3)"# (# %+%)$%2 1 +%+" \! ". /0*, %! +% #"%1 +%+" )(1D$ ,%6 ",(*K- ,% " )! ,( !(, %18

(*#%+( "*+"! (2!"#4% @3" %! /#%*+"! +", !G"! +% 3)#"-%

(#$" %-"# ,%*%6 ,(*@3%*$( )(10- ,%! " +3#%-"*$" ,# $ ,%+%!6 7(#%- #"!)" $%+%! " ,3-)# +%!6 )#(4(,%*+( "- !"3! ()(! $(#"! % * , %$ 4% +" #"$(#*%#6 #"! /*%+(!6 \ %#"*% )(1D$ ,% )%#% % + !,3!!'( +(! $"-%! +", + +(! 23!,%*+(6 ,(- !!(6 % #"4 !'( *!$ $3, (*%1 +" $% ! +", !G"! ;8 .)1 ,% ( 3$(# @3" "!$" $ )( +" #"%&'( $%14"9 !" +"4% % 3-% -% (# #"4"#0*, % + !)"*!%+% \ +", !'( C3+ , %1 )"1% ,31$3#% C3#D+ ,% %-"# ,%*%6 73*+%-"*$%+% *( #"!)" $( \ !3% 73*+%&'( ,(*!$ $3, (*%16 *($%+%-"*$"6

22

6 0+% E(",A%$8 , 3 . , 8 ^ +8 (Q

4 1 9%&'( E#%! 1" #%6 R<< 8 )8 R 8

;

(27)

%,#"!,"*$(6 %( "."#,D, ( +% C3# !+ &'( ,(*!$ $3, (*%18 $%*+( ( ,%!( : ! ; <=

,(-( "."-)1(6 (*#%+( "*+"! %+396 )%#% %)( %# !3% %7 #-%&'(6 @3"Q

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

!$%+(! * +(!X6 2 3! 6 : R: ;?8 ", !G"! -% !

#","*$"!6 %)"!%# +" *'( $"#"- #"4(/%+( ( )#","+"*$" +" : ! ; 6 C5 ! *%1 9%- )%#% 3-% $"*+0*, % W-% ! ,(*!"#4%+(#%X +% 3)#"-% (#$"6 @3" %," $(3 % ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 +%+" +" *(4%! #"!$# &G"! %( %2(#$( >( "."-)1( #","*$" H % +", !'( "-> # !

, 6 +" ;?8T

0 !"6 )( !6 @3" /#%*+"! +"2%$"! ,(*!$ $3, (*% ! -(4 -"*$%- %

!(, "+%+" ,(-( #"!31$%+( +( $#%2%1A( +( 3+ , 5# ( *( "."#,D, ( +% C3# !+ &'(

,(*!$ $3, (*%16 7%9"*+( !" %4%1 %# ( #"%1 )%)"1 +(! # 23*% ! *( +"!"*A(

,(*!$ $3, (*%1 +( -(+"1( +"-(,#5$ ,(8 !$( )(#@3"6 *% %$3%&'( +( 3+ , 5# ( *%

#"!(13&'( +" ,(*71 $(!6 "*@3%*$( /3%#+ '( +% (*!$ $3 &'(6 "*$#% "- + !,3!!'( %

+"$"#- *%&'( +" 4%1(#"! ,%#(! \! )"!!(%! " \ !(, "+%+" "- /"#%16 (! @3% ! +'( 7(#-%$( % 3-% "!$#3$3#% !(, %1 " )(1D$ ,( *!$ $3, (*%1 ,(-( ,(#(15# ( +(! ,(*71 $(!

@3" "*,(*$#%- *( 3+ , 5# ( % *!$M*, % I1$ -% +" +"7 * &'(8 7%-(!( ,%!( : !

; 13!$#% 2"- "!!" 7"*K-"*(6 ,(*7(#-" %)#()# %+%-"*$" (2!"#4%+( )(# (*%1+

N(#F *Q

+", !'( @3" % 3)#"-% (#$" $(-(3 "- R<Z; *( ,%!( (" 48 Y%+"6 )"1% @3%1 %! -31A"#"! $0- ( + #" $( +" %2(#$%# *(! )# -" #(! +( ! $# -"!$#"! +" /#%4 +"96 )%#","3 %(! (1A(! +" -3 $(! C3# !$%! " *'( !(-"*$" %(! @3" !'( ,(*$#5# (! %( %2(#$( )(# -($ 4(! -(#% !

24

: ! ; 6 UR 8 8 RR; >R<Z;?8 ", !'( )"1% @3%1 % 3)#"-% (#$" %!!"/3#(3 \! -31A"#"! ( + #" $( +" %2(#$%# *(! )# -" #(! +( ! $# -"!$#"! +" /#%4 +"98

(28)

$"# +( 1(*/" +"-% ! *% 4 % +( /(4"#*( )"1( C3+ , 5# (8 (*!$ $3 &'( *'( + 9 *%+% +" ".)1 , $( !(2#" ( %2(#$( "6 "-2(#% ,"#$%! +", !G"! )%!!%+%! +% 3)#"-% (#$" "- )%#$ ,31%# % +", !'( +" @3" %! )"!!(%! $0- ( + #" $( +" 3!%# %*$ ,(*,"), (*% ! %)%#"*$"-"*$" $ 4"!!"- %1/3-% #"1%&'( ,(- ( %!!3*$(6 ( 7%$( H @3"6 *% () * '( +"!!"! C3# !$%!6 % (#$" *'( $ *A% ( + #" $( +" +", + # 3-% @3"!$'( !(, %1 " )(1D$ ,% $'( #"*A +% @3%*$( "#%6 *% H)(,%6 % @3"!$'( +( %2(#$(8 !!%! +I4 +%! %,"#,% +( ,(##"$( )%)"1 (,3)%+( )"1% 3)#"-% (#$" *( !$%+( 1(/( )%!!%#%- % 7%9"# )%#$" +( +"2%$" )I21 ,( /"*"#%1 9%+( !(2#" ( %2(#$(6 " %! )"!!(%!6 *"!!% ,(*$#(4H#! % @3" "*4(14 % % (#$" " % (*!$ $3 &'(6 $(-%4%- ( )%#$ +( @3" -"1A(# #"71"$ % >*'( !L @3%*$( \! $"*+0*, %!6 -%! $%-2H- @3%*$( \ )% .'(? %! !3%! ,(*4 ,&G"! %,"#,% +% @3"!$'( -% (# @3" "!$%4% "- C(/(8V

(2#" ( W/(4"#*( +" C3D9"!X6 (!H %#+ - (,A% I* (# *(! #"1"-2#%

@3" % ",1%#%&'( +(! #" $(! +( P(-"- " +( +%+'( ,(*! +"#% !"- (*!$ $3 &'(

% !(, "+%+" "- @3" *'( "!$"C% %!!"/3#%+% % " % $

8 "!$%#$"6 #"!!%1$% "1"6 *(! I1$ -(! +39"*$(! %*(!6 % -% (# % +%!

!(, "+%+"! )(1D$ ,%! (, +"*$% ! 13$% 7"##"*A%-"*$" )%#% %!!"/3#%# ( ,3-)# -"*$(

+"!!"! +( ! #"@3 ! $(! ,(-( 7(#-% +" %!!"*$%# 3-% (*!$ $3 &'( ,(-( *(#-%

73*+%-"*$%1 +" !"3! /(4"#*(! Z8 3-% )# -" #% 7%!"6 % )#"(,3)%&'( ,"*$#(3 !" *( %##%*C( *+")"*+"*$" " A%#-K* ,( +(! $#0! )(+"#"!6 )(#H-6 !$( 1"4(3 %( @3%!"

%* @3 1%-"*$( +% /%#%*$ % +(! + #" $(! 73*+%-"*$% !8 !! -6 (! + #" $(! *"#"*$"! \

+ /* +%+" +% )"!!(% A3-%*% )%!!%#%- % !"# ( )%#M-"$#( +" 4%1 +"9 +% %$3%&'(

+(! $#0! (+"#"!6 )#()(#, (*%*+( 3- !%1$( +( !$%+( +" #" $( 1"/%1 )%#%

3-!$%+( +" + #" $(! ,(*!$ $3, (*% !8 %##"-%$% %#+ - (,A%Q

"!!" !$%+( (*!$ $3, (*%16 % @3"!$'( +", ! 4% )%!!% % !"# ( "@3 1D2# ( "*$#" ( ' 6 "- *(-" +( )(4(6 )(# )%#$" +(! )(+"#"! "1" $(#%1-"*$" #"!)(*!54" !6 " % $ 6 % 7%4(# +( )(4(6 )(# -" ( +% %7 #-%&'( +% !3)"# (# 7(#&% *(#-%$ 4% +% (*!$ $3 &'(6 ,(- 2%!" *( ,(*$#(1" +% ,(*7(#- +%+" % "!!% -"!-% (*!$ $3 &'( +(! %$(! +%@3"1"! )(+"#"! "1" $(! @3" 7%9"- % )(1D$ ,%8

V

Y ` 6 (*%1+81 . + / + - , $ 0 8 '(

%31(Q %#$ *! (*$"!6 V8 8 V; VU8

27

a 6 (!H %#+ - (,A%8 # /

(29)

]3%*+( 3- $%1 ,(*$#(1" H ,(*7(#-%+( ,(-( 3- "."#,D, ( +% 73*&'( +( (+"# 3+ , 5# ( "6 +"!!% 7(#-%6 %$# 23D+( % %/"*$"! @3" $#%+ , (*%1-"*$" "#%- ,(*! +"#%+(! 1"/ $ -%+(! %)"*%! )%#% *$"#)#"$%# " %)1 ,%# ( + #" $(S " @3%*+( *( "."#,D, ( +"!!" ,(*$#(1" "!!"! C3D9"! +% ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 +%+" )%!!%- "7"$ 4%-"*$"6 " ,%+% 4"9 -% !6 % ,(*$#(1%# % )(1D$ ,% )%#% %7 #-%# (! + #" $(! 73*+%-"*$% ! +(! *+ 4D+3(!6 *+%/% !" !" C5 *'( !"# % ( ,%!( +" !" #",(*A","# % *4"#!'( +( ! *%1 +% *(!!% "@3%&'( +" )%#$ +% " %!!3- # @3" % "7"$ 4%&'( +( #"@3 ! $( +% /%#%*$ % +(! + #" $(! H @3" "!$%# % "#(+ *+( ( #"@3 ! $( +% !")%#%&'( +(! )(+"#"! 8 >/# 7(! *". !$"*$"! *( (# / *%1?8

!$" @3"!$ (*%-"*$(6 ,"#$%-"*$"6 H )%#$" +% *+%/%&'( @3" !"

$"*$%#5 "13, +%#8 %$ 4 !-(6 %)"!%# +" ,(*!$ $3 # 3-% +H % +" 4%1(#%&'( #"1%$ 4%6

,(-( !" 4"#5 %+ %*$"6 ,%##"/% @3%!" !"-)#" % )",A% +" 3- ,(-)(#$%-"*$( !3!)" $(6 @3" )G" "- # !,( ( "@3 1D2# ( " % A%#-(* % "*$#" (+"#"!6 $"*+"*+( % !"

,(*!$ $3 # *3-% " 8 %14"96 !"C% "!$%6 !"*'( % )# *, )%16 3-% +%!

)#"(,3)%&G"! "-23$ +%! *( @3"!$ (*%-"*$( %#/3$%-"*$" 7(#-31%+( )(# (!H

%#+ -8

%1 @3"!$ (*%-"*$( 7%9 #"!!3#/ # (3$#( +" #"1"4M*, % *,(*$"!$54"16 @3%1 !"C%6 %@3"1" #"1%, (*%+( \ 1"/ $ - +%+" +% %$ 4 +%+" C3# !+ , (*%16 *($%+%-"*$" *( )"#$ *"*$" \ C3# !+ &'( ,(*!$ $3, (*%18 ,#D$ ,% "!$5 ,"*$#%+% *% $"!" +" @3" (! C3D9"! ,(*!$ $3"- 3-% ,%!$% +"$"*$(#% +" 3- )(+"# ,(*!$ $3, (*%1-"*$" *!$ $3D+( @3"6 "*$#"$%*$(6 #"7(/" +( ,# 4( )()31%# %$#%4H! +" !37#5/ ( *%! 3#*%!6 %( ,(*$#5# ( +( @3" (,(##" ,(- (! -"-2#(! +(! L#/'(! +" )(+"# #")#"!"*$%$ 4(! ,(-( (

"/ !1%$ 4( " ( .",3$ 4(8 3#/ # % +%D 3- ,(*$#% !"*!( C3#D+ ,( )(1D$ ,(6 )( !6 %(!

C3D9"! !"# % +%+( )(+"# )%#% %*31%# +", !G"! )(1D$ ,%! "1%2(#%+%! 4 % )#(,"!!(! +"-(,#5$ ,(! *(! 7L#3*! +" L#/'(! +" #")#"!"*$%$ 4 +%+" )()31%#8

( "*$%*$(6 A5 3-% ,#D$ ,% % "!$" )"*!%-"*$( !"/3*+( ( @3%1 ( -"!-( "!$%# % 73*+%-"*$%+( *% "@3 4(,%+% )#"- !!% +" @3" A5 3-% +"*$ 7 ,%&'(

"*$#" +"-(,#%, % " /(4"#*( +% -% (# %8 +"-(,#%, % %3$0*$ ,%6 ,(*$3+(6 ,(*$"-)1%

$%-2H- ( #"!)" $( \! - *(# %! " %(! + #" $(! 73*+%-"*$% ! +(! , +%+'(!8 32H*

%11" %!!"4"#% @3" ( ,(*," $( -(+"#*( +" +"-(,#%, % H -% ! # ,(6 )( ! %)#"!"*$%

28

(30)

-%$ 9"! " -)1 ,%&G"! @3" ,(##(2(#%- % +H % +" @3" (! $# 23*% ! ,(*!$ $3, (*% ! $0- $%-2H- 3-% %3$0*$ ,% "6 *% -% (# % +%! 4"9"!6 -% ! )#(73*+% 4(,%&'( " 1"/ $ -%&'( +"-(,#5$ ,% @3" (! L#/'(! +" (# /"- )()31%# <8

% 4"#+%+"6 %! !(, "+%+"! A(+ "#*%! "*$#"/%- % /"!$'( +" !"3! *$"#"!!"! % 3- /(4"#*( #")#"!"*$%$ 4(6 ,3C% 4(*$%+" "!$%$%1 H /"#%+% % )%#$ # +% ,(*,(##0*, % +% )%#$ , )%&'( +" 45# (! L#/'(! "!$%$% !6 "*$#" "1"!6 *+32 $%4"1-"*$"

( 3+ , 5# (8 #%6 % C3# !+ &'( ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 %$3% )%#% #"!/%$%# % *$"/# +%+" +%

(#+"- ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 4 (1%+% (3 "- %-"%&% +" 4 (1%&'(6 %!!"/3#%*+( )#($"&'( %(!

+ #" $(! 73*+%-"*$% ! +(! , +%+'(!8 %D )(#@3"6 "*! *% 32H* %11"6 )(+" !" *7"# #

@3" (! $# 23*% ! ,(*!$ $3, (*% ! )%#$ , )%- %$ 4%-"*$" *% 7(#-%&'( "6 !(2#"$3+(6 *%

)#"!"#4%&'( +% 4(*$%+" )()31%#8 - (3$#%! )%1%4#%!6 %( )#($"/"# % !3)#"-%, %

,(*!$ $3, (*%1 " $3$"1%# + #" $(! 73*+%-"*$% !6 (! $# 23*% ! ,(*!$ $3, (*% ! ,(*,(##"-)%#% % -%*3$"*&'( +% #"/31%# +%+" +(! %$(! "!$%$% ! " +" )%#$ ,31%#"! "- #"1%&'( \

(*!$ $3 &'(8 73*&'( +"!!"! $# 23*% !6 )(#$%*$(6 ,(*! !$"6 I1$ -% *!$M*, %6

"-4"1%# )%#% @3" % 7(#-%&'( +% 4(*$%+" )()31%# !" #"%1 9"6 %( 1(*/( +( )#(,"!!(

)(1D$ ,(6 +"*$#( +%! *(#-%!6 )# *,D) (! " 4%1(#"! +% (#+"- ,(*!$ $3, (*%1; 8

B! 4"9"!6 )(#$%*$(6 ( "/ !1%$ 4( " ( .",3$ 4( %$3%- +" 7(#-%

*!37 , "*$" (3 (- !!% *% ,(*,#"$ 9%&'( +(! + $%-"! ,(*!$ $3, (*% ! "- )#(1 +(!

, +%+'(!8 - ! $3%&G"! @3" $% !6 % C3# !+ &'( ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 !" )#"!$% )%#% +%#

"7"$ 4 +%+" %(! + #" $(! 73*+%-"*$% !6 7%9"*+( 4%1"# (! 4%1(#"! *!,31) +(! *%

(*!$ $3 &'(8 ( @3" (,(##"36 )(# "."-)1(6 *(! "- #"1%&'( %(! + #" $(! , 4 !

29

6 32H* P"#*5*+"98 )8 , $8 )8 Z<8 ( (# / *%1Q ?

9 "

" 9

9 5 9 5 5

!

30

2 +"- )8 R8 ( (# / *%1Q.

5 9 ! 1

5

9 9

5 9 . , 5 !

5 * 5

# 9 "

(31)

+(! *"/#(!6 @3%*+( % 7%-(!%, ; ;R%$3(3 +" 7(#-% "7"$ 4% )%#% %,%2%# % !"/#"/%&'( #%, %1 *%! "!,(1%! " 3* 4"#! +%+"!6 +%*+(6 %!! -6 ,(*,#"$3+" %( )# *,D) ( ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 +% /3%1+%+" +" $(+(! )"#%*$" % 1" 8

"!$%#$"6 H 7(#&(!( ,(*,13 # @3" % C3# !+ &'( ,(*!$ $3, (*%1 !" 1"/ $ -% %$#%4H! +" !3% %$3%&'( "- )#(1 +% )%#$ , )%&'( +" $(+(! (! , +%+'(! *%

+ *M- ,% +( !$%+(6 $(#*%*+( ( #"!31$%+( +( $#%2%1A( +( 1"/ !1%+(# %1/( +"

"7"$ 4 +%+" /"*3D*%6 )( ! %!!"/3#%6 +"!$% 7(#-%6 + #" $(! 73*+%-"*$% ! @3" 4'( %(

"*,(*$#( +%! *","!! +%+"! " %*!" (! !(, % ! " *+ 4 +3% !8 ",(##" +%D %

*","!! +%+" +" $(#*%# ,1%#( ( @3" !" "*$"*+" )(# %$ 4 !-( C3+ , %1 )%#% -"1A(# !" ,(-)#""*+"# % #"%1 + -"*!'( +"!!" 7"*K-"*(6 )"#- $ *+( +"*$ 7 ,5 1( !"-#",3#!(! % *(&G"! )#",(*," $3(!%! @3" "4(,%- ,(*,13!G"! %)#"!!%+%! % #"!)" $(8 @3" !" *+%/% H !" ( %$ 4 !-( )(+" !"# ,%#%,$"# 9%+( ,(-( %1/( 2(- (3 #3 - "-! -""-!-(6 (36 )(# (3$#%6 "-!" "-!3%"-! ,%#%,$"#D"-!$ ,%"-!6 )%#% "-!"#"- )"#,"2 +%"-! ,1%#%-"*$"6 ". /"- 3-% -"1A(# %)#""*!'( +( ,(*$".$( "- @3" ( %$ 4 !-( 4"*A% % (,(##"#8

31

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

; , 9

A % B 2 C!3!

, , C3+/"+ *$"#)#"$"+ #"4 "N"+

1"/ !1%$"+X8 >+"!$%@3"! (# / *% !?> E P 6 P"*#O 8 6 )8 ;;R? %#% 3-%

(32)

;8 [ - "*K-"*( 1(2%1

+"2%$" !(2#" %$ 4 !-( C3+ , %1 "*4(14" 45# (! %!)",$(! ,(*7(#-" %

-%*" #% )"1% @3%1 H ,(-)#""*+ +(8 3- +"1"!6 "*$#"$%*$(6 )%#"," "!$%#

3-2 1 ,%1-"*$" 4 *,31%+(Q ( 7"*K-"*( +% " # $ 8 !$" 7"*K-"*(

+ 9 #"!)" $( % 3-% -% (# )%#$ , )%&'( +( 3+ , 5# ( *% ,A%-%+% %#"*% )(1D$ ,%

%$#%4H! +" +", !G"! ,(- -)%,$( + #"$( *% %$3%&'( +( "/ !1%$ 4( " +( .",3$ 4(8

" %,(#+( ,(- "!!% ,(1(,%&'(6 % " # $ %)#"!"*$% (! !"/3 *$"!

! /* 7 ,%+(! %1$"#*%$ 4(!; Q

? .)%*!'( +% 5#"% +" %$3%&'( +(! $# 23*% ! (3 +(! C3D9"!

"-+"$# -"*$( +(! )(1D$ ,(! ":(3 %+- * !$#%+(#"! )I21 ,(!6 (3 !"C%6 %

$#%*!7"#0*, % +(! + #" $(! +" +", !'( +( "/ !1%$ 4( (3 +%

%+- * !$#%&'( )I21 ,% )%#% (! $# 23*% !S (3

? + 73!'( +(! -H$(+(! C3+ , % ! +" +", !'( )%#% (3$#%! 5#"%! @3"

*'( ( 3+ , 5# (8

! -H$(+(! +" +", !G"! C3+ , % ! $0- (! !"/3 *$"! )%#M-"$#(! ,%#%,$"# 9%+(#"!Q ? (! 3D9"!6 4"#!%+(! "- #" $(S ? % #"!(13&'( +" ,(*71 $(! "*$#" +3%! )%#$"! ,(- )(+"# +" %3$(# +%+"S ? 3$ 1 9%&'( +" #"/#%! )#"+"$"#- *%+%! @3" + !, )1 *%- % #"!(13&'( +" $% ! ,(*71 $(! "6 %$#%4H! +%! @3% !6 (! 7%$(! +( ,%!( !'( +"7 * +(!S 4? % %)#", %&'( +(! %#/3-"*$(! +(! 1 $ /%*$"! "6 *( ,%!( +(! ! !$"-%!

C3#D+ ,(! +% %6 4? (! "7" $(! 4 *,31%*$"! +% +", !'( $(-%+% !(2#" (!

,%!(! ! - 1%#"! @3" !3#C%- +%D "- + %*$";;8

! -(+(! +" #"!(13&'( +" ,(*71 $(! )"1( 3+ , 5# ( + 7"#"-6

(24 %-"*$"6 +%@3"1"! 3!%+(! )"1( "/ !1%$ 4(8 !! -6 !" *( )#(,"!!( C3+ , %1 $"-(! % $# %*/31%&'( 7(#-%+% )"1%! )%#$"! " ( 3 96 *( "/ !1%$ 4( (! %$(#"! !'( -I1$ )1(!8

;

6 8 "%1S E b 6 %11 *+"#8 > ?' % 8 "N c(#FQ "N

c(#F * 4"#! $O #"!!6 R<<T8 8 R;8

(33)

% 3!$ &%6 A5 %! %3+ 0*, %! )I21 ,%! " % )(*+"#%&'( +" %#/3-"*$(!6 %( )%!!( @3" *( "/ !1%$ 4( )#"4%1","- %! *"/(, %&G"! )(1D$ ,%! 7" $%! \! )(#$%! 7",A%+%!;U8

+", !'( *( 3+ , 5# (6 )(# !3% 4"96 H 7" $% )(# 3- 3 96 (3 ,(1"/ %+(6 -)%#, %16

"*@3%*$( @3" *( "/ !1%$ 4( % +", !'( H $(-%+% ,(- 2%!" *( )# *,D) ( +% -% (# %8 "/ !1%$ 4( )#(+39 #"!31$%+(! /"#% ! ,(-( 1" !6 (#&%-"*$(6 +"7 * &'( +" )(1D$ ,%!

)I21 ,%!6 (! @3% ! !'( (2$ +(! )(# ,# $H# (! )(1D$ ,(!8 ! +", !G"! C3+ , % ! !'(

%1,%*&%+%! )"1% 3$ 1 9%&'(6 +" 7(#-% )#"+(- *%*$"6 +" ,# $H# (! $H,* ,(! )"1(! @3% ! !'( +"7 * +(! (! 7%$(! +( ,%!( " "*,(*$#%+% % #"/#% C3#D+ ,% %)1 ,54"1 )%#% ( +"!1 *+" +% @3"!$'(8 1%#( @3" $% ! + !$ *&G"! *'( "!$%2"1","- )"#"-)$(# %-"*$" ,%#%,$"#D!$ ,%! ".,13! 4%! +" 3- (3 +" (3$#( -H$(+(6 )(+"*+( A%4"# ! $3%&G"! "-@3" 3- " (3$#( %+($"- )(!$3#%! "-@3" !" ,(*73*+"-8 @3" 7 ,% *($L# (6 "*$#"$%*$(6 H

@3" (! -H$(+(! "-23$"- +( ! )%)H ! + !$ *$(! "!!"*, % ! %( %+"@3%+(

73*, (*%-"*$( +( -(+"1( +"-(,#5$ ,(Q ( )%)"1 +( 3+ , 5# ( +" )#($"/"# (! + #" $(! 73*+%-"*$% ! +(! , +%+'(! "- /"#%1 " ( )%)"1 +( "/ !1%$ 4( +" 9"1%# )"1(! + #" $(!

" (2# /%&G"! +% -% (# %8 ( @3" !" ,(*,13 @3" %" # $ ,(*! !$"6

/#(!!( -(+(6 *% %$3%&'( +( 3+ , 5# ( ,(-( *!$#3-"*$( +" %)"#7" &(%-"*$( "

#"%1 9%&'( +" + #" $(! 73*+%-"*$% !6 "- /"#%1 +"*$ 7 ,%+(! ,(- /#3)(! - *(# $5# (!6 -"!-( @3" !!( )(!!% #")#"!"*$%# 3-% %)%#"*$" ,(*$#%)(! &'( \ %$3%&'( +(

"/ !1%$ 4( *% +"1 2"#%&'( " +"7 * &'( +(! + #" $(! +% -% (# %;T8

"4%*$% !"6 )( !6 ( @3"!$ (*%-"*$( +" ,(-( ( %$ 4 !-( C3+ , %1

"!$%# % ,(*",$%+( ,(- % " # $ 8 -2(#%6 *"!$% %1$3#%6 % *+% *'(

!" $"*A% $"*$%+( $#%&%# (! ,(*$(#*(! +%@3 1( @3" !" +"*$ 7 ,%# % ,(-( %$ 4 !-( C3+ , %16 -%! 1"4%*+( "- ,(*$% 3-% -)#"!!'( * , %1 " -% ! +"2%$ +% +" $%1

7"*K-"*(;V6 H #%9(54"1 %7 #-%# @3" % ,(*".'( )(+" (,(##"# *% #"4 !'( C3+ , %1 +%!

1" ! " %$(! +( "/ !1%$ 4( " +( .",3$ 4(8 -"#!(* %#, %6 % )#()L! $(6 *7(#-% @3"

*$( *" %#%)(* ,(*! +"#% % " # $ 3- ,1%#( *+ ,%+(# +%

;U % ! *"/(, %&G"! *'( !'(6 *","!!%# %-"*$"6 "!,3!%!8 @3" !" )#(,3#% %,"*$3%# %@3 6 ,(-(

"1"*$( +" + !$ *&'(6 H @3"6 +" 7(#-% )#"4%1","*$"6 %,(*$", *"/(, %&G"! #"%1 9%+%! "-#"3* G"! *%! @3% ! 3- )"@3"*( /#3)( +" 1D+"#"! @3" #")#"!"*$%- (! + 4"#!(! )%#$ +(! >(3 2%*,%+%!? @3" ,(-)G"- ( "/ !1%$ 4( ,(-( 3- $(+(8

;T

2 +8 )8 RU RT8

;V

Referências

Documentos relacionados

Mantenha uma única estrutura no plano da Administração Pública que tenha como missão a coordenação, o planeamento, a investigação e a intervenção no combate à

Fonte: Elaborado pela autora. Selecionamos, então, atividades relacionadas às percepções dos sons pelas crianças; apresentação de algumas relações construídas com os

34 para preservação da VSM, e a técnica que faz a safenectomia parcial ao nível da coxa até o terço superior da perna, fizeram um estudo prospectivo e randomizado em 105

a) ao constante empenho do papado na defesa dos índios contra os colonos. e) ao desejo manifestado pelos negros de emigrarem para o Brasil em busca de trabalho... 3) (FUVEST)

Objetivamos, com a pesquisa, verificar quais os gêneros discursivos (orais, escritos ou virtuais) são produzidos na escola pública e na privada, para atender às demandas

Em razão do atual cenário vivido pelo direito no mundo, em especial a expansão do judiciário, o ativismo judicial e a judicialização da política tornaram-se temas de

Neste capítulo o autor discute sobre os ataques de diver- sos países da região a órgãos fundamentais do Sistema, a Comissão Interamericana de direitos Humanos e a Corte

4 No caso do Brasil, o modelo de controle de constitucionalidade é considerado “forte” (Bayón, 2000), pois corresponde àquele que possui uma Constituição abrangente, com um amplo