Responsabilidade civil na ruptura da sociedade conjugal à luz do princípio da dignidade humana

(1)

(2)

! "

&!' () * +, , -".'& (//0&'& !

#

(3)

! ' '

( '

"

# )% $%%&"

1

* + " " , - . / 0

" " , 1 2/ !

(4)

! " # $

%

& ' ( ) *

+ , & $

$

# &- &

)

&-. &

/ - / /

% - %

(5)

# '

' " 0 '

/ '

' /

23 4 5 " 0

. '

' / ' 6

/

3 " # 7

-6 . ' 4

/ ' 5 ' '

'

8 5 " , ' '

' 6 '

5 ' ' ' '

8 5 / ' 9

/ "

( (2 (3 /0(2!+ "

(6)

: ; / / / / ' ;

/ ; ;" < / ' /

/ / = ; ' ; /

;' / >/ / / ?/ ;

/ " < > ;2 / /

> . ; : >' /

;' ; / ;' ;

/ / / ; / ; / ; "

< > / / . ; : >

; / ; /

/ ' / /

' @ ; / " # '

/ ' > / /

; / /

' ; ' ;

/ ; / ' /

/ / ;"

4!5 6 )3* ;" ! "

(7)

7

8 """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" &

# ₋₋₋₋

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""A%

$"A ,B*: CD* , , , *0#:<E#CD* * < ,<F* , .#!G:<#""""""""A%

$"$ * <0 G <* # < #: # , 0* < ,<F* , .#!G:<#""""""""""""""""AH

$") * <0 G <* # < 0< # , 1 !#0# 0* < ,<F* , .#!G:<# "A&

$"I * < ,<F* # , *0#:< # , , * <0 G <* # < 0< # ,

1 !#0# 0* < ,<F* , .#!G:<#"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""$%

9 """"""""""""""""""""""" $I

)"A # !<F< #CD* # : # 0# #0CJ, , <B# # # F #

# * <, # , *0K #: """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""")A

9,8,8 &:!' 3"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""")$ 9,8,# -( )( ) 3 & 0 3"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""")) 9,8,9 ( ';:&/ ( & ( """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""")I

< 7

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""")&

I"A !*0,F# <E#CD* # ,:#CJ, #.,F<B# """""""""""""""""""""""""""""")L

I"$ *0F # <, # , M !* #: , #* N*0 * F !, """"""""""""""""""IA

I") # OF, <0 ,0<E#FP <* * #:<!,0F* """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""I$

I"I # Q0 <# , < * <F<B* :, #: , , G.< * """"""""""""""""""""""""II

=

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""H%

(8)

6

0*B* P < * <B<: """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""HA

H"$ , *0 #N<:< # , <B<: , # F F,:# * < ,<F* #

, *0#:< # , 0# F # # * <, # , *0K #: """"""""""HH

H") , *0 #N<:< # , <B<: * #0* !* #: 0# F # #

* <, # , *0K #:""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""HR

H"I , *0 #N<:< # , <B<: ,:* #0* , <B# * #

F # # * <, # , *0K #: """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""SH

=,<,8 !2! )! &)! &)()! !/;> /("""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""S& =,<,# !2! )! &)( !: :-: ' :&/; & '?-"( """""""""&I =,<,9 !2! )! @ -( 33&3 .'/&( """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""&S =,<,< !2! )! -3 !' A -( )( )-/(BC ) 3 & 0 3"""""""&& =,<,= !3>!& '3&)! (BC @ - 3"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""&L =,<,D - 3 !2! !3""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""RA

D E """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""RI

(9)

7

8

0 6 '

. '

5 ' " # 7

. 6

5 - ' ' '

2 3 ' ( "

. '

( ' T .

N ALRR' ( 7

" 0

' / '

T "

# ' 3 '

4 ' 2

. " *

' / 5 '

' /

' 8 5 ' / ' ' / ' "

, ' ( (

U V 8 5 /

5 ' ( - " '

3 ' ' '

"

(10)

8

' ' 6 '

"

2 ' 6 6 6 W '

6 - 7

" , '

6 ' 6 ( '

/ (

5 ' ' ' "

0 ' ( 3

. X ' ' / ₋

2 - 5 '

/ '

/ 5 "

B ( 5 - ' '

4 2

8 5 + /( ' '

5 W

( ' ' W ' ( '

/( 8 5 ' 3

4 2 ' 4 5 2 "

/

' ( ' ' 6

( 9 . '

' 5

/ " , - ' '

7 ( 5 '

5 ' 2

(11)

9

, ' 6

' 5 '

/ 5 ( 0 /(

' 6

/ 6

3 ' ' 2 ' / / 6 (

' ' U V'

' ' 2 '

Y-' ' '

' "

#

'

" ' '

' ' 7 ' /(

' '

8 5 / '

'

(12)

D E

* '

5 ' 5

4 3

3 ' / " '

' 4 / '

' 2

4 8 5 / '

4 "

< '

' 6' (' T (

" 6 /

2 5 "

, / ' 3

' / ' 7 '

6 ' 6' ( ( '

" 0 '

/ 3 5 "

. ALRR' AZ'

<<<' / '

2 " 0

' 4 2

/ ' '

' '

(13)

11

0 7 ' 4 2

/ '

/ ' 2 ' 2 '

3 6'

" 0 ( ' 6 '

/ U 'V 5 - U

V' 5 /

U V' N "

! ' ' ' '

5 ( " # /

' $%%$

[ << : < \'

/ '

5 - " *

2 ' 5 ' 5 X ' 6 '

2 5 5 "

0 . 2 ' ]4

2 4 / V'

3 ' 7 ' 2

' 4 ' 4 ' 4

/ '

2 " K ' '

4

8 5 ' ' ' 9 4

/ ' 4 '

3 ' ' 5 "

B 3 . ₋

' / ₋ 2

(14)

12

'

$%%$' ARS L$&'

'

"

F 5

4 / ' HZ' ' ^ _ $Z

. '

4 2

' 5 $$S' _ RZ

- , - 4

'

-9 3 "

, / ' 5

'

5 " F 6

5 ' '

" # ' 7 6' ( U

V ' ' 2

"

' 6 ' 6 2

5 2 3 ' 6 '

< ` ' '

' ' 6

5 "

* ' 6 '

5 '

(15)

13

/ " 0 / '

/ /

-'

" # ' / / 6' 2 ' (

/ + ' ' 2

7 ( - "

a 7

( 2 ' 7

-" *

/ '

0 N / U V' 5 '

'

' ( '

/ "

0 2

/ 2

' 6 " #

3

-' ' ' "

5 ' 6 7 '

( ' 3 " 0

' 7 ' ' 6

6 U V" ' / '

( ' U ' /( '

7 ( V"

0 ' '

(16)

14

5 4 2 / '

4 4 7 ' / / 3 '

Y 7 ( '

+ "

'

/ ' 5 ₋ '

− " 0 /(

2 ' 6 1 ' ' '

- / '

(17)

15

F

# <0.< ,:< # ," +

b/ +?? / " " ?^ H%?HHL$H$"/ c" # + AL "

$%%&+

# <# Kd0<* ' ; " 2

+ + b/ +??/ "/ " ?$%AA?A))Hc" #

+ " $%%&"

#!# #0F,' # <" 2 " S" "

" " N 1 2 + ;' $%%H"

# *00,' " )

+ 2 9 "

K + ' $%%A"

N,# B*< ' " 3 % " K + 0 . '

$%%%"

N,:: <*' # N " 2 '

* N # + 1 ' ALR)"

N,B<:Oe #' " . . ( 4 5

A%" " " K + . # ' ALH)" " <<"

N<FF# ' # " 3 " S" "

K + . ( ' $%%)"

fffff 2 &- )" " +

F ' ALLR"

N*NN<*' 0 " " K + ' ALL$"

Ng `,0.g ' , h W #,!#00' " i N

! / >Y " < + Ng `,0.g ,' ," hW #,!#00' " [ \

6 6 78 + ` ' ALR&' "

$L&"

N #0 *' N " ' ' * +

!6 ' $%%S"

N # <:' [ALRR\" T .

N " N ' .+ . ' ALRR"

fffffff' : AA")I%?%S

-6 " U : ! / V"

fffffff' : AA")I%?%S' II" # A$L : Z

$"RIR' & 2 ALI% [ \"

ffffffff' 5 , " , &%?$%%)' $R

$%%)" - _ )Z $$S

. N ALRR" 6 "

ffffff' N " )j " '

(18)

16

fffffff' F K " +

b/ +??>>>" 5" " ? / ? 7 "/ c" # + A%

$%%&"

ffffff' F K " " Z $)"H&H .' I F '

5 %L"%S"ALL&' K A%"%L"ALL&" +

b/ +??>>>" 5" " ? / ? 7 "/ c" # + A%

$%%&"

N # 0, ' ! " * .

+ " < + h,:F, ' N

W !# #:,0*' 1 " ' '

* # + : # ' $%%I"

#1#:<' K 6 . " 4 - $ "

" " " + K 2 * ' $%%%"

#1#:<' k " ' &- " R" " + F' ALLH"

fffff" ' $" "' )j " + F '

ALLL"

#0*F<:1*' K 6 K " ' . S" " "

+ # ' ALL)"

# B#:1* 0,F*' < ( "

" < + 9 ' . " + # '

$%%%"

#B#:<, < .<:1*' 6 " S" " "

" + ! / ' $%%S"

1#B, ' 6 . B " # (

. " < + h,:F, ' N W

!# #:,0*' 1 ' ' * "

# + : # ' $%%I"

fffff" 2 . < + .# <# ' / /

[ "\ 9 ' * "

K + : K ' $%%I"

fffff" ' ( " 2

: ' # + ' I&' " $S&' 5 "$%%%"

*:#0<' " ₋ 2 5 0

" < + .# <# ' / / [ "\" 9

' K + : K ' $%%I"

* F#' K / ! " * + , 6

" 2 * 4*2,;' "$%' " $%%A"

* F#' K / ! " * 4

2 2 9 ' ' L%'

"&RL' " $A I&' 5 " $%%A"

fffff" &- ' " +

F ' $%%$"

* :#0 , ' . " " K + , ' $%%)"

< <0*' 0 , ( N " "

(19)

17

- " *0 , * N # <:,< * , < ,<F* , .#!G:<#' <<' $%%%'

" N 1 2 + ;' $%%%"

#B< ' # ! ! " ) "

F / F

3 . "

' # ' ALLL"

<# ' K 6 # " ' " A%" " K +

. ' ALL&"

<# ' ! N " " < + ' *

. . I" " " " N 1 2 + ;' $%%H"

fffff" * " < < h,:F, ' N W !# #:,0*'

1 [ "\ ' ' *

# + : # ' $%%I"

fffff" * l 5 =5'* 6' " AH' $' 5 "?5 "

$%%$W 5 1 > ' # ' %& 5 "$%%$' "AA"

fffff" # " < + .# <# ' / / [ "\"

9 ' K + :

K ' $%%I"

<# ' ; # " . "

< + h,:F, ' N " ' '

* # + : # ' $%%I"

????? . " '@

' A < ; &# : " $' " )L I)" " $%%H"

+ b/ +?? 5 " 5" " ? ?/ ?$%AA?A))Hc

# + AI $%%&"

<0<E' ! 1 " ' . ₋ " &" "

+ ' $%%I"

# F, :*0' : " - B C D K +

, ' $%%S"

.# 1<0< 0,F*' , - " # < +

h*:. #0 < [ "\ 3 . . .

&-# + : # ' $%%)"

.#!< :<# < F<#0# *!#" +

b/ +?>>>" " " ? ? " # + A% $%%&"

.# <# ' / / " 4 [ .

/ + 5

7 4 2 \"

< + .# <# ' / / [ "\" 9 '

" K + <N .#!' :T KT ' $%%I"

., ,< #' # 1 W ,#:,' ! " 3 . . <

5 " + N @ ' $%%)"

.<0 , ' KT 6 " + #

/ 2 " < + # :,F' <

h [* "\" &- / +

(20)

18

. #0 <* <' " * 2 < = 4

" )" " F + " / ' ALLH"

. ,<F# ' K 2" &- $ ' " I" " " "

+ ! / ' $%%I"

. , ' 9 " $" " K + < ' ALLH"

*0C#:B, ' " 2 L" " "

+ ' $%%S"

g,0<0 ' 9 " ( " / 2

" < + , ,< #' / [ "\" # ' 6

" *0 , * N # <:,< * , < ,<F*

, .#!G:<#' I" " N 1 2 + ;' $%%I"

`#0F' < " .

3 + , ' ALLH"

:,<F,' , * " 9 ' * " *

" + K (" ALLA" " <"

fffff 9 ' * " + " F ' ALLI"

fffff" + " < + :,<F,' ,

* [ "\" , " K +

. ' $%%$"

:mN*' : 2 0 " 2 " 2

= &- E ' " AIA' 5 "? " ALLL' "LL"

fffff" " < + <# ' ! N W , ,< #'

/ [ "\" ' * + . . " N

1 2 + <N .#!' $%%)"

fffff" + b/ +??5 $" " " ? ? 7 c #

+ $R " $%%&"

!# #:,0*' " # " 2

5 ' * ' # ' "AA' $%%A"

fffff" ' * # + : # '

$%%I"

fffff" " 2 5 ' *

# + ' <N .#!' A' "$' "S% SH' 5 "? "? "

ALLL"

!,::*' ( # " /

" < + # :,F' < h [ "\< 3 .

. . &- $" " # + : # ' $%%S"

!,0 , ' . " K +

N # / " + ' ALLS"

!< #0 #' " 9 ' " ' +

N @ ' $%%A" B " B<<"

!* #, ' ! N " 3 < +

, ,< #' / [ "\" # ' 6

" *0 , * N # <:,< * , < ,<F* , .#!G:<#' I"

" N 1 2 + ;' $%%I"

fffff" '

(21)

19

fffff" " 2 '

* B<<' " )A' " " $%%H"

0, !#00' " F; hY " # / /

, >n 2 ! / >Y 2 " < + 8 2

2 / / ' N " RI' ALLR' " AH) ASS"

*:<B,< #' , W 1< *0#`#' ! . 0 "

" < + <# ' ! N W , ,< #' /

[ "\ ' * . . N 1 2 +

<N .#!' $%%)"

*:F #!# <' B " 3 "

K + . ' $%%H"

# * <' # " 2

" + , '

$%%&"

, ,< #' !( " 2 K +

. ' $%%A"

, ,< #' / " ' l < +

/ . " [ "\ 9 ' *

K + : K ' $%%I"

fffff" ' * " N 1 2 +

;' $%%)"

fffff" * 6 6 5 " 5 =5'* 6' " AH' $'

5 "?5 " $%%$' "&" , ,< #' 6 /@ >" ( '

* # + : # ' $%%I"

fffff" . + 2 3

2 ' # ^^B<<' " RH' " )H%' F <<"

<*B, #0' . ( W * K "' 8 " '

/ " N 1 2 + ;' $%%I"

* F*' !( ! " / < +

#1#:<' k " 2 < 5 - "

+ ' ALRI"

,N,:#F*' # W #0F=#0#' " . ₋ (

# + ' ALLA"

,< ' ; " 3 /

&-K + . ' $%%$"

<EE# *' # " ' * " : " A%"I%S' A%"%A"$%%$"

)" " K + . ' $%%H"

fffff" " < + , ,< #' / [ \"

' * A + ' 5 - '

" N 1 2 + ;' ALL&"

fffff" 2 + : o A%"I%S' A%?%A?$%%$" $" "

K + . ' $%%S"

,:' N " 3 " )" " +

(22)

20

#0F* ' : 2 . N " 5 " < +

h*:. #0 ' < [ "\ 3 . . .

&-# + : # ' $%%)"

#0F* ' N 2 F " ' )

F " K + . ( '

ALL%"

#0F* ' N 2 F " 6 5 " < +

, ,< #' / [ "\"

. . " *0 , * N # <:,< * , < ,<F* , .#!G:<#' I"

" N 1 2 + ;' $%%I"

fffff" 2 &- &- + '

ALLL"

fffff" 3 " +

b/ +??>>>" " " ?c # + $R " $%%&"

D* N, 0# * * #! *" # " IA)"%RR I?A %%'

N ' $j 9 ' + N

` X $I"A%"%S X B" " X B " A)ALL\" +

/ +??>>>" 5" " " ?5 G, # + $R " $%%&"

# :,F' < h " ! ' U V ,

" .' : ' " &$' " $' " $%%)"

fffff" $ &" " " " "

# + : # ' $%%&"

fffff" '

. &- * GHII" I" " " " # + :

# ' $%%S"

#B#F<, ' 6 9 ' * & + '

' ' 6 " $" " + : " 6 6

K ' ALHA"

1i:F, ' h " # . " .#N < '

6 # [, "\ 5,5 * " F " L" " # '

$%%$"

,B, *' 6 " 3 % " + ' ALLS"

<:B#' , " # / /

+ " < <

* F# K / ! [ "\ &- <

7 ' 2

" + F' $%%$"

<:B#' ! .( # " ' '

* " # + 6 . ' $%%S"

E#0<#h `<' , " ' " $" "

" " " + " F ' $%%H"

F,<^,< #' # N / " 4

/ 25'*' <N .#!' " )$' B<<' "? " $%%H"

F, , <0*' " 9 ' . " )" " " "

(23)

21

F1,* * * Kd0<* ' 1 " ' " , " " " +

K 2 * ' $%%%"

F <N 0#: , K F<C# * <* #0 , * :" # Z

&%%ARSI))%I' 6 9 ' FK '

! N ' 5 %L?%H?$%%&" +

b/ +??>>>" 5" " " ? f / ?5 $?" # + )% $%%&"

ffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff#

" Z &%%AI%I&)A%' Rj 9 F K

" + K 6 # F ' 5

%L?%)?$%%S" + b

/ +??>>>" 5" " " ? f / ?5 $?" # + A% $%%&"

fffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff"#

" &%%%HR)ILAS" &j 9 " K %$ $%%)"

" K 6 F 7 ' 5

" + b/ +??>>>" 5" " " ? f / ?5 $?"

# + A% $%%&"

fffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff"#

" &%%ASSA%SHA" &j 9 " FK 5 AA

$%%&" ! N " +

b/ +??>>>" 5" " " ? f / ?5 $?" # + )% $%%&"

ffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff" #

" " HLL"$H&")I$' H 9 "

# N @ ' " & A% ALLL' !2&3 ( ) & !& ) '3-:&) A

9%G99#,

ffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff" #

Z &%%ARRAIRL&' Lj 9 ₋ K $H

$%%&' * 6, +

b/ +??>>>" 5" " " ? f / ?5 $?" # + A% $%%&"

fffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff" #

Z HRH%IA&&H' 7 9 ' F K '

+ # . . ' 5 $S?AA?ALRH"

+ b/ +??>>>" 5" " " ? f / ?5 $?" # + A% $%%&"

ffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff" #

Z &%%A&I))SI%' * 9 ' + ( .

. ' K )%?AA?$%%S"

ffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff"#

" Z &%%ARRAIRL&' Lj 9 X K $H

(24)

22

ffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff" #

" Z &%%%IRS&)LS X &j 9 ' " " ! N

' 5 %L?A%?%$" !2&3 ( ) 3 &H-'(&3 FK

$$H?)SI"

fffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff"#

Z &%%A$)IL%HS' * 9 ' F K

' + h ! ! ' K

AH?A$?$%%H" +

b/ +??>>>" 5" " " ? f / ?5 $?" # + A% $%%&"

ffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff"#

Z &%%%SL&I&AA' 5 A&?A$?$%%)' &j 9

F K " +

b/ +??>>>" 5" " " ? f / ?5 $?" # + A% $%%&"

fffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff" #

Z HR)%)%RH)' 9 ' FK " + !

' 5 %&?A$?ALR)" +

b/ +??>>>" 5" " " ? f / ?5 $?" # + A% $%%&"

ffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff"#

Z &%%%LA%$)&&' * 9 ' FK ' + !

# 8 * ' 5 $L?%L?$%%I" +

b/ +??>>>" 5" " " ? f / ?5 $?" # + A% $%%&"

fffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff" #

Z &%%A%IRH)RA' " K

$%%&' &j 9 F K

− + ! N " +

b/ +??>>>" 5" " " ? f / ?5 $?" # + A% $%%&"

fffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff"#

Z &%%%SI%&%I)' 6 9 ' FK ' + K 6

F 7 ' K $%?%R?$%%)" +

b/ +??>>>" 5" " " ? f / ?5 $?" # + A% $%%&"

fffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff",

Z &%%AIRLL)IR' * 9 ' FK ' +

h ! ! ' 5 $&?%I?$%%S" +

(25)

23

ffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff" ,

Z H%%)S%ASL' 9 ' FK '

+ , , ; ! ' 5 %H?%H?ALRL"

+ b/ +??>>>" 5" " " ? f / ?5 $?" # + A% $%%&"

ffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff"

Z &A%%%H&S)S)' F ' F '

+ K K ' K $A?A%?$%%I"

+ b/ +??>>>" 5" " " ? f / ?5 $?" # + A% $%%&"

B<::,:#' K N " + "

< + N# ,F*' B [* "\" K + ' ALL&"

h,N, ' F/ " J * # + A ALLL"

h,:F, ' N ' * < e 3

# + ' $%%%"

fffff" ' ( " 2

: ' # ' " $S&' " )%' 5 " $%%%"

fffff" 2 . " < + /

. " [ "\ 9 ' *