Perspect. ciênc. inf. vol.21 número3

(1)

! " #$ % &'(% &)% &''*+,% - &. & '/(0

! " #

" $ % &

' " ( ))

*++ , +-. -/0.+-01- /233+4/42

5 67 * ! " # "

$ "

% &

&' (

)

&'

(2)

' ( (

$ &'

+

* ,

-+

&' .

-+

*

* ! " / &'

" 0 * " / '

(

1 '2&/2&'/(3 '/&/3&'/(0

4 & 5

1 1

-&

6 % 1

7 &

"

7 %

1 8 9

: 1 ; 8 <% 9 =& 89= ;<% %

> ? 1 8?; <<&

@ %

&

; 1 4

4

1 %

1 &

5 % '%

& ) 1

* & " +%

&

3 %

& A %

0% B 4

(3)

! " #$ % &'(% &)% &''*+,% - &. & '/(0

!

C 1

&

5 : : 8'/(/<% 4

@

& A @@ 1

8'/(/<%

% 1 "

@ &

D 8'//0< 1

1 %

8" 5<

1 % E E

&

% @

" 5&

? 8(,,,<

1

@ & 6 % 1

1 & 5 B

1

8 C55" ;" ;% '//0<&

9 " 5

1 & 6 %

D F 8'//'<%

1

1 & 5 %

% 7 7

" 5 8 :>;?% '//+<&

A % 8'//+< 1

" 5

% % 1

& ;

1 1 * 4 & "

% 1 *E %

% 1

1 & 9

% 1 @

8 C55" ;" ;% '//G<&

5 1

%

1

(4)

E 1 @ B

8 C5; =9 C >9 9HH ;= % '//,<&

8'///< D 8'//3< " 5

@

& 5 1 8

<% 8:IJK% '//)<%

@

8:IJK% (,,,<&

5 : : 8'/(/<% 1

4 1

% &

"

" 5 @ 1

% %

1 4 1 1 8 C5; % '/(+<&

#

5 % 1

7 % 1

7 1 1 &

A % 7 1 &

? % D 1 8(,,)< %

% 7 @ % 1

* &

= 8(,,G<% @ D 1 B %

@ @

% 1

& 5 1

7 @ &

"

1 1

B & B

1 4 8 5L>9

=9C "C A9C 9:% (,,2<& % %

@ 4 8 L59C=9 D 5;>9 ; D L56"9 %

'//,<&

1

& 5 1 1

1

1 1 8C;K DL"CC9 %

'//(<& 5 %

8 @ <

(5)

! " #$ % &'(% &)% &''*+,% - &. & '/(0 _$

; 1 4 %

4 % %

% % %

1 % 1 % 1

8 LM 9H*A"DL9 ; % '/((<&

" 1 4 %

@ % 4 & =

% 1

1 & 5

1 @ %

% %

& " 4 %

8 5L>9 =9C "C A9C 9:%

(,,2<&

%

&

5 &

4 1 %

8 5L>9

=9C "C A9C 9:% (,,2<&

5 8=; 5% (,,G 5L>9 =9C "C

A9C 9:% (,,2<

<> ; % @ @

1<D ; % 1 1

1 %

< ; % 1

4% 1

< ; % 7

@ 1

4

< ; % 4

1 4

<5 4 ; % 7 @ 1

1 &

? 4

1 %

(6)

1 1 B 4

8 5L>9 =9C "C A9C 9:% (,,2<&

%

#

(

5 4 %

1 ;

9 & 5

B %

%

8 "C5; 5"C % '//+ LM 9H*A"DL9 ; %

'/((<& >

& % C D

8'//(<%

<5

1<5 4

<5 4 7

<5 4

4

<5 @ 4 &

8'//+<%

%

@ % @ % 8A

(<& > %

&

(7)

! " #$ % &'(% &)% &''*+,% - &. & '/(0 ₎

"C5; 5"C 8'//+<&

" % 4 1 8 "C5; 5"C %

'//+<

< B

8 <

1< @ 1

8

1 <

<A @

8 7

1 @

% N * O N * O<

<" @

4

< &

%

< E E 4 1

E 7 4

81 % % E % 7

E <

1<9 - E

<> %

& 5

Documentation

Evaluation Knowledge acquisition

(8)

B 1 % &

C D 8'//(<%

& 5 8C;K

DL"CC9 % '//( L 9 5L>9 % '//) DP 9H* I 9H A9 CMC>9H*

:P 9H ; 6;% '//+ "C5; 5 = 59 " 6% '//+ L59C=9 D

5;>9 ; D L56"9 % '//, LM 9H*A"DL9 ; % '/(/<%

1 1 &

5 1 % 7 1

1 B

% % % 8C;K DL"CC9 %

'//(<

<> 8 <

1<; @ 7

<> B 8 <

<J 8

<&

1 % 5 D 8'//,<

1 1

! 0 121 8C;K DL"CC9 % '//(<%

! - -# 8 L 9 5L>9 % '//)< 3 8DP 9H*

I 9H A9 C C>9H*:; 9H ; 6;% '//+<&

5 1 - %

@ % @ % %

4 8 L59C=9 D 5;>9 ; D L56"9 %

'//,<

<

% 4 %

% E

&

1< @ % 1

% &

<A @ %

%

B &

<" B

&

<9 4

(9)

! " #$ % &'(% &)% &''*+,% - &. & '/(0 ₊

5 B

A '&

A ' * ;

L59C=9 D 5;>9 ; D L56"9 8'//,).

> 1 1 %

4% 4 E

& C % 1

@ 4 8 : J"9 ;

D " "9:% '/((<&

,

5

& %

1 7 4 & "

8 < 4

E 8>9*: *5; 9*LD 59*DL C":;

5 6 6" =9 5;:;HH"% '/((<&

5

& "

1

% &

%

8 >% '//( "; C "C"%

'//G<&

7 % % 1

1 & 5 E %

% 1 7

% 1 %

8 "; C "C"% '//G<&

5 % 4 8'//+<%

8A )<&

A ) *

P

ro

té

g

é

Identify the purpose Identify the scope

Consider reuse Identify sources Generate questions List terms Aggregate terms Classify terms Define terms Create hierarchy Map relations Map instances Map properties Map restrictions Refine relations Refine restrictions Value properties Value relations Value restrictions

Evaluate according to sources Evaluate according to requirements

Evaluate witch users SPECIFICATION

CONCEPTUALIZATION

FORMALIZATION _{IMPLEMENTATION}

EVALUATION

TOOLS

Refines the ontology project in implementation details Provides the test environment to the

built ontology Generates the documentation artifacts

Automatically generates the OWL file to export

(10)

;C 8'//+<&

" % & ?

1 % %

7 8 & &% %

% 1 <&

? 1 % 9= ;% % >

?; & 5 1 1

1 9 1

- 1 1 1- &

5 4

8 ;

; ; !/

!/ !/ < C> 8 <&

? 4 %

& 5 N-O 8

/ 7 % 4

< N.O 8

7 % 5 4

<&

5 % 8 Q Q R R ;

R ; Q1 R ; R< ; 8 Q Q R

R ; R< ; 8 1 < C> 8 R<&

D 1 %

1 5 1 (

5 1 ( * 1

Database Search field selected

(11)

! " #$ % &'(% &)% &''*+,% - &. & '/(0

EBSCO All

Scopus TITLE-ABS-KEY

ScienceDirect TITLE-ABSTR-KEY

WOS Topic2

> 1 &

% %

& ? 4

9 % & C

1 1 1

&

A % %

1 % 4 B 1 1

% 7 & ? 4

E &

5 A +&

A + *

> 1 &

5 % 4 8'//+<%

E & 5 % 1

E / 0

1 Q

5

1 * 1 1

/) (+ ; 1 '/()&

1 330 & 8 5<

1 8 <% '2 E &

1 % '/ &

2

(12)

% % 5 1 '&

5 S &

Table 2 - Number of articles per database

Database Total After RT and

RA Repeated Available Selected

Scielo - - - - -

EBSCO 316 13 2 11 3

Scopus 164 9 3 6 1

ScienceDirect 10 1 - 1 -

WOS 66 5 2 2 -

TOTAL 556 28 7 20 4

> 1 &

5 8 ; 9 5 CA; >% '//G< 7

1

% %

% 1 %

& 5 B - 1

&

5 8 : J"9 ; D " "9:% '/((<%

7 1

& 5 %

4 % %

% % %

1 &

5 8 :* L> " K J " 5 % '/('<

@

% @ 4 1

" 5

4 @ &

5 8> "D ;L " C " % '/()<

1

% 1 @

& " 1

1 8 E

< 1

&

%

1 &

1 8?" 9 % '//G

: ; " 5 =;L " 5 = C" % '//2<&

(13)

! " #$ % &'(% &)% &''*+,% - &. & '/(0

% 1

% @ % @ %

% 4 1

&

5 1

1 &

%

#

5 1 4

E %

4 B 8 L59C=9 D

5;>9 ; D L56"9 % '//,<&

2 5 1

% 1

4 &

3 5 B 4

% 1

&

4 5

? 4 Q

? 1 Q

5

4 % 1 %

@ 8= L :"L ; 6";55"% '//G

9 " 59 5 = C" D;L>; % '//,<&

6 % 1 8

< 1 8? 3

> :4_< ₁ _&

; 1 % 1

4 4 %

" ? 1 %

8 % <% & ?

7 %

%

1 &

% > : 1 % &

; 1 1

1 4 %

7 % 1

&

4 B

% 1 &

3

http://watson.kmi.open.ac.uk/WatsonWUI/. Accessed on: October 14th 2013.

4

(14)

%

#

6

" 1 %

1

8 L59C=9 D 5;>9 ; D L56"9 % '//,<& 5

9

B * 4 7

&

1 4

1 & 4 8'//0< 4

< 8 <

* 4

1<5 1 1

< 1 1

< 1 1 1 E 1

<5 1 1

< % B

7 &

7

& 5 1 8C 6" 9% '/('<

@ % % % CD; &

& %

1 1 1 4 % 5 1 5 1 8'//2<

% 4 % %

1

7#1 (

1 4 1

& 5 1

T T

17 (

& 5

% U B E

& " U B

(15)

! " #$ % &'(% &)% &''*+,% - &. & '/(0 _$

78 9 1

& 5

U B

7, : 1

%

& 5

U B

7# : 1

& 5

U B U

B &

9 1

@ 8 ;:9 C DV5H9% '//(

; >9% '//' "C5; 6% '//+ " '% '//G ?" 9 % '//G

5 =;L " &% '//G<& 5 8 1 %

<% 8 % % 1

< 8 % %

% 1 <& =

%

1 ;9 > 8'//)<% :

7 % 8

1 < %

%

&

174 % *

1 1

1 4 &

7; ( % *

1

1 4

1 &

9

4 & %

5 1 8'//G<

% 8'/('<

%

73 ( " 5 %

174 1 ( ( " 5

(16)

73 1 " 5 1 1

1 1

74 ( " 5 % 11 %

4

7! " 5

11

78 1 " 5

1

78 " 5

7, " 5

7

7& " 5 1

<7# " 5

1

97= " 5 %

1

7; " 5

7# " 5 %

&

* 4 * 4

1 1

1 1 8 9 6"% '/()<&

1

* 4 &

? 1 S

% % 4 %

86;?:955 9 6% (,,3 9= 9% '//2< %

% 4 % 8;9 >% '//)< *

8 9 6"% '/()<

73 1 %

1

17; 1 1

% %

E

7; (

(17)

! " #$ % &'(% &)% &''*+,% - &. & '/(0 ₎

E

78 9 E B 7

1 1

7 %

7!( B 1

7!0 1 S

1 1 % 1

1 &

5 > 4 4 8'/()<%

&

1 1

& " 1

% %

1 1

1 &

" 7 %

1 @ 1 &

? E 1

% 1 7

E &

E % 1 % 1 %

&

> E E

1

& 5 8 ":J % '//,< 1 8 4

1 @ <% 8 4 <

8 4 1 <&

8'//,<% 1

1

1 @ &

B 1 @ & A %

7 B 1 %

@ 4

4 &

L 1 1 E E

1 1 %

(18)

E E

@ 1

1 @ &

%

#

6

; @ % %

1 %

&

? % @

1 85 1 )<

1 85 1 +< 8 L59C=9 D

5;>9 ; D L56"9 % '//,<&

5 1- B * %

1 * 4

1 1 % 4

(19)

! " #$ % &'(% &)% &''*+,% - &. & '/(0 ₊

5 1 ) W ; 1

Classes Subclasses

Engagement area

Providing information, Collaborative environment, Public consultation, Collective action, Election campaign, Deliberation, Discourse, Mediation, Territorial planning, Opinion and satisfaction research, Voting, Account rendering, Open data Actor Citizen, Government agency, Private sector entity, NGO, Political

party Phase of the

decision-making process

Problem identification, Agenda setting, Alternative formulation, Decision making, Implementation, Evaluation, Extinction

Tool Information, Communication Electronic

democracy initiative

-

Engagement level

Information, Consultation, Active participation

Role Observer, Participant (owner/initiator, information provider, moderator/facilitator, decision maker)

Principle Mutual assistance, Benefit division, Collaboration, Consensus decision, Maximum participation, Availability of information

Requirement Democratic requirement, Usability and accessibility requirement, Security and privacy requirement

Result Participation, Accountability

> 1 &

5 1 + W ;

1-Properties Classes

Name Related Classes

Actor has level Engagement level

has role Role

Use Tool

Tool Satisfy Requirement

Support Electronic democracy initiative enable level Engagement level

Electronic democracy initiative

Engage Actor

has area Engagement area Pursue Principle

Aim Result

Result Encourage Phase of the decision-making

process

(20)

1 1 1

85 1 3<%

&

5 1 3 W ; &

Properties Classes

Name Restriction

Observer use Information tool

has level Information

Decision Maker has level Active participation Moderator/facilitator has level Active participation Owner/initiator has level Consultation

has level Active participation

> 1 &

5 & A

%

< 1 E &

1<

% U B

E & "

U B % &

<5 4 % . .

E &

<5 U B E

&

<5 U B E

&

% #

5

1- 1

1 & " 1 DX @* @%

A Y @*:X @ 8'//+<%

% @ & 5

1-1 % @ &

5 *;?: +

* A 4 8 Z L '//0%

+&)&/<& A 3% 0 G &

(21)

! " #$ % &'(% &)% &''*+,% - &. & '/(0

> 1 &

A 0 *

> 1 &

(22)

> 1 &

%" #

(

"

% 7

&

5 7

1 1 1

B 4 4

1 &

1 7 %

: > = %

% + 3 > 1 '/()

N: % D 5 &O

L 3 6

+ %

1 1 4

& 1 %

&

> % 1 1

E &

" % 1

B % @

& 9E %

8 1 <

1 8 1- %

1 <&

" 1 % E

7

B 8 <

& ? %

8 <% @ 4

(23)

! " #$ % &'(% &)% &''*+,% - &. & '/(0

5 1

E 1 1 % %

& ? 1 % 1 %

E 1 %

E 4

% @ B &

" >

9

5 4 B 1 @

% *

8C J"D:" J9: >"% '//+<% 1

4 &

D [ 8'//3<%

%

4 & ;

1 1 &

% @ % @ %

%

E 4

& 5

@ %

1 &

" B 4 %

1 &

4% 1

& ; 9

5 4 9

&

:* L> " K% & & 5& J " 5 % 5& D& & A 4

@ *

1 1 > & 789 : #

3 % 6 1 % & (/% & (% & 3+*0+% & '/('&

C55" ;" ;% &*J& 7 * & 7 ; J" 5" "C%

& 9"\;5;% 5& 89 &<& - %!/ & : 1 *

7 & " * .9

% '//0& & '03*'G2&

C55" ;" ;% &*J& > * 1 %

& -< 5 9*D

(24)

=; 5% ?& C& ,

(,,G& ''G & 5 8>

" #$ < * 5 "

5 % L 5 % 9 % (,,G&

= L % D& :"L ;% & :& 6";55"% ;& 9 1 4

* 1 4* & :

% 5 % & '% & (%

& ))*+2% & '//G&

:>;?% & $- 1 & ? % >

" 9 D % "= % '//+&

59:: % & ! & '& & $ @ 5 % '///&

9C5 9 A; 9J"9? C> >" 9 "C 5";C 8 ><& 8

>T

& ' & K 4 L K 4&

'//(& > +&

;:9 C% & DV5H9% & = 1

1 & : 6 % '//(&

>9*: *5; 9*LD 59*DL C":;% & & 5 6 6"% & A& =9 5;:;HH"%

& & $ Y C #] & / $

$ 8 9% $ % & +3% & 3% & ('0/*('00% ; & '/((&

> "D % & & ;L " C " % :& 9*

7 : , 7 %

1 % & (/% & '% &G3)*G32% & '/()&

D ^ ;% A& & 5 4

& 7 ; "C59 C 5";C :

;CA9 9C 9 9D;J% +&% '//3% % > 4 9 >

= 6 1 % '//3& & (32*(03&

D ;C% D& >& 9

-& 1 = % '//0&

D; 9 % ?& 1 #$

$ [ & / ? ; ( % $ : % &

G% & )% & '(+*'''% &. @& '//3&

DP 9H* I 9H% & A9 CMC>9H*:P 9H% & ; 6;% ;& !

7 4 % *

1& : *J % '//+&

D _C:LC>% `& 9* * & 7 ; "A:

;LC ": C> D9C9 : ;CA9 9C 9% 02&% '//'& D &

9 > C "A: % '//'& > [

a .. 7& & & . . - b>>9 A/=92A

G=3,A9 +0(32),+(,=0'+0Q b(/&(&(&(/'&0'+,c b (c b d&

(25)

! " #$ % &'(% &)% &''*+,% - &. & '/(0 _$

D L=9 % 5& & 1 &

# % : % & 3% & '% & (,,*''/% & (,,)&

6;?:955% & & 9 6% &

1 & 5 ;7 L % (,,3&

"C59 C 5";C : ; " 5";C A; L=:" 5" " 5";C 8" '<&

& > [

a .. & '& . .+G+2. ." 'e'/ f

& d& '/ & '//,&

;C% C&

1 & : 5 1 % '//+&

: ; " % 9& 5 =;L " % 9& 5 = C" % & *

& 7 ; "C59 C 5";C : ;CA9 9C 9 ;C "C59 C95 C> ?9=

:" 5";C C> 9 J" 9 % )&% '//2% & 9 >

? "999 % '//2& & '3*)/&

:9 ; % & :IJK% & ! #$

1 Y & $ % '/(/&

:IJK% & ) ; 1 # & $

: % (,,,&

:IJK% & , & : 1 " % '//)&

"C5; 6% & @ 9* * 4 & 7 ;

6 ? "" "C59 C 5";C : ;CA9 9C 9 ;C K 59 "9C 9 % )G&% '//+&

= " % 6 & 9 > ? "999

'//+& & (*(/&

C J"D:"% & J9: >"% & :

1 & , @ %

1 % & )/% & '% & (3(*(G,% '//+&

C 6" 9% & & 5 *

& 7 ; "C59 C 5";C : ;CA9 9C 9 ;C >"D"5 :

D;J9 C 9C5 9 9 6% ()&% '/('& C K 4& 9 > C K 4

% '/('& & (03*(G'&

C;K% C& A& DL"CC9 % >& :& ! 121

& > [

a .. & & . 1 . f .

(/(& d& )/ & '/()&

; D C"H gh; ;; 9 gh; 9 >9 9CJ;:J" 9C5; 9 ;Ci " ;

8; >9<& ! ' ; >9 1 #$ %

#$ #$ [ j1 & = [ %

9D9 % '//'&

; D C" 5";C A; 9 ;C; " ;; 9 5";C C> >9J9:; 9C5

8;9 ><& 9

(26)

9 " 59 % J 5 = C" % D;L>; % &

* D 1

& , A 7 % % & )(% & +% & 0()*

0'2% & '//,&

95 L % & : X

X & 7 ; D :"C>;% A& 8 &<& % +

j1 & H @ 5 % '//0& &

23*(()&

"C5;% 6& & 5"C % & & ; 1 1 Q

# 7 % C K 4% & 0% & +% & ++(*+0+%

& '//+&

"C5;% 6& & 5 =% & 59 " 6% & >":"D9C5 *

1 % *

& 7 9L ; 9 C ;CA9 9C 9 ;C 5"A" " :

"C59::"D9C 9% (0&% '//+& J & 9 J "; %

'//+& & ),)*),G&

L59C=9 D% & 5;>9 ;% & :& D L56"9 % A& & ;&

& /

% A @ % & )/% & (% & ())*(++% - & '//,&

; 9% & 5 CA; >% &

& , 7 %

& '/% & ,/,*,+)% '//G&

;J9 % & & 9HH ;= % ;& k

$ & 7 9HH ;= % ;& D :"C>;% A& 8; &<& 0

* & H @ L Y H @ % '/(/& & (3*)0&

";% & A& C "C"% & & 9 $ Y

[ ! [ & / =

? % $ % & ((% & (% & 2)*2,% - &. & '//G&

C5; % & & ? B *

( ' & '/(+& +)/ &

5 8> 9 D $ *

L A % 5 X %

X *D #$ 9 D $ % A X %

'/(+&

C5; % & & =9 C >9 % =& 9HH ;= % ;& >

l & 7 ; 9C ;C5 ; "C59 C ";C " >;

; >% '//,% A X & A X A #$ = 7%

'//,& > [

a .. & & &1 . . . 1 e )e Ge )e ) *

* e )e=+ * * * d& '3

(27)

! " #$ % &'(% &)% &''*+,% - &. & '/(0 ₎

9 J"g; = ":9" ; >9 ;"; " ; 9 9mL9C 9 9

8 9= 9<& 9 + C Y & = 6 @

1 . D% '//2&

9 6"% :& 9 + C % E Y %

Y & '& & $ : % '/()&

9 % & & & J :6;% & & & & C9" ;% & 1

Y & / , $

3 % % = 6 @ % #$ 5 !

% & '/('% & ()3*(3)% '/('&

6 C9% & & 0

& C K 4 % '//+&

":J % & & $ E Y

] [ 9 & '//,& +'+ & 5

8> #$ n < *

X * #$ #$ n % A

#$ % L A = & % '//,&

: J"9 ;% & D " % & & =& "9:% & 5

& 7 ; 9:9 5 ;C"

D;J9 C 9C5 C> 569 "CA; 5";C K 59 9 9 5"J9& '&% '/((&

5 & 9 > = = 6 1 % '/((& & (+0*

(0/&

5L>9 % & =9C "C % J& & A9C 9:% >&

& 0 A # $ % % &

'3% & (*'% &(0(*(,G% & (,,2&

LM 9H*A"DL9 ; % & & D !

% & '/(/& '22 & 5

8> ! #$ " ! < *

> " % A " Y %

L & % '/(/&

LM 9H*A"DL9 ; % & & & 9

% % & 7 ; ?; 6; ;C =L":>"CD

> 5 ;>9: % '&% '/((& % A & 9 > =

9 % '/((& & ,*'(&

L 9% K& 5L>9 % & *1 4

& 7 ; > J"9 % & A9C 9:% >& J C 6 9:9C% A& 89 &<&

* 4 &

? c % '//)& & ))*+0&

5 =;L " % 9& 7 >9 ;* 1 4

o(& = 9 % '//G&

? 5 ;C% & 5& 5 &

(28)

?" 9 % & & ; * %

'//G& 7 ; "C59 C 5";C : ;CA9 9C 9 ;C 569; K C> 5" 9 ;A

9:9 5 ;C" D;J9 C C 9% (&% '//G& % & 9 > C