DEgb^dCdWZaYZBZY^X^cVYZ'%%%[d^XdcXZY^YdV6gk^Y8Vgahhdc!EVja <gZZc\VgYZ:g^X@VcYZaedghZjhigVWVa]dhhdWgZVigVchb^hhdYdh^cVa cdh^hiZbVcZgkdhd#
DhighX^Zci^hiVhÒoZgVbYZhXdWZgiVhZhhZcX^V^hhdWgZjbbdYd^bedgiVciZ YZigVchb^hhdYdh^cVaZcigZVhY^[ZgZciZhXajaVhcZgkdhVh!VigVchb^hhd h^c{ei^XVaZciV!fjZ[d^YZiZgb^cVciZeVgVVXdbegZZchdYVh[jcZh cdgbV^hYdXgZWgdZYVhXdcY^ZhYVheZgijgWVZhcVigVchb^hhdYd h^cVafjZedYZb^cYjo^gZc[Zgb^YVYZhcZjgda\^XVhdj[h^XVh#
6gk^Y8Vgahhdc!EVja<gZZc\VgYZ:g^X@VcYZa\Vc]VgVbdEgb^dCdWZaedg hjVhYZhXdWZgiVhhdWgZXdbdVhbZchV\ZchhdigVchb^i^YVhcdh^hiZbV cZgkdhdXZcigVa!igVWVa]dfjZiZb]d_Z^cÓjcX^VY^gZiVcdigViVbZcidYV YdZcVYZEVg`^chdc#DhighaVjgZVYdhXdcig^WjgVbeVgVVX^cX^VedghjVh YZhXdWZgiVhe^dcZ^gVhhdWgZXdbdjbVXajaVZck^VbZchV\ZbeVgVdjigV! ^c[dgbVdXgjX^VaeVgVhZZciZcYZgV[jcdYdXgZWgd#6abYZhZgZbV WVhZeVgVdigViVbZcidYdbVaYZEVg`^chdc!VhYZhXdWZgiVhXdcig^WjgVb iVbWbeVgVdYZhZckdak^bZcidYdhVci^YZegZhh^kdh!XdbddEgdoVX#
6H9:H8D7:GI6H
CdXgZWgd]jbVcdZm^hiZbbV^hYZ&%%W^a]ZhYZXajaVhcZgkdhVh! XdcZXiVYVhjbVh|hdjigVhedgjbVgZYZ^cÒc^iVbZciZXdbeaZmV#JbV bZchV\ZbigVchb^i^YVYZjbVXajaVeVgVVdjigVedgbZ^dYZY^[ZgZciZh igVchb^hhdgZhfjb^Xdh#6igVchYjd!djigVchedgiZ!YZh^cVadXdggZZb edcidhZheZX^V^hYZXdciVidh!X]VbVYdhh^cVehZh!ZjbVc^XVXajaV cZgkdhVedYZiZgb^a]VgZhYZhhZhedcidhXdbdjigVhXajaVh#
DhigheZhfj^hVYdgZhÒoZgVbYZhXdWZgiVhe^dcZ^gVhfjVcidVjbi^edYZ igVchYjdYZh^cVaZcigZVhXajaVhcZgkdhVh!X]VbVYdYZigVchb^hhd h^c{ei^XVaZciV#>hhdedhh^W^a^idjZciZcYZgV[jcdcdgbVaYdXgZWgdZ XdbdVheZgijgWVZhcZhhVigVchYjdYZh^cVaedYZbegdkdXVgYdZcVh
cZjgda\^XVhZeh^fj^{ig^XVh!edhh^W^a^iVcYdV^cYVfjZcdkVhYgd\Vh[dhhZb YZhZckdak^YVh#
6gk^Y8Vgahhdc[d^fjZbYZhXdWg^jfjZVYdeVb^cVjbigVchb^hhdgYd XgZWgd!ZfjZ^hhdiZbjbV\gVcYZ^bedgi}cX^VfjVcid|cdhhV]VW^a^YVYZ cdXdcigdaZYZbdk^bZcidh#HjVeZhfj^hVaZkdjVdZciZcY^bZcidYZfjZV YdZcVYZEVg`^chdcXVjhVYVedgjbVXVgcX^VYZYdeVb^cVZbXZgiVh eVgiZhYdXgZWgd!ZjbgZbY^dZÒX^ZciZeVgVZhiVYdZcVdA"YdeV eYZhZgYZhZckdak^Yd#8Vgahhdc[ZoYZhXdWZgiVhhjWhZfZciZh!idYVh XaVgZVcYddeVeZaYVYdeVb^cVcdXgZWgd!ZYZbdchigdj!Vhh^b!Xdbd V\ZbVhYgd\VhjhVYVhcdigViVbZcidYVZhfj^od[gZc^V#
EVja<gZZc\VgYYZhXdWg^jXdbdVYdeVb^cVZjbVhg^ZYZdjigdh igVchb^hhdgZhZmZgXZbhjVVdcdh^hiZbVcZgkdhd#DigVchb^hhdgV\Z eg^bZ^gdZbjbgZXZeidgcVhjeZg[X^ZYVXajaV#:hiZVX^dcVgZVZh ZbXVYZ^VfjZkdV[ZiVgXZgiVhegdiZcVh"X]VkZ!VhfjV^h!edghjVkZo! gZ\jaVbk{g^Vh[jcZhYVXajaVcZgkdhV#6hegdiZcVhhdbdY^ÒXVYVh Xdc[dgbZhdVY^X^dcVYdh[dh[dg^aVddjgZbdk^YdhYZh[dh[dg^aVd dh\gjedhYZ[dh[Vidh!dfjZegdkdXVjbVbjYVcVcV[dgbVZcV[jcd YVegdiZcV#6igVkhYZhhZbZXVc^hbddhigVchb^hhdgZhedYZbXVggZVg hjVhbZchV\ZchYZjbVXajaVeVgVVdjigV#
:g^X@VcYZa!edghjVkZo!YZhXdWg^jXdbdVZÒX^cX^VYVhh^cVehZhedYZhZg bdY^ÒXVYVZfjZdhbZXVc^hbdhbdaZXjaVgZh[VoZbeVgiZYZhhZegdXZhhd# JhVcYdjbbdajhXdbVgi^bdhZVhaj\XdbdbdYZadZmeZg^bZciVa!ZaZ YZbdchigdjXdbdVhbjYVcVhYZ[jcdh^c{ei^XVhdXZcigV^heVgVd VegZcY^oVYdZeVgVVbZbg^V#6[dh[dg^aVdYZegdiZcVZbh^cVehZh YZhZbeZc]VjbeVeZa^bedgiVciZcV\ZgVdYZjbV[dgbVYZbZbg^V YZXjgidegVod#EVgVYZhZckdakZgVbZbg^VVadc\degVod!cZXZhh{g^V iVbWbjbVbjYVcVcVhciZhZYZegdiZcV!fjZedYZaZkVgVVaiZgVZh cV[dgbVZcV[jcdYVh^cVehZ#
DhbZXVc^hbdh[jcYVbZciV^hfjZ@VcYZagZkZadjiVbWbhdVea^X{kZ^hV ]jbVcdh#EdYZ"hZY^oZgfjZcdhhVbZbg^VadXVa^oVYVcVhh^cVehZh#8db VhYZhXdWZgiVhYZ@VcYZa!edhhkZaV\dgVZhijYVg!edgZmZbead!Xdbd Vh^bV\ZchXdbeaZmVhYVbZbg^VhdVgbVoZcVYVhcdh^hiZbVcZgkdhd ZXdbdhZedYZgZXg^VgVbZbg^VYZZkZcidhVci^\dh#8dc]ZXZcYdZhhZh bZXVc^hbdh!hZg{edhhkZaZcidYZhZckdakZgcdkdhi^edhYZbZY^XVd eVgVbZa]dgVgVh[jcZhYVbZbg^V#
6gk^Y8Vgahhdc!YZ,,Vcdh!cVhXZjZbJeehVaV!cVHjX^V!ZY^g^\Zd 9ZeVgiVbZcidYZ;VgbVXdad\^VYVJc^kZgh^YVYZYZ<diZbWjg\d#EVja <gZZc\VgY!YZ,)Vcdh!cVhXZjZbCdkVNdg`ZigVWVa]VcdAVWdgVig^d YZCZjgdX^cX^VBdaZXjaVgZ8ZajaVgYVJc^kZgh^YVYZGdX`Z[ZaaZg!ZbCdkV Ndg`#?{:g^X@VcYZa!YZ,%Vcdh!cVhX^YdZbK^ZcV!Ûjhig^V!ZcVijgVa^oVYd cdgiZ"VbZg^XVcd!igVWVa]Vcd8ZcigdYZCZjgdW^dad\^VYVJc^kZgh^YVYZYZ 8dajbW^V!ZbCdkVNdg`#
I]ZCdWZaEg^oZd[BZY^X^cZ[dg'%%%lVhVlVgYZYid6gk^Y8Vgahhdc!EVja <gZZc\VgY!VcY:g^X@VcYZaWZXVjhZd[i]Z^gldg`hdch^\cVaigVchb^hh^dc ^ci]ZcZgkdjhhnhiZb#
I]Zi]gZZgZhZVgX]Zgh]VkZbVYZZhhZci^VaY^hXdkZg^ZhVWdjiVc^bedgiVci lVnd[igVchb^hh^dch^\cVaVbdc\i]ZY^[[ZgZcicZgkdjhXZaah!i]Zhadl hncVei^XigVchb^hh^dc!YZX^h^kZidi]ZjcYZghiVcY^c\d[i]ZWgV^ccdgbVa [jcXi^dchVcYd[i]ZXdcY^i^dchd[Y^hijgWhdci]Zh^\cVaigVchb^hh^dci]Vi XVc^cYjXZe]nh^XVaVcYcZjgdad\^XVaY^hZVhZh#
6gk^Y8Vgahhdc!EVja<gZZc\VgY!VcY:g^X@VcYZaldci]ZCdWZaEg^oZ[dg i]Z^gÒcY^c\hdc]dlbZhhV\ZhVgZigVchb^iiZYl^i]^ci]ZXZcigVacZgkdjh hnhiZb!l]VicdlVYVnhY^gZXian^cÓjZcXZhi]ZigZVibZcid[EVg`^chdcÉh Y^hZVhZ#I]Zi]gZZaVjgZViZhXdcig^WjiZYidhX^ZcXZ[dgi]Z^ge^dcZZg Y^hXdkZg^Zhdc]dlVXZaahZcYhVbZhhV\ZidVcdi]Zg!XgjX^Vae^ZXZd[ ^c[dgbVi^dcidjcYZghiVcYi]ZWgV^c[jcXi^dc#7Zh^YZhWZ^c\i]ZWVh^hid igZViEVg`^chdcÉhY^hZVhZhjX]ÒcY^c\hVahdXdcig^WjiZYidi]ZYZkZadebZci d[Vci^YZegZhhVcih!a^`ZEgdoVX#
I=:9>H8DK:G>:H
I]Z]jbVcWgV^c]VhbdgZi]Vc&%%W^aa^dccZgkdjhXZaah!XdccZXiZYid dcZVcdi]ZgWnVXdbeaZmcZildg`#6bZhhV\Z^hhZci[gdbVXZaaidVcdi]Zg WnbZVchd[Y^[[ZgZciX]Zb^XVaigVchb^iiZgh#I]Zh^\cVaigVchYjXi^dc!dg igVchedgi!iV`ZheaVXZ^cheZX^VaXdciVXied^cihXVaaZYhncVehZh!VcYVadcZ cZgkdjhXZaaXVc]VkZi]djhVcYhd[i]ZhZXdciVXihl^i]di]ZgXZaah# I]Zi]gZZgZhZVgX]ZghÉY^hXdkZg^ZhgZaViZYidV`^cYd[h^\cVaigVchYjXi^dc Vbdc\cZgkdjhXZaahXVaaZYhadlhncVei^XigVchb^hh^dc#I]^hZcVWaZYi]Z jcYZghiVcY^c\d[i]ZWgV^ccdgbVa[jcXi^dcVcYi]ZlVnY^hijgWVcXZh^c i]Vih^\cVaigVchYjXi^dcbVnXVjhZcZjgdad\^XVaVcYehnX]^Vig^XY^hZVhZh! VcYVaadlZYi]ZYZkZadebZcid[cZlYgj\h#
6gk^Y8VgahhdcY^hXdkZgZYi]ViYdeVb^cZ^hVWgV^cigVchb^iiZgVcYi]Vi^i^h d[\gZVi^bedgiVcXZiddjgh`^aa^ci]ZbdkZbZciXdcigda#=^hgZhZVgX]Wgdj\]i
a^\]idci]ZXVjhZd[EVg`^chdcÉhY^hZVhZVaVX`d[YdeVb^cZ^cXZgiV^ceVgih d[i]ZWgV^cVcYVcZ[[ZXi^kZYgj\V\V^chi^iA"YdeVXdjaYWZYZkZadeZY# 8VgahhdccZmiÒcY^c\hVaaXaVg^ÒZYi]ZgdaZd[YdeVb^cZ^ci]ZWgV^c!i]jh YZbdchigVi^c\]dlYgj\hjhZY^ci]ZigZVibZcid[hX]^ode]gZc^VVXiZY# EVja<gZZc\VgYY^hXdkZgZY]dlYdeVb^cZVcYdi]ZgigVchb^iiZghdeZgViZ ^ci]ZcZgkdjhhnhiZb#I]ZigVchb^iiZgÒghildg`hdcVgZXZeidgdci]ZXZaa hjg[VXZ#8]V^cgZVXi^dchig^\\ZgZYWni]^hgZXZeidgV[[ZXiXZgiV^c`ZnegdiZ^ch i]VigjaZhZkZgVacZgkdjhXZaah[jcXi^dch#EgdiZ^chVgZbdY^ÒZYVhhjae]ViZ \gdjehVgZVYYZYe]dhe]dgnaVi^dcdggZbdkZYYZe]dhe]dgnaVi^dc! l]ViX]Vc\Zhi]Z[dgbVcYi]Z[jcXi^dcd[i]ZegdiZ^c#7ni]^hbZX]Vc^hb igVchb^iiZghXVciV`Zi]Z^gbZhhV\Zh[gdbdcZXZaaidVcdi]Zg#
:g^X@VcYZaY^hXdkZgZY]dlhncVehZhZ[ÒXVXnXVcWZbdY^ÒZYVcYl]^X] bdaZXjaVgbZX]Vc^hbhiV`ZeVgi^ci]ViegdXZhh#Jh^c\VhcV^ahZVhaj\ VhVcZmeZg^bZciVabdYZa]Zh]dlZY]dlhncVei^X[jcXi^dcX]Vc\ZhVgZ ZhhZci^VaidaZVgc^c\VcYbZbdgn#I]ZegdiZ^ce]dhe]dgnaVi^dc^chncVehZh eaVnhVc^bedgiVcigdaZ^c\ZcZgVi^c\V`^cYd[h]dgi"iZgbbZbdgn#>cdgYZg idYZkZadei]Zadc\"iZgbbZbdgnVX]Vc\Z^ci]ZegdiZ^chnci]Zh^h^h cZXZhhVgn!l]VibVnaZVYidhncVehZhVaiZgVi^dch^c[dgbVcY[jcXi^dc# I]ZWVh^XbZX]Vc^hbh@VcYZagZkZVaZYVahdVeeanid]jbVch#>cVhZchZ djgbZbdgn^hadXViZY^ci]ZhncVehZh#7ZXVjhZd[@VcYZaÉhY^hXdkZg^Zh cdl^i^hedhh^WaZidhijYn]dli]ZXdbeaZmbZbdgn^bV\ZhVgZhidgZY ^ci]ZcZgkdjhhnhiZbVcY]dllZXVcgZ"XgZViZdaYZkZcihbZbdgn#7n `cdl^c\i]ZhZbZX]Vc^hbhlZXVcYZkZadecZl`^cYhd[Ygj\hid^begdkZ bZbdgn[jcXi^dch#
