Mineração de texto aplicada às publicações científicas sobre gestão do conhecimento no período de 2003 a 2012.

(1)

' ( ) * + (, -+ , + , . /0+ ,12 , /

! "

# $ # % &

'

! "

( )** +, , *-.,-/0.*-01-2/344*-134

! " #

$ %

% & '%

( $

) % *

+ % ,

% ) ! - ) .

/ ! 0 %

$ % 1

% ) +

)

! - % ) %

) ) % +

% 1 ) # %

$ $ # .

) 1 + %

% % !

2 ( ) 2 3

(2)

' ( ) * + (, -+ , + , . /0+ ,12 , /

!

"

4 .

56 7% ) 3 ) 5 63

++ ! 8

$ 9 + %

% 9 ( +

+ 7 :

* ++ 7 + ; # %

+ ) % ! < 7 % /

) $ ! = % 7 % )

63 9 +

% ) %9 + %

% %! <

) % % % ) 9 +

9 7 +

63 % ) # % : 7% ) 7 %

% # 9 )

++ % %

% !

5 67 ) 6 7% ) ) 2 = / )!

& , 0, /, ,

#

3 $ -- + 4 5

6

78 , 9 " 7 + 6 )

( + + 4:99#

;<=> >+ ?+ , @/-5+ ( 4:<A3B ::# A*9:;9A+ ?+ , ?5+

7 4'9&&>CC+ ?+ , @ 5+ 7 "

4;D A # :*A+ -+ , @ -5 " 43 A> *# >&;*# '*:>CC*+ -+

, -05, A ! + E $ )

( + 4:9*C9# >;C + ?+ ,

- 5+ 4 '>;+ ?+ , /5+ 7) (

4 '< A># ; 9;# >;C + -+ , -5+ 7 "

4 >AF :9F# &C*A;# C>:93>+ -+ , @?# & !9:> %!+ + ,

5+ ( " 7 4 >FF*+ + , 5 E

(3)

' ( ) * + (, -+ , + , . /0+ ,12 , /

> 6 6

( ! G ! G 4 + , 5+ ; H

%! 4 + , 5 ; 7 ; 4 + , /@5, ' = 7 + A H

& 4 + , / 5+ 7 " 2E

(E 8 ,

; 7 ' + ; ; 4 + , /@ 5+ 2E

7 ) 7 " I

,

+ ( ( ( (

4 + $ 7

$ 6 5 E

8 8 4 2E 5+

7 . J 6 7

I " K 6 +

7 K > 2 (

6 $+ + +

7 6

+ ,

> . ( 7 J

8 +

87 + E +

) " ,

$

%

, DE 6 6 7

+ + +

6 ,

&

'

+ ". E

L L, + ;( M 4 --N+ ,

5 A H 4 -- + , 0 5+ 6 E +

L L+ $

7 , ' ;( M 4 --N+ , @./ 5+ 4 5

$ E + )

( # 4 5 $ # 4 5 $ 7 +

6 # 4/5 E

, %E A H 4 -- + , 0@5 )

J 4 5 " + 2 +

) ( # 4 5 E # 4 5

$ , > 7 6

7 " $

7 + 7 " E

(4)

' ( ) * + (, -+ , + , . /0+ ,12 , / ₍

< ( " ) 7 "

" 7 7 + 7

6 ( 7 , ' O 7

4 --?+ , 05+ -N0 -N- I

6 + + 7

, ; 7 ;( M 4 + , @5+ L7

L 7 + ( "+

7 " 4 7 " +

$ + 6 7) 5+ 2

= O 7+ 6 + 7 + -- +

7 6 ( ,

3 3 H 4 @5+ (E 7

7 7 " + 6 +

+ + 6

, ! ( 7

43 :=*&+ @+ , / 5J

5 J .> "+ . "+ ; .

B . 4 + , ///5+

( $ . E

7 " ,

( ( "

( ( 4'&>!;C# & <!#

&> D &3C+ + , N?5#

5 J 7 H +

4 + , 5+ E(

E +

+ ) + 7 (

7 E + ($ #

5 6 J 3 H 4 @+ , ? 5

4 6 5 E

( +

( . L 7) 7 " L,

> E , ' * & 4 + ,

@5+ +

,

4 N+ , @?N.@?-5 E

78 4 5+ $ + 6

E $ 6 7

, 4 /+ , - .- 5 $ ( J .

, %E ' 6 4 N+ , 05 ( 6 +

8 + . 7 +

(5)

' ( ) * + (, -+ , + , . /0+ ,12 , / ₎

&

; 7 P + ; 4 + , 0 5+ 2 (

E $

E. , ' O 7+ 7

= 4 + , /-/5+ . E

$ E + ( ( (

7 6

, %E Q + ' ' 4 N+ , @/5 ( 6

$ 4

5 +

, 9 6 + 7

7 I ( .

( + + I ( "

4Q>>A# 'D :# '&>!9&C+ N+ , @/5,

; 7 2" 4 + , . /5+

$ 6 E7 J

5 J

+ ( 1

E #

5 ( 4 H " 5J ; + '

4 N+ , 5+ . $ 6

+ 6

+ (

+ +

I 4 6 + + 7 7 (

5#

)J 7 ; + ' 4 N+ , /5+

E7 + 6 : $ +

6 : +

2 + R " 7 + 6

( "

S#

5 " 6 ) J P %! 4 0+ ,?-5+

E7 $ E( 7 "

. ( 6 ) )

+ + )

+ T + U

,

E7 + ; + ' 4 N+ , ?5 (

T 6 ) :

2 + $ + + ( 6 6 )

6 , 9

(6)

' ( ) * + (, -+ , + , . /0+ ,12 , / _*

* "

+ + (

" + $

, ' $ + O + * H M F 7 4 + , N-. -/5

6 + 2E +

8 J " + 6

E (E 8 # " ( +

6 E # "

,

+

%

; ( " 4 @+ , -.

5+ 6 6 4 5 6 " +

E # 4 5 6 7 + 6 ( # 4 5

( 2 ( + 8 # 4/5 6

$ + 7 E ,

> E + J

9!; >+ > + 6 7% ) + ; >'<;+ ; 3

; ! , > 4 5

7 6 ( V W V6 7% )

) W , A +

@ - 7 4 6 + + 7 . ? -?

+ + 7 5+

N? ; ! , A ( 6

I 7 + . + + 7

7 ( J 9

* + 9 A' 3+ 9 A 9 7

' + = !& ;*: ; 8 ' + : 7

> * + ( + ; # %

? @ 7+ ! + ; # % ; @ 7+ ! + )

* + 3 F + X ' + * X

* + * X ; + ' ( )

* + & ( T + & (

9 + & ( H " + & (

'I + & ( < (

; ' + & ( ! ! 3 + & (

3 7 ! ) * + & ( 9 U

+ & ( ' 7 !

C , + 7 7 ) " / ?

4 I + ? + ( 6 (

5,

Y 6 6 4 5 6

( ) +

6 6 # 4 5

V6 7% ) ) W 4 5 V

W 4 5+ VC W+ $

(7)

' ( ) * + (, -+ , + , . /0+ ,12 , / _,

. +

Z ( ( +

7 $ # 4/5 +

I

7 + 7 " Z (

+ + ( ,

3 7 + 6

[ J

[ Z ' 6

Etapa Objetivos Materiais

1 Levantamento de artigos

Resgatar artigos que contenham o termo ‘Gestão do conhecimento’ e/ou ‘Knowledge management’ no título

Bases de dados, sites e anais de revistas e eventos

2 Seleção de artigos

Remoção de artigos duplicados (encontrados em mais de uma base de dados)

EndNote® X6 (THOMSON REUTERS, 2013) 3 Conversão de

artigos

Separação e conversão dos artigos, do formato XML (gerado pelo EndNote® X6) para o formato txt

Aplicativo PHP

desenvolvido pelo autor

4 Mineração de texto

Identificação e agrupamento de termos encontrados nos arquivos convertidos

PreText 2

(LABORATORY OF COMPUTATIONAL INTELLIGENCE, 2013) 5 Pré-análise de

resultados

Identificação e retirada de stems naturalmente recorrentes encontrados nos resumos

(exemplo: ‘objetivo’, ‘pesquisa’, ‘study’, ‘paper’, ...)

P J 3 6 ,

& . 6 + 9 /+ ( 2

8 7 ( ' C + ( 6 7 .

) + E7 )+ 7 :

+ Z 2E (

+ & 2 7 4 -?-+ , /5 %! 4 + , @5, $

+ + " . + 7 ' C

4: !>& C>&Q >P > '<C C*>A : *AC9::* 9A 9+ 5+

6 ( +

" ( , E

6 ,

P + E 6 6 +

6 8 + " 4 5 7

" " ,

+ 6 ( )

+ +

( E 8

(8)

' ( ) * + (, -+ , + , . /0+ ,12 , /

-( .

/

* + E 6 6 7 +

V W V= G 7 7 W+ +

7 ,

P 7 J

P 7 . '

P J 3 6 ,

3 . 48 ( 5 6

+ . 6 +

6

6 7 7 47

$ / + + ( N+ 5+

+ ) Z

( 6 + ( 6

7 ( ( 4 +

; ! + . 7 V

W / 0 5,

9 .7

+ . + ( + @ / ,

C 6 6 7 J

C Z .7

Nacionais Internacionais

stems fi n % stems fi n %

(9)

' ( ) * + (, -+ , + , . /0+ ,12 , / ₀ pratic 248 125 32,89 practic 2213 1137 32,89

model 227 115 30,26 technolog 1864 1065 30,81 estrateg 208 123 32,37 design 1668 962 27,83 competit 172 110 28,95 effect 1625 1010 29,22

sistem 156 86 22,63 perform 1564 715 20,68

ambient 148 99 26,05 implement 1547 942 27,25

ferrament 144 89 23,42 busi 1455 810 23,43

relacion 128 94 24,74 learn 1379 625 18,08

criaca 124 93 24,47 support 1359 926 26,79

identific 124 97 25,53 firm 1277 536 15,50

compartilh 112 79 20,79 strategi 1188 574 16,60

inov 105 56 14,74 compani 1151 646 18,69

estrutur 99 79 20,79 innov 1122 512 14,81

projet 96 54 14,21 framework 1116 636 18,40

P J 3 6 ,

C 6 6 + 7 +

7 Z . 6 +

+ + V 6W+ V W+

V W+ $ 6 6 ( 7 6

+ V W+ V7 W+ V )W+ V: 7% )W,

4 5

C $ 6 ( + 7

+ 7 + + $ +

7 6 , $ + 6

" 7 $

+ 6

7 +

6 , %E 6 6 )

+ + ( (

7 4V W+ V W+ V W5+

6 6 + + . 6

+ 7 + 4V ++ W+ V + W5,

' .7 4 )

2 5+ + 7 ' C 4: !>& C>&Q >P

> '<C C*>A : *AC9::* 9A 9+ 5+

" + -??/ 7 7 0

7 7 ,

C JC Z .7

stems fi n % stems fi n %

conhec_organizac 112 78 20,53 manag_system 893 582 16,84

tecnolog_informac 90 65 17,11 knowledg_share 501 317 9,17

pratic_gesta 73 50 13,16 manag_knowledg 446 364 10,53

process_gesta 68 51 13,42 competit_advantag 367 295 8,53

vantag_competit 60 48 12,63 inform_technolog 340 274 7,93

compartilh_conhec 46 39 10,26 practic_implic 313 299 8,65

conhec_tacit 42 26 6,84 manag_process 284 195 5,64

model_gesta 41 38 10,00 manag_practic 275 155 4,48

(10)

' ( ) * + (, -+ , + , . /0+ ,12 , / ₍

conhec_empres 35 30 7,89 inform_system 265 194 5,61

capital_intelectual 34 28 7,37 implement_knowledg 257 218 6,31

sistem_gesta 31 24 6,32 knowledg_creation 243 186 5,38

criaca_conhec 30 25 6,58 organizat_knowledg 241 188 5,44

estrateg_organizac 23 22 5,79 km_process 229 118 3,41

ferrament_tecnolog 23 19 5,00 tacit_knowledg 215 148 4,28

aprendizag_organizac 23 16 4,21 km_practic 214 134 3,88

gesta_informac 22 16 4,21 km_strategi 211 117 3,38

cultur_organizac 22 15 3,95 human_resourc 208 138 3,99

recurs_human 21 20 5,26 organizat_perform 197 95 2,75

ambient_organizac 20 18 4,74 effect_knowledg 195 167 4,83

Fonte: Dados da pesquisa.

3

+ , > + +

7 + 6 + +

. 6 +

V W V W 7 " Z + (

7 4V ) # % + W

V ++ : 7% ) W5+ $ E 4V

% A % W V: W5, $ + $ 6

V $7 W V 7 " W 7

+ + 8 ,

C .

7 4 00? 7 "

@ ? / 5J

C Z .7

stems fi n % Stems fi n %

pratic_gesta_conhec 59 39 10,26 knowledg_manag_system 772 506 14,64

process_gesta_conhec 57 41 10,79 knowledg_manag_process 249 168 4,86

gesta_conhec_organizac 49 39 10,26 implement_knowledg_manag 240 203 5,87

model_gesta_conhec 27 24 6,32 knowledg_manag_practic 228 124 3,59

gesta_conhec_empres 22 21 5,53 knowledg_manag_strategi 156 94 2,72

sistem_gesta_conhec 20 16 4,21 effect_knowledg_manag 152 128 3,70

conceit_gesta_conhec 15 14 3,68 knowledg_manag_organizat 113 96 2,78

relacion_gesta_conhec 14 12 3,16 relationship_knowledg_manag 105 87 2,52

tecnolog_informac_comunicaca 13 12 3,16 develop_knowledg_manag 89 86 2,49

ferrament_tecnolog_informac 12 10 2,63 small_medium_size 89 76 2,20

ferrament_gesta_conhec 11 11 2,89 inform_commun_technolog 87 85 2,46

conhec_tacit_explicit 11 11 2,89 critic_success_factor 83 65 1,88

vantag_competit_sustent 10 8 2,11 success_knowledg_manag 82 68 1,97

program_gesta_conhec 10 8 2,11 structur_equat_model 80 72 2,08

estrateg_gesta_conhec 9 6 1,58 knowledg_manag_tool 76 56 1,62

informac_gesta_conhec 9 8 2,11 sustain_competit_advantag 76 67 1,94

instrument_gesta_conhec 9 7 1,84 knowledg_manag_activ 76 55 1,59

process_criaca_conhec 8 7 1,84 knowledg_manag_implement 75 52 1,50

relaca_gesta_conhec 8 7 1,84 approach_knowledg_manag 75 70 2,02

cientif_gesta_conhec 7 7 1,84 knowledg_manag_initi 75 58 1,68

(11)

' ( ) * + (, -+ , + , . /0+ ,12 , / ₍

P J 3 6 ,

3 6 )

+ . + + 6 6

) 4V 7 W V

7 W5+

V W1W W + + C* ,

A +

1 ( ( 4V % : 7% )

) W+ V % : 7% ) ) W V: 7% )

) % W5 + $ 6 6

Z ( ( Z 4V %

+ W V + % : 7% ) ) W5 ( 1 (

4V: 7% ) ) W V: 7% ) )

W5,

E .7 + 6 " 6 )

2E 6

, ' + E /.7 + +

. J V7 \ \ \ W 4

) 7 5+ V \7 \ \ 7 " W 4?1?5+

V7 \ \ \ W 40105+ V \ \ 2 \ W 40105+

V 7\ \ \ 6 W 4@1@5 + V \ \ \ W 4@1@5,

3 7 + V (W 4

( V ( W5+ 7 7 ) +

?] V (W+ 7 7

7 + -] + .7

+ (

H + 4 + , 5# = 7 + A H &

4 + , @N5# .> "+ . "+ ; . B .

4 + , // 5,

( 1

* + E 6 7 6 7

6 , A +

7 + I " +

+

, [ 7 7 4V

7 KW5+ 6 +

6 2 ( " ) (

4 ( 6 ) 5+ 7

7 E , ' $ + 7 . 6 (

Z 6 7

,

+ , 3

$ E J I 7 6

(12)

' ( ) * + (, -+ , + , . /0+ ,12 , / ₍

. T 6

2 ( 6 , A + ( .

( I 7

6 . ( +

6 + + E 6 "

6 , > ( ,

> ( ) 7 ( +

4 2 5+ $ Z

+ 6 + ,

C ( + $ 6 . ++J ' 4 + ( "+ 5

$ E T 6

( 4 N /@? 5,

+ 6 $ 8 4 + +

( ) 5+ 2 7 . 6

( ) 7 T

,

> 6 ( (

+ 7 , [

+ ( )

" Z

K & . 6

7 E + .7

7 ) + . ( ?+ ? 0 4

. 0+ / 5, $ + $ (

6 7 + 7 +

K [ 7 + 6

+ + + $

7 +

6 4 + + 7 6 5J

( . ( 7 + $ +

7 K

3 7 + $ ( 6 7

7 +

V W +

6 , C V E W+ V W+ V 7

W+ V W+

, > + $ +

, 9 6 6

+

7 . T ( 6

6 ( 6 7 E , A +

(

) 6 E + + +

(13)

' ( ) * + (, -+ , + , . /0+ ,12 , / ₍

2

3

=CD &;D + <, ;,# A*; + D# :*+ ;, 3, C 7 (

H G 7 7 M , = 8B- C % +

6 7% ) 3 ) + (, + , + , .//+ ,

!&9O9&+ ', 3,# !&9O9&+ =, :, = G 7 7 +

7 + 7 J , C % +

D + ; + (, N@+ , 0+ , . @+ ,

9:>.>&3 F+ , %! C 7

H G 7 7 ( ; J 7

( , = 8 % C % + E @

3 ) + (, + , ?+ , // . /0 + , ,

'>;+ :, P, !, E ( 7 J (

7 , - & 8 + + (, +

, + , /. + 2 ,1 , ?,

'< A>+ 9, ,# ; 9;+ %,# >;C + %, &, * 7) (

87 7 ,

& 8 + + (, N+ , + , -. /+ 1 7 , -,

3 :=*&+ =, 6 7% ) ) 9 , > J

9 ( + @,

3 A> *+ *,# >&;*+ :,# '*:>CC*+ :, < M 7

( 7 " J G H G 7

7 , = 8 + B 9 C % + 6 7% ) 3 ) + (,

?+ , ./+ , -0. + -,

3&<F* A*+ , P, ,# =9&A+ B, ,# C ' A+ , D, 7

7 7 Z

E ) 9; H 8

O , - F + (, + , + , -/. ?+

2 ,12 , ,

P A+ O, %! C 7 G 7, +

? 3+ (, /-+ , -+ , ??.N + ; , 0,

P &>+ ,# *>&3 A>+ 3,# ;' '*A C>+ , 7

7 G M J ( M 7M 7,

; + ) ; + + (, + , + , 0 .N + 2 , ,

%F9&+ , C 7 6 H G 7

6 M M,

= % ) % D % + D 9+ (, 0+ , + , -.

+ ,

>AF :9F+ &, B, 3,# &C*A;+ , P,# C>:93>+ %, ,

7 " ,

(14)

' ( ) * + (, -+ , + , . /0+ ,12 , / ₍₍

>FF*+ , ', > 7

( " 7 , - F + (, +

, + , . /+ 2 ,1 ", ,

& AC+ =, ,# & AC+ , C, 3 ( 7 7

H G 7 7 , 8 8 + ) 4 8 +

= % )9+ (, @+ , @? .@- + N,

*!& D* + P,# &9*3+ B, < H 7 H G 7 7 J 7

K D @ : 3 ) + (, + , + ,

/. N+ ,

=&> D+ ,# A>A = + *,# &9 D;C9*A9&+ :, : 7 "

H G 7 J ( G G H, C % + 3 )

4 + (, /-+ , + , / . ??+ ,

: !>& C>&Q >P > '<C C*>A : *AC9::* 9A 9, - = / *J

$. , ;

J : !* 1* 1<;'+ , 3 (

^ J11 , , , , 1 _, J ? 2 , ,

:99+ :, C, ;,# ;<=> >+ !, , C

H G 7 7 M 7 " (

C G J 7 , 8 % C % +

3 ) + (, /+ , + , @/-.@? + ; , ?,

:9*C9+ P, , :,# >;C + ;, , ;, J

, & 8 + + (, 0+ , + , - . ?+

2 ,1 , ?,

:<A3B :+ !, ,# A*9:;9A+ ', = G 7 7 (

, 8 % C % + 3 7 + (, N+ , 1/+ , ?.

+ ?,

:D>C& + Q, O M H G 7 7 M K 9

H G 7 7 , 8 G =>9A* +

, 9, 3,# ;&*= AC * D+ C, =, 6 7% ) ) % % J

G G H G L , ` , ,aJ * C M * + /, + , N?.

&C*A;+ , , %! B / & / % #

% ) %H % ) 1 $ , ; J *

) E + 2 , & 8 $ ,

A>A = + *, C H G 7 . 7 M, E ; @ 7+

(, 0-+ , 0+ , 0 . ? + 2 , 7, -- ,

' ;C>&+ *, , ',# ; AC A + , ',# ;*9&& + , , 7 7 H G 7

7 J ;

( M, = 8 % C % + E @

3 ) + (, + , + , /@ Z /0?+ > , ,

'9&&>C+ !, 9, 7 H H G 7 7 ,

(15)

' ( ) * + (, -+ , + , . /0+ ,12 , / ₍₎

'9;[<9<b+ Q, < 6 H G 7 7 , D D +

(, + , + , @. 0+ N,

'&>!;C+ ,# & <!+ ;,# &> D &3C+ =, , '

7 J ! H + ,

& !9:>+ &, , %!

7 " J ( (

, - F + (, + , + ,

. @+ 2 12 ,

&*%;!9& 9A+ , %, M , 8 G &*%;!9& 9A+ , %,

8 + @ %, A G J ! G + -?-, 3 (

^ J11GGG, ,7 , , H1= 1 , 1 , , _, J ?

2 , ,

;9&9A=>+ , %! M H G 7 7

4 --/. N5, C % +

6 7% ) 3 ) + (, /+ , + , . + ,

;D A + ;,# :*A+ ;, P, < 7 ( M

M * 7 M 7 H G 7 7

G ( , = % I % 9 3 ) + (, + , @+

, @ -.@ + M -,

;*:B + 9, :,# 9A9F9;+ 9, , 3 % ) $ %

, /, , P 8 J <P; + @,

;*A D+ ,# ;>:C A*+ 9, = G 7 7 *

7M , = % I % 9 3 ) + (, + , +

, /@. @?+ P , ,

;> &9;+ ,# '& C*+ &, ,# >A &3+ , , ' C CJ

$. , ; J * + 7 ,

N, & 8 $ ,

;B9*!Q+ =, 9, ? $ # ) # , J 7 (

U , & % J + --N,

;B9*!Q+ =, 9, 6 7% ) ) J : , ,

3 ( J ^GGG, ( M, 1' 1 1 1= . , _,

J ,

CD> ;>A &9<C9&;, D " J! J C & + ,

3 ( ^ J11 , _, J ? 2 , ,

O A + , Q,# D A + 3, ;,# = >+ , D, * M 7 7M

&X3 7 7 C&*F 7, @F 3 ) + (, / + , @+

, /- .@ -+ ,

O9*;;+ ;, ,# *A3<&=DQ + A,# FD A + C, < % +

/ )! : J ; 7 .B 7+ ,

O** + =, , = G 7 7 J ( ,

(16)

' ( ) * + (, -+ , + , . /0+ ,12 , / _(*

Q>>A+ !,# 'D :+ &,# '&>!9&C+ 3, 7M M 7M

7J 7, @F 3 ) + (, N+ , + ,

@ .0N+ N,

F A + ;,# >+ [,# Q A + , G 7

H G 7 7 , C % + ? 3 + ) 49 + (,