The Neoliberal Challenge: Between The Scientific Sophism And The Communicative Fascination

(1)

835188

628

5

123 658183

851865

35353 !

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email protected]:4,.:64,+C2 9+:.-+C.1;D2

M02-6.12F+@?2-642:,/:/1+C2/A2ND2O4,;/<42A/,2+2-4>[email protected],/8B62-642,/+<2 H74B.00.0B340<3:/-40-.+C.-@J2;+P412/:4,[email protected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

TU'VW&XYZ219.409.421/9.+C?204/C.74,+C.1;?26.1-/,@?2.<4/C/B@2 [\]2^_%YY`a`b%c`WdZ2efg?2ehi?2Sjk2

lm12351837881612353678937315

noppqrstuvopwpvxwytutwvotztq{|}p~pystwptspqopypt}pw~pvop sxv|pztvw|yr}txwp}opwprsxvrv|tytuvoptw||yr|pwrwpupwpyv|}|vyp}}pz uwtsvopypr}}|srwtptyts|}vtvopryrwtr|vr|}svotxo|v|}pwvr|y vorvprwp|yuwtyvtur~pw}|tytuvopurprtxv~|yvrp|yp|yyp|yp}|y}|v|} r}tw|ovvt}r{vorv|vryytvpo|zzpyvorvvopty}t|zrv|tytuvopxwwpyvvwpyz} wp}pyv}sxv|p}t|rt|v|rxvxwrryzptyts|r}pv}vopts|yrv|tytu o|o|y}p|u|ttwz|yrvp}tuo|}vtw|rv|spryz}rpsrpp~pystwp|y}wxvrpr sxv|xwt}pwpupwpyvxp}v|tyrwprz{t}}pz{wvpr

uwts|yxwtprvorv|yurspzryzpq|vpzr}rpzuwppztsr} vopwpp}rpzrtyvopst}vz|}rwrvpvo|y}r}tyr}vop{t|y|zpz|yvop|w

(2)

61162691762 !9 !66 2679"#$ 17%& '96 61(9&6'726'6)1762'1 '1* &$267 + 17+17!117122,9 &969 29& 6921-./01234125623178123921:;23<1=2341952789/19/012341>407292;5?154@455401 A7231234189>41B5C12;1237/D81/;21E45C154F924019>;/D1234>84FE48GH

I9 &7!62719692617,J27692661'2622 -21'1 69 2 K6K2&-K69"6221!2-692717&9217 622&1917L9"K6269 &912&1721,26 76766 K1,792!-&9"96&'6999 ,61K-"67,2769 22-212921,27269 ,2-62K177-96K9M-2N217 ,K1-219296699 L&OPQRS26192M-9&619",29 ,6,'71-2K2119,-6 761917+91!627+ -9 211 62"1!6,1"67 2"9 69 T16,, 9,29216 ,6219"16)16-7-6199,,66,627N919919 '91192K6K9 1966,621-92S

U9169 &91!669 6' 922,617921662 76!1L2,12K69 9176K696)2216969176266M- 2--669"N62629"9 !)27-691-2 K1,791 "1!6L619,1221'176*69 9 216"7961991917 !1*2S61-"6-7-6 J,962-26291V-267-9 111 1J)66

I96&-991!6,11W1917,1"6722-,,1 !)6 29,66 "7662916 6'6)969K2!'6)29OXXR&9 K9'62921*)9269A4F@954182924196L ,6999"6 9 &99 "&K6!)1769272121W6 76* 161621-29)1696-91!627&92292&2 K61912,7699)&2177296 9'6)&!-'1-69" "916 N6,121,6&,16&1917K2&S6,1K 2'K6) ,1"67912,6221)9'2,6,61929J-26!1

921,1 -1916,622)271'2!-6)

K26)191!6271 9 669211W1917,1V2& 6,,69)&2-,29"69 1291261266,6129691 "-669"W,1)1!VK#,1 -1911 2K2 Y216)&!6,1"6762"K9-,29OP₉_-₎₇₆₉_,6_9"

(3)

0 !"##$%&'$!#!""!! #(#("!#)!!%"%#!%!& "*" &(!#!'"" &'+%"##,"##$ '#!#*!"(-#!#(#"#(!!##"##"!#!%)# './*$&*! 0!#!#!-#)%'#" "'-!1##(1&#!2#(%&$"!&( -(!#!!"##(!#!#%,

9*)3'#*''#!(,4%"$!#( !"##''!!'!#%+!#!')#(!!#! "!"!#!')!%('!!"%!+(-#)!!!( #!##-!*"! (3*#'#(%'' !%##567!"8"!(")#9/ ))0 ''#! "(1#&:/%0$!)#"( #!#/'#'*0$((--%#&! !"! '/-!)!4,!3!"'"(%;!0 $ #"#$-- ! ()"!'#%!"*!" &1 ##!!"!"#" & !#%$8,,,#) "##"!,9

<=>?@A>BAC?@>DE>FBADGDHFAI>

%;0!&!3!"2)#$")&#!!% *!!%!# !!J!(!)'("!#!"*!#!#!$'!!" %#&#%$!"#K-"#)#,2!#!#'!'*!)'!$ ")&#!#!%%!*'%!# !#"+1! %!#!-"#( !0&(#!##+!#%!"#!(# 1 -1-")/""!'"!#8#(90!"# /1! %!#$5LM0,

0*!#('!$###$!& !##( # .)#'#!#!!(##!)"$ # %!!%'#$#($!")!"#,0) !))!"'# !#%%!#!")!#&#%(#)(! !"'#!('%!(#!#!"$#%!#&$)!( !")!!","#!'##(%!)%J! ##%&!!!()!(%!"#%)& &)!")#!$'!!"#!!####,#! !!"2"#!(%**"!)#$!#!)"#( '#!#' '!"#.")%!!)%('&+ %!1!#!8!&93#( .*&!")$%!),(8'9 (")#!"*!#/(,9$5N70,

(4)

271262299162729 169 162162 196 6 191!67226"62 19"212 66 #$11%1917 11261!!221 9 1676& 669"1'69()* 1922 9"99(9"+2 969 191!11"6696+11"6 , 11!2 6 79 2!!26217796 ,91796#

-9!6 *9162762661!'6 1!11"2.17262 !!11!21%629%11"(2216 196(/626 216"11 69+11"(1291 6,' 16.11 9 6(* 6&21610 69!6219291 9" 67119(122# 19612 69!17776 9"*21"671291 122226"16 29 6 191!2!6929 6(1979 119 96!6"79 ,179 9 ,,9 269*19229 (*2 16(92"9!69 #

$9167696 191!9+26719"212261 '6 1!11"2.69' 91!32 1(.2699 1" 17796 , 917961!174!1717 9"1222 1 2 9 1&21!7622 765#-9!2 6*17 29212 6 191!71921(612 19 169"6 191!76& 2(2 7119 6 "6721!916 1171796 1921!262%1719179!176 19*6 9" 9 11%19176 161 9(1!2 671! 192129221!9161" 6 62 6 1!'69.11"2( 76921!19216 191!2'19.*6(9"1 191!712 66 2 !6 299 29 !&91"46(1 6*78985:2962776991! 2!#

-92196*!6"79 6 191!6(6 9162776&2 211!7622%7669921291 2 11,,91966 ,9 262 92 79 2 6 76& 1229 "266696 2 161226919(96 9 26192 ,,179 1! 267#4;66*788<5#

;22*79 1929 !6917796 ,!6"79 6 1976926 2!22(7171,279 1!6(:9166"912227!2769 21669191717269112261"671!262,6 1902 622,6#-926(*916696 ,2626(6(96 62622 161 9( 129 2!62 19(,6 9621199!19 1!2121917172929 26 191! 32 1( 6 *661+6(*21979 127799 946699=* 78985#/1 61 *22676221!2121!69#9 62 1*917(17969 19176917796 ,9 2 2*6(6 6692,1(1!'6 1!11"2.1'91!32 1(.691!

(5)

!"

#$8%&&'()*+,-./0&123%456%17/89/:24%/&/72%;<84%.;5//41;%=61<;5%4 0<..%85;56151.%;<>;525<5%4>98%/0/8;%.?152;31848%/%3-2.2;3';20,561556%1<56/. 4/%;8/5;<.-.2;287&90/8;24%.1;24%/&/72%;$4%/&2>%.1&2;314/-5;562;5%068/0.1520 -/285/:?2%@/:56%?<&71.-/;252?2;35/4%:28%56%A24%/&/79A0/80%-5>93%18;/:56% 0<.2/<;42178/;2;/:25;8/8%=2;5%80%$

752;8/510151;5./-62;514?/0109/:56%%84/:12;5/.9><5.156%.56%>%7288287/: 56%62;5/.9/:0/33<820152?%./<528%561531B%;CDEFGDHDID/:;-%02:202592856% 4%;0.2-52/8/:.%&%?185:105;J24%852:9287;%&:2;6&956%;/02/K%0/8/320.%1&259@25656% 32.././:25;;23<&152/8$06%1.7<3%851>&%;%L<%80%&%14;:./3M56%49287;25<152/8/: 24%/&/72%;N5/56%M2..%?%.;2>&%%84/:12;5/.9N<84%.;5//41;1.%;<&5/:0/85.1;5;/: 1&5%.8152?%24%/&/7201&?2%@-/285;$

7856%@24%.187%/:&28%1&184090&201&0/80%-52/8;/:56%62;5/.201&-1;;287>9 /:523%/8&956%1%7%&218-/285/:?2%@-/;5<&15%;25;28%&<051>&%%84J1-1.14/=201& :/.%01;5:/.@6/3J1;$$1%7%&J1--./106%;56%5/-20>/56:./356%-/285/:?2%@/: 62&/;/-6918402%80%'1%7%&J()*O184()PO,$78562;56/<765;/<.0%$<B<9131 -20B;<-10/85.2><52/828@620656%%84/:56%0/&[email protected]%4%019/:56%.%1& ;/021&2;30/3-&%5%18285%.-.%52?%./&%;232&1.5/5615/:56%.%8069%?/&<52/8184 41-/&%/8Q;013-1278;2856%1%7%&218@/.B$

784%%4184:./356%8%/&2>%.1&-%.;-%052?%J56%42;1--%1.180%/:56%421&%0520;/: >&/0B;4/%;8/5/8&9.%-.%;%8556%>.%1B<-/:7%/;5.15%7205%8;2/8;><51&;/ <8%L<2?/01&;278;/:56%%84/:12;5/.9$5%.3281&-61;%28@620656%49287%?/&<52/8 /:24%/&/72%;@2&&&%1?%56%@195/56%-./-6%09/:182317281.94/;5.1413<;5615J15 56%?%.9%84/:132&&%882<3J188/<80%;56%-./7.%;;2?%<82?%.;1&2R152/8/:&2>%.1& 4%3/0.1091;1B284/:7/?%.83%8518456%%=5%8;2?%4/3128/:56%31.B%51;1@19/: 1&&/01528756%%0/8/320.%;/<.0%;/:;/02%59'0:$<B<9131J())O184())S,$

06%<82:9287188/<80%3%85-./-/;%;181<56%852062;5/.201&138%;21184J56<;J1 ;/3>%.-./;-%052?%$3%;;17%42::<;%4/856%;01&%/:56%-%.2-6%.1&01-251&2;3>91 7./@2870/33<8259/:;/021&184%4<0152/81&;02%852;5;:1;02815%4>9156%/.%5201& ;9;5%3%L<242;5185:./356%;/021&#1.@282;318456%5.<;52856%0/85./&/:-/&2520/K %0/8/320<80%.5128591>/<51@%&&KB8/@8:<5<.%/.J2818901;%J8/5;<>T%05%4%256%.5/ .184/3J/.5/56%.2;B;/:1&5%.8152?%24%/&/7201&184>%&&27%.%85-./T%05;$

06%-/;5K62;5/.201&-%.2/4&%4>915/51&2R2878%/&2>%.1&2;3@2&&>%8/56287><51 3%.%3%0618201&184-%.-%5<1&.%-./4<052/8/:25;%&:$<.-.2;287&9J56%-/285/:?2%@/: $<B<9131/856%6%7%3/820:<5<.%/:8%/&2>%.1&2;3100%-5;56%@%&&KB8/@81.=2;5 0&1<;%561524%852:2%;UICVHW1;56%M62;5/.9/:24%/&/72%;N18456%M62;5/.9/:56%:2765 /:0&1;;%;N184J28;6/.5J56%1>;%80%/:>/563%18;56%%84/:56%:2.;5/8%$

(6)

76261191 2!276"2#6!112$1917%$&&&'69 612691(6!1676"96%"16)1")91!62*2)62+61, 622-626691916229(6&

.)6696%6"796191 6%-11 696-)2161919) 776)9"-)66279199)261 )26929!9") 1 291!66!16191 ,62-9676"2$)699!%/0112/3450$! )61912)1)(692191 12699"11-1917 1222!)71919)6)6+61,676191 9 176192) 76$)2"91 217)9"-76%!621%$76%!)91!61"672-)6 2$2(%$61266122!1 !9" 6)6%)9) (721 )216691917121 )91!62791$62)6929 )622)1921 .66!1)76%676"9296$)6")9" 266%)%61") 6&

78798:;<=>?@AA

B&C+66$0&#BDDE'$FGHIJGKLMGJNKOPGHQNRHSGR$&96"676$+6196 T&C+$&#BDU'$VRHWPKHQNHRGLHPQNXRXYZGL$&.912$6

&C[%676$[&#BDDE'$\]VRHWPKGRHQNHRGH^PLIXJPG_\$[662$BDDE$&`-B

&C[%676$[&#BDDT'$VRHWPKGRHQNHRGH^PLIXJPGHaHNRHbRIPSXHcXSdJN$&e696$+6196 `&C6699f$0&5&#BDgU'$\hXKNIGJPLSXHNHPQNXRXYZGiHjNRNYGKIHIXSdLIXKNkHQNHRGH

VLOlNRGHQNHmcPOGYX\$1917n6%2611$9oBE$6!BDgU$&BB-B`E

U&C6699f$0&5&#BDgp'$\VRHQNdGINHLXdJNHNRHjWGLOPLSXHQNMNKQPNKINkHNKHqSrJPOGH FGIPKG\$5(26e66"6%6s111"n6$9oUg$91-6!BDgp$&p-U

p&C6699f$0&5&#BDgD'$VRHNtlPRPdJPXHLlIPRuHvNJJlSdNHaHJNWXJSlRGOPwKHQNRH RPdNJGRPLSXHMXRZIPOXxNOXKwSPOX$&89$s696"1

g&C66!762$0&#BDgT'$mXKXOPSPNKIXHNHPKINJrL$&.62$6

D&C6"$&y&#BDUE'$HmPNKOPGHQNHRGHFwYPOG$&s16-66)$+9122

BE&C6"$&y&#BDgE'$HFNOOPXKNLHLXdJNHRGHWPRXLXWZGHQNHRGH^PLIXJPGHlKPzNJLGR{69f6&$ 6

BB&C|%16$0&[&#BDgD'$HFGHOXKQPOPwKHMXLSXQNJKG$&}6$6 BT&C~"6ss.$0&#BDgE'$(2-1)$,1$6