Math-Net.Ru
Общероссийский математический портал
В. Л. Эпштейн, Антропоцентрическое информационное взаимодействие (вопро- сы терминологии), Пробл. управл., 2003, выпуск 1, 28–33
Использование Общероссийского математического портала Math-Net.Ru подразумевает, что вы прочитали и согласны с пользовательским соглашением
http://www.mathnet.ru/rus/agreement Параметры загрузки:
IP: 139.59.245.186
7 ноября 2022 г., 00:59:22
«¨²¥° ²³°
(RP 6% 'HVLFLRQ VXSSRUW V\VWHPV UHVHDUFK UHIHUHQFH GLVFL SOLQHVDQGDFXPXODWLYHWUDGLWLRQ7KH,QWHUQDWLRQDO-RXUQDORI 0DQDJHPHQW6FLHQFHÜÜ9RO¢ÜcÜ È¯ÒËm|jlº }ºmÒplzÈË°mËÓÓ©Ëä˺©¹¯Ò
Ó«Ò«¯Ë ËÓÒ®ÜlsÈ}È
6LPRQRYLF$6ORERGDQ3'HFLVLRQVXSSRUWIRUVXVWDLQDEOHZD WHUUHVRXUFHVGHYHORSPHQWLQZDWHUUHVRXUFHVSODQQLQJLQD FKDQJLQJZRUOG3URFHHGLQJRI,QWHUQDWLRQDO81(6&2V\P SRVLXPÜ.DUOVUXKH*HUPDQ\Ü3W,,,ÜcÜ *LQ]EHUJ0-6WRKU($$GHFLVLRQVXSSRUW,VVXHVDQG3HU
VSHFWLYHV3URFHVVHVDQG7RROVIRU'HFLVLRQ6XSSRUWÜ$P VWHUGDP1RUWKÜsROODQG3XEO&R
¯È²ËÓ˯wk{ºÏäºÎÓº°ÒÒ¯ËÈãÒÏÈÒ«}ºä¹Ë¯Ó©²
°Ò°Ë乺˯Î}Ò¹¯ÒÓ«Ò«¯Ë ËÓÒ®jÏmË°Ò«cksË º¯Ò«Ò°¹º°º©¹¯ÈmãËÓÒ«ÜÜ¢Üv Ü ¯È²ËÓ˯wkzºä¹Ë¯ÓÈ«¹ºË¯Î}ȹ˯˺mº¯ºm¹¯Ò
°ºãÈ°ºmÈÓÒÒ¹¯ÈmãËÓË°}Ò²¯Ë ËÓÒ®Ülvjsp
7XUEDQ('HFLVLRQVXSSRUWDQGH[SHUWV\VWHPVÜ1<0D[
ZHOO0DFPLOODQÜc
lºÒ°ËËm ss ¯ËÒ°ãºmÒË |¯ãºm°}Ò® vk ¯ºãËä©
¹¯ÒÓ«Ò«¯Ë ËÓÒ®¹¯ÒÓËË}º®Ò°²ºÓº®ÒÓÁº¯äÈÒÒÜ lsÈ}È
ȯÒËm|jsË}ºº¯©Ë¹¯ºãËä©Ò°}°°mËÓÓººÒÓËã ãË}Èv¯{sjjvjÜÜ¢ÜvÜ j¯Ò}ºm{k¯ËÓËm{scÈ°¹¯ËËãËÓÓ©Ë°Ò°Ë䩹¯ÒÓ«
Ò«¯Ë ËÓÒ®ÜlsÈ}È
¯È²ËÓ˯ wk vË}ÒmÓº° m }ºä¹Ë¯Óº® ¹º ˯Î}˹¯ÈmãËÓË°}Ò²¯Ë ËÓÒ®Ülvjsp
b˯ È}ºm{lj°°ã˺mÈÓÒËÒ¯ÈϯȺ}Èä˺ºmÒ¹¯º
¯ÈääÓ©²°Ò°Ë乺˯Î}Ò¹¯ÒÓ«Ò«¯Ë ËÓÒ®m¯ËÏm©
Ȯө²°ÒÈÒ«²°m«ÏÈÓÓ©²°¯ÈÒºÈ}ÒmÓ©äÏȯÈÎËÓÒ Ëäº}¯ÎÈË®°¯Ë©iÒ°¯È˲ÓÓÈ}ÜljÓ
¹¯ºãË乯ÈmãËÓÒ«
ÈÓ}ºmÈ k ¯È²ËÓ˯ wk vË}ÒmÓº° m ÒÓËã ãË}ÈãÓºäÈÓÈãÒÏËÈÓÓ©²ljÓ¹¯ºãË乯ÈmãË ÓÒ«rËãËÓ}Ò®kn˺°ËËmÈjs¯ºÓºÏÒ¯ºmÈÓÒË°º°º«ÓÒ«
ÒÓÈäÒË°}Ò²°ãºÎÓ©²°Ò°Ëäm°ãºmÒ«²Ó˺¹¯ËËãËÓ Óº°ÒÜl{¡cks
¯È²ËÓ˯wkzºä¹Ë¯ÓÈ«¹ºË¯Î}ȹ¯ÒÓ«Ò«¯Ë ËÓÒ®Ülvjsp
ºãºmËÓ}º{r¯ºÓºÏÒ¯ºmÈÓÒËm¯ËäËÓÓ©²¯«ºm¹º¯ÈÏ Óº¯ºÓº®ÒÓÁº¯äÈÒÒÜsºmº°ÒÒ¯°}sÈ}È ¯È²ËÓ˯ wk kÓÈãÒÏ mËËÓÒ«Ëãºm©² ¹Ë¯Ëºmº¯ºm °
¹ºäº}ºä¹Ë¯Ó©²°Ò°Ë乺˯Î}Ò¹¯ÒÓ«Ò«
¯¹¹ºm©²¯Ë ËÓÒ®jÏmcks˺¯Ò«Ò°Ò°Ë䩹
¯ÈmãËÓÒ«ÜÜ¢ÜvÜ
)DEHOOD59*HQHUDOL]HGVKDULQJPHPEHUVKLSVL]HDQG3DUHWR HIILFLHQF\LQWHDPV7KHRU\DQG'HFLVLRQÜÜ¢Ü 3Ü7KLHVVHQ (0 /RXFNV '3 6WHGLQJHU -5 &RPSXWHUDVVLVWHG QHJRWLDWLRQVRIZDWHUUHVRXUFHVFRQIOLFWV*URXS'HFLVLRQV DQG1HJRWLDWLRQÜÜ¢Ü3Ü
(PDLOWUDFKW#LSXUVVLUX R
³¤ª
²°®¯®¶¥²°¨·¥±ª®¥¨´®°¬ ¶¨®®¥
¢§ ¨¬®¤¥©±²¢¨¥ÂÎÏÐÎÑÛÒÅÐÌÈÍÎËÎÃÈÈ
¢«½ÏØÒÅÉÍ
¯ËÎËËä°¹º¯ÒÈmȮ˺ºmº¯Òä°«ºË¯äÒÓȲ {ºã˯
¢¢¥¤¥¨¥
¯ºãËäÈ ÒÓÁº¯äÈÒºÓÓºº mÏÈÒäºË®°mÒ«
ËãºmË}È°}ºä¹Ë¯ºä«mã«Ë°«ºÓº®ÒÏmÈÎ ÓË® Ò² ÓÈÓ©² ¹¯ºãËä ¹º°ÒÓ°¯ÒÈãÓºº ºË°mÈ
wº°ãËËÒϺº¹¯º°ººÁÈ}Ⱥm¹º°
ÒÓ°¯ÒÈãÓ ª¹º² ÏÓÈÓÒË °¯}¯Ò¯ºmÈÓ ÓÈ« ÒÓÁº¯äÈÒ« ¯ËÏãÈ© ÁÓÈäËÓÈãÓ©² Ò°°ã˺mÈÓÒ® ÈÎË ÓËÏÈm˯ ËÓÓ©² °ÈÓºm«°«
ºËÓº¯ºÒäºmȯºäÒãÈmө乯ºÒÏmº°mËÓ
Ó©ä¯Ë°¯°ºä>@È}ºä¹Ë¯Üº°Óºmө亯
ÒËä¯ÈËÓ©²¹¯Ë¹ºÈmÈËãË®ÈÒ²°«äË ÓËÎ˯ºm¹ºãÒÒË°}Ҳ˫ËãË®m°Ë²½¯ÈºÓÒ }ºmÏÓÈÓÒ« NQRZOHGJHZRUNHUV
|°ÎÈ°«¹ºÓ«Ò«Ò°ººmË°mÒËÒä˯äÒÓ©kÓ¯º¹ºËÓ¯ÒË°}ºËÒÓÁº¯äÈ ÒºÓÓºËmÏÈÒäºË®°mÒË~ÓÈÓÒËjÓÁº¯äÈÒ«jÓÁº¯äÈÒºÓÓ©®ºË}¯ÈÓãÈÏÓÈ ÓÒ«kÓ¯º¹ºËÓ¯ÒË°}È«ÈÏÈÏÓÈÓÒ®
.QRZOHGJH ZRUNHUV .: Ü ÓºmÈ« °ºÒÈãÓÈ«¯¹¹È m
¹º°ÒÓ°¯ÒÈãÓ©²°¯ÈÓȲ㫺ºÏÓÈËÓÒ«}ºº¯º®m¯°
°}ºä«Ï©}ËËËÓ˺˹¯ÒÓ«ººÓÈÏmÈÓÒ« Ò°ãËÓÓº°
.:°º°Èmã«ËºãËË°ºmº}¹Óº®¯ÈºË®°Òã©vbkm
ºm¯Ëä«}È}Ò°ãËÓÓº°ÁȯÒÓº¹¯ºÒÏmº°mËÓÓºº¹Ë¯
°ºÓÈãÈ°ÓÒÏÈãÈ°º>@
sjºÈËm°}Ò®¹Ò°Èã½Ë¯m©Ë¹ºÓ«Ò«°
}ºº¯©² ÓÈÒÓÈË°« }È}È«ãÒº ÓÈ}ȺãÎÓ©
© «°Ó© Ò ¹¯ÒmËËÓ© } °Èäºä ÓÈÒäËÓ Ëä
Ò°ã >@
zÒ°ãÈ}Ò²¹Ë¯m©²¹ºÓ«Ò®ÒÓÁº¯äÈÒºÓ ÓººmÏÈÒäºË®°mÒ«ËãºmË}È°}ºä¹Ë¯ºäº
Óº°«°«~ÓÈÓÒËÒjÓÁº¯äÈÒ«|°ºËÓÓº°ªÒ²
¹ºÓ«Ò®°º°ºÒmºäº~ÓÈÓÒËÒjÓÁº¯äÈÒ«
«mã«°«ºËÓÈÓ©äÒ}È˺¯Ò«äÒ¹º¯Ëã«
°«m¯ÈÏÓ©²ÓÈÓ©²Ò°Ò¹ãÒÓȲÒm¹ºm°Ë ÓËmÓºäºÒ²ºËÓº¹¯Òªºä¹º¯Ëã«°«m¯ÈÏ ãÒÓ©²ÏÓÈËÓÒ«²{ºÏÓÒ}ÈËmº¹¯º°}È}¹¯ÒÈ
ªÒä «Ï©}ºm©ä ÏÓÈ}Èä º¹¯ËËãËÓÓ©® °ä©°ã m }ºÓË}°ËÒÓÁº¯äÈÒºÓÓººmÏÈÒäºË®°mÒ«Ë㺠mË}È°}ºä¹Ë¯ºäÈÏÓÈҺ˰¹ËÒºã ÓÈËÎÓº°Ò°¯ºº°mÒ²¹º¯ËãËÓÒÒ}È}m ÓÈÓ©²Ò°°ã˺mÈÓÒ«²È}Òm¹¯Ò}ãÈÓ©²¯ÈÏ
¯Èº}Ȳ
iÈÓÓÈ«°È«¹º°m«ËÓȹºÓ«Ò«äÒ°ººmË
°mÒäÒä˯äÒÓÈäkÓ¯º¹ºËÓ¯ÒË°}ºËÒÓ Áº¯äÈÒºÓÓºË mÏÈÒäºË®°mÒË ~ÓÈÓÒË jÓÁº¯äÈ Ò«jÓÁº¯äÈÒºÓÓ©®ºË}¯ÈÓãÈÏÓÈÓÒ«kÓ
¯º¹ºËÓ¯ÒË°}È«ÈÏÈÏÓÈÓÒ®
p°ãÒ ¹¯ËãÈÈËä©® ¹º²º «mÒ°« Òä¹ã°ºä ã«Ò°}°°ÒÒ ¹º mº¹¯º°Èä ÒÓÁº¯äÈÒºÓÓºº mÏÈÒäºË®°mÒ«ËãºmË}È ° }ºä¹Ë¯ºä m ¹¯º Ë°°È²¹¯Òº¯ËËÓÒ«Ò°¹ºãϺmÈÓÒ«ÒËÓ˯ÈÒÒ ÏÓÈÓÒ®ºËãÈÓÓº®°ÈÒ˺°ÒÓÈ
²°®¯®¶¥²°¨·¥±ª®¥¨´®°¬ ¶¨®®¥
¢§ ¨¬®¤¥©±²¢¨¥
{°ºm¯ËäËÓÓº®ÓÈӺ˲ÓÒË°}º®ãÒË¯È¯Ë Ò m vlj m©¯ÈÎËÓÒË ½ÒÓÁº¯äÈÒºÓÓºË mÏÈÒäº Ë®°mÒË Ò¯º}ºÒ°¹ºãÏË°«ËÏ°ÈÓºmãËÓÒ«
ÒãÒºÓËÓÒ«°m«ÏÒªºº«Ï©}ºmººm©¯ÈÎËÓÒ«
°Ë人ӺºÏÓÈÈË}È}ÏÓÈ}«Ï©}È
{¯ÈºË>@˯äÒÓjÓÁº¯äÈÒºÓÓºËmÏÈÒäºË®
°mÒË}ÈÎË°« m¹Ë¯m©Ë º¹¯ËËãËÓ }È} ¹¯ºË°°
ÒÏäËÓËÓÒ« ÏÓÈÓÒ® ½{ÏÈÒäºË®°mÒË ºË}ºm
¹¯Òmº«ËË}ÒÏäËÓËÓÒÏÓÈÓÒ®²º«©mºÓºä ÒÏÓÒ²ËäÓÈÏ©mÈÒÓÁº¯äÈÒºÓÓ©ämÏÈÒäº Ë®°mÒËä
p°ãÒºÓÒäÒÏÈ}Ò²ºË}ºm«mã«Ë°«}ºä¹
˯ȯÒäÏÓÈÓÒ«}ºº¯ººÒÏäËÓ«°«ÜË ãºmË}ºÈ}º®mÒÒÓÁº¯äÈÒºÓÓººmÏÈÒäºË®
°mÒ«äºÎË©ÓÈÏmÈÓkÓ¯º¹ºËÓ¯ÒË°}ÒäÒÓ Áº¯äÈÒºÓÓ©ämÏÈÒäºË®°mÒËäkj{
¯ÒªºäºÓÈ}ºº°ÈË°«°ºm˯ ËÓÓºÓË«°
Óº®°Óº°ªºº¹ºÓ«Ò«Ü˺º°ÓºmÓ©Ë°¹Ë ÒÁÒË°}Ò˹¯ÒÏÓÈ}Ò
|¯ÈÒämÓÒäÈÓÒËÓÈ°ãËËË
z kj{ܪº¹°Ò²ÒË°}Ò®¹¯ºË°°°m«ÏÈÓÓ©®°
ä© ãËÓÒËä ¹Èä« mÓÒäÈÓÒËä Ò äºÒmÈ ÒË®
z kj{ܪº¹¯ºË°°¹¯ÈmãËÓÒ«mÒÎËÓÒËäÓ˺
°«ÏÈË䩲½ÒÓÁº¯äÈÒºÓÓ©² ºË}ºm
z kj{ܪº¹¯ºË°°¹¯ÈmãËÓÒ«°¹°Ò²ÒË°}º®
º¯ÈÓº®°m«Ï
z ËãËmº®ÁÓ}ÒË®kj{«mã«Ë°«¹¯Òº¯ËËÓÒË
~ÓÈÓÒ® Ó˺²ºÒ䩲vË}kj{vkj{
ã«°¹Ë ÓººmÏÈÒäºË®°mÒ«°º®°¯Ëº®m }ºº¯º®ºÓÎÒmË
z äºÒm©ËãÒËãÒÏÈÈÒÒ¹°Ò²ºÁÒÏÒºãºÒ Ë°}Ò˲ȯÈ}˯ҰÒ}Òvkj{äºÒÏäËÓ«°«
m¹¯ºË°°ËÒÓÁº¯äÈÒºÓÓººmÏÈÒäºË®°mÒ«
mÈ°Óº°Ò¹ºmãÒ«ÓÒËäjÓÁº¯äÈÒÒÒÏmãË }ÈË亮ÒÏ}ºä¹Ë¯È
z ˲ÓÒË°}È«¯ËÈãÒÏÈÒ«kj{¹ºÏmºã«Ëvkj{
m©Ëã« ÒÓÁº¯äÈÒmÓºË °ºË¯ÎÈÓÒË m mÒÒ ä©²ÓÈ˯äÒÓÈãȲ}ºä¹Ë¯Èm˯ÈãÓ©²Ò ÓËm˯ÈãÓ©² ºË}Ȳ °º¹º°Èmã« mº°¹¯Ò ÓÒäÈËä©ËºË}©°²¯ÈÓ«ÒäÒ°«m˺¹Èä«Ò
¹¯ËÎÓÒäÒÒ²º¯ÈÎËÓÒ«äÒ°ººÓº°ÒÒ²}º äÒãÒÒÓºä°ËäÈÓÒË°}ºä}ãÈ°°ÏȹºäÒ ÓÈÒÏäËÓËÓÓvÒ°Ëä~ÓÈÓÒ®
j°²º« ÒÏ °}ÈÏÈÓÓººkÓ¯º¹ºËÓ¯ÒË°}Òä ÒÓÁº¯äÈÒºÓÓ©ä mÏÈÒäºË®°mÒËä Ëä ÓÈÏ©
mȹ¯Èmã«Ëä©®ËãºmË}ºä¹¯ºË°°ÒÏmãËËÓÒ«
jÓÁº¯äÈÒÒÒϹÈä«Ò}ºä¹Ë¯È°ËãÒÏäË ÓËÓÒ«vÒ°Ëä©~ÓÈÓÒ®m¹Èä«ÒËãºmË}È
{}ãËÓÒËËãºmË}Èm¹¯ºË°°kj{m}ÈË°mË Óº°ÒË㫺¯ÈÎËÓÒ«Ò¹ºmËËÓÒ«È˺°ÓºmÈÓÒË
¯È}ºmÈkj{}È}º°ºÈ°ÓÁº¯ä¹¯º Ë°°È ¹ºÏÓÈÓÒ« ÒÓÒmÒÈãÓ °ºm˯ ÈËä
ÒÓÒmÒºäÒÓ˹¯ÒäËÓÒä}ºm°ËäËãºmËË
°mmËãºäÒ°¹ºãÏm}ÈË°mËÒ°ºÓÒ}È ÒÓÁº¯äÈÒÒ}ºä¹Ë¯Òº¯ÈÓÒËÓÓ}ºÓË}°
ºäÏÓÈÓÒ®¹¯Ë°ÈmãËÓÓ©²m¹Èä«Ò}ºä¹Ë¯È
~Ë°ÒÈã Ë°¹ËÒÈãÓ©Ë˯äÒÓ©kj{m©Ëã«°«
¹¯º¹Ò°Óº®}mº®Ò}¯°Òmºä
{ º©ËÓÓºä «Ï©}Ë ½mÏÈÒäºË®°mÒË ¹ºÓÒäÈË°« }È}
½mÏÈÒäÓÈ«°m«Ïm²«mãËÓÒ® >@{ãºÒ}Ë}È}½m°ËºÈ«
Áº¯äÈ°m«ÏÒ¹¯Ëä˺m«mãËÓÒ®ºË}ÒmÓº®Ë®°mÒËã Óº°ÒÈÈ}ÎË°m«ÏÒä©°ãË®«mã«Ò²°«ºº¯ÈÎËÓÒËä
¹¯Ëä˺m«mãËÓÒ®ÒÒ²°m«ÏˮҺӺ ËÓÒ®m°ºÏÓÈÓÒÒË ãºmË}È >@{ÁÒ㺰ºÁÒÒ}È}½¹¯ºË°°mÏÈÒäÓººmãÒ«ÓÒ«
Ëã¯ÓȯȹËä¹Ë¯ËÓº°ÈäÈ˯ÒÒÒmÒÎËÓÒ«ÓÒ m˯°ÈãÓÈ«Áº¯äÈÒÏäËÓËÓÒ«°º°º«ÓÒ«Ëã{ªºä°ä©°ãË wÓËã°º¹¯ËËã«ãmÏÈÒäºË®°mÒË}È}}ºÓËÓ¹¯ÒÒÓ
m°Ëº°Ë°m˺ÏÈ}ºº¯º®Ó˯ҲºãËËÁÓÈäËÓ
ÈãÓ©²º¹¯ËËã«Ò²°mº®°m >@
|¹¯ËËã«ÒäÒ ¹¯ÒÏÓÈ}ÈäÒ ¹°Ò²Ò}Ò «mã«°« º¯È ÎËÓÒËÈË˺¯ÈϹ¯ËäËÓº®°¯Ë©m}ºº¯º®Ë®°m
ÎÒm©Ë°Ë°mÈÒ²º¯ÒËÓÈÒ«mªº®°¯ËËÒºmãËmº
¯ËÓÒ˹º¯ËÓº°Òm}ºÓÈ}Ȳ°ÓËwÒ}ºÓÈ}©m°mº ºË¯Ë¹º¹¯ÒÓÒ¹º¯ÈÓº®°m«ÏÒ}ºÓ¯ºãÒ¯¹¯ÈmÒã Óº°º¯ÈÎËÓÒ«>@
º ½°Ë}ºä mÓº°ËºãºÒÒ ¹ºÓÒäÈË°« ½È}ÒmÓº Ë®°mÒ®Ò¹ºÏÓÈÒ®ºãÈÈÒ®°ºÏÓÈÓÒËäÒmºãË®
ÒÓÒmÒÒãÒ°ºÒÈãÓÈ«¯¹¹È >@
zÈ} °¹ËÒÈãÓ©® ¹¯ËäË Ò°°ã˺mÈÓÒ«kj{
äºÎËÒÏÈ°«°º°º¯ºÓ©¹¯ºË°°È¹Ë¯Ë¯Èº}Ò ÒÓÁº¯äÈÒÒ mº°¹¯ÒÓÒäÈË亮 ° }ºä¹Ë¯Ó©²
˯äÒÓÈãºmÒ°º°º¯ºÓ©Ò°¹ºãϺmÈÓÒ«ÒÓ˯Ò
¯ºmÈÓÓº®ËãºmË}ºäÈ ÒÓÓº®°Ò°Ëä©ÏÓÈÓÒ®
zÈÎÈ«ÒϪҲ°º¯ºÓÒäË˺Ӻ°ÒËãÓ°È äº°º«ËãÓº°¹ºªºämÒ°°ã˺mÈÓÒÒäºÎË
¹¯ËºãÈÈ ÈÓÈãÒÏ ¹¯ºË°°ÈãÓº® ÒãÒ ¹¯º}
ÒºÓÓº®°º¯ºÓ©°ËºäÒ²ËÒÓ°mÈÒmÏÈÒäÓº®
°m«ÏÒ{°ËªºÈ˺°ÓºmÈÓÒ˲ȯÈ}˯ÒϺmÈkj{
}È}ÁÓÈäËÓÈãÓÓÈÓÒ°Ò¹ãÒÓº²mÈ
©mÈÒÒÓ˯ү¹¯Ë°ÈmãËÓÒ«¯È ÒÒºÓÓ©²ÓÈ}ºä© ãËÓÒÒÁÒ㺰ºÁÒÒãºÒ }Ò ¹°Ò²ºãºÒÒÒ¯ ° ¹¯Ë°ÈmãËÓÒ«äÒ °ºm¯Ë äËÓÓº® ˺¯ÒÒ ¹¯ÈmãËÓÒ« Ò mºÏäºÎÓº°«äÒ Óºm©²ÒÓÁº¯äÈÒºÓÓ©²Ë²ÓºãºÒ®
§ ¨¥¢ª®²¥ª±²¥ ¨¢
ºË°~ÓÈÓÒË"
|ÓÒÓÈ}񼊩 ãËÓÒÒÁÒ㺰ºÁÒ«ãºÒ}ÈÒ Ò² ¹º¯ÈÏËãËÓÒ« ¯È°°äȯÒmÈ ÏÓÈÓÒË }È}
¹¯Ë°ÈmãËÓÓ©®mÏÓÈ}ºmº®Áº¯ä˹¯º}¹ºÏÓÈ mÈËãÓº®Ë«ËãÓº°ÒËãºmËË°mÈmºm¯Ëä«
}È}¯ÒË Óȹ¯Òä˯ ¹°Ò²ºãºÒ« ÁÒÏÒºãºÒ«
m©° Ë® Ó˯mÓº®Ë«ËãÓº°Ò Ò¯ °ººÓº°«
ÏÓÈÓÒË°¹ºÏÓÈmÈËãÓº®Ë«ËãÓº°ËãºmË}È
È}Òä º¯ÈÏºä °Ë°m }È} ©mÈ mÒÈ
~ÓÈÓÒ«|Óº«mã«ËË°«¹¯º}ºäºÓºËÓËÏÈ
¯ºËÜÁÒãºËÓËÏÈ
|ÓºËÓËÒË°}ºË~ÓÈÓÒË«mã«Ë°«¹Ë¯mÒÓ©ä Ò½ÓËÒ¯ÈÎÒ¯Ëä©ä ÏÓÈÓÒ«pm}ãÒÈw®Ó Ë®
ÓÈ ãºº ¯ºº ÒÓÒmÒäÈ ÓËmºÏäºÎÓº ÈËÓÒÓº¹Ë¯ËÈ}ºäãÒºËËmºäÒ°ãË Ò²}ãºÓÈä°Ò°ËäÈäÓË°ÒË°}Ò²°ã˺mÁº¯äÒ
¯Ë°« m ºÓºËÓËÏË Ë¯ËÈmÈ Ò ½Ò¯ÈÎÒ¯º mÈ äºÎÓººã}ººãËËÒãÒäËÓËËÈË}mÈÓºË
¯Ë°ÈmãËÓÒËÏÓÈÓÒ«Óº°ÒËãËä}ºº¯©²«mã«Ë
°« º ÒãÒ ÒÓº® ËÓ©® ¹ËȺ °¹ËÒÈãÒ° Ò
¯Ë°ÈmãËÓÒËÏÓÈÓÒ«ÁÒ}°Ò¯Ë°«ÓÈÒ°}°
°mËÓÓº°ºÏÈÓÓºääÈ˯ÒÈãÓºäÓº°ÒËãËäÈ ËäÈÓÒÓºääÈ˯ÒÈãËÒ¯mÏÓÈ}ºmº®«Ï©
}ºmº®Áº¯äËÒËä°Èä©äm}ãÈË°«mÁÒãºË ÓËÒË°}ºËÏÓÈÓÒË
{¹¯ºË°°È²kj{mÏÈÒäºË®°mºÈªÒmÒÈ
~ÓÈÓÒ« Ü Óº°ÒËãËä ºÓºº ºÓºËÓËÒË°}ºº
«mã«Ë°«vkj{¯ººÁ¯ÈäËÓÈÁÒãºËÓËÒ Ë°}ººÏÓÈÓÒ«Ü}ºä¹Ë¯
|°Óºm©mÈ«°ÓÈ°}ÈÏÈÓÓºä°Áº¯äãÒ¯Ëä°ãË
Ò®¯«°ÎËÓÒ®
z ~ÓÈÓÒËvkj{}È}äÈ˯ÒÈãÓ©®ºË}ܪº
°Ò°ËäÈ äÓË°ÒË°}Ò² °ã˺m m }ãË}Ȳ }º¯©
˺ºãºmÓººäºÏÈ
z ~ÓÈÓÒËvkj{}È}È°¯È}Ó©®ºË}ܪº°Ò°
ËäÈ º¯ÈϺm Ò ¹ºÓ«Ò® ºÓº ËÓÒ® Ò °m«ÏË®
äËÎÓÒäÒ}ºº¯©Ëvkj{ÏÓÈËÒ¹ºÓÒäÈË
z ~ÓÈÓÒË vkj{ }È} º¯ÈÎËÓÒË ºË}ÒmÓº® ¯Ë ÈãÓº°ÒܪºäÓºÎË°mºËº¯ËÒË°}Ò²Òªä
¹Ò¯ÒË°}Ò²ÁÈ}ºm°m«ÏˮҺӺ ËÓÒ®äËÎ
ÓÒäÒ}ºº¯©Ëvkj{ÏÓÈËÒ¹ºÓÒäÈË
z jÏäËÓËÓÒË~ÓÈÓÒ®vkj{¹¯ºÒ°²ºÒm¯ËÏãÈ
Ëmº°¹¯Ò«Ò«ÒäÒÓÁº¯äÈÒÒ°}ºä¹Ë¯Ó©²
˯äÒÓÈãºmÒ¹º¯ºÎÈË亮ªÒämÓ¯ÒäºÏº mº®ä©°ãÒËãÓº®Ë«ËãÓº°Ò
~ÈäËÈÓÒ«
|äÓË°ÒË°}Ò²°ãËȲbÒ¯º}º¹¯ÒÏÓÈÓº
ºËãºmË}²¯ÈÓÒÏÓÈÓÒ«mmÒË°ã˺m½äÓË°
ÒË°}Ò²°ã˺m m}ãË}Ȳºã Ò²¹ºã ȯҮ
ºãºmÓººäºÏÈvãË©ªÒº¯ÈÏ°«Ò¯È°¹ÈÈ
°«m¹¯ºË°°È²m°mËÓÓººÒãºÒË°}ºº¹º ÏÓÈÓÒ«äÒ¯ÈmËË®ÒÒË®cËÏãÈ©m°mËÓ Óºº¹ºÏÓÈÓÒ««mã«°«°ãËÈäÒϯÒËãÓ©²Ïm
}ºm©²º°«ÏÈËãÓ©²Ò¯Ò²º¯ÈϺm˲«mãËÓÒ®
}ºº¯©Ëmº°¹¯ÒÓÒäÈËËãºmË}ȯËÏãȩ㺠ÒË°}ºº¹ºÏÓÈÓÒ«°Ë°mmmÒ˹ºÓ«Ò®Ü ä©°ãË®m©¯ÈÎËÓÓ©²°ãºmÈäÒ
nÒ㺰ºÁÒ«¯È°°äȯÒmÈËÏÓÈÓÒË}È}½¹¯º}ºË°
mËÓÓº®äÈ˯ÒÈãÓº®Ò²ºmÓº®Ë«ËãÓº°ÒãË®ÒË ÈãÓºËm©¯ÈÎËÓÒËmÏÓÈ}ºmº®Áº¯ä˺Ë}ÒmÓ©²°mº®°mÒ
°m«ÏË®äүȹ¯Ò¯ºÓººÒËãºmËË°}ºº >@ãºÒ}È}È}½Ë 㺰ÓÒ°Ò°ËäÈÒÏÒ¯ºmÈÓÓ°ºmº}¹Óº°ÓÈÓ©²¹ºÓ«
Ò®ºÏÈ}ºÓºä˯Ӻ°«²¹¯Ò¯º©ºË°mÈÒä© ãËÓÒ« >@
¹°Ò²ºãºÒ«}È}°Ò°ËäÁÈ}ºm¹ºÓ«Ò®°ÎËÓÒ®}ºº¯©Ë ÒÓÒmÒ°mºÒãÒäºÎËmº°¹¯ºÒÏmË°Ò>@
nÈ}ãÈIDFWXPÜ°ËãÈÓӺ˰ºm˯ Òm ËË°«cÈÏãÒ È¹ºÓ«Ò«ºË}ÒmÓººÒÓÈÓººÁÈ}ȺºË}Òm Ó©än¹¯ÒÓ«º¹ºÓÒäÈÓË}ºº¯ºË°º©ÒË«mãËÓÒËÁ¯È äËÓ¯ËÈãÓº°Ò}¯©Ë°º°Èm㫺Ë}ËãºmËË°}º®Ë
«ËãÓº°ÒÒãÒ¹ºÏÓÈÓÒ«sÈÓ©®nܪºº¯ÈÎËÓÒ˺
Ë}ÒmÓººÁÈ}ÈmËãºmËË°}ºä°ºÏÓÈÓÒÒ Ë˺º¹Ò°ÈÓÒË
¹º°¯Ë°mºäÓË}ºº¯ººÒ°}°°mËÓÓººÒãÒÎËË°Ë°mËÓÓºº
«Ï©}ÈsÈÓ©Ën°ãÎȺ°Óºmº®Ëº¯ËÒË°}Ò²¹º°¯º ËÓÒ®}ºº¯©Ë©ãÒ©ËÏÓÒ²ÓËmºÏäºÎÓ©ËrÒËÒ ÓÒÓ©ä«mãËÓÒËäÒãÒ°º©ÒËänÓ˺²ºÒ亰m«ÏÈÓäÓº ºº¯ÈÏÓ©äÒºÓº ËÓÒ«äÒ°¯nºªºäÓÈӺ˹ºÏÓÈ ÓÒ˺ãÎӺȹºmºÏäºÎÓº°Ò¹ºãÓ}ȯÒÓn°ºm°Ë äÒÒ²ºÓº ËÓÒ«äÒÒ°m«Ï«äÒ>@
{ÓÈ°º«ËËm¯Ëä«ÓËËÒÓº®Ëº¯ÒÒ¹Èä«ÒnÒÏҺ㺠ÒË°}ȫ˺¯Ò«mº°²º«È«}ËÓÒjÈmãºmȺÏÈ}º Óºä˯Ӻ°«²m©° Ë®Ó˯mÓº®Ë«ËãÓº°Ò¹ºãÈÈ˺
½äÓË°ÒË°}ÒË°ãË© mºÏÓÒ}È}È}ÒÏäËÓËÓÒ«m¹º¹ã«Ò
«²ÓË®¯ºÓºm}ºº¯©ËºãËȯȰ¹¯º°¯ÈÓËÓÒËÓ˯mÓ©²
¹¯ºË°°ºmm˲ÒãÒÒÓ©²Óȹ¯ÈmãËÓÒ«²rÒº²ÒäÒË°}È«Ë º¯Ò«ÒÏÈËäËÓÈãÓ©Ë°ãË©ÓÈäºãË}㫯Ӻ䯺mÓË
¯Ë¹ºãÈÈË°«ºÓ˯mÓ©®Òä¹ã°¹º°¹È«mºË¯ËÓº®
ÓË®¯ºÓm©Ï©mÈËÒÏäËÓËÓÒËm°¯}¯È²cszÒisz
©ËÒÏäËÓËÓÒ«¹º¯«}ÈÓ}ã˺ҺmmäºãË}ãËisz°Ë®È°
Î˹¯Òmº«}°ÒÓËÏÒ¯ºmÈÓÒÒÏäËÓËÓÓº®cszȺÓÈË°Ë
°mËÓÓºÓÈÒÓÈË°ºÒ¯ÈÓºm©®¯ÈÓË˺°°mºmÈm Ò®m }ãË}ȲËãº}zÈΩ®ÓË°ÈÓȯө®Ëãº}äºÎË°È¹È ä«}º®m½ÏȹҰӺ®}ÓÒÎ}Ë äºÏÈ
½ ËãºmË}Ü¹Ò ËjÈmãºmܹ¯ËÎËm°Ëºmº°¹¯Ò ÓÒäÈËË®°mÒËãÓº°Ë¯ËϹ˯m°ÒÓÈãÓ°Ò°ËäÏÈ
ËäºÓ°ÈÓºmÒ°«²ºÏ«ÒÓºäË®°mÒËãÓº°ÒÜ˯ËÏmº¯
°ÒÓÈãÓ°Ò°Ëä°ãºmº¯ËÓÈÓºËä© ãËÓÒË >@
| º¯ÈÏÓºä Ò ¹ºÓ«Ò®Óºä ä©ãËÓÒÒ |
¯ÈÏÓºËÒÈ°¯È}Ӻ˺¯ËÒË°}ºËä© ãËÓÒË«m ã«°«mÒÏmË°Óºä°ä©°ã˯ÈÏãÒÓ©äÒ°º¯ºÓÈ äÒËÒÓºº¹¯ºË°°ÈÒ¯ÈmÓºÈË}mÈÓ©äÒ°¹º°º
ÈäÒ ¹ºÏÓÈÓÒ« ¯ÈÏãÒÓ©² °º¯ºÓ ºË}ÒmÓº®
Ë®°mÒËãÓº°Ò zÈÎÈ« ÒÏ ªÒ² Áº¯ä ÒäËË
°mºÒ °Á˯© Ò¯ÈÓÒ© ªÁÁË}ÒmÓº°Ò sË}ºº
¯©®}ãÈ°°ÏÈÈãËË¯Ë Èº¹Ò¯È«°ÓÈÓÈã«
Ó©ËäºËãÒÈ㫯ººÓ˺°¹º¯Òä©Ë¹¯ËÒä
Ë°mÈÒäËËÒ°}¯°ÒmÓºËä© ãËÓÒËp°ãүȰ
°äȯÒmÈä©°ãÒËãÓË«ËãÓº°ËãºmË}È m°Á˯˺ө²ÓÈ}ËË°Ë°mËÓÓºmËãÒ}Ⱥã«
È°¯È}Ӻ˺¯ËÒË°}ºº ä© ãËÓÒ« ºÈÎË ÏË° ÓÈ ÓÈÈãÓºä ªÈ¹Ë mº¯Ë°}ºº ¹¯ºË°°È º¯ÈÏ©Ò¯È¯Ë È¯ºã>@kw®Ó Ë®Ó
¹ºªºä¹ºmº¹Ò°Èãm°mºË®mº¯Ë°}º®Òº¯È ÁÒÒ½iã«äËÓ«Ó˹ºãËÎÒ°ºäÓËÓÒºÓÈ Ë ä© ãËÓÒ˹¯ºË}ÈËmº°ÓºmÓºääÒÓ«°Òämºã©
°ãºmÈÒ}ºäÎËË°°ºÏÓÈËãÓºk}ÒmãË ÓÒ« ¹ºmÒÒäºä ÓÈ°¹ÈË ºÈ }ºÈ mº°¹
¯Ò«ÒËm°¹ÈËm}ºÓÁãÒ}°°ÈÓºmÒm Òä°«m ÓÈ° äÒ¯ºä ¹ºÓ«Ò® { ˲ °ãÈ«² }ºÈ È}º®
}ºÓÁãÒ}¹Ë¯ËÎÒmÈË°«º°¯ºÒÒÓËÓ°ÒmÓººÓm
°mººË¯Ëº}ÈÏ©mÈË°ÒãÓºËmãÒ«ÓÒËÓÈÓÈ
ä°mËÓÓ©®äÒ¯ >@
|ÏÓÈÓÒÒÒ¹ºÓÒäÈÓÒÒºÓÒäÈÓÒËÓË°ãË
Ë ººÎË°mã« ½°º ÏÓÈÓÒËä Ë °¹º°ºÓº
°ËãºmË}È°mºÒÒmº°¹¯ºÒÏmË°Ò°ää°mË ËÓÒ®m¹¯ÈmÒãÓº°Ò}ºº¯©²ºÓÓË°ºäÓËmÈË
°«¹º°}ºã}mºÏäºÎÓºÏÓÈÓÒËËϹºÓÒäÈÓÒ«Ò
¹ºÓÒäÈÓÒËËÏÏÓÈÓÒ«i㫹ºÓÒäÈÓÒ«²È¯È}˯Ӻ ºËÓÒË «°Óº® mÓ¯ËÓÓË® °m«ÏÈÓÓº°Ò º¯È ÓÒϺmÈÓÓº°Ò¯È°°äȯÒmÈË䩲«mãËÓÒ®wºäº ÎË©ãºÒË°}È«¹º¯«ºËÓÓº°«°ÓºËmÒ ËÓÒ˹¯ÒÒÓÓº°ãË°mËÓÓ©²°m«ÏË®}ºÈ¯ÈÓËË ä˲ÈÓÒË°}ҹ˯ËÒ°ãÒä©ËÁÈ}©ºËÒÓ«°«
mËÒÓãºÒË°}°Ò°Ë乺ÓÒäÈÓÒ˺}ÈÏÈ
Ëã°mÈ˺¯Ë䩹ºÓÒäÈÓÒËÁº¯äã©ÏÈ}ºÓÈË°
Ë°mºÏÓÈÓÒ« Ò >@ jÏäËÓËÓÒË ÏÓÈÓÒ« m
¹¯ºË°°Ëkj{ºÏÓÈÈ˺vkj{¯È° Ò¯«Ë°mºÒ ÏÓÈÓÒ«Òãã«Ë¹ºÓÒäÈÓÒ˺Ӻ ËÓÒ®Ò°m«
ÏË®¹¯Ëä˺mÒ«mãËÓÒ®m}ºÓË}°Ëkj{
| °¯}¯Ë ÏÓÈÓÒ® { °Èäºä ºËä mÒË
°¯}¯ÈÏÓÈÓÒ®mäË°º°ºÒÒϪãËäËÓºmº
¯ÈϺmÒ¹ºÓ«Ò®Ò°ä©°ãºm©²°m«ÏË®äËÎÓÒäÒ {ÏÈÒ亰m«ÏÈÓÓ©Ë °¯}¯© ¹¯Ë°ÈmãËÓÒ® m
°mº ºË¯Ë «mã«°« ªãËäËÓÈäÒ m °¯}¯Ë
¯Ò²°Á˯ÏÓÈÓÒ«ÈËÓÓÈ«ÒËÈãÓÈ«Áº¯äÈ ÏÓÈÓÒ®ÓÈÒºãËËÈË}mÈÓÈËä°mº®°mÈämÓË ÓË®¯ËÈãÓº°Ò}ºº¯ºÓȺ¯ÈÎÈËÓºmªº®
ÒËÈãÓº® Áº¯äË ÓË äºÎË ¹¯ºÒ°²ºÒ ºäËÓ ÏÓÈÓÒ«äÒäËΰË}ÈäÒÏÓÈÓÒ®¹ºªºäÓË º²ºÒ佫ϩ}}È}äÈ˯ÒÈãÓÈ«ººãº}Èä©°ãÒ | ¹¯Ë°ÈmãËÓÒÒ ÓÈÓºº ÏÓÈÓÒ« ¯ÒmË ËäºmºãÓºãÒÓÓÒÈ ½cËÏãÈ© ¹º ÏÓÈÓÒ«ÁÒ}°Ò¯°«¹¯ËÎËm°Ëºm¹¯ËãºÎË ÓÒ«²ººÒãÒÒÓºº«Ï©}ÈsȪº®º°ÓºmËmÓÈ}Ë
ÒϺ¯ËÈ°«º¹ºãÓÒËãÓ©Ë°¯Ë°mÈÜÁº¯ä
ã©°²Ë䩯ÈÁÒ}ÒÈãÒ©Ò¯ÒË}ºÓ°¯}
ÒÒm}ãÈËä©Ëm«Ï©}ÓÈ}Ò~Ë°m°ËºÓÒ°mº
«°«}Áº¯ä˹¯ËãºÎËÓÒ®vªº®È°¯È}ÒÒ
°º°ºÒmºäºm°«}º®«Ï©}ºmº®}ºÓ°¯}ÒÒ ÁÒ}°Ò¯Ë®ÏÓÈÓÒË°ÈmÒ°«m°ººmË°mÒËÓË }ºº¯ºËäÓºÎË°mº¹¯ËãºÎËÓÒ®ÈË}mÈÓºËË®°
º}Ò Ï¯ËÓÒ« °ºË¯ÎÈË®°« m ÓË® ÒÓÁº¯äÈÒÒ wÈÈ°¯È}Ò«°ººmË°m˺äºÒäËË ºË㺰ÓÈ}º®ËãºmË}ÈË°ÓÈm©}¹ºãϺmÈ°«
¯ÈÏãÒÓ©äÒ «Ï©}ºm©äÒ }ºÓ°¯}Ò«äÒ ¯ÈÁÒ }ÈäÒÈãÒÈäÒ°²ËäÈäÒäËÓÒ˽ÒÈ Ò²m
¹¯ËãºÎËÓÒ«²º©Óº®¯ËÒ >@
| ¹È¯ÈÒäËҹ˯Ë}°È {°Ë m© Ë°}ÈÏÈÓ ÓºËÓÈÒºãË˹ºãÓºÈ}}äãү˹ȯÈÒäÈÒ
¹Ë¯Ë}°È>Ü@m°ººmË°mÒÒ°}ºº¯º®ÏÓÈ ÓÒ« ¹¯Ò 㺮 ÒÓ˯¹¯ËÈÒÒ ªºº ¹ºÓ«Ò«
亩¯ÈÏÒ©ÓȺºÏ¯Òä©ËªãËäËÓ©¹¯Ë
°ÈmãËÓÓ©ËmmÒËË}°È¯ÈÁÒ}ÒÈÒºÒmÒË ºÒÓÁº¯äÈÒÒÒmÏÈÒ亰m«ÏÈÓө˯ÈÏãÒÓ©äÒº
Óº ËÓÒ«äÒ
¨´®°¬ ¶¨¿¢ª®²¥ª±²¥ ¨¢
{°m«ÏÒ°ËäºËãºmË}ÓËäºÎ˺¯ÈÏÒ
äÒ¯°¯ÈÏmºm°Ë®Ëº¹ºãÓºËm˺Ó˹º°¯Ë°
mËÓÓº®ËãÓº°Ò ä©°ãÒËãÓ©® ¹¯ºË°° °}ãÈ
©mÈË°«ÒϺËãÓ©²½ËÒÓÒä© ãËÓÒ« ¹¯º°
©²ÒãÒ°ãºÎÓ©²i㫺¹Ò°ÈÓÒ«mÏÈÒ亰m«ÏÒ°ÁË
¯© ÒËÈãÓºº Ò °Á˯© äÈ˯ÒÈãÓºº mmËËä
¹¯Ë°ÈmãËÓÒ˺¹¯º°©²Ò°ãºÎÓ©²½ÒÓÁº¯äÈÒ ºÓÓ©²ºË}Ȳ
jÓÁº¯äÈÒºÓÓ©äºË}ºäj|ËäÓÈÏ©
mÈ°ãºmË°ÓºãºÒË°}Ò®ÒãÒÓÈã«Óºº¯ÈÏÓ©®
ºË}mº°¹¯Ò«ÒË}ºº¯ººäºÎ˹¯ÒmË°Ò}ÒÏ äËÓËÓÒ~ÓÈÓÒ®vË}Èkj{
º°}ºã}kj{ÜÒ°}¯ËÓ©®¹¯ºË°°ºÒÏ äËÓËÓÒË~ÓÈÓÒ®vË}Èkj{ܹ˯˲ºÒϺӺ º°º°º«ÓÒ«m¯ºËܹ¯ºÒ°²ºÒm¯ËÏãÈË mº°¹¯Ò«Ò«Ò¹Ë¯Ë¯Èº}Ò°ºÏÓÈÓÒËäºË¯ËÓºº jÓÁº¯äÈÒºÓÓºººË}È
p°ãÒmº°¹¯Ò«ÒËÈÓÓººj|Ó˹¯ÒmºÒ}ÒÏ äËÓËÓÒ~ÓÈÓÒ® vkj{ ºÈÓÓ©®j| «mã««°
jÓÁº¯äÈÒºÓÓ©äºË}ºäËäÓËäËÓËËmÈÓ Ó©®äºäËÓm¯ËäËÓÒã«ÈÓÓºº¯ËÒ¹ÒËÓÈÒÓ Áº¯äÈÒË®ÓË«mã«Ë°«jÓȺº¯ºjÓÁº¯äÈÒ ºÓÓ©®ºË}«mã«Ë°«ÒÓÁº¯äÈÒˮ˰ãÒ¹¯Ò˺ mº°¹¯Ò«ÒÒm©«°Ó«Ë°«ºÈ}ÈãÓÈ«¹Èä«¯Ë Ò¹ÒËÓÈ ÓË °ºË¯ÎÒ Ëº äÓË°ÒË°}Ò² °ã˺m
²º«mºÏäºÎӺ˺°ãË©ÒäË°«mãÈËÓÓº®
¹Èä«ÒªÈ°ÒÈÒ«¹ººÓȺ®m}ºº¯º®Ë ÓÒ}ºmº¯Ò½ÏÓÈãÓºÏÈ©ã ȹËȺºmËÈËÜ
½Ó˹ºäÓÒ ÜÏÓÈÒÓËÏÓÈË
jÓÁº¯äÈÒºÓө˺Ë}©«mã«°«º¹Ë¯ÈÓÈäÒ
¹¯ºË°°Èkj{|ÓÒ亩¹¯º°©äÒÒ°ãºÎ Ó©äÒ°º°º«ÒäÒÒϹ¯º°©²
¯º°©ËÓËËãÒä©ËË㺰өËÒ¯ÈÏãÒÒä©Ë mÈÓÓºä }ºÓË}°Ë jÓÁº¯äÈÒºÓÓ©Ë ºË}©
¹¯Ë°Èmã«ÒËmÓÈã«Óºº¯ÈÏÓº®ÒãÒ°ãºmË°
ÓºãºÒË°}º®Áº¯äË˺¯ËÒË°}ÒËÒªä¹Ò¯ÒË
°}ÒËÁÈ}©¹¯ËäËÓº®ºãÈ°Òkj{ËäÓÈ Ï©mȯÈÓãÈäÒÏÓÈÓÒ«
º°¯ºÒÓÒm˯°ÈãӺ˺¹¯ËËãËÓÒ˯ÈÓã©
ÏÓÈÓÒ«ÏȯÓÒËãÓºÈäºÎË©ÒÓËmºÏäºÎ ÓºvˮȰº°ÈºÓº°}ÈÏȺ¯ÈÓãÈÏÓÈÓÒ«Ü Ó˺ °Ë°mËË Ò ¯ÈÏãÒÒäºË }È} ¹¯ËäË
ä©°ãÒ Ëä©äºÎËäºãÒÒºÓ¯ÈÓãÏÓÈ ÓÒ«º¯º®sȹ¯Òä˯}ÈÎȫ˺¯ËäÈË°¯È ÓãÈÏÓÈÓÒ«¯ÈÓãÈäÒÏÓÈÓÒ««mã«°«Ë¯äÒÓ©
Áº¯äã©ÁȯäÈ}ºãºÒË°}Ò˺¹Ò°ÈÓÒ«¹¯Ë¹È¯È
ºm°ÈÒÓº¯äÈÒmÓ©²È}ºm¯ÈÁÒ}Òª}°¹Ë¯Ò äËÓÈãÓ©² ÏÈmÒ°Ò亰ˮÒȯÈää© Áºº¯È ÁÒÒÒ ¹¯Òªºä½ÓËËãÒäºË mºÓºä}ºÓ
Ë}°Ëkj{ äºÎË º}ÈÏÈ°«ËãÒä©ä m¯ºä
È}ÎË}È}Ⱥäm°Ò°Ëä˽äºãË}ãÈ ªãË}¯ºÓm
°Ò°Ëä˽Ⱥä Ò
cË ËÓÒËmº¹¯º°ÈººäºË}©}È}Ò²Ò¹ºm
°ÒȯÈÓãÈäÒÏÓÈÓÒ«º¹¯ËËã«Ë°«ÏÈÈÈäÒ kj{ÒË}Ò䯺mÓËäÏÓÈÓÒ®Èmº¯È}ºÓË}°È ÒÒãÒ½ÒÓÎËÓ˯ȹºÏÓÈÓÒ«ä
ºÓ«ÒËjÓÁº¯äÈÒºÓÓ©®ºË}¹ºÏmºã«Ëº¹
¯ËËãÒÈÓ¯º¹ºËÓ¯ÒË°}ÈÏÏÓÈÓÒ®kÓ
¯º¹ºËÓ¯ÒË°}º® ÈϺ® ÏÓÈÓÒ® Ëä ÓÈÏ©mÈ
äÓºÎË°mºÓÒm˯°äjÓÁº¯äÈÒºÓÓ©²ºË}
ºm¹¯ËäËÓº®ºãÈ°ÒÒ²°m«ÏˮҺӺ ËÓÒ®
~ÈäËÈÓÒ«
vºm¯ËäËÓÓºËÓÈÓºËäÒ¯ºmºÏϯËÓÒË°Áº¯
äÒ¯ºmÈ㺰mÏÓÈÒËãÓº®°mºË®È°Ò¹ºmãÒ«
ÓÒËäȺäÒ°Ò}ÒÜËÓÒ«º¹¯Ë¯©mÓºäÒ°}¯Ë
Ӻ䰯ºËÓÒÒäÈ˯ÒÒÒÏȺäºmÒ¯Ò²äÒ}¯º È°ÒsËÒmÒËãÓº¹ºªºäºÒm°ÁË¯Ë ÒËÈãÓºº Ó˺Ӻ}¯ÈÓº ¹¯Ë¹¯ÒÓÒäÈãÒ° ¹º
¹©}Ò¹º°¯ºÒÈË}mÈÓ©ËäºËãÒ½¹¯Ë°ÈmãË ÓÒ« ÏÓÈÓÒ® ã« äÒ¯È ÒË® ½ªãËäËÓ© äÒ¯È m
ªä¹Ò¯Òº}¯ÒÒÒÏäËlȲÈ>@½ÈºäȯөËÁÈ}
© mãºÒË°}ºäȺäÒÏäËcÈ°°ËãÈ>@Ò{Ò
ËÓ Ë®ÓÈ >@ Ò¯ |°ºËÓÓº ºËãÒmº ªº mÒÓºmãÒÓmÒ°ÒË°}º®Ëº¯ÒÒºÓº°ÒËãÓº°Ò v˹¯ÒÈܺ¯ÁÈ>@¹ºãÈÈË®º«Ï©}Ò
¯ÈÏãÒÈ°«ÓËËä}È}Ò˺ÓÒÒ°¹ºãÏ°ãºmÈ Ò}È}°¯º«¹¯ËãºÎËÓÒ«ÈËä}È}ºÓÒËã«
äÒ¯ÓȪãËäËÓ©}ºº¯©Ëº¯ÈÎÈ°«m°ãºmȲÒ
¹¯ËãºÎËÓÒ«²
~ÓÈËÓÒËȺäȯӺºªãËäËÓȯӺºÏÓÈ}È ÁÒ}°Ò¯Ë Ó˯ÈÏãºÎÒä©® m ¹¯ËËãȲ ÈÓÓºº
¯ºmÓ«Ë°°¯}¯Ó©®ªãËäËÓÏÓÈÓҫ˯˲º º Ó˯ȰãËÓËÓÓºº ÏÓÈÓÒ« } ¯È°ãËÓËÓÓºä
°¯}¯ÓºäÏÓÈÓÒ¹¯Ë¹ºãÈÈËm}ÈË°mË°mºË º°ãºmÒ«¹Ë¯Ë²ººÒ°²ºÓ©²ÏÓÈËÓҮȺäȯ
Ó©²ÏÓÈ}ºm}°ä©°ã}ºä¹ãË}°Ó©²ÏÓÈ}ºm©²º
¯ÈϺmÈÓÒ®>@
§ ª«¾·¥¨¥
sÈÒºãËËmÈÎÓ©Ëmä˺ºãºÒË°}ºäºÓº Ë ÓÒÒ¯ËÏãȩ亩°Áº¯äãÒ¯ºmÈÓ©°ãË
Ò亯ÈϺä
z ~ÓÈÓÒ«vË}Èkj{}È}ÒÏäËÓ«Ò®°«äÈ
˯ÒÈãÓ©®ºË}ܪº°Ò°ËäÈäÓË°ÒË°}Ò²
°ã˺mm}º¯Ë˺ºãºmÓººäºÏÈ
z jÏäËÓËÓÒË~ÓÈÓÒ®m¹¯ºË°°Ëkj{¹¯ºÒ°²ºÒm
¯ËÏãÈËmº°¹¯Ò«Ò«ÓËäÈ˯ÒÈãÓ©²mÒÒ ä©²ÓÈ˯äÒÓÈãȲ}ºä¹Ë¯È°ãºm˰Ӻ㺠ÒË°}Ò² Ò ÓÈã«Óºº¯ÈÏÓ©²jÓÁº¯äÈÒºÓ Ó©²ºË}ºmÒÒ²¹Ë¯Ë¯Èº}Ò°ºÏÓÈÓÒËä
z jÓÁº¯äÈÒºÓө˺Ë}©äº©¹¯º°©
äÒÒȯËÒ¯ºmÈÓÓ©äÒ¯ÒÒÏËÓÒÒ~ÓÈÓÒ«
}È} °Ò°ËäÓºº ºË}È mÈÎÓº º¹¯ËËãÒ ÓË
ºã}º ˺ ¹¯º°©Ë Ò°²ºÓ©Ë ËÒÓÒ© Óº Ò
¹º°Ò°Ëä© Ò Ò˯ȯ²ÒË°}ÒË ¯ºmÓÒÈÓÓº®
°Ò°Ë䩺ãÈÈÒ˺Ӻ°ÒËãÓº®°È亰º«
ËãÓº°ÒãÒÈmºÓºäÓº°
z ¯º°©ËÒÓÁº¯äÈÒºÓө˺Ë}©ÓÈÏ©mÈ°«
¯ÈÓãÈäÒÏÓÈÓÒ«¯ÈÓãÈÏÓÈÓÒ«ºãÈÈË°mº®
°mÈäÒ ÓËËãÒ亰ÒË㺰Ӻ°Ò Ò ¯ÈÏãÒÒ äº°Òm¯Èä}Ȳ}ºÓË}°Èkj{{ºËä°ãÈË
¯ÈÓãÈ ÏÓÈÓÒ« º¹¯ËËã«Ë°« }È} ÓËËãÒä©®
ÒÓÁº¯äÈÒºÓÓ©® ºË} ¹¯Ë°Èmã«Ò® m m˯ÈãÓº®ÒãÒÓËm˯ÈãÓº®Áº¯ä˯ËÏãÈ
¹ºÏÓÈÓÒ«Ü˺¯ËÒË°}Ò®ÒãÒªä¹Ò¯ÒË°}Ò®
ÁÈ}
z jÓÁº¯äÈÒºÓÓ©®ºË}äºÎË«mã«°«Èäº ÎËÒÓË«mã«°«ÒÓÁº¯äÈÒˮ㫯Ë˹ÒËÓ
ÈjÓÁº¯äÈÒºÓÓ©®ºË}«mã«Ë°«ÒÓÁº¯äÈ Òˮ˰ãÒ¹¯Ò˺mº°¹¯Ò«ÒÒ°ºÏÓÈÓÒËm©«°
ӫ˺mÈ}ÈãÓº®¹Èä«ÒÒäË°«°ºº
mË°mÒËËääÓË°ÒË°}ÒË°ãË©{°m«ÏÒ
°ªÒä°ãË˯ÈÏãÒÈÒÏäËÓËÓÒËÏÓÈÓÒ®m
{°Ò°ËäȲҰ}°°mËÓÓººÒÓËããË}ÈÏÈÈÈÒÓÎËÓ˯È
¹ºÏÓÈÓÒ«äÏÈ}ãÈË°«mÁº¯äÈãÒϺmÈÓӺ亹ҰÈÓÒÒÏÓÈ ÓÒ®ª}°¹Ë¯Èã«ÈãÓË® Ë®¯ËÈãÒÏÈÒÒmÒÓËããË}ÈãÓº®
°Ò°ËäË{°Ò°ËäȲkj{ÏÈÈÈÒÓÎËÓ˯ȹºÏÓÈÓÒ«ä°º°º Òm°¯}¯Ò¯ºmÈÓÒÒ¹¯ºãËäÓº®ºãÈ°Òm©«mãËÓÒÒ¯È ÓãÏÓÈÓÒ«Ò²°m«ÏË®°ººÓº ËÓÒ®ÒÁº¯ä¹¯Ë°ÈmãËÓÒ«
ÓÈ˯äÒÓÈãȲ}ºä¹Ë¯Èm°ãºmË°ÓºãºÒË°}º®ÒÒãÒÓÈ ã«Óºº¯ÈÏÓº®Áº¯äË
ÓÒm˯°ÈãÓ©ä äÓºÎË°mºä ÒãÒ ¹¯º°º ½ÓÒm˯°
äºä ÓÈÏ©mÈË°«È}ºËäÓºÎË°mº}ºº¯ºË°º°ºÒÒÏm°Ë² ªãËäËÓºmÒ°°ãËË亮ºãÈ°Ò>@¯ËäËÓÈ«ºãÈ°º
ãÈ°ºË}ºmÓÒm˯°ä¯È°°ÎËÓÒ«ÓÒm˯°ä¯È°°äº
¯ËÓÒ«ÒãÒ¹¯º°ºÓÒm˯°ä}ãÈ°°äÓºÎË°mººË}ºm
¯È°°äȯÒmÈË䩲m¹¯ËËãȲÈÓÓºº}ºÓË}°Èº}ºÓË}°
ºäÏË°äºÎ˹ºÓÒäÈ°«ºËãӺ˯Ȱ°ÎËÓÒËÒãÒm©
¯ÈÎÈȫ˺Á¯ÈÏÈÒãÒ°ºmº}¹Óº°Á¯ÈÏÁ¯ÈäËÓÓÈ
Óº®Ëº¯ÒÒÒãÒ˺¯Ò«mËãºä>@
jËÈãÓºË Ü °Ë}ÒmÓ©® º¯ÈÏ ºË}ÒmÓº® ¯ËÈã Óº°ÒmºÏÓÒ}ÈÒ®m¹¯ºË°°ËËãË°ºº¯ÈÏÓº®Ë«ËãÓº°
ÒËãºmË}È>@ kºäȯө®ÁÈ}ÜÁÈ}Ó˯ÈÏãºÎÒä©®ÓȯÒËÁÈ}©
È}ÈãÓº®¹Èä«ÒÒÒÏäËÓËÓÒËÏÓÈÓÒ®mãÈ
ËÓÓº®¹Èä«ÒËãºmË}ÈÒ°ººmË°mËÓÓº¹
¯Èm㫹¯ºË°°ÈäÒÒÏäËÓËÓÒ«ªÒ²m²mÏÈÒ äº°m«ÏÈÓÓ©²}ºä¹ºÓËÓºmÏÓÈÓÒ«
sȪº®}ºÓ˹ÈãÓº®º°ÓºmË
z kÓ¯º¹ºËÓ¯ÒË°}ºËÒÓÁº¯äÈÒºÓÓºËmÏÈÒäº Ë®°mÒ˺¹¯ËËãËÓº}È}¹¯Èmã«Ëä©®ËãºmË }ºä¹¯ºË°°ÒÏmãËËÓÒ«ÒÓÁº¯äÈÒºÓÓ©²º
Ë}ºmÒϹÈä«Ò}ºä¹Ë¯È°ËãÒÏäËÓË ÓÒ«~ÓÈÓÒ®m¹Èä«ÒËãºmË}È
z kÓ¯º¹ºËÓ¯ÒË°}º®ÈϺ®ÏÓÈÓÒ®¹¯ËäËÓº®
ºãÈ°Òkj{ÓÈÏ©mÈË°«äÓºÎË°mº¹¯Ë°Èm ã«Ò²ËËÒÓÁº¯äÈÒºÓÓ©²ºË}ºmÒÓË}º
º¯©²°m«Ï©mÈÒ²Ò²ºÓº ËÓÒ®
z jÓ°¯äËÓÈã Óº®°Ò°Ë亮kj{ÓÈÏ©mÈË°«
}ºä¹Ë¯ÓÈ« °Ò°ËäÈ Ò°¹ºãÏËäÈ«ËãºmË }ºäm}ÈË°mËÒÓ°¯äËÓȹ¯Òº¯ËËÓÒ«ÏÓÈ ÓÒ®Ó˺²ºÒ䩲Ëäã«°¹Ë ÓººmÏÈÒäº Ë®°mÒ«°º®°¯Ëº®m}ºº¯º®ºÓÎÒmËÒ¯È
ºÈË ªº äºÎË © ºËÓÒË °ÈäººË ÓÒ˺ӺmãËÓÒËÏÓÈÓÒ®¯Ë ËÓÒ˹¯ºãËä
«¨²¥° ²³°
sºmÈ« ¹º°ÒÓ°¯ÒÈãÓÈ« mºãÓÈ ÓÈ ~ȹÈË º ¯Ë { jÓºÏËäËmÈÜl$FDGHPLD
ºÈËm°}Ò® sj ºãÓºË °º¯ °º Ü Ü l jÏmºksvvvc
zÏÓ˺m sk jÓÁº¯äÈÒºÓÓºË mÏÈÒäºË®°mÒË m ˲ÓÒ Ë°}Ò²ÒÎÒm©²°Ò°ËäȲjÓÁº¯äÈÒºÓө˹¯ºË°°©
,¢v|Î˺m vj vãºmȯ ¯°°}ºº «Ï©}È º ¯Ë s b m ˺mº®Ülc°«ÏÜ ° ºÒË°}Ò®°ãºmȯ|m¯Ëiº¯°}Ò®ÜlsÈ}È
nÒ㺰ºÁ°}Ò®°ãºmȯº¯Ëjn¯ºãºmÈË ÒÏlºãÒÒÏÈÜ °
z¯È}Ò®¹°Ò²ºãºÒË°}Ò®°ãºmȯvº°kzȯ¹ËÓ}º
ºº¯Ëk{˯ºm°}ººlЯº Ëm
° }ººÜlºãÒÒÏÈÜ °
Èmãºm°}ÒË °¯Ë© Ü Ü l jÏmº ks vvvc |¯ÁËËm { {ºÏäºÎÓº°Ò äºËãÒ¯ºmÈÓÒ« º¯ÈÏÓºº Ò
¹ºÓ«Ò®Óººä© ãËÓÒ«ÓÈw{ljÓËããË}ËãºmË}ÈÒ
¹¯º¯Èää©w{l|m¯Ë|zÒ²ºäÒ¯ºmÜlsÈ}È w®Ó Ë®ÓknÒÏÒ}ÈÒ¯ËÈãÓº°ÜlsÈ}È ~ÒÓºmËmkk|°Óºm©ãºÒË°}º®Ëº¯ÒÒÓÈÓ©²ÏÓÈÓÒ®Ü
lsÈ}È
w¹ Ë®Ó{ҹ˯Ë}°ÜÓºmÈ«¹È¯ÈÒäÈÒÓÁº¯äÈÒ }ÒkmºäÈÒ}ÈÒËãËä˲ÈÓÒ}È¢
w¹ Ë®Ó {ҹ˯Ë}°ºmÈ«ÈÏÈ ÏÓÈÓҮ˺¯ÒÒ¹¯Èm ãËÓÒ«kmºäÈÒ}ÈÒËãËä˲ÈÓÒ}È¢
w¹ Ë®Ó { {mËËÓÒË mҹ˯Ë}° Òҹ˯Ë}°ºm©Ë
°Ò°Ëä©KWWSZZZLSXUXSXEOHSVWQKWP
rºã È«vºmË°}È« wÓÒ}㺹ËÒ« Ü l vºm ªÓÒ}
ËÓÒÓ { j lÈ˯ÒÈãÒÏä Ò ªä¹Ò¯Òº}¯ÒÒÒÏä ºãÓ
°º¯°ºÜÒÏÜ
cÈ°°Ëã r nÒ㺰ºÁÒ« ãºÒË°}ºº ȺäÒÏäÈ KWWSZZZ SKLORVRSK\UXOLEUDU\UXVVHOODWRPKWPO
cÓËm{{ÒËÓ Ë®ÓÒttmË}{º¹¯ÁÒ㺰ºÁÒÒ ¢6DSLU(,Q/DQJXDJH&XOWXUHDQG3HUVRQDOLW\,Q0DQGHO EDXP'DYLG*HG6HOHFWHG:ULWLQJVRI(GZDUG6DSLU%HU NHOH\DQG/RV$QJHOHV8QLYHUVLW\RI&DOLIRUQLD3UHVVÜ c:KRUI %HQMDPLQ /HH 7KH 5HODWLRQ RI +DELWXDO 7KRXJKW DQG
%HKDYLRUWR/DQJXDJH+ROODQGHU(GZLQ3DQG5D\PRQG
*+XQWHGV&ODVVLF&RQWULEXWLRQWR6RFLDO3V\FKRORJ\1HZ
<RUN2[IRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV/RQGRQ7RURQWRÜ c ܲÒÓ {v |¯ÈÎËÓÒË °Ò°Ëä© }Ò˯ÓËÒ}È Ü l
sÈ}È
(PDLOHSVWHLQ#LSXUVVLUX R
$%675$&76
7UDFKWHQKHUW]($
&20387(5$,'('0$1$*(0(17'(&,6,210$.,1*68332576<67(06
7KHSDSHUIRUPXODWHVWKHWDVNVIRUFRPSXWHUDLGHGGHFLVLRQPDNLQJVXSSRUWV\VWHPVDQGFRQVLGHUV WKHIDFWRUVWKDWDIIHFWWKHFDSDELOLWLHVRIVXFKV\VWHPVDQGWKHGLIILFXOWLHVWKDWHPHUJHGXULQJWKHLULP SOHPHQWDWLRQDQGDSSOLFDWLRQ,WDOVRGLVFXVVHVWKHWHFKQLTXHVRIFRPSXWHUDLGHGVLWXDWLRQDQDO\VLV FRPSXWHUEDVHGJHQHUDWLRQDQGHYDOXDWLRQRISRVVLEOHVROXWLRQVVLPXODWLRQRIWKHWDNHQGHFLVLRQVDQG FRPSXWHUDLGHGVXSSRUWRIWHDPGHFLVLRQDJUHHPHQW7KHFDSDELOLWLHVRIVXFKV\VWHPVDUHDOVRGHP RQVWUDWHGÜ3
(SVWHLQ9/
$17+5232&(175,&,1)250$7,21$/,17(5$&7,21 7(50,12/2*<,668(6
7KHSDSHUGLVFXVVHVWKHFRQFHSWVDQGWKHFRUUHVSRQGLQJWHUPV$QWKURSRFHQWULFLQIRUPDWLRQDOLQ