Discrete public goods with incomplete information

(1)

❊♥s❛✐♦s ❊❝♦♥ô♠✐❝♦s

❊s❝♦❧❛ ❞❡

Pós✲●r❛❞✉❛çã♦

❡♠ ❊❝♦♥♦♠✐❛

❞❛ ❋✉♥❞❛çã♦

●❡t✉❧✐♦ ❱❛r❣❛s

◆◦ ✸✺✾ ■❙❙◆ ✵✶✵✹✲✽✾✶✵

❉✐s❝r❡t❡ P✉❜❧✐❝ ●♦♦❞s ✇✐t❤ ■♥❝♦♠♣❧❡t❡ ■♥❢♦r✲

♠❛t✐♦♥

P❛✉❧♦ ❑❧✐♥❣❡r ▼♦♥t❡✐r♦✱ ❆❦r❛♠ ❚❡♠✐♠✐✱ ❋❧❛✈✐♦ ▼❛rq✉❡s ▼❡♥❡③❡s

❖✉t✉❜r♦ ❞❡ ✶✾✾✾

(2)

❖s ❛rt✐❣♦s ♣✉❜❧✐❝❛❞♦s sã♦ ❞❡ ✐♥t❡✐r❛ r❡s♣♦♥s❛❜✐❧✐❞❛❞❡ ❞❡ s❡✉s ❛✉t♦r❡s✳ ❆s

♦♣✐♥✐õ❡s ♥❡❧❡s ❡♠✐t✐❞❛s ♥ã♦ ❡①♣r✐♠❡♠✱ ♥❡❝❡ss❛r✐❛♠❡♥t❡✱ ♦ ♣♦♥t♦ ❞❡ ✈✐st❛ ❞❛

❋✉♥❞❛çã♦ ●❡t✉❧✐♦ ❱❛r❣❛s✳

❊❙❈❖▲❆ ❉❊ PÓ❙✲●❘❆❉❯❆➬➹❖ ❊▼ ❊❈❖◆❖▼■❆ ❉✐r❡t♦r ●❡r❛❧✿ ❘❡♥❛t♦ ❋r❛❣❡❧❧✐ ❈❛r❞♦s♦

❉✐r❡t♦r ❞❡ ❊♥s✐♥♦✿ ▲✉✐s ❍❡♥r✐q✉❡ ❇❡rt♦❧✐♥♦ ❇r❛✐❞♦ ❉✐r❡t♦r ❞❡ P❡sq✉✐s❛✿ ❏♦ã♦ ❱✐❝t♦r ■ss❧❡r

❉✐r❡t♦r ❞❡ P✉❜❧✐❝❛çõ❡s ❈✐❡♥tí✜❝❛s✿ ❘✐❝❛r❞♦ ❞❡ ❖❧✐✈❡✐r❛ ❈❛✈❛❧❝❛♥t✐

❑❧✐♥❣❡r ▼♦♥t❡✐r♦✱ P❛✉❧♦

❉✐s❝r❡t❡ P✉❜❧✐❝ ●♦♦❞s ✇✐t❤ ■♥❝♦♠♣❧❡t❡ ■♥❢♦r♠❛t✐♦♥✴ P❛✉❧♦ ❑❧✐♥❣❡r ▼♦♥t❡✐r♦✱ ❆❦r❛♠ ❚❡♠✐♠✐✱ ❋❧❛✈✐♦ ▼❛rq✉❡s ▼❡♥❡③❡s ✕ ❘✐♦ ❞❡ ❏❛♥❡✐r♦ ✿ ❋●❱✱❊P●❊✱ ✷✵✶✵

✭❊♥s❛✐♦s ❊❝♦♥ô♠✐❝♦s❀ ✸✺✾✮

■♥❝❧✉✐ ❜✐❜❧✐♦❣r❛❢✐❛✳

(3)

6*@L i?i3it

t|h@@? @|L?@ N?iht|) @?_ ,B,%6BV

@*L k L?|ihL

,B,%6BV

!h@4 Ai44

N?iht|) Lu *@M@4@

#tUhi|i MU BLL_t | W?UL4Ti|i W?uLh4@|L?

|

U|LMihc bbb

Devwudfw

Zh dqdo|}h vlpxowdqhrxv glvfuhwh sxeolf jrrg jdphv zlwk lqfrp0 sohwh lqirupdwlrq dqg frqwlqxrxv frqwulexwlrqv1 Wr xvh wkh whuplqro0 rj| ri Dgpdwl dqg Shuu| +4<<4,/ zh frqvlghu frqwulexwlrq dqg vxe0 vfulswlrq jdphv1 Lq wkh iruphu/ frqwulexwlrqv duh qrw uhixqghg li wkh surmhfw lv qrw frpsohwhg/ zkloh lq wkh odwwhu wkh| duh1 Iru wkh vshfldo fdvh zkhuh surylvlrq e| d vlqjoh sod|hu lv srvvleoh zh vkrz wkh h{lv0 whqfh ri dq htxloleulxp lq erwk frqwulexwlrq dqg vxevfulswlrq jdphv zkhuh d sod|hu ghflghv wr surylgh wkh jrrg e| klpvhoi1 Iru wkh fdvh zkhuh lv qrw ihdvleoh iru d vlqjoh sod|hu wr surylgh wkh jrrg e| klpvhoi/ zh vkrz wkdw dq| htxloleulxp ri erwk jdphv lv lqhflhqw1 ZH dovr surylgh d vxflhqw frqglwlrq iru _frqwulexwlqj }hur% wr eh wkh xqltxh htxloleulxp ri wkh frqwulexwlrq jdph zlwk qsod|huv dqg fkdudfwhul}h htxloleuld ri wkh vxevfulswlrq jdph lqyroylqj srvlwlyh frqwulexwlrqv1

_{Fruuhvsrqghqfh wr}_{= I1 Phqh}hv/ Ghsduwphqw ri Hfrqrplfv/ Idfxow| ri Hfrqrplfv dqg}

Frpphufh/ Dxvwudoldq Qdwlrqdo Xqlyhuvlw|/ Fdqehuud/ DFW/ 3533/ Dxvwudold1

|_{Zh zrxog olnh wr wkdqn Mrkq Frqoh|/ Fkduohv Ndkq/ Eduw Olspdq/ Sdxo Shfrulqr/ Wrgg}

Vdqgohu dqg Kduulv Vfkohvlqjhu iru khosixo frpphqwv1 Phqh}hv dqg Prqwhlur judwhixoo| dfnqrzohgjh wkh qdqfldo vxssruw ri FQSt1 Whplpl dfnqrzohgjhv wkh qdqfldo vxssruw ri wkh Froohjh ri Exvlqhvv Dgplqlvwudwlrq dw wkh Xqlyhuvlw| ri Dodedpd1

(4)

MHO Fodvvlfdwlrq=G:</ G;</ K;<

Nh| Zrugv= sulydwh surylvlrq ri sxeolf jrrgv> frqwulexwlrq dqg vxe0 vfulswlrq jdphv> lqfrpsohwh lqirupdwlrq1

W?|hL_U|L?

Ai *|ih@|hi L? Th@|i ThLtL? Lu TM*U }LL_t U@? Mi __i_ ?|L |L MhL@_ U@|i}Lhit Ai ht| Mh@?U Lu |i *|ih@|hi uLUtit L? |i ThL tL? Lu UL?|?Lt TM*U }LL_t @Tiht ?U*_i `@hh EbH2c bHc Lh?it @?_ 5@?_*ih EbHec ih}t|hL4c *4i @?_ V@h@? EbHSc ?_hiL? EbHHc Bh@_t|i?c |3@? @?_ 5*|t!) Ebbe @?_ L|iht t|@?_@h_ hit*| ? |t *|ih@|hi t |@| TM*U }LL_t @hi ?_ihThL_i_ M) L*?|@h) UL?|hM|L?t _i |L uhii h_?} Mi@Lh2 ?i 4}| UL?iU|hi |@| |i }Lih?4i?| U@? tL*i |t ?_ihThLtL? ThLM*i4 M) ThL_?} tL4i Lu |i }LL_ @?_ ?@?U ?} | M) 4TLt?} |@ it L? UL?|hM|Lht OLiihc `@hh EbH2 @?_ +LMih|t EbHec ? |L ?i?|@* T@Tihtc tL |@| }Lih?4i?| UL?|hM|L?t hit*| ? @ _L**@h |L _L**@h hi_U|L? ? Th@|i UL?|hM|L?t u |i |@ L? UL? |hM|Lht _Lit ?L| U@?}i |i ti| Lu UL?|hM|?} ?__@*t ih}t|hL4c *4i @?_ V@h@? EbHS tL |@| |i UhL_?} L| igiU| t L?*) T@h|@* u L?i @**Lt uLh |i |@ it |@| T@) uLh |i }Lih?4i?| UL?|hM|L? |L Mi @*tL UL**iU|i_ uhL4 ?L? UL?|hM|Lht Oi?Ui |i *|ih@|hi t}}it|t |@| ? _ihThLtL? t @ hLMt| UL?U*tL? u |i TM*U }LL_ *ii* t i?_L}i?Lt*) _i|ih4?i_ M) L*?|@h) UL?|hM|L?t

4_{Lq wklv sdshu/ zh irfxv rq sulydwh surylvlrq1 Wkhuh lv dq h{whqvlyh phfkdqlvp ghvljq}

olwhudwxuh wkdw wuhdwv sxeolf surylvlrq1 Sdshuv lq wklv olwhudwxuh ghyhors hflhqw phfkd0 qlvpv iru wkh surylvlrq ri sxeolf jrrgv1 Wkhvh phfkdqlvpv duh lq jhqhudo frpsoh{ dqg uhtxluh d fhqwudo dxwkrulw| wr lpsohphqw wkhp dqg khqfh zrxog eh ehvw ghfvulehg dv phfkd0 qlvpv iru sxeolf surylvlrq ri sxeolf jrrgv1 Judgvwhlq +4<<7, h{dplqhv hflhqw phfkdqlvpv iru glvfuhwh sxeolf jrrgv1 Rwkhu sdshuv wkdw wuhdw sxeolf surylvlrq lqfoxgh Pdvnlq +4<::,/ g*Dvsuhprqw dqg Yduhw +4<:</ 4<;5,/ Sdoiuh| dqg Vulydvwdyd +4<;9,1 Fruqhool +4<<9, h{0 dplqhv dq rswlpdo phfkdqlvp iru d prqrsrolvw zklfk surgxfhv dq h{foxgdeoh jrrg wkdw kdv odujh {hg frvwv1

5_{Wkh iuhh ulglqj sureohp ehfrphv zruvh lq wkh suhvhqfh ri lqfrpsohwh lqirupdwlrq1}

Judgvwhlq +4<<5, frqvlghuv d g|qdplf prgho ri sulydwh surylvlrq iru d frqwlqxrxv sxeolf jrrg zlwk lqfrpsohwh lqirupdwlrq zlwk wkh uhvwulfwlrq wkdw sod|huv hlwkhu frqwulexwh }hur ru dq h{rjhqrxv srvlwlyh dprxqw1 Kh frqfoxghv wkdw lq dgglwlrq wr wkh vwdqgdug xqghu0 surylvlrq uhvxowv/ lqhflhqf| rffxuv ehfdxvh ri d ghod| lq frqwulexwlrqv1 Wklv lqhflhqf| grhv qrw glvdsshdu dv wkh srsxodwlrq ehfrphv odujh1

6_{Dqguhrql +4<<;, dqdo|}hv wkh uroh ri vhhg prqh| lq wkh suhvhqfh ri qrqfrqyh{lwlhv}

lq wkh surgxfwlrq ri wkh sxeolf jrrg1 Kh vkrzv wkdw d vpdoo dprxqw ri vhhg prqh| fdq

(5)

Ai tiUL?_ t|h@?_ Lu |i *|ih@|hi uLUtit L? _tUhi|i TM*U }LL_t ihi @ i_ *ii* Lu @ TM*U }LL_ t ThL_i_ u i?L} UL?|hM|L?t @hi UL**iU|i_ |L ULih |t ULt| S |ihtic |i }LL_ t ?L| ThL_i_ A)TU@* i @4T*it ?U*_i M*_?} @ Mh_}ic @ *Mh@h) Lu @ Uih|@? t3ic TM*U h@_L u?_ h@t?} |L ?@?Ui @ Uih|@? ThL}h@4 W? @** Lu |iti i @4T*itc u i?L} 4L?i) t h@ti_ |L ULih |i ULt| Lu |i TM*U }LL_c |i? |i }LL_ t ThL_i_c L|ihti |i }LL_ t ?L| ThL_i_

@*uhi) @?_ +Lti?|@* EbHe _ii*LTi_ |i ht| 4L_ih? |hi@|4i?| Lu Th@|i ThLtL? Lu _tUhi|i TM*U }LL_t Lhi tTiUU@**) |i) @?@*)3i UL?|hM|L? @?_ tMtUhT|L? }@4it Q |L ti |i |ih4?L*L}) Lu _4@| @?_ ihh) Ebb Q uLh @ _tUhi|i TM*U }LL_ ?_ih UL4T*i|i ?uLh4@|L? ihi T*@)iht< t|h@|i}it @hi hit|hU|i_ |L i|ih UL?|hM|i 3ihL Lh @? i L}i?Lt TLt|i @4L?| W? @ UL?|hM|L? }@4ic UL?|hM|L?t @hi ?L| hiu?_i_ u |i t4 Lu |i UL?|hM|L?t _Lit ?L| ULih |i ULt| Lu |i TM*U }LL_ Sc *i ? @ tMtUhT|L? }@4i T*@)iht }i| |ih 4L?i) M@U! u |i ThLiU| t ?L| UL4T*i|i_ ? i @4T*i | |i 4@? ui@|hit Lu @ tMtUhT|L? }@4i U@? Mi }i? @t uL**Lt Ai `tUL?t? BLih?Lh @t hiUi?|*) T*i_}i_ m2. 4**L? ? t|@|i ML?_t |L ?@?Ui @ ?i m.2 4**L? M@t!i|M@** @hi?@ L? |i UL?_|L? |@| |i hit| Lu |i 4L?i) Mi h@ti_ M) Th@|i _L?@|L?t E?_hiL?c bbH A@| tc |i BLih?Lh ** ThL_i m2. 4**L? @t *L?} @t |i hi4@??} meD 4**L? t h@ti_c L|ihti |i Lgih t U@?Ui**i_ |ih i @4T*it U@? Mi uL?_ ? |i u?_h@t?} *|ih@|hi , @4T*it Lu UL?|hM|L? }@4it ?U*_i TM*U h@_L @?_ AV u?_h@t?} igLh|t ihi UL?|hM|Lht _L ?L| }i| |ih 4L?i) M@U! u |i ThL}h@4 t ?L| ThL_i_ |ih i @4T*it Lu UL?|hM|L?t }@4it @hi t|@|L?t ihi UL?|hM|L?t |@!i |i uLh4 Lu T)tU@* *@MLhc ? |t U@ti L*?|iiht U@??L| hiULih |ih igLh| u |i ThLiU| t ?L| UL4T*i|i_ W? UL?|h@t| | |i t|@?_@h_ ?_ihThLtL? hit*| uLh UL?|?Lt TM*U }LL_tc @*uhi) @?_ +Lti?|@* EbHe LM|@? |i t|@h|*?} UL?U*tL? |@| iUi?| ThLtL? Lu @ _tUhi|i TM*U }LL_ t @ TLttM*i L|UL4i Lu ML| UL?|hM|L? @?_ tMtUhT|L? }@4it ii? |L} ?iUi?| i^*Mh@ @*tL i t| @}?L* @?_ wT4@? EbHb i |i?_ @*uhi) @?_ +Lti?|@* 4L_i* M) @**L?} ?__@*t |L 4@!i UL?|?Lt UL?|hM|L?t Ai) tL |@| |i ti| Lu ?_L4?@|i_ TihuiU| i^*Mh4 L|UL4it Lu |i tMtUhT|L? }@4i t ?L| L?*) iUi?| M| UL?U_it | |i ULhi Lu |i iUL?L4) Ai) @*tL tL |@| | @ _)?@4U ihtL? Lu |i tMtUhT|L? }@4ic | t TLttM*i |L LM|@? iUi?| L|UL4it ii? u |i *ii* Lu |i TM*U }LL_ t ?L| M?@h) jhqhudwh d vxevwdqwldo dprxqw ri yroxqwdu| frqwulexwlrqv1

(6)

@t *L?} @t |i ?4Mih Lu ?|t Lu |i TM*U }LL_ t UL?|@M*ie W| uL**Lt |@| |i }i?ih@* UL?U*tL? uhL4 |i |iLhi|U@* *|ih@|hi t |@| Th@|i ThLtL? Lu _tUhi|i TM*U }LL_t | UL4T*i|i ?uLh4@|L?U@? Mi iUi?| LhiLihc iUi?| ThLtL? t @ TLttM*i L|UL4i uLh ML| tMtUhT|L? @?_ UL?|hM|L? }@4it

? 4TLh|@?| ^it|L? |@| @t ?L| Mii? @__hitti_ ? |i *|ih@|hi L? L*?|@h) ThLtL? Lu _tUhi|i TM*U }LL_t t |L @| i |i?| |iti hit*|t }i?ih@*3i |L @ 4L_i* ihi T*@)iht @i ?UL4T*i|i ?uLh4@|L? @ML| L|ih T*@)iht< @*@|L? Lu |i TM*U }LL_ LhiLihc |ihi t ML| U@t@* i _i?Ui uhL4 |i u?_h@t?} *|ih@|hi Lu |i tTihLh|) Lu tMtUhT|L? }@4it @?_ i Tih4i?|@* i_i?Ui uhL4 @}?L* @?_ Ukii Ebb @?_ @_tM) @?_ @)?it Ebbb |@| @ hiu?_ ?Uhi@tit |i U@?Ui Lu ThL_?} |i }LL_ Lhi tTiUU@**)c @_tM) @?_ @)?it UL?t_ih @ _tUhi|i TM*U }LL_ i Tih4i?| Ai) ThL_i i Tih4i?|@* i_i?Ui tL?} |@| ThLtL? t i?ULh@}i_ ? @ tMtUhT|L? }@4i t@t @ UL?|hM|L? }@4i Ai) @*tL ThL_i i _i?Ui |@| @ } S _tULh@}it ThLtL? ? |i UL?|hM|L? }@4i M| ?L| ? |i tMtUhT|L? }@4i h hit*|t ** UL?h4 |iti ?_?}t

W? |t T@Tihc i i @4?i UL?|hM|L? }@4it @?_ tMtUhT|L? }@4it uLh @ _tUhi|i TM*U }LL_ ? |i Thiti?Ui Lu ?UL4T*i|i ?uLh4@|L? `i ht| @?@*)3i ThLtL? }@4it ihi | t ui@tM*i uLh @ T*@)ih |L ThL_i |i TM*U }LL_ M) 4ti*u L44L? i @4T*it ?U*_i LTi??} @ ?_L ? @ L| hLL4c hitU?} @? ?hi_ TihtL? ? @ |h@U @UU_i?|c i|U `i tL |@| i? |i ULt| Lu ThLtL? St ?L| ThLM|i*) } @t |L Thii?| @ t?}*i T*@)ih uhL4 ThL_?} |i }LL_c |ihi @*@)t i t|t @? i^*Mh4 ihi @ T*@)ih | @ tUi?|*) *@h}i @*@|L? ThL_it |i }LL_ ? ML| |i tMtUhT|L? @?_ |i UL?|hM|L? }@4i LhiLihc i tL |@| |i uhii h_?} ThLM*i4 U@? MiUL4i 4Lhi tiihi Lh *itt tiihi @t |i TLT*@|L? MiUL4it *@h}ih

`i @*tL i @4?i UL?|hM|L? @?_ tMtUhT|L? }@4it i? UL?|hM|L?t

7_{Dgpdwl dqg Shuu| dqdo|}hg wkh uroh ri frpplwphqw lq wkh surylvlrq ri sxeolf jrrgv1}

Pruh vshflfdoo|/ wkh| h{dplqhg wzr0sod|hu frqwulexwlrq dqg vxevfulswlrq jdphv zlwk frpsohwh dqg shuihfw lqirupdwlrq zkhuh sod|huv dowhuqdwh lq pdnlqj sohgjhv ru frqwulex0 wlrqv xqwlo wkh sxeolf surmhfw lv frpsohwhg1 Wkh| vkrz wkdw zlwk olqhdu frvwv/ d qhfhvvdu| dqg vxflhqw frqglwlrq iru frpsohwlrq ri wkh surmhfw xqghu d frqwulexwlrq jdph lv wkdw hdfk sod|hu zrxog frpsohwh wkh surmhfw lpphgldwho| e| klpvhoi li kh zdv wkh rqo| sod|hu1 Zh surylgh d vxflhqw frqglwlrq dqg zlwk wzr ru pruh sod|huv iru _frqwulexwlqj }hur% wr eh wkh xqltxh htxloleulxp ri wkh frqwulexwlrq jdph1 Iru wkh vxevfulswlrq jdph/ wkh| vkrz wkdw doo vrfldoo| ghvludeoh surmhfwv duh frpsohwhg lq htxloleulxp1 Lq frqwudvw/ zh vkrz wkdw zlwk lqfrpsohwh lqirupdwlrq wkh suredelolw| ri surylvlrq frqglwlrqdo rq ehlqj hflhqw wr gr vr lv dozd|v ohvv wkdq rqh1

(7)

Lh T*i_}it uhL4 4Lhi |@? L?i ?__@* @hi ?iUitt@h) ? Lh_ih uLh |i }LL_ |L Mi ThL_i_ ì ** U@h@U|ih3i tL4i t)44i|hU i^*Mh4 Lu |i tM tUhT|L? }@4i @?_ _i4L?t|h@|i |@| @** i^*Mh@ @hi ?iUi?|c |@| tc |i ThLM@M*|) Lu ThLtL? }i? |@| | t iUi?| |L _L tL t *itt |@? L?i At ?iUi?U) t|i4t uhL4 |i _U*|it @ht?} ? ULLh_?@|?} |L LihUL4i |i uhiih_ih ThLM*i4 ? |i Thiti?Ui Lu ?UL4T*i|i ?uLh4@|L? ì ** @*tL ThL_i @ tUi?| UL?_|L? uLh UL?|hM|?} 3ihL< |L Mi |i ?î i^*Mh4 Lu |i UL?|hM|L? }@4i AihiuLhic i tL |@| ?_ih tL4i UhU4t|@?Uit |i UL?|hM|L? }@4i t ?iih 4Lhi iUi?| |@? |i tMtUhT|L? }@4i At UL?h4t |i i_i?Ui uhL4 |i i Tih4i?|@* *|ih @|hi Lu |i tTihLh|) Lu tMtUhT|L? }@4it Lih UL?|hM|L? }@4it W? UL?|h@t| |L |i 4iU@?t4 _it}? *|ih@|hic Lh @TThL@U Lu U@h@U|ih3?} i^*Mh4 Mi@Lh ? i t|?} 4iU@?t4t i?@M*it t |L ThL_i hit*|t U U@? Mi |it|i_ ? @ *@MLh@|Lh) i?hL?4i?| Lh M) t?} i4ThU@* _@|@ At hi4@?_ih Lu |i T@Tih ThL_it 4Lhi _i|@*t L? @** Lu |iti ttit W? 5iU|L? 2c |i tTiUUt Lu |i 4L_i* @hi Thiti?|i_ 5iU|L? ThL_it @? i @4T*i |@| **t|h@|it |i 4@? hit*|t Lu |i T@Tih W? 5iU|L? ec |i U@ti ihi @ t?}*i ?__@* U@? ThL_i |i }LL_ M) 4ti*u t @?@*)3i_ Ai }i?ih@* @?@*)tt Lu tMtUhT|L? }@4it t UL?|@?i_ ? 5iU|L? D 5iU|L? S i @4?it |i UL?|hM|L? }@4i 5iU|L? . **t|h@|it @ _gihi?|@* i^@|L?t @TThL@U |L ?_ i^*Mh4 t|h@|i}it ? }@4it | |L T*@)iht h 4@? hit*|t @hi t44@h3i_ ? 5iU|L? H

2 Ai L_i*

`i ?L Thiti?| |i uLh4@* 4L_i* Aihi @hi 2 ?__@*t | Th@|i ?_iTi?_i?| @*it uLh @ _tUhi|i TM*U }LL_ A@| tc i@U ?__@* c

' c c !?Lt t L? @*iM| L?*) |i _t|hM|L? Lu t LTTL?i?|t< @*it V@*it @hi @tt4i_ |L Mi ?_iTi?_i?|*) _h@? uhL4 @ UL?|?Lt _t|hM|L? 8 Ai ULt| Lu ThL_?} |i TM*U }LL_ tS

`| |i i UiT|L? Lu 5iU|L? ec i @tt4i |hL}L| |i T@Tih |@| @? ?__@* U@??L| ThL_i_ |i }LL_ M) 4ti*u W? |t U@tic 8 ES ' @?_ |t |i _t|hM|L? @t @ ML?_i_ tTTLh| t @ ?Lh4@*3@|L? i tTTLtic |L| *Ltt Lu }i?ih@*|)c |i tTTLh| |L Mi UL?|@?i_ ? |i ?|ih@* dfco

`i ** i @4?i ML| tMtUhT|L? @?_ UL?|hM|L? }@4it W? @ tM tUhT|L? }@4i |i 4L?i) UL?|hM|i_ M) T*@)iht t hi|h?i_ u |i t4 Lu |i T*i_}it t *itt |@? S W? @ UL?|hM|L? }@4i |i 4L?i) t ?L| hi|h?i_

(8)

ii? u |i }LL_ t ?L| ThL_i_ `@|iih |i 4i|L_ |L i*U| _L?@|L?t tc u _L?@|L?t @__ T |L 4Lhi |@? Sc |i @__|L?@* 4L?i) t ?L| hi|h?i_ |L |i UL?|hM|Lht

Lhi tTiUU@**)c i @?@*)3i L?itL| t4*|@?iLt 4Li UL?|hM|L? @?_ tMtUhT|L? }@4it uLh @ _tUhi|i TM*U }LL_ ? |i Thiti?Ui Lu ?UL4 T*i|i ?uLh4@|L? @ML| Thiuihi?UitD h 4L_i* @*tL hi*@ it |i M?@h) UL? |hM|L? hit|hU|L? 4TLti_ ? |i *|ih@|hiS `*i |ihi @hi 4TLh|@?| ?t|@?Uit ihi M?@h) UL?|hM|L?t @hi hi*i@?| _i |L |h@?t@U|L? ULt|tc ? }i?ih@* T*@)iht U@? }i @?) @4L?| Lu 4L?i) |i) _ithi E@*4? _L?@ |L?c _L?@|L?t |L @ *Mh@h)c i|U LhiLihc ? @ UL?|?Lt UL?|hM|L?t uh@4iLh!c ?__@*t 4@!i UL?|hM|L?t |@| Mit| 4@|U |ih Thiuihi?Uit @t LTTLti_ |L @ _tUhi|i UL?|hM|L? 4L_i* @_tM) @?_ @)?it Ebbb ThL_i i Tih4i?|@* i_i?Ui tL?} |@| @**L?} UL?|?Lt h@|ih |@? M?@h) R@**Lh?L|?} UL?|hM|L?t u@U*|@|it ThLtL?

t | t t|@?_@h_ ? 4@?) }@4it Lu ?UL4T*i|i ?uLh4@|L? | i @?|i t)44i|hU T*@)iht Q tU @t ? ?_t|h@* Lh}@?3@|L? @?_ @U|L?t Q Lh uLUt t 4@?*) L? t)44i|hU i^*Mh4 iih|i*ittc i ThL_i ?i Ui?U) hit*|t |@| L*_ uLh ML| t)44i|hU @?_ @t)44i|hU i^*Mh@( i tL |@| uLh @?) i^*Mh4 |i ThLM@M*|) Lu ThLtL? Lu |i TM*U }LL_ }i? |@| | t iUi?| |L _L tL t *itt |@? L?i ? ML| UL?|hM|L? @?_ tMtUhT|L? }@4it @?_ | t uhiî?|*) i^@* |L 3ihL ? UL?|hM|L? }@4it ì @*tL ThL_i tUi?| UL?_|L?t ?_ih U UL?|hM|?} 3ihL t |i ?î i^*Mh4 Lu |i UL?|hM|L? }@4i

Ai 4*|T*U|) Lu i^*Mh@ |@| U@h@U|ih3it |iti }@4it @t |L tLhUit 6ht|*)c |t t @? ?t|@?Ui Lu @ ULLh_?@|L? }@4i `| |L T*@)iht L U@??L| ThL_i |i }LL_ M) |i4ti*itc |i ULLh_?@|L? ?@|hi Lu |i }@4i t U*i@h `| 4Lhi |@? |L T*@)ihtc |i? i @i |L @UUL?| uLh @** TLttM*i UL4M?@|L?t Lu T*@)iht L U@? ThL_i |i }LL_ @t @ }hLT At @__t @ ?i *@)ih Lu UL4T*i |) |L t|@?_@h_ ULLh_?@|L? }@4it 5iUL?_*)c

8_{Lw lv lpsruwdqw wr qrwh wkdw wkhuh duh vhyhudo sdshuv wkdw lqwurgxfh lqfrpsohwh lq0}

irupdwlrq lq rqh irup ru dqrwkhu exw gr qrw dgguhvv wkh deryh txhvwlrqv1 Sdoiuh| dqg Urvhqwkdo +4<;;, dqdo|}h wkh surylvlrq ri d glvfuhwh sxeolf jrrg zkhq lqglylgxdov kdyh lqfrpsohwh lqirupdwlrq derxw wkh ghjuhh ri dowuxlvp ri rwkhu sod|huv xqghu wkh uhvwulfwlrq wkdw sod|huv duh rqo| doorzhg wr pdnh glvfuhwh frqwulexwlrqv1 Qlw}dq dqg Urpdqr +4<<3, vkrz wkdw zkhq wkh frvw ri wkh glvfuhwh sxeolf jrrg lv xqfhuwdlq wr wkh sod|huv/ wkhq hflhqf| lv qr orqjhu rewdlqhg1

9_{Edjqrol dqg Olspdq +4<;<, dovr frqvlghuv frqwlqxrxv frqwulexwlrqv1 Krzhyhu wkhlu}

prgho lv zlwk frpsohwh lqirupdwlrq1

(9)

|i ?UL4T*i|i?itt Lu ?uLh4@|L? @?_ |i @tt4T|L? |@| T*@)ih U@? UL? |hM|i Lh T*i_}i @?) @*it |i) *!i @*tL Uhi@|it @__|L?@* ULLh_?@|L? ttit Mi)L?_ |i t|@?_@h_ ULLh_?@|L? ThLM*i4 W| t |i UL4M?@|L? Lu |iti |L ui@|hit |@| 4@!it | _U*| |L LM|@? ?^i?itt Lu i^*M h4 W? T@h|U*@hc @t i ** i T*@? ? |i UL?|i | Lu |i i @4T*i Mi*Lc i**!?L? @h}4i?|t |L LM|@? ?^i?ittc tU @t |i |ih@|i_ _i*i|L? Lu _L4?@|i_ t|h@|i}it @t ? @}?L* @?_ wT4@? EbHb E| UL4T*i|i ?uLh 4@|L? @?_ *}hL4 @?_ +LMih|t Ebbf E| ?UL4T*i|i ?uLh4@|L? uLh |i U@ti Lu tTih4L_*@h }@4itc _L ?L| @TT*) ? |t UL?|i |

? , @4T*i

iuLhi |h??} |L @? @?@*)tt Lu |i 4L_i*c | t ?t|hU|i |L UL?t_ih @ t4 T*i i @4T*i ihi | t TLttM*i |L 4@!i |i TL?| |@| |i iUi?| hit*|t ? |i _tUhi|i TM*U }LL_t *|ih@|hi @hi ?L| hLMt| |L |i ?|hL_U|L? Lu ?UL4T*i|i ?uLh4@|L? At i @4T*i ?ULhTLh@|it |i t4T*it| t|hU|hi uLh U |t *@U! Lu hLMt|?itt t i_i?| @?_ uLh U i LM|@? @ t|h! ?} _t|?U|L? Mi|ii? Thi_U|i_ L|UL4it ? tMtUhT|L? @?_ UL?|hM|L? }@4it `i Mi}? | |i UL4T*i|i ?uLh4@|L? U@ti

L4T*i|i W?uLh4@|L?

tt4i |@| T*@)iht @?_ 2 @i @*@|L?t uLh |i TM*U }LL_ @?_2 ? dfco @?_ |@| @hi UL44L? !?L*i_}i wi| |i ULt| Lu ThLtL? Lu |i TM*U }LL_SMi tU |@| S 2 @?_n₂ SA@| tc @ t?}*i T*@)ih U@??L| ThL_i |i }LL_ M) 4ti*u @?_ | t tLU@**) iUi?| |L ThL_i |i }LL_ Wu i _i?L|i M) Kc ' c2c T*@)ih<t T*i_}?} t|h@|i}) ? @ tMtUhT|L? }@4ic |i? i U@? U@h@U|ih3i |i ti| Lu EThi t|h@|i}) i^*Mh@ @t uL**LtG E _iEKc K2 GK nK2 'S(K (K2 2j(

E Efcf(

E _iEKc K₂ GK S₂(K₂ S_j

Ai i^*Mh@ _itUhMi_ ? E @hi iUi?|c *i |i i^*Mh@ _itUhMi_ ? E @?_ E @hi ?L|. LhiLihc |i i^*Mh@ _itUhMi_ ? E @?_ E

:_{Wkh htxloleulxp ghvfulehg lq +ll, lv nqrzq dv wkh vwurqj iuhh ulglqj htxloleulxp1}

(10)

@hi ?L| t|hU| @t Mit| hitTL?tit @hi ?L| ?^iH

L|i |@| |i i^*Mh@ Lu |i UL?|hM|L? }@4i U@? Mi _itUhMi_ M) E @?_ E @MLi Bi? |@| ?__@*t ? @ UL?|hM|L? }@4i ?iih hiUii |ih UL?|hM|L?t M@U!c |i t|h@|i}it ThL*it _itUhMi_ ? E @hi ?L *L?}ih i^*Mh@ N?*!i ? |i U@ti Lu |i tMtUhT|L? }@4ic |i i^*Mh4 t|h@| i}) Efcf t ?L @ t|hU| i^*Mh4 A@| tc UL?|hM|?} 3ihL t |i ?^i Mit| hitTL?ti i? |i L|ih T*@)ih UL?|hM|it 3ihL

At i @4T*i t}}it|t |@| ?_ih UL4T*i|i ?uLh4@|L? |i _t|?U|L? Mi|ii? UL?|hM|L? @?_ tMtUhT|L? }@4i ML| ? |ih4t Lu iUi?U) @?_ ? |ih4t Lu i TiU|i_ L|UL4it t ?U*i@h `i ?L UL?t_ih |i ?UL4T*i|i ?uLh4@|L? U@ti

2 W?UL4T*i|i W?uLh4@|L?

`i ?L @tt4i |@| @?_ ₂ @hi ?_iTi?_i?| _h@t uhL4 |i ?uLh4 dfco _t|hM|L? LhiLihc *@)ih' c2 !?Lt t L? @*@|L? M| L?*) |i _t|hM|L? Lu t LTTL?i?|<t @*@|L? wi| t tTTLti |@| S 2 Ai tMtUhT|L? }@4i @t 4@?) t)44i|hU i^*Mh@ @?_ |i UL?|hM|L? }@4i @t L?*) |i t|hL?} uhii h_?} i^*Mh@ wi| t tii tL4i tMtUhT|L? }@4i i^*Mh@ ht|G

Efcf(

KWE '

fc u S₂

S

2c u 2S (

KWE '

2S3

S n 2c u 2S3

fc L|ihti

A@| Efcf t t|** @? i^*Mh4 ? |i ?UL4T*i|i ?uLh4@|L? uL**Lt |h@**) uhL4 |i u@U| |@| @ t?}*i T*@)ih U@??L| ThL_i |i }LL_ M) 4 ti*u L *i|<t UiU! |@| |i t|h@|i}) ThL*i _itUhMi_ ? E t ?_ii_ @? i^*Mh4 5TTLti *@)ih 2 uL**Lt KWE Wu *@)ih <t @*i t *itt |@?

S

2c |i? <t Mit| hiT*) t |L T*i_}i @?) ?4Mih *itt |@? S2 W? T@h|U*@hc T*i_}?} 3ihL t @ Mit| hitTL?ti Wu *@)ih <t @*i t }hi@|ih |@? i^@* |L

S

2c |i? *@)ih <t Mit| hitTL?ti t |L T*i_}i 2S *i_}?} *itt |@? S2 *@)ih

;_{Edjqrol dqg Olspdq +4<;<, vkrz wkdw wkh lqhflhqw htxloleuld lq +ll, dqg +lll, fdq eh}

holplqdwhg e| xqgrplqdwhg shuihfwlrq1

(11)

LM|@?t 3ihL ThL|t( M) T*i_}?} 4Lhi |@? ₂Sc *@)ih _Lit ?L| ?Uhi@ti |i ThLM@M*|) |@| |i }LL_ t ThL_i_ M| _iUhi@tit ThL|t UL?_|L?@* L? ThLtL?

Ai i^*Mh4 T*i_}?} t|h@|i}it _itUhMi_ ? E U@? Mi i T*@?i_ @t uL**Lt T*@)ih T*i_}it |i i^@*i?| |L |i i TiU|i_ @*i Lu |i L|ih T*@)ih Mi?} *Lih |@? t L?c UL?_|L?@* L? |i ?|ih@* d2S3 coc |@| tc L? |i hi*i@?| ?|ih@* ihi T*i_}it @hi *itt |@? Lh i^@* |L |i @*@|L?t uLh |i TM*U }LL_c i KE uLh4@* _ih@|L? t *iu| |L |i @TTi?_ L|i |@| |i |ih@|i_ i*4?@|L? Lu _L4?@|i_ t|h@|i}it _Lit ?L| M|i ihi W? Lh ti||?}c ? @ ht| hL?_ Lu i*4?@|L? *@)ihi*4?@|it t|h@|i }it KE : Ai i*4?@|L? ThLUitt t|LTt |ihi- Ai |)Ti Lu ML?_t LM|@?i_ ? *}hL4 @?_ +LMih|tEbbf @hi ?L| TLttM*i ihi t?Ui |i }@4i t ?L| tTih4L_*@hG L?t_ih |L t|h@|i}it K ' f @?_ K₂ ' S @?_ ?L|i |@| sEK₂c K₂sEK₂c KdsEKc K₂sEKc K₂o ' ESEf ' f

u ULhti |t 4*|T*U|) Lu i^*Mh@ U@? TL|i?|@**) h@ti _U*|it ? ^it|L?t Lu i*u@hi iih|i*ittc i ** tL *@|ih |@| @?) i^*Mh@ Lu |i tMtUhT|L? }@4i t ?iUi?| Lhi ThiUti*) i ** tL |@| |i ThLM@M*|) Lu ThLtL? Lu |i TM*U }LL_ }i? |@| | t iUi?| |L ThL_i t E?uLh4*)*itt |@? L?i ? @?) i^*Mh4b LhiLihc i ** ThL_i @ tUi?| UL?_|L? ?_ih U |i i*u@hi UL4T@htL? Mi|ii? tMtUhT|L? @?_ UL?|hM|L? }@4it t t|h@}|uLh@h_ Q @t |i L?*) i^*Mh4 Lu |i UL?|hM|L? }@4i t |L UL?|hM|i 3ihL

`i ?L hi|h? |L |i i @4T*i @?_ @?@*)3i |i UL?|hM|L? }@4i At i @4T*i t@|tit |t tUi?| UL?_|L? |@| ** Mi tTiUi_ *@|ih OL iihc | 4@) Mi ?t|hU|i |L tL _hiU|*) |@| Efcf t |i ?^i i^ *Mh4 5TTLti EKc K₂ t @? i^*Mh4 Lu |i UL?|hM|L? }@4i W| t 44i_@|i |@| K2E2 2 wi| t ?_ |i Mit| hitTL?ti Lu *@)ih |L K2 Wu *@)ih M_t %f t i TiU|i_ |*|) t

E% 'EK₂E₂S%%

Wu % ₉' f @?_ S% |i? E% ' % f L tTTLti S% `i @i

E%E₂ S%%'EES%%'ES n E% f

<_{Wklv suredelolw| lv htxdo wr 425 lq wkh htxloleulxp ghvfulehg lq +ll, dqg htxdo wr 526}

lq wkh htxloleulxp ghvfulehg lq +lll,1

(12)

At % ' f t |i Mit| hitTL?ti EL|i |@| i @hi ?L| *4|?} Lhti*it |L t)44i|hU Thi t|h@|i}) i^*Mh4 AihiuLhic _itT|i |i 4*|T*U |) Lu i^*Mh@ Lu |i tMtUhT|L? }@4ic i @hi t|** @M*i |L 4@!i i*u@hi UL4T@htL?t Lhi ThiUti*)c |i UL?|hM|L? }@4i t *itt iUi?| |@? |i tMtUhT|L? }@4i ? |t i @4T*i At hit*| UL?|h@t|t }hi@|*) | |i U@ti ihi T*@)iht @i UL4T*i|i ?uLh4@|L? @?_ ML| }@4it @i iUi?| i^*Mh@

e

hLtL? M) @ 5?}i @)ih

W? |t tiU|L?c i @?@*)3i UL?|hM|L? @?_ tMtUhT|L? }@4it i? @*@ |L?t uLh |i TM*U }LL_ U@? |@!i @*it *@h}ih |@? |i ULt| Ai uL**L?} |iLhi4 tLt |@| |ihi @*@)t i t|t @ t)44i|hU i^*Mh4 ihi @ T*@)ih | @ tUi?|*) } @*@|L? ThL_it |i }LL_ M) 4ti*u AiLhi4 5TTLti 8 G dfc₄ _$_U t @ UL?|?Lt _t|hM|L? 5TTLti |ihi @hi 2 T*@)iht uLh @ ThLiU| | ULt| S : f @?_ |@| 8 ES

Ai? |ihi i t|t @? k :f ihi k tL*it k8Ek3 'S tU |@|

KE '

f u k

S u : k

t @? i^*Mh4 t|h@|i}) uLh ML| UL?|hM|L? @?_ tMtUhT|L? }@4it

hLLu 5TTLti T*@)iht ?' 2c c T*@) @UULh_?} |L KE wi| t ?_ |i Mit| hitTL?ti Lu *@)ih Wu t @*i t f @?_ t UL?|hM|L? t %fc

t i TiU|i_ T@)Lg ? |i UL?|hM|L? }@4i t }i? M)

}E% 'h E%nKE₂ nnKES%

5?Ui KE2 n nKE t i|ih f Lh ?L| *itt |@? Sc | uL**Lt |@| u

% S |i? }E% }Ef At 4@ _i}E% (%f_j ' 4@ _i}Efc }ES_j ' 4@ q8Ek3c Sr Oi?Ui u _{8 Ek}S3 'kc |i Mit| UL?|h M|L? t % ' f Wu : k |i Mit| UL?|hM|L? t % ' S ?_ u ' k |i T*@)ih t ?_gihi?| Mi|ii? %' f @?_%'S 6Lh |i tMtUhT|L? }@4ic |i i TiU|i_ thT*t t }i? M)

sE% ' E% h E%nKE₂ nnKES

(13)

Ai ThLLu t _i?|U@* |L |i UL?|hM|L? }@4i t?Ui sEf ' }Ef @?_sES '

}ESf

+i4@h! At i^*Mh4 t ?L| i TLt| iUi?| *|L} iUi?U) hi

^hit |@| |i TM*U }LL_ Mi ThL_i_ i?iih |i t4 Lu ?__@*<t @* @|L?t i Uii_ Sc |i }LL_ t ThL_i_ L?*) u @| *i@t| L?i ?__@*<t @*@|L? i Uii_t k U t }hi@|ih |@? S LhiLih i ** tL *@|ih |@| @?) i^ *Mh4 t ?iUi?|

ThLM|i*) } @t |L Thii?| @ t?}*i T*@)ih uhL4 ThL_?} |i }LL_c |ihi @*@)t i t|t @? i^*Mh4 ihi @ T*@)ih | @ tUi?|*) *@h}i @*@|L? ThL_it |i }LL_ M) 4ti*u

*tt @?_ @*iMg EbHe @?@*)3i @ @h Lu @||h|L? }@4i ihi |i TM*U }LL_ t ThL_i_ M) @ t?}*i ?__@* Ai) tL |@| ? |t _)?@4U uh@4iLh! |i uhii h_ih ThLM*i4 t *itt 4TLh|@?| @t |i TLT*@|L? MiUL4it *@h}ih @?_ ThL_i UL?_|L?t ?_ih U |i ht| Mit| t @Uii_ @t |i TLT*@|L? @TThL@Uit ??|) Oi?Uic @ ?@|h@* ^it|L? t i|ih ? Lh uh@4iLh!c |i ThLM@M*|) |@| |i }LL_ }i|t ThL_i_ ?Uhi@tit Lh _iUhi@tit @t |i TLT*@|L? MiUL4it *@h}ih Ai @?tih |L |t ^it|L? _iTi?_t L? |i i*@t|U|) Lu |i _t|hM|L? u?U|L? AL tii |tc ht| ?L|i |@| k t ?Uhi@t?} ? @?_ |@| |i ThLM@M*|) |@| |i }LL_ t ThL_i_ t

8Ek ' 8Ek

k S

A@!?} |i _ih@|i Lu |t | hitTiU| |L kc i UL?U*_i |@| |i _ih@|i t TLt|i u 8_{8 Ek}Ekk @?_ ?i}@|i u |t |ih4 t }hi@|ih |@? L?i A@| tc uhii h_?} U@? MiUL4i *itt tiihi Lh 4Lhi tiihi @t |i TLT*@|L? MiUL4it *@h}ih Aihi t ?L Thit4T|L? |@| | ** }i| Lhti Lh |@| | ** }i| Mi||ih W| _iTi?_t L? |i _t|hM|L? u?U|L? 6Lh i @4T*ic u 8 t ?uLh4c |i? |i i*@t|U|) t i^@* |L L?i @?_ |i ThLM@M*|) |@| |i }LL_ }i|t ThL_i_ _Lit ?L| U@?}i @t ?Uhi@tit

43_{Wkh vroxwlrq lv qrw xqltxh lq jhqhudo1 Iru h{dpsoh li} _Q _{@ 5}_{> I}₊_{_{, @} _{{> {} ₅ _^3_>_4`_>

wkhq li 3 ? f ? 4@h dqrwkhu htxloleulxp vwudwhj| iru wkh frqwulexwlrq jdph lv e+{, @ pd{if.norj +{,>3jzkhuhnlv vxfk wkdwnn@hf=Wkhuh duh wzr vroxwlrqv= n₄?4@h ? n₅=

(14)

D

Ai 5MtUhT|L? B@4i

W? |t tiU|L? i @?@*)3i |i tMtUhT|L? }@4i ihi @ t?}*i T*@)ih U@??L| ThL_i |i }LL_ M) 4ti*u At t |i U@ti L?*) u 8ES ' At |i _t|hM|L? 8 @t @ ML?_i_ tTTLh| @?_ |L| *Ltt Lu }i?ih@*|) i tTTLti |i tTTLh| t |i ?|ih@* dfco *@)iht< @*it @hi _i|ih4?i_ M) ?_iTi?_i?| _h@t uhL4 @ UL?|?Lt _t|hM|L? 8 G dfco _$ U Ai ULt| Lu |i TM*U }LL_ t S₅d6c 6n ihi 6 i 6n t |i 4?44 ?4Mih Lu T*@)iht ?ii_i_ |L ThL_i |i TM*U }LL_

Wu T*@)iht ' 2cc c uL**L |i u?U|L? KE @?_ T*@)ih | @* @|L? UL?|hM|it %fc t i TiU|i_ thT*t t

E% ' E% h E%nKE₂ n nKES E ' E% h EKE₂ n nKES%

`i tii uhL4 |i @MLi |@| u :2c |L h|i E% @t @ u?U|L? Lu |i _t |hM|L? Lu ?__@* @*@|L?tc 8c _i|@*i_ ?uLh4@|L? L? KE t ?ii_i_( | _Lit ?L| tUi |L !?L |@| KE t ?Uhi@t?} ? |i Th@|i @*@|L? Oi?Ui |i t|@?_@h_ |iU?^i |@| t ti_ |L U@h@U|ih3i i^*Mh4 ? L*?} ?Uhi@t?} t|h@|i}it ? }@4it Lu ?UL4T*i|i ?uLh4@|L? U@??L| Mi ti_ ? |t ThLM*i4 i? : 2 LhiLihc | L*_ Mi uh|*itt |L |h) |L }itt @** |i u?U|L?@* uLh4t |@| i^*Mh@ 4}| |@!i Atc | L*_ Mi i |hi4i*) _U*| |L ?_ @** |i i^*Mh@ Lu |i tMtUhT|L? }@4i

W? |t tiU|L?c i tL _hiU|*) |@| |ihi i t|t @? i^*Mh4 | U|Lg t|h@|i}it ihi |i }LL_ t ThL_i_ u 6n T*@)iht @i @ @*i }hi@|ih |@? @ Uih|@? U|Lg @*i `i |i? tL |@| uLh @?) i^*Mh4c |i ThLM@M*|) |@| |i }LL_ }i|t ThL_i_ }i? |@| | t iUi?| |L tL t *itt |@? L?i

hLTLt|L? 2 5TTLti |@| T*@)iht<t @*@|L?t @hi _t|hM|i_ ? |i dfco ?|ih@* 5TTLti |i ULt| Lu |i TM*U }LL_ tS₅d6c 6n @?_ |i ?4Mih Lu T*@)iht 6n Ai uL**L?} t|h@|i}) t @ t)44i|hU i^*Mh4 t|h@|i}) Lu |i tMtUhT|L? }@4iG

KE '

f u @(

S

6n u @

E2 ihi @ t tU |@|

@

6

3E8 E@68 E@336

S3

'63 E8 E@8 E@33

' S

6n E

(15)

@?_ _? ' _-E?3-?-

hLLu `i ht| ThLi |i i t|i?Ui Lu @#i?i

E@ ' @

6

3E8 E@68 E@336

S3

'63 E8 E@8 E@33

' @

6 3

₃6 n 3S

'6n

3E8E@368 E@63

L|i |@|

*4

@<fE@ ' f @?_ *4@<E@ '

₃6 ₃6 '

5?Ui t @ UL?|?Lt u?U|L?c M) |i ?|ih4i_@|i @*i |iLhi4 |ihi i t|t @? @ tU |@| E@ ' _6nS ₅Efc

`i ?L ThLi |@| KE t @? i^*Mh4 5TTLti @?_ T*@)ih T*i_}it%f @?_ T*@)iht? ' 2c c uL**LKE_?Ai i TiU|i_ |*|) Lu T*@)ih t }i? M)

E% ' E % h #

[

?'2

KE_?S%

$

Ai h@?}i Lu S

?'2KE? t

q

fc_6nS c_6n2S c cE3S_6n r

WuS%₅E_6nS cEnS_6n oc |i?

E% ' E% h #

[

?'2

KE? E n S

6n $

S En S 6n

At |i LT|4@* T*i_}i %W t tU |@|

%W ₅

SEn S

6n (

At

%W 'S E

W_n_S

6n 5dfcc

W

(16)

AihiuLhiW _{5 i}6c 6_jt?Ui _6n2S 2_6n6 6?@**) i @iW '6 u @?_ L?*) u S

6n

Ef Lh i^@*i?|*) u @?_ L?*) u

S 6n

h

# [

?'2

KE?S S

6n $

h

# [

?'2

KE?S

$ Lh h # [ ?'2

KE? ' 6S

6n $

₆S_nh #

[

?'2

KE? 6S

6n $ 5?Ui h # [ ?'2

KE_? ' 6S

6n $

'₃6 E8 E@68 E@336

@?_

h #

[

?'2

KE_? 6S

6n $

' 3

[

'6

₃ E8 E@8 E@33

i UL?U*_i |@| S

6n

Ef u @?_ L?*) u @

+i4@h! 2 Ai @MLi i^*Mh4 t ?L| i TLt| iUi?| W? |t i^*M

h4c u |i }LL_ t ThL_i_ |i? |i t4 Lu |i T*@)ih<t @*@|L?t t @| *i@t| E6n @ : S

+i4@h! Wu iih) T*@)ih t TL|@*c i u '6n c |i? |i i^*Mh4 E2 t }i? M)G

KE '

f u _6nS

S

6n u 6nS

At i@U T*@)ih UL?t_iht |i ULt| i^@**) __i_ @4L?} |i T*@)iht @?_ UL?|hM|it u @?_ L?*) u t @*i t @| *i@t| t t@hi ,Ui?U) hi^hit |@| |i }LL_ t ThL_i_ i?iih S

S ihi@t |i @MLi i^*Mh4 hi^hit i@U |L Mi }hi@|ih Lh i^@* |L _6nS

?@|h@* ît|L? t i|ih |i tMtUhT|L? }@4i @_4|t @?) i^*Mh@ |@| @hi iUi?| ì tL Mi*L |@| iih) i^*Mh4 Lu |i tMtUhT|L? }@4i t ?iUi?| ì ?ii_ |L *i44@t |L ThLi |i ?iUi?U) hit*|

(17)

wi44@ 5TTLti T*@)ih c2 ? T*@)t t|h@|i}) KE @?_ |@| KE t @ Mit| hitTL?ti uLh T*@)ih Ai?

: '_, h # _?

[

'2

KESKE $

h

# _? [

'2

KESKE $

Ee hLLu #i?iME₃ 'S?

'2KEc K'KE @?_ K 'KE Ai? M) |i _i?|L? Lu KE i @i

EK h EME₃SKE EK h EME₃SKE @?_ EK h EME₃SKE EK h EME₃SKE

__?} ML| ?i^@*|it @?_ t4T*u)?} i @i

E Eh EME3SKEh EME3SKEf

wi44@ e 5TTLti t tU |@| hS?

'2KESKE

: f Ai? uLh @?) i @i KE KE At |i LT|4@* hitTL?ti KE t ?L?_iUhi@t?} uLh @?) t}?@* }hi@|ih |@? tL4i t}?@* |@| }it @ TLt|i ThLM@M*|) Lu }i||?} |i TM*U }LL_

hLLu 5TTLti : : Ai? uhL4 Ee @MLi i @i h EME₃SKE h EME₃SKE

h EME₃SKE:f

L ?L|i |@| |t @?_ |i ?L??i}@||) Lu |i i TiU|i_ |*|) 4T*it |@|

K'KE @?_ K 'KEWu K : |i? K : K ?_ u KG EK h EME₃SK EK h EME₃SK

EK h EME₃SK

W? |i *@t| ?i^@*|) @MLi i ti_ Ee @}@? AihiuLhi K K@?_

KK

(18)

+i4@h! e Ai *@t| |L *i44@t tL |@| @*|L} @? i^*Mh4 t|h@|i}) 4@) ?L| Mi ?L?_iUhi@t?} | t ?L?_iUhi@t?} L?*) uLh @?) @*@|L? }hi@|ih |@? @ @*@|L? |@| )i*_t @ TLt|i ThLM@M*|) Lu LM|@??} |i }LL_ *tL

KE ? |t U@ti

6?@**) i U@? ThLi |@| @** i^*Mh@ Lu |i tMtUhT|L? }@4i @hi ? iUi?|

AiLhi4 D E5MtUhT|L? }@4i ?iUi?U) 5TTLti |i _t|hM|L?

8 @t @ _i?t|) sE% : fc % ₅ dfco Ai? |i ThLM@M*|) |@| |i }LL_ t ThL_i_ }i? |@| | t iUi?| |L _L tL t ?uLh4*) *itt |@? L?i ? |i tMtUhT|L? }@4i

hLLu 6 @lc tU |@| _?S l `i @?| |L tL |@| |ihi t @- tU |@| uLh @?) i^*Mh4 EKEc c K?Ec |i UL?_|L?@* ThLM@M*|)

h # _?

[

'

KES

? [ ' S $ - ED

`i ?L|i |@| KE t @ tL*|L? Lu

4@

%Df E% h

# [

'

KES%

$

5TTLti ht| |@| uLh tL4i ?c hS

'KESK

S

?

' f Ai? | t U*i@h uhL4 Ee |@| u _?Sc hS

'KESKE

' f @t i** At uhL4 6M?<t |iLhi4 | uL**Lt |@|

h # ?

[

'

KESc ? [ ' S $ ' h # ? [ '

KESc ?

[

'

Sc : S

? $ h # _? [ '

Sc : S ? $ 4@ $$?h # _? [ '

Sc : S ? $ h # _? [ ' S $

5TTLti ?L |@| uLh iih) ?c hS

'KESK_?S

: f `i ?L __i |i ThLLu ? |L U@tit

(19)

@ti G Wu S?

'KEl S #i?i

f ' +

₅dfc lo?( ? [ ' S , ES

W| t U*i@h |@| h Ef:f @?_ t?Ui uLh iih) l | t |hi |@|KE 4@

KS

?

c KEl

'KEl |i?S?

'KE Su Ec c ?5fAihi uLhi

h # ?

[

'

KESc ? [ ' S $ ' h # ? [ '

KESc ?

[

'

Sc *5f

$

h

# ? [

'

Sc *₅f

$ ' h # _? [ ' S $

h Ef

h # _? [ ' S $

@ti 2G S?

'KElS

W? |t U@ti u l uLh @** 9' |i? KEKEl uLh @** 9' At

[

'

KE

[

'

KEl '[

KElKElSl

AihiuLhi

h #

[

'

KESl

$

h E lc ₉' ' E8 El?3'G

Oi?Ui

KEEKE h #

[

'

KESKE $

El h

# [

'

KESl

$

El

(20)

At

E nl KE

#i?i t ' _i ₅dfco?(KEcuLh @** _j ? @TT*U@|L? Lu 6M?<t |iLhi4 tLt |@|

h # ?

[

'

KESc tS

$ ' f

Wu ₅t @?_ S?

'KES|i? S?' S At

h # ?

[

'

KESc

? [ ' S $ ' h # t _{_} ? [ '

KESc

$

h

# _? [

'

4?_ic E nl_jS

$ h # _? [ ' S $

At u i |@!i

-' 4@ ; A A A ? A A A =

hS?

'4?ic E nlj S

c

hS?

' Sc *5f

c

4@ _$$?hS?

' Sc : ?S

c < A A A @ A A A > E.

i ?t |i ThLLu

+i4@h! D Ai )TL|itt Lu TLt|i _i?t|) Lh ii? |i i t|i?Ui Lu @ _i? t|) uLh |i _t|hM|L? 8 U@? Mi @L_i_ u - _i?i_ ? E. t *itt |@?

S

Ai L?|hM|L? B@4i

W? |t tiU|L? i @?@*)3i |i UL?|hM|L? }@4i i ihi T*@)iht 4@!i UL?|hM|L?t |@| @hi ?L| hiu?_i_ u |i |hitL*_ t ?L| 4i| *@)iht< @*it @hi _i|ih4?i_ M) ?_iTi?_i?| _h@t uhL4 @ UL?|?Lt _t|hM|L?

8 G dfco_$U Ai ULt| Lu |i TM*U }LL_ t S

(21)

Wu T*@)iht ' 2cc c uL**L |i u?U|L? KE @?_ T*@)ih | @* @|L? UL?|hM|it %fc t i TiU|i_ thT*t t

E% ' h E%nKE2 n nKES% ' h EKE2 n nKES%%

Ai uL**L?} |iLhi4 tLt |@| |i ULLh_?@|L? ThLM*i4 ? |i UL?|h M|L? }@4i t tL tiihi |@| u |i ULt| Lu |i TM*U }LL_ t t*}|*) @MLi |i @}}hi}@|i 4i@? Lu |i @*@|L?tc |i? |i ?^i i^*Mh4 Lu |i UL?|hM|L? }@4i t uLh i@U T*@)ih |L UL?|hM|i 3ihL ?L 4@||ih @| t @*i t

#i?L|i M) > |i 4i@? @?_ M) j2 |i @h@?Ui Lu |i _t|hM|L? 8

#i?i @t |i hLL|S Lu j2E SS

>

2

' f#i?i @*tL - ' 4@

c >E n njs

AiLhi4 S E5|hL?} ?iUi?U) 5TTLti |@| T*@)iht< @*@|L?t @hi _t |hM|i_ ? |i dfco ?|ih@* @?_ |i ?4Mih Lu T*@)iht t Wu |i ULt| t

S-c |i? |i ?^i i^*Mh4 Lu |i UL?|hM|L? }@4i t K f hLLu 5TTLti t *@)ih<t@*@|L? Wu EKc c K? t @? i^*Mh4c

<t i TiU|i_ |*|) uhL4 UL?|hM|?} % t

E% ' h #

[

'

KES%

$

%

5?Ui KE i @i

E%h #

[

'

S%

$

%h

# [

'

S%

$

%'G}E% EH

|i ?i^@*|) Mi?} t|hU| u hS

' S%

: f At | tUit |L ThLi |@| u % S |i? }E% f 5?Ui ? |t U@ti |i LT|4@* M_ f KE S @?_ |ihiuLhi S

'KE S uLh iih) Ec c Oi?Ui

KE ' f

5TTLti |ihiuLhi |@|% S `i |i? @i

h #

[

'

S%

$

' h #

[

'

E >S%E >

$

(22)

.

S

'E >

2

ES%E >2

' E j2

ES%E >2 W| uL**Lt |@|

}E% Ej2

ES%E >2 %'GE%

Ai u?U|L?E t t|hU|*) UL?i L|i |@| E ' _ES33E3>E3j2 2f *tL

E S

>

2

S

' j2E S S >

2

f

At

4@ S $%$

E% ' 4@ qS

c Erf

+i4@h! S 6Lh i @4T*i u 8 t ?uLh4*) _t|hM|i_ L? dfcoc |i? > ' ₂ @?_ j2 ' ₂ Ai? u ' fc S 4@ _i.c.fD_j ' . |i ?^i i^*Mh4 Lu |i UL?|hM|L? }@4i t |i 3ihL i^*Mh4 Wu ' ff |i *Lih ML?_ t DbD u ' fff |i *Lih ML?_ t D2.D LhiLih u

_{$ 4}c * _$>

Ai @MLi hit*| 4T*it |@| uLh @ _i h@?}i Lu |i ULt| Lu |i TM*U }LL_c |ihi t i |hi4i ?_ihThLtL? i? hiu?_t @hi ?L| @**Li_

6Lh t4@** i U@? LM|@? t@hTih ML?_t L?-6Lh i @4T*i u ' 2c

|i? - ' `i |h? |L |t ? |i ?i | ThLTLt|L? `i tL |@| |i t|h@|i}) RUL?|hM|?} 3ihL uLh ML| T*@)iht t |i L?*) i^*Mh4 uLh @ }i?ih@* u@4*) Lu _t|hM|L?t

hLTLt|L? . 5TTLti S 2 Wu |i _t|hM|L? u?U|L? t@|tit

8E5 5c 5 ₅ Efc |i? |i Mit| hitTL?ti |L K2E tU |@| K2E2 2 t

KE ' f

(23)

hLLu #i?iE% 'EK₂E₂S%%Wu% : |i?E%% f

At |L 4@ 43i i 4t| @i % 5TTLti % : f Wu % S |i?

E% 'f%'% f5TTLti ?LS%`i @iES '%

@?_ Ef LG

E% E₂ S%%'E8ES%%

EES%%'ES n E% f

L|i |@| |i @MLi u@4*) Lu _t|hM|L?t ?U*_it i** !?L? _t|hM |L?t tU @t |i ?uLh4 @?_ |i i TL?i?|@* _t|hM|L?t Lhi }i?ih@**) @?) UL?U@i _t|hM|L? t@|tit |

+i4@h! . `i UL*_ ThLi @*tL |@| |ihi t ?L 4 i_ t|h@|i}) i^*Mh4 `i L4| |i ThLLu

Ai ThLTLt|L? E. @MLi t ?L| |hi uLh iih) _t|hM|L? W?||i*) u |i _t|hM|L? }it @ } i}| |L } @*@|L?t |i? @? i^*Mh4 i t|t At t |i ti?ti Lu |i ?i | ThLTLt|L?

hLTLt|L? H 5TTLti |@| S : @?_ |@| |ihi i t|t @? k ₅ Efc tU |@| 8 S

2k

' k Ai?

KE ' S

2 u 2kS

f u _2kS

t @? i^*Mh4 t|h@|i}) Lu |i UL?|hM|L? }@4i | |L T*@)iht

2

'kEk 5?Ui

4@ _ikEk (k₅dfco_j'

n

c

|ihi t @? i^*Mh4 u S2_n _n At u ' c S' D i @i

k ' fHH @?_ S*2k' fHD

(24)

Ai ThiLt |iLhi4t tLt |@| uLh } i?L} ULt| Ei }hi@|ih |@?

- |i UL?|hM|L? }@4i iUi?U) t 3ihL Ai uL**L?} |iLhi4 tLt |@| ii? uLh *L ULt|tc @?) i^*Mh4 Lu |i UL?|hM|L? }@4i t ?iUi?|

#i?i 7₆E% ' hS6

' %

Ai uL**L?} |iLhi4 tLt |@| |i ThLM@M*|) |@| |i }LL_ t ThL_i_ }i? |@| | t iUi?| |L _L tL t ML?_i_ @@) uhL4 ? @?) i^*Mh4 Lu |i UL?|hM|L? }@4i

AiLhi4 b EL?|hM|L? }@4i ?iUi?U) Ai iUi?U) ThLM@M*

|) Lu |i UL?|hM|L? }@4i t @| 4Lt|

' h E S?

'E7?3ESS

7_?ES

hLLu G 5TTLti EKEc c K?E t @? i^*Mh4 Lu |i UL?|hM|L? }@4i W| t U*i@h |@| KE uLh @** *@)ih | @*@|L? 7 i TiU|i_ |*|) t

7

h

# [

'

KESKE7

$

KE77hE[ '

KESf

AihiuLhi

7

h

# [

'

S7

$

7h

# [

'

KESKE7

$

KE7

5L 7E7?3ES7KE7 uLh iih) @?_ iih) 7 At

h # _?

[

'

KES

$

h

# _? [

'

E7_?3ESS

$

hE ?

[

'

S ' 7_?ES

(25)

.

Ai _gihi?|@* i^@|L? @TThL@U |L ?_

i^*Mh4 t|h@|i}it

Ai |iLh) Lu t?}*iLMiU| @U|L?t | Th@|i ?_iTi?_i?| @*it ThL_it t | @ 4i|L_ |L ?_ |i Et)44i|hU i^*Mh4 t|h@|i}) |@| t ih) ?@|h@* Nt@**) L?i tTTLtit |@| M__iht ' 2c c M_ @UULh_?}*) |L |i t|hU|*) ?Uhi@t?} t|h@|i}) KE @?_ ?_t __ih <t Mit| hiT*) % M) 4i@?t Lu |i ht| Lh_ih UL?_|L? uLh i TiU|i_ |*|) 4@ 43@|L? Ai? ? i^*Mh4%'KE @?_ i LM|@? @ _gihi?|@* i^@|L? uLhKEwi| t |h) |L 44U |t @TThL@U |L ?_ i^*Mh@ uLh |i UL?|hM|L? @?_ tMtUhT|L? }@4it +iU@** uhL4 |i _tUttL? uL**L?} i^@|L? E |@| u : 2c

_i|@*i_ ?uLh4@|L? L? KE t ?ii_i_ ? Lh_ih |L _ihi |i _t|hM|L? Lu S

'KEwi| t |ihiuLhi tTTLti ' 2`i tTTLti @*tL |@|s '8 :f i t|t @?_ t UL?|?Lt iih)ihi 6ht| i i @4?i |i tMtUhT|L? }@4i

.

Ai tMtUhT|L? }@4i _gihi?|@* i^@|L?

5L tTTLti *@)ih 2 M_t @UULh_?}*) |L KE U t t|hU|*) ?Uhi@t?} *@)ih <t i TiU|i_ thT*t }i? |@| i @t @ @*i @?_ UL?|hM|it %f t }i? M)

E% ' E% h EKE₂S% Eb ' E% h

2 K3ES% Ef ' E%

8

K3ES%

L|i |@| i |LL! |i ?ihti Lu KE |L T@tt uhL4 Eb |L Ef *@)ih <t i TiU|i_ T@)Lg t t4T*) t thT*t u |i ThLiU| t UL4T*i|i_ |4it |i ThLM@M*|) Lu UL4T*i|L? Ai ht|Lh_ih UL?_|L? t

E% '

8

K3ES%

n E%s

K3ES% K3

E % ' f

W? @ t)44i|hU i^*Mh4 %'KEc tL

EKEs

K3ESKE K3

ESKE ' 8

K3ESKE

E At t ?L| @? Lh_?@h) _gihi?|@* i^@|L? t?Ui |i u?U|L?KE @TTi@ht ?t_i |i @h}4i?| `i ** |h@?tuLh4 E ? @ t)t|i4 Lu |L Lh_?@h)

(26)

_gihi?|@* i^@|L?t #i?i CE 'K3ESKE At 4T*it |@|

KECE nKE ' S E2 EKEsECE

K3

EKECE ' 8 ECE E W? E i ti_ |@| KECE 'SKE5?UiK3EKE/ ' / i @i |@| EK3EKE/KE/ ' At ULLt?} /'CE i }i|

K3

EKECE ' *KECE

5Mt|||?} |t ? E | uL**Lt |@| EKEsECE

8 ECE 'K

_E_C_E _Ee

L uhL4 E2 @TT*i_ |L @?_ |L CE i @i |@|KECE nKE 'S'

KEC2E nKECE Oi?Ui KEC2E ' KE @?_ |ihiuLhi CECE '

AihiuLhi uhL4 Ee i UL?U*_i |@|

KE ' ECEKECEsE

8 E ED

#gihi?|@|?} E2 i LM|@?KECECE nKE ' f Ai uL**L?} |iLhi4 _itUhMit |i t)t|i4 Lu _gihi?|@* i^@|L?t |@| @? ?Uhi@t?} i^*Mh4 t|h@|i}) |L |i tMtUhT|L? }@4i 4t| t@|tu)

AiLhi4 f Ai tL*|L? Lu |i t)t|i4 Lu _gihi?|@* i^@|L?t Mi*L U@h @U|ih3it @ t)44i|hU i^*Mh4 ?L*?} t|hU|*) ?Uhi@t?} t|h@|i}it uLh |i tMtUhT|L? }@4i | |L T*@)iht | @*it _i|ih4?i_ M) ?_iTi?_i?| _h@t uhL4 @ _t|hM|L? 8 G dfco _$ Uc ihi 8 t UL?|?Lt*) _gihi? |@M*i @?_ s '8 :f iih)ihi

KE ' ECEKECEsE

8 E c ES

CE 'E8 ECE ECEKECEsE E8 E EKEsECE

+i4@h! H W| t 4TLh|@?| |L ?L|i |@| |i t)t|i4 ES }it L?*) @ U@?__@|i uLh @? i^*Mh4 t|h@|i}) ? i @4T*i ? |i @TTi?_ tLt |@| tL4i ?i |??} 4@) Mi ?iUitt@h) At UL?|h@t|t }hi@|*) | |i tL*|L? i LM|@? ? @U|L? |iLh) U t t@**) _i?i_ uLh iih) t}?@* Oihi | t TLttM*i |L ?ih|KEL?*) *LU@**) LhiLih |i i t|i?Ui LuC_i?i_ @MLi t }*LM@* ? ?@|hi

(27)

.2

Ai UL?|hM|L? }@4i _gihi?|@* i^@|L?

? @?@*)tt t4*@h |L |i @?@*)tt 4@_i @MLi }it |i t)t|i4 Lu _gihi?|@* i^@|L?t |@| @ t|hU|*) ?Uhi@t?} i^*Mh4 Lu |i UL?|hM|L? }@4i 4t| t@|tu)

AiLhi4 Ai tL*|L? Lu |i t)t|i4 Lu _gihi?|@* i^@|L?t Mi*L U@h @U|ih3it @ t)44i|hU i^*Mh4 ?L*?} t|hU|*) ?Uhi@t?} t|h@|i}it uLh |i UL?|hM|L? }@4i | |L T*@)iht | @*it _i|ih4?i_ M) ?_iTi? _i?| _h@t uhL4 @ _t|hM|L? 8 G dfco _$ Uc ihi 8 t UL?|?Lt*) _gihi?|@M*i @?_ s '8 :f iih)ihi

KE 'CEsEc E.

CE 'CEsE

sECE 6Lh i @4T*i u8 t |i ?uLh4 _t|hM|L?c

KE ' CEc CE ' CE

At }it CE ' & @?_ KE ' @n&*L} E @|h@**) KE U@??L| Mi @? i^*Mh4 uLh @** t?Ui | t ?i}@|i uLh t4@** Wu f S *ec KE ' 4@ _ifc Sn&*L} E_jihi&t tU |@|&& 'e3Sct @? i^*Mh4

H

L?U*tL?

`i @?@*)3i_ |L 4iU@?t4t uLh Th@|i ThLtL? Lu _tUhi|i TM*U }LL_t | ?UL4T*i|i ?uLh4@|L? @?_ UL?|?Lt UL?|hM|L?t Ai tMtUhT |L? 4iU@?t4 hiu?_t |i 4L?i) |L UL?|hM|Lht u |i TM*U }LL_ t ?L| ThL_i_ ihi@t |i UL?|hM|L? 4iU@?t4 _Lit ?L| @**L uLh hiu?_t

h @?@*)tt tLi_ |@|c ?*!i |i 4L_i* | UL4T*i|i ?uLh4@|L?c |i ULLh_?@|L? ThLM*i4 MiUL4it 4Lhi UL4T*i @?_ iUi?| ThLtL? t ?L *L?}ih TLttM*i LhiLihc |i |L 4iU@?t4t *i@_ |L UL4T*i|i*) _gihi?| L|UL4it `i tLi_ |@| uLh |i UL?|hM|L? }@4ic uLh @ _i h@?}i Lu ULt|t Lu |i TM*U }LL_c |i }LL_ ** ?iih Mi ThL_i_ At UL?h4t |i i_i?Ui uhL4 |i i Tih4i?|@* *|ih@|hi Lu |i tTihLh|) Lu tMtUhT|L? }@4it Lih UL?|hM|L? }@4it

(28)

+iuihi?Uit

do _4@|c + @?_ ihh)c bbc RaL?| hLiU|t |L| L44| 4i?|c +ii Lu ,UL?L4U 5|_it DHc 2Db2.S

d2o ?_hiL?c ac bbHc RAL@h_ @ AiLh) Lu @h|@M*i 6?_+@t?}c aLh?@* Lu L*|U@* ,UL?L4) fSc HS2f

do ?_hiL?c ac bHHc Rh@|i*) hL_i_ M*U BLL_t ? @ w@h}i ,UL? L4)G Ai w4|t Lu *|ht4c aLh?@* Lu M*U ,UL?L4Ut Dc D..

deo @}?L*c @?_ Ukiic bbc RVL*?|@h) L?|hM|L? B@4iG , Ui?| h@|i hLtL? Lu M*U }LL_tc,UL?L4U W?^h) 2bc D DS

dDo @}?L*c @?_ w wT4@?c bHbc RhLtL? Lu M*U BLL_tG 6**) W4T*i4i?|?} |i Lhi |hL} h@|i L?|hM|L?tc +ii Lu ,UL?L4U 5|_it DSc DHSf2

dSo ih}t|hL4c Ac w *4i @?_ O V@h@?c bHSc R? |i h@|i hLtL? Lu M*U BLL_tc aLh?@* Lu M*U ,UL?L4Ut 2bc 2Deb

d.o *ttc @?_ @*iMgc bHec R#h@}L?5*@)?} @?_ @**hLL4 #@?U?}G Ai h@|i 5TT*) Lu @ M*U BLL_caLh?@* Lu M*U ,UL?L4Ut 2Dc 2

dHo @_tM)c @?_ , @)?itc bbbc RVL*?|@h) hLtL? Lu M*U BLL_t | L?|?Lt L?|hM|L?tG , Tih4i?|@* ,_i?UicaLh

?@* Lu M*U ,UL?L4Ut .c D.

dbo Lh?itc + @?_ A 5@?_*ihc bHec R,@t) +_ihtc aL?| hL_U|L?c @?_ M*U BLL_tc ,UL?L4U aLh?@* bec DHfDbH

dfo Lh?i**c 6c bbSc RT|4@* 5i**?} hLUi_hit | 6 i_ Lt|tc aLh?@* Lu ,UL?L4U AiLh) .c f

(29)

W?|ih?@|L?@* ,UL?L4U +ii DEec H..Hb.

dDo Bh@_t|i?c c 5 |3@? @?_ 5 5*|t!)c bbecRi|h@*|) @?_ |i h @|i hLtL? Lu M*U BLL_t | W?UL4T*i|i W?uLh4@|L?c ,UL ?L4Ut wi||iht eSc Sb.D

dSo @t!?c ,c b..c R@t i^*Mh4 @?_ `i*u@hi T|4@*|)c 4iL d.o *}hL4c @?_ a +LMih|tc bbfc R+@|L?@*3@M*|)c *i@h??}c @?_ i^

*Mh4 ? }@4it | t|h@|i}U UL4T*i4i?|@h|itc,UL?L4i|hU@ DHc 2DD2..

M*U ,UL?L4Ut Dc fb2

d2fo @*uhi)c A @?_ O +Lti?|@*c bHec R@h|UT@|L? @?_ |i hLtL? Lu #tUhi|i M*U BLL_tG 5|h@|i}U ?@*)ttc aLh?@* Lu M*U ,UL?L4Ut 2ec .b

d2o @*uhi)c A @?_ 5 5h@t|@@c bHSc R@t W4T*i4i?|@|L? Nt?} N? _L4?@|i_ 5|h@|i}itc 4iL @h?i}i i**L? N?iht|)

d2o `@hhc Bc bHc R@hi|L T|4@* +i_t|hM|L? @?_ h@|i @h|)c

aLh?@* Lu M*U ,UL?L4Ut bc H

d2eo `@hhc Bc bH2c RAi h@|i hLtL? Lu @ M*U BLL_ W?_iTi?_i?| Lu |i #t|hM|L? Lu W?UL4ic ,UL?L4Ut wi||iht c 2f.2

(30)

TTi?_

Ai tMtUhT|L? }@4i | |L T*@)ihtG Ai ?uLh4

_t|hM|L? U@ti

W? @| uL**Ltc i ThL_i tL4i ?||L? L |L tL*i |t ThLM*i4 i? i |@!i ?|L @UUL?| |i ML?_@h) UL?_|L?t 6Lh |i ?uLh4 _t|hM|L? L? |i ?|ih@* dfcoc |i ?UL?t|h@?i_ tL*|L? |L |i t)t|i4 Lu _gihi?|@* i^@|L?t t|@|i_ ? 5iU|L? . t }i? M) |i uL**L?} T*i_}?} u?U|L?G

KE ' 2S

S n

2

L|ic Liihc |@| ? i^*Mh4 @ T*@)ih 4@) ?L| uL**L KE uLh @?)

? dfco @t |t 4@) *i@_ |L T*i_}?} 4Lhi |@? t @*i Lh 4Lhi |@? |i ULt| Lu |i TM*U }LL_ Oi?Ui i ?ii_ |L 4TLti |i uL**L?} ML?_@h) UL?_|L?t

KE Sc EM EH

KE c EM2 Eb

KE fc EM E2f

W| |h?t L| |@| EM @?_ EM @hi ?L| M?_?} t?Ui S : L?_|L? EM2 t M?_?} @t KE : uLh 2S3 `i ?L tL uLh4@**) |@| |i uL**L?} t @ t)44i|hU i^*Mh4 T*i_}?} t|h@|i}) uLh |i tMtUhT|L? }@4i | |L T*@)iht Lti @*it @hi ?uLh4*) _t|hM|i_ L? dfco @?_ S 2G

KWE '

2S3

S n2c u 2S3 c fcL|ihti

AL ihu) |@| |t t @? i^*Mh4c i @tt4i |@| *@)ih 2 t uL**L?} |i ThLTLti_ i^*Mh4 T*i_}?} t|h@|i})c i @i |L ?_ |i Mit| hitTL?ti Lu T*@)ih `i ht| tL |@| uLh 2S3 c KE ' 2S3_S n ₂ t @ Mit| hitTL?ti |L KWE₂ *@)ih <t i TiU|i_ thT*tc u i T*i_}it Kc t }i? M)

EK ' EK h EKnKWE₂S

AL ?_ |i 4@ 44 Lu ht| ?L|i |@| u f SK KW2S3

' 2S3 |i?

EK ' EK

2S3

Sn 2S3

' Sn

L|i |@| u

(31)

SKKWE |i?EK ' fwi| t UL?t_ih ?LSKWE K SKW2S3

Ai? i @i

EK ' EK h

₂ 2S

(2

eSn

2K

'

EK

4@

2S

c

eSn

2K

Aihi @hi |L U@tit |L UL?t_ihG 2S3 : eSn 2K

W? |t U@tiEK ' EK

2S3

Sn

2 2S3 eSn 2K

W? |t U@ti EK ' EK

eSn n 2K

At ^@_h@|U u?U|L? @t @ ?^i 4@ 44 @| KW ' 2S3_S n ₂ At KW t |i LT|4@* T*i_}i u

KW ₅

SKEc SK2S3

@?_ 2S3 eSn 2KW Ai *@t| ?i^@*|) t @*_ uLh @** ₅ dfco Ai ht| ?i^@*|) t @*_ u ₅ d2S3 co At

KE ' 2S3_S n ₂ t |i Mit| hitTL?ti |L KWE₂ u ₅ d2S3 c o AL ?t *i| t ?_ |i Mit| hitTL?ti uLh ₅ dfc2S3 W| t U*i@h uhL4 |i hi@tL??} ? E2 @MLi |@| |i 4@ 44 Lu t ?L| ?|ihLh At i ?ii_ L?*) |L UL4T@hi ESKWE ' 2S3

'

2S3 eSn n 22S3

' f @?_

SKW2S3

'Sn

'

Sn 2S3

f At u ₅dfc2S3 |i 4@ 44 i TiU|i_ thT*t t 3ihL Oi?Ui t?Ui T*i_}?} 3ihL @?_ T*i_} ?} 2S3 }i |i t@4i i TiU|i_ thT*tc i ?ti_ |i ThLLu |@|KE t @? i^*Mh4

t |i i^*Mh4 T*i_}?} t|h@|i}) t t|hU|*) ?Uhi@t?} @?_ _gihi? |@M*i ? |i hi*i@?| h@?}i Lh ThiLt @?@*)tt t t|i_ `i ?L ThL_i |i ?||L? uLh |i tL*|L? Lu |i tMtUhT|L? }@4i @?_ UL4T@hi | |L |i i^*Mh4 ? @ ht| ThUi ti@*i_M_ @U|L? +iU@** |@| ? @ t)44i|hU i^*Mh4 Lu @ ht|ThUi ti@*i_M_ @U|L? Q ihi |i LMiU| t @@h_i_ |L |i ?__@* | |i }it| M_ Q @? ?__@* M_t ? tU @ @) |L L|M_ |i LTTL?i?| | |i }it| @*i A@| tc UL?_|L?@* L? t @*i Mi?} |i }it|c t M_ t i^@* |L |i i TiU|i_ @*i Lu |i ht|Lh_ih t|@|t|Ut Lu t LTTL?i?|t

W? |i tMtUhT|L? }@4ic Liihc |i }LL_ t ThL_i_ |L ML| T*@)iht u |ih UL?|hM|L?t @__ T |L |i ULt| Lu ThLtL? S Atc |i ThLM*i4

(32)

MiUL4it L?i Lu uLhiU@t|?} |i *Lit| T*i_}i L?i U@? 4@!ic }i? |@| | t Mi*L L?i<t @*ic @?_ t|** @i |i }LL_ Mi?} ThL_i_ Atc |i i^*Mh4 T*i_}?} t|h@|i}) 4T*it |@| @ T*@)ih T*i_}it |i i^@*i?| |L |i i TiU|i_ @*i Lu |i L|ih T*@)ih Mi?} *Lih |@? t L?c UL?_|L?@* L? ?|ih@* ihi T*i_}it @hi *itt |@? Lh i^@* |L |i @*@|L?t uLh |i TM*U }LL_

L|Ui |i _t|?U|L? Mi|ii? |i tL*|L? Lu |i tMtUhT|L? }@4i @?_ |i tL*|L? Lu |i ht|ThUi @U|L? W? |i *@||ihc u @ M__ih<t @*i t ?L| |i }it|c |i? ? @?) t)44i|hU i^*Mh4 | ?Uhi@t?} M_t i ** *Lti |i LMiU| @?_ |ihiuLhic ? i^*Mh4c i _Lit ?L| @i |L UL?t_ih @| i L*_ _L u t @*i t ?L| |i }it| L?i W? |i tMtUhT|L? }@4i |t t ?L| |i U@ti Wu t @*i t |i *Lit| Lu |i |Lc i 4@) t|** LM|@? |i LMiU| @?_c |tc uL**L?} E2 }@h@?|iit |@| |t t |i 4?44 T*i_}i tL |@| |i LMiU| t ThL_i_ @?_ |i T*@)iht @hi t@h?} |i ULt| ? tU @) @t |L i^@*3i |ih 4@h}?@* UL?|hM|L?t At ThLTih|) Lu |i i^*Mh4 T*i_}?} t|h@|i}it t ih) _t|?U| uhL4 |i hit*| uLh ht|ThUi @U|L?t @?_ | U@T|hit |i ?@|hi Lu |i |h@_iLg Mi|ii? |i ThLM@M*|) Lu |i TM*U }LL_ Mi?} ThL_i_ @?_ |i uhiih_?} Mi@Lh

i | i UL4T|i |i ThLM@M*|) |@| |i }LL_ ** Mi ThL_i_ i?iih t iUi?| |L _L tL ? |i t)44i|hU i^*Mh4

5?Ui KWE nKWE2S4T*it |@| n2 Si ?ii_ |L UL4T|i h E_iEc ₂ (KWE nKWE₂S_j

h E_iEc ₂ (n₂ S_j L|i |@|

h E_iEc ₂ (KWE nKWE₂S_j '

2

e2S

2

n

2S

ES

Sn

' e

e Sn

S

2 _'

ES2 2

LhiLih h E_iEc ₂ (n₂ S_j ' ₂E2S2

AihiuLhic

oEKWE nKWE₂S_mn₂ S ' 2

Discrete public goods with incomplete information

❊♥s❛✐♦s ❊❝♦♥ô♠✐❝♦s

❉✐s❝r❡t❡ P✉❜❧✐❝ ●♦♦❞s ✇✐t❤ ■♥❝♦♠♣❧❡t❡ ■♥❢♦r✲

♠❛t✐♦♥

❖✉t✉❜r♦ ❞❡ ✶✾✾✾

❖s ❛rt✐❣♦s ♣✉❜❧✐❝❛❞♦s sã♦ ❞❡ ✐♥t❡✐r❛ r❡s♣♦♥s❛❜✐❧✐❞❛❞❡ ❞❡ s❡✉s ❛✉t♦r❡s✳ ❆s

♦♣✐♥✐õ❡s ♥❡❧❡s ❡♠✐t✐❞❛s ♥ã♦ ❡①♣r✐♠❡♠✱ ♥❡❝❡ss❛r✐❛♠❡♥t❡✱ ♦ ♣♦♥t♦ ❞❡ ✈✐st❛ ❞❛

❋✉♥❞❛çã♦ ●❡t✉❧✐♦ ❱❛r❣❛s✳

6*@L  i?i3it

t|h@*@? @|L?@* N?iht|) @?_ ,B,%6BV

@*L k L?|ihL

,B,%6BV

!h@4 Ai44

N?iht|) Lu *@M@4@

#tUhi|i M*U BLL_t | W?UL4T*i|i W?uLh4@|L?

U|LMihc bbb



W?|hL_U|L?

2

Ai L_i*

? , @4T*i



L4T*i|i W?uLh4@|L?

2

W?UL4T*i|i W?uLh4@|L?

e

hLtL? M) @ 5?}*i *@)ih

D

Ai 5MtUhT|L? B@4i

S

Ai L?|hM|L? B@4i

.

Ai _gihi?|@* i^@|L? @TThL@U |L ?_

i^*Mh4 t|h@|i}it

.

Ai tMtUhT|L? }@4i _gihi?|@* i^@|L?

.2

Ai UL?|hM|L? }@4i _gihi?|@* i^@|L?

H

L?U*tL?

+iuihi?Uit

TTi?_

Ai tMtUhT|L? }@4i | |L T*@)ihtG Ai ?uLh4

_t|hM|L? U@ti

6*@L i?i3it

t|h@@? @|L?@ N?iht|) @?_ ,B,%6BV

@*L k L?|ihL

#tUhi|i MU BLL_t | W?UL4Ti|i W?uLh4@|L?

U|LMihc bbb

Ai L_i*

hLtL? M) @ 5?}i @)ih

Ai _gihi?|@* i^@|L? @TThL@U |L ?_

.