HAL Id: hal-00474987
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00474987
Submitted on 21 Apr 2010
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Comparative Analysis of Brass Wind Instruments With an Artificial Mouth: First Results
Franck Teissier, Joël Gilbert, Murray Campbell, Jean-François Petiot
To cite this version:
Franck Teissier, Joël Gilbert, Murray Campbell, Jean-François Petiot. Comparative Analysis of Brass Wind Instruments With an Artificial Mouth: First Results. Acta Acustica united with Acustica, Hirzel Verlag, 2003, 89, pp.974-979. �hal-00474987�
! "#
$ %&' ( )&*$ +','&--.+' /.0
1 2" (3 4 '.%&"45#5 &
+,6 1 / &0
(7 ! 8$ & 4 8 9 &: ( ; /< ((* ( 9& 8 ( & 9
= .:>& ( & ? 9
! " ! " #
$ % & # '(" &
#
# " # ) * "
! !' + # #
$ "
" &" , & %'( " "
# # "" # ' -
# - , "
" " & " '
$" #5-.5 50@
! "# ! "
. # $ '''% # "
" $ & " %
" & $ %
" /0 1 2 34' "" " & ! ! #
" " /5 6 7 84'+ # " "
* & " # ++'0' # "
! !
$ ++'1%' # "
" # " & " "" # '
+++ # # '
$ % # ! & ' " !(
) *
! " !" # "! " !$ - "
# # %# "#
- ! " )# !' 9 :
" " ' " " "
# " " & /54 # !
! & '
& + ) " 8 ( 8 4 A+%5
$"&'0%# "
" " /6 74' ;, " $
" , %# - " & #
- # - ' " , "
- # # " ,
&" '( )
- # & & "" /84'
# " #
" - & " /<4'
, ! - +.
# " &
# ' # & #
& # #
" $"&'1%' " # & 0 "
" =1 =2'
! ) > =1 > =2
)#
"
(
$ # ? 5?? %
)#
@ & " )#
( $ # ?
5?? %
( " A - ∅1? ∅01
" $
B %
B ('C ! 4 ( 8 8 ( 4 A+ A.
=2 # " "" ' "
" # & '
& + , " 8 ( 8 < 4 A.%5
" / ! 01 ! # "&! /1!
)
. # & # " #
' & 2 $ &
% " # ' & " , &
" " , ' " " ,
" ' /0?4'
, $CD%
0?? 1?? 2?? 3?? 5?? 6?? 7?? 8?? <?? 0???
? 1?
5?
&
$ .%
0'5
? 0'5
$ %
& + 2 / !( 8 ! ! 8 ! 9 ! %5
" , & - " " , "
" # '+ &
# " , $ &" , % " , "
" - $"&'3%'
& &
0??
5?
5?
?
0??
$?% $0% $1% $01% $2% $02% $12% $012%
E
$ %
& + 3 ! 8 . 8 8 ! %
. 9 !( ! !( D% ! 9 6 8 9 9 5B
8 4 8 ( 8 8
!( 98 % ( 4 ( (( (( ! ( < "-E
--,=F%5
"" , # " ,
& " , ' "" "" -
$# " " , %* "
"" - & # "
' " "
" , " ' & )
" , " /00 014' "
&/024'
# - "" & &
" " , " " ( E &
"# " & " # # /03 05 064'
" # ) & $#
" , % - " "
" /074' - "" "
# # " "
"" ) "" /084'
, & $ " , "
%" " - " ' -
# && & " " $ " ,
, " & " % #
, " /0<4'
# " '@ ) # "
# # "
" # " /1?4'
,
% 8 !( 98
# " "" F " # & "& '
+ " & " , #
# &" , " & & # "
$" & ) # # % #
' # - *
" , "
' " & &" , # #
& " , # " , ' 1
" " , $ " , & " , %
, " # 3 E5
" & & " '+ &
# ' & '
" " " " & " '
&3 234(5 #6 678(5
0 9 9 ,% '.% ,% .% '+%
B!!( G15 G35 G05 G15 G2?
0 35 05 6? 2< G6<
!/
" 85 G03 G1< G03 G12 G16
B!!( G6? G00? G55 G75 G0??
50 5 ? G62 10 G< G3<
!/
" 85 G52 G0?5 G36 G66 G8?
B ( +C 4 8 8 8 !( 98 %&
< . 88 C'%B ! !( &+% 8 &.%" 8 ( 5
%0 (( ( < 9 (4 (
H # " # ) &"
" & ) #
# ' &" , " ." 2 #
& $"&'5%'
5 10 15 20 25 30 440
450 460 470 480 490 500
H $ %
&
" ,
$CD%
Trumpet Y
. 2$366CD%
Trumpet C
& + 6 4 ( 8 !( 9 8 8 8 9 9&8 < ! G5
*8( . !( < 8 ( < 5B !( 98 =F%
! 9 4 ! %5
+" , # $ & " &" , #
& % & & "" , '@
- # # #
" & +" &
#
# '( # & # "
# # # & ' #
" " # & '
" & ) " " $# "
" )#% & " ' -
I # " , ' 2
" # ""
'; " & " I
I ) # # & '
F
(" 2 057 086
;" 3 << 0? 6
(" 3 025 0<1
B ( .C ( ! & < 88 & 4
( & # 9 " &:
F $ # "
% " # I )
" # '
+ "
- $ - " %'
& $"&'6%'
14 16 18 20 22 24
100 105 110 115 120 125
H $ %
@
$ .%
Trumpet C Trumpet Y
& + 9 H 8 ( ! (4 ( (( 8 * !(% 9
4 ! %5B !( < ! G 9
8 ( 0-5
" # , '
F # '@ "
# & # # '
% ! 8 4 (8 9 9
(" " & #
" & & ' "" " & & E5$
" & & # " & & %' " #
) " - "
& " " & & ' & 7 # &" ,
" " ' " " & & #
" , $ &" # "05CD%'
"" # " & &* "" "
" , '
10 15 20 25 30
580 585 590 595 600 605 610 615
H $ %
&
" ,
$CD%
:;<
:2<
:),<
+ E3 $587CD%
" & &$01%
& + 8 H 8 !( 98 8 8 9 9 8 ! G8 7-!(
9 8 ( &< 9 4 ! 5B 88 8 9 9 C
( < 4 (4 ! ,%I < C4 (4 ' + ! '+%& 4 (4 . ! .%5
( & " & & " '+
# " & & '+
&" , # "" " & &
" " & & # '+
- # # " # &
&" , # & #
# '
& 7 &" , $ " %" " & &$01%
& " " & & $?% # " I '
. # " & &$01% & " & &$2% # #
' " & , ) #
, # # # ) '
" " & " " & &
$ 3%J
3 $?% $01% $2%
81 0? 5 01<
B ( -C ( ! & < 88 & 4
8 9 9 &8 7 5
# " & &$?% #
# I - '
0 " ' " # / " /1 !
# " " #
'@ ) ! !" &'
' "
& '
# & , ' "
& " " "
'; 9 " : & &
"" # " ""
"" '(
# # " &
'+ "" " " 9 : #
" & & " " " -
'; " ) & & -
'
+ # # " & #
# " & " #
& " # '
- +
# (K>(L # " # !( - )
I &, !' # # & " &&
" # # '
==
0'('C'. J " '@-" M K # F 0<76'
1' ' ' J I ( '@-" M
$ %M N & 0<<8'
2'K'C' 'E'L &J " $1 O %'H & K #
F 0<<8'
3'; H''. # ' ' 9 < 5'H > '72080107
$0<81%'
5' ' '' ( ( J 4 ! 4 C (
/! /5( 3P &P I( , 630633 $0<<7%'
6' ' ''* & ( /! ( ( 5 &
+H ( '+ " ; & MN 2<03?? $0<<7%'
7' ' H' ''" 8 ( FF 9(! C /! (
( 5'( 'H '( ');306170621$0<<8%'
8' ' ' E' '* C ( ( (
/! < 8 ( 5( 797?3 713 $1???%'
<'A K'' 'C " ' ''> L'K''C &('" ( < 4 (
8( ( !( 4 ( &< !!( ! 9 5(
730025005? $0<<<%'
0?' E '' . (' '" ! C!( < 4 8
( ( 5'( 'H '( '4)2?162?22$0<<0%'
00' . '+ ' & "+H (<8 $A # MH(% 02503?
$0<<8%'
01' . '> ' & "+H (<7 + "
; & MN 3?03?6$0<<7%'
02' OL'N & 'A Q' ! ! 8 ( & !
< /! ( (5'( 'H '( '86130153 $0<83%'
03' N ' ( & ' '" ! ! 9 8 ! 8
5$ 5 !& !( 5( R( ( 76H77$0<<<%'
05' (' A'S@ S T " , " T'
( U '79727735$1???%'
06' ' '9; " , '
;- " :' & "H ( <2 H ( "
$0<<2%'56? 565'
07' L'A' . # ' '9 ) " , :' "H
> 96510537$0<7<%'
08' L'A'. # ' '9 ) " , :' "H
> 68315325$0<78%'
0<' 'L A # .'(''" 4 9 8 ( < 9 &
4 ( & ! ! 8 0 ! 5'( 'H '( '
);900000015$0<<<%'
1?' '' 'K" 9 8 ( 5L+ & E &
" & ; & &V<8'; . . D 'A' ' & '
'3<75?3 N # ( $0<<<%'
