w w w . e l s e v i e r . c o m / l o c a t e / b j i d
The
Brazilian
Journal
of
INFECTIOUS
DISEASES
Brief
communication
High
incidence
of
tuberculosis
in
patients
treated
for
hepatitis
C
chronic
infection
Silvia
Naomi
de
Oliveira
Uehara
a,∗,
Christini
Takemi
Emori
a,
Renata
Mello
Perez
b,
Maria
Cassia
Jacintho
Mendes-Correa
c,
Adalgisa
de
Souza
Paiva
Ferreira
d,
Ana
Cristina
de
Castro
Amaral
Feldner
a,
Antonio
Eduardo
Benedito
Silva
a,
Roberto
José
Carvalho
Filho
a,
Ivonete
Sandra
de
Souza
e
Silva
a,
Maria
Lucia
Cardoso
Gomes
Ferraz
aaGastroenterologyDivision,UniversidadeFederaldeSãoPaulo(UNIFESP),SaoPaulo,SP,Brazil bInternalMedicineDepartment,UniversidadeFederaldoRiodeJaneiro(UFRJ),RiodeJaneiro,RJ,Brazil cInfectiousDiseaseDivision,UniversidadedeSãoPaulo(USP),SaoPaulo,SP,Brazil
dGastroenterologyDivision,UniversidadeFederaldoMaranhão(UFMA),SaoLuis,MA,Brazil
a
r
t
i
c
l
e
i
n
f
o
Articlehistory:
Received28August2015 Accepted6December2015 Availableonline9February2016
Keywords:
HepatitisC Tuberculosis Alpha-interferon
Latenttuberculosisinfection
a
b
s
t
r
a
c
t
Brazilisoneofthe22countriesthatconcentrates80%ofglobaltuberculosiscases concomi-tantlytoalargenumberofhepatitisCcarriersandsomeepidemiologicalriskscenarios arecoincidentforbothdiseases.Weanalyzedtuberculosiscasesthatoccurredduring ␣-interferon-basedtherapyforhepatitisCinreferencecentersinBrazilbetween2001and2012 andreviewedtheirmedicalrecords.Eighteentuberculosiscaseswereobservedinpatients submittedtohepatitisC␣-interferon-basedtherapy.Allpatientswerehuman immuno-deficiencyvirus-negative.Ninepatients(50%)hadextra-pulmonarytuberculosis;15(83%) showedsignificantliverfibrosis.HepatitisCtreatmentwasdiscontinuedin12patients(67%) duetotuberculosisreactivationandsix(33%)hadsustainedvirologicalresponse.The major-ityofpatientshadafavorableoutcomebutonedied.Consideringtheevidencesof␣-IFN interferenceoverthecontainmentofMycobacteriumtuberculosis,theimmuneimpairment ofcirrhoticpatients,theincreaseoftuberculosiscasereportsduringhepatitisCtreatment withatypicalandseverepresentationsandthenegativeimpactonsustainedvirological response,wethinkthesearestrongargumentsforlatenttuberculosisinfectionscreening beforestarting␣-interferon-basedtherapyforanyindicationandeventoconsiderIFN-free regimensagainsthepatitisCwhenapatienttestspositiveforlatenttuberculosisinfection. ©2016ElsevierEditoraLtda.ThisisanopenaccessarticleundertheCCBY-NC-ND license(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
∗ Correspondingauthorat:RuaDoutorDiogodeFaria,539,apto104–10◦andar,VilaClementino,CEP:04037-001,SãoPaulo,SP,Brazil.
E-mailaddress:[email protected](S.N.deOliveiraUehara).
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.bjid.2015.12.003
1413-8670/©2016 Elsevier Editora Ltda. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons. org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Tuberculosis(Tb)isanair-borneinfectiousdiseasecaused by the Mycobacterium tuberculosis, considered priority for surveillanceandtreatmentbytheWorldHealthOrganization becauseofitshighincidenceandmortalityrates,especiallyin countrieswithsocio-economicandsanitaryissues.
Brazilisoneofthe22countriesintheworldthat concen-trate80%ofglobalTbcases,ranking16thinabsolutenumber ofcases(71,123casesin2013)and22ndinincidencerate(35.4 cases/100,000inhabitants).Mostofthereportedcasesoccur amongmenintheagegroupfrom40to59years,with pul-monarypresentation(86%).1
Somegroups are moresusceptible to Tb than the gen-eral population, such as patients living with the human immunodeficiency virus/acquired immunodeficiency syn-drome (HIV/Aids), patients under immunosuppressive or immunobiologicaltherapyaswithrheumatic,inflammatory boweldisease,andalsoindiabetis,chronickidney disease, andsolidorgantransplantedpatients.
ThetreatmentofTbwithrifampicin,isoniazidand pyraz-inamidewasadoptedinBraziluntil2009.From2010on,the drugregimencontainingrifampicin,isoniazid,pyrazinamide, andethambutolwasadopted.Alternativetherapyis recom-mendedforpatientswithliverdiseasesoraminotransferases abnormalities,includingstreptomycin,ofloxacin,and etham-butol(SOE).2
ThestandardtherapyforchronichepatitisChaschanged significantlyduringtheyears.Initiallypatientsweretreated with conventional interferon. When pegylated interferon becameavailablepatientshadamoreconvenientand effec-tivetherapy withaduration of24–48 weeksdependingon the hepatitisC virus (HCV) genotype and fibrosis stage.In specialsituationssuchasend-stagerenaldisease(ESRD) iso-latedIFNwasrecommendedduetothehighriskofhemolytic anemiainducedbyribavirin.Thisassociationofdrugscould alsoleadtoarelativeimmunosuppression.Nowadaysseveral directactingantiviraldrugs(DAA)areavailablewithhighcure rates,shorterdurationoftreatment,andfeweradverseevents. EveninthisneweraofCHCtreatment,IFNwillstillbeused insomesituationssuchasgenotype3infectionandrescue therapyfornon-responders.3
HepatitisCpatientstreatedwith␣-interferon(␣-IFN)and ribavirinarenotyetcharacterizedasamoresusceptiblegroup fordevelopingTb,althoughitisalreadyknownthatthereis anincreaseonhepatitisCprevalenceamongTbpatientswhen comparedtothegeneralpopulation.4Indeed,some
epidemio-logicalriskscenariosarecoincidentforbothdiseases,suchas incarceration,homelessness,anddrugaddiction.1Otherrisk
factorsforTbsuchasundernourishmentandrelative immun-odepressioncanalsobeinducedby␣-IFN-basedhepatitisC treatment.5
Totheextentofourknowledge,atleast16Tbcasesduring orsoonafterinterferon-basedhepatitisCtherapyinnon-HIV patients were reported in15 articles so far,some ofthem describingsevereoutcomesoftuberculosisreactivation.6–15
Theaimofthepresentstudy wastoanalyze18casesof TbobservedinreferencecentersforhepatitisCtreatmentin Brazil,countrywithahighprevalenceofTbandanexpressive numberofhepatitisCcarriers(2–3millionpeople).3
We retrospectively analyzed the records of all treated patients for hepatitis C which were seen monthly during
therapyandidentified,basedonthesignsandsymptoms,the occurrenceofTbcasesundervariousclinicalpresentations inpatientssubmittedto␣-IFN-basedtherapyforhepatitisC (pegylatedornot).
Patientswereevaluatedbetween2001and2012,infour ref-erencecentersinBrazil(twoinSaoPaulo,oneinRiodeJaneiro andoneinMaranhaowherethepeakofincidenceof tubercu-losisduringthisperiodwas43.7/100,000in2001,93.9/100,000 in 2001and 47/100,000 in2002, respectively).16 Cases were
consideredrelatedtohepatitisCtreatmentwhendiagnosed duringorwithinsixmonthsaftertheendoftreatment.
Oncethecaseshadbeenidentified,theirmedicalrecords werereviewedtoobtainepidemiological,clinical,laboratory, andtherapeuticcharacteristicsrelatedtohepatitisCandTb andthedataaboutthedecisiontointerrupttreatment.This decisionwasmadebyclinicaljudgmentbasedontheseverity ofthedisease.
This study reports secondary data from a main study approvedbytheEthicsCommitteeforClinicalResearchofthe mainstudycenter.
Weidentified18casesofTbinourstudy,withanincidence rateof809cases/100,000treatedpatients.
Themajorityofpatientsweremale(78%),withameanage of49±10years;15patients(83%)hadsignificantliverfibrosis, including six(33%)withcirrhosis; HCVgenotype1wasthe mostfrequent(78%).ThemeantimeunderhepatitisC treat-mentuntiltheonsetofTbsymptomswas33±15weeks.The meanhemoglobinlevelonTbdiagnosiswas12.1±4.2g/dLand themeanofneutrophilcountswas3596±1938cells/mm3.
Most patients were treated for hepatitis C with double therapy, including ␣-IFN (pegylatedor not) associatedwith ribavirin(89%).Thetreatmentwasdiscontinuedearlyin67% ofcasesbecauseofTbonset.Inanintentiontotreatapproach, onlysixpatients(33%)achievedsustainedvirologicalresponse (SVR),whilefiverelapsed(RR),andtheremainingwere non-responders(NR).
At least nine patients (50%) had other risk factors for Tb development(diabetesmellitus,chronic kidney disease, tobaccosmoking,oralcoholintake).BothDiabetesmellitusand chronickidneydiseasecoexistedin17%ofTbcases. Cirrho-siswaspresentin33%ofcases.Themostfrequentclinical presentationwaspulmonaryTb,in50%ofcases,withhalfof patientsdevelopingextra-pulmonaryTb.Onlyoneofcirrhotic patientshadextra-pulmonaryTb(pleuraleffusion) concomi-tantlytopulmonarydisease.
Symptoms and signsofTb usuallyappearedduringthe thirdandfourthtrimestersoftreatment(83%ofcases).Three patients presented Tb afterconcluding ␣-IFN therapy (two afterthreeandoneaftersixmonthsoftheendoftreatment). DetailsoftreatmentforhepatitisCandTbare shownin
Table1andclinicalpresentationofTbinTable2.Ninepatients were treated with the association of rifampicin, isoniazid andpyrazinamide,adoptedinBraziluntil2009forTb treat-ment.From2010on,thedrugregimencontainingrifampicin, isoniazid,pyrazinamide,andethambutolwasadopted,what explainsitspredominanceinthefourcasesidentifiedbetween 2010and2012.
The18Tbcasesreportedinthisstudyrisethepossibility ofahigherriskforinfection inpatientsunder␣-IFN-based therapyforhepatitisC.
Table1–Clinical/epidemiologicalcharacteristicsofpatientswhodevelopedtuberculosisduringorsoonafterhepatitisC treatment.
Case Gender Age (years) Liver fibrosis (METAVIR) Genotype Therapeutic regimenfor hepatitisC Outcomeof hepatitisC Riskfactors forTba Drug regimen forTb Outcomeof Tb
1 Mb 50 2 1 IFNpeg2bc/RBVd SVRe RHZEf,g,h,i Curewithout
sequelae
2 M 59 2 1 IFNpeg2aj/RBV Death DMk,
former smoker
RHZE Death
3 Fl 58 2 1 IFNpeg2b/RBV SVR RHZE Curewithsequelae–
ventriculoperitoneal shunt 4 M 40 4 3 IFNm/RBV NRn Previous Pulmonary Tb,former DAo
SOEp,q,i Curewithout sequelae
5 M 52 1 1 IFN NR CKDr,
smoker
S,Ets,E,Z Curewithout sequelae
6 M 66 4 1 IFNpeg2a/RBV NR RHZ/SOE Curewithout
sequelae
7 F 50 3 1 IFNpeg2b/RBV RRt RHZ/SOE Curewithout
sequelae
8 M 65 4 1 IFNpeg2a/RBV SVR SOE Curewithout
sequelae
9 F 52 1 1 IFNpeg2a/RBV RR RHZ Curewithout
sequelae
10 M 44 4 3 IFNpeg2b/RBV RR Alcohol
intake
RHZ Curewithout
sequelae
11 M 52 2 3 IFN/RBV NR DM RHZ Curewithout
sequelae
12 M 28 1 1 IFNalone RR CKD RHZE Curewithout
sequelae
13 M 40 2 1 IFNpeg2aalone RR CKD RHZ Curewithout
sequelae
14 F 55 4 1 IFN/RBV NR DM RHZ/SOE Curewithout
sequelae
15 M 53 4 1 IFN/RBV SVR RHE Curewithout
sequelae
16 M 41 2 1 IFNpeg2b/RBV NR AIu,former
DA
RHZE Curewithout sequelae
17 M 32 2 3 IFNpeg2b/RBV SVR RHZ Curewithout
sequelae
18 M 47 2 1 IFNpeg2a/RBV SVR RHZ Curewithout
sequelae
a Tuberculosis. b Male.
c Pegylated␣-interferon2b. d Ribavirin.
e Sustainedvirologicalresponse. f Rifampicin.
g Isoniazid. h Pyrazinamide.
i Ethambutol.
j Pegylated␣-interferon2a. k Diabetesmellitus. l Female. m Standard␣-interferon. n Non-responder. o Drugaddict. p Streptomycin. q Ofloxacin.
r Chronickidneydisease. s Ethionamide.
t Responseandrelapse. u Alcoholintake.
Table2–Clinicalaspectsanddiagnosticmethodsoftuberculosiscases.
Case Symptomsandsigns Damagedorgans Diagnosticmethods
1 Fever,axillarylymphadenopathy, asthenia,myalgia
Lymphnode Lymphnodebiopsy
2 Fever,diarrhea,asthenia,nightsweats, nausea,gaitdisorder
Disseminated Bonemarrowbiopsy
3 Arthralgia,irritability,transientcognitive deficit
Centralnervoussystem Cerebrospinalfluidexamination
4 Fever,cough,chills,bronchospasm Lungs Chestradiography,positivesputum
smearmicroscopy
5 Fever,cough Lymphnode Lymphnodebiopsy
6 Fever,cough,fatigue,weightloss,anemia, leukopenia,thrombocytopenia,
hemoptysis
Lungs Symptomsandpositivetuberculin
skintest 7 Fever,cough,asthenia,anorexia,myalgia,
arthralgia,weightloss,anemia, leukopenia
Lungs Positivesputumsmearmicroscopy
8 Cough,asthenia,anemia,leukopenia Lungs Positivesputumsmearmicroscopy
9 Fever,weightloss,lossofappetite, asthenia,nightsweats,chestpain, anemia,leukopenia
Lungs ChestradiographyandCTa
10 Fever,cough,weightloss,dyspnea,chest pain
Pleuraandlungs Pleuralfluidexamination,ChestCT
11 Fever,cough,weightloss Lungs Chestradiography
12 Thoracolumbarpain Spine SpineCT–Pott’sdisease
13 Ascites,weightloss Peritoneum Ascitesfluidexamination
14 Fever,cough Lungs Chestradiography
15 Leftwristpain Bone/joint Histopathology
16 Nightsweats Lungs Positivesputumsmearmicroscopy
17 Cough Lungsandrelapseinlymph
node
Positivesputumsmearmicroscopy
18 Fever,cough,chestpain Pleuraandlungs Chestradiography,pleuralfluid
examination
a Computerizedtomography.
In a population-based study conducted in Taiwan, an endemicTbarea,Linetal.,2014studiedtheincidencerates ofactivetuberculosisinHCV-infectedpatientswith(n=621) or without (n=2460) interferon-based therapy (IBT). They observedanon statisticallysignificant increasedhazard of activeTbinHCVinfectedpatientsonIBTinone-year follow-up.17 Moreover,theymentionthatthe investigatorshadno
accesstootherimportantTbriskfactors,detailedlaboratory results,andmedicationrecords.Theyalsoconsiderthatsome patientscouldhavediedbeforebeingregisteredintheHealth InsuranceResearch DatabaseduetoTb infection ortaking medicationsforthatcondition,underestimatingthenumber ofcases.Themagnitudeof809cases/100,000treatedpatients ismoreimpressivewhenthedataarecomparedtothe inci-denceofTbcasesinthe Brazilianpopulationin 2013(35.4 cases/100,000inhabitants).Othergroups,traditionallya pri-ority forTb control,suchastheindigenous people, havea lowerincidence(94.5cases/100,000 inhabitants)when com-paredtoourreport.1Ontheotherhand,comparableincidence
rates had been described in renal transplant patients: 803 cases/100,000patients.18
Most patients were male within the age group of higher prevalence of Tb in Brazil.1 Diabetes mellitus and
chronickidneydisease coexistedinlessthan 20%ofcases, comorbidities widely known to increase the risk of active tuberculosis.19Cirrhosis,alsoblamedasariskfactorforTb,20
waspresentinonethirdofcases.Halfofthecaseswere extra-pulmonary tuberculosis, more compatible with a situation of immunosuppression, since in non-immunosuppressed subjects only 15–20% of extra-pulmonary forms are expected.21
WeobservedahighdiscontinuationrateofIBTduetothe onsetofTb;onethirdofpatientsachievedSVR.Oncasetwo, theacuteonsetofTbsymptomsandsevereandfataloutcome ofthediseaseinlessthan60days,bringthepossibilityof bac-teremiaandsepsiscausedbyM.tuberculosisinanearlyphase ofinfection.15
Onthepreviouscasereportstheauthorsdiscussedmany mechanisms ofassociation between hepatitis C treatment andTbreactivation.TheysuggestedthatIFNcaninducean impairmentoftheearlyimmuneresponseagainstM. tuber-culosis,specificallyobservedonseverecases,besidestherole ofleukopenia,neutropenia,aloweringonT-CD4+lymphocyte populationandabnormalitiesonchemotaxisandphagocytic functionsofmacrophages5,8,10,11,15.
Wewouldliketoemphasizethatmanystudieshadalready showed that ␣- and -IFN inhibit typeI immuneresponse whichischaracterizedbylL-12,␥-IFNandTNF-␣production, cytokinesthat restrainM. tuberculosis.Thisinhibitioncould leadtoLTBIreactivation,22asoccurredonmostcasesreported
here, includingthe threecasesinwhichTb appearedafter stoppinghepatitisCtreatment.Weconsiderthattherewasa
residualimmuneeffectof␣-IFNthatcanlastuntil16weeks afterthelastdoseadministered.
Insummary,consideringtheevidencesof␣-IFN interfer-enceovertheconstrainmentmechanismsofM.tuberculosis,
theimmune impairmentofcirrhotic patients, theincrease ofTb casereports duringhepatitisC treatment, as inthis expressiveretrospectivestudy,withatypicalandsevere pre-sentations,andthe negativeimpactonSVR,we thinkthat thesearestrongargumentsforLTBIscreeningbytuberculin skintestand/orbyinterferongammareleasingassays,before starting␣-IFN-basedtherapy. Thisis evenmore important incountrieswithhighTbincidenceandinmoresusceptible populationsinwhichepidemiologicaldeterminantsofboth diseases cancoexist and interact.Inthese mediumorlow incomecountriestheuseof␣-IFN-basedtherapywillstill per-sistforsometimebeforeitispossibletoextendtheuseof direct-actingantivirals(DAA)forhepatitisC.DAAshouldbe consideredifapatient testspositiveforLTBI. Furthermore, eveninthedirectactiveantiviralsera,theinclusionofpatients in the treatment of hepatitisC is anopportunity forLTBI screening.
Conflicts
of
interest
Theauthorsdeclarenoconflictsofinterest.
r
e
f
e
r
e
n
c
e
s
1. Brasil.MinistériodaSaúde.SecretariadeVigilânciaem Saúde.BoletimEpidemiológico.Ocontroledatuberculoseno Brasil:avanc¸os,inovac¸õesedesafios;2014.
2. Brasil.MinistériodaSaúde.SecretariadeVigilânciaem Saúde.DepartamentodevigilânciaEpidemiológica.Manual deRecomendac¸õesparaocontroledatuberculoseno Brasil/MinistériodaSaúde,SecretariadeVigilânciaemSaúde. Brasília:DepartamentodevigilânciaEpidemiológica;2011.
3. Brasil.MinistériodaSaúde.SecretariadeVigilânciaem Saúde.DepartamentodeDSTAidseHepatitesVirais. ProtocoloclínicoeDiretrizesTerapêuticasparaHepatiteCe Coinfecc¸ões/MinistériodaSaúde,Secretariadevigilânciaem Saúde,DepartamentodeDST,AidseHepatitesVirais.Brasília: MinistériodaSaúde;2015.
4. WuP-H,LinY-T,HsiehK-P,ChuangH-Y,SheuC-C.HepatitisC virusinfectionisassociatedwithanincreasedriskofactive tuberculosisdisease:anationwidepopulation-basedstudy. Medicine.2015;94(33):e1328.
5. PuotiM,BabudieriS,RezzaG,etal.Useofpegylated interferonsisassociatedwithanincreasedincidenceof infectionsduringcombinationtreatmentofchronichepatitis C:asideeffectofpegylation?AntivirTher.2004;9(4):627–30.
6. FerreiraCN,BarjasER,CorreiaLA,etal.Generalized peripherallymphadenopathyinapatienttreatedforchronic HCVinfection.NatClinPractGastroenterolHepatol. 2008;5(8):469–74.
7.TsaiM-C,LinM-C,HungC-H.Successfulantiviral antituberculosistreatmentwithpegylatedinterferon-alfa andribavirininachronichepatitisCpatientwith pulmonarytuberculosis.JFormosMedAssoc.2009;108(9): 746–50.
8.BelkahlaN,KchirH,MaamouriN,etal.Reactivationof tuberculosisduringdualtherapywithpegylatedinterferon andribavirinforchronichepatitisC.RevMedIntern. 2010;31(11):e1–3.
9.VelascoJ,GonzálezS.Tuberculouslymphadenitisafter successfultreatmentofhepatitisC.EnfermInfeccMicrob Clin.2011;29:8.
10.BabudieriS,SodduA,MurinoM,etal.Tuberculosisscreening beforeanti-hepatitisCvirustherapyinprisons.EmergInfect Dis.2012;18(4):689–91.
11.LeeS,AttenMJ,AttarB.Esophagealtuberculosisduring treatmentofhepatitisC.ClinGastroenterolHepatol. 2013;11(12):A27.
12.SaitouY,HataziO,AonumaH,OguraS,YamamotoN, KobayashiT.Pulmonarytuberculomainapatientwith chronichepatitisC:aclinicalpitfallinthetreatmentstrategy. InternMed(Tokyo,Japan).2014;53(15):1669–74.
13.Rodrigues-MartínL,LinaresTorresP,AparicioCabezudoM, etal.Reactivationofpulmonarytuberculosisduring treatmentwithtripletherapyforhepatitisC.Gastroenterol Hepatol.2015.
14.FukubaR,KawarataniH,KuboT,etal.Tuberculousperitonitis duringpegylatedinterferonplusribavirincombination therapyinapatientwithchronichepatitisC.Nippon ShokakibyoGakkaiZasshi.2014;111(12):2337–45.
15.HametnerS,MonticelliF,KernJM,SchoflR,ZiachehabiA, MaieronA.TuberculoussepsisduringantiviralHCVtriple therapy.JHepatol.2013;59(3):637–8.
16.Brasil.MinistériodaSaúde.SecretariadeVigilânciaem Saúde.ProgramaNacionaldeControledaTuberculose.Série históricadataxadeincidênciadetuberculose.Brasil,regiões eunidadesfederadasderesidênciaporanodediagnóstico (1990a2014);2015.Availablefrom:http://portalsaude. saude.gov.br/images/pdf/2015/setembro/24/taxa-incid–ncia-tuberculose-1999-2014-base-JUN-2015.pdf[cited30.11.15] [Internet].
17.LinS,ChenT,LuP,etal.Incidenceratesoftuberculosisin chronichepatitisCinfectedpatientswithorwithout interferonbasedtherapy:apopulation-basedcohortstudyin Taiwan.BMCInfectDis.2014;14(1):705.
18.MarquesID,AzevedoLS,PierrottiLC,etal.Clinicalfeatures andoutcomesoftuberculosisinkidneytransplantrecipients inBrazil:areportofthelastdecade.ClinTranspl.
2013;27(2):E169–76.
19.SantinCerezalesM,NavasElorzaE.Tuberculosisinspecial populations.EnfermInfeccMicrobClin.2011;29Suppl.1: 20–5.
20.LinYT,WuPH,LinCY,etal.Cirrhosisasariskfactorfor tuberculosisinfection–anationwidelongitudinalstudyin Taiwan.AmJEpidemiol.2014;180(1):8.
21.SharmaSK,MohanA.Extrapulmonarytuberculosis.IndianJ MedRes.2004;120(4):316–53.
22.dePausRA,vanWengenA,SchmidtI,etal.Inhibitionofthe typeIimmuneresponsesofhumanmonocytesbyIFN-alpha andIFN-beta.Cytokine.2013;61(2):645–55.