Method
Article
Two
CRISPR/Cas9-mediated
methods
for
targeting
complex
insertions,
deletions,
or
replacements
in
mouse
Kyriel
M.
Pineault
a,b,
Ana
Novoa
b,
Anastasiia
Lozovska
b,
Deneen
M.
Wellik
a,1,
Moises
Mallo
b,*
,1a
DepartmentofCellandRegenerativeBiology,UniversityofWisconsin-Madison,USA
bInstitutoGulbenkiandeCiência,Portugal
ABSTRACT
Geneticallymodifiedmodelorganismsarevaluabletoolsforprobinggenefunction,dissectingcomplexsignaling
networks,studying human disease,and more.CRISPR/Cas9 technologyhas significantlydemocratizedand
reducedthetimeandcostofgeneratinggeneticallymodifiedmodelstothepointthatsmallgeneeditsarenow
routinely and efficiently generated in as little as two months. However, generation of larger and more
sophisticatedgene-modificationscontinuestobeinefficient.AlternativewaystoprovidethereplacementDNA
sequence,methodofCas9delivery,andtetheringthetemplatesequencetoCas9ortheguideRNA(gRNA)haveall
beentestedinanefforttomaximizehomology-directedrepairforprecisemodificationofthegenome.We
presenttwoCRISPR/Cas9methodsthathavebeenusedtosuccessfullygeneratelargeandcomplexgene-editsin
mouse.Inthefirstmethod,theCas9enzymeisusedinconjunctionwithtwosgRNAsandalongsingle-stranded
DNA(lssDNA)templatepreparedbyanalternativeprotocol.Thesecondmethodutilizesatetheringapproachto
coupleabiotinylated,double-strandedDNA(dsDNA)templatetoaCas9-streptavidinfusionprotein.
Alternativemethodforgeneratinglong,single-strandedDNAtemplatesforCRISPR/Cas9editing.
DemonstrationthatusingtwosgRNAswithCas9-streptavidin/biotinylated-dsDNAisfeasibleforlargeDNA
modifications.
©2019TheAuthors.PublishedbyElsevierB.V.ThisisanopenaccessarticleundertheCCBY-NC-NDlicense
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
ARTICLE INFO
Methodname:CRISPR/Cas9-mediatedlargegeneticmodificationsinmouse
Keywords:CRISPR/Cas9,Gene-editing,Mouse,Zygote,Microinjection,ssDNA,Streptavidin/biotin
Articlehistory:Received23July2019;Accepted5September2019;Availableonline10September2019
*Correspondingauthor.
E-mailaddresses:kpineault@wisc.edu(K.M. Pineault),anovoa@igc.gulbenkian.pt(A.Novoa),alozovska@igc.gulbenkian.pt
(A.Lozovska),wellik@wisc.edu(D.M. Wellik),mallo@igc.gulbenkian.pt(M.Mallo).
1
Co-seniorauthors.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.mex.2019.09.003
2215-0161/©2019TheAuthors.PublishedbyElsevierB.V.ThisisanopenaccessarticleundertheCCBY-NC-NDlicense(http:// creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
ContentslistsavailableatScienceDirect
MethodsX
Methoddetails Animaluse
AllanimalexperimentswereperformedfollowingPortuguese(Portaria1005/95)andEuropean (Directive2010/63/EU)legislationsregardinghousing,husbandry,andwelfare.Thisprojectreceived reviewandapprovalbytheEthicscommitteeofInstitutoGulbenkiandeCiênciaandbythePortuguese NationalEntity,DirecçãoGeraldeAlimentaçãoVeterinária(licensereference:014308).
Commonmaterialsforallprocedures DNase/RNase-freewater
RNase-freeEppendorftubes RNase-freefilteredpipettetips Thermocyclersystem
Heatblockorwaterbath Agarose
1xTAEbuffer
Gelelectrophoresissetup(chamberandpowersupply) Gelloadingdye
DNAladder(100bpor1kbladder)
DNAstain(ethidiumbromideoralternative) Gelimagingsystem[ultraviolet(UV)imaging] Temperaturecontrolledcentrifuge
NanoDropspectrophotometerorsimilarequipment
NOTE1:Commonmaterialsandequipmentcanbeusedfromanyreliablecompany. NOTE2:AllprotocolsshouldbeperformedunderDNase/RNase-freeconditions. A.invitrotranscriptionofCas9orCas9-streptavidinmRNA
Materials.
Cas9orCas9-streptavidinplasmid(thisprotocolisintendedforplasmidscontainingaT7promoter) Cas9:pT7-Cas9(availablecommerciallyfromOriGeneCat.No.GE100014)
Cas9-streptavidin:PCS2+Cas9-mSA(availablefromAddgenePlasmidNo.103882)
NOTE: TheSP6 promoterin thisplasmidwas replaced witha T7 promoterusing standard cloningtechniques.
NOTE:ProtocolcanbeadaptedtouseaplasmidcontaininganSP6promoter. RestrictionenzymeappropriatetolinearizeCas9plasmid(seenote1c) Phenol/Chloroform
100%ethanol
mMessagemMachineT7Ultrakit(ThermoFisherCat.No.AM1345)
NOTE:UseSP6invitrotranscriptionkitifusingaplasmidcontaininganSP6promoter. RNeasyMiniKit(QiagenCat.No.74104)
Dryice Protocol
RestrictiondigestandcleaningofCas9orCas9-streptavidinplasmid.
1 PerformarestrictiondigestoftheCas9orCas9-streptavidinplasmid.Incubatereactionovernight atappropriatetemperatureforrestrictionenzyme.
a Basicreactionconditions:Plasmid10
m
g10xEnzymeBuffer5m
lRestrictionEnzyme2m
lWaterto 50m
lbNOTE:Obtainalargeamountofplasmidthroughstandardmidi-prepormaxi-prepprocedures. cNOTE:RestrictionenzymeshouldlinearizetheplasmidimmediatelyaftertheCas9or Cas9-streptavidinsequencewithintheplasmid.Thisallowsfor“runoff”transcription.Itispossibleto useanenzymethatcutsmultipletimeswithintheplasmidbackboneaslongasitgeneratesa linearpieceofplasmidcontainingtheT7primingsiteandtheentireCas9orCas9-streptavidin sequence.
2 Runasmallamount(200ng)ofthecleanedrestrictiondigestona0.8%agarosegeltoconfirm plasmidwasproperlylinearized.
3 Add50
m
lofDNase/RNase-freewatertobringthereactionto100m
l.4 Add100
m
lofphenol/chloroformandshakevigorouslyuntilreactionbecomesopaque. 5 Spinsolutionatmaximumspeedfor5minatroomtemperature.6 Carefullyremovetheupper,aqueouslayerofthereactionandmovetoanewtube. dNOTE:Itisveryimportanttoavoidcontaminationwiththelowerlayer.
7 Add1/10thvolume(10
m
l)of3MNaOAc,pH5.3,andmixwell. 8 Add2.5volumes(250m
l)oficecold100%ethanolandmixwell. 9 Chillondryicefor>30minorat-20CovernighttoprecipitateDNA. 10Spinreactionatmaximumspeedfor30minat4C.11 CarefullyremovesupernatanttakingcarenottodisturbtheDNApellet. 12WashDNAbyadding500
m
lofice-cold70%ethanol.13Spinatmaximumspeedfor10minat4C.
14CarefullyremoveallofthesupernatanttakingcarenottodisturbtheDNApellet.
15Air dry DNA pellet at room temperature for 5–10minutes or until all traces of liquid have evaporated.
16ResuspendDNAinasmallvolume(15
m
l)ofDNase/RNase-freewaterandmeasureconcentration onaNanoDroporsimilar.eNOTE:ThedesiredDNAconcentrationisbetween1–2
m
g/m
ltohaveenoughDNAtemplatefor thesubsequenttranscriptionreaction.Cas9 or Cas9-streptavidin mRNA synthesis: mMESSAGE mMACHINE T7 Ultra Kit. Follow the manufacturer’sprotocolwiththefollowingnotes:
1 Incubatethetranscriptionreactionfor2hat37C.
2 Increaseto2
m
lTURBODNase,mixwell,andincubatefor15minat37C. aPropermixingwillensurethatalltracesofDNAtemplateareremoved. 3 Save2m
lofthesolution(Sample1)beforeaddingtheE-PAPreagent. 4 IncubatewiththePoly(A)tailingreagentsfor30minat37C.5 Save2
m
lofthesolution(Sample2)aftercompletingthePoly(A)tailingprocedure. a Dilutebothreservedsampleswith9m
lofwaterandaddRNase-freegelloadingdye. bRunsamplesona0.8%agarosegeltodetermineifPoly(A)tailingwassuccessful(Fig.1).CleanCas9orCas9-streptavidinmRNA:RNeasyMiniKit. Followthemanufacturer’sprotocolwiththe followingnotes:
1Elutein40
m
lofRNase-freewaterinsteadofprovidedelutionbuffer. 2MeasuretheconcentrationoftheelutedRNAonaNanoDropofsimilar.3Run200–500ngofmRNAona0.8%agarosegel(Sample3)toconfirmthatithasnotdegraded duringthecleaningprocedure(Fig.1).
4StoremRNAat-80C.
a NOTE: Aliquotintosmallervolumesand avoid freeze-thawcycles which might degradethe product.RunasmallamountofmRNAonagelpriortoeveryexperimenttoinsureproducthasnot degraded.
B.invitrotranscriptionofsgRNA(skipthisprocedureifpurchasingcommerciallysynthesizedsgRNA) RefertomethodvalidationforfurtherinformationonchoosingsgRNA(s)
Materials
sgRNAplasmid(protocolisintendedforplasmidscontainingaT7promoterduetorestrictionsof MEGAshortscriptT7kit).
sgRNA plasmids can be made in-house (e.g. Using pT7-sgRNA commercially available from OriGeneCat.No.GE100025)orpurchasedfromnumerousvendors.
LinearT7-sgRNAtemplate canalsobegenerated viaPCR. Proceedimmediatelywithin vitro transcriptionifusingthismethod.
RestrictionenzymeappropriatetolinearizesgRNAplasmid(seenote1c). Phenol/Chloroform.
3MNaOAcpH5.3. 100%ethanol
Fig.1.SynthesisofCas9orCas9-streptavidinmRNA.ImagesofGelSafestained0.8%agarosegelsofsamples1–3ofpreparation ofCas9-streptavidinmRNA(sectionA).Leftgelshowsexpectedsizeincreasepre-andpost-Poly(A)tailing(samples1and2)and asinglenon-degradedCas9-streptavidinmRNAproductaftercleaning(sample3).RightgelshowsexampleofappropriatePoly (A)tailing(samples1and2)butdegradationoftheCas9mRNAproductfollowingcleaning(sample3).Ladder:1kbladder,1kb and3kbbandsmarked.
MEGAshortscriptT7Kit(ThermoFisherCat.No.AM1354)
MEGAcleartranscriptionclean-upkit(ThermoFisherCat.No.AM1908) Dryice
Protocol
RestrictiondigestandcleaningofsgRNAplasmid.
1 Perform a standard restriction digest of the sgRNA plasmid. Incubate reaction overnight at appropriatetemperaturefortherestrictionenzyme.
a Basicreactionconditions:Plasmid25
m
g10xEnzymeBuffer5m
lRestrictionEnzyme2-3m
lWaterto 50m
lbNOTE:Obtainalargeamountofplasmidthroughstandardmidi-prepormaxi-prepprocedures. cNOTE:RestrictionenzymeshouldlinearizetheplasmidimmediatelyafterthesgRNAscaffold withintheplasmid.Thisallowsfor“runoff”transcription.Itispossibletouseanenzymethat cutsmultipletimeswithintheplasmidbackboneaslongasitgeneratesalinearpieceofplasmid containingtheT7primingsiteandtheentiresgRNAscaffold.
2 Runasmallamount(200ng)ofthecleanedrestrictiondigestona0.8%agarosegeltoconfirm plasmidwasproperlylinearized.
3 Add50
m
lofDNase/RNase-freewatertobringthereactionto100m
l.4 Add100
m
lofphenol/chloroformandshakevigorouslyuntilreactionbecomesopaque. 5 Spinsolutionatmaximumspeedfor5minatroomtemperature.6 Carefullyremovetheupper,aqueouslayerofthereactionandmovetoanewtube. aNOTE:itisveryimportanttoavoidcontaminationwiththelowerlayer.
7 Add1/10thvolume(10
m
l)of3MNaOAcpH5.3andmixwell. 8 Add2.5volumes(250m
l)oficecold100%ethanolandmixwell. 9 Chillondryicefor>30minorat-20CovernighttoprecipitateDNA. 10Spinreactionatmaximumspeedfor30minat4C.11 CarefullyremovesupernatanttakingcarenottodisturbtheDNApellet. 12WashDNAbyadding500
m
lofice-cold70%ethanol.13Spinatmaximumspeedfor10minat4C.
14CarefullyremoveallofthesupernatanttakingcarenottodisturbtheDNApellet.
15Air dry DNA pellet at room temperature for 5–10minutes or until all traces of liquid have evaporated.
16Resuspend DNA in a small volume (15
m
l) of DNase/RNase-free water and measure the concentrationonaNanoDroporsimilar.aNOTE:ThedesiredDNAconcentrationisbetween1–2
m
g/m
ltohaveenoughtemplateDNAfor thesubsequenttranscriptionreaction.InvitrotranscriptionofsgRNA:MEGAshortscriptT7kit. Followthemanufacturer’sprotocolwiththe followingnotes
1 Incubatethetranscriptionreactionat37Cfor4h.
aIfdrops accumulatein thetube’slid,collectthereactioncontentswithashortspinatroom temperature(advisable,every1.5h).
2 Increaseto2
m
lTURBODNase,mixwell,andincubatefor30minat37C. aPropermixingwillensurethatalltracesofDNAtemplateareremoved.CleaningsgRNAtranscript:MEGAcleartranscriptionclean-upkit. Followthemanufacturer’sprotocol withthefollowingnotes
1MakesureallcentrifugationstepsdonotexceedanRCFof15,000xg.Thiswillpreventdamagetothe spincolumns.
2UseRNAelutionoption1.Elutein50
m
lofDNase/RNase-freewaterandnottheprovidedelution buffer.Incubateat70Cinaheatblockfor10min.3Donotrepeattheelutionprocedureassuggestedbythemanufacturer.Inourhandsthisdoesnot increasetheRNAyieldssignificantlyandreducesfinalsgRNAconcentration.
4Followingcleaning,measuretheRNAconcentrationonNanoDroporsimilar.
5Run500ngona2%agarosegeltoconfirmproductionofasinglesgRNAproduct(Fig.2). a NOTE:InsomecasestheRNAmightgivetwoapparentproducts,onewiththeexpectedsizeand
anotherabitbigger.ThispatternresultsfromtheRNAacquiringdifferentconformationsthatrun differentlyinthegel.
6StoresgRNAat-80C
a NOTE:Aliquotintosmallervolumesandavoidfreeze-thawcycleswhichmightdegradetheproduct. RunasmallamountofsgRNAonagelpriortoeveryexperimenttoinsureproducthasnotdegraded.
C.SynthesisofsinglestrandedDNA(ssDNA)template Materials.
Targetingplasmidtemplate
Refertomethodvalidationforfurtherinformationondesignoftargetingplasmidtemplate. Primersetfortemplategeneration(forwardandreverse)
Oneprimermustcontainabiotinmodificationonthe50end
HighFidelityTaqPolymerasekitwithproofreadingactivity(e.g.HotStarHiFidelityPolymerasekit, QiagenCat.No.202602)
PCRpurificationsystem(e.g.QIAquickPCRpurificationkit,QiagenCat.No.28104) DynabeadsMyOneStreptavidinC1beads(ThermoFisherCat.No.65001)
Magnetictuberack 3MNaOAc,pH5.3 1MTrisHCl,pH7.5 100%ethanol BufferA 10mMTrisHClpH7.5 30mMNaCl 1mMEDTA BufferB
Fig.2. SynthesisofsgRNA.ImageofGelSafestained2%agarosegeloffinalsgRNAproduct(sectionB).Singlebandisobserved showingnosignsofdegradationfollowingprocedure.Ladder:1kbladder,1kband3kbbandsmarked.
0.15 1mMEDTA Dryice
Tris-EDTA(TE)buffer 10mMTrisHCl 1mMEDTA Protocol
1 PCRprimersshouldbedesignedtoamplifydesiredgene-editedsequenceandcontain100-200bp offlankinghomologyupstreamanddownstreamtothesiteofeditingwithinthegenome. a NOTE:OnlyonePCRprimershouldcontainabiotinmodificationonthe50end.
bNOTE:Ithasnotbeenempiricallytestedwhetherthechoiceofprimercontainingthebiotin modification(forwardorreverse)affectstheefficiencyofgene-editing.
2 Setup5–10PCRreactionstoamplifytemplatesequencefromthetargetingplasmidtemplate. a NOTE: Use of a proof-readingenzyme is essential toreduce theprobability of introducing
mutations.
bNOTE:Minimizetheprimerconcentrationasmuchaspossibletoallowformoreefficientoligo removalduringstep3.
cNOTE:CheckPCRreactionbyrunningasmallamount(2–5
m
lofthereaction)onanagarosegel toconfirmreactiongeneratessinglePCRproduct.Ifreactioncannotbeoptimizedtoeliminate un-desiredbands,proceedwithagelPCRpurificationmethodtoobtaindesiredband. 3 PoolPCRreactionsandcleanusingacolumn-basedPCRpurificationsystemtoremovetheunusedbiotinylatedprimerthatwillinterferewiththereactioninstep4.Thetypicalelutionvolumeis 50
m
l.EluteinDNase/RNase-freewaterinsteadofprovidedelutionbuffer.a Reserve2
m
lofcleanedproducttoserveasaloadingcontrol(Sample1).bCalculatethetotalyieldofpurifiedDNA.Thiswillbenecessarytocalculatethevolumeofbeads necessaryinstep4.
4 Wash Dynabeads MyOne Streptavidin C1 beads twice with 500
m
l of Buffer A. Use 1.5mL Eppendorfftubeswithamagneticracktoprecipitatebeads.aFollow manufacturer’s recommendations to determine volume of beads required to bind biotinylatedDNA.
5 DilutepurifiedPCRproductin300
m
lofBufferAandincubatewithstreptavidinbeadsatroom temperaturefor1hwithrotation.aNOTE:ForPCRproductsgreaterthan1kb,increasetheincubationtimetoseveralhoursorto overnighttoincreaseefficiencyofbiotin/streptavidinbinding.
6 Collectbeadsusingamagneticrackandsavethesupernatant(Sample2).Thiswillbeusedto estimatetheefficiencyofbiotin/streptavidinbinding.
7 Washbeads2x500
m
lwithBufferAatroomtemperature.8 DenaturetheDNAtoliberatetheun-biotinylatedDNAstrand with300
m
lofBufferBatroom temperaturefor25minwithrotation.aNOTE: ForPCRproductsgreaterthan 1kb,increaseelutiontime toseveralhoursforhigher efficiency.
9 Collectthebeadsusingamagneticrack.Carefullyrecoverthesupernatantensuringnobeadsare carriedover(Sample3).
a NOTE:DoNOTusenon-stickyEppendorftubesasthiswillresultinlosingthessDNAinthenext steps.
bNeutralizereactionwith30
m
lof1MTrisHCl,pH7.5. 10PrecipitateDNAfromSample2andSample3.a Add30
m
lof3MNaOAc,pH5.3and900m
lof100%ethanolandmixthoroughly. bPlacetubesondryiceforatleast30min.11 RecoverprecipitatedDNAsbycentrifugationatmaximumspeedfor30minat4C.
aRemovesupernatantandallowDNApellettoair-dryfor5–10minoruntilanyremainingliquid hasevaporated.
b ResuspendSample2in5
m
lofTEbufferorwater.cResuspendSample3(ssDNA)inasmallvolume(11–15
m
l)ofRNase-freewater.d NOTE:PrecipitatedssDNAfrequentlyadherestothetubewallalongtheentireverticallength insteadofformingapellet.Toresuspend,usethepipette-tiptomovethedropletofwateralong thetube.Liquidwillformdropletsalongthetube.Recovertheliquidwithashortcentrifugation andrepeattheprocessuntildropletsnolongeradheretothetubewall,whichmeansthatthe DNAisdissolved.Recoverthewholevolumewithashortspin.
12MeasuretheconcentrationofSample2andSample3onaNanoDroporsimilar. 13RunSamples1–3ona1%agarosegel(Fig.3).
a Run1–2
m
lofSample3(ssDNA).b Trytousecomparableamountsofallsamplestoimprovecomparison.
c NOTE:ssDNArunsdifferentfromPCRproductsandsignalcanbedifficulttodetectusingmost gelvisualizationmethods.
14ssDNAcanbestoredat-20Cor-80C.
D.SynthesisofbiotinylateddoublestrandedDNA(dsDNA) Materials.
Targetingplasmidtemplate
Refertosupplementalinformationforfurthernotesondesignoftargetingplasmidtemplate Primersetfortemplategeneration(forwardandreverse)
Bothprimersmustcontainabiotinmodificationonthe50 end.
HighFidelityTaqPolymerasekitwithproof-readingactivity(e.g.HotStarHiFidelityPolymerasekit, QiagenCat.No.202602)
Fig.3. GenerationofssDNAproduct.ImageofGelSafestained1%agarosegelofsamples1–3ofgeneratinga738bpssDNA product(sectionC).15.5mgofbiotinylatedPCRproductwasboundtostreptavidin-conjugatedbeads(sample1).1.8mgof unboundDNAwasrecoveredinthesupernatantfollowingbinding(sample2).2mgofssDNAproductwasrecoveredinthefinal steps(sample3).TheweakssDNAbandandsmearwithinthelaneiswhatistypicallyobserved.Approximately350ngofDNA (dsDNAorssDNA)wasloadedperlane.Ladder:100bpladder,200bp,500bp,and1200bpbandsmarked.
PCRpurificationsystem(e.g.QIAquickPCRpurificationkit,QiagenCat.No.28104) Protocol
1 PCRprimersshouldbedesignedtoamplifydesiredgene-editedsequenceandcontain100-200bpof flankinghomologyupstreamanddownstreamtothesiteofeditingwithinthegenome. 2 Setup5–10PCRreactionstoamplifytemplatesequencefromthetargetingplasmidtemplate.
a NOTE: Use of a proof-reading enzyme is essential to reduce the probabilityof introducing mutations.
bNOTE:Minimizetheprimerconcentrationasmuchaspossibletoallowformoreefficientoligo removalduringstep3.
cNOTE:CheckPCRreactionbyrunningasmallamount(2–5
m
lofthereaction)onanagarosegelto confirmreactiongeneratessinglePCRproduct.Ifreactioncannotbeoptimizedtoeliminate un-desiredbands,proceedwithagelPCRpurificationmethodtoobtaindesiredband.3 PoolPCRreactionsandcleanusingaPCRpurificationsystem.Thisstepisessentialtoremovethe unusedprimersthatwillinterferewiththebindingoftheDNAtotheCas9-mSAmoleculeupon injection(sectionE).Thetypicalelutionvolumeis50
m
l.EluteusingRNase-freewaterandnot suppliedelutionbuffer.aMeasureconcentrationofcleanedPCRproductonNanoDroporsimilar.
4 Runasmallamount(200–500ng)ofcleanedPCRproductonageltoconfirmsizeandpurityof product.
5 BiotinylateddsDNAcanbestoredat-20Cor-80C.
E.ConditionsformicroinjectionofCRISPR/Cas9reagents Materials.
Cas9protein(optionforMethod1only)
Cas9orCas9-streptavidinmRNA(seeprocedureA) sgRNA(s)(seeprocedureB)
ssDNAtemplate(seeprocedureC,forMethod1only)
Biotinylated-dsDNAtemplate(seeprocedureD,forMethod2only) Microinjectionbuffer
8mMTrisHCl,pH7.5 0.2
Method1:Gene-editingusingCas9,gRNA(s),andssDNAtemplate
Cas9protein 100ng/ml –
Cas9mRNA – 37.5ng/ml
sgRNA(s) 20ng/ml(eachifusingmultiple)
ssDNA 20ng/ml
Method2:Gene-editingusingCas9-streptavidinfusionproteinmRNA,gRNA(s),and Biotinylated-dsDNAtemplate
Cas9-streptavidinmRNA 35-40ng/ml
sgRNA(s) 20ng/ml(eachifusingmultiple)
Biotinylated-dsDNA 20ng/ml
CRISPR/Cas9 reagents were injected into the pronuclei of fertilized oocytes using standard procedures[1].Gene-editingcanbeassessedbyPCRanalysisand/orSouthernBlottingasappropriate forthedesiredmodification.
Fig.4. Generationoflargegeneticmodificationsinmouse.(A)InsertionoftwoLoxPsites700bpapartusingMethod1(section E).DiagramrepresentstargetingstrategyusingtwosgRNAs(purplearrows)andalssDNAtemplatetoinserttwoLoxPsites (orangetriangle)flankinganexon(bluebox).Homologyregionsarenotedbyblackdashedlines.RepresentativelocationsofPCR primers(blackarrows)withintheendogenousandeditedsequencearemarkedandexpectedbandsizesarelistedabovegel images.Gels(right)showPCRanalysisforthe50and30LoxPsitesof4founder(F0)animals,twoheterozygoteanimalsmarkedby blackarrows.(B)GeneswapofcodingexonsusingMethod2(sectionE).Diagramrepresentstargetingstrategyusingtwo sgRNAs(purplearrows)andabiotinylateddsDNAtemplatetoreplacetwoexons(blueboxes–endogenousexons,redboxes– swapexons)whilepreservingflankingandintronicsequence(blueline).Homologyregionsarenotedbyblackdashedlines.
NOTE: It isofcritical importancetoprepare allstockreagents(Cas9/Cas9-streptavidinmRNA, sgRNAs,and replacementDNA) asconcentrated aspossible.Thus, whenreagents aredilutedfor microinjection, potential contaminants are diluted beyond detection and will not obstruct the injectionneedle.
Methodvalidation
WehaveusedbothMethod1andMethod2togenerateadiversearrayofgene-editedmouse modelsincluding;
ConditionalalleleviasimultaneousincorporationoftwoLoxPsites
GeneswapsthroughremovingandreplacingthecodingregionsofGeneAwithGeneB
For ourgeneediting strategies,potentialsgRNAs aremanuallyidentifiedtogenerateadouble strandbreakatthe50and30boundariesoftheregionofDNAtobeedited.ItisimportantthattheCas9 generatedcutsiteisascloseaspossibletothedesirededitingsite tomaximizetheefficiencyof homologydirectedrepair.Thus,therelativenumberofpotentialsgRNAstobeconsideredwillvary dependingonthenatureofthedesirededit.Publicallyavailableonlinetoolscanbeusedtoevaluate thepotentialefficiencyofsgRNAs;however,Cas9-mediatedcuttingefficiencyshouldbeempirically determinedforeachsgRNA.AfterthesgRNA(s)havebeenvalidated,thetargetingplasmidvectorcan be designed and generated using conventional cloning techniques or custom synthesized commercially.Weuse100-200bpofflankinghomologyforboththessDNAandbiotinylated-dsDNA targetingmethods.Thesizeofthehomologyarmisbasedonevidenceprovidedbyotherpublished CRISPRmethodologiesandexperienceinourlaboratory[2–5].Atargetingplasmidcontaining300bp ormoreofflankinghomologyallowsenoughflexibilitytopickoptimalprimerpairsforgenerating DNAtemplates.
The choiceof using Method 1 or Method 2 must be determinedempirically and will differ dependingonthenatureofthedesirededit.Wehavesuccessfullygenerated“floxed”allelesusing Method1;however,noevidenceofeditingwasobservedwhenweattemptedtogenerateageneswap (Fig.4A).Alternatively,weachievedveryhighgeneeditingefficiencywhencreatingacomplexgene swapusingMethod2(Fig.4B).Itisimportanttonotethattheefficiencyofgeneeditingwillvary dependingonthetargetlocusandthenatureoftheeditbeinggenerated.Efficiencyofeditingalso dependsonthequalityoftheCRISPRreagentsusedformicroinjectionanditisofcriticalimportanceto insure that RNA based components show no signs of degradation prior to every round of microinjection.
Additionalinformation
ThecommercialavailabilityofCRISPR/Cas9reagentsandnumerousadvancementsinefficiencyof CRISPR-based gene editing have allowed this technology to be routinely used in laboratories throughoutthelifesciencesandmedicinedisciplines.Thegenerationofnovelgene-editedmouse modelsisnowsubstantiallyeasierandfasterthanusingconventionalstemcell-basedgene-editing technologies.CRISPR/Cas9isnowroutinelyusedforthegenerationofpointmutations,“indels”to createloss-of-functionalleles,andinsertionofDNAsequencesincludingproteintagslikeFLAGorHA andfluorescentreporterslikeGFP[6,7].However,efficienteditingand/orinsertionoflargesequences ofDNA,eveninthecaseoffluorescentreporters,remainabigchallengeinthefield.
RepresentativelocationsofPCRprimerstogenerateauniquebandifexonswapoccurs(Analysis1,greenarrowsandbrackets) areshowninupperdiagram,PCRprimerstoscreenforcompleteexonswap(Analysis2,bluearrowsandbrackets)areshownin lowerdiagram,expectedbandsizesarelistedabovegelimages.Gels(right)showPCRanalysisforexonswapsof16F0animals. BlackarrowsonAnalysis2gelsshowtwoanimalstargetedtohomozygousefficiency.Boxedregion,showninhigher magnificationininset,demonstratesbandingpatternsforwildtype(WT),heterozygous(het),andhomozygous(homo) targetedExon2swap.Targetingplasmid(+)andwildtypegenomicDNA(WT)wereusedascontrols.
Severalgroupshaveexploredmethodstoincreasetheefficiencyofhomologydirectedrepair(HDR) thoughtheactiverecruitmentortetheringofthetemplateDNAsequencetoeitherCas9orthesgRNA [11–14].TheCas9fusionproteintomonomericstreptavidinusedinMethod2describedherewas initiallydeveloped toimprovetheefficiencyof generatingfluorescent reporteralleles [15]. They report targeting efficiencies up to 97% when using a single sgRNA, Cas9-streptavidin, and a biotinylated-dsDNAtemplatetoknockinaparticularDNAsequenceintoaspecificpositioninthe genome.Themaindifferencebetweenthisreportandourmethodisthedemonstrationofeffective targetingusingtwosgRNAstoreplaceaparticulargenomicsequenceforanotherone(e.g.ageneor enhancerswap).Inourhands,theuseoftwoguidesdoesnotappeartointerferewithhomologous recombinationortheorientationoftheeditedsequence,asmightbepredicted.Thisnewmethod mightproveparticularlyusefulforgeneratingallelesrequiringgene-editingoflargesequencesof DNA.
DeclarationofCompetingInterest
Theauthorsdeclarenoconflictsofinterest Acknowledgements
WeacknowledgethehelpandservicesoftheAnimalFacilitystaffattheInstitutoGulbenkiande Ciência.ThisworkwassupportedbyPTDC/BEX-BID/0899/2014andLISBOA-01-0145-FEDER-030254 (FCT, Portugal) toM.M. and bythe NationalInstitute of Arthritis and Musculoskeletal and Skin DiseasesoftheNationalInstituteofHealth(NIH)AwardNumberR61AR073523-02toD.M.W. References
[1]B.Hogan,F.Costantini,E.Lacy,ManipulatingtheMouseEmbryo:aLaboratoryManual,Vol.34,Coldspringharbor laboratory,ColdSpringHarbor,NY,1986.
[2]G.F.Codner,etal.,Applicationoflongsingle-strandedDNAdonorsingenomeediting:generationandvalidationofmouse mutants,BMCBiol.16(1)(2018)70.
[3]D.G.Lanza,etal.,Comparativeanalysisofsingle-strandedDNAdonorstogenerateconditionalnullmousealleles,BMCBiol. 16(1)(2018)69.
[4]H.Miura,etal.,CRISPR/Cas9-basedgenerationofknockdownmicebyintronicinsertionofartificialmicroRNAusinglonger single-strandedDNA,Sci.Rep.5(2015)12799.
[5]R.M.Quadros,etal.,Easi-CRISPR:arobustmethodforone-stepgenerationofmicecarryingconditionalandinsertion allelesusinglongssDNAdonorsandCRISPRribonucleoproteins,GenomeBiol.18(1)(2017)92.
[6]H.Wang,etal.,One-stepgenerationofmicecarryingmutationsinmultiplegenesbyCRISPR/Cas-mediatedgenome engineering,Cell153(4)(2013)910–918.
[7]H.Yang,etal.,One-stepgenerationofmicecarryingreporterandconditionalallelesbyCRISPR/Cas-mediatedgenome engineering,Cell154(6)(2013)1370–1379.
[8]P.Singh,J.C.Schimenti,E.Bolcun-Filas,Amousegeneticist’spracticalguidetoCRISPRapplications,Genetics199(1)(2015) 1–15.
[9]H.Yang,H.Wang,R.Jaenisch,GeneratinggeneticallymodifiedmiceusingCRISPR/Cas-mediatedgenomeengineering,Nat. Protocols9(8)(2014)1956–1968.
[10]F.A.Ran,etal.,GenomeengineeringusingtheCRISPR-Cas9system,Nat.Protoc.8(11)(2013)2281–2308.
[11]E.J.Aird,etal.,IncreasingCas9-mediatedhomology-directedrepairefficiencythroughcovalenttetheringofDNArepair template,Commun.Biol.1(2018)54.
[12]J.Carlson-Stevermer,etal.,AssemblyofCRISPRribonucleoproteinswithbiotinylatedoligonucleotidesviaanRNAaptamer forprecisegeneediting,Nat.Commun.8(1)(2017)1711.
[13]K.Lee,etal.,SyntheticallymodifiedguideRNAanddonorDNAareaversatileplatformforCRISPR-Cas9engineering,Elife (2017)6.
[14]M.Ma,etal.,Efficientgenerationofmicecarryinghomozygousdouble-floxpallelesusingtheCas9-Avidin/Biotin-donor DNAsystem,CellRes.27(4)(2017)578–581.
[15]B.Gu,E.Posfai,J.Rossant,Efficientgenerationoftargetedlargeinsertionsbymicroinjectionintotwo-cell-stagemouse embryos,Nat.Biotechnol.36(7)(2018)632–637.