HAL Id: jpa-00210810
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/jpa-00210810
Submitted on 1 Jan 1988
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Local ordering in lyotropic cholesteric liquid crystals studied by X-ray scattering
A.M. Figueiredo Neto, A.M. Levelut, Y. Galeme, L. Liebert
To cite this version:
A.M. Figueiredo Neto, A.M. Levelut, Y. Galeme, L. Liebert. Local ordering in lyotropic cholesteric liquid crystals studied by X-ray scattering. Journal de Physique, 1988, 49 (7), pp.1301-1306.
�10.1051/jphys:019880049070130100�. �jpa-00210810�
Local ordering in lyotropic cholesteric liquid crystals studied by X-ray scattering
A. M.
Figueiredo
Neto(1),
A. M. Levelut(2),
Y. Galeme(2)
and L. Liebert(2) (1)
Instituto de Fisica, Universidade de Sao Paulo, C.P.20516, CEP01498,
Sao Paulo(SP),
Brazil(2)
Laboratoire dePhysique
des Solides, Université Paris-Sud, Bât.510,
91405Orsay Cedex,
FranceLaboratoire pour l’Utilisation du
Rayonnement Electromagnétique (LURE)
Université Paris Sud, 91405Orsay Cedex,
France(Reçu
le 27janvier
1988,accepte
le 28 mars1988)
Résumé. 2014 Nous avons réalisé des
expériences
de diffraction X sur desphases nématiques-calamitiques lyotropes
etcholestériques-calamitiques lyotropes
induites par undopage
de sulfate de brucine et de d-octanol.Les spectres de diffraction de la
phase cholestérique
déroulée sontcomparés
aux spectres de laphase nématique
orientée usuelle. Ils montrent une conservationglobale
de la structurepseudo-lamellaire
enphase cholestérique,
avec toutefois des déformations locales de cette structurepseudo-lamellaire
dans le cas deséchantillons
dopés
au sulfate de brucine.Abstract. 2014
X-ray
diffractionexperiments
withlyotropic
calamitic-nematicphases
and inducedlyotropic
calamitic-cholesteric
phases doped
with brucine sulfate and d-octanol areperformed.
The diffraction pattern of the usual oriented nematicphase
iscompared
with the patterns of the untwisted cholestericphase.
Theanalysis
of the patterns indicate that even in the cholesteric
phase
thepseudo-lamellar
structure is maintained. The different features observed in the diffraction patterns of the nematic and cholestericphases doped
with thebrucine sulfate are
explained
in terms of local deformations of thepseudo-lamellar
structure.Classification
Physics
Abstracts61.30G - 61.30J - 75.30
Introduction.
Lyotropic
cholestericliquid crystals [1-3]
may be obtainedby adding
chiral molecules tolyotropic
nematic
mesophases.
These chiralmolecules,
suchas brucine
sulphate, d(f)2
octanol orcholesterol,
induce a cholesteric
arrangement
of theamphiphilic
micelles. Three
types
oflyotropic
cholestericmesophases
have been identified:ChD-discotic
cholesteric
[3, 4] ; ChBx-biaxial
cholesteric[5]
andChc-calamitic
cholesteric[3, 4].
Thesubscription D,
BX and C indicate
only
that the cholestericphases
are obtained from the discotic
(ND ),
biaxial(NBx )
or calamitic
(Nc)
nematicphases [6, 7] respectively, by adding
chiral molecules. In the presence of astrong enough magnetic
field(H),
theChD
andChBx
orient with the cholestericplanes perpendicular
to H and the
Chc phase
is untwisted. The untwisted effect of the field on theChc phase
may be inter-preted
as a cholesteric(Ch)
to nematic(N*) phase
transformation
[8],
where thepitch diverges
for acritical
field, starting
from a finite value. We nameN(*
the nematicphase
obtained from theuntwisting
of a cholesteric
phase.
A
puzzling question
that came from the inducedcholesteric
systems
is how the chiral moleculesmodify
the localordering
of the nematics to form along
range cholesteric structure.Especially
how thepseudo-lamellar ordering
observed in nematics[7]
isperturbed by
the presence of theoptical
activeagent.
In this paper we
present
aX-ray
diffractionstudy
of the
N(* phases
obtained from theChc phase
untwisted
by
themagnetic
field. Thelyotropic systems
studied are thepotassium
laurate(KL)
andthe sodium decil sulfate
(SdS) doped
with the chiralmolecules d-Octanol
(DOC)
and brucine sulfatehepta-hydrated (BS) respectively.
The location of the DOC and the BS molecules isexpected
to bedifferent
[2]
in these cholesteric mixtures : theamphiphilic
molecules of DOC areexpected
to belocated in the micelles
(as
the decanol or thepotassium laurate) ;
the BS molecules in the pres-ence of water
partially
ionizes and areprobably
Article published online by EDP Sciences and available at http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/jphys:019880049070130100
1302
located
[2]
in the water, in the electric doublelayer,
outside the micelles. The diffraction
patterns
of theN(c* phase
arecompared
with the usualN, patterns.
Experimental
section.MATERIALS. - Sodium
decylsulphate (SdS),
1-de-canol
(DeOH),
the brucinesulphate heptahydrated (BS),
the d-2-Octanol(DOC)
and thed, f-2
Octanol(DLOC)
are of commercialorigin (Merck
p.p.e.> 99
%), (Fluka
p.p.e.> 99%) (Flukapurum),
Al-drich
respectively.
Thepotassium
laurate(KL)
wasprepared
in thelaboratory (Orsay).
COMPOSITION OF THE MESOPHASES. - The
lyotropic mesophases
wereprepared following
the classicalprocedure [9].
Their concentrations inweight
per cent and theirphase
sequence as a function of thetemperature
are :(a)
the nematicphase -
Slwhere POL denotes a
polyphasic
domain.(b)
The cholestericphase -
S2(c)
The nematicphase -
S3(d)
The cholestericphase -
S4The molar concentration of
quiral
molecules peramphiphilic
moleculesMa
is defined as follows :Sample
S2 and S4 haveMB =
2.7 x10- 3
andMf
= 9.9 x10- 2 respectively.
The cholestericpitch
is about 100 03BCm for both S2 and S4
samples.
A small
quantity (about
0.05 wt%)
of a water-base ferrofluid
[10]
from FerrofluidsCorp.
wasadded to the
lyotropic
mixtures tohelp
thealigne-
ment under weak
magnetic
field(typically
100G).
This addition of ferrofluid does not
change
thetemperature
transitions and thegeneral
features of theX-ray
diffractionpatterns
as has been checked.X-RAY DIFFRACTION. -
Samples
are sealed inLindemann
glass capillaries
of 1.5 mm diameterplaced
in the vertical direction in atemperature
controlledstage (stability
of ± 0.2°C). X-ray
diffrac-tion
patterns
were obtained at fixedtemperatures :
24.4 °C for thesamples
Sl andS2 ;
24.0 °C for thesamples
S3 and S4. The axis of thecapillary
isperpendicular
to both themagnetic
field(3 kG)
andthe
X-ray beam,
in a transmissiongeometry. X-ray
diffraction
patterns
are obtainedby
thephotographic
method
using
thesynchrotron X-ray
monochromatic radiation(Ge crystal, wavelength,
A = 1.62A)
ofOrsay (Laboratoire
pour l’Utilisation duRayonne-
ment
Electromagndtique - LURE).
The mean exper- imental resolution isAq
= 4 x10- 3 A-1 (where
thescattering
vector modulus is s = 2sin 2 cp
isthe
scattering angle and q
= 27TS).
LABORATORY REFERENCES AXES. - The
magnetic
field defines the axis X of the
laboratory
frame. Thecapillary
axis isalong
the axis Y and theX-ray
beamis
along
the axis Z.Results and discussion.
1. COMMON FEATURES IN THE STRUCTURE OF THE
Nc
ANDN(*c
PHASES. - TheX-ray
diffractionpatterns
of the oriented nematicNc phases (samples
Sl and
S3)
and theNc phases (samples
S2 andS4)
inthe presence of the
magnetic
fieldpresent
the samegeneral
features : theirreciprocal
space structure may be schematized as a hollowcylinder parallel
toH with intense
edges [7].
Atypical
two-dimensional densitometer map of the diffractionpattern
obtained with theChc phase (sample S2)
untwistedby
thefield is shown in
figure
1[11].
One can observe in the diffractionpattern
the first(a-band :
hereafter wewill use this name for all the
strong
first order bandsalong
theY-axis,
for both theNc
andN c *
diffractionpatterns)
and the second order[12]
bandsalong
theY-axis, indicating
the existence of apseudo-lamellar ordering along
thisdirection,
and a more diffuseband
along
the X-axis(this
band is notclearly
visiblein
Fig.
1 because this diffractionpattern
cannot beover
exposed
- this band can be seen in Ref.[4]).
From the relative width of the
a-bands,
we canestimate the
positional
correlation in the direction ofFig.
1. - Two-dimension densitometer map of thesynchrotron X-ray
diffraction pattern ofsample
S2(calamitic
cholesteric
phase - Chc)
untwistedby
themagnetic
field H :phase N c *.
Axes X and Y of thelaboratory
frame. Thecapillary
is set up in the vertical direction in theplane
of thefigure.
T = 24.4 °C. The first-order diffraction bandalong
the axis Y is named a-band.
the Y-axis.
Using
Scherrer’sexpression [13]
we findthe
positional
order to extendalong
this direction to about 200A ( = 5
lamellardistances)
in all thesamples.
The measurements of thescattering
vectormodulus
along
the Y-axis and the X-axis show that theseperiodicities
are :Sy 1.= (41.0 ± 0.2) A
andSx 1 = (60 ± 1) A- 1 respectively
in both the Sl andS2
samples ; Sy 1 = (50.0
±0.5) A
andSx 1 = (110
±1) A
in both the S3 and S4samples.
The existence of the first and second order bands
along
the Y-axis and the sameperiodicities
in thenematic and cholesteric
samples
indicate that thepseudo-lamellar ordering previously
observed in the nematic structure[7],
is maintained even after the chiral moleculedoping
in theNc* phase.
2. DIFFERENCES BETWEEN THE STRUCTURES OF THE
Nc
AND THENt
PHASES. - Even if thegeneral
features of the diffraction
patterns
of the orientedNc
andNt phases
are the same, a difference in theshape
of thestrong
first order band(a-band
ofFig. 1)
in the case of the BSdoping
can be detected.To
analyse
theshape
of this diffraction band wemeasured the diffracted
intensity
I in theplane
X Yfrom the 2D densitometer maps.
Figure
2 shows asketch of the
pattern
with the local axes X Y and theangle
0. p is theposition
of the diffractedintensity
maximum as a function of 0
(po corresponds
to03B8 =
0°).
The diffractedintensity
of the a-band isFig.
2. - Sketch of theX-ray
diffraction pattern of a nematicN, phase
with the local axes X Y and theangle
8.p is the
position
of the localintensity
maximum as afunction of 0
(po corresponds
to 0 =0°).
1304
measured in
arbitrary
unitsalong
the Y-axis(Fig. 3a)
and as a function of 03B8
(Fig. 3b)
for both the orientedNc
andN c * phases (BS doping) (the
maximumintensities are
normalized).
Within our accuracy, nodifference has been detected between the
X-ray patterns
of theNc (sample S3)
andNê (sample S4) phases, doped
with the octanol.Fig.
3. - The normalizedintensity
of the a-band inarbitrary
units :(a) along
the axis Y ;(b)
as a function of 0.Yo
is a normalization constant.Nc phase (.)
andN * phase (+).
In order to
analyse
thea-band,
we first focus ourattention upon the crest
line, i. e. ,
for agiven
valueof
0,
we determine theposition
p of the diffractedintensity
maximum.Analysing
thedependence
ofI ( e , p o )
as a function of 8 one can estimate the orientational orderparameter
S. In bothNc phases
-
samples
Sl and S3 - and in theN(* phase
-sample
S4(DOC-doping)
- we obtained S = 0.85. TheN*
orientedphase (DOC-doping)
can bedescribed as a non chiral
Nc phase
with the sameliquid
order andparticularly
the same orientationalordering.
In otherwords,
the substitution off-
octanol does not affect the local
ordering
of themicelles.
For the BS
doped sample
thedescription
of theordering
is less obvious. In aliquid containing
identical micelles
(or molecules),
the diffractedintensity
is a function of[13]
the form factor of the micelles and the intermicellar interference function.If the form factor of the micelles and the interference function were
exactly
the same in both theNc
andN(*c phases,
one wouldexpect
that the maximum intensitiesalong
the a-band arc(for
different values of0, Fig. 2)
to be located at the samescattering angle 2 .0 (tan
20
=p /D,
where D is the distancebetween the
sample
and thefilm). Comparing
theNc [7]
and theN(* (Fig. 1)
diffractionpatterns
it is observed that forincreasing
valuesof 0,
the maxi-mum intensities of the a-band in the
Nê sample,
areat
decreasing
values of2 cp (i.e. p).
At 0 -40°,
themaximum
intensity
of the a-band(N* sample)
isshifted towards
large spacing
distances in the direct space of about 10 % of theoriginal pseudo-lamellar spacing
distancesY l. Figure
4 shows the relative shift of the maximumintensity
of the a-band5p = po - p, as a
function of 8. The dotscorrespond
Fig.
4. - Relative shift of the maximum diffracted inten-sity
of the a-band5 p
=1- P )
as a function of 0. ThePo Po
dots
(o) correspond
tosample
S2(N c *-brucine doping)
andthe crosses
(x )
tosamples
Sl(NJ,
S3(Nc)
and S4(N c
octanol
doping).
to
sample
S2 and the crosses(6p
=0)
tosamples Sl,
S3 and S4. The width athalf-height
of the a-bandat 0 = 40° is about three times
larger
than the widthalong
theY-axis, corresponding [13]
to apositional
correlation distance of about 50
A.
Our results indicate that the BSdoping promotes
abending
ofthe first-order diffraction a-band.
Figure
5 shows asketch of the deformation of the first order diffrac- tion
band,
inducedby
the BS(the proportions
arenot maintained in this
sketch,
the effect isamplified
to be more
visible).
Apossible
deformation of the broad and diffuse bandalong
the X-axis is not observed within our accuracy andexperimental
resolution.
The small value of the
positional
correlation distance for 8 = 40°(20
%bigger
than thespacing
distance
along
theY-axis)
indicates that the localFig.
5. - Sketch ofX-ray
diffraction patterns :(a)
usualnematic
Nc phase ; (b)
untwisted cholestericN * phase (the
proportions
are not maintained in this sketch, the effect isamplified
to be morevisible).
deformations of the
pseudo-lamellar
structureresponsible
for thebending
of the a-band are noncorrelated.
In nematic
liquid crystals
it is assumed that the interference function is that of anassembly
ofparallel aggregates
and that the orientational dis- order does not disturb the interference function. Infact,
thisassumption
issupported by
the fact that themaximum
intensity
Icorresponds always
to p = p o(see Fig. 4,
nematicsamples).
In the case of theBS
doped sample
let us firstneglect
the influence ofthe form factor of the micelles since in
lyotropic
nematics the localisation of the scattered
intensity
ismainly
due to the interference function. The centralpart
of the a-band(0 - 0° ) (BS doping)
is similar to the a-band for theundoped sample (Sl).
Thereforethe structure of the
N(* phase (S2) along
the Y-axisresembles very much the
Nc
structure(Sl).
Theouter
part
of the a-band( 8 > 20° ) corresponds
toless ordered zones, where the
pseudo-lamellar
order-ing
isdisturbed,
withlarger
mean micellarspacing
distances. If we assume that the
magnetic
field doesnot disturb the local
ordering
at a scale whichcorresponds
to theX-ray
diffractionexperiment (coherence length -
300A),
we have evidenced the presence of disordered zones in thepseudo-lamellar
structure, induced
by
the BSdoping.
Taking
into account thepossibility
of a nonuniform distribution of BS in the
sample (already evoked),
theselarge
space distances could exist in theregions
of thepseudo-lamellar
structurehighly perturbed by
the presence of the BS. In theseregions
the orderparameter
is smaller than thosetypical
of theNc phase.
This effect is more visible atlarge 0 (- 40° )
because at small 0 theintensity
of thea-band
(originated by
the almostunperturbed pseudo-lamellar ordering)
is veryhigh.
In a
previous
paper[14]
it waspointed
out that inthe
pseudo-lamellar
structure oflyotropic
nematicsthere is a
large
number ofedge
dislocations. Theseedge
dislocations in fact are needed to account for thegood fluidity
of the nematicphases,
inspite
oftheir lamellar structure. These numerous
aperiodic objects
areresponsible
for the diffuseX-ray
scat-tering
observedalong
theaxis-Y,
around the a-bandin both
Nc
andNê phases.
Taking
into account that the brucine moleculesionize in the presence of water
[2],
weexpect
thatthe brucine ions are
preferentially
located in thehydrophilic regions
of theN(*
structure. The reten- tion of the samesy 1
and width of the a-bandalong
the Y-axis is consistent with this
assumption.
If theBS were
placed
in thehydrophobic region
of themicelles,
the available volume of theparaffinic
chains of the
amphiphilic
molecules would besignifi- cantly
reduced tokeep
the samesy 1.
Apossible
origin
of thebending
of the a-band tolarger spacing
distances for 9 > 20°
(see Fig. 4)
is the existence ofedge
dislocations swollenby
the BS ions(the
BSdimensions are 6.5 x 10 x 16
A). Considering
thatthe brucine
sulphate
iscompletely
ionized[2], sample
S2 has about one brucine ion per micelle[15, 16].
As the structure of theNc (or Nê)
ispseudo-
lamellar and not
lamellar,
the swollenregions
arenot
necessarily compensated by compressed regions,
which could supress this excess of
bending
of the a-band
i.e.,
could make8 p
= 0. The presence of the brucine in theedge
dislocations could thus induce alocal micellar deformation which increases the spac-
ing
distances forincreasing
values of 0.The
swelling
ofedge
dislocations is not theonly possibility
for the BS molecules to make a local deformation of the structure. The samething
couldalso
happen
if the BS molecules were included in thepseudo-lamellar
structure near the micelleedge.
This could also
produce
micellar deformations in-creasing
thespacing
distances atlarge 0,
butkeeping
SY 1
constant.Comparing
the values of the molar concentrationMa
for both S2 and S4samples (Experimental section)
we observe that about 40 times moreoctanol than BS is needed to
produce
the samecholesteric
pitch.
This fact indicate that BS is moreefficient to induce the cholesteric structure in a
previous lyonematic pseudo-lamellar
structure. The local deformation thepseudo-lamellar
structure(ori- ginated by
theswelling
ofedge
dislocations and/orby
the deformations of the micelles near theiredges)
is observed in our
experiment, only
in cholestericsamples doped
with BS and not in cholestericsamples doped
with octanol.Considering
that thecholesteric structure in a
lyotropic mesophase
isachieved
by
the twist of theoriginal lyonematic pseudo-lamellar
structure(by
means of thedoping
with a chiral
agent),
two different processes seem to exist :- if the chiral molecule is an
amphiphile,
it canbe
integrated
to the micellesinducing
the cholesteric twist of thepseudo-lamellar
structure, without intro-ducing strong
local deformations of theoriginal lyonematic
structure ;- if the chiral molecule is not an
amphiphile,
it isprobably
notdirectly incorporated
to the micellesand the twist of the
original pseudo-lamellar
struc-ture, to
give
a cholestericordering,
is achieved witha
great
number ofstrong (detected
in the diffractionpattern)
local deformations in thepseudo-lamellar
structure. The presence of the
big
BS molecule(its
volume is about 1/3 of the
typical
micellar volume[14])
between the micelles could act asstrange
bodies in thepseudo-lamellar
structure.Conclusions.
In
conclusion,
we observe that thepseudo-lamellar
ordering
characteristic of thelyotropic
nematic struc-1306
ture, is maintained
along
the Y-axis in the cholestericNê phases (BS
or octanoldoping).
In the case of theoctanol
doping,
where thequiral
molecules areincorporated
inside themicelles,
both theNc
andN c * phases present
the samemicroscopic
structures.On the other
hand,
the presence oflarge
chiralmolecules
(BS)
in thepseudo-lamellar
structure,probably
notdirectly incorporated
to themicelles,
modifies thereciprocal image
of theN(*c phase compared
to that of the usualNc.
Thereciprocal
image
of theN(*c phase
in this case could beexplained by
non correlated localperturbations
ofthe
pseudo-lamellar
structure.Acknowledgments.
,It is a
pleasure
to thank Dr. S.Megtert
for hishelp
inthe
synchrotron
measurements. This work was done underpartial
finantialsupports
of theCNPq (Brazil)
and CNRS
(France).
References
[1]
RADLEY, K., REEVES, L. W. and TRACEY, A. S., J.Phys.
Chem. 80(1976)
174.[2]
RADLEY, K. andSAUPE,
A., Mol.Phys.
35(1978)
1405.
[3]
YU, L. J. and SAUPE, A., J. Am. Chem. Soc. 102(1980)
4879.[4]
FIGUEIREDO NETO, A. M., LIÉBERT, L. and LEVELUT, A. M., J.Phys.
France 45(1984)
1505.
[5]
FIGUEIREDO NETO, A. M.,GALERNE,
Y. and LIÉBERT, L., J.Phys.
Chem. 89(1985)
3939.[6]
YU, J. L. and SAUPE, A.,Phys.
Rev. Lett., 45(1980)
1000.
[7]
FIGUEIREDO NETO, A. M., GALERNE, Y., LEVELUT,A. M. and LIÉBERT, L., J.
Phys.
Lett. France 46(1985)
L-499.[8]
DE GENNES, P. G., ThePhysics
ofLiquid Crystals,
Eds. W. Marshall and D. H. Wilkinson
(Claren-
don Press -
Oxford)
1975.[9]
FIGUEIREDO NETO, A. M., LIÉBERT, L. and GALERNE, Y., J.Phys.
Chem. 89(1985)
3737.[10]
FIGUEIREDO NETO, A. M., LEVELUT, A. M., LIÉBERT, L. and GALERNE, Y., Mol.Cryst. Liq.
Cryst.
129(1985)
191.[11]
Thetypical
diffraction patterns of orientedNc phase
werepublished
elsewhere ; see refer-ence
[7].
[12]
The second order band is notclearly
visible infigure
1 because the diffraction pattern necessary for the 2D microdensitometeranalysis
cannothave the first order band over
exposed.
We haveobserved the second order band in patterns with
typical
exposure times of about 15 min.[13]
GUINIER, A., Théorie etTechnique
de la Radiocris-tallographie (Dunod - Paris)
1956.[14]
GALERNE, Y., FIGUEIREDO NETO, A. M., LIÉBERT, L., J. Chem.Phys.
87(1987)
1851.[15]
HENDRIKX, Y.,CHARVOLIN,
J., RAWISO, M., LIÉBERT, L. and HOLMES, M. C., J.Phys.
Chem. 87
(1983)
3991.[16]
The estimatedaggregation
number of a micelle is about 200. See reference[15]