ContentslistsavailableatSciVerseScienceDirect
Vaccine
jo u r n al h om ep a ge : w w w . e l s e v i e r . c o m / l o c a t e / v a c c i n e
Re-circulation
of
lymphocytes
mediated
by
sphingosine-1-phosphate
receptor-1
contributes
to
resistance
against
experimental
infection
with
the
protozoan
parasite
Trypanosoma
cruzi
Mariana
R.
Dominguez
a,b,
Jonatan
Ersching
a,b,
Ramon
Lemos
a,b,
Alexandre
V.
Machado
c,
Oscar
Bruna-Romero
d, Mauricio
M.
Rodrigues
a,b,∗,
José
Ronnie
C.
de
Vasconcelos
a,b,∗aCentrodeTerapiaCelulareMolecular(CTCMol),UniversidadeFederaldeSãoPaulo-EscolaPaulistadeMedicina,Brazil
bDepartamentodeMicrobiologia,ImunologiaeParasitologia,UniversidadeFederaldeSãoPaulo-EscolaPaulistadeMedicina,Brazil
cCentrodePesquisasRenéRachou,FIOCRUZ,BeloHorizonte,MG,Brazil
dDepartamentodeMicrobiologia,InstitutodeCiênciasBiológicas,UniversidadeFederaldeMinasGerais,BeloHorizonte,MG,Brazil
a
r
t
i
c
l
e
i
n
f
o
Articlehistory:
Received13December2011
Receivedinrevisedform26January2012 Accepted15February2012
Available online 28 February 2012
Keywords: CD8 Protozoan FTY720
Gene-basedvaccines
a
b
s
t
r
a
c
t
T-cellmediatedimmuneresponsesarecriticalforacquiredimmunityagainstinfectionbytheintracellular protozoanparasiteTrypanosomacruzi.Despiteitsimportance,itiscurrentlyunknownwhereprotectiveT cellsareprimedandwhethertheyneedtore-circulateinordertoexerttheiranti-parasiticeffector func-tions.Here,weshowthataftersubcutaneouschallenge,CD11c+-dependentspecificCD8+T-cellimmune responsetoimmunodominantparasiteepitopesarisesalmostsimultaneouslyinthedraininglymphnode (LN)andthespleen.However,untilday10afterinfection,weobservedaclearupregulationofactivation markersonlyonthesurfaceofCD11C+PDCA1+cellspresentintheLNandnotinthespleen.Therefore, wehypothesizedthatCD8+Tcellsre-circulatedrapidlyfromtheLNtothespleen.Weinvestigatedthis phenomenonbyadministeringFTY720toT.cruzi-infectedmicetopreventegressofTcellsfromtheLNby interferingspecificallywithsignallingthroughsphingosine-1-phosphatereceptor-1.InT.cruzi-infected micereceivingFTY720,CD8T-cellimmuneresponseswerehigherinthedrainingLNandsignificantly reducedintheirspleen.Mostimportantly,FTY720increasedsusceptibilitytoinfection,asindicatedby elevatedparasitemiaandacceleratedmortality.Similarly,administrationofFTY720tomicegenetically vaccinatedwithanimmunodominantparasiteantigensignificantlyreducedtheirprotectiveimmunity, asobservedbytheparasitemiaandsurvivalofvaccinatedmice.
Weconcludedthatre-circulationoflymphocytesmediatedbysphingosine-1-phosphatereceptor-1 greatlycontributestoacquiredandvaccine-inducedprotectiveimmunityagainstexperimentalinfection withahumanprotozoanparasite.
© 2012 Elsevier Ltd.
1. Introduction
T cells are important mediators of the adaptive immune response againstinfections caused by intracellular microorgan-isms, including the digenetic intracellular protozoan parasite
Trypanosomacruzi,thecausativeagentofChagasdisease(American trypanosomiasis).Geneticdeficiencyorspecifictreatments lead-ingtothedepletionofCD4+orCD8+Tcellscriticallyimpairsthe acquiredimmunityobservedduringexperimentalmouseinfection
[1–4].Although,theanti-parasiticeffectexertedbytheTcellsis
∗Correspondingauthorsat:CTCMol,UNIFESP– EscolaPaulistadeMedicina,Rua Mirassol,207,SãoPaulo-SP,04044-010,Brazil.Tel.:+551155711095;
fax:+551155711095.
E-mailaddresses:[email protected](M.M.Rodrigues), [email protected](J.R.C.deVasconcelos).
largelymediatedbyIFN-␥,othermediatorsmayalsoparticipatein theefficienteliminationofparasitesfromthehost[1–4].
Ininbredmousestrainsorhumans,MHCclassII-restrictedCD4+ Tcells recognizemultipleantigensfromT.cruzi[5–9],whereas MHC class Ia-restricted CD8+ T cells are primarily specific for immunodominantepitopesthatareexpressedbysurfaceantigens membersofalargefamilyofT.cruziproteinsnamedtrans-sialidases (TS)[1,4,9–18].Tcellsarenotonlycriticalforacquiredimmunity, buttheyarealsoimportantmediatorsofprotectiveimmunityin responsetovaccinationwithrecombinantproteins,plasmidDNA, andbacteria-andvirus-basedvaccineconstructsagainstT.cruzi [19–25].Additionally, asinthecase ofimmunityacquired dur-inginfection,IFN-␥isakeymediatorofprotectiveimmunity[25]. DespitetheimportantroleofT-cellmediatedimmuneresponses, itiscurrentlyunknownwhereprotectiveTcellsareprimedand whetherthey need tore-circulate in order to exert their anti-parasiticeffectorfunctionsduringacquiredimmuneresponses.
0264-410X/© 2012 Elsevier Ltd.
doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2012.02.037
Open access under the Elsevier OA license.
M.R.Dominguezetal./Vaccine30 (2012) 2882–2891 2883
Withthisaim,we firstevaluatedthekineticsofCD8+ T-cell activationintheLNand spleenfollowing asubcutaneous para-sitechallenge.Althoughthekineticsofactivationinbothlocations wereverysimilar,wedetectedthepresenceofclearlyactivated CD11C+PlasmacytoidDendriticCells1+(PDCA-1)cellsonlyinthe LN.CD11C+PDCA-1+areknownfortheircapacitytosecretelarge amountsoftypeIIFNuponactivation.Butmostimportantforour purposes,veryrecently,theyhavebeenimplicatedinthepriming ofCD8+Tcells[26].Basedonthat,wehypothesizedthatCD8+Tcells wereactivatedattheLNsandre-circulatedrapidlytothespleen.
To evaluate this possibility, we administered an immuno-suppressivedrug,FTY720,tointerferewithT-cell signallingvia
thesphingosine-1-phosphate receptor-1(S1P1). Thisreceptor is expressedonTcellsthatrespondtoS1P1byemigratingoutofthe thymus,LN,andbonemarrow[27–29].FollowingT-cellactivation, S1P1istransientlydownmodulated,resultinginprolonged resi-denceofTcellswithinlymphoidtissuesand improvedpriming efficacy.FTY720interfererswiththisprocess,sinceupon applica-tion,itbecomesrapidlyphosphorylatedtoFTY720-P,thusbehaving asa strongS1P1agonist.Thisresultsin sustainedinhibition of S1P1signalling,effectivelytrappingnaiveandrecentlyactivated Tcellswithinthesecondarylymphoid.AlthoughFTY720allows T-cellpriming,itefficientlyblocksmigrationofactivatedTcellsfrom theLNstotheperipheraltissuesandtherebyprecludesperipheral T-cellresponses[27–29].
Essentially,we observedthatadministration ofFTY720after challengewithT.cruziinmicethatnormallysurviveacuteinfection (C57Bl/6) or susceptible vaccinated A/Sn mice ledto a signifi-cantincrease in the susceptibilityto infection, as indicated by elevatedparasitemiaand accelerated mortality.Together,these resultscorroboratethehypothesisthatre-circulationofT lympho-cytesmediatedbyS1P1playsanimportantroleduringacquiredor vaccine-inducedprotectiveimmuneresponsestoT.cruziinfection.
2. Methods
2.1. Ethicsstatement
Thisstudywascarriedout instrictaccordancewiththe rec-ommendationsin theGuidefor theCareand UseofLaboratory AnimalsoftheBrazilianNationalCouncilof Animal Experimen-tation(http://www.cobea.org.br/).Theprotocolwasapprovedby theCommitteeontheEthicsofAnimalExperimentsofthe Institu-tionalAnimalCareandUseCommitteeattheFederalUniversityof SaoPaulo(Id#CEP0426/09).
2.2. Miceandparasites
Female8-week-oldmice(C57BL/6andA/Sn)werepurchased fromCEDEME(FederalUniversityofSãoPaulo).Transgenicmice expressingthediphtheriatoxinreceptor(DTR)undercontrolof theCD11cpromoter(CD11c-DTR)onaC57BL/6backgroundwere derivedasdescribedandweremaintainedinourcolonyas het-erozygotes[30].Blood-derivedtrypomastigotesoftheYstrainof
T.cruziwereobtainedfromA/Snmiceinfected7–8daysearlier. EachC57BL/6orA/Snmousewaschallengedsub-cutaneously(s.c.) atthebaseofthetailwithafinaldosecontaining104–105or150 parasites,respectively,inafinalvolumeof0.1mL.Parasite devel-opmentwasmonitoredbycountingthenumberofblood-derived trypomastigotesin5Loffreshbloodcollectedfromthetailvein
[10].
2.3. AdministrationofDTorFTY720
Wildtype(WT)andCD11c-DTRmiceweretreatedi.p.with2 dosesof50ng diphtheriatoxinfromCorynebacteriumdiphteriae
(DT,Sigma),48hbeforeandonthesamedayofchallenge.In addi-tion,infectedWTmiceweretreatedeveryotherday,beginningon thesamedayofinfection,withdosesof20gFTY720(Cayman Chemical,AnnArbor,MI)permouse(1mg/kg)inafinalvolumeof 0.2mL.Thecontrolmicewereinjectedwiththediluentonly.
2.4. Peptides
PeptideswerepurchasedfromGenscript(Piscataway,NJ).Purity wasasfollows:VNHRFTLV,97.2%andTsKb-20(ANYKFTLV),99.7%.
2.5. Recombinantplasmidsandadenoviruses
PlasmidpIgSPCl.9andthehumanreplication-defective aden-ovirustype5containingtheasp-2geneweredescribedpreviously
[22,24,25,31].Heterologousprime-boostimmunization involved primingi.m.with100gofplasmidDNAfollowedbyadoseofviral suspensioncontaining2×108plaque-formingunits(pfu)of aden-ovirus21dayslaterinthesamelocations.Immunologicalassaysor challengeswereperformed14daysafterviralinoculation(boost).
2.6. Phenotypiccellanalysesbyflowcytometry
ThepanelofconjugatedantibodiesusedforFACSanalyseswere CD11c-FITC (clone HL3), CD19-PECy7 (clone 1D3), CD8␣-PerCP (clone53-6.7),CD86-APC(cloneGL1),CD80-APC(clone16-10A1), CD40-APC(clone3/23)allfromBD;PDCA-1-PE(cloneJF05-1C2.4.1) fromMiltenyiBiotec.Single-cellsuspensionsfromInguinallymph nodesorspleenwerestainedforsurfacemarkersonicefor20min, andthen washedtwiceinbuffercontainingPBS,0.5%BSA, and 2mMEDTAfixedin4%PBS-paraformaldehydesolutionfor10min. Atleast300,000eventswereacquiredonaBDFACSCantoIIflow cytometerandthenanalyzedwithFlowJo(TreeStar,Ashland,OR).
2.7. Sortingofcellsbyflowcytometry
PDCA-1+ cellswereisolatedfromLN collectedfromC57BL/6 miceinfected5daysearliers.c.with104T.cruziparasites.As con-trols,weusedPDCA-1+cellsisolatedfromLNofnaïveC57BL/6mice (n=15).Inguinallymphnodeswereremoved,collagenase-treated, andthesinglecellsuspensionwasstainedwiththefollowing anti-bodies:CD3PacificBlue(500A2),IAbFITC(25-9-17),CD11cAPCCy7 (HL3)allfromBD, and PDCA-1PE(JF05-1C2.4.1) fromMiltenyi Biotec.CD3−IAb+CD11c+PDCA-1+cellswerethensortedinaBD FACSAriaIIIcellsorter.
CD8+cellswereobtainedfromC57BL/6mice(n=2)s.c.infected with104 T.cruziparasites.Spleenswereremoved15daysafter infection.Followingredbloodcelllysis,asinglecellsuspension wasstainedwithCD8PE(53-6.7)fromBDandpositivecellswere subjectedtosortinginaBDFACSAriaIIIcellsorter.Asdetermined byFACSanalysis,thepurityoftheCD8+was98%.
2.8. ImmunologicalT-cellassays
ExvivoELISPOT(IFN-␥)orinvivocytotoxicityassayswere per-formedexactlyasdescribedpreviously[13,25].Briefly,theinvivo
cytotoxicityassays, C57BL/6 splenocytes weredividedinto two populationsandlabeledwiththefluorogenicdye carboxyfluores-ceindiacetatesuccinimidyldiester(CFSEMolecularProbes,Eugene, Oregon,USA)atafinalconcentrationof10M(CFSEhigh)or1M (CFSElow).CFSEhighcellswerepulsedfor40minat37◦Cwith1M
2884 30 (2012) 2882–2891
Fig.1. KineticsofthespecificCD8+T-cell-mediatedimmuneresponsesinmiceinfectedwithT.cruzi
C57BL/6micewerechallengeds.c.with104blood-bornetrypomastigotesoftheYstrainofT.cruzi.Attheindicateddays,IFN-␥-producingcellswereestimatedexvivoby
usingtheELISPOTassayinthepresenceofpeptidesVNHRFTLV(PanelA)orTsKb-20(PanelB).Theinvivocytotoxicactivitieswereestimatedagainsttargetcellscoatedwith peptidesVNHRFTLV(PanelC)orTsKb-20(D).Theresultsarepresentedasthemeanofthevaluesof4mice±SDpergroup,exceptfortheinvivocytotoxicactivityofLN cells.Inthatcase,wepooledcellsfrom4miceforanalysis.AsterisksdenotethefrequencyofSFCsinthespleenofinfectedmiceweresignificantlyhigherthantheLNcells (P<0.05).
lymphnodecellsofrecipientmicewerecollected20hafter trans-fer,fixedwith3.7%paraformaldehydeandanalyzedby FACSas describedabove.Thepercentageofspecificlysiswasdetermined usingtheformula:
1−%CFSEhigh infected/%CFSElow infected %CFSEhigh naive/%CFSElow naive ×
100%
ThesurfacemobilizationofCD107aandtheintracellular expres-sionofcytokines(IFN-␥andTNF-␣)wereevaluatedafterinvitro
cultureofsplenocytesinthepresenceorabsenceofanantigenic stimulus. Cells were washed 3 times in plain RPMI and re-suspendedincellculturemediumcontainingRPMI1640medium (pH7.4),supplementedwith10mMHepes,0.2%sodium bicarbon-ate,59mg/Lpenicillin,133mg/Lstreptomycin,and10%Hyclone fetalbovinesera(Hyclone,Logan,Utah).Theviabilityofcellswas evaluatedusing0.2%Trypan Blueexclusion dyetodiscriminate betweenliveanddeadcells.Thecellconcentrationwasadjusted to5×106cells/mLinacellculturemediumcontaininganti-CD28 (2g/mL,BD Pharmingen),brefeldinA(10g/mL,BD Pharmin-gen),monensin(5g/mL,Sigma,St.Louis,MO),andFITC-labeled anti-CD107a(Clone1D4B,2g/mL,BDPharmingen).Inhalfofthe cultures,VNHRFTLVpeptidewasaddedatafinalconcentrationof 10M.CellswerecultivatedinV-bottom96-wellplates(Corning)
inafinalvolumeof200Linduplicates,at37◦Cinahumid
envi-ronmentcontaining5%CO2.Afternomorethan12hincubation, cellswereharvestedandstainedforsurfacemarkerswithPer-CP orPE-labeledanti-CD8onicefor20min.TodetectIFN-␥,or
TNF-␣byintracellularstaining(ICS),cellswerethenwashedtwicein buffercontainingPBS,0.5%BSA,and2mMEDTAandthenfixedand permeabilizedfor20minonicewith100LCytofix/Cytoperm(BD Pharmingen).Afterwashingtwicewith250Lpermwashbuffer (BD Pharmingen), the cells were stainedto detectintracellular markersusingAPCorPE-labeledanti-IFN-␥(cloneXMG1.2)and PE-labeledanti-TNF-␣(cloneMP6-XT22).Finally,cellswerewashed twice and fixed in 1% PBS-paraformaldehyde.At least 300,000 eventswereacquiredona BDFACSCantoIIflowcytometerand thenanalyzedwithFlowJo(TreeStar,Ashland,OR).
2.9. Statisticalanalysis
Valuesareexpressedasmeans±SD.Thesevalueswere com-pared using Oneway ANOVA followed by Tukey’s HSD tests (http://faculty.vassar.edu/lowry/VassarStats.html). The Logrank testwasusedtocomparemousesurvivalratesafterchallengewith
M.R.Dominguezetal./Vaccine30 (2012) 2882–2891 2885
Fig.2.CD11c+cellsarerequiredfortheCD8T-cellimmuneresponsesofmice
infectedwithT.cruzi.
WTorCD11c-DTRmicewereinfecteds.c.with104T.cruzibloodparasites.48h
beforeandonthedayofchallenge,WTandCD11c-DTRmiceweretreatedi.p.with 50ngofDT.Oneweeklater,IFN-␥-producingspleencellswereestimatedexvivoby ELISPOTinthepresenceofpeptidesVNHRFTLVorTsKb-20.Resultsareexpressedas means±SDof4micepergroupandarerepresentativeofexperimentsperformedat twicewithsimilarresults.Asterisksdenotethatthenumberofspotsformingcells (SFC)frominfectWTmiceweresignificantlyhigherwhencomparedtonaïveor infectedCD11c-DTRmice(P<0.01,one-wayANOVA).
3. Results
During experimentalinfectionof H-2b inbred mousestrains withparasitesoftheYstrainofT.cruzi,epitopesVNHRFTLVand TsKb-20 (ANYKFTLV) are recognized by H-2Kb-restricted CD8+ cytotoxicTcells.Inpreviousstudieswehavedescribedthatthe firstistheimmunodominantepitopeleadingtoahigherimmune responseandthesecondasub-dominantepitope[10,12,13].After s.c. challenge withinfective trypomastigoteforms of the para-site,detailedanalysesofthekineticsofpeptide-specificimmune responsesweredeterminedexvivobyELISPOTandinvivoby cyto-toxicityassays.Attheindicatedtimepoints,spleenorLNcellswere incubatedinvitrowithmedium(control)orpeptides(VNHRFTLV orTsKb-20).Thenumberofpeptide-specificIFN-␥secretingcells wasdeterminedbyELISPOTassay(13).Alternatively,atthe indi-catedtimepoints,targetcellswerelabeledwithCFSEandcoated withpeptidesVNHRFTLV or TsKb-20as described inSection 2. Thesecellsweretransferredtoinfectedornaïvemice.Twentyhours later,spleenorLNcellswerecollectedandtheinvivocytotoxicity estimated.
Theresultsshowedthattheeffectorpeptide-specificimmune cellsdevelopedatasimilarrateinboththedrainingLNandthe spleen(Fig.1A–D).Themaintransitionoccurredfromdays4to12 inbothorgans,forbothpeptides.
To determine the role of CD11c+ cells during the expan-sion/maturationphaseoftheadaptiveimmuneresponse,weused transgenicmiceexpressingtheDTRundercontrolof theCD11c promoter.Wheninfectedmiceweresubjectedtodiphtheriatoxin (DT),thepeptide-specificimmuneresponseintheirspleen12days afterinfectionwasseverelycompromised,asmeasuredusingthe ELISPOTassay(Fig.2).TheseresultsstronglysuggestthatCD11c+ cellsareimportantforprimingofpeptide-specificcellsfollowing
T.cruziinfection.
TofurtherevaluatethesubpopulationofCD11c+cellsthatcould potentiallybeinvolved inthepriming ofthepeptide-specificT
cells,westainedLNandspleencellswithantibodiestoCD11cand PDCA-1andtheactivationmarkersCD40,CD40L,CD80,andCD86 atdifferenttimesafterchallenge.AsdepictedinFig.3A,aclear upregulatedpatternofexpressionofCD40,CD80andCD86,butnot CD40L,canbeseenonthesurfaceofCD11c+PDCA-1+cellsobtained fromtheLN.Incontrast,wedetectonlytheupregulationofCD40 onCD11c+PDCA-1+splenocytesatday10afterinfection(Fig.3B).
In addition, we also stained LN and spleen cells for CD11c expressioninconjuctionwithCD8␣inadditiontotheactivation markersCD40,CD40L,andCD86atdifferenttimesafterinfection. AlimitedpatternofupregulationofexpressionofCD86canbeseen onthesurfaceofCD11c+CD8␣+cellscollectedfromtheLNorspleen ondays3–7followinginfection(Fig.4AandB).
SimilaranalyseswerealsoconductedforCD11C+CD8a− cells
collectedfromthespleenandLN,butwedidnotdetectan upregu-lationofexpressionoftheactivationmarkersCD40,CD40L,CD80, orCD86atanytimepointfrom3to30daysinthespleenorLN (datanotshown).
To determine whether indeed CD11c+PDCA-1+ cells could present antigen for specific CD8 lymphocytes, we purified CD11c+PDCA-1+.Aftersortingthecellsfromnaïveor5-dayinfected LNcells,weobtainedcellsthatwere95.3and83%pureas deter-minedby thePDCA-1marker (Fig. 5Aand B, respectively). For someunknownreason,duringthepurificationprocess,somecells becomenegativeforthemarkerforCD11cmarkerbutstillretained thePDCA-1marker.ThePDCA-1+ cellsobtainedfrommicethat wereinfectedexpressedsignificantlyhigheramountsof MHC-II-IAb and CD80(Fig.5C and D,respectively).PDCA-1+ cells were used to stimulate purified CD8+ splenic cells obtained from T.
cruziinfected mice.Asshown in Fig. 5E, IFN-␥ producing cells weredetectedonlywhenCD8+wereincubatedwithPDCA-1+cells obtainedfrominfectedmice.
ThefactthatCD11c+cellsfromthespleenexhibitalimited acti-vationphenotypesuggestedthatperhapsmostofthespecificTcells foundinthespleenmightnotbeprimedthere.Ifthisassumptionis correct,there-circulationofTcellscouldaccountfortheCD8+T-cell mediatedfunctionsdetectedinthisorgan.Totestwhether lym-phocytere-circulationwasresponsiblefortheimmuneresponse observedinthespleen,wetreatedinfectedmicewithFTY720.This immunosupressivedruginhibitsS1P1signalling,thusefficiently blockingre-circulationofnaïveandactivatedTcellsfromtheLNs intoperipheraltissues,therebypreventingdevelopmentperipheral T-cellresponses[27–29].
MicewereinfectedwithT.cruziparasitesandFTY720or dilu-entwereadministeredonthesamedayofchallengeandevery2 daysthereafterasdescribedinSection2.Twoweekslater,the fre-quencyofIFN-␥-producingcellswereestimatedexvivobyusing ELISPOTassayinthepresenceofpeptidesVNHRFTLVorTsKb-20. Alternatively,splenocyteswereculturedinthepresenceorabsence ofpeptidesVNHRFTLVorTsKb-20andtheexpressionofsurface CD107a,IFN-␥andTNF-␣byICS.
In infected mice,administrationof FTY720resulted in 2.52-or 3.05-fold increasesin the frequency of IFN-␥-secreting cells fromtheLNsspecificforVNHRFTLVorTsKb-20,respectively,as detectedusingtheELISPOTassay(Fig.6).Incontrast,thisincrease inthefrequencyIFN-␥-secretingpeptide-specificcellsintheLN wasaccompaniedbyasignificantdecreaseofimmuneresponses ofsplenic lymphocytes.Immune responseswereinitially deter-minedbythefrequencyofIFN-␥-producingcellsasmeasuredby theELISPOTassay(Fig.7A).ThefrequencyofIFN-␥-producingcells foundinthespleenafterFTY720administrationwasreducedby 74.55%or100%uponstimulationwithpeptidesVNHRFTLVor TsKb-20,respectively(Fig.7A).
2886 30 (2012) 2882–2891
Fig.3. ExpressionofactivationmarkersonCD11c+andPDCA-1+DCsfromtheLNsorspleensfrominfectedmice
WTC57BL/6micewereinfecteds.c.with104T.cruzibloodparasites.Attheindicateddaysafterinfection,LN(panelA)orsplenic(PanelB)cellswerecollectedandco-stained
fortheexpressionofCD11c,PDCA-1,andtheindicatedmarker.
Theexpressionofthedifferentactivationmarkerswerecomparedbetweencellscollectedfrominfected(bluelines)andnaïve(redlines)mice.
peptidesinvitro.ThefrequencyofCD8+cellsthatwereCD107a+, IFN-␥+ or TNF-␣+ wasreduced by74.61% or 84.15%after stim-ulation withVNHRFTLV or TsKb-20, respectively (Fig. 7B). The reductionsubstantiallyaffectedallthedifferentsubpopulationsof CD8+ cells (Fig.7C).Theproportionsofeachpopulationdidnot changesignificantlyinthecellscollectedfrominfectedmicethat wereadministeredornotwithFTY720(Fig.7D).
ToevaluatetheinfluenceofrestrictingT-cellre-circulationon theoutcomeofinfection,wealsomonitoredtheparasitemialevels andsurvivalofmicethatwereandwerenotsubjectedtoFTY720 overthecourseofinfection.Wefoundthatdrugexposureresulted inincreasedparasitemiaandacceleratedmortalityofinfectedmice (Fig.8AandB,respectively).Therefore,weconcludedthat lympho-cytere-circulationisindeedimportantfortheacquiredprotective immuneresponseinthismousemodelofacuteinfection.
We then sought totest thesame hypothesis by applying a distinctlydifferentapproach.Inthiscase,weusedhighly suscep-tibleA/Snmicethatweregeneticallyvaccinatedbyprimingwith
plasmidpIgSPCl.9followedbyaboosterimmunizationwith AdASP-2. We previously showed that this heterologous prime-boost regimen reproducibly conferred protective immunity against a lethalchallengewithT.cruzi[25].ImmunitywasmediatedbyCD8+ TcellsasdepletionoftheseTcellsrendersthesemicecompletely susceptibletoinfection.TheseCD8+Tcellsarespecificforthe ASP-2H-KkrestrictedepitopesTEWETGQI,PETLGHEIorYEIVAGYI[31]. Priortochallenge,thesemiceexhibitastrongimmuneresponseto allthreeepitopes[31].
M.R.Dominguezetal./Vaccine30 (2012) 2882–2891 2887
Fig.4.ExpressionofactivationmarkersonCD11c+andCD8-␣+DCsfromtheLNsorspleensofinfectedmice
WTC57BL/6micewereinfecteds.c.with104T.cruzibloodparasites.Attheindicateddaysafterinfection,LN(panelA)orsplenic(PanelB)cellswerecollectedandco-stained
fortheexpressionofCD11c,CD8-␣,andtheindicatedmarker.
Theexpressionofthedifferentactivationmarkerswerecomparedoncellscollectedfrominfected(bluelines)andnaïve(redlines)mice.
protectiveimmuneresponse,asseeninthissecondmousemodel ofacuteinfection.
4. Discussion
TheCD8+T-cellimmuneresponseelicitedbyT.cruziinfectionin mostinbredmousestrainscancontrolmultiplicationofthis intra-cellularpathogenandpreclude acute-phasepathologies suchas death[1,10–17].Thetimeatwhichacquiredimmunitydevelopsis highlydependentontheparasiteload[12,32].Inourmodel,with theYstrainofT.cruzi,weobservedthattheCD8+T-cellimmune response is only triggeredat thetime of thepeak parasitemia
[10,12].Becausethenumberofcirculatingparasitesatthistime ishigh,antigenpresentationcouldoccurinthedrainingLNorthe spleen.However,theresultsofourexperimentsthatinvolvedthe useoftheimmunosupressivedrugFTY720,incombinationwith theidentificationofactivatedCD11c+cells,foundmostlyintheLN, clearlydemonstratedthattheLNsdrainingtheparasiteentrance arewherethespecificCD8+Tcellsareprimed.Then,theyexittheLN andreachthespleen.Ourresultsaresimilartothoseof experimen-talvaccinationstudieswithradiation-attenuatedmalariaparasites
[33].In this case,theCD8+ T-cellresponseoriginatesin theLN drainingsiteatthesiteofparasiteentranceintheskin,andthen thesecellsmigratetootherperipheralorgans.Similartoourresults, exposuretoFTY720ledtoaccumulationofspecificTcellsinthe drainingLNanda∼85%reductionofthespecificCD8+Tcellsinthe spleen[33].Together,theseresultsprovidecompellingevidence thattheprimingofCD8+Tcellscantakeplaceinthelocallymphoid tissueduringprotozoaninfection/vaccinationandthatarapid re-circulationtothespleenislikelytooccur.Asinourcase,theauthors concludethatthisrapidre-circulationduringinfectionwascritical forprotectiveimmunitymediatedbymalaria-specificCD8+Tcells
[33].
2888 30 (2012) 2882–2891
Fig.5.PDCA-1+cellspurifiedfrominfectedmicepresentantigentospecificCD8+
cells.
PDCA-1+cellsweresortedfromLNcellsfrommiceinfected5daysearliers.c.withT.
cruziparasitesasdescribedinSection2.Ascontrols,weusedPDCA-1+cellsisolated
fromLNofnaïvemice.
(AandB)Sortedcellsfromnaïveorinfectedmicewerestainedwithantibodiesto CD11candPDCA-1.Numbersrepresentthefrequencyofcellsineachgate. (CandD)PDCA-1+cellswerestainedwithantibodiestoIAborCD80.
(E)PurifiedPDCA-1+cellsfromnaïveorinfectedmicewereusedin
quadrupli-cateculturestostimulatespecificCD8+cells.Asteriskdenotesthethatnumber
ofSFCsofCD8+cellsstimulatedwithPDCA-1+cellspurifiedfrominfectedmice
weresignificantlyhighertheonestimulatedwithPDCA-1+cellsfromnaïveanimals
(P<0.01).
infections [34–36]. The precise reasons for these divergent responsesarenotclearbutprobablyreflectdifferencesinthe prim-ingsitesaswellas,theimmunopathologiescausedbythedifferent infectiousagents.
Inaddition totheroleof S1P1-dependentcirculationduring protective immunityacquired duringT. cruziinfection, wealso
Fig.6.AdministrationofFTY720increasesthenumberofpeptide-specificcellsin theLNofmiceinfectedwithT.cruzi.
C57BL/6micewereinfecteds.c.with105T.cruziblood-borneparasites.Micewere
administeredonthesamedayofchallengeandevery2daysthereafter20gof FTY720ordiluenti.p.Twoweekslater,thefrequencyofIFN-␥-producingcellswere estimatedexvivobyusingELISPOTassayinthepresenceofpeptidesVNHRFTLV orTsKb-20.Theresultsarepresentedasmeans±SDof4micepergroupandare representativeofexperimentsperformedatleasttwicewithsimilarresults. Aster-isksdenotethenumberofSFCsfrominfectedmicegivenFTY720weresignificantly higherthaninfectedmicetreatedwiththediluentonly(P<0.01).
observedthatpreviouslyvaccinatedmicebecamemoresusceptible toinfectionwhensubjectedtoFTY720exposure.Forvaccination, weusedaheterologousprime-boostregimenconsistingofan ini-tialimmunizationwithplasmidDNAandaboosterimmunization withareplication-defectiverecombinanthumanadenovirustype 5(HuAd5),bothencodingtheasp-2gene.Immunityelicitedbythis vaccinationprotocolislonglivedandmediatedbyTh1CD4+aswell asCD8+Tc1cells[25,31,37].
Theheterologousprime-boostingregimenofvaccinationusing plasmidDNAandreplication-defectiverecombinantHuAd5 pro-videsprotective immunityinsomeotherimportantpre-clinical experimental modelssuch as SIV,malaria, Ebola, and Marburg viruses[38–45].Based onthesepre-clinicalexperimental mod-els,humantrialshavebeeninitiated[46–49].Ourobservationthat S1P1isimportantforprotectiveactivityofTcellsinpreviously vac-cinatedanimalsiscompletelynewandshouldbestudiedfurther intheseexperimentalmodels.
Although we measured only CD8 T-cell mediated immune responsesonly,itishighlypossiblethatthesamepatternwould happentospecificCD4+Tcells.ThisT-cellsub-populationisvery important for protective immunity during to T. cruzi infection
[25]. The absence of re-circulation of both types of lympho-cytesprobablyaccountforthesub-optimalprotectiveimmunity observedafteradministrationofFTY720.Possibly,bothcells pro-mote the processes required for parasite elimination on the tissue.
ThefactthatFTY720interferewithS1P1activationmakesit theoreticallycapableofactonothercellstypesthatexpressthis receptor.However,theeffectonothercelltypesispoorlyknown atpresent.IthasbeenpreviouslydescribedthatFTY720 admin-istrationmayincreaseorreducetheactivityofregulatoryTcells
M.R.Dominguezetal./Vaccine30 (2012) 2882–2891 2889
Fig.7. AdministrationofFTY720reducesthenumberofpeptide-specificcellsinthe spleenofmiceinfectedwithT.cruzi
C57BL/6micewereinfecteds.c.with104T.cruziblood-borneparasites.Micewere
administeredonthesamedayofchallengeandevery2daysthereafter20gof FTY720ordiluenti.p.Twoweekslater,thefrequencyofIFN-␥-producingcellswere estimatedexvivobyusingELISPOTassayinthepresenceofpeptidesVNHRFTLVor TsKb-20(PanelsAandB).
Alternatively,splenocytesfromthesemicewereculturedinthepresenceof anti-CD107aandanti-CD28,withorwithoutthepeptidesVNHRFTLVorTsKb-20.After 12h,thecellswerestainedtodetectCD8,IFN-␥,andTNF-␣(PanelsCandD).The resultsarepresentedasmeans±SDof4micepergroupandarerepresentativeof experimentsperformedatleasttwicewithsimilarresults.Asterisksdenotethatthe numberofSFCsfrominfectedmicereceivingFTY720weresignificantlylowerthan theinfectedmicetreatedwiththediluentalone(P<0.01).
AcurrentlimitationofthisexperimentalmodelforT.cruzi infec-tionisthelackofinformationonwhereCD8+ Tcells encounter andeliminateparasite-infected cells;thisisanaspectthatmay be critical to fully understand immune responses. Considering
Fig.8. AdministrationofFTY720increasessusceptibilitytoT.cruziinfection C57BL/6micewereinfecteds.c.with105T.cruzibloodparasites.Miceweretreated
onthesamedayofchallengeandevery2daysthereafterwith20gofFTY720 i.p.ordiluentonly.(A)Parasitemialevelsforeachmousegroupispresentedasthe mean±SD(n=6).Asterisksdenotethatmicefromgroupsinjectedwithdiluentonly exhibitedsignificantlylowerparasitemia(P<0.01)thananimalsreceivingFTY720. (B)Kaplan–Meiersurvivalcurvesforthemousegroupstreatedasdescribedabove (n=6).Micefromgroupsinjectedwithdiluentonlysurvivedlongerthananimals receivingFTY720(P<0.01,Logranktest).Noanimalsdiedafterthe30thdayuntil theterminationoftheexperiment.Theresultsarerepresentativeof2independent experiments.
that T. cruzi can infect many cell types and cause systemic infection, it is plausible that many tissues may serve as sites of infection and for parasite/T-cell encounters. Supporting this hypothesis,weobservedthatvaccinated animalswereresistant toT.cruzichallengebydifferentroutesofinfection(i.p.ands.c.
[25,37]).
The finding that the administration of FTY720 significantly reducesprotectiveimmunityagainstT.cruziinfectionandimpairs theprotectiveimmunityaffordedbyvaccinationmayalsohave clinicalimplicationsfortheuseofthisimmunosuppressivedrug. Certainly, its use in regions where Chagas disease is endemic shouldbedonewithcautionconsideringthepotentialincreasein susceptibilityoftreated individuals.Finally,treatmentof organ-transplantedpatientswithFTY720mayinterferewithimmunity elicitedbypreviousvaccination.
2890 30 (2012) 2882–2891
Fig.9.AdministrationofFTY720increasessusceptibilitytoT.cruziinfectionin pre-viouslyvaccinatedA/Snmice
A/Snmicewereprimedi.m.with100gofplasmids,pcDNA3orpIgSPCl.9.Three weekslater,thesemicewereboostedi.m.with2×108pfuAd-galorAdASP-2.
Allmicewerechallengeds.c.with150bloodstreamtrypomastigotes.Halfofthe vaccinatedmicereceived20gofFTY720everyotherday,andtheotherhalf receiveddiluentonly.(A)Parasitemialevelsforeachmousegroupispresented asthemean±SD(n=5).Asterisksdenotethatmicefromgroupsimmunizedwith pIgSPCl.9/AdASP-2andwhoreceiveddiluentonlyhadsignificantlylower para-sitemiathanothermousegroups(P<0.01).(B)Kaplan–Meiersurvivalcurvesforthe mousegroupsimmunizedandchallengedasdescribedabove(n=10).Mice immu-nizedwithpIgSPCl.9/AdASP-2andreceivingdiluentonlysurvivedsignificantly longerthanthoseimmunizedwithpIgSPCl.9/AdASP-2andadministeredFTY720 (P<0.01).Theresultsshownarecombinedfrom2experiments.Noanimalsdied afterthe50thdayofchallenge.
Acknowledgments
Funding:Fundac¸ãodeAmparoàPesquisadoEstadodeSãoPaulo (2009/06820-4), The National Institute for Vaccine Technology (INCTV-CNPq),TheMillenniumInstituteforVaccineDevelopment and Technology (CNPq – 420067/2005-1) and The Millennium InstituteforGeneTherapy(Brazil).MMR,OBRandRLare recip-ientsoffellowshipsfromCNPq.MRD,JEandJRVarerecipientsof fellowshipsfromFAPESP.Conflictofinterest:Theauthorsdeclareno competinginterest.Authors’contributions:MRD,JE,RL,andJRV per-formedtheexperimentalwork;AVMandOBRprovidedessential reagents;MRD,JE,RL,MMRandJRVwereresponsiblefor concep-tionanddesign,aswellaswritingthefirstandfinalversionsofthe manuscript.Allauthorshavereadandapproveofthefinalversion ofthemanuscript.
References
[1] TarletonRL.Immunesystem recognitionofTrypanosomacruzi.CurrOpin Immunol2007;9:430–4.
[2] MiyahiraY.TrypanosomacruziinfectionfromtheviewofCD8+Tcell
immu-nity– aninfectionmodelfordevelopingTcellvaccine.ParasitolInt2008;57: 38–48.
[3] PadillaAM,BustamanteJM.TarletonRLCD8+TcellsinTrypanosomacruzi infection.CurrOpinImmunol2009;21:385–90.
[4] JunqueiraC,CaetanoB,BartholomeuDC,etal.Theendlessracebetween Try-panosomacruziandhostimmunity:lessonsforandbeyondChagasdisease. ExpertRevMolMed2010;12:e29.
[5] ArnholdtAC,PiuvezamMR,RussoDM,LimaAP,PedrosaRC,ReedSG,etal. AnalysisandpartialepitopemappingofhumanTcellresponsestoTrypanosoma cruzicysteinylproteinase.JImmunol1993;151:3171–9.
[6] Michailowsky V, Luhrs K, Rocha MO, Fouts D, Gazzinelli RT, Manning JE.Humoralandcellularimmuneresponses toTrypanosomacruzi-derived paraflagellarrodproteinsinpatients withChagas’ disease.InfectImmun 2003;71:3165–71.
[7]MillarAE,Wleklinski-LeeM,KahnSJ.Thesurfaceproteinsuperfamilyof Try-panosomacruzistimulatesapolarizedTh1responsethatbecomesanergic.J Immunol1999;162:6092–9.
[8]RibeirãoM, Pereira-Chioccola VL,RéniaL, Schenkman S,RodriguesMM. ChagasicpatientsdeveloptypeiimmuneresponsetoTrypanosomaCruzi trans-sialidase.ParasiteImmunol2000;22:49–53.
[9] CuellarA,RojasF,Bola ˜nosN,etal.NaturalCD4(+)T-cellresponsesagainst TrypanosomacruziKMP-11proteininchronicchagasicpatients.ImmunolCell Biol2009;87:149–53.
[10]TzelepisF,deAlencarBC,PenidoML,GazzinelliRT,PersechiniPM,etal.Distinct kineticsofeffectorCD8+cytotoxicTcellsafterinfectionwithTrypanosomacruzi
innaiveorvaccinatedmice.InfectImmun2006;74:2477–81.
[11]MartinDL,WeatherlyDB,LaucellaSA,CabinianMA,CrimMT,etal.CD8+ T-CellresponsestoTrypanosomacruziarehighlyfocusedonstrain-variant trans-sialidaseepitopes.PLoSPathog2006;2(8):e77.
[12]Tzelepis F, Persechini PM, RodriguesMM. Modulation of CD4(+) T cell-dependentspecificcytotoxicCD8(+)Tcellsdifferentiationandproliferation bythetimingofincreaseinthepathogenload.PLoSOne2007;2(4):e393. [13] TzelepisF,deAlencarBC,PenidoML,etal.InfectionwithTrypanosomacruzi
restrictstherepertoireofparasite-specificCD8+Tcellsleadingto immunodom-inance.JImmunol2008;180:1737–48.
[14]BixbyLM,TarletonRL.StableCD8+Tcellmemoryduringpersistent Try-panosomacruziinfection.JImmunol2008;181:2644–50.
[15] RosenbergCS,Martin DL, Tarleton RL. CD8+ Tcells specificfor immun-odominanttrans-sialidaseepitopescontributetocontrolofTrypanosomacruzi infectionbutarenotrequiredforresistance.JImmunol2010;185:560–8. [16] Freire-de-LimaL,Alisson-SilvaF,CarvalhoST,etal.Trypanosomacruzi
sub-vertshostcellsialylationandmaycompromiseantigen-specificCD8+Tcell responses.JBiolChem2010;285:13388–96.
[17]OliveiraAC,deAlencarBC,TzelepisF,etal.Impairedinnateimmunityin Tlr4(−/−)micebutpreservedCD8+TcellresponsesagainstTrypanosomacruzi inTlr4-,Tlr2-,Tlr9-orMyd88-deficientmice.PLoSPathog2010;6(4):e1000870. [18]RodriguesMM,deAlencarBC,ClaserC,TzelepisF.Immunodominance:anew hypothesistoexplainparasiteescapeandhost/parasiteequilibriumleadingto thechronicphaseofChagas’disease.BrazJMedBiolRes2009;42:220–3. [19]VasconcelosJR,HiyaneMI,MarinhoCR,etal.Protectiveimmunityagainst
Try-panosomacruziinfectioninahighlysusceptiblemousestrainaftervaccination withgenesencodingtheamastigotesurfaceprotein-2andtrans-sialidase.Hum GeneTher2004;15:878–86.
[20]MiyahiraY,TakashimaY,KobayashiS,etal.Immuneresponsesagainsta sin-gleCD8+-T-cellepitopeinducedbyvirusvectorvaccinationcansuccessfully controlTrypanosomacruziinfection.InfectImmun2005;73:7356–65. [21] Hoft DF, Eickhoff CS, Giddings OK, Vasconcelos JR, Rodrigues MM.
Trans-sialidase recombinant protein mixed with CpG motif-containing oligodeoxynucleotideinducesprotectivemucosalandsystemicTrypanosoma cruzi immunityinvolving CD8+CTL andB cell-mediated cross-priming.J Immunol2007;179:6889–900.
[22]MachadoAV,CardosoJE,ClaserC,etal.Long-termprotectiveimmunityinduced againstTrypanosomacruziinfectionaftervaccinationwithrecombinant aden-ovirusesencodingamastigotesurfaceprotein-2andtrans-sialidase.HumGene Ther2006;17:898–908.
[23]AraújoAF,deAlencarBC,VasconcelosJR,etal.CD8+-T-cell-dependent con-trolofTrypanosomacruziinfectioninahighlysusceptiblemousestrainafter immunizationwithrecombinantproteinsbasedonamastigotesurfaceprotein 2.InfectImmun2005;73:6017–25.
[24] CazorlaSI,FrankFM,BeckerPD,etal.Redirectionoftheimmuneresponse to the functional catalytic domain of the cystein proteinase cruzipain improvesprotectiveimmunityagainstTrypanosomacruziinfection.JInfectDis 2010;202:136–44.
[25]deAlencarBC,PersechiniPM,HaollaFA,etal.Perforinandgamma inter-feronexpressionarerequiredforCD4+andCD8+T-cell-dependentprotective immunityagainstahumanparasite,Trypanosomacruzi,elicitedby heterolo-gousplasmidDNAprime-recombinantadenovirus5boostvaccination.Infect Immun2009;77:4383–95.
M.R.Dominguezetal./Vaccine30 (2012) 2882–2891 2891
[27]RosenH,SannaG,AlfonsoC.Egress:areceptor-regulatedstepinlymphocyte trafficking.ImmunolRev2003;195:160–77.
[28]CysterJG.Chemokines,sphingosine-1-phosphate,andcellmigrationin sec-ondarylymphoidorgans.AnnuRevImmunol2005;23:127–59.
[29]BrinkmannV,CysterJG,HlaT.FTY720:sphingosine1-phosphate receptor-1inthecontroloflymphocyteegressandendothelialbarrierfunction.AmJ Transplant2004;4:1019–25.
[30] JungS,UnutmazD,WongP,etal.InvivodepletionofCD11c(+)dendriticcells abrogatesprimingofCD8(+)Tcellsbyexogenouscell-associatedantigens. Immunity2002;17:211–20.
[31]DominguezMR,SilveiraEL,deVasconcelosJR,deAlencarBC,MachadoAV, Bruna-RomeroO,GazzinelliRT,RodriguesMM.Subdominant/crypticCD8Tcell epitopescontributetoresistanceagainstexperimentalinfectionwithahuman protozoanparasite.PLoSOne2011;6:e22011.
[32]PadillaAM,SimpsonLJ,TarletonRL.InsufficientTLRactivationcontributesto theslowdevelopmentofCD8+TcellresponsesinTrypanosomacruziinfection.
JImmunol2009;183:1245–52.
[33] ChakravartyS,CockburnIA,KukS,OverstreetMG,SacciJB.ZavalaFCD8+T lymphocytesprotectiveagainstmalarialiverstagesareprimedinskin-draining LN.NatMed2007;13:1035–41.
[34] PinschewerDD,OchsenbeinAF,OdermattB,BrinkmannV,HengartnerH,etal. FTY720immunosuppressionimpairseffectorTcellperipheralhomingwithout affectinginduction,expansion,andmemory.JImmunol2000;164:5761–70. [35]KursarM,JnnerN,PfefferK,BrinkmannV,KaufmannSH,etal.Requirementof
secondarylymphoidtissuesfortheinductionofprimaryandsecondaryTcell responsesagainstListeriamonocytogenes.EurJImmunol2008;38:127–38. [36]LopesCT,dePaulaDMB,CuryPM,Valero-LapchikVB.BuenoVLeishmania
(Leishmania)amazonensisinfectioninmicetreatedwithFTY720.Transplant Proc2010;42:578–81.
[37]RigatoPO,deAlencarBC,deVasconcelosJR,etal.HeterologousplasmidDNA prime-recombinanthumanadenovirus5boostvaccinationgeneratesa sta-blepoolofprotectivelong-livedCD8(+)Teffectormemorycellsspecificfora humanparasite,Trypanosomacruzi.InfectImmun2011;79:2120–30. [38]AciernoPM,SchmitzJE,GorgoneDA,etal.Preservationoffunctional
virus-specificmemoryCD8+Tlymphocytesinvaccinated,simianhuman
immunod-eficiencyvirus-infectedrhesusmonkeys.JImmunol2006;176:5338–45. [39]CasimiroDR,ChenL,FuTM,etal.Comparativeimmunogenicityinrhesus
mon-keysofDNAplasmid,recombinantvacciniavirus,andreplication-defective adenovirusvectorsexpressingahumanimmunodeficiencyvirustype1gag gene.JVirol2003;77:6305–13.
[40]Casimiro DR, WangF, SchleifWA, et al. Attenuationof simian immun-odeficiencyvirusSIVmac239infectionbyprophylacticimmunizationwith
DNA andrecombinantadenoviralvaccinevectors expressingGag. JVirol 2005;79:15547–55.
[41]GeisbertTW,BaileyM,GeisbertJB,etal.Vectorchoicedetermines immuno-genicityandpotencyofgeneticvaccinesagainstAngolaMarburgvirusin nonhumanprimates.JVirol2010;84:10386–94.
[42]GilbertSC,SchneiderJ,HannanCM,etal.EnhancedCD8Tcellimmunogenicity andprotectiveefficacyinamousemalariamodelusingarecombinant ade-noviralvaccineinheterologousprime-boostimmunizationregimes.Vaccine 2002;20:1039–45.
[43] HensleyLE,MulanguS,AsieduC,etal.Demonstrationofcross-protective vac-cineimmunityagainstanemergingpathogenicEbolavirusSpecies.PLoSPathog 2010;6:e1000904.
[44]LetvinNL,MascolaJR,SunY,etal.PreservedCD4+centralmemoryTcellsand
survivalinvaccinatedSIV-challengedmonkeys.Science2006;312:1530–3. [45]Wilson NA, Reed J, Napoe GS, et al. Vaccine-induced cellular immune
responsesreduceplasmaviralconcentrationsafterrepeatedlow-dose chal-lengewithpathogenicsimianimmunodeficiencyvirusSIVmac239.JVirol 2006;80:5875–85.
[46]FreelSA,LamoreauxL,ChattopadhyayPK,etal.Phenotypicandfunctional pro-fileofHIV-inhibitoryCD8Tcellselicitedbynaturalinfectionandheterologous prime/boostvaccination.JVirol2010;84:4998–5006.
[47]JaokoW,KaritaE,KayitenkoreK,etal.Safetyandimmunogenicitystudyof Mul-ticladeHIV-1adenoviralvectorvaccinealoneorasboostfollowingamulticlade HIV-1DNAvaccineinAfrica.PLoSOne2010;5:e12873.
[48]KoupRA,RoedererM,LamoreauxL,FischerJ,NovikL,etal.Priming immu-nization with DNA augmentsimmunogenicityof recombinantadenoviral vectors for bothHIV-1 specific antibodyandT-cell responses.PLoS One 2010;5(2):e9015.
[49]SchooleyRT,SpritzlerJ,WangH,etal.AIDSclinicaltrialsgroup5197:a placebo-controlledtrialofimmunizationofHIV-1-infectedpersonswitha replication-deficientadenovirustype5vaccineexpressingtheHIV-1coreprotein.JInfect Dis2010;202:705–16.
[50]WolfAM,EllerK,ZeiserR,DürrC,GerlachUV,SixtM,etal.The sphingo-sine1-phosphatereceptoragonistFTY720potentlyinhibitsregulatoryTcell proliferationinvitroandinvivo.JImmunol2009;183:3751–60.
[51] SehrawatS,Rouse BT.Anti-inflammatoryeffectsofFTY720 against viral-inducedimmunopathology:roleofdrug-inducedconversion ofTcells to becomeFoxp3+regulators.JImmunol2008;180:7636–47.