Instrumentalidade e efetividade do processo : ressistematização das tutelas antecipadas

(1)

(2)

!! "#$ "% ! & "'" ( ) *+ ! %" ( " %" " " , &#$ ' - + ' ! ) % ")" ' .!/ "'+"#$ '" "(+ '"' ' '" & 0-( " & 1 ! '"' " . (" '

"&' ' +

(3)

6

!""# $$%

&' (

)*+,

- . / ' + 0 1

$ * ! 0

2 0 * 3 4 5 0 )

, 6 % + 7 -78

0 1 . / ' + 09

(4)

7

!! "#$ "% ! & "'" ( ) *+ ! %" ( " %" " " , &#$ ' - + ' ! ) % ")" ' .!/ "'+"#$ '" "(+ '"' ' '" & 0-( " & 1 ! '"' " . (" '

"&' ' +

% 1"' )2 8888 ' 8888888888888888 ' 888888888

9 :

8888888888888888888888888888888888888 & "' 2 3 !4 " " !" !5 &

888888888888888888888888888888888888

(5)

;

! ) +! %" !< 4 = "< % "( ' " ) ) ) ) ' !' ! % ) !

%"!! ! ' ) &5" 1 '"

! ) +! )$ !< &' 4 "0" < , 5"& ! "'1 "' !< % !! "! *+ ! )% ) "( )%"&5" ") ">+'" ")

' ! ! 0") " ! *+ ! )% ! 1 ") " ) + "' " ("'" " ?"#$

! ) +! ( "! ' !( . *+ ( ) ! + "% < ">+'" ( )% &!$ < &" ") % !!-1 " " ?"#$ ' ! "," 5

! ( )% & & ! ' ) &5" ,"&("< ! , 5"& ! % 0 !! ! "&

"&( !( ' 4 , % "! ( - ("! ! &( "! *+ )+

( & ,+- ") %" " ! =

(6)

(7)

B

% ! & ! +' ( &( & "/! &+)" "&@ ! '"! ' !% ! #C ! ' & *+ "& D "& ( %"#$ ' + " D + " ("+ " < ( ) 1 ! "! " +)"

!! ! )" ?"#$ < ,+!("&' < "!! )< % % ( " )"

&! +) & " '"' " % ( !! < &"' / )" ! 0 1 +" ) & < & !! (.' ' % ( !! " " '"! ) ' '"! "& ( %"'"! ("+ " ! ) ' !% ! 1 ! ' !% ! !

! "," 5 < !+ /! " ( &( & "#$ ' ' ! ! ' !% ! 1 ! & 1 < &" ) & ' ! &"' "% &"! D! + "! ("+ " ! &' /! " &'" ' ) &! " " & ( !! '"' ' +)" )" "% = )"#$ % ( ' ) & " '"! + "! ("+ " ! "& ( %"'"! $ ", '"'"! % % ! "! ' 0 )"! ! " 1"! *+ ,+!(")

0 ( ! & 0 (" 1"! )+'"&#"! " ! &! + ! &'"< !$ "% ! & "'"! *+ ! C ! " 1"! D "& ( %"#$ ' + " " ! ! )" (+ !"

2 + " & ( %"'" + " "+ " ! + "#$ &! +) & " '"' 0 1 '"' ! ", ?"#$ + " & " !0" 1" + E& )"

(8)

5 % ! & ! +'F ( &( & " ! & "& "&" F! ! 0 5 ' !% ! &! 0 5 ' 0 5 1 ( !! " ' 5 "& ( %" & 0 &>+&( & "&' % ("+ &" F &>+&( &< G" '! " !F! )" ?" & < F & % % " " " &! +) & " F 5 % ( !!< + & & ) 00 ( 1 G"'"F!< + ( ' 0 % ( !! ( 1 ! 5 "& ( %" ' ) "!+ ! "&' &>+&( &! & ' !% ! ' % & ! & 5 ! G H ! !+ ! ' ( &( & " " "!% ( ! & , H < &" F ' ! & ' !% ( 0 (" F % ("+ &" F &>+&( &! ! ! & &' ' ' ) &! " 5 & ' 0 % = ) F % ( !! ! 0 "& ( %" ' "&' % ("+ &" F &>+&( &! ! " 1

0 )! " % % ! ' 00 ! & 0 ("& (5"& ! 5 &! + ! < ! ) % & ! " ' "& ( %" & 0 &>+&( & "&' 5 "%% " & !F! ) " ! &

! "# $ 2 & ( %" ' &>+&( & ("+ &" F &>+( & ! + " & &! +) & " F 00 ( 1 & !! ", ?" & & " !0 ' )"& & &>+( &

(9)

I

%

!"#$%$% &$ '#$( !)*+,

-,.) '$/01.,() 23$-,%% 4 56)'*) &, -$ #,7 -89'( ) 2!$- 8, ') &$4,-)7

:0%, &, -$ #, &$ $;$%)

$'#$'*) )-( )5 &$ <- #, 2 )-#$ '(,'#-,.$-%)7 = ; (>( )% '#$( !>.$ %

;$# .)*+,

? '(-$# %4, -,($%%0)5 @ 0'8 : 5 &)&$ &)% 0#$5)% 3

=

A =

A =?

3 B =

! " " # $ %

&' ( ) $ ($

(( % ( ! " "

C D ?

* ?

E F 3 ?

? F

= 3

A 3

+ ,

(10)

J

&

% ! & "," 5 1 !" " ! +'" '4 "! ' !! ! )" ?"#$ '"! + "! "& ( %"'"! ) & !! ! ! )" % ( !!+" < " 0 ) ' &" )" ! ( " "! "! "! % & & ! " &! + < % ( &! *KL&( "< &" % ( !! )" ! 0 1 %#$ ' "," 5 4 % +)" 1 !$ 0 = 1"< 1 ! *+ ,+!(" ' & 0 (" % , )"!

0 ( ! +#C !

)" ( & ( " ' ! +' 4 .' ' JIB6< *+" ! @ "),4) 0 '

( ) (.' ' 9+?" '< ( & "% &' /! " (.' 0 )"' < ), "< 0 )" ) & < ! >" ) !) " & & ' !$ % ( ! ! " "0 )" *+ ( )

"'1 & '"! ! I; MJII7< J 777M JJ 6 M ; ) ! ' ! .' !< '

9+?" ' 0 )"' J

' JIB6 % ( & ?"1" +)" ' 1 !$ ! "&*+ & ! % ( !! ! ' ( &5 ( ) & < = (+#$ ("+ " % ( !! ' ( &5 ( ) & &$ "+ ?"1" & &5+) "# ' = (+#$ < &*+"& " = (+#$ &$ "+ ?"1" ( &5 (

% ( !! ("+ " ! " +) *+ ( )% " " " ) !) )% "!

0+&#C ! ' ( &5 ( ) & = (+#$ < ( ) ) & !% (-0 ( ' % 1 &#$

" ' 1 !$ >@ &$ )" ! % ! ! % ( !! " +" 4 ! &( 4 ( < + ! >"< "+ ?" " %" < ) +)" ) !)" "#$ >+ -' ( /% ( !!+" < ( &5 ( < = (+ " "("+ " "& ( %"#$ ' + " & , > ' % ( !! ' ( &5 ( ) & "+ ? + " !

= (+ 1 ! "& ! '" ! & &#" %" @ "0 BN ' " B6 ' "+ ? + ' 0 ) & ' ) ' '" ("+ " ! ) " & ( !! '"' ' "#$ "+ E& )" ! & &#" ( &' &" . " 4 = (+ "'" & ! % .% ! "+ ! '" "#$ ' ( &5 ( ) & % ! )% ! % ' ' ' (+)% ) & '" ! & &#"< &$ = &' & 1" "#$ "+ E& )"< % " & 1"

'"#$ ' " 7B; '

(.' "),4) 0 ) ' 0 ("' & *+ "& " ! ! )" (+ !" (.' ' 9+?" ' % 1 " " "% "#$ ( ) (+ ! (",-1 ' ! & &#" *+ = & + !!

J

< + ? + 5 ) O < "& "&( !( '$()# $ #* # ( (

#+ ,- $# -()# .# -()# $ "+ 2 ' 1 ! " ' ! ,+&" !< < % I6

(11)

JJ

% ( !! " "1 %" " ! 1 *+ ! $ &( ' & 6 " '"#$ '"'" " " 7B; P

< %" @ "0 6N ' < " ' ( !$ *+ ! 1 " )%+ &"#$ 4 ( -1 %

" "1 ' &! +) & < !" 1 *+"&' )% " ) = &#$ '" = (+#$ < ("! ) *+ (", @ "% "#$

( "!! 0 ("#$ '"! 0 (@( "! ! & &( " ! ' ' JIB6< ! + &' " "' #$ " "&"< " &" "< &$ "') &' < % "& < " ) & ! =% !!") & < "! 0 (@( "! = (+ 1" )"&'") & " " ! 0 (@( "!< " +" ) & < !$ % &") & "') '"!< ( &0 ) ) 5 ! @ ' ) &! "' ) ("%- + !% (-0 (

! = )% ! '"' ! ' ) &! ") *+ (.' 5 > 1 & ) )+ !

' ! "&( + '"*+ ' 9+?" '< ! >" ) "?$ ' )+'"&#"! ! + + " !< ! >" % 0 )"! % & +" !

&1 ! "#$ "*+ 0 "< % !+" 1 ?< ! "% 0+&'" @ )" ! ! , " ' + &" "%.! (.' ' JIB6 + ! >"< " ' + &" ( @!! (" ! , " )" 4 "< ' & ! *+" !< !5 & < 1-' < < " & & < 5 !< , ) ( ) ! ( @!! ( ! " "& !< *+ % ' !< ! ), " @ ' " ")"&' < "+ ! !! ! *+ >@ ' !1 &'" ") ( ) )" ! " (") &5 "#"' ! ! +' " % % ! " ! @ + "< " ' ' & 0 (" % , )"! & ! ! )" % ! < ) "&' 0+ + < >@ &$ %"!!"' + "' < ( " *+ " 1 +#$ ' .' ' 9+?" ' ! % &( %" ! ) & ! '" "& ( %"#$ ' + " ! $ ", '"' !

0" 4 *+ )+&' ! 0 + )+ "! ) ' 0 ("#C ! & + ! 0" !< " 0 0 ("#$ ' "( !! D >+! #"< " )"!! 0 ("#$ '"! "#C ! , "( &" ! " 1 +#$ '" &0 )@ ("< ' ! &("' " ") +) ! &!-1 "+) & & &Q) ' ' )"&'"! ">+ ?"'"! % &"! %" " ! +)" '4 " ' !! ( !( ) & < ) JIB6< "& ' !+" ' #$ < ), " &5" %"!!"' " 1 " "% &"! & "& ! + & < 0 ") ' ! ,+-' ! B ;7 % ( !! ! >+& " < &*+"& *+ ) B 0 ") JJ I6 7

6

=% ! #$ ' ) 1 ! ' .' ' ( !! 1 < % & 66

7

!% &-1 )2

(12)

J

"& < "! 0 )"! &$ !$ "% &"! % ! 1"!< )"! 0+&'") & " ! "

% ( !! ) ' & W ' 1 ' ! "' % ! 1 0 ( &! +) & ! %" " *+ "

>+ !' #$ ! >" % ! "'" ,! 1"&' ! % &(-% ! ( &! +( &" ! '" ( '"' < 0 1 '"' "? @1 '+ "#$ ' % ( !!

& "& < )+ "! 1 ? ! "! 0 )"! "(" ") % , )"! ' ! ! )" ?"#$ " "/! ' +)" " 0" @ '+" " '"#$ ' +) = " < ! ) '+, '"' + "(+&"< " &'" )" ! *+"&' " "/! ' +)" 0 )" ' +) (.' 'Q1 '" & 0 )" ' JI6I + ( " +) & 1 "!!" + 9+?" ' *+"&' '" ( "#$ ' " +" < &' "!! ) ! )"& 0 ! "' 2

& ( " ) ! ! ! +' ! ' %" " ")/! /& ! '+"! !+ ! C !2 1 .' 1 & + ", " .' & 1 % ) " &5" " 1"& " ) ' &$ & )% " ( & &+ '"' ! " 1" % "& '

"," 5 < , ) *+ ( )% &' &' " *+"! / " '"' ' ! % ( ! " !< ( & /! / " " )"& +' *+"& ! "1" ( &0 ) ( ) ! &+&( "' ! '" ( L&( "< ) &'"&' *+ 0 !! & ( !!@ < % &(5 &' "(+&"! !+% ) &' !+%4 0 + < *+ " '" "&'") & ' ! 0 !

"! " % +( % +( & ! ( &1 &( ) ! ' *+ " )" ! ' 0-(

( .' 1 5 *+ !( 1 +) & 1 ) &'" " .'

" +" *+ " +) ( &( ' % & C !< % ( !") & & ! % & ! ) *+ " 0 ' '"' " ! % &(-% ! &$ " "&! L&( "! *+"&' " ' !! &!$ 4 &!+% @1 < " &'L&( " 4 ' ! 1L/ " ) ' "& ( &( !!C !< *+ &$ " !"( 0 (") " 1 '"' ( & -0 (" " ) "!

"?C ! ' % +& '"' "&' )" '"! 0 )"! %" ( " ! 4 "&!0 )" .' ) ) !" ( < ( ) ( ' ! ' 1 ! ! *+ "'+? ) "! )" ! 1" "'"! ' #C ! !!"! 1@ "! 0 )"! ) =% L&( " %"-!O )"!< ( ) ,! 1 + % ! '" ! "< +)"! 0 ") %" " ) 5 < )"! ) + "!< " ) &'" !" + % *+ ! &

% ! ' ' ) "'" 0 =$ < 1 0 (") ! *+ % , )" " )+ )" ! ")% < "1 % 0+&' < " & &' " !+,! X&( " '"! &! + #C !< " ' !% ! #$ ' &"'" '"! )" 4 "! " & )" ( "#$ & " 0+&#$ ' % ( !! ( 1 " ! + + " X& (" '

' 3+' ( @ 3+! ") & % !! " & !!" " 0" &$ ! ) + D ) " 1 !$ )%+&5"/! 0"? .' ) !+"! &5"! 0+&'") & " !< '"&' / 5 & 1 % "& ' "( ' ( ) "! ( &*+ ! "! ) ' &"! "! =% L&( "! ' ! % 1 ! (+ ! !!" % (+%"#$ 0 ' " ?" +) "," 5 +& @ < "!! ) & % "& ' ! % &(-% !< ( ) & ' !+"! "% ("#C ! % @ ("!;

"!!"' ! )" ! ' & " "& ! '" ' #$ ' .' ' 9+?" '< &$ ! " ' !(", ' 0" " ) +) & 1 (.' < *+ ' ! ,+-!! "! )" 4 "! " 5 %. ! < %

;

(13)

J6

+ "' < &0 & " " % , )"! ' 1 ! ! " ( ) #" % " ' ) "< ! ) 1 '" "! *+ ! C ! *+ &1 1 ) " % - (" ! " 1" !! )< " ) 5 ! +#$ < & " +"

! @ < 4 " )"&+ &#$ '"! 0 )"!

) >@ 0 ' < *+ ! % &' & % ! & ! +' 4 +)"

!! ! )" ?"#$ '"! ) ' '"! *+ "& ( %") " + "< " 4) ' 0 ( " +)"! !+ ! C ! ( ) ,"! ) % > ! ' ! %" "1 "! ' 3 !4 + " ( " ' &" 1L) ' &( & " !%- % % ! & ! "," 5 2 Y &( ?" & !!" % &( %" "!% "#$ < *+" ! >"< " ' ( & ,+ %" " ( ) " ! )% 0 ("#$ ' % ( !! < *+ ! &' &! +) & %" " " " ?"#$ ' ' )" " < &$ % ' &$ ' 1 ! ( )% ("' YA

! ' !% ! 1 ! *+ (+ '") '" "& ( %"#$ ' + " !" !0" 1" '" + " ("+ " ") !4 ! % , )"! ' & % "#$ ), " & 4 % &5" 0 )"! ' !+% "(+&"!< " 0" " ' +)" & "#$ ( " " 4 % >+' ( " D >+ !' #$ < % ! " ' 0 (+ '"' ' " +"#$ ' ! % "' ! ' ' ! "'1 "' ! % ! + ") ' 0 )" *+ 1 ("'"< ! >+-? ! >+ ") ' 0 )" ' !+& 0 ) " ! +"#$ ( & ,+ %" " "

% 0 "#$ ' ! &0 "'" ' ! (+ ! !< " ) !) )% ) *+ " +)"

' !( &0 "&#" ' >+ !' ( &"' & ! ! )" !!" /! < " 4 " % &( %" 0 & ' & !! ' " ( " ?" ) !+" '"#$ ! ) & ( & ,+ ( ) " &! +) & " '"' ' % ( !! " 0 1 '"' '" >+ !' #$

! " ( " *+ "! 0 )"!< % ! !.< &$ ,"! " $ %" " ! 1 "! ' 0 (+ '"' ! '" >+ !' #$ < " 4 % *+ + ! % , )"! 5@ ! & "1 ! !+ ) ' !' ! ,"&( ! !( " !< %"!!") % " 0" " ' " +" ?"#$ ' ! % 0 !! &" ! % ) ' (+ ! ! ' = &!$ %.!/ "'+"#$ < !," ") ) % , )"! 0 &"&( !

&0 & "' ! % +) %"-! % , < *+ ! 0 ) ) ' 0 ( & ! + + " 0-! (" 5+)"&" ' ! ,+&" !

+ " "?$ ' "," ") & ' ! 0 ! 4 " ,+-'" " &Q) ' "'1 "' !< + '" 0" " ' (+ + " ) ,+!(" ! +#C ! &$ !"! 1 '"' 4 *+ +) 3+' ( @ "," "' 0 "+ ' >+! #" ' +) %"-! " "/! ' ) *+ -,

A

< 3 !4 + " ( "O Z 9 < !" +'" 1 ) - #* #

(14)

J7

&" + " '"! ( !"! $ ! ! @ "*+ " ' 0 &' "! ' ! ) @ "! + "! % ! + "#C ! ' !*+" 0 ("'"!< % ( & @ % &"! ! ,+!(" ' =" ( " *+ "& "! "#C ! ! $ ">+ ?"'"! *+"& ! 0 ) ! &Q) ! ' " '"' ! % " ("' ! %

)% !"! + % ' %Q, ( W 0 &E) & &" + " &"0"! @1

,+!(" % " 1 +#$ '" >+ !' #$ ' 1 ! ( &! "& ' "#$ ( &>+& " )% " ! . $ ! ' = (+ 1 " )% ) & "#$ ' % - ("! '+("( &" ! ", D! &! + #C ! &( & 1 D " +" ?"#$ % 0 !! &" < ! >") ' "'1 "' !< >+-? !< % ) !< % (+ "' !< &0 )< ' ' ! "*+ ! *+ & % ( !! " +") W & ( !!@ " " "( &" ?"#$ ' ! "! ! &" "') & ! "#$ ' ! ,+&" !

("' ) (") & < ,+!(") ! (+)% " & !!" %" < 0 ( &' "&@ ! % % ! "

' 0 )"! ( ) % " ! 0"?

"," 5 ' 1 ' /! ) L! ("%- + ! % &( %" !< *+ !$ ' 1 ' ' ! ) !+,/ ("%- + ! 0 ) !$ "% ! & "'"! % & +" ) & "! ( &( +!C ! '4 " ( & " 4 " +& $ ' ! ' !% ! 1 ! *+ " ") '"! + "! ("+ " ! "& ( %" . "! !" !0" 1"! & 1 ' < *+ " +" ) & " " '"! + "! ("+ " ! !! )< ' 1 ) ! ' ! ("' ! ! ' !% ! 1 ! % 1 ! ! & ! " ! B6 7AJ 9+!("/! < " &'"< +)" )" "% = )"#$ % ( ' ) & " ' " ! + "!

% ) ("%- + ,+!(" @< & ( " ) & < +) %"& ")" " ! , " >+ !' #$ % ( !! ( ) &! +) & %" " " & " '" + " >+ !' ( &"

!! + @ ( ) +)" ' ) &! "#$ '" 1 +#$ ' ' 9+?" '< ( ) L&0"! " % ( !! ' &@ < ("+ " "! ) ' '"! ' "& ( %"#$ ' + "

("%- + ! + & < ! +' ", '" @ % % ! "! ' 0 )" ! " 1"< ( ) " 0 &" '"' ' "+) & " " &! +) & " '"' ' % ( !! & *+ "&

!% ( 0 (") & "! ) ' '"! ' "& ( %"#$ ' + " ("+ " !

(15)

J;

/0 1

W ' 1 ' ! "' 0 ( " + " >+ !' ( &" ' 0 )" 0 1"< (4 ) )% "? @1

% ( !! 4 &! +) & %" " " % ! "#$ '" + " >+ !' ( &"

W ' 1 ' ! "' % " % ! "#$ &$ 0 ( "% &"!

!!" ( ) & % *+ 1" &

) &" 4 % 1 ) & >+' ( " % 0 ' & &-( ' % ( !! < &$ ! ( &0+&' &' ( ) "& ( %"#$ ' + " !" !0" 1" + + " ("+ "

"& ( %"#$ ' + " % ' @ ! !" !0" 1" + ("+ "

"& ( %"#$ ' + " !" !0" 1" ,! 1" *+ ! ! )" ! - ' ! *+ " "& ( %"#$ ' + " ("+ " %" " " !+" ( &( !!$

$ "& ( %@1 ! "! ( &( 0 (@( "! ! & &( " !< *+" ! ! >")< ' ( " " . "< ( &! + 1"< ( &' &" . "< = (+ 1" )"&'") & "

& ( %"/! " + " &$ "% &"! ! ! +! 0 !

"& ( %"#$ ' + " % ' @ ! ' 0 '" ) "?$ '" + L&( "< ",+! ' ' 0 !" 1 'L&( "

"& ( %"#$ ' + " ' %" &( & 1 !"< " "/! < ) 1 '"' < ' >+ ") & "& ( %"' '" ' 4 "% " " % '+? ( !" >+ "'" )" " ( )% "

= (+#$ ' 0 & 1"

(+ ! (",-1 '" ! & &#" %" ( " ' )4 4 " "1 ' &! +) & 0+& , '"' '"! + "! ' + L&( " "+ ?" ! ") & "& *+ ) & ' ) ' '" ("+ " & , > ' % ( !! ' ( &5 ( ) & ( ) ' ) ' '" !" !0" 1" ) % ( !! ("+ " "& ( ' &

! + "#$ 4 ) *+ ) 5 ' 0 & +)" + " "& ( %"'"< ! >" " ("+ " + !" !0" 1"

1 5"1 0 )" " " 0 ) ' *+ ! % ( ' ) & ! ("+ "

"& ( %" . ! ' + " ! >") =% !!") & +& 0 ("' !

(16)

JA

% ( !! "& ( ' & ' 1 @ ( )% " "& " + " !" !0" 1" ( ) "

("+ " < ) !) ( &' ( ) % ( !! ' &@

! ! )" " +" &$ "') " [ + " + & !" !0" 1" "+ E& )"Y

! + "! 1 !-1 ! ' 1 ) ! 1 "'"!< % 4)< !$ "') !!-1 ! ) & !! ! ! )" >+ -' (

!% &!", '"' ,> 1" % ! '"& ! ("+!"' ! % "*+ *+ +!+0 + ' + " "& ( %"'" "(" " +) ' ! *+ -, % ( !!+" ) 0"1 ' 4+

1 ! !% &!", ?"' !+,> 1") & "*+ *+ , 1 + "

"& ( %"'" % ) ' " ! (" "( ?"' ! ( ) )@\04 % ( !!+"

"' #$ '" [ + " + & !" !0" 1" "+ E& )"Y ) & !! ! ! )" >+ -' ( 1 " " ( & ,+ ( ) " &! +) & " '"' 0 1 '"' ' % ( !! < ) ! "&' /! < % "& < % ! 1"

" " " "' #$ '" [ + " + & !" !0" 1" "+ E& )"Y ) & !! ! ! )" ' 1 $ ! =( +-'"! " !% &!", '"' ,> 1" '"*+ *+ +!+0 + " + " "& ( %"'" " & ( !! '"' ' % !! + ) & ' % ( !! " 4 0 &"

! ", ?"#$ '" + " "& ( %"'" ! )% 0 (" % ( !! < ) ! "&' /! ) ! & & " ( ) "! % % ! "! ' ) ?"#$ ' % ( !! < ! &' ( ) &'@1 !+" "' #$

! ", ?"#$ '" + " "& ( %"'" &$ !+% ) ( & "' . < &"/ 1 & +"

"& ( %"#$ ' + " ' 0 '" ) ! & &#" 4 "% " " "' " 0 ! ' 0 )" ) ' " "

' ( !$ *+ 1 " " "& ( %"#$ ' + " ) ! & &#" &$ " 0 ! ) ' " !

W ( ) &'@1 *+ 5">" )+'"&#" ! " 1" %" " *+ ! >" ( , '" & 0 ) ") & ' 1 + 1 " "% "#$ '" ! & &#" *+ ' ( '" ! , " "& ( %"#$ ' + "< &$ "% &"! " *+ " ( &0 )

% ! ' & ' ,+&" 4 ( )% & %" " ( &5 ( ' ) ' '" + & "& ! '" & % ! #$ ' (+ ! !% ( " + = " ' &@

%.! >+-? ' "') !! , '"' 0 % ,+&" ' )< ( )% "

+ 3< ' & ' !+"! ( )% L&( "!< ( &5 ( ' ) ' '" + & < % 1 " ' ' '" "+ "

(17)

JB

)4 '" "#$ &$ ! ( &0+&' ( ) !( ' '"& " >+ !' ( &"' W 0"(+ "' " >+ ? >+ " % ( ' & +)" "#$ !+!% &' " !+" = (+#$ < ( )