HAL Id: jpa-00232550
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/jpa-00232550
Submitted on 1 Jan 1985
HAL
is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire
HAL, estdestinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Pseudo-lamellar ordering in uniaxial and biaxial lyotropic nematics : a synchrotron X-ray diffraction
experiment
A.M. Figueiredo Neto, Y. Galerne, A.M. Levelut, L. Liebert
To cite this version:
A.M. Figueiredo Neto, Y. Galerne, A.M. Levelut, L. Liebert. Pseudo-lamellar ordering in uniaxial and
biaxial lyotropic nematics : a synchrotron X-ray diffraction experiment. Journal de Physique Lettres,
Edp sciences, 1985, 46 (11), pp.499-505. �10.1051/jphyslet:019850046011049900�. �jpa-00232550�
Pseudo-lamellar ordering in uniaxial and biaxial lyotropic nematics :
a
synchrotron X-ray diffraction experiment
A. M.
Figueiredo
Neto(*),
Y. Galerne, A. M. Levelut and L. Liebert Laboratoire de Physique des Solides (**), Université de Paris-Sud,Bât. 510, 91405 Orsay Cedex, France
(Re~u le 27 novembre 1984, revise le 18 fevrier 1985, accepte le 15 avril 1985)
Résumé. 2014 Des mesures sont réalisées aux rayons X du synchrotron de LURE sur les phases lyotropes nématiques, uniaxes (discotiques et calamitiques) et biaxes, d’un mélange de laurate de
potassium, 1-décanol et
D2O.
Dans les trois phases, on observe le premier et le second ordre d’unebande de diffraction caractéristique d’une structure
pseudo-lamellaire.
Les clichés de diffraction X sont interprétés en termes de fluctuations orientationnelles de volumes de corrélations intrinsèque-ment biaxes. On en déduit que les phases
calamitiques
et discotiques ne sont pas composées de micellescylindriques
(ou en forme dedisques),
mais d’agrégats de forme statistiquement biaxe, semblable dans les trois phasesnématiques.
Seul l’ordre àlongue
distancechange
aux transitionsnématiques
uniaxes-biaxes.
Abstract. 2014 Synchrotron X-ray measurements are
performed
in both uniaxial (discotic and cala- mitic) and biaxial nematic lyomesophases of the mixture K-laurate, 1-decanol andD2O.
A first-order band and a second-order band with spacing ratio 1 : 2 characteristic of apseudo-lamellar
structureare observed in the three nematic phases. The X-ray diffraction results are
interpreted
in terms of theorientational fluctuations of intrinsically biaxial correlation volumes. It is argued that the calamitic and discotic phases are not built up
of cylindric-like
and disk-like micelles, but of aggregates of statis- tically biaxial shape, similar in the three nematic phases. The only change at the uniaxial-biaxial nematic transitions is the long-range order.Classification
Physics Abstracts
64. 70E -- 61.30E
1. Introduction.
Under proper
temperature-concentration conditions,
mixtures ofamphiphilic
molecules and water maygive lyotropic
nematicphases [1].
Fromsymmetry
considerations[2],
threetypes
of nematics areexpected,
two uniaxial[1]
and one biaxial[3]. X-ray [4, 5]
and neutron[6]
diffraction structural studies have beenperformed
on both uniaxialphases. Depending
on whether the director(n)
orientsparallel
orperpendicular
to themagnetic
field(H),
these uniaxialphases
havebeen classified
[6]
as calamitic(Nc)
and discotic(Np), respectively.
The form of theamphiphilic
aggregates,
averaged
in thelaboratory frame,
was obtained from the maximumpositions
on the(*) On leave from the « Instituto de Fisica, Universidade de Sao Paulo, CP : 20516 CEP : 05508 Sao Paulo (SP), Brazil » CNPq financial support.
(**) Laboratoire associe au CNRS.
Article published online by EDP Sciences and available at http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/jphyslet:019850046011049900
L-500 JOURNAL DE PHYSIQUE - LETTRES
diffraction patterns
[6].
In thisanalysis,
the micellarshapes
were found to beamphiphilic
oblateand
prolate ellipsoids
in theNo
andNc phases, respectively [5].
In this Letter we report what we believe to be the first
X-ray
structuralstudy
of the biaxial nematicphase (NBx).
From the dataanalysis,
we argue inparticular,
that theNc
andND phases
are not built up
of cylindric-like
and disk-like « micelles », but of aggregates ofstatistically
similarbiaxial
shape, piled
up in alocally
lamellar structure.2.
ExperimentaL
The nematic
lyomesophase
isprepared according
to conventionalprocedures [1]
with the follo-wing composition
inweight % : potassium
laurate(synthesized
andrecrystallized
in the labo-ratory) - 26.50 ;
1-decanol(> 99 % purity
fromFluka)
- 6.68 andD20 -
66.82. A smallquantity
of ferrofluid-FF( 10-4 by weight)
is added in order tohelp
thealignment
in themagnetic
field[7].
This addition of FF does notmodify
thetemperature
transitions and the diffractionpatterns
within ourexperimental
accuracy, as we haveindependently
checked in theNc phase.
As the temperature isincreased,
the successivephases
identifiedby conoscopic
measure-ments
[8]
are :Isotropic (9.5 °C) ND(13.2 °C) NBx(23.2 °C) N~(40 °C) Isotropic [9].
The
sample
is sealed in a Lindemannglass capillary
with 1.5 mm diameterplaced
in a tempe-rature controlled device
(accuracy ± 0.1 °C),
in the verticaldirection, perpendicular
to theX-ray beam,
in a transmission geometry. Amagnetic
field of 3 kG and - 500 G(permanent magnet)
isapplied perpendicular
orparallel
to theX-ray beam, respectively. X-ray
diffraction patterns are obtainedby photographic
methodusing
asynchrotron X-ray
monochromatic radiation(Ge crystal, wavelength
x = 1.62A)
ofOrsay (Laboratoire
pour l’Utilisation duRayonnement Electromagnetique
-LURE).
The exposure times are about 10 min and the meanexperimental
resolution in 2 e
scattering angle
is 0.04°(in
fact this resolution does not varydrastically
with thedirection of the
scattering
vector in the smallangles
which are of interest in theseexperiments [10])
H defines the l-axis of the
laboratory frame;
the 3-axis coincides with thecapillary
axis(X-ray
beam
along
the 1- or2-axes).
The orientation of the
sample
has beencarefully
achieved in the three nematicphases.
In theNc phase,
the director nsimply
orientsparallel
to H(1-axis).
In theNo phase,
thecapillary
is rotatedaround its axis the
3-axis),
in presence of H(along
theI-axis), following
the classical NMRorienting procedure [1],
which orients the director nalong
the 3-axis. Because the relaxation time of the orientation of oursamples
istypically
15min,
it isenough
toapply
theorienting procedure
every 5 min to
produce
and tokeep
agood alignment
of thesample.
InNBx,
the monodomain is obtainedby just oscillating
thecapillary by
450 around its axis andrestoring
it into its initialposition.
Note thatinterruptions
of the exposure are needed forlonger
exposure times. Thehigh intensity X-ray
beam of thesynchrotron
source, which allows short exposuretimes,
is veryhelpful
toapply strictly
theorienting procedure and, thus,
to warrant theperfect
orientation of thesamples during
theexperiments.
3. Results.
3.1 GENERAL FEATURES. - The
X-ray
diffractionpatterns
of the uniaxial and biaxialphases
are
presented
infigure
1 : theX-ray beam,
directedalong
the 1- or 2-axes isparallel (or equiva- lently perpendicular)
to themagnetic
field H in theND phase (Fig.1 a), perpendicular
to H in theNe phase (Fig. Ib)
andrespectively parallel
andperpendicular
to H in the biaxialphase (Figs. Ic
and
Id) [11].
Due to the infinite fold axis(director n)
of the uniaxialphases,
the measurement of the diffractedintensity
may be reduced to one meridianplane
of thereciprocal
space. The whole three dimensionalreciprocal
structure is thengenerated by
the rotation of the diffractionpattern
around the director. In ourexperimental conditions,
the directors in theND
andNe phases
arealong
the 3- and 1-axesrespectively.
Fromfigures
la and Ib, we see therefore that thereciprocal
Fig. 1. - Synchrotron X-ray patterns of oriented K-laurate, 1-decanol,
D20
nematiclyomesophases.
The capillary is set up in the vertical direction in the plane of the figure. (a) Discotic phase with the director (n) along the vertical direction. T = 12 °C. Note that, for symmetry reasons, the X-ray pattern is the same when H is in the plane of the figure,perpendicular
to n.(b)
Calamitic phase with n parallel to the magnetic field (H)in the plane of the figure. T = 24 °C. (c) and (d) Biaxial nematic
phase
with H parallel and perpendicular tothe beam
respectively.
The sharp band d in figure 2 near the beam stopper more visible in(c)
is due to the~/3 radiation. T = 20 °C.
structure of the uniaxial
phases
may be schematized as a hollowcylinder parallel
to n with intense ends in theND phase [5],
and intenseedges
in theNc phase.
The biaxialphase
hasonly
threeperpendicular
two-fold axes, and at least two cuts of thereciprocal
space are needed togive
itsreciprocal
structure.Figure
Ic andId,
which represent cuts of thereciprocal
spaceby
theplanes containing
the3-,
2-axes and the3-,1-axes, respectively
show that the 3Dimage
in thereciprocal
space is a hollow barrel of section flattened in the direction of
H,
intermediate between the two uniaxialreciprocal images. By comparing
the patterns of the uniaxialphases
with thosepreviously published [4, 5]
we observe newfeatures,
common to all our uniaxial and biaxialX-ray
patterns.We see
essentially
a second-order band(band
b in the scheme ofFig. 2)
with aspacing-ratio
of1 /2
associated to the first-order band
(a-band) along
the 3-axis direction. It is to be noted that these characteristic features are observed in all the numerous( N 10)
nematicsamples
of variousconcentrations that we have
prepared
in thephase diagram
ofSaupe [3].
3.2 ANALYSIS OF THE X-RAY DIFFRACTION PATTERNS ALONG THE 3-AXIS.
3 . 2 .1 Orientational
fluctuations.
-Liquid crystals [ 12] have,
in addition to theirshort-range (positional
andorientational) ordering,
along-range
orientational order. The associated fluctua- tions of orientation smear theX-ray
pattern from theshort-range positional ordering, giving typical
band-arcs(band
a inFig. 1). These,
in turn, allow a measurement of theamplitude 4>
of theorientational oscillations about the 3-axis which
yields
a determination of the order parameter S in the uniaxial nematicphases
S 3cos2 4> - 1 ~ .
From theanalysis
offigures
la andL-502 JOURNAL DE PHYSIQUE - LETTRES
Fig. 2. - Sketch of the diffraction patterns
presented
infigure
1 with a denomination of the different diffraction bands.I b
[13], ~
is found to be 0.85 in theN D phase
and 0.90 in theNc phase,
close to the biaxial transi- tions.Moreover,
thehigh degree
of orientational order is confirmedby
the rectilinearshape
of thec-band. In the middle of the biaxial temperature range
(Figs.
Ic andId),
the oscillations referred to the 3-axis are of the same order ofmagnitude
as in the uniaxialphases,
butthey
have inreality,
different
amplitudes
in the3-1-plane
and in the3-2-plane
because of the biaxialsymmetry.
Near theNBx - Nc phase transition,
the orientational fluctuations in the3-2-plane
have alarger amplitude,
untilthey
become full rotations over the director(the 1-axis)
of theNc phase.
3. 2. 2 Pseudo lamellar structure. - The second-order band
(b)
which is observed(Fig. 1 )
in thethree nematic
phases, including
theNc phase
up to theNc-Isotropic
transition, is remarkable.In the usual
picture
of theNc phase
ascomposed
ofcylinder-like
micelles[5],
a second-order bandrelatively
broadcorresponding
to a six-fold coordinence would have beenexpected
at aratio of about
1 .
Within ourpresent sensitivity
weonly
see asharp
band witha spacing
B/3
ratio. This indicates a ID
periodicity
of the micellesalong
the 3-axis. The measurement of thescattering
g vector modulus(~ = 2013~2013) ( ~, ) along
g the 3-axis shows that thisperiodicity
p Y iss3
48.7 ± 0.8
A,
constant across the wholeND, N~ Nc
range(Fig. 3).
From the relative width of the a-band(Fig. 1) [13],
we can estimate thepositional
correlation in the direction of the 3-axis.Using
Scherrer’sexpression [14]
we find thepositional
order to extendalong
this direc- tion on about400 A (~8
lamellardistances),
ingood agreement
withprevious
andX-ray
measurements in the
Nc phase
of a different mixture[15],
and constant in the three nematicphases.
Note that thisID-periodicity
is also correlated in the directionsperpendicular
to the3-axis,
as indicates the narrowarc-shape
of the a-band, very reminiscent of thethermotropic
smectic A.
Finally,
the three nematicphases
are found to exhibit the samepseudo-lamellar
structure on
short-range
scales.3. 3 DIFFRACTION MAXIMA ALONG THE 1- AND 2-AXES. The
positions
of the diffraction maximaare also measured
along
the 1- and 2-axes(c-band
ofFig. 2).
Thedata s~ 1 and S2 1, (and s3 ~)
areplotted
versustemperature
infigure
3. In the uniaxialphases,
because ofsymmetry,
two out of the threes~ 1
becomeundistinguishable.
Infigure 3,
we note thatsï1
variesslowly
withtemperature ( ~
4%
from theND
to theNc phase),
and thatS31
is constant. This indicates in the usual naivereal-space picture
that the dimensions of themicelles,
i.e. their « dianlctcrs » and «lengths
»,[19]
are
just interchanged
in theND
andNc phases.
Fig.
3. - Synchrotron X-ray measurementsof~ ~), ~ ~(0)
ands3 ’ (
x ) as functions of temperature in the three nematic phases. The variations ofsl and s;’
with temperature are visualizedby
brocken lines. Theexperimental
error in themeasurements of Si-
from the microdensitometer profile of the diffraction patterns is about (0.8A).
The transition temperatures (dashed lines) are determinedindependently by
measuring the optical anisotropies [8].4. Discussion.
The observation of the same local structure in the three
Np, NBx’! Nc phases
is notreally
asurprise.
Thetheory
of second-orderphase
transitions shows that localordering,
on scales smaller than the correlationlength ~,
should be the same on both sides of thetransition,
and identical to that of the orderedphase [16].
This remarkapplies
to the uniaxial-biaxial nematicphase
transitionwhich is found to be a mean-field second-order transition
[8].
The correlationlength ~
hasrecently
been estimated from a
Rayleigh scattering experiment [17].
The bare correlationlength ~o
for the...
/ T 2013 r ’~B
ND - NBx transition,
is found -100 A.
This indicatesthat, = ’0 B 2013=2013~ )
c/
islarger
than - 500
A
over the whole nematic range, at least an order ofmagnitude larger
than the micellarsize. The local order should therefore be similar in the three nematic
phases,
and identical to that of the orderedphase,
i.e. biaxial. In theNc phase,
such a biaxial localordering
seems to beconfirmed from recent neutron measurements
[18].
One can now use this idea to reconstruct the observed diffractionpatterns.
Let us consider thereciprocal-space image
of a cluster of IDposi-
tional order
(of
size - 400A,
smaller than~),
similar in the three nematicphases,
and biaxial.In a coarse
approximation,
it is anelongated cylinder
C* with anelliptic section, resembling
the
reciprocal image
of theNBx phase.
It hassharp
and intensespots
at the ends(due
to the well-defined
pseudo-lamellar ordering)
and more diffuseedges.
Thereciprocal
structure of the differentnematic
phases
can be obtainedby averaging
thecylinder
C* over the orientational fluctuations characteristic of thesephases.
In theND phase,
the orientational fluctuations consistmainly
inrotations over the 3-axis. The
reciprocal
structure of theND phase
is then a circularcylinder,
similar to
C*,
which may beinterpretated
in the real space, asproduced by
average disk-like micelles ofspacing
distancesequal
tos31 and sl 1 along
and between theirsymmetry
axis(3-axis) respectively.
In theNc phase,
thereciprocal
structure is obtainedby averaging
the samecylinder
C* over rotations around the 1-axis. This is now a thick disk which seems, in the real space, to be due to average
cylindric
micelles ofspacing
distancesequal
tosi 1 and s:; 1 along
and between theirsymmetry
axis( 1-axis), respectively.
This reconstructionexplains
that the dimensions of theL-504 JOURNAL DE PHYSIQUE - LETTRES
average
micelle,
i.e. the « diameter » and the «length >> [19],
arejust interchanged
in theND
andNc phases,
as foundexperimentally (Fig. 3).
Theinterpretation
of theX-ray
measurements in the biaxialphase
can also be obtainedby averaging
thereciprocal cylinder
C* over the orientational fluctuations(of
smallamplitude now).
These fluctuations which are describedby
the biaxial order parameter qxa[12],
introduce similarities between thetemperature
variations of thesi’s
and theoptical
indices n;[8].
Inparticular, they drive S2
in theNBx phase
from its value(= s 1 )
in theND phase
to its value(= s3 )
in theNc phase [20].
5. Conclusions.
Using
theSynchrotron X-ray radiation,
we have obtained thereciprocal
structure of the nematicdiscotic, biaxial,
and calamiticphases
in theternary
mixture ofpotassium laurate,
decanol andD20.
We have observed the same localpseudo-lamellar ordering
in the three nematiclyomeso- phases. Using
this local biaxialordering,
one can reconstruct the observedX-ray
diffraction patterns in the three nematicphases, by averaging
over thesymmetry
allowed rotations and oscillations around the directors of thephases. Going
back to real space, if one supposes that thesephases
are built of individualmicelles,
one cangive
theimage
that the micelleskeep
a well-defined thickness
(related
to theamphiphilic double-layer), and,
on a local average, the samelateral
elliptic shape.
The statistics which governs the biaxialshape
and the size of the micelles isactually
unknown(a
mixture of disk-like andcylinder-like
micelles may not beexcluded).
Theimportant point
is that this statistics(e.g.
mixture of disks andcylinders)
must remain very similar in the three nematicphases,
withonly
a smooth temperature variation which couldtrigger
thenematic
phase
transitions.Acknowledgments.
We are
greatly
indebted to Dr. P. Keller forpreparation
of thepotassium
laurate and Mr. S.Megtert
for hishelp
in theSynchrotron
measurements. Professors G.Durand,
and N. V. Madhu-sudana are
greatly acknowledged
for veryhelpful
discussions.References
[1]
RADLEY, K., REEVES, L. W. and TRACEY, A. S., J.Phys.
Chem. 80 (1976) 174.[2] FREISER, M. J.,
Phys.
Rev. Lett. 24 (1970) 1041.RABIN, Y., MULLEN, W. E. and GELBART, W. M., Mol.
Cryst. Liq.
Cryst. 89 (1982) 67.[3]
YU, L. J. and SAUPE, A.,Phys.
Rev. Lett. 45 (1980) 1000.[4]
AMARAL, L. Q., PIMENTEL, C. A., TAVARES, M. R. and VANIN, J. A., J. Chem. Phys. 71 (1979) 2940.[5] CHARVOLIN, J., LEVELUT, A. M. and SAMULSKY, E. T., J.
Physique
Lett. 40 (1979) L-587.[6]
HENDRIKX, Y., CHARVOLIN, J., RAWISO, M., LIEBERT, L. and HOLMES, M. C., J.Phys.
Chem. 87 (1983)3991.
[7] LIEBERT, L. and MARTINET, A., J. Physique Lett. 40 (1979) L-363.
BROCHARD, F. and DE GENNES, P. G., J.
Physique
31(1970)
691.[8]
GALERNE, Y. and MARCEROU, J. P.,Phys.
Rev. Lett. 51 (1983) 2109 and J.Physique
46(1985)
81, and references therein.[9] This
sample
has been chosen for its wide biaxial range.[10]
LEVELUT, A. M., J.Physique
Lett. 45 (1984) L-603.[11]
FIGUEIREDO NETO, A. M., LEVELUT, A. M., LIEBERT, L. and GALERNE, Y.,Proceedings
of the X Inter-national
Liquid
Crystals Conference, York 1984, Mol. Cryst. Liq. Cryst.[12]
DE GENNES, P. G., ThePhysics of Liquid Crystals
(Clarendon Press,Oxford)
1974.[13] More
specifically,
the measurement is achieved from the microdensitometeranalysis
of unsaturated films.[14] GUINIER, A., Théorie et Technique de la Radiocristallographie (Paris, Dunod) 1956.
[15] FIGUEIREDO NETO, A. M. and AMARAL, L. Q., Acta Crystallogr. A 39 (1983) 651.
[16] MA, S. K., Modern Theory
of
Critical Phenomena(Benjamin, Reading,
Mass) 1976.[17] LACERDA SANTOS, M. B., GALERNE, Y. and DURAND, G.,
Phys.
Rev. Lett. 53 (1984) 787.[18] HENDRIKX, Y., RAWISO, M., ALPERINE, S., CHARVOLIN, J., ILL Rep. n° 9-09-24.
[19]
The inverted commas mean that the dimensions (diameter and length) considered here concern theamphiphilic
aggregate itself,plus
the surrounding water which ispartly
bound to it.[20] GALERNE, Y. and FIGUEIREDO NETO, A. M., in
preparation.