Antonio Saraiva Muniz, José de Deus Viana da Mata e Alberto Yuji Numoto
Departamento de Agronomia, Universidade Estadual de Maringá, Av. Colombo 5790, 87020-900, Maringá, Paraná, Brasil. *Autor para correspondência: E-mail: [email protected]
! " # $% " & ' "
# ( ' " ) & ' " " ' '* % + # '* ,
' - " . % / " " 0 #1 ' " !
" # $% " " " " " '* ' " % +
' $% " 2 3 4 * 5 " , ', " 6
7 8 7 3 9 5: 8 3 5: 8 3 99 5: 897 3 5 " " # $% , ,
" " 3 5 " " '* " "
30 5 " " '* 3 5 ) # " # $%
" " 3 9 4 * 5 % , " # " : '*
# " # $% ) ) # " # $% " #
" 3 9 4 * 5 4 " ) * " " '* & , - ' " 99 4 )
* + ' " ' & " " " # " 99 4 * " )
" # ' " $% " & ' ,'
# $% " ) " " " " '* : % , # " " , $ " " " " '* # " ! " # $% " ; " ' 3 4 * 5 & " ' " " )
" " " # " 3 99 4 * 5 ! " $% " ' 2
#$ % #&% "'" ( " (" ) !" * ! ( + ,
-. " - " . "' 8* #' 4 * " < '' , '
' # " ' , ) <* * * # " #
8* = < ' * " . % 0 < ' ' "
* " * " #1 ' * , , ' - < '' *
'" , ' " 8* " , ' 3 4 * 5
* * * ', , '' < 7 9 : : 99 : : *
& , # " ) ' " * < , #' 4 3 5 ) <
, 30 5 " ) * < , 3 5 > * * " ' *
, ' - < , 9 4 * " * < * < , ' - " #
* " > * * * " , ' - # < ,
9 4 * < '' " 4 ) , * " , 99 4 ) * 8* ' ' " *
' * * , ' - " < * 99 4 * , ) " < # " ' " , " < '' " * ) " '": * * " ,, , '"
<* # " * , ' - * # , * ' 3 4 * 5 <*
* , ' - < ' " '' * < 3 99 4 * 5 /". *
-$% " ' ' "
# "
? , ' # " "
" ' " , " " "
', 1 ' $%
" ,; ' " # ' " " ' ! '
" ' , '
) @ % ' " A ' ' " / "
0 " ' " # '
" " ' ' ;"
" $% +
' " " ! " " '
" " $% " , "
' # " ' '
, ' " " " " $% " " " $%
0 "
" " , ! & " "
& ' " " " ;" " '
, ' " $% " % '*
& ' " " ,; & ; " " " # 'B C
" A ' 3 5 "
" " " " $% " $% " ,
# ' ; ' "
' # $% " ,; C
, $% " " - , ' "
D E 3 5 E - 3 5
, " , $% " # ' - $%
" )
+ " $% " # "
% ' " ' # = $% "
2 ' 0 " # $% "
& " & ' - '
# " : " # ' " " "
2 ' " "
" ' ,' = # $% "
" $% " , " 3A/)
' : A+@8+F>)> ' 5 ' "
" * ' # $% " ) "
' "
' - $% " ;"
0 " " &
' $% .G) ' 9 7
" 2 ' ' " %
% " & ;"
, # " - # ' - $% # "
3H IJD ) ' : F @
. A/K 5 8 ' , " ?
" $% " " # $% " '
" % '*
I , " ' " $% "
'* " " ' " ' # $% " )
' " % " - ' $% .G)
" " $% " 2 "
" '* / "
" " '*
" " ' " , ' - $% & ' )
' " " #
= . ' 3 #5 "
" " " " '* " !
" " & 2 &
' " # '* ' '
" , '* "
C " = #1 " # '* ,
' ? " " # $% "
" " #
, ,' 2 " " $% " #
" ) # " ' " " " "
'* ' " %
+ = , ' - " " "
" = ' " L - " "
. . % / " " 0
F ' H '* " , M 4 "
' 1 ; & ; " % 7
D 3. .' 5N : D 3D +5N : DOO 'ON9
' " : 'ON ' " : . ON9 '
" : ON M ' " : EON ' " :
0N " : .N " : ; "
% 7 D 3. .' 5N9 : D 3D +5N :
DOO 'ON9 M ' " : 'ON ' " :
. ON9 M ' " : ON M ' " :
EON M ' " : 0N " : .N
"
' " ,
" " , ; ' "
" 9 " # $% # "
3 4 * 5 " " 9 4 " )
M 4 " 0 + M 4 " E + , @ 1 '
3 M5 " " " ' ' " , "
9 M ' ' $
" ' *
) " , " " ' $%
" * # " ! # " 3 F * 5 & "
P " ' " " %
' 3 " B " 5:
& " P " '
" 3 " B " 5
) " " % ' "
, ' " " "
' " , M Q.
" $% "
+ '* 3 0 0
*;# " J " " 5 ,
" # " # " 9
" # " " 4 * " ) 3 ',
" 6 5 0 E " " M 4 * "
,B ' 3 4 * 5 "
, " # ;" ' * $ "
" " ' " 9 3 = 95
, " " & ' * ,
" ' $% " " " " "
" $% ' " " " "
' ' " " M ' *
+ " ' $% " )
3 ', " 6 5 '*
8 7 3 9 5: 8 3 5: 8 3 99 5:
897 * " # $% " # $%
" , , " "
3 5 " " '*
" " 30 5 " " '* 3 5 )
# " # $%
% , " # " '* #
" # $% ) ) #
" # $% " # "
3 9 4 * 5 4 " ) * " "
'* & , - ' " 99 4 ) *
+ " ' = ' , " #'
& & $R
' - " M ' " # ;" "
= 9 39 5
" ( ' " )
" " " " '* , " "
" '* $% " )
3 F H+F8 ' 5 " 3/ A@ 0
5 , " " , '* ' " # = "
" - ' '* " ' '
) " " " " " '* ,
' " " '* ? &
' * " ' 3 5 = ' "
" * " '
+ % " " , "
" " " " P
0 ' " ? " ' " "
" " '*
(" " ) '* , ' - "
; 3 5
) " ' " $% "
" " " " '*
& " " # $% " , ,
" " '* " "
% " # " " " '* 3 5
L + ' " #
, ' 3 5 & , '*
" $% " " " " " '*
& " " " # $% " , ' - "
" " , ' " "
# C " " $%
" " '* ) "
" , " 9 4 *
" " " , " MM M 4 * " " " " '*
, ! " ' 3 5
& ' '* " $% " 9 4
* ' J " M M 4 *
J & " " 2 3 4 * 5 ,
' " "
0 ' " " " $% "
" " " " '* ,
'* " " " " ' $%
" ) 3L A5 " $% " % " '*
B , ! " '
' 3 5 ' ' 3 #5 '*
" & ' * M * )
" 4 * #
" "
) " " " $% " "
" # $% " " '* ' - "
" " 3 99 5
" $% " "
3L A5 '* "
' 3 5 ' 3 5 ' '
3 #5 &
" $% " " & " #
9 4 * " ) # " M *
2 ' / F - '
3 5 % , '* " $% "
" " & " # )
4 * " $% " " "
" " " ,
" 4 * $% " & "
"
C " " " " " '*
B " # " 99 4 * " )
9 4 * " ) , '* '
& % , " # ' - " ! '
' ' # ' - $% ' C
, ' # '* & ,
, " # $% " "
4 * % * " ) ' # " "
'* =
" " " " % 3 > ' : C+
' 5 " ' 3 5
" $% " '* " # " M 4 * " )
B 1 " " " , " 4 *
! " " " " '* B
" # " 9 9 4 * " ) 1
' , " 9 4 *
+ ' " " " '*
" , '* "
J ' 3 95 ' " @
J " " ': ' " , &
" ' 3 95 1 " $%
" " '* 3SF M 5 B
' " @ J " " ' , " 9
9 99 4 * " " " "
" " " " '* " ,
# = , $% " & " " "
* : '* ' " "
C @ 3 M5 A ' ' 3 5
' 3 5 " " ) ' - "
6 "
J " " ' ' "
M M 4 ) * '* B $% P
"
0
"
$%
34
*
5
0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000 12000 14000 16000
24-90-30 0-90-30 144-0-0 0-0-0
M S m ilho P ro dm ilho M S a ve ia
a a a
b
a
b
a b
c
a a a
b
T " " ) ' " 34 * 5
0
"
$%
34
*
5
A
0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000
24-90-30 0-90-30 144-0-0 0-0-0
M S m ilho P ro dm ilho M S a ve ia a
a
a b
b
a a a
a
a
b
a
b
T " " ) ' " 34 * 5
7 2 0 " $% " " '* " " " " " '* # " 1 " " # $%
" " "
" " '* " " '* " G 9 3 5 9G 3A5
F " , ? , ? ; ' " P
'* 3.HN P5 P 3.HN9 P5 )
" ' " , ? , ?
; ' " P '* 3.HN P5 P 3.HN P5
" ' 3 5 " # $% "
" , & " " $% " " , ' & " "
" ) ' " , : " $% =
" , " 4 * " "
4 * " ) ' "
' " ' " ' " /
# '* ' - " ' " " %
, " # " " $% " , ,
3 99 9 4 * 5 " J $ '
' 3 5: ' 3 5 C @ 3 M5
$% " ) , ' " "
,' '* ' $%
" " " " '* 38 # ' 5
! $% "
" % B '*
% +" . ' $R " " " " '* $% " ) , '* ,'
3 ' , '* '* # 5 % " '* " " ; '
L '* 3 5 0 3 5 J % 3 5
0 ?
' " ) ) )
. ' $% M
. ' $% 9
8 " 3 4 5 M9 9 9M
8 " 3 4 5 M M M 9
/, 2 " " 3/I)5
M M9 M 9
/, 2 " " , ' - 3/IL5
M 9 M M
3 5, '* ' " ,' :3 5 " '* : 3/I)5 N 4 # " % " - " : /ILN 4 # " 4 , ' - ' "
+ % ' , 2 "
" 3/I)5 )
% " & "
' 38 # ' 5 C , '* %
# , # " , 2 "
, ' - " 3/IL5 !
& )
" 4 " , ' - ' " + 2
% , & & " " "
' " ' , ' - 3 ', "
6 5 & , & " ,
# " " " '
) ,' , ' " ) ,
, " J ' 3 5 '*
' . - ' 3 5 '* # "
" " # & F '
' " ' : " &
, " D * ' 3 5 . '
3 M5 '* B &
" " 4
) '* " ) ' %
, '* " U ' * 4
' 3 5 0 ' " " )
% , " K '' '
3 5 '* B $
' ' " 0
$% " % " '* , ,
!& ' " D * ' 3 5
@* * ' 3 5
! " #
! "! " ##
! " #
+ (" " " ) 3L 5 "
3L A5 % ' " '*
3 ' , '* '* # 5 , & "
" # $% " , ' " ; "
" ' " ' C ,
' , & ' & " # $% " ,
, " " " '*
' " % ! % " # " 3 5
" " " " ) , ' "
" " , $ " & '*
) # " ' ' $% )G
" 7 , " C "
* 3 5 L '' C " )
3 5 ' $% )G & 7 "
( ' " ) %
' ) )+ , % ' " '
'
)
'
"
34
*
5
0 -0 -0 2 4 -9 0 -3 0
14 4 -0 -0 0 -9 0 -3 0 0
50 10 0 150 2 0 0
2 50 N Paérea
N g rão s N t o t al
c c
c
c a
a
a
a a
b b
b
T " " ) 34 * 5
'
"
34
*
5
A
0 -0 -0 2 4 -9 0 -3 0
14 4 -0 -0 0 -9 0 -3 0 0
2 4 6 8 10 12 14
16 N Paérea
N g rão s N t o t al
b c
b c
a b
a a c
c
b
a
T " " 34 * 5
7 2 ( ' " " 2 3 5 = , 3A5 ' '* # " 1 " " # $% " ', " 6 " "
" " " '* " " " F
( ' ? % ,
' " 8 4 P " # # ' " "
+ ) " ' " % " '*
& " , ' - , ' " ; "
" ' 3 5 B=
4 * ' " '*
(" " ) , B= 4
* '* " C '
3 5 & 9 4 *
% 4 * '
+ " ' " %
" '* , B=
4 * 9 4 *
+ ( ' " ' " ) 3 4 * 5
3 4 * 5 '* , "
. '* ' 3 5 D * ' 3 5
(' , " ' " "
: #
& " " ' " " 4 * " )
" " 4 * " ) + ' " ,
" M 4 * 4 * " " "
0 C @ ' 3 5 ( ' " ) %
'* " '* , " 4 * B
" # $% " " " 4 *
" # " 99 4 * " )
" # " $% "
& ' ,' # $% " )
" " " " '*
)% , " " , $ " " "
" '* # " ! " # $% "
3 4 * 5 ; " ' & "
' " " " " " # "
3 99 4 * 5
>8 . : ./@/88 . : 8D+ F :
0 H>) 8+ : A V/@ . / "
, " 2 ' ; , 1%
' " " $ " -" & 9 -9
>8 . : A + . W : ./@/88 . : J+)X FH/
. ) : C @+ . + 0' " # " '
, " 2 '* " $ " -"
& 9 - M
C+ 8 W . : >/F)>.KIE W : >8 .
@ " $% " " # $% " '* @
J " " ' . " " " '
" # " ' # ' " " $ "
-" & 9 - : M 9 9
C+ 8 W . : )8> : .+ 8 W " # $%
" > ,' 2 " $% "
;" ' # $% " 2 " " '* # ' " " $ " -" & 9
-: M M
@L + : L/@) )C/ @ ) : AIK/88> :
@+C@>JI/ @ L : Y / : )C@ C/ W .
1 " ' " ' $% " 2
" ' " " '* #
" 2' # '.
A V/@ . : >/F)>.KIE W : C+ 8 W . :
@8>) )/8+ F : L/@)Y)C/K H +
" ' ' ' ,, " #
'' " * A - '
6 "
A/) W @ : 0Z88E/@ C : L+)8 )/F> @ :
U>/8DZF8/@ @ " ! " # $%
" " " #
" $ " -" & 9 - 9
A+@8+F>)> . J : >FH 0 @ L : @J/)8 J /, " ;" " ' 1 "
# ' " '* " ;2
# 5" 2< = > ! M
A+@8+F>)> . J : >FH 0 @ L : @J/)8 J :
L+@ 8D+L/@ / F " ' $% " 2
, # ( ' " ) ' " '*
" $ " -" & 9 - M M
MM
. >@/ / L : J @AI>+ L W : FF/+)> F @ L :
. A@> . ' , ' # "
" " ' " '* 1 ' " " $ " -" & 9
-M
. @H FD+ F A : A> ).+ : 0>8/FF> @ :
A> ).+ / " " ( ' "
' " '* A
M A & ' !
./@/88 . : A + . W : LF/.D 8 :
0 H>) 8+ 0 : H>/>@ L . A : > /
1 " " # $% " %
G '* ' " " $ "
-" & 9 - M M
./@/88 . : A + . W : C>/E+U W : >8 . : 0 H>) 8+ 0 : H>/>@ L . A : H/)C@I .IF+
/ @ + ) , ' - ' ' ,
'' #' 4 " #
9 9 #
C @+ . + : >8 . /, " "
# " ' , " 2
'* ' " " $ " -" & 9
- 9 M
C @+ . + : F/8 @ F : 0+@) @ F :
.D C+ W ) . C # ' " " " 2 " " " " '* " , " "
" # $% " ' " & 9
2 9
CI/8/ @ @ . : I@ +E 8 : >FH / . :
8@>H/F>) 0 . + : A@+ )+ / W 1 "
" # $% " ' - $% " 2 3) 5 '
'* F ' H '* " $ " -"
& 9 - M
/ A@ 0 / A ' " 0 &
2 -" < " ;2?' -" : 5 "
(" ) " A ;' 7 / # '
L )./FF> F : C+I@ C+ )/8+ C !
" @ -" ' "1 5 5 -2 - -"
0 # 7 / '&GI 0
J> .+ >)> W : >8 . : .D> 0>)+88+ > . :
DIA)/@ W 0 : @[I/ : . C+@/ L
. $% " ' " # " "
'* ' " >> ) 2 ' " '
'* " " " " % " $ " -"
& 9 - 9 9 9
J+ / @ L : >FH J : > F : 0>@/ L @
/, " " " " ' $% " 2
6 " ' " '* # '
" " $ " -" & 9
-J+)X FH/ . ) : ./@/88 . : A + . W
% " ' ' " # '*
' " ,' 2 # 2 '
" $ " -" & 9 - 9
D V 8 I : E+ IJ/ ) /,, , , '
-" ' , . " ' 3A - '5 8 4
" " - A2 M
D/>)@>.D @ : H>88> J . : +@/>@ : L )./FF> F 0 " $% " ' " '*
' ' " # " "
$ " -" & 9 - M
E@/I8K/@ E /,, , , ' '
- M G M 99 9
F @ . A/K U @ : @@IC @ :
. )8 @/FF D : 0 IF/88> H : 8@>H/F>) 0 . + : A/)C +FF> W > # ' - $% " 2 "
" ', " 6 ' " "
# ' " '* ' "
" $ " -" & 9 -M
FIK 0 D . : D/@F>)J H @ : A@ J J W :
)+JI/>@ L>FD+ W . : L @> F : F> .
J @ " 3 * #5
$% % " # $% " #
" 2' # '. 9 9 M
> / : ./@/88 . : A + . W :
>FH/>@ W : 0 H>) 8+ : 0 H>) 8+ 0 1 " " # $% " %
'* ' " " ;2 # 5" 2<
$ "
F H+F8 / : H>88> J . : +F>H/>@
# 34 - " - 2 - 5 7
; ' $R " 0 # 7 0 ,B
@ .D)/@ D " 2 ( ! !"
5 + ' " 7 " 0
@ >W A H : . )8 @/FF D : [I JJ>+ W :
LI@F )> . " '" - 3B" -" -2+ 34 "
"' 5 - -" 4 2 " . 7
> 6 M
@D/>)D/> /@ C : FH @/K W U @ : + +@>+ L>FD+ A C : >FH F : A+@8+FIKK> / .
@ " ' ! ' $% " = , "
', ' " = # ' "
& 9 2 M M
)8> : C+ 8 W . : .+ 8 W
" # $% " 7 > > ,' 2
" $% " ' " #
)8+ : J FH\+ W . . : >@ )C J H :
L/@@/>@ F @ : /F+ H : L+)8 )/88>
/ $ , ' " # $% " '*
# " 2' # '. 9
> . "' ( ( ' H
. 7 >
>FH : >FH 0 @ L : ID@/ / : @J/)8
J : 8@>/C/@ F : @ A+ F "
# " ' , #
" " % " '* % & 9
2 9
>FH : >FH 0 @ L : )J+> F : 0> ) 8 : 8@>/C/@ F : W )C@/V C A : /)C@>J+ 0 . 0 " " " " '* " %
" $% " '* % " ;2
# 5" 2< $ " 9
>FH : >FH 0 @ L : >)/88+ 8 : 8@>/C/@
F : W )C@/V C A : /)C@>J+ 0 . C *
6 6 " '* " % !
" # " ' G " $% "
% & 9 2 M M #
>FH .@IK . : 0/@/>@ L @ : A>.IC+ W :
FAI[I/@[I/ U : )8+ W @ :
.D C+ . J ) $% " '* "
' " B " ,
" ' # " 2' # '.
K+8 @/FF> F : . @C+ + / J : 0>..>)>) W F :
I@[I> J : A+CC/V @ : 8+@@/ / : FH/
A W @ . ' # $% " " " " ' , ' ' 0 C
' $% " (" " 2 '*
" ;2 # 5" 2< $ "
H IJD ) W C : D+V8 J C : U+FFI J
. ' # ' ' "
'' 7 ' ' "
'" & ''2 ( " "
-# . 9
U+F .D>.E C : . @F/ + @ : 0/8@V 8 :
W C+ E> + " # $% " ' "
'* ' " $%
' ' ' ] ' ^ " $ " -"
& 9 - 9M 9M
! " !
F , 7 8* ' " # " " * , * . . # F <* * " " #