! ["#] $ ! % "&
$ ' ! ' ( (
( ( ( (
$ ' ( ' ! ) ' ( !
$ ! ! ' !' ! ! %& ' ! ! ' ! '
* ( ! !
!"!#$"%% "! &% "%'('$#")
8,1æ(1-(56798=$ä7,7(æ,9271(
65(',1(
8 UDGX VX SULND]DQL HNVSHULPHQWDOQL UH]XOWDWL LVWUDçLYDQMD PRJXþQRVWL SULPHQH IRQWDQVNRJ L IRQWDQVNR²IOXLGL]RYDQRJ VORMD X WUHWPDQX RWSDGQLK PDWHULMDOD SUH KUDPEHQH LQGXVWULMH L IOXLGQR²PHKDQL ND LVWUDçLYDQMD LVWRVWUXMQRJ IRQWDQVNRJ VORMD NDR RVQRYH ]D QMHJRYX SULPHQX X VLVWHPLPD ]D WUHWPDQ YRGD VD LPRELOL VDQLP PLNURRUJDQL]PLPD ,VSLWLYDQL VLVWHPL VX SULPHQMHQL X SURFHVX VXåHQMD çL YRWLQMVNH NUYL L NUYQH SOD]PH NDR MHGQRP RG PRJXþLK HNRORåNLK UHåHQMD X NODQL QRM LQGXVWULML L VXåHQMD SLYVNRJ NYDVFD NDR RWSDGQRJ PDWHULMDOD SLYDUVNH LQGXVWULMH NRML VX X VOX DMX QHNRQWUROLVDQRJ LVSXåWDQMD X SULURGQH UHFLSLMHQWH YHRPD RSDVQL ]DJDLYD L 8 GUXJRP GHOX UDGD MH SULND]DQD IOXLGQR²PHKDQL ND NRQFHSFLMD LVWRVWUXMQRJ IRQWDQVNRJ VORMD NRMD EL RPRJXþLOD PLNURELRORåNL WUH WPDQ YRGD X] LVWRYUHPHQX DHUDFLMX X SURFHVLPD QLWULILNDFLMH DPRQLMD QRJ D]RWD
' 3RYUHQRYLþ 7HKQRORåNR²PHWDOXUåNL IDNXOWHW .DUQHJLHYD %HRJUDG
H²PDLO SRYUHQRYLFHODEWPIEJDF\X
5DG VDRSåWHQ QD VNXSX 6DYUHPHQH WHKQRORJLMH L SULYUHGQL UD] YRM 2NWREDU ² /HVNRYDF NDR VHNFLMVNR SUHGDYDQMH X RNYLUX UDGD 6HNFLMH ]D KHPLMVNR LQçHQMHUVWYR
! " # ! $ ! %
"& " ' ( ( ( ( ! " ( # ( )* ( $ ( )* (%
! " # $! % ! & ' &! ( % ) * + , & " % % - .% % " % % % % & % / R# !
0 % . . 1 2
,3²
% [4] ,3²& 1 - ,5 ,3² ,3²! [/] . - - 1 -
,1 %- 3 % - 1 1 -
,5+−−−→2 − −−−−→2 ,3−
$ 1 - 5 &
L RGJRYRUQL ]D QLWULILNDFLMX NRMD VH VDVWRML RG GYH ID]H 3UYD ID]D SUHGVWDYOMD RNVLGDFLMX DPRQLMDND GR QLWUL WD NRMX REDYOMD 1LWURVRPRQDV L QD]LYD VH QLWULWDFLMD 'UX
JX ID]X LQL RNVLGDFLMD QLWULWD GR QLWUDWD NRMX REDYOMD 1L WUREDFWHU L NRMD VH QD]LYD QLWUDWDFLMD PDGD VX QDMQRYLMD LVWUDçLYDQMD SULPHQRP WHKQLND DQDOL]H ULER]RPDOQH 51. SRVHEQR ),6+ PHWRGH IOXRUHVFHQWQD KLEUL GL]DFLMD SRND]DOD GD VX 1LWURVRFRFFXV PRELOLV L 1LWURV SLUD GRPLQDQWQH SRSXODFLMH QLWULILNXMXþHJ DNWLYQRJ PXOMD IDEULND ]D SUHUDGX LQGXVWULMVNLK RWSDGQLK YRGD VD YHOL NRP NRQFHQWUDFLMRP DPRQLMDND 1LWURVRVSLUD L 1LWURVSLUD VSS VX GRPLQDQWQH SRSXODFLMH QLWULILNXMXþHJ UHDNWRUD VD IOXLGL]RYDQLP VORMHP NRML UDGL VD PDOLP NRQFHQWUDFLMDPD DPRQLMDND 1LWURVRPRQDV L 1LWURVSLUD VX GRPLQDQWQH SUL SUHUDGL RWSDGQH YRGH GRPDþLQVWYD
8NXSQD MHGQD LQD QLWULILNDFLMH JGH MH X]HW X RE]LU L EDNWHULMVNL UDVW JODVL
1+ 2 +&2²→
→ &+21 +2 12² +&2
JGH &+21 SUHGVWDYOMD EDNWHULMVNX ELRPDVX ,] RYH MH GQD LQH PRçH VH L]UD XQDWL GD MH ]D VYDNL PJ D]RWD X REOLNX 1+RNVLGRYDQRJ GR 12²QHRSKRGQR PJ 2L PJ +&2² PJ L]UDçHQR NDR &D&2 6WR JD LQWHQ]LYQD DHUDFLMD SUHGVWDYOMD L RVQRYQL XVORY ]D L]YRHQMH SURFHVD QLWULILNDFLMH 3URFHV QLULILNDFLMH WM XNOD QMDQMH DPRQLMD QRJ D]RWD L] YRGH PRçH VH REDYOMDWL X UHDNWRULPD VD LPRELOLVDQLP PLNURRUJDQL]PLPD X IOXLGL]R YDQLP IRQWDQVNLP L IRQWDQVNR²IOXLGL]RYDQLP VORMHYLPD SUL HPX MH X RYRP UDGX LVSLWLYDQ IRQWDQVNL VORM VD DHUL VDQLP DQXOXVRP
(.63(5,0(17$/1, 6,67(0
[] !" # $% $$ & $$ ' ( & )* & +, &! - & " . " & " / $0 "
! ! "
# ! $ % ! & "
' ()* +, (- *.4 / & & (
0 " & " !
" "
0
& %
1 " & 0 " 2 -
S ² ² ²
ρS !" " "
ε "# $"
! " # $% & # ' ! ( ) " * + # # ! ! !
, " - .4/ #
04/ #
! ! *12 1 %2
* ! " ) # ! "
# 04/ 3 # 04/
" ! # ! 4%)5 3 ! ! ! 4 & # - # ! ! !
'# ! ! ) ! 6 # ! ! 1 2 ! !
& #
!4" # # ! $%
&$ '( ( ) (
* !4" # # ! $%
+ ,
$ # # ! $%
&$ + '( ( -*) )
* - # # ! $%
QMD MH ELR RGUHGLWL SDUDPHWUH NRG NRMLK MH XRSåWH PRJXþH GRVWLþL VWDQMH X NRPH þH VH REUD]RYDWL IRQWDQVNL VORM VD X GRQMHP GHOX SRWRSOMHQLP DQXOXVRP L JRUQMLP VXYLP GHORP X NRPH EL ELOR PRJXþH YUåLWL DHUDFLMX
=DYLVQRVW FLUNXODFLMH HVWLFD RG YLVLQH VORMD X DQX OXVX SUL NRQVWDQWQRP QLYRX YRGH X DQXOXVX SULND]DQD MH QD VOLFL 0RçH VH YLGHWL GD FLUNXODFLMD HVWLFD RSDGD VD SRUDVWRP YLVLQH YRGH X DQXOXVX VORMD L WDM SDG MH QD UR LWR L]UDçHQ NDGD MH VORM HVWLFD SRWRSOMHQ YRGRP
5H]XOWDWL SULND]DQL QD VOLFL SRND]XMX GD YLVLQD YR GH X DQXOXVX XWL H QD FLUNXODFLMX HVWLFD SUL NRQVWDQWQRP SURWRNX YRGH NUR] POD]QLFX 6D SRUDVWRP QLYRD YRGH X DQXOXVX VORMD GROD]L GR SRYHþDQMD FLUNXODFLMH HVWLFD X VORMX VYH GR GRVWL]DQMD YUHGQRVWL NDGD MH SRWRSOMHQ LWDY DQQXOXV GD EL QDNRQ WRJD VD SRYHþDQMHP QLYRD L L]QDG YLVLQH VORMD GROD]LOR GR SDGD YUHGQRVWL FLUNXODFLMH HVWL FD 2YDM WUHQG MH ]DSDçHQ X VYLP LVSLWLYDQLP VLVWHPLPD
&LUNXODFLMD HVWLFD SR LQMH GD VH VPDQMXMH QHSRVUHGQR SRVOH WUHQXWND NDGD VORM ELYD SRWRSOMHQ 1D LVWRM VOLFL VH PRçH XR LWL GD QHNH NULYH QHPDMX PDNVLPXP YHþ MH QML KRY WUHQG OLQHDUQR RSDGDMXþL ]DWR åWR MH FLUNXODFLMD HVWL FD PHUHQD VDPR NDGD MH QLYR YRGH ELR MHGQDN L L]QDG YLVLQH VORMD MHU SUL RGUHHQLP SURWRFLPD YRGH QLMH ELOR PRJXþH RVWYDULWL FLUNXODFLMX HVWLFD D GD VORM QH EXGH SRWSXQR SRWRSOMHQ
=$./-8ÿ$.
8 LQçLQMHUVWYX ]DåWLWH çLYRWQH VUHGLQH SRVWRMH GYD RVQRYQD SUDYFD D WR VX SUHYHQFLMD ]DJDHQMD L WUHWPDQ YHþ ]DJDHQRJ PHGLMXPD ,VWUDçLYDQMD SUH]HQWLUDQD X RYRP UDGX SRND]XMX GD VH GLVSHU]QL VLVWHPL X YLGX IRQ WDQVNRJ L IRQWDQVNR²IOXLGL]RYDQRJ VORMD VD XVSHKRP PRJX SULPHQLWL X RYLP SRVWXSFLPD
7UHWPDQ RWSDGQH NUYL L SLYVNRJ NYDVFD NDR YHRPD ]DJDXMXþLK PDWHULMD X FLOMX VSUH DYDQMD QMLKRYRJ QH NRQWUROLVDQRJ LVSXåWDQMD X SULURGQH UHFLSLMHQWH L GRELMD QMD SURL]YRGD VD RGUHHQRP NRPHUFLMDOQRP YUHGQRåþX MH PRJXþH REDYLWL QD IOHNVLELOQLP MHGLQLFDPD ]D VXåHQMH VD IRQWDQVNR²IOXLGL]RYDQLP VORMHP
,VWUDçLYDQMD IOXLGQR ² PHKDQL NLK NDUDNWHULVWLND LV WRVWUXMQRJ IRQWDQVNRJ VORMD VD FHQWUDOQRP FHYL VX RVQRY ]D GDOMD LVWUDçLYDQMD NRMD þH ELWL XVPHUHQD ND GHILQLVDQMX SDUDPHWDUD QHRSKRGQLK ]D ELRORåNL WUHWPDQ RWSDGQLK YRGD X RYDNYRP VLVWHPX
6,0%2/,
F ² SUH QLN FLOLQGUL QH NRORQH P ''7 ² SUH QLN FHQWUDOQH FHYL P GL ² SUH QLN POD]QLFH P GS ² SUH QLN HVWLFH P *S ² PDVHQL SURWRN HVWLFD NJK + ² YLVLQD VORMD P
+Z ² YLVLQD SRWRSOMHQRJ VORMD X DQXOXVX P / ² GXçLQD FHQWUDOQH FHYL P
O ² UDVWRMDQMH FHQWUDOQH FHYL RG GQD NRORQH P 0$ ² PDVHQL SURWRN IOXLGD QD GQX DQXOXVD NJK 01 ² PDVHQL SURWRN IOXLGD QD POD]QL QRP YRGX NJK 0$ ² PDVHQL SURWRN IOXLGD X DQXOXVX VORMD NJK 0P) ² PDVHQL SURWRN IOXLGD X QDVXWRP VORMX SUL PLQLPDOQR
IOXLGL]RYDQRP VWDQMX NJK
7$ ² WHSHUDWXUD YD]GXKD DQXODUQRJ YRGDR& 7% ² WHSHUDWXUD VORMDR&
7H ² L]OD]QD WHSHUDWXUDR&
71 ² WHSHUDWXUD YD]GXKD POD]QRJ YRGDR& X7 ² WHUPLQDOQD EU]LQD IOXLGD PV
9$ ² ]DSUHPLQVNL SURWRN IOXLGD QD GQX DQXOXVD PK 9P) ² ]DSUHPLQVNL SURWRN IOXLGD X QDVXWRP VORMX SUL PLQLPDOQR
IOXLGL]RYDQRP VWDQMX NJK
91 ² ]DSUHPLQVNL SURWRN IOXLGD QD POD]QL QRP YRGX PK 97 ² ]DSUHPLQVNL SURWRN IOXLGD SUL WHUPLQDOQRM EU]LQL
PK
ϖ ² EU]LQD HVWLFD PV
ε ² SRUR]QRVW VORMD
ρS² ² JXVWLQD HVWLFD NJP
! "
/,7(5$785$
[1] !"#$ %$ &'!#! ()*!"#)+(,-.)/!)0 ",)1! ) )"23. "(3+/)!&$ )#*)3"#! "3*!41!$ '),) 5#)+*!,-35# (!#-,**$ 6/3.** - 7)03!-$ 7)03! 8
[2] -#)/9$ $ &/)(!. *3)(!. ()*!"# ()*!"#)+(,-.)/! ",)1/ #!) )/ ""* /5(!.)0 #)*!#*!&$ )#*)3"#! "3*!41!$ '),)5#)+*!,-35# (!#-,**$ 6 /3.** - 7)03!-$ 8:
[3] ;3<!/ 9$ =7$ &"2*/!1 '!# ()*!"#)0 ",)1! "! #)*3),"! #3*!1 "*4!&$ )#*)3"#! "3*!41!$ '),)5#)+*!,-35# (!#-,**$ 6/3.** - 7)03!-8:8
[4] )/3)/9$ &-51 "-"2.1! - ()*!"#)+(,-.) /!) ",)1-& )#*)3"#! "3*!41!$ '),)5#)+*!,-35# (!#-,**$ 6/3.** - 7)03!- 88>
[5] 3"1/9$ $ &6#,!1!1 *,)#"! . )*2!' 0!") /! - #)<)/!) ""*- !"2)3<3?#!*!,* # 3!# *)3&$ !0"*!3"# 3!$ '),)5#)+*!,-35# (!#-,**$ 6/3.** - 7)03!-$ 888
[6] @)'3$ A$ &),,-*) A)*3), ()3 034-,*-3&B 4!4 3""$ 4 3,!)$ %@$ 8:>
[7] @!C")$ 7$ D D--"$ ,)" E"$ ! D 4)** &E3!-,4 3()3!4 ! *3(4!*) !*" )( ! A)*-)-"+A,!0 %,)!*0 ! 7)(,*3& 23"* !* F-!4-,*-3 34! G8H 3,0*) I!" J)3, F-!4-,*-3 )4*E ! !*)!, F-!4-,*-3 "")4!* ) 7))# )( <"*3!4*" 20 :H$ 88H
[8] )/3)/9$ $ *31/9+73!#)/9$ $ 3E0 )( <
),)04!, !*3!," ! "2)-*+(,- < C*' 3!(* *-<$ > >+>H
6800$5<
7+( $33/,&$7,21 2) ',63(56( 6<67(06 ,1 (19,5210(17$/ (1*,1((5,1* 6FLHQWLILF SDSHU
'UDJDQ 63RYUHQRYLþ
)DFXOW\ RI WHFKQRORJ\ DQG PHWDOOXUJ\ .DUQHJLHYD %HOJUDGH
! •
" • " •
# •
$ ! • %& $ • %& $• '$ ( ' •
