ÍNDICE DE ECOEFICIÊNCIA E A REGRESSÃO TOBIT: UMA ANÁLISE ENTRE OS
ANOS DE 1991 A 2012
Ecoeficiency index and the tobit regression: an analysis between the years from
1991 to 2012
Harine Matos Maciel
Economista. Doutora em Desenvolvimento e Meio Ambiente (UFC). Professora do Instituto Federal de Educação, Ciência e Tecnologia - IFCE. harinematos@yahoo.com.br
Ahmad Saeed Khan
Engenheiro Agrônomo. Ph.D em Economia Agrícola e Recursos Naturais pela Oregon State University, EUA. Professor do Prodema/UFC e do Mestrado em Economia Rural da UFC. saeed@ufc.br
Leonardo Andrade Rocha
Economista. Doutor em Desenvolvimento Econômico pelo Instituto de Economia da Universidade Estadual de Campinas. Professor do Programa de Pós-Graduação em Ambiente, Tecnologia e Sociedade,
da Universidade Federal Rural do Semiárido. leonardoandrocha@yahoo.com.br
Resumo:2REMHWLYRGHVWDSHVTXLVDIRLFDOFXODURËQGL
-FHGH(FRH¿FLrQFLD,(SDUDSDtVHVDWUDYpVGRPp
-WRGRFree Disposal Hull)'+HDHVWLPDomRGHXPD
5HJUHVVmR7RELWD¿PGHGHWHUPLQDUDVYDULiYHLVH[SOL
-FDWLYDVTXHWLYHUDPPDLRULPSDFWRQR,(9HUL¿FRXVH TXHRYDORUGDHFRH¿FLrQFLDPpGLDGLPLQXLX1DFODVVL
-¿FDomRHPUHODomRDR,(HPWRGRVRVDQRVR,(PXLWR EDL[RREWHYHRPDLRUQ~PHURGHSDtVHVHRFRQWLQHQWH SUHGRPLQDQWH IRL D ÈVLD 'DV YDULiYHLV H[SOLFDWLYDV XWLOL]DGDVQRPRGHORGHUHJUHVVmRD)RUPDomR%UXWD GH&DSLWDO)L[R&RQVXPRGH&RPEXVWtYHLV)yVVHLVH 5HQGDVGH&DUYmRPRVWUDUDPTXHSRVVXHPXPHIHLWR QHJDWLYRVREUHRHVFRUHGHHFRH¿FLrQFLDHQTXDQWRDV YDULiYHLV7D[DGH$OIDEHWL]DomRGH$GXOWRVH4XDOLGDGH GR*RYHUQRJHUDPXPHIHLWRSRVLWLYR(VWHVUHVXOWDGRV PRVWUDPTXHDOJXQVSDtVHVSDVVDUDPDDVVXPLUUHVSRQ
-VDELOLGDGHFRPRVDVVXQWRVUHODWLYRVDRPHLRDPELHQWH HQWUHWDQWR LQVX¿FLHQWHV SDUD WUDQVIRUPDU D UHDOLGDGH DWXDOPRVWUDQGRTXHpQHFHVViULRDDPSOLDomRGRFR
-QKHFLPHQWRDFHUFDGRDVVXQWRSDUDSURSRUPHOKRUHVDO
-WHUQDWLYDVJOREDLVHORFDLVQDEXVFDSDUDVHDOFDQoDUD VXVWHQWDELOLGDGHWmRQHFHVViULDHXUJHQWHSDUDDVIXWXUDV JHUDo}HV
Palavras-chave: (FRH¿FLrQFLD UHFXUVRV QDWXUDLV GH
-VHQYROYLPHQWRSUHVHUYDomR
Abstract: 7KHREMHFWLYHRIWKLVUHVHDUFKZDVWRFDOFXOD
-WHWKH(FR(I¿FLHQF\,QGH[(,IRUFRXQWULHVXVLQJ WKH)UHH'LVSRVDO+XOO)'+PHWKRGDQGWKHHVWLPD
-WLRQRID7RELW5HJUHVVLRQLQRUGHUWRGHWHUPLQHWKHH[
-SODQDWRU\YDULDEOHVWKDWKDGWKHJUHDWHVWLPSDFWRQ,(,W ZDVIRXQGWKDWWKHYDOXHRIWKHDYHUDJHHFRHI¿FLHQF\ GHFUHDVHG,QWKH,(FODVVL¿FDWLRQLQDOO\HDUVYHU\ORZ ,(ZDVWKHODUJHVWQXPEHURIFRXQWULHVDQGWKHSUHGR
-PLQDQWFRQWLQHQWZDV$VLD)URPWKHH[SODQDWRU\YD
-ULDEOHVXVHGLQWKHUHJUHVVLRQPRGHOWKH*URVV)RUPD
-WLRQRI)L[HG&DSLWDO&RQVXPSWLRQRI)RVVLO)XHOVDQG &RDO5HQWVVKRZHGWKDWWKH\KDYHDQHJDWLYHHIIHFWRQ WKHHFRHI¿FLHQF\VFRUHZKLOHWKH$GXOW/LWHUDF\5DWH DQG*RYHUQPHQW4XDOLW\YDULDEOHVJHQHUDWHDSRVLWLYH HIIHFW7KHVHUHVXOWVVKRZWKDWVRPHFRXQWULHVKDYHDV
-VXPHGUHVSRQVLELOLW\IRUHQYLURQPHQWDOLVVXHVEXWWKH\ DUHLQVXI¿FLHQWWRWUDQVIRUPWKHFXUUHQWUHDOLW\VKRZLQJ WKDWLWLVQHFHVVDU\WRLQFUHDVHWKHNQRZOHGJHDERXWWKH VXEMHFWWRSURSRVHEHWWHUJOREDODQGORFDODOWHUQDWLYHV LQWKHVHDUFKWRUHDFKVXVWDLQDELOLW\LVVRQHFHVVDU\DQG XUJHQWIRUIXWXUHJHQHUDWLRQV
Keywords: (FRHI¿FLHQF\1DWXUDO5HVRXUFHV'HYHOR
1 INTRODUÇÃO
2FRQFHLWRGHFUHVFLPHQWRHFRQ{PLFRHVWHYH KLVWRULFDPHQWHUHODFLRQDGRDXPDXPHQWRGRVQt
-YHLVGHFRQVXPRRTXHDFDUUHWRXSUHVV}HVVREUHR PHLRDPELHQWHHRVUHFXUVRVTXHRIHUHFHPVXSRUWH jDWLYLGDGHKXPDQD
$SyVDVJUDQGHV*XHUUDV0XQGLDLVDVGH¿QL
-o}HVGHFUHVFLPHQWRHFRQ{PLFRHQYROYLDPDERU
-GDJHQVGLVWLQWDVLQFOXLQGRRSURJUHVVRHFRQ{PLFR DUHYROXomRFLHQWt¿FDHWHFQROyJLFDDRUJDQL]DomR HDJHVWmRGRWUDEDOKRHRVUHFXUVRVQDWXUDLVFRQ
-IRUPH/XSDQH&R]RULFLHUDPYLVWRVFRPR PHUFDGRULDVOLYUHVFRPFXVWR]HURHHPTXDQWLGD
-GHVLOLPLWDGDV
$VLQRYDo}HVHRVDYDQoRVWHFQROyJLFRVTXHVH VHJXLUDPOHYDUDPRVSDtVHVLQGXVWULDOL]DGRVSULQFL
-SDOPHQWHDFRQVLGHUDUHPDPHGLomRGRFUHVFLPHQ
-WRHFRQ{PLFRHPWHUPRVGH3URGXWR,QWHUQR%UXWR 3,%HQWUDQGRQRTXH/XSDQH&R]RULFLGH
-QRPLQDPGHD³SULVmRGRFUHVFLPHQWR´XPDYH]TXH DFDGDGLDRDXPHQWRGDSURGXomRHGRFRQVXPR GHWHUPLQDYDPDLRUSURJUHVVRHFRQ{PLFRDLQGDTXH FRPRFRPSURPHWLPHQWRGRVUHFXUVRVQDWXUDLV
1DDEHUWXUDGD&RQIHUrQFLDGD³Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development ±
2(&'´HPHP5RPDR0LQLVWURGR0HLR $PELHQWH(GR5RQFKL2(&'GHVWDFD
>@$SURGXomRHRPRGHORGHFRQVXPRGRVpFXOR ;;MiQmRVHUiFDSD]GHFRQWLQXDUHVHH[SDQGLU QRSUy[LPRVpFXORSRUTXHQmRpVXVWHQWiYHOHKi XPULVFRUHDOGHJUDYHVFULVHVDPELHQWDLVJOREDLV FRPJUDQGHVFRQVHTXrQFLDVHFRQ{PLFDVHVRFLDLV 3DUDH[HPSOL¿FDUVXDVSUHRFXSDo}HV5RQFKLD¿U -PD ³QR VpFXOR ;; D SRSXODomR PXQGLDO OHYRX DSHQDVDQRVSDUDTXDGUXSOLFDU2FUHVFLPHQWR H[SRQHQFLDOGDSRSXODomRPXQGLDOIRLDFRPSD -QKDGR GH XP YLJRURVR FUHVFLPHQWR HFRQ{PLFR QRTXDODSURGXomRDQXDOGRPXQGRHVWLPDGDHP WULOK}HV GH GyODUHV QR LQtFLR GR VpFXOR ;; VXELXSDUDWULOK}HVGHGyODUHVSRUDQR%DVWRX VRPHQWH XP VpFXOR SDUD TXH D SURGXomR WHQKD FUHVFLGRDXPIDWRUGHRXVHMDYH]HVPDLV UiSLGRGRTXHDSRSXODomR2LQWHQVRFUHVFLPHQWR HFRQ{PLFREDVHRXVHQDH[SORUDomRGHFRPEXVWt -YHLVIyVVHLVFXMRFRQVXPRDXPHQWRXGHPL -OK}HVGHWRQHODGDVHTXLYDOHQWHVGHSHWUyOHRSDUD ELOK}HVGHWRQHODGDV$VHPLVV}HVPXQGLDLV GHGLy[LGRGHFDUERQR&2VXELUDPGHEL
-OK}HVGHWRQHODGDVHPSDUDELOK}HVGH WRQHODGDVHP´
$ SDUWLU GD GpFDGD GH DV SUHRFXSDo}HV FRPDVTXHVW}HVDPELHQWDLVUHWRPDPRFHQiULRLQ
-WHUQDFLRQDOHSDUD/XSDQH&R]RULDLGHLD GDGLVVRFLDomRHQWUHRFUHVFLPHQWRHRPHLRDP
-ELHQWH SDVVD D VHU UHFRQKHFLGD DLQGD TXH VHMDP QHFHVViULRV DOWHUDU RV FRQFHLWRV H YDORUHV DWXDLV WUDQVIRUPDQGRDVHVWUXWXUDVFRPRREMHWLYRGHUH
-DORFDUDHFRQRPLDHDYLGDLPSRQGRXPDPRGL¿
-FDomRSURIXQGDGRFRQVXPRGHEHQVFRPRIRUPD GHFRQVWUXLUXPDVRFLHGDGHVXVWHQWiYHO
3DUDHVVHVDXWRUHVXPGRVFRQFHLWRVTXHLQFRU
-SRUDPHVVHVIDWRUHVpRGHHFRH¿FLrQFLDTXHWHP UDt]HVQRFRQFHLWRGHGHVHQYROYLPHQWRVXVWHQWiYHO HVHXREMHWLYRSULPRUGLDOpRXVRVXVWHQWiYHOGRV UHFXUVRV2XWURVHVWXGLRVRV.RUWHODLQHQH.XRV
-PDQHQWDPEpPFRQFRUGDPFRPHVVDLGHLD HD¿UPDPTXHRFRQFHLWRHVWiUHODFLRQDGRFRPD QRomRPDLVDEUDQJHQWHGHVXVWHQWDELOLGDGH
2FRQFHLWRGHHFRH¿FLrQFLDpXVDGRGHGLIHUHQ
-WHVIRUPDVSRLVGHSHQGHGRFRQWH[WR(QWUHWDQWR VXD GH¿QLomR FRQFUHWD H PHQVXUDomR GHSHQGHP GDLGHQWL¿FDomRGRVLQGLFDGRUHVVHOHFLRQDGRVGH DFRUGRFRPD2(&'
'HQWUHRVLQ~PHURVFRQFHLWRVGLVSRQtYHLVQDOL
-WHUDWXUDHVSHFLDOL]DGDRPDLVQRWiYHOpRGRWorld Business Council for Sustainable Development
:%&6' TXH DGRWRX D HFRH¿FLrQFLD FRPR XP FRQFHLWR~WLOHPHPVHX5HODWyULR5LR Ear-th Summit6&+0,'+(,1<HGHVFUHYHD
HFRH¿FLrQFLD FRPR XPD FRPELQDomR GD H¿FLrQ
-FLDHFRQ{PLFDHHFROyJLFD1HVVHVHQWLGRSDUDR :%&6'RGHVHQYROYLPHQWRHFRH¿FLHQWHp DOFDQoDGRDWUDYpVGDSURGXomRGHEHQVHVHUYLoRV DSUHoRVFRPSHWLWLYRVTXHVDWLVIDoDPDVQHFHVVL
-GDGHVKXPDQDVHWUDJDPTXDOLGDGHGHYLGDHDR PHVPRWHPSRUHGX]DPRLPSDFWRDPELHQWDODWp XPQtYHOSHORPHQRVLJXDOjFDSDFLGDGHGHVXVWHQ
-WDELOLGDGHGRUHFXUVRGDGDSHORSODQHWD7HUUD 3DUD.RUWHODLQHQH.XRVPDQHQH[LVWH XP DUJXPHQWR SUiWLFR HP IDYRU GD HFRH¿FLrQFLD MiTXHDGH¿QLomRpFODUDHLQWXLWLYDHPQtWLGRFRQ
-WUDVWH FRP R FRQFHLWR PXLWR YDJDPHQWH GH¿QLGR GHVXVWHQWDELOLGDGH3DUDHVVHVHVWXGLRVRVDHFR
-H¿FLrQFLDUHIHUHVHjFDSDFLGDGHGHSURGX]LUEHQV HVHUYLoRVVHPSROXLURPHLRDPELHQWHHXVDQGR RPtQLPRSRVVtYHOGHHQHUJLDHUHFXUVRVQDWXUDLV
7RGDYLD D FRPSOH[LGDGH GR FRQFHLWR 81,
-7('1$7,216PDVWDPEpPDSRVVLELOL
OHYRXDWUDQVIRUPDomRGDHFRH¿FLrQFLDGHXPDQR
-omRWHyULFDSXUDHPXPD¿ORVR¿DGHJHVWmR $ HFRH¿FLrQFLD GHVWDFD D 8QLWHG 1DWLRQV H[HUFHXPSDSHOLPSRUWDQWHDRH[SUHVVDUR TXmRH¿FLHQWHpDDWLYLGDGHHFRQ{PLFDQRTXHGL] UHVSHLWRDEHQVHVHUYLoRVGDQDWXUH]DHDWXDFRPR XPLQVWUXPHQWRTXHHVWiGLVSRQtYHOSDUDHPSUHVDV H(VWDGRV0HPEURVD¿PGHUHGX]LUDVXDSHJDGD HFROyJLFDHWRUQDUVHPDLVUHVSRQViYHOSDUDFRPR DPELHQWHHDVRFLHGDGH
$FHOHEUDomRGR3URWRFRORGH4XLRWRHP QD &RQYHQomR4XDGUR GDV 1Do}HV 8QLGDV VREUH 0XGDQoDVFOLPiWLFDV81)&&UHDOL]DGDHP4XLR
-WRQR-DSmRWURX[HSDUDRVSDtVHVVLJQDWiULRVGR DFRUGRRFRPSURPLVVRGHUHGX]LUHPVXDVHPLVV}HV GHJDVHVGHHIHLWRHVWXIDQDDWPRVIHUDHRDTXHFL
-PHQWRJOREDO$WXDOPHQWHGRVSDtVHVPHPEURV GD81)&&UDWL¿FDUDPRDFRUGRRXVHMDHOHV VHFRPSURPHWHUDPDDVVXPLUDVREULJDo}HVOHJDLV WRUQDQGRR3URWRFRORH¿FD]HQWUHRVSDUWLFLSDQWHV
1HVVHVHQWLGRDHFRH¿FLrQFLDHPQtYHOPDFUR
-HFRQ{PLFRDVVXPHUHOHYkQFLDDRSRGHUFRQWULEXLU SDUDUHYHODUHLQIRUPDURVGHFLVRUHVVREUHDH¿FL
-rQFLDHFRQ{PLFDHDPELHQWDOGHVHXVSDtVHVHVH VmRQHFHVViULDVLQWURGX]LURXDOWHUDUQRYDVSROtWL
-FDVDPELHQWDLV
$RUHXQLULQGLFDGRUHVHFRQ{PLFRVHDPELHQWDLV jHFRH¿FLrQFLDSRGHVHUHVSRQGHURXSHORPHQRV LOXPLQDU RV HVWXGLRVRV VREUH D VXVWHQWDELOLGDGH GHVVHVSDtVHV
5DWL¿FDQGRDLPSRUWkQFLDGDPHGLomRGDHFRH¿
-FLrQFLD.RUWHODLQHQH.XRVPDQHQGHVWDFDP TXH HVVH SURFHGLPHQWR p FULWLFDPHQWH LPSRUWDQWH SHOR PHQRV SRU GRLV PRWLYRV D PHOKRULD GD HFRH¿FLrQFLDPXLWDVYH]HVpDPDQHLUDPDLVHFR
-Q{PLFDGHUHGX]LUDVSUHVV}HVDPELHQWDLV0HVPR TXHDPHOKRULDGDH¿FLrQFLDFRPRWDOQHPVHPSUH VHMDVX¿FLHQWHSDUDDOFDQoDUXPQtYHOVXVWHQWiYHOGH SUHVVmRDPELHQWDOID]VHQWLGRHFRQ{PLFRH[SORUDU HVVDVRSo}HVWDQWRTXDQWRSRVVtYHODVSROtWLFDV SDUDPHOKRUDUDHFRH¿FLrQFLDWHQGHPDVHUPDLVIi
-FLOGHMXVWL¿FDUGRTXHDVSROtWLFDVTXHUHVWULQJHPR QtYHOGHDWLYLGDGHHFRQ{PLFD2VDXWRUHVUHIRUoDP DLQGDTXHDVPHGLGDVGHHFRH¿FLrQFLDVmRLQIRUPD
-o}HVQHFHVViULDVSDUDDWRPDGDGHGHFLV}HV 2VHVWXGRVVREUHDHFRH¿FLrQFLDDLQGDVmRSRX
-FRGLVVHPLQDGRVQDOLWHUDWXUDHVSHFLDOL]DGDRTXH VyUHIRUoDDMXVWL¿FDWLYDSDUDHVWHHVWXGRFXMRRE
-MHWLYRpDQDOLVDUDHFRH¿FLrQFLDGHSDtVHVGLV
-WULEXtGRVQRVFLQFRFRQWLQHQWHVQRSHUtRGRHQWUH
D(VSHFL¿FRXVHXPPRGHORGHIURQ
-WHLUDHVWRFiVWLFDFRPYDULiYHLVHFRQ{PLFDVHDP
-ELHQWDLV XWLOL]DQGR D PHWRGRORJLDFree Disposal Hull )'+ ( WDPEpP HVWLPRXVH XPD 5HJUHV
-VmR7RELWSDUDDQDOLVDUTXDLVYDULiYHLVSRVVXHPR PDLRUSRGHUGHH[SOLFDomRGDHFRH¿FLrQFLD
(VSHUDVHTXHDHFRH¿FLrQFLDVHMDPDLRUTXDQ
-GRDVHPLVV}HVGRVJDVHVGRHIHLWRHVWXIDGLPLQXt
-UHPSDUDRPHVPRYDORUGR3URGXWR,QWHUQR%UXWR $OpPGLVVRHVWHHVWXGRSRGHUHVSRQGHUDTXHVW}HV FRPRDHFRH¿FLrQFLDGRVSDtVHVPHOKRURXGHVGHR LQtFLRGRVDQRVGH"2VSDtVHVGHVHQYROYLGRV DOFDQoDUDPPHOKRUHVUHVXOWDGRVTXHRVSDtVHVHP GHVHQYROYLPHQWRHRVSDtVHVSREUHV"6HDVVLPIRU TXDLVRVSRVVtYHLVPRWLYRVGHVVHVUHVXOWDGRV"
2 ECOEFICIÊNCIA
2GHVHQYROYLPHQWRVXVWHQWiYHOpXPDUHVSRQVD
-ELOLGDGHGHWRGRVRVDJHQWHVGDVRFLHGDGHHSDUDDO
-FDQoiORVmRQHFHVViULDVDo}HVFROHWLYDVSDUDSURWH
-JHURPHLRDPELHQWHEXVFDQGRRSo}HVGHSURGXomR PHQRVGDQRVDVDRVUHFXUVRVQDWXUDLV2FRQFHLWRGH HFRH¿FLrQFLDVXUJLXGHVVDQHFHVVLGDGH
$H¿FLrQFLDHVWiGLUHWDPHQWHUHODFLRQDGDjFD
-SDFLGDGHGHUHDOL]DUDWLYLGDGHVFRPDPHQRUTXDQ
-WLGDGH GH UHFXUVRV SRVVtYHLV H DR FRPELQDUPRV FRPR³HFR´TXHWUD]DLGHLDGHQDWXUH]DRXHFROR
-JLDLPSOLFDULDHPSURGX]LUPDLVHQTXDQWRHVWLYHU XVDQGRPHQRVUHFXUVRVHSURGX]LQGRPHQRVUHVt
-GXRVHSROXLomR(VWDLGHLDSDVVRXDVHUXPDHVWUD
-WpJLDGHQHJyFLRSDUDDVHPSUHVDVSRLVpDYDOLDGD HP HPSUHVDV H HFRQRPLDV PXQGLDLV QDFLRQDLV H UHJLRQDLV$HFRH¿FLrQFLDpXPGRVSDVVRVSDUDVH DOFDQoDURGHVHQYROYLPHQWRVXVWHQWiYHO
'HDFRUGRFRP(UNNRHWDODHFRH¿FL
-rQFLDFRQVLVWHQDEXVFDSHORGHVHQYROYLPHQWRVXV
-WHQWiYHOQRVQHJyFLRVFRPELQDQGRH¿FLrQFLDVHFR
-Q{PLFDVHDPELHQWDLV(VWDFRQFHSomRUHTXHUHVWHV GRLV ODGRV HFRQ{PLFR H DPELHQWDO TXH SDUHFHP RSRVWRVMiTXHGXUDQWHPXLWRVDQRVSHQVRXVHTXH RODGRDPELHQWDOSUHMXGLFDULDRVUHWRUQRV¿QDQFHL
-URVGRVQHJyFLRVHRFRQFHLWRPRVWUDTXHpSRVVtYHO WUDEDOKDUHPFRQMXQWRFRPHVVHVGRLVODGRV
$GpFDGDGHFRQVROLGRXRFRQFHLWREXVFDQ
-GRDVVLPGLPLQXLUDGLVWkQFLDHQWUHRDYDQoRHFRQ{
-PLFRHDXWLOL]DomRGRVUHFXUVRVGDQDWXUH]DPRV
GDVOHLVDPELHQWDLVPDVVHPVHLPSRUWDUFRPRPHLR DPELHQWHHVLPDSHQDVFRPRVUHWRUQRV¿QDQFHLURV 3DUD PHQVXUDU D HFRH¿FLrQFLD VmR XWLOL]DGRV LQ
-GLFDGRUHVTXHPRVWUDPFRPRDDWLYLGDGHHFRQ{PLFD VHUHODFLRQDFRPRVUHFXUVRVGDQDWXUH]DSHUPLWLQGR DQDOLVDU R GHVHPSHQKR DPELHQWDO H HFRQ{PLFR GDV DWLYLGDGHVHDVVLPFRQWULEXLUSDUDDJHVWmRDPELHQWDO
=KDQJHWDOD¿UPDPTXHDH¿FLrQFLDHFR
-Q{PLFDHDPELHQWDOpXPH[FHOHQWHLQGLFDGRUSRLV p FDSD] GH PRVWUDU D VLWXDomR GH ³win-win´ TXH
VLJQL¿FDJDQKRVSDUDDPERVHFRQRPLDHHFRORJLD 'HXPODGRDOFDQoDUPHOKRULDVQDSURGXWLYLGDGHH SRURXWURODGRUHGXomRGRLPSDFWRDPELHQWDO
$DSOLFDomRGDHFRH¿FLrQFLDWHPVHDPSOLDGRQR DX[tOLRjFULDomRGHSROtWLFDVS~EOLFDVRTXHUHIRUoD DUHOHYkQFLDGRFRQFHLWRQDPHQVXUDomRGRGHVHQ
-YROYLPHQWRVXVWHQWiYHO3DUD/HKQLDHFRH¿
-FLrQFLDpXWLOL]DGDFRPRLQGLFDGRUSDUDTXDQWL¿FDU RSURJUHVVRGHXPSDtVSDUDRGHVHQYROYLPHQWRVXV
-WHQWiYHOSRLVFDGDSDtVSRVVXLVXDVHVSHFL¿FLGDGHV HHVWDVSUHFLVDPVHUFRPSUHHQGLGDVSDUDTXHDEXV
-FDSHODHFRH¿FLrQFLDVHWRUQHSUHGRPLQDQWH&KHQ HWDOD¿UPDPTXHRJRYHUQRHPXPSDtV SRGH GHVHPSHQKDU XP SDSHO VLJQL¿FDWLYR HP DO
-FDQoDUHFRH¿FLrQFLD3RUpPQmRVyRJRYHUQRWHP HVVD REULJDomR PDV WRGD D SRSXODomR SRLV WRGRV LPSDFWDP GH IRUPD QHJDWLYD R PHLR DPELHQWH DR XVXIUXtUHPGHSURGXWRVHVHUYLoRVeQHFHVViULRTXH VHEXVTXHRHTXLOtEULRHQWUHRFRQVXPRGHVHQIUHDGR HDOLPLWDomRGRVUHFXUVRVQDWXUDLVSDUDTXHHVWHV DLQGDSRVVDPVHUXWLOL]DGRVSHODVIXWXUDVJHUDo}HV
3 METODOLOGIA
3.1 Área geográfica de estudo e fonte de dados
$SHVTXLVDDEUDQJHSDtVHVGLVWULEXtGRVHP FLQFRFRQWLQHQWHV$PpULFDÈVLDÈIULFD(XURSD H 2FHDQLD SDtVHV VHOHFLRQDGRV SHOD GLVSRQLELOL
-GDGHGHGDGRVSDUDRSHUtRGRHVWXGDGR2VGDGRV XWLOL]DGRVIRUDPGHRULJHPVHFXQGiULDSHULRGLFL
-GDGHDQXDOREWLGRVQRVLWHGR%DQFR0XQGLDOQR SHUtRGRGHD
3.2 Free Disposal Hull (FDH)
2 PRGHORFree Disposal Hull )'+ IRL GH
-VHQYROYLGRSRU'HSULQV6LPDUH7XONHQV HDDQiOLVHGHWHUPLQDXPDIURQWHLUDGDSRVVLELOLGD
-GHGHSURGXomRTXHUHSUHVHQWDDFRPELQDomRGRV PHOKRUHVUHVXOWDGRVREVHUYDGRVHPXPDDPRVWUD DOpPGHPHGLUDUHODWLYDLQH¿FLrQFLDGRVSURGXWR
-UHVGHQWURGDIURQWHLUDGHSRVVLELOLGDGHGHSURGX
-omRPHGLGDSHODGLVWkQFLDGDIURQWHLUD
6XSRQGR XPD DPRVWUD ȤQ 'HSULQV 6LPDU H 7XONHQVSURSXVHUDPXPHVWLPDGRUTXHQmR LPS}HUHVWULomRGHFRQYH[LGDGHVREUHșPDVDVX
-SRVLomRGHOLYUHGLVSRQLELOLGDGH1RPpWRGR)'+ DH¿FLrQFLDRULHQWDGDSDUDRVLQVXPRVpHVWLPDGD DRFRPSDUDUVHFDGD'08L 1FRPWRGRV DV RXWUDV '08V M 1 TXH SURGX]HP SHOR PHQRV WDQWR TXDQWR HOD 2 FRQMXQWR GH SDUHV GH '08VQDDPRVWUDTXHVDWLVID]DFRQGLomR[OMPDLRU RXLJXDOD[OLSDUDTXDOTXHUOpGHQRWDGRSRU%L(Q
-WUHRVSDUHVGH'08VDTXHOHTXHH[LEHRFRQVXPR PtQLPRGHLQVXPRVVHUYHFRPRUHIHUrQFLDSDUDLH
ș
±
i F–D–H–
pFDOFXODGRFRPRRXVRUHODWLYRGRVLQVXPRV
șˆ i
FDH = min
jגBi maxk=1,...,K x
kj xki
$V '08V TXH DSUHVHQWDP XP FRQVXPR Pt
-QLPRGHLQVXPRVHQWUHWRGRVRVVHXVSDUHVVHUYH FRPRVXDSUySULDUHIHUrQFLD1HVWHFDVRșiFDH
as-VXPHRYDORUXP7RGDYLDDWpPHVPRXPD~QLFD '08QRVGDGRVTXHDSUHVHQWHSHTXHQRFRQVXPR GHLQVXPRVSRGHWRUQDUDVGHPDLVLQH¿FLHQWHV
3.3 Definição das variáveis para o cálculo de ecoeficiência
$ VHOHomR GDV HQWUDGDV inputs H VDtGDV ou-tputs GR PRGHOR IRUDP EDVHDGDV QR HVWXGR GH
5REDLQD$OYHV 0RXWLQKR H 0DFHGR 2V
inputsXWLOL]DGRV(PSUHJR7RWDOPRVWUDRQ~PHUR
WRWDOGHSHVVRDVFRPLGDGHHQWUHDQRVRXPDLV TXHHVWmRWUDEDOKDQGRÁrea de Floresta: área de terras naturais ou plantadas de árvores de pelo menos 5mVHMDSURGXWLYRRXQmRHH[FOXLiUYR
-UHVHPVLVWHPDVGHSURGXomRDJUtFRODHiUYRUHVHP SDUTXHVHMDUGLQVXUEDQRV&RQVXPRGH(QHUJLDV 5HQRYiYHLV p D TXRWD GH HQHUJLD UHQRYiYHO GR FRQVXPR¿QDO
2Voutputs XWLOL]DGRV 3URGXWR ,QWHUQR %UXWR
SURGXWRV (PLVV}HV 7RWDLV GRV *DVHV GR (IHLWR (VWXIDHPNWGHHTXLYDOHQWHGH&2VmRFRQVWL
-WXtGDV SRU WRWDLV GH &2 H[FOXLQGR D TXHLPD GH ELRPDVVDGHFLFORFXUWRFRPRDTXHLPDGHUHVt
-GXRVDJUtFRODVHDTXHLPDGH6DYDQQDKLQFOXLQGR RXWUDVTXHLPDGXUDVGHELRPDVVDWDLVFRPRLQFrQ
-GLRVÀRUHVWDLVWXUIHLUDVGUHQDGDVWRGDVDVIRQWHV DQWURSRJrQLFDVGH&+IRQWHVGH12HJDVHV) +)&V3)&VH6)
3DUDRFiOFXORGDHFRH¿FLrQFLDRRXWSXWXWLOL
-]DGRIRLDGLYLVmRHQWUHR3URGXWR,QWHUQR%UXWR FRQVLGHUDGDVDtGDGHVHMiYHOHDV(PLVV}HV7RWDLV GRV*DVHVGR(IHLWR(VWXIDVDtGDLQGHVHMiYHO(V
-SHUDVHTXHDHFRH¿FLrQFLDVHMDPDLRUTXDQGRDV HPLVV}HVGLPLQXtUHPSDUDRPHVPRYDORUGR3,% 2 FiOFXOR IRL UHDOL]DGR QR SURJUDPD HVWDWtVWLFR 6WDWD
2tQGLFHGHHFRH¿FLrQFLD,(YDULDHQWUHH 4XDQWRPDLVSUy[LPRGHPDLVHFRH¿FLHQWHp RSDtV'HQWURGHVWHVOLPLWHVHFRPEDVHQRHVWX
-GRGH5REDLQD$OYHV0RXWLQKRH0DFHGR RSWRXVHSRUHVWDEHOHFHURVVHJXLQWHVFULWpULRV D0XLWR%DL[R,( E%DL[R ,( F0pGLR ,( G$OWR ,(
3.4 Regressão Tobit
(VWHWUDEDOKRDSUHVHQWDXPPRGHORTXHFRPELQD DWpFQLFDGH)'+HDUHJUHVVmR7RELWSDUDLGHQWL¿FDU TXDLVYDULiYHLVGRPRGHORSURSRVWRLQÀXHQFLDPR tQGLFHGHHFRH¿FLrQFLDGRVSDtVHVHPHVWXGR
$UHJUHVVmR7RELWIRLGHVHQYROYLGDSRU-DPHV7R
-ELQ6HJXQGR$PHPL\DDEDVHGRPR
-GHOR7RELWpVLPLODUjUHJUHVVmRGHPtQLPRVTXDGUD
-GRVPDVDVVXPHXPDGLVWULEXLomRQRUPDOWUXQFDGD RXFHQVXUDGDHWRUQDVHXPH¿FLHQWHPpWRGRSDUDHV
-WLPDUDUHODomRHQWUHXPDYDULiYHOGHSHQGHQWHWUXQ
-FDGDRXFHQVXUDGDHRXWUDVYDULiYHLVH[SODQDWyULDV 'HSRVVHGRVHVFRUHVGHHFRH¿FLrQFLDGHFDGD SDtV HVWXGDGR H GH FHUWDV YDULiYHLV TXH SRVVDP H[SOLFDUDVGLIHUHQoDVQDHFRH¿FLrQFLDHQWUHHOHV GH¿QLXVHRVHJXLQWHPRGHORGHUHJUHVVmR
/RJ,( ȕȕ/RJ57 ȕ/RJ)%&)ȕ/RJ&&)ȕ/RJ7$$
ȕ/RJ4*ȕ/RJ5&XL
HPTXH/RJ,(pRORJDULWPRGDLQYHUVDGR HVFRUUHGHHFRH¿FLrQFLDGRLpVLPRSDtVȕLQGLFD RVSDUkPHWURVDVHUHPHVWLPDGRVHpXPLQGLFDGRU GHHODVWLFLGDGHTXHIRUQHFHDSDUWLFLSDomRUHODWLYD GHFDGDYDULiYHOQDHFRH¿FLrQFLDGHFDGDSDtVRV /RJ;V UHSUHVHQWDP ORJDULWPRV GDV YDULiYHLV H[
-SOLFDWLYDVRWHUPRXpRHUURHVWRFiVWLFRTXHVH SUHVVXS}HWHUPpGLDHYDULkQFLDFRQVWDQWH7HQ
-GRHPYLVWDTXHDLQYHUVDGRHVFRUUHGHH¿FLrQ
-FLDijWHPYDORUOLPLWDGRHQWUHHWRUQDVH QHFHVViULRXWLOL]DURPRGHOR7RELWSDUDHVWLPDURV SDUkPHWURVGDUHJUHVVmR
$YDULiYHOGHSHQGHQWHXWLOL]DGDIRLRtQGLFHGH HFRH¿FLrQFLD,(HDVYDULiYHLVH[SOLFDWLYDVIRUDP R5HEDQKR7RWDOÈUHD5XUDO57)RUPDomR%UX
-WDGH&DSLWDO)L[R)%&)&RQVXPRGH(QHUJLDV GH &RPEXVWtYHLV )yVVHLV GR WRWDO GH HQHUJLD XWLOL]DGD&&)7D[DGH$OIDEHWL]DomRGH$GXO
-WRV7$$SRSXODomRGHDQRVRXPDLVDPERV RVVH[RV4XDOLGDGHGR*RYHUQR4*YDULD HQWUHHFRQVLVWHQRYDORUPpGLRGDVYDULiYHLV &RUUXSomR/HLH2UGHPH4XDOLGDGHGD%XURFUD
-FLDYDORUHVPDLVDOWRVLQGLFDPPHOKRUTXDOLGDGH GRJRYHUQRH5HQGDVGH&DUYmR5&GR3,% 2VGDGRVIRUDPREWLGRVQRVLWHGR%DQFR0XQGLDO DQRGHSDUDRVSDtVHVTXHSDUWLFLSDUDP GDDPRVWUD2SURJUDPDHVWDWtVWLFRXWLOL]DGRSDUDR FiOFXORGD5HJUHVVmR7RELWIRLR6WDWD
4 RESULTADOS E DISCUSSÃO
4.1 Índice de ecoeficiência (IE)
2tQGLFHGHHFRH¿FLrQFLD,(YDULDHQWUHH TXDQWRPDLVSUy[LPRGHPDLVHFRH¿FLHQWHpR SDtVRXVHMDHOHHVWiVHFRPSURPHWHQGRDGDULP
-SRUWkQFLD QmR VRPHQWH jV YDULiYHLV HFRQ{PLFDV PDVWDPEpPjVYDULiYHLVDPELHQWDLVEXVFDQGRDV
-VLPPLQRUDURVLPSDFWRVFDXVDGRVSHODVDWLYLGDGHV SURGXWLYDVHFRQWULEXLUSDUDTXHDVJHUDo}HVIXWX
-UDVSRVVDPXVXIUXLUGRVUHFXUVRVQDWXUDLV $RVHDQDOLVDUDVHVWDWtVWLFDV7DEHODYHUL¿FD
-VHTXHDHFRH¿FLrQFLDPpGLDGLPLQXLXSDVVDQGR GHQRDQRGHSDUDHP WD[DGHFUHVFLPHQWRGH2VYDORUHVPt
-QLPRVHDXPHQWD
-UDPHRVYDORUHVQRDQRGHGDPH
UHIHUHQWHV DR tQGLFH GH HFRH¿FLrQFLD GLPLQXtUDP DRORQJRGRSHUtRGRHVWXGDGRFRQ¿UPDQGRSRV
-VLYHOPHQWHTXHRVSDtVHVQmRHVWmRGHIDWRFRP
-SURPHWLGRV HP GLPLQXLU RV LPSDFWRV DPELHQWDLV FDXVDGRVSHODVDWLYLGDGHVSURGXWLYDVDXPHQWRSR
-SXODFLRQDOHGHFRQVXPR
7DEHOD±(VWDWtVWLFDGHVFULWLYDGRtQGLFHGHHFRH¿FLrQFLDSDUDRVDQRVGH H
Estatísticas ËQGLFHGH(FRH¿FLrQFLD,(
1991 1996 2000 2004 2008 2010 2012
0tQLPR
0i[LPR
0pGLD
0HGLDQD
)RQWHHODERUDGDSHORVDXWRUHVFRPEDVHQRVUHVXOWDGRVGDSHVTXLVD
([DPLQDQGR RV HVFRUHV GH HFRH¿FLrQFLD GRV SDtVHV SRU RUGHP GHFUHVFHQWH GH WD[D GH FUHVFL
-PHQWR7DEHODSDUDRVDQRVGH HQRWDVHTXHDSHQDVQRYH SDtVHV %pOJLFD (VSDQKD )UDQoD ,WiOLD -DSmR 1RUXHJD3DtVHV%DL[RV5HLQR8QLGRH8UXJXDL DOFDQoDUDPRYDORUPi[LPRHPDOJXPPRPHQWR GRSHUtRGRDQDOLVDGR1RUXHJDH8UXJXDLIRUDPRV ~QLFRVTXHREWLYHUDPYDORUPi[LPRHPWRGRVRV DQRVHVWXGDGRV
(VSHUDYDVHTXHRVSDtVHVGHVHQYROYLGRVREWL
-YHVVHPPHOKRUHVUHVXOWDGRVMiTXHVHGHGX]TXH HVWHVLQYHVWHPPDLVHPSHVTXLVDVFLHQWt¿FDVHWHF
-QROyJLFDVQDEXVFDSRUFRQWLQXDUSURGX]LQGRHP XPULWPRDFHOHUDGRPDVFRPPHQRVLPSDFWRVDRV DPELHQWHVQDWXUDLV4XDQGRVHDQDOLVDRVPHOKR
-UHVtQGLFHVSHUFHEHVHTXHKiHVVDGRPLQkQFLDQR HQWDQWR RV SDtVHV HP GHVHQYROYLPHQWR WDPEpP DOFDQoDUDP ERQV UHVXOWDGRV FRPR 8UXJXDL 1L
-FDUiJXDH+RQGXUDVVLQDOL]DQGRTXHDULTXH]DGR SDtVQmRGLPHQVLRQDWRWDOPHQWHDVXDFDSDFLGDGH GHJHULUHLQRYDUHPSROtWLFDVDPELHQWDLV
2VUHVXOWDGRVREWLGRVHPSDUWHHVWmRGHDFRU
-GRFRPRTXHVXJHUHD&XUYD$PELHQWDOGH.XWQH] DTXDOD¿UPDTXHQRVSDtVHVGHVHQYROYLGRVDSDU
-WLUGHXPFHUWRSRQWRDWUDYpVGRDXPHQWRGDUHQGD HGRQtYHOHGXFDFLRQDORFRUUHUiLQHYLWDYHOPHQWH XPD GLPLQXLomR GD GHJUDGDomR DPELHQWDO (P FRQVRQkQFLDFRPHVWDLGHLDPXLWRVDXWRUHVGHVHQ
-YROYHUDP HVWXGRV QHVVD SHUVSHFWLYD %HFNHUPDQ GHIHQGHXTXHDPHOKRUPDQHLUDGHDWLQJLU DTXDOLGDGHDPELHQWDOVHULDRSDtVVHWRUQDUULFR &DUYDOKRH$OPHLGDD¿UPDUDPTXHDSR
-OXLomRSULPHLURDXPHQWDHHQWmRGHFUHVFHFRPR FUHVFLPHQWRGDUHQGDIRUWDOHFHQGRDLGHLDGHTXH RV SDtVHV HP GHVHQYROYLPHQWR VmR PXLWR SREUHV SDUDVHUHPYHUGHV
1RHVWXGRGH5REDLQD$OYHV0RXWLQKRH0D
-FHGRIRLFDOFXODGDDHFRH¿FLrQFLDSDUDRV SDtVHVHXURSHXVHRUHVXOWDGRREWLGRIRLTXHRVSD
-tVHVPDLVHFRH¿FLHQWHVVmRRVPDLVULFRVHHVWHV IRUDP6XpFLD5HLQR8QLGRH)UDQoD
'HVGH D UDWL¿FDomR GR 3URWRFROR GH 4XLRWR RV SDtVHV GD 8QLmR (XURSHLD WrP WRPDGR YiULDV LQLFLDWLYDVSDUDUHGX]LUDVHPLVV}HVHHVVHFDPL
-QKRWURX[HDHYROXomRGRQtYHOGHHFRH¿FLrQFLD 2LQYHVWLPHQWRHPHQHUJLDVUHQRYiYHLVSDUHFHVHU XPGLIHUHQFLDOGHVVHFRPSRUWDPHQWR52%$,1$
-$/9(60287,1+20$&('2S 2HVWXGRGH&DPDUHURHWDOFRUURERUDP RV PHOKRUHV UHVXOWDGRV DOFDQoDGRV SHORV SDtVHV HXURSHXVSRLVRVSDtVHVPDLVHFRH¿FLHQWHVIRUDP 6XtoD6XpFLD)UDQoD1RUXHJDH'LQDPDUFDHRV PHQRV&DQDGiH(VWDGRV8QLGRV
$1RUXHJDSDtVGHVHQYROYLGRREWHYHUHVXOWD
-GRVSRVLWLYRVUHIHUHQWHVjVYDULiYHLVHFRQ{PLFDV MiTXHR3,%TXDVHGREURXQRVDQRVDQDOLVDGRVHR HPSUHJRWRWDODXPHQWRX&RPUHODomRjV YDULiYHLVDPELHQWDLVRFRQVXPRGHHQHUJLDVUHQR
-YiYHLVGLPLQXLXDSHVDUGHWHUPHOKRUDGR VXDFODVVL¿FDomRQRUDQNLQJSDVVDQGRGDGpFLPD TXDUWDSRVLomRQRDQRGHSDUDDQRQDQRDQR GHHQDVHPLVV}HVWRWDLVGRVJDVHVGRHIHLWR HVWXIDRSDtV¿JXUDHQWUHRVYLQWHSDtVHVGDDPRV
7DEHOD±ËQGLFHGHHFRH¿FLrQFLDSRURUGHPGHFUHVFHQWHGHWD[DGHFUHVFLPHQWRSDUDRVSDtVHVQRVDQRV GHH
Países 1991 1996 2000 2004 2008 2010 2012 Taxa de Crescimento
ËQGLFHGH(FRH¿FLrQFLD,( (%)
&XED
ËQGLD
7DLOkQGLD
7XUTXLD
&DQDGi
$UJHQWLQD
$XVWUiOLD
0DUURFRV
5~VVLD
,QGRQpVLD
1HSDO
ÈIULFDGR6XO
%DQJODGHVK
%UDVLO
6XpFLD
&KLOH
1LJpULD
)UDQoD
)LOLSLQDV
3DUDJXDL
%ROtYLD
&KLQD
9HQH]XHOD
(TXDGRU
0p[LFR
Gana
1RUXHJD
8UXJXDL
&DPDU}HV
+RQGXUDV
1LFDUiJXD
&RQJR
$QJROD
0RoDPELTXH
6HQHJDO
3DTXLVWmR
6XGmR
3HUX
&RO{PELD
*UpFLD
*XDWHPDOD
3RUWXJDO
%pOJLFD
(JLWR
(VWDGRV8QLGRV
3DtVHV%DL[RV
Espanha
5HLQR8QLGR
,WiOLD
$OHPDQKD
-DSmR
)RQWHHODERUDGDSHORVDXWRUHVFRPEDVHQRVUHVXOWDGRVGDSHVTXLVD
1D VHJXQGD PHWDGH GR VpFXOR ;; FRP R GH
-VHQYROYLPHQWRGDLQG~VWULDGRSHWUyOHRD1RUXHJD HPHUJLXFRPRXPGRVSDtVHVPDLVGHVHQYROYLGRV GRPXQGReXPDQDomRYROWDGDSDUDDQDYHJDomR
SRLVWHPXPDGDVPDLRUHVIURWDVPHUFDQWHVPXQ
-GLDLV2SDtVpRVHJXQGRPDLRUIRUQHFHGRUGHSUR
-GXWRVHQHUJpWLFRVGHSRLVGD5~VVLDLQFOXLQGRSH
D1RUXHJDHVWiHQWUHRVFLQFRPHOKRUHVSDtVHVHP XPDVpULHGHPHGLGDVDPELHQWDLV2SDtVpRVHJXQ
-GRDWUiVDSHQDVGD6XpFLDHPHPLVV}HVSRU3,%GH DSHQDVWRQHODGDVSRUPLOKmRGHGyODUHVPXL
-WRPHOKRUGRTXHDPpGLDGD2&'(GHPLO WRQHODGDVSRVVXLXPGRVPDLRUHVUHFXUVRVKLGUHOp
-WULFRVGRFRQWLQHQWH(XURSHXHWDPEpPpRVHJXQGR SDtVTXDQGRVHWUDWDGHiJXDUHWLUDQGRDSHQDV GRVVHXVUHFXUVRVWRWDLVGHiJXDGRFHUHQRYiYHOH SRVLFLRQDVH HP TXLQWR OXJDU QR ËQGLFH GH 6D~GH GRV2FHDQRVTXHDYDOLDRVHFRVVLVWHPDVPDULQKRV 0217(3,2S
28UXJXDLSDtVHPGHVHQYROYLPHQWRQmRSRV
-VXLXP3,%FRPYDORUVLJQL¿FDWLYRTXDQGRFRP
-SDUDGRFRPRXWURVSDtVHVGDDPRVWUDPDVREWHYH XPFUHVFLPHQWRGHGXUDQWHRSHUtRGRHVWX
-GDGR&RPUHODomRDRHPSUHJRWRWDORVXUXJXDLRV DXPHQWDUDP 1DV YDULiYHLV DPELHQWDLV R 8UXJXDLDOFDQoRXUHVXOWDGRVPDLVVLJQL¿FDWLYRV$ iUHDGHÀRUHVWDVQmRpPXLWDH[WHQVDMiTXHpXP SDtVSHTXHQRSRUpPHVWDiUHDDXPHQWRX FRQWULEXLQGRDVVLPSDUDXPDUPDLVOLPSRPHQRV SROXtGRDOpPGHDX[LOLDUDUHJXODURFOLPDHRVROR
2FRQVXPRGHHQHUJLDVUHQRYiYHLVGRVXUXJXDLRV FUHVFHXDSHQDVSDVVDQGRGDYLJpVLPDSRVL
-omRQRDQRGHSDUDDGpFLPDVH[WDQRDQRGH 2SDtV¿JXUDHQWUHRVGH]TXHPHQRVHPLWHP JDVHVGRHIHLWRHVWXIDSRLVFRQVRPHEDVWDQWHHQHU
-JLDVUHQRYiYHLVGHYLGRDR3ODQR1DFLRQDOGH(QHU
-JLD IRUPXODGR HP TXH LQYHVWLX HP HQHU-JLD HyOLFDVRODUHELRPDVVD)UHLUHD¿UPDTXH R8UXJXDLpDWXDOPHQWHRSDtVGRFRQWLQHQWHFRP PDLRUGHVHQYROYLPHQWRHLQYHVWLPHQWRVHVWUDQJHLURV HPHQHUJLDVUHQRYiYHLVHWDPEpPFRPDPDLRUFD
-SDFLGDGHLQVWDODGDHyOLFDper capitaQRDQRGH
28UXJXDLWHPFRPRSULQFLSDLVIRQWHVGHHQHU
-JLDRSHWUyOHRHVHXVGHULYDGRVDSHVDUGLVVRQRV ~OWLPRV DQRV KRXYH XP DXPHQWR QD JHUDomR GH HQHUJLDV UHQRYiYHLV$ SROtWLFD GH HQHUJLD GR8UXJXDLIRLWUDQVIRUPDGDHPXPDSROt
-WLFD GH (VWDGR TXH HVWDEHOHFH DV SULQFLSDLV GLUH
-WUL]HV QR FDPSR GH HQHUJLD HP WRGR R SDtV FRP XPD YLVmR GH ORQJR SUD]R$ SROtWLFD HQHUJpWLFD FRPSURPHWHVH IRUWHPHQWH FRP D GLYHUVL¿FDomR GDPDWUL]HQHUJpWLFDHHPSDUWLFXODUGHHQHUJLDV UHQRYiYHLV(VWDDSRVWDWHPYiULRVREMHWLYRVHQWUH RVTXDLVDOFDQoDUDVREHUDQLDHQHUJpWLFDDUHGX
-omRGHFXVWRVGHHOHWULFLGDGHDDWLYDomRGRVHWRU QDFLRQDO GH HQHUJLD UHGXomR GD GHSHQGrQFLD GH yOHRHGLPLQXLomRGRVLPSDFWRVDPELHQWDLV,16
-7,7872'(35202&,Ï1'(,19(56,21(6 <(;3257$&,21(6S
2V SDtVHV TXH DWLQJLUDP DV PDLRUHV WD[DV GH FUHVFLPHQWRGRtQGLFHGHHFRH¿FLrQFLDIRUDP&XED HËQGLD&XEDDXPHQWRXR3,% HPSUHJRWRWDOHiUHDGHÀRUHVWDV$VÀRUHVWDVFXED
-QDV SDVVDUDP D VHU PDLV SURWHJLGDV DSyV DV DOWH
-UDo}HV QD OHJLVODomR ÀRUHVWDO RFRUULGDV QR DQR GH IRUWDOHFHQGR DVVLP R GHVHQYROYLPHQWR GH XPDSROtWLFDDPELHQWDOHDPSOLDQGRDSDUWLFLSDomR GRSDtVHPWUDWDGRVLQWHUQDFLRQDLVTXHSRVVXHPUH
-OHYkQFLDSDUDDVÀRUHVWDVDOpPGHPRGHUQL]DUWHF
-QRORJLDVYROWDGDVSDUDDVXVWHQWDELOLGDGH
$SHVDUGRVFXEDQRVWHUHPDXPHQWDGRDV HPLVV}HVWRWDLVGRVJDVHVGRHIHLWRHVWXIDRSDtV PHOKRURXVHLVSRVLo}HVSDVVDQGRGHGpFLPRTXLQWR PHQRUHPLVVRUHPSDUDQRQRQRDQRGH &RQIRUPHD&RQYHQomR4XDGURGDV1Do}HV8QL
-GDVVREUH0XGDQoDVGR&OLPD81)&&& DFRQWULEXLomRGH&XEDSDUDDVHPLVV}HVJOREDLV GHJDVHVGHHIHLWRHVWXIDpPtQLPDPDVDSHVDUGR EDL[RLPSDFWRGDVHPLVV}HVHGDSULRULGDGHRSDtV YHPGHVHQYROYHQGRH¿QDQFLDQGRDo}HVGHPLWL
-JDomRUHODFLRQDGDVDRXVRGHHQHUJLDVUHQRYiYHLV H¿FLrQFLDHQHUJpWLFDHUHÀRUHVWDPHQWR
$ËQGLDDOFDQoRXDVHJXQGDPDLRUWD[DGHFUHV
-FLPHQWRGHYLGRDRDXPHQWRQR3,%HP
-SUHJRWRWDOHQDiUHDGHÀRUHVWDV 1DËQGLDGHDFRUGRFRP5DYLQGUDQDWKHWDO DVSROtWLFDVÀRUHVWDLVSURJUHVVLYDVHRVSURJUDPDV FRQWULEXtUDP VLJQL¿FDWLYDPHQWH SDUD DXPHQWDU D DUERUL]DomRHDViUHDVGHÀRUHVWDV2SDtVpSRU
-WDQWRXPGRVSRXFRVSDtVHVWURSLFDLVQRVTXDLVD FREHUWXUDÀRUHVWDOVHHVWDELOL]RXRXDXPHQWRX2V IDWRUHVTXHFRQWULEXHPSDUDDHVWDELOL]DomRGDFR
-EHUWXUDÀRUHVWDOEHPFRPRRVHVWRTXHVGHFDUERQR LQFOXHPOHJLVODo}HVUHÀRUHVWDPHQWRHSURJUDPDV FRPRVLOYLFXOWXUDVRFLDOJHVWmRFRQMXQWDGDÀRUHVWD HFRQVFLrQFLDHSDUWLFLSDomRGDFRPXQLGDGH
4XDQGRVHWUDWDGRFRQVXPRGHHQHUJLDVUHQRYi
-YHLVHDVHPLVV}HVWRWDLVGRVJDVHVGRHIHL
-WRHVWXIDGRVLQGLDQRVRVUHVXOWDGRVVmR QHJDWLYRVSDUDRPHLRDPELHQWH8PDGDVSULQFLSDLV FDXVDVGHVVHVUHVXOWDGRVVmRRVFRQVWDQWHVGHVPDWD
-PHQWRVDLQGDRFRUULGRVHPWHUUDLQGLDQDVDSHVDUGR DXPHQWRGDFREHUWXUDÀRUHVWDOQRV~OWLPRVDQRV
$ËQGLDHVWiEXVFDQGRXPDUiSLGDH[SDQVmRQR IRUQHFLPHQWRHJHUDomRGHHQHUJLDHGHIRQWHVQmR UHQRYiYHLVFRQVHTXHQWHPHQWHDVHPLVV}HVGHJD
-ULGJHHWDOD¿UPDPTXHDHVWUDWpJLDGDËQGLD SDUDOLGDUFRPDVPXGDQoDVFOLPiWLFDVpSURVVHJXLU FRPRGHVHQYROYLPHQWRMiHVWDEHOHFLGRHPVHX3OD
-QRGH$omR1DFLRQDOVREUH0XGDQoDV&OLPiWLFDV ODQoDGRHP2SULQFLSDOREMHWLYRpUHGX]LUD LQWHQVLGDGHGDVHPLVV}HVHPDWpRDQRGH
2VSDtVHVFRPDVPHQRUHVWD[DVGHFUHVFLPHQWR GRtQGLFHGHHFRH¿FLrQFLDIRUDP-DSmR H$OHPDQKD(VWHVUHVXOWDGRVRFRUUHUDP GHYLGRDPXGDQoDVH[WUHPDVQRVYDORUHVGRVtQGL
-FHV2-DSmRQRVSULPHLURVDQRVGDDQiOLVHDWLQJLX RYDORUPi[LPRGRtQGLFHSRUpPQRV~OWLPRVDQRV RYDORUFDLXSDUD+RXYHTXHGDQRVYDORUHVGR HPSUHJRWRWDOHQRFRQVXPRGHHQHUJLDV UHQRYiYHLVHDXPHQWRQR3,% iUHDGHÀRUHVWDVHHPLVVmRWRWDOGHJDVHV GRHIHLWRHVWXID
2JRYHUQRMDSRQrVQRDQRGHODQoRXDO
-JXPDVDo}HVFRPRREMHWLYRGHFRPEDWHURDTXH
-FLPHQWRJOREDODWUDYpVGDDFHOHUDomRHGLIXVmRGH WHFQRORJLDVTXHUHGX]DPDVHPLVV}HVGHJDVHVGH HIHLWR HVWXID H R FUHVFLPHQWR HFRQ{PLFR DR PHV
-PRWHPSR6HJXQGR.DXIIPDQQ/HVVH7HLFKPDQQ R -DSmR LQWURGX]LX UHODWyULRV REULJDWyULRV DQXDLVGHHPLVV}HVGHJDVHVGRHIHLWRHVWXIDQRDQR GHSDUDDVHPSUHVDVEXVFDQGRDVVLPDXPHQ
-WDUDFRQVFLHQWL]DomRGDVHPSUHVDVVREUHDQHFHVVL
-GDGHGHFRQWULEXLUSDUDDo}HVGHPXGDQoDVFOLPi
-WLFDVHSRXSDQoDGHHQHUJLDDOpPGHGLVSRQLELOL]DU LQIRUPDo}HV UHODFLRQDGDV jV HPLVV}HV SDUD RXWUDV SDUWHVLQWHUHVVDGDVSULQFLSDOPHQWHRVLQYHVWLGRUHV
$H[SDQVmRGRXVRGDVHQHUJLDVUHQRYiYHLVpXP GRV SULQFLSDLV REMHWLYRV GR JRYHUQR MDSRQrV PDV TXHDLQGDQmRIRLSRVVtYHODOFDQoDU2SDtVSRVVXL SRXFDVIRQWHVGHHQHUJLDDGYLQGDVGRVFRPEXVWtYHLV IRVVHLVHSRULVVRLPSRUWDJUDQGHVTXDQWLGDGHVPDV LQYHVWLXHPWHFQRORJLDVGHHQHUJLDQDEXVFDSRUSUR
-PRYHUDGLYHUVL¿FDomRGHVHXVUHFXUVRVHQHUJpWLFRV 2tQGLFHGHHFRH¿FLrQFLDGD$OHPDQKDQRDQR GHIRLGHHQRDQRGHFDLXSDUD GHYLGRSULQFLSDOPHQWHjVHPLVV}HVGHJD
-VHVGRHIHLWRHVWXID$$OHPDQKDpXPDSRWrQFLD HFRQ{PLFD PXQGLDO SHUWHQFHQWH j 8QLmR (XUR
-SHLDHVXDVSROtWLFDVDPELHQWDLVQHFHVVLWDPHVWDU DOLQKDGDVjVSROtWLFDVGRVRXWURVSDtVHVLQWHJUDQ
-WHVMiTXHRVHVIRUoRVQHFHVVLWDPVHUIHLWRVGHQWUR GHWRGDDFRPXQLGDGHSDUDJHUDUXPTXDGURTXH LQFHQWLYH QRV SUy[LPRV DQRV D QHXWUDOLGDGH GDV HPLVV}HVGHJDVHVGRHIHLWRHVWXID
3DUDR)HGHUDO(QYLURQPHQW$JHQF\R REMHWLYRFOLPiWLFRDFRUGDGRLQWHUQDFLRQDOPHQWHVy SRGH VHU FXPSULGR VH WRGRV RV SDtVHV UHGX]LUHP VXDV HPLVV}HV GH JDVHV GH HIHLWR HVWXID 3DUD DV QDo}HVLQGXVWULDLVFRPRD$OHPDQKDLVVRVLJQL
-¿FDULDTXHHODVGHYHULDPVHWRUQDUTXDVHQHXWURV HPJDVHVGHHIHLWRHVWXIDHUHGX]LUVXDVHPLVV}HV
GHDHPUHODomRDRDQRGH0DVVH
-JXQGRR&RQVHOKR0XQGLDOGH(QHUJLD:25/' (1(5*< &281&,/ D $OHPDQKD DLQGD YDLGHSHQGHUGHXPPL[GHHQHUJLDTXHWDPEpP LQFOXL QmR UHQRYiYHLV GXUDQWH GpFDGDV D ¿P GH FRQVHJXLUXPDWUDQVLomRVHJXUDSDUDXPVLVWHPD GHHQHUJLDFRPEDL[DHPLVVmRGHFDUERQR
2VSLRUHVUHVXOWDGRVGRVtQGLFHVIRUDPDOFDQ
-oDGRVSHODËQGLD,(PpGLR WDEHOD$QR DSrQGLFHH&KLQD,(PpGLR HPWRGR RSHUtRGRDQDOLVDGR3DtVHVHVWHVTXH¿JXUDPHQ
-WUHRVFLQFRPDLRUHVHPLVVRUHVGRVJDVHVGRHIHLWR HVWXIDMXQWDPHQWHFRP5~VVLD(VWDGRV8QLGRVH %UDVLO$&KLQDPDLVTXHWULSOLFRXDTXDQWLGDGHGH JDVHV HPLWLGRV H D ËQGLD DXPHQWRX GHYLGR SULQFLSDOPHQWHDRLQWHQVRFUHVFLPHQWRGDVDWLYL
-GDGHVSURGXWLYDV
'LYHUVRVSDtVHVTXHHVWmRHPFRQVWDQWHFUHVFL
-PHQWRHFRQ{PLFRGHPDQGDPPXLWDHQHUJLDHFRQ
-VHTXHQWHPHQWHHPLWHPPDLVJDVHVGRHIHLWRHVWX
-IDMiTXHRREMHWLYRpXWLOL]DUIRQWHVGHHQHUJLDV PDLVHFRQ{PLFDVVHPVHSUHRFXSDUFRPRVLPSDF
-WRVFDXVDGRVDRPHLRDPELHQWHDFXUWRPpGLRH ORQJRSUD]RV6HJXQGR'HOJDGRH)HEUDUR D&KLQDpRPDLRUFRQVXPLGRUGHHQHUJLDGRPXQ
-GRUHVSRQGHQGRSRUGRFRQVXPRJOREDOGH HQHUJLDQRDQRGH'HVWDFDQGRVHDJUDQGH SDUWLFLSDomR GD LQG~VWULD SHVDGD QD HFRQRPLD H HVWDGHPDQGDPXLWDHQHUJLD$QHFHVVLGDGHGHGH
-VHQYROYLPHQWRGHLQIUDHVWUXWXUDQD&KLQDGHSHQGH IRUWHPHQWH GRV VHWRUHV LQWHQVLYRV HP HQHUJLD 2 SDtVpRPDLRULQÀXHQFLDGRUGHWHQGrQFLDVJOREDLV GH FUHVFLPHQWR GH FRQVXPR GH HQHUJLD GHVGH RV DQRVHHVVDWHQGrQFLDVHJXLUiDWpTXDQ
-GR GHYH VHU XOWUDSDVVDGD SHOD ËQGLD 3HOD WHRULD GRVUHFXUVRVQDWXUDLVXWLOL]DVHSULPHLUDPHQWHR UHFXUVRPDLVDEXQGDQWHHSRUFRQVHJXLQWHPDLV EDUDWR3RULVVRD&KLQDLQVLVWHHPXPDPDWUL] HQHUJpWLFDIRFDGDHPFDUYmRVHJXLGDSHODSDUWLFL
-SDomRGRyOHREUXWRHJHUDomRKLGUHOpWULFD
HHVWiSURMHWDGDSDUDFKHJDUDHPFRP R DXPHQWR GD SDUWLFLSDomR GR JiV QDWXUDO PDLV TXHGXSOLFDQGRSDUDGDPDWUL]HQHUJpWLFDHP HFRPRDXPHQWRGDSDUWLFLSDomRGHyOHRFUX GH SDUD $V HQHUJLDV UHQRYiYHLV HVWmR DXPHQWDQGR VXD SDUWLFLSDomR FRQVLGHUDYHOPHQWH FUHVFLPHQWR GH DVVLP FRPR D QXFOHDU H KLGURHOpWULFD FRP FUHVFLPHQWR GH H UHVSHFWLYDPHQWH *UDoDV D HVVH H[SUHVVLYR DX
-PHQWRGDJHUDomRQXFOHDUD&KLQDUHVSRQGHUiHP SRUGHWRGDDJHUDomRQXFOHDUGRPXQ
-GR'(/*$'2)(%5$52S
$ËQGLDGLPLQXLXRFRQVXPRGHHQHUJLDVUHQRYi
-YHLVSDUDDSHVDUGHHVWDU LQYHVWLQGRHPVXDH[SDQVmR8PGRVFRPSOLFDGR
-UHVpTXHXPDGDVPDLRUHVUHVHUYDVGHFDUYmRGR PXQGRpLQGLDQDHRSDtVFRQWLQXDDXWLOL]iODLQWHQ
-VDPHQWHMiTXHpVXDSULQFLSDOIRQWHGHHQHUJLD2V JRYHUQDQWHVDGLDUDPRTXDQWRSXGHUDPDDVVLQDWXUD GHDFRUGRVUHIHUHQWHVDRVFRPSURPLVVRVGHOLPLWDU DHPLVVmRGRVJDVHVGRHIHLWRHVWXIDSRLVVHJXQGR HOHVDSULQFLSDOPHWDpGLPLQXLUDSREUH]DQRSDtV HSDUDLVVRpQHFHVViULRXWLOL]DUDVXDSULQFLSDOIRQWH GHHQHUJLDHTXHRVSDtVHVULFRVSRVVXHPPDLRUUHV
-SRQVDELOLGDGHFRPDVPXGDQoDVFOLPiWLFDV
9HUtVVLPRH1XVVEDXPD¿UPDPTXHQD ËQGLDTXDVHWRGDVDViUHDVÀRUHVWDLVVmRGHSURSULH
-GDGHHVWDWDOHDOHLÀRUHVWDOH[LJHTXHDSURSULHGDGH VHMDPDQWLGDFRPRÀRUHVWD0HVPRDVVLPPXLWRV KHFWDUHVVmRXWLOL]DGRVSDUDDXPHQWDUDFDSDFLGDGH SURGXWLYDGRSDtVDWUDYpVGHJHUDomRGHHQHUJLD GHVPDWDPHQWRVHDWLYLGDGHVGHPLQHUDomR
2%UDVLOFODVVL¿FRXVHFRPRRTXDUWRSLRUSDtV HPWRGRVRVDQRVDQDOLVDGRV,(
HHP,( REWHQGRDSHQDVXPDX
-PHQWRHPWRUQRGHQRVDQRVHVWXGDGRV(VWDU HQWUH RV FLQFR SDtVHV TXH PDLV HPLWHP JDVHV GR HIHLWR HVWXID FRQWULEXLX SDUD HVWH PDO UHVXOWDGR DSHVDUGRVQ~PHURVUHIHUHQWHVjVYDULiYHLVHFRQ{
-PLFDVWHUHPVLGRSRVLWLYRVR3,%GXSOLFRXHRHP
-SUHJRDXPHQWRX1RHQWDQWRHVVHVUHVXOWDGRV QmRIRUDPVX¿FLHQWHVSDUDPHOKRUDURGHVHPSHQKR EUDVLOHLUR
&RQIRUPH R 0LQLVWpULR GR 0HLR $PELHQWH HPGH]DQRVRXVRGHHQHUJLDUHQRYiYHO FUHVFHXSDVVDQGRGHGHWRGDDRIHUWD GHHQHUJLDLQWHUQDHPSDUDHP (VVDSHTXHQDH[SDQVmRGDRIHUWDGHHQHUJLDUHQR
-YiYHOQmRIRLVX¿FLHQWHSDUDDWHQGHUDRFRQVXPR GH HQHUJLDV UHQRYiYHLV QR %UDVLO PRVWUDQGRVH
XUJHQWHDQHFHVVLGDGHGHXPPDLRUHVFODUHFLPHQ
-WRGDLPSRUWkQFLDGRXVRGHVVDVHQHUJLDVDOpPGH HVWtPXORV DWUDYpV GH SROtWLFDV S~EOLFDV SDUD TXH HPSUHVDVHVRFLHGDGHHPJHUDOWRUQHPVHDGHSWRV HGHIHQVRUHVDRXVRGDHQHUJLDUHQRYiYHO
$ViUHDVÀRUHVWDLVEUDVLOHLUDVGLPLQXtUDPSDV
-VDQGRGHQRVDQRVGHSDUD QR¿QDOGRSHUtRGRDQDOLVDGRRSDtVSHUGHX PLOKHFWDUHVGHÀRUHVWDVGHYLGRDRVGHVPDWDPHQ
-WRVTXHRFRUUHPFRPIUHTXrQFLDQDUHJLmRDPD]{
-QLFD6HJXQGRD2UJDQL]DomRGDV1Do}HV8QLGDV SDUD$JULFXOWXUD H$OLPHQWDomR R %UDVLO OLGHUDRUDQNLQJGHGHVPDWDPHQWRV
2V(VWDGRV8QLGRVSLRUDUDPRVHXUHVXOWDGRQR SHUtRGR DQDOLVDGR ,( HP H ,(
HPRFXSDQGRDQRQDSLRUFODVVL¿
-FDomR$WpRDQRGHRV(VWDGRV8QLGRVHUDP RPDLRUHPLVVRUGRVJDVHVGRHIHLWRHVWXIDVHJXQ
-GRRVGDGRVGR%DQFR0XQGLDOSRUpPDSDUWLUGH SHUGHXHVVHSRVWRSDUDD&KLQD&RQWXGRD YDULiYHOHFRQ{PLFD3,%DXPHQWRXGXUDQWHWRGR RSHUtRGRDQDOLVDGRDOpPGHVHURPDLRU3,%GH WRGRVRVSDtVHVGDDPRVWUD
4XDQWRDRFRQVXPRGHHQHUJLDVUHQRYiYHLVRVUH
-VXOWDGRVQRUWHDPHULFDQRVDLQGDQmRVmRPXLWRUHOH
-YDQWHV1RVDQRVGHDPpGLDGHFRQVXPRIRLGH HQRVDQRVKRXYHXPDPHOKRUDSDVVDQGR SDUD2V(VWDGRV8QLGRVWrPRREMHWLYRGHGH
-VHQYROYHUDVXDPDWUL]HQHUJpWLFDSULQFLSDOPHQWHQD SURGXomRHFRQVXPRGHHQHUJLDUHQRYiYHOHDVVLP FRQWULEXLUSDUDDGLPLQXLomRGRDTXHFLPHQWRJOREDO
1RV(VWDGRV8QLGRVHVWLPDVHTXHHPD iUHDÀRUHVWDOHUDGHPLOK}HVGHKHFWDUHVDSUR[L
-PDGDPHQWHGDiUHDWRWDO'HVGHFHUFDGH PLOK}HVGHKHFWDUHVGHÀRUHVWDVIRUDPFRQYHUWL
-GRVHPRXWURVXVRVSULQFLSDOPHQWHYROWDGRVjDJUL
-FXOWXUD$WpDiUHDGHWHUUDVÀRUHVWDLVMiKDYLD GLPLQXtGR SDUD HVWLPDGRV PLOK}HV GH KHFWD
-UHVFRUUHVSRQGHQGRDGDiUHDWRWDO(P DiUHDÀRUHVWDODEUDQJLDPLOK}HVGHKHFWDUHV GDiUHDWRWDOGRV(VWDGRV8QLGRV$iUHDÀR
-UHVWDOSHUPDQHFHUHODWLYDPHQWHHVWiYHOGHVGH HPERUDDSRSXODomRWHQKDDXPHQWDGRHPPDLVGH WUrVYH]HVQHVVHSHUtRGR86'$S
2V QtYHLV GH HFRH¿FLrQFLD QRUWHDPHULFDQRV FRQWLQXDUDP D QmR DOFDQoDU UHVXOWDGRV VDWLVID
-WyULRV GHYLGR SULQFLSDOPHQWH jV QRYDV SROtWL
FRP XPD SURPHVVD GH UHYHUWHU RV UHJXODPHQWRV DPELHQWDLVDGRWDGRVSHODDGPLQLVWUDomRGH2EDPD HJHUDUXPUHQDVFLPHQWRQDSURGXomRHQRHPSUH
-JRGHFDUYmRGRV(VWDGRV8QLGRV
2VPDSDVHPRVWUDPXPSDUkPHWURJHUDOGD FODVVL¿FDomRGR,(SDUDRVDQRVGHDQRLQLFLDO
HDQR¿QDO(PWRGRVRVDQRVDQDOLVDGRVR,( PXLWREDL[RREWHYHRPDLRUQ~PHURGHSDtVHVHP WRUQRGHGDDPRVWUD1RDQRGH0DSD RPDLRUQ~PHURGHSDtVHVVHFRQFHQWURXQR,(PXLWR EDL[RHHPVHJXQGROXJDUQR,(DOWR
Mapa 1 ±&ODVVL¿FDomRGRtQGLFHGHHFRH¿FLrQFLDSDUDRVSDtVHVQRDQRGH
)RQWHHODERUDGDSHORVDXWRUHVFRPEDVHQRVUHVXOWDGRVGDSHVTXLVD
(PPDSDR,(PXLWREDL[RFRQWLQXRX LQWHJUDQGR R PDLRU Q~PHUR GH SDtVHV LQFOXVLYH FRPDXPHQWRPDVRVHJXQGRLQWHUYDORFRPR
0DSD± &ODVVL¿FDomRGRtQGLFHGHHFRH¿FLrQFLDSDUDRVSDtVHVQRDQRGH
)RQWHHODERUDGDSHORVDXWRUHVFRPEDVHQRVUHVXOWDGRVGDSHVTXLVD
2,(PXLWREDL[RREWHYHXPDXPHQWRHQWUHRV DQRVGHSDtVHVHSDtVHV1R DQR GH RV FRQWLQHQWHV SUHGRPLQDQWHV IRUDP RDPHULFDQRSDtVHVFRPR%UDVLO(VWDGRV8QLGRV H&DQDGiHDVLiWLFRSDtVHVFRPRËQGLD&KLQDH 1HSDO$R¿QDOGRSHUtRGRHVWXGDGRRFRUUHUDPPX
-GDQoDVVLJQL¿FDWLYDV2FRQWLQHQWHDVLiWLFRSDVVRX DSUHGRPLQDUFRPSDtVHVRDPHULFDQRRFXSRXD VHJXQGDSRVLomRFRPRVPHVPRVSDtVHVHRFRQ
-WLQHQWHHXURSHXTXHQRDQRGHVyREWHYHXP SDtVHVWHHUDD5~VVLDSDVVRXDVHUFRPSRVWRSRU SDtVHV,WiOLD$OHPDQKD(VSDQKDH5HLQR8QLGR
$TXDQWLGDGHGHSDtVHVTXHDWLQJLXR,(EDL[R PDQWHYHVHTXDVHLQDOWHUDGDGXUDQWHWRGRRSHUtRGR DQDOLVDGR2VSDtVHVGRFRQWLQHQWHDIULFDQRSUHGR
-PLQDUDPQHVVHLQWHUYDORHPWRUQRGHFRPR 0RoDPELTXH$QJROD*DQDH6XGmR-iRJUXSRGR ,(PpGLRWHYHXPDXPHQWRGHHQWUHRVDQRV DQDOLVDGRV(PHRVSDtVHVGD$PpULFD IRUDPPDLRULDFRPR%ROtYLD3DUDJXDLH+RQGXUDV
2VSDtVHVSHUWHQFHQWHVDRLQWHUYDORGR,(DOWR GLPLQXtUDPHPWRUQRGHHHPWRGRRSHUtR
-GRRFRQWLQHQWH(XURSHXPDQWHYHVHFRPHOHYD
-GRVtQGLFHVGHHFRH¿FLrQFLDFRPSDtVHVFRPRD 1RUXHJD6XpFLDH)UDQoD
1RSHUtRGRLQLFLDOGHDQiOLVHDQRGHRV SDtVHVFRP,(PXLWREDL[RTXHHVWmRHPGHVHQYRO
-YLPHQWRFRPRR%UDVLO&KLQDËQGLDH0p[LFRVmR MiRVSDtVHVULFRVFRPRRV(VWDGRV8QL
-GRV&DQDGiHD$XVWUiOLDVmRHRVSREUHV FRPR&RQJRH1HSDOVmR-iQRDQRGH R,(PXLWREDL[RpFRPSRVWRSRUGHSDtVHV HPGHVHQYROYLPHQWRGHVHQYROYLGRVHRUHV
-WDQWHVmRSREUHV5HYHODQGRTXHWDQWRSDtVHV ULFRVFRPRSREUHVHVWmRSROXLQGRRDPELHQWHSR
-UpPRVSDtVHVULFRVHHPHUJHQWHVHPXPDSDUFHOD EHPPDLRUMiTXHSURGX]HPPDLVHDVVLPHPLWHP PDLVJDVHVFDXVDGRUHVGRHIHLWRHVWXID
$R ¿QDO GR SHUtRGR DQDOLVDGR QRWDVH TXHKRXYHXPDGLPLQXLomRDSHQDVQRVSDtVHVFODV
-VL¿FDGRVFRPR,(DOWRHDXPHQWRQRVHVWUDWRVGH ,(PXLWREDL[RHPpGLR(VWHVUHVXOWDGRVPRVWUDP TXH DOJXQV SDtVHV SDVVDUDP D DVVXPLU UHVSRQVD
-ELOLGDGH FRP RV DVVXQWRV UHODWLYRV DR PHLR DP
-ELHQWHHQWUHWDQWRLQVX¿FLHQWHVSDUDWUDQVIRUPDUD UHDOLGDGHDWXDOPRVWUDQGRDVVLPTXHPXLWRDLQGD SUHFLVDVHUIHLWRSDUDTXHGHIDWRRVQ~PHURVDFHU
-FDGDHFRH¿FLrQFLDSRVVDPVHWRUQDUUHOHYDQWHVH HVVHQFLDLVQDIRUPXODomRGHSROtWLFDVS~EOLFDVHQD FRQVFLHQWL]DomRGDSRSXODomRHPJHUDO
4.2 Análise Econométrica
$UHJUHVVmR7RELWIRLUHDOL]DGDFRPRREMHWLYRGH YHUL¿FDUDVYDULiYHLVVLJQL¿FDQWHVSDUDRtQGLFHGH HFRH¿FLrQFLDGRVSDtVHVSHORVRIWZDUH6WDWD
2VUHVXOWDGRVGDUHJUHVVmRHVWmRGHWDOKDGRVQD 7DEHOD'DVVHLVYDULiYHLVXWLOL]DGDVFLQFRPRV
-WUDUDPVHVLJQL¿FDWLYDVDRQtYHOGHSRUFHQWDJHQV GLIHUHQFLDGDV25HEDQKR7RWDOÈUHD5XUDO57 IRLD~QLFDYDULiYHOTXHQmRVHPRVWURXVLJQL¿FDQ
-WH DSHVDU GH VHU XPD LPSRUWDQ-WH IRQ-WH HPLVVRUD GH JDVHV GR HIHLWR HVWXID 2 VLQDO GR FRH¿FLHQWH REWLGRIRLRHVSHUDGRQHJDWLYRPRVWUDQGRTXHR DXPHQWRGRUHEDQKRSRGHYLUDGLPLQXLURtQGLFH GHHFRH¿FLrQFLD,(
7DEHOD±5HVXOWDGRVGDUHJUHVVmR7RELW
Variáveis &RH¿FLHQWH Erro Padrão t P > |t|
&RQVWDQWH
57
)%&) e e
&&)
7$$
QG
5&
1XPGHREV
/RJOLNHOLKRRG PRGHORFRPSOHWR
/5FKL
3URE!FKL
3VHXGR5
2WHVWHGH5D]mRGH9HURVVLPLOKDQoDTXLTXDGUD
-GRLR chi2FRQVLVWHTXHSHORPHQRVXPGRVFRH¿
-FLHQWHVGHUHJUHVVmRQmRVHMDLJXDOD]HURQRPRGHOR $RYHUL¿FDUTXHRPRGHORDSUHVHQWDGRpJOREDOPHQ
-WH YiOLGR LQGLFDVH TXH RV FRH¿FLHQ-WHV HVWLPDGRV DSUHVHQWDPFRQMXQWDPHQWHDMXVWDPHQWRVDWLVIDWyULR $3URE!FKLpDSUREDELOLGDGHGHREWHUXPD HVWDWtVWLFDGHWHVWH/5WmRH[WUHPRTXDQWRRXDWp PDLVGRTXHDREVHUYDGDVREDKLSyWHVHQXODWR
-GRV RV FRH¿FLHQWHV GH UHJUHVVmR GR PRGHOR VmR LJXDLVD]HUReDSUREDELOLGDGHGHREWHUDHVWD
-WtVWLFDTXLTXDGUDGRVHKiGHIDWRQHQKXP HIHLWRGDVYDULiYHLVGHSUHYLVmR
2SYDORUGRWHVWHD¿UPDTXHSHORPHQRVXP GRVFRH¿FLHQWHVGHUHJUHVVmRGRPRGHORQmRpLJXDO D]HUR23VHXGR-RFRUURERUDPFRPDLQ
-GLFDomRGRERPDMXVWDPHQWRGRPRGHORDRVGDGRV REVHUYDGRV$SHVDUGHTXHSDUDDQDOLVDURJUDXGH DMXVWHHPXPDUHJUHVVmR7RELWpPDLVLQGLFDGRR WHVWH GH 5D]mR GH 9HURVVLPLOKDQoD TXLTXDGUDGR LR chi2 Mi TXH D LQWHUSUHWDomR GR SVHXGR5
QmRpDPHVPDGR5SRUpPFRPFDXWHODSRGH
-VHDQDOLVDUFRPRXPDDSUR[LPDomRGDYDULDomRGD YDULiYHOGHSHQGHQWHVREUHDYDULiYHOLQGHSHQGHQWH $LQWHUSUHWDomRGRVFRH¿FLHQWHVȕQmRVmRWmR GLUHWRVTXDQWRIHLWRVHPXPDUHJUHVVmROLQHDUSRLV PXGDQoDV QDV YDULiYHLV H[SOLFDWLYDV WrP HIHLWR QmRVyVREUHDPpGLDGDYDULiYHOVHGHQWURGROLPL
-WHGHWHUPLQDGRPDVWDPEpPVREUHDSUREDELOLGD
-GHGHHVWDUGHQWURGROLPLWH$SHVDUGDVOLPLWDo}HV RVUHVXOWDGRVLQGLFDPTXHDVYDULiYHLV)RUPDomR %UXWDGH&DSLWDO)L[R)%&)&RQVXPRGH&RP
-EXVWtYHLV)yVVHLV&&)H5HQGDVGH&DUYmR5& SRVVXHP XP HIHLWR QHJDWLYR VREUH R HVFRUH GH H¿FLrQFLDHQTXDQWRDVYDULiYHLV7D[DGH$OIDEH
-WL]DomRGH$GXOWRV7$$H4XDOLGDGHGR*RYHUQR 4*JHUDPXPHIHLWRSRVLWLYR
3RGHVH FRQFOXLU TXH DV YDULiYHLV )%&) &&)H5&LPSDFWDPQHJDWLYDPHQWHQRtQGLFHGH HFRH¿FLrQFLD,(DXPDVLJQL¿FkQFLDGH2X VHMDTXDQWRPDLRUIRUDIRUPDomREUXWDGHFDSLWDO ¿[R TXDQWR PDLV DV HPSUHVDV DXPHQWDUHP VHXV EHQVGHFDSLWDOEHQVTXHVHUYHPSDUDSURGX]LURX
-WURVEHQVDWHQGrQFLDpTXHR,(GLPLQXD$XPHQ
-WDQGRRFRQVXPRGHFRPEXVWtYHLVIyVVHLVKiXPD GLPLQXLomRGR,(RPHVPRRFRUUHFRPDVUHQGDV DGYLQGDVGHFDUYmR
$VFRQVWDWDo}HVGRPRGHORHFRQRPpWULFRPRV
-WUDPTXHD7D[DGH$OIDEHWL]DomRGH$GXOWRV7$$ ±DXPQtYHOGHHD4XDOLGDGHGR*RYHUQR4*
±DXPQtYHOGHLPSDFWDPGHIRUPDSRVLWLYD QR,(HPRVWUDUDPVHVLJQL¿FDQWHV8PDXPHQWR QD7$$LQFRUUHHPXPDXPHQWRGR,(MiTXHHV
-SHUDVHTXHTXDQWRPDLVHGXFDGDIRUDSRSXODomR PDLVFRQVFLrQFLDHFROyJLFDHVWDVWHUmRDX[LOLDQGR DVVLP QD GLPLQXLomR GRV LPSDFWRV FDXVDGRV DR PHLRDPELHQWHSHORVHUKXPDQR$4*DXPHQWDQ
-GRWDPEpPVHHVSHUDTXHR,(DXPHQWHSRLVXP JRYHUQRPHQRVFRUUXSWRTXHVHJXHDVOHLVHFRPD EXURFUDFLDQDPHGLGDTXHQmRDWUDSDOKHRGLDDGLD GDVHPSUHVDVHGRVFRQVXPLGRUHVpHVSHUDGRTXH WHQKDPXPDPDLRUSUHRFXSDomRFRPDSUHVHUYDomR GRVUHFXUVRVQDWXUDLVSDUDDVIXWXUDVJHUDo}HV
5 CONCLUSÕES E SUGESTÕES
2VUHVXOWDGRVUHIHUHQWHVDRtQGLFHGHHFRH¿FL
-rQFLD,(DRORQJRGRVDQRVGHHVWXGRVPRVWUDP TXHRYDORUPpGLRGLPLQXLX8UXJXDLH1RUXHJD DOFDQoDUDP R YDORU Pi[LPR GR ,( HP WRGRV RV DQRVDQDOLVDGRV2VSLRUHVUHVXOWDGRVGR,(IRUDP DOFDQoDGRVSHODËQGLDHD&KLQD2%UDVLOFODVVL¿
-FRXVHFRPRRTXDUWRSLRUSDtVHHVWDUHQWUHRVFLQ
-FRSDtVHVTXHPDLVHPLWHPJDVHVGRHIHLWRHVWXID FRQWULEXLXSDUDHVWHPDOUHVXOWDGR
2V(VWDGRV8QLGRVIRUDPSLRUDQGRRVHXUHVXOWD
-GRGXUDQWHRSHUtRGRDQDOLVDGRRFXSDQGRDQRQDSLRU FODVVL¿FDomR$WpRDQRGHRV(VWDGRV8QLGRV HUDPRPDLRUHPLVVRUGRVJDVHVGRHIHLWRHVWXIDSR
-UpPDSDUWLUGHSHUGHXHVVHSRVWRSDUDD&KLQD (PUHODomRjFODVVL¿FDomRGR,(HRQ~PHURGHSD
-tVHVSHUWHQFHQWHVDFDGDLQWHUYDORHPWRGRVRVDQRVR ,(PXLWREDL[RREWHYHRPDLRUQ~PHURGHSDtVHV1R DQRGHRPDLRUQ~PHURGHSDtVHVVHFRQFHQWURX QR,(PXLWREDL[RVHJXLGRSHOR,(DOWR-iHP HVVDVLWXDomRVHPRGL¿FRXR,(PXLWREDL[RFRQWL
-QXRXLQWHJUDQGRRPDLRUQ~PHURGHSDtVHVLQFOXVLYH FRPDXPHQWRPDVRVHJXQGRLQWHUYDORFRPRPDLRU Q~PHURGHSDtVHVSDVVRXDVHURFXSDGRSHOR,(EDL[R
1RDQRGHRVFRQWLQHQWHVSUHGRPLQDQWHV QR,(PXLWREDL[RIRUDPRDPHULFDQRHRDVLiWLFR $R¿QDOGRSHUtRGRHVWXGDGRRFRUUHUDPPXGDQ
-oDV VLJQL¿FDWLYDV 2 FRQWLQHQWH DVLiWLFR SDVVRX DSUHGRPLQDUHRFRQWLQHQWHHXURSHXTXHQRDQR GHVyREWHYHXPSDtVD5~VVLDSDVVRXDVHU FRPSRVWRSRUSDtVHV
2VUHVXOWDGRVUHIHUHQWHVjUHJUHVVmR7RELWLQGL
-WRQHJDWLYRVREUHR,(HQTXDQWRDVYDULiYHLV7D[D GH$OIDEHWL]DomR GH$GXOWRV 7$$ H 4XDOLGDGH GR*RYHUQR4*JHUDPXPHIHLWRSRVLWLYR
(VVHVUHVXOWDGRVVXJHUHPTXHPXLWRDLQGDSUH
-FLVDVHUIHLWRSDUDTXHGHIDWRRVQ~PHURVDFHUFD GDHFRH¿FLrQFLDSRVVDPVHWRUQDUUHOHYDQWHVHHV
-VHQFLDLVQDIRUPXODomRGHSROtWLFDVS~EOLFDVHQD FRQVFLHQWL]DomRGDSRSXODomRHPJHUDO
2HVWXGRUHYHODWDPEpPTXHWDQWRSDtVHVULFRV FRPRRVHPHUJHQWHVHSREUHVHVWmRSROXLQGRRDP
-ELHQWHSRUpPRVSDtVHVULFRVHHPHUJHQWHVHVWmR SROXLQGRHPXPDSDUFHODEHPPDLRUMiTXHSURGX
-]HPPDLVHDVVLPHPLWHPPDLVJDVHVFDXVDGRUHV GRHIHLWRHVWXIDSRLVDLQGDVmRPXLWRGHSHQGHQWHV GHFRPEXVWtYHLVIyVVHLV
8PDGDVSULQFLSDLVFRQFOXV}HVGRVUHVXOWDGRV REWLGRVpGHTXHPHVPRFRPRVFRPSURPLVVRVLQ
-WHUQDFLRQDLVGHFRRSHUDomRHQWUHRVSDtVHVFRPR REMHWLYRGHFRPEDWHURDTXHFLPHQWRJOREDOFRPR R3URWRFRORGH4XLRWRHVWHVPXLWDVYH]HVQmRHQ
-WUDPHPFRQVHQVRVREUHVXDVPHWDVGHGLPLQXLomR GHHPLVV}HVRXQmREXVFDPFRORFiODVHPSUiWLFD
$VXJHVWmRSDUDIXWXUDVSHVTXLVDVVHULDDLQFOX
-VmR GH PDLV YDULiYHLV HFRQ{PLFDV H DPELHQWDLV RDXPHQWRGDDPRVWUDHGRSHUtRGRXWLOL]DGRSR
-GHQGR REWHU UHVXOWDGRV PDLV DEUDQJHQWHV H PDLV SUy[LPRVGDUHDOLGDGH$PSOLDQGRDVVLPRFRQKH
-FLPHQWRVREUHRDVVXQWRQDEXVFDSRUPHOKRUHVDO
-WHUQDWLYDVSDUDVHDOFDQoDUDVXVWHQWDELOLGDGHWmR QHFHVViULDHXUJHQWHSDUDDVIXWXUDVJHUDo}HV
REFERÊNCIAS
$0(0,<$7DNHVKL7RELWPRGHOVDVXU
-YH\6WDQIRUG8QLYHUVLW\6WDQIRUG86$
Journal of Econometrics,S
$77(5,'*($DURQ$;%(5**|UDQ1LOVVRQ *2(/1LWX.80$5$WXO/$=$5860LFKD
-HO267:$/'0DGHOHQH32/<&$53&OLIIRUG 72//()6(13HWWHU7259$1*(5$VEM¡UQ 83$'+<$<$3UDEKDW=(77(5%(5*/DUV
Reducing greenhouse gas emissions in India Financial mechanisms and opportunities for EU-India collaboration.6WRFNKROP(QYLURQ
-PHQW,QVWLWXWH3URMHFW5HSRUW'LVSRQtYHO HPKWWSVZZZVHLLQWHUQDWLRQDORUJPH
-GLDPDQDJHUGRFXPHQWV3XEOLFDWLRQV&OLPDWH
-PLWLJDWLRQDGDSWDWLRQUHGXFLQJJUHHQKRXVHJDVH
-PLVVLRQVLQGLDSGI!$FHVVRHPVHWGH
%$1&2081',$/Dados ambientais,
eco-nômicos e sociais'LVSRQtYHOHPKWWS
ZZZZRUOGEDQNRUJ!$FHVVRHPMXO %(&.(50$1:(FRQRPLFJURZWKDQGWKHHQ
-YLURQPHQW:KRVHJURZWK":KRVHHQYLURQPHQW"
World DevelopmentYS
&$0$5(520DULDP&$67,//2-X
-DQD3,&$=27$'(2$QGUpV-7$
-0$5,7&HFLOLR(FRHI¿FLHQF\DQGFRQ
-YHUJHQFHLQ2(&'FRXQWULHVEnviron
Resource EconYQ
&$59$/+27HUFLDQH6DEDGLQL$/
-0(,'$(GXDUGR$KLSyWHVHGDFXUYDGH .X]QHWVDPELHQWDOJOREDOXPDSHUVSHFWL
-YDHFRQRPpWULFDHVSDFLDOEstudos
Eco-nômicos6mR3DXORYQ
&+(1$-:%28'5($80&:$7
-62157,QIRUPDWLRQV\VWHPVDQGHFRORJLFDO VXVWDLQDELOLW\Journal of Systems and
Infor-mation Technology
'(/*$'2)HUQDQGD)(%5$52-~OLD &URQRV&KLQDHDVVXDVTXHVW}HVGHVHJXUDQ
-oDHQHUJpWLFD&DGHUQR2SLQLmRCadernos
FGV Energia'LVSRQtYHOHPKWWS
ZZZIJYEUIJYHQHUJLDFURQRVBVHJXUDQ
-FDBHQHUJHWLFD¿OHVDVVHWVFRPPRQGRZQORD
-GVSXEOLFDWLRQSGI!$FHVVRHPRXW '(35,16'6,0$5/78/.(16+
0HDVXULQJODERULQHI¿FLHQF\LQSRVWRI¿F
-es, in the performance of public enterpris-es:FRQFHSWVDQGPHDVXUHPHQWV(GE\0
0DUFKDQG33HVWLHDXDQG+7XONHQV$PV
-WHUGDP1RUWK+ROODQGS (5..26DQQD0(/$1(10DWWL0,
-&.:,7=3HU(FRHI¿FLHQF\LQWKH¿QQLVK UHSRUWVDEX]]ZRUG"Journal of
Clean-er ProductionYS
(6&$381,7('1$7,216(&2120,&$1' 62&,$/&200,66,21)25$6,$$1'7+( 3$&,),&(FRHI¿FLHQF\LQGLFDWRUVPHDVXULQJ UHVRXUFHXVHHI¿FLHQF\DQGWKHLPSDFWRIHFR
-QRPLFDFWLYLWLHVRQWKHHQYLURQPHQW )('(5$/(19,5210(17$*(1&<*HU
-PDQ\DJUHHQKRXVHJDVQHXWUDO&RXQ
-WU\Background Paper'LVSRQtYHO
VLWHVGHIDXOW¿OHVPHGLHQSXEOLNDWLRQHQ JHUPDQ\BBDBJUHHQKRXVHBJDVBQHXWUDOBFRXQ
-WU\BODQJIDVVXQJSGI!$FHVVRHPQRY )5(,5(/XFLDQR(QHUJLDVUHQRYiYHLVFRP
-SOHPHQWDUHVCadernos FGV EnergiaQ
DQR'LVSRQtYHOHPKWWSV ELEOLRWHFDGLJLWDOIJYEUGVSDFHELWVWUHDP KDQGOHFDGHUQRHQHUJLDBIJY
-ERRNSGI!$FHVVRHPVHW
+286(57UHYRU%25'2))-DVRQ0$56
-7(563HWHUCan coal make a comeback?
&HQWHURQ*OREDO(QHUJ\3ROLF\&ROXPELD 'LVSRQtYHOHPKWWSHQHUJ\SROLF\ FROXPELDHGXVLWHVGHIDXOW¿OHV&HQWHUBRQB*OR
-EDOB(QHUJ\B3ROLF\B&DQB&RDOB0DNHB&RPHED
-FNB$SULOBSGI!$FHVVRHPQRY ,($,17(51$7,21$/(1(5*< $*(1&<Energy and Climate Change
:RUOGHQHUJ\RXWORRNVSHFLDOUHSRUW 'LVSRQtYHOHPKWWSVZZZLHDRUJSX
-EOLFDWLRQVIUHHSXEOLFDWLRQVSXEOLFDWLRQ :(26SHFLDO5HSRUWRQ(QHUJ\DQG&OL
-PDWH&KDQJHSGI!$FHVVRHPQRY
,167,7872'(35202&,Ï1'(,19(56,2
-1(6<(;3257$&,21(6Energias
Renova-bles.8UXJXD\;;,'LVSRQtYHOHPKWWS
ZZZGQHJXEX\GRFXPHQWV ,QIRUPHGHHQHUJ&$'DVUHQRYDEOHV
-$EUSGI!$FHVVRHPVHW .$8))0$11&pOLQH/(66&ULVWLQD7p
-EDU7(,&+0$11'RURWKHHCorporate Greenhouse gas emission reporting: a
sto-FNWDNLQJRIJRYHUQPHQWVFKHPHV2(&' ZRUNLQJSDSHUVRQLQWHUQDWLRQDOLQYHVWPHQW 2(&',QYHVWPHQW'LYLVLRQ'LVSR
-QtYHOHPZZZRHFGRUJGDILQYHVWPHQW ZRUNLQJSDSHUV!$FHVVRHPQRY .257(/$,1(10.8260$1(1 70HDVXULQJHFRH¿FLHQF\RISURGXF
-WLRQDIURQWLHUDSSURDFK'LVSRQtYHO HPZZZHFRQZSDUHSHFRUJHSVHPSD
-SHUVSGI$FHVVR /(+1,0DUNXV(FRHI¿FLHQF\FUH
-DWLQJPRUHYDOXHZLWKOHVVLPSDFW 6ZLW]HUODQG:%&6'
/83$10&2=25,&,$16XVWDLQD
-EOH(FRQRPLF*URZWKDQG(FRH¿FLHQF\ 7KH869$QQDOVRI(FRQRPLFVDQG3XEOLF $GPLQLVWUDWLRQY,VVXH 00$0,1,67e5,2'20(,2$0%,(1
-7(Entenda o acidente de Mariana e suas
FRQVHTXrQFLDVSDUDRPHLRDPELHQWH
'LVSRQtYHOHPKWWSZZZEUDVLOJRYEU PHLRDPELHQWHHQWHQGDRDFLGHQWH
-GHPDULDQDHVXDVFRQVHTXHQFLDVSDUDR
-PHLRDPELHQWH$FHVVRHPIHY 0217(3,2'HSDUWDPHQWRGHHVWXGRV1R
-UXHJD1RY'LVSRQtYHOHPKWWSV ZZZPRQWHSLRSWLZRYUHVRXUFHV6LWH3XEOLFR GRFXPHQWRVSWB37HPSUHVDVLQWHUQDFLRQDO UHVHDUFKPRQWHSLRUHVHDUFKLQWHUQDFLRQDO
-QRUXHJDSGI!$FHVVRHPQRY 2(&'25*$1,=$7,21)25(&2
-120,&&223(5$7,21$1''(9(
-/230(17(FRHI¿FLHQF\
2(&'25*$1,=$7,21)25(&2120,& &223(5$7,21$1''(9(/230(17 7RZDUGV6XVWDLQDEOH'HYHORSPHQW,QGLFDWRUV WRPHDVXUHSURJUHVV5RPD&RQIHUHQFH S'LVSRQtYHOHPKWWSZZZRHFGRUJVLWH ZRUOGIRUXPSGI!$FHVVRHPRXW 25*$1,=$d2'$61$d®(681,'$6 3$5$$*5,&8/785$($/,0(17$d2
$VÀRUHVWDVDLQGDFREUHPGDVXSHUIt
-cie da Terra'LVSRQtYHOHPKWWS
ZZZIDRRUJEUDVLOSW$FHVVRHPVHW 21825*$1,=$d2'$61$d®(6 81,'$6$FREHUWXUDÀRUHVWDOQD&KL -na'LVSRQtYHOHPKWWSZZZIDR
RUJEUDVLOSW!$FHVVRHPQRY
5$9,1'5$1$7+1+65,9$67$9$1DOLQ 0857+<,QGX.0$/$9,<$6XPHGKD 0816,0DGKXVKUHH6+$50$1LWDVKD 'HIRUHVWDWLRQDQGIRUHVWGHJUDGDWLRQLQ,QGLD ±LPSOLFDWLRQVIRU5(''Current Science,
YQ'LVSRQtYHOHPKWWSDG
52%$,1$$/9(60DUJDULWD0287,1+2 9LFWRU0$&('23HGUR$QHZIURQWLHUDSSURD
-FKWRPRGHOWKHHFRHI¿FLHQF\LQ(XURSHDQFRXQ
-WULHVJournal of Cleaner Production[[[
6&+0,'+(,1<6(FRHI¿FLHQF\DQGVXV -tainable development5LVN0DQDJHPHQW
$%,,1)250*OREDOYQ
72%,1-DPHV/LTXLGLW\SUHIHUHQ
-FHDVEHKDYLRUWRZDUGVULVNReview of
Economics Studies)HE
81)&&&&219(1d248$'52'$6 1$d®(681,'$662%5(08'$1d$'2 &/,0$&RQWULEXLo}HVGH&XEDSDUDDVHPLV
-V}HVJOREDLV'LVSRQtYHOHPKWWS ZZZPPDJRYEUFOLPDFRQYHQFDRGDV
-QDFRHVXQLGDV!$FHVVRHPRXW
86'$'(3$57$0(172'($*5,&8/785$ '26(67$'2681,'26)DWRVHWHQGrQFLDV KLVWyULFDVGDVÀRUHVWDVGRV(VWDGRV8QLGRV
:DVKLQJWRQ'LVSRQtYHOHPKWWSVZZZ IVIHGXVVLWHVGHIDXOW¿OHVOHJDF\B¿OHVPHGLD
W\SHVSXEOLFDWLRQ¿HOGBSGIB)RUHVW)DFWVB 3RUWXJXHVHBBBSGI!$FHVVRHPQRY 9(5Ë66,02$GDOEHUWR1866%$80
5XWK8PUHVXPRGRVWDWXVGDVÀRUHVWDV
em países selecionadosQRWDWpFQLFD%H
-OpP,PD]RQ7KH3URIRUHVW,QLWLDWLYH :%&6':25/'%86,1(66&281&,/ )256867$,1$%/('(9(/230(17&UH
-DWLQJPRUHYDOXHZLWKOHVVLPSDFW :25/'(1(5*<&281&,/World
Ener-gy Resources 2016'LVSRQtYHOHPKWWSV
ZZZZRUOGHQHUJ\RUJZSFRQWHQWXSORD
-GV:RUOG(QHUJ\5HVRXUFHV)XOO
-UHSRUWSGI!$FHVVRHPVHW =+$1*.:$1*5+$16621//,8-:$1*<,PSOHPHQWLQJVWULFWHUHQYLURQPHQWDO UHJXODWLRQWRHQKDQFHHFRHI¿FLHQF\DQGVXVWDL
-QDELOLW\DFDVHVWXG\RI6KDQGRQJ3URYLQFH¶V SXOSDQGSDSHULQGXVWU\&KLQDJournal of
