Exchange rate policies, patterns of specialization and economic development: theory and evidence in developing countries

(1)

E

XCHANGE RATE POLICIES

,

PATTERNS OF

SPECIALIZATION AND ECONOMIC

DEVELOPMENT

:

THEORY AND EVIDENCE IN

DEVELOPING COUNTRIES

P

AULO

G

ALA

G

ILBERTO

L

IBANIO

Julho

de 2010

T

e

x

t

o

s

p

a

r

a

D

i

s

c

u

s

ã

o

(2)

TEXTO PARA DISCUSSÃO 211• JULHO DE 2010• 1

Os artigos dos Textos para Discussão da Escola de Economia de São Paulo da Fundação Getulio

Vargas são de inteira responsabilidade dos autores e não refletem necessariamente a opinião da

FGV-EESP. É permitida a reprodução total ou parcial dos artigos, desde que creditada a fonte.

(3)

! " # $

%

" #

# # # # # "

# # # #

# #

& ! " " # '

& # (

( ) ! & #

# #

( & #

) ! ( *

! # " # #

!" #$ % +" # !

& ' ()( ($* ,& -. / ,0

-. $ ,% #

-' 1'%' 2 1 % 334

2 2 + 5 26 ) ! 7 # 8 9

(4)

* $%+ ($*

#

, - # #

' " # + 2 1

# # 3 ' :#

0 <=3 ' <<3

>

# " # #

* % %

% ?

" # # #

# " @ %

# # #

# # # #

" % 2 A B

! 1 < 2 4 #

" # # # & #

% #

# #

) ( # " (

" # # *

% % C # *

" # # "

) # "

#

"

&

) ! 2 1 % % ' #

" " # ( &

) ! " # #

(5)

1 #

" # ) ! #

# # " # ' "

" # #

! " # $

%

" #

# # # # # "

# # # #

# # 1

* ! #

0 E *E "

# " # #

) 0 # , <<3- " #

# # ) # ## #

! #

# #

" # & " #

#* #

E

# # " # #

" "

, - # #

# " # # #

# ( # &

" " #

, # % "

<4D-& ! "

(6)

/

( ) ! &

# # #

( & #

) ! ( * !

# " # #

#

# #

" # # * !

#

!"*! ( * !))!

$ " # # #

## # ) ) 0 # ,

<<3-#

) # ## #

! # #

#

# " #

> # ) 0 # , <<3- #

" F > ( F

G G-H -, H

, ,

-F G ) # H

F H G ! ! #

G I

,

(7)

-D

3 ,

-) # (* # # (*

I

-H

, ,

-# H (*

) # H

( H (*

H H H

H

,/-F H

H H

H -,

H

,D-+@ , - ,/- ,D- # #

(* # # (

# #

& # I

" # #

1

# #

# # &

( #

# # " #

# ( 1 # ( # #

" #

& #

(8)

,J-J

# " #

" # G

G

,4-# " #

, - # # (* #

,

-K H K -, -G

LL,

,=-1 " # #

# # #

" #

# #

# > #

# # # " "

#

) # ( F ) 0 # ,

<<3-# # #

# 1 @ ## #

# # # #

## # & # ) 0 # ,

<<3-# I

-,

,<-3

H ,<

-+@ # ( # M

&2 I

-, ,

3-' ! # # #

(9)

4 H

-,

H ,

-3

H ,

-1 ! #

-, & # # #

-, * #

## # $ #

" # ( A * B

# #

& #

# # # ## #

! # A * B

) # ) 0 # , <<3- !

C ## #

! #

# ( @ I

3 3 -, , -, , -H, -,

H ,

/-) # E @ # ( #

# # , - 3 @

#

& ) 0 # , <<3- "

"

" # ! # I

-H -, H

(10)

D-=

-H -, H

, ,

J -H -, H

, ,

4-& # ( @ # @

"

-, ,

=-! #

, -I

--,

,

H ,

<-" %

! ) # , - 3

#

& #

# # & " #

& "

" 0 *

# ,

-" #

# " # E " #

# #

#

" >

# " #

# # 2 # (

" # @

,) *2 - " #

@ " #

(11)

<

'%$ ( * !))!

# " # #

E #

# #

# (* # #

# # " # #

" & # @ #

# ( # # @

# #

E ,

1 % " ,

<4D-! *

( ! @ , 3- , - #

# " , -I

,

3-# . # "

# " #

# " " I

-, _,

-# # .

# . ,N 3- " O

"

# # (* # @ I

,

-# # #

(12)

3

A B ,% " <4D 3D- #

P @ I

,

# ! P

@ #

, @

-# # " # , @ - # , @

3-' # @ , 3- , - , - , - " @ #

I

9 -,

7

,

/-+@ , /- # #

, - # , -/ ,

-" ,"- 1 # # #

# (*

) @ #

# " # #

" # A B ( "

# # 1 ( , 33J

D- I A& "

( C+C ## #

# B

# " # F

! E A # #

# B 5 ( E F ,E <JJ- #

# " #* #

# # # *

/

(13)

# * & #

! #

# & # #

# % #

" # #

#

" #

, #

-, # - #

#

# " 1 # E

A B A B A B

#

# #

" # 2

# # # Q F # #

" %

" # ! +"

#

, - # @ ) # *

# *

# #

:

# > "

# * # #

E " # (

# ) #

(14)

" # & #

( #

#

* # * # * # # *

# & #

# A B " C

# # (

# # %

( # !

# " # 1 *(

) * * # ,

<4<-# # F ( "

D

: F # #

# " # , - ,&- 5

* F I

'( ,

D-& #

!

# #

1 , 334- *

F , <= << - ## #

"

" ( # #

F # F !

* * #

& #

#

# ! # "

D

1 F #

(15)

33/-# * ! #

#

" # #

& # * " #

# ## # "

#

# $ A # " # *

# # #

) B ,) * 33J

-1 @ " #

# " 1 >

, 33 - # A B " #

# % ! , 33

-) # (

" # # # #

# # #

# ,> 33 . 33 - #

* 1 # # #

"

# * & #

" # (

# " #

# $ # #

# # # #

# # ) #

#

# # ( (

& " " & '

(16)

/

,! ! $) *%$*! (

& # & #

<43 & %

:2R4 D , <=D :2 - <

2 <J4

# I ! # *

" #

" # ( " " # #

<4 & # # # I

3S # #

" # /S % <JD 3S <43

& <43 " " # # 5 #

# ( 5 #

" # 1 # , <== 34- " #

" 33 <43* <4 <4=

# # 1 <4= / D

J D 0 J

# ( # "

, <==- # # , *

-# # &

# <4 */ #

" # #

1 (

( &

& JS % , " #

# - S % <43 #

:2R J <4= :2R D <=3 # "

) <4= <= " # #

, <==- 1 <=3 @

#

5 <43 <=

J

(17)

J-D

% # <=3 " # <=J

@ # # #

<<3 1 !

# T 1 !

<<3 & #

# # (

# " #

:2 P !

! ,+ 33

(18)

-J

G2 I > ) (

" # <43

<=3 & <4=

? # ,+ 33

-G2 I 1 F # + , 33

(19)

4

' , <<<- # # " # # &

? # # <43 <=3 A

" # # ) <43 & (

# " #

# ) & " #

)

? # # " # #

@ * "

# " # 1 (

<=

B4

& * "

<= << " * 33S & <4<

( # " J3S 2

<= , <== 3- # "

( # &

* # & # " *

<=J & " #

# # & <=3 S & " # &

<= # 4S << D3S ;

"

" * # # # 1 : <<3 "

# S %

& " #

# # " " #

" # # # <=3

# # *

4

(20)

=

' +" 5 & <J3 * <<3

' # <J3 <43 <=3 <<3

43 JS /< 3S /4 DS = S

? * / S /= DS 4 S S

# S 3S < S 3 S

0 # S 3 4S / 3S 3S

; # # 3 JS 3 =S 3S 4 /3S

33 3S 33 3S 33 3S 33 3S

G1 F , 33 - $ , 33D- :?' 1% ; (

, <==- &

( # #

# " # " &

& # # <43* <<3 &

" # D S % # <S

# 4 S <J D3S <<3

& A% % B ( #

# @ " #

<43 <=3 # #

1! , <<3- " #

# # # # "

I A1 # (

0 <= ,

=S-2 <=J , S- #

# # DDS " # #

<= * <== # # # *

" & #

# B ,1! <<3 /

-# & <=3 <<3

" " # 1

#

; " #

# & #

(21)

<

( #

( 5 *( (

* #

( @ &

<<3

" &

" # " 2 1

3 #

# 1 1 ,) * 33J. ' <<3.

% << . ) U <<<. ! 33 - &

# *

#

,! ! $) ,('!

1 # # # "

' " @ =

# #

# DS % <4

DS <4D % DS <4D # #

" # <4J (

# # # # #

" # ! 1 <4 * <4

#

<= ' " 3

' # # <=3 # 4S %

( # / DS <= , /- ' (

:2 0 " " " # # '

1 ( # !

% DS <= ( # '

' ) (

=

(22)

/-3

2 ' " #

' #

# <4< <=

# A% V "

<= @ W W W W

+ X X

@ " W #

# " B< $

A # @ "

@ W W @ V !

# @ # @ V V #

B 3

-, .

+ !* $+* /012311 45 %$ 67

*4 * / D

*< D *D J * 3 *= J *J 4 * J * 3 * D * J *3 * *D 4 * *

*D *D 3 *D 4

*3

* / * < * J 3

* / 3

* 3

* 3 3

*= 3

*J 3

*/ 3

* 3

3 3

<=3 <= <= <= <=/ <=D <=J <=4 <== <=< <<3 << << << <</ <<D <<J <<4 <<= <<< 333 33

$ I ,*- V > % & 33

1 # # <=3

# # <= <<3 #

' ) ( * # #

# & # <=/

<<< 2 , %

,-<

% #W , 33D -3

Y , <<= D

(23)

<<J-# <=3 ' "

3S <= <== <=3

# " <=< <<3 #

# # #

% # <<3 # # @

# # #

" # F

# # '

# '

# S*/S % 1 # <<3H <<D *

D S &) <<JH <<= *D S ,

/-# ' (

# ) #

' ) ( << &

+ 3S 3S << 3S

1 <<= '

! # # <<3 +"

# " 1 # D

' " #

#

(24)

-, 8

9 , *:! ! *% (* ,('! /0. ; 311.

3 33 33 33 /33 D33 J33 433 =33

H= H= H=/ H=D H=J H=4 H== H=< H<3 H< H< H< H</ H<D H<J H<4 H<= H<< H33 H3 H3 H3

'Z ?

G' ) ( '

( & <</

( # , D3S

/DS- $ % 0 ( U T 1

" # #

# # #

1 # #

<<3 # J ' ) ( #

2

# # # # <=3 )

) ! 0 " 1 #

' # 1 # *% F , 33/

3<- <</ ' JS # <=4* <<3

1 /S % # <<D* <<4

' # JS 1

(25)

-, <

G' ) ( '

'

" : 1 " # # 3S 4

' " # +

, 33 - <43* <<< P !

! & F #

# # <=3 # # " #

# #

! "#$ %%$

&'()

"#$* %%

(26)

/

-, =

G2 I 1 F # + , 33

-2 ( ' # <=3 <<3

1 0 V , 33 - A F

" #

" # # *

* " # B ,0 V 33 - 1 # Y

, <<=- # ( (

#

> ! # ' *% ,

33/-# # " # A

[ V ' W X "

" \ 6 ]

V X " ^ @

# " W

W " W B /

Y , <<= D/-/

*% 33/ D

(27)

D

+" # <J3* <4 DS ( # <4 * <=

# D DS <= * 33 D !

' " "

" *

' +" 5 ' <J3 * <<3

' # J3 43 =3 1 <3

4 S J4 S JD 3S D= S

? * / DS < DS 4S /S

# 3 /S 3S 3 <S S

0 # JS S S / =S

; # # 3 S 3 S 3 S 3 DS

33 3S 33 3S 33 3S 33 3S

G1 F , 33 - $ , 33D- :?' 1% ; (

= " # ) ! 1 # 0V"

' ' <4< + F , 33 - ,

( - # <<3 ) ! 1 # 0V"

' '

-, 0

G2 I 1 F # + , 33

-D

1 ! 33/

+ ,

*

+ ' $

"

!(

(28)

J

& ( " # # # > , <<J- # #

" # ' # %

A' # <= # %

# 1 # # #

# ( #

' #

# ! # #

# '

( # # B J

2 ' "

" # # # <=3 <<3 0 , 33 - ' , 33

-% , <<D- ' " # (

' 1 #

# # <<3 @

1# ' # "

" # #

( 1#

) * + * * # #

*(

# # *

# ( '

&

$* '+ ($*

! " #

$

" #

# # # # # " #

# # # #

#

J

(29)

4 !

# ' & # #

" # <=3 <<3 # #

#

# #

" # # * !

#

!)! !* !

1 P1C+Y C + , 33/- A% \ " I #

! B .* ) / ) = #

1C1_U$ C &01 , 334- A1 *

* # B / * 0, ) , %, , *% 4DD544/

1Y&2 & U , <<3- A+ * I

& B ( % *. , ( %* *% ' * %, , 1 %, * , ,

2 * 3 * 2 *% & % # + ( U

)1C)$21* & ;$ ? , 33J- A+" # # B

1 ' % ' # ' U 6 ) !

? 33J

)+?1C$T1 U1?'& % , <<<- A0 # " # #

# B % (,)*%* * * 2 *

/, * 2 ' # U * T # ' ( , - C #

? T (

);1%:C& 1 01C &? 2 1 , <<3- Q: # I

# # F / * 0, ) , %, , *%

/ %

)C+22+C* +C+&C1 ' , 33/- A) ! F @ * # # #

# # B *, ) 0, ) , (,)* *% ) %, , ,/- 33/I 4J* 3

)C+22+C* +C+&C1 ' , 33J- A+" # " # `B

0 P # , - 4* %* ) *, , 5,)) * *, 1 , ( %

' I + + #

'1C%$2$ + , 33 - A: a ) I

(30)

=

6 ' *) , , 7 * , , 89, > # %'

';1? ; , 33 - A + 1 " B C ( # %

+ ; *U ' # , - 1

'$ &+C )+P1? % :??&? U > , <<<- : (,)* *% ) %, , ,

(,. ; * < , 1 * * , * 1 > ) ( '

2 $" : $"

'$C%+? > 0 , <=/- A) # 2 % + I

B $" + J ?

'$ 1?& U '1P1 $ % E;1? 0 , <<3- AC " #

'% B + % ' ' # <,

-$ I J *4J

% C+ $C&$ U . $E01? 1 .P1 %d2 C , 33D- A ' "

& W ' I +" [ B % X

+ a ) ' ' / 1#

%&e$? C 1 ;&C >1 , <4D- Q1 # #

E F 6 , %, , *% ( 4 3 * /

%$ 1C % , << - A$ * % # + C % 0

C I + <D %' <4J* <=D B %, , *% 5 . ),

/ ) ) / /3I D *//

%$$ +T 0 1?%1: % 1C)+C , 33 - A1 + )

> 2 B ?)+C > ( # <<4 2

%$C?):2'; C 1CE T ' , <<<- A " `B %

(,)*%* * * 2 * /, * 2 ' # U * T #

' ( , - C # ? T (

%$C?):2'; C , 333- = , , * 1 > , , * , ) %>

0& ' # :21

%$C?):2'; C $ % 1U? & P1 %+2 C , <<D- A' B

' ,,>* ( , %, , *% 2% *.* > # I & < ,4D

-+12 +C T > , 33 - A % I % # ' F 2 # 2

C <=3* <<=B > ) (

+&';+? C++? ) 0122$? ; # ) ( 7 9 , <<=- A+"

# I ( # # " # " B

6%% *, ) ( J= &0 > # %' /=

1U?YT )+C $1TY1 ? '1 %+Cf? ' , 33 - A+

(31)

<

C+?';*%1P&2 C , 33 - A+ "

' B .* ) / )4J 1 '

C+?';*%1P&2 C . 1 $2g? 0 . : ;$ 1 , <<4- A0

V# " a ' B C+?';*

%1P&2 C . C& & ;*U$?+2 2 , # - 6 4) , 4* % * , 2 ? *% 3 *

C U I + ! 4<* <

C+?';*%1P&2 C , 33/- ) ,)* )* , ) % %* * , %, ; *

?% ,)@ *% %, A *% / *) 2 # P + ) 1

&2';+C 2 , << - A 0 # B U 0

+ 0

C+?E+ C , 33/- AC " # 1 # ) ! '

0 " B ' ) 1 /

C+?E+ C 1T $C , 33J- QC " #

F % > ( # < : ? ? T (

+ ) 1 ; , <==-6*) * )) ) * , % B > ) (

;$2; 1 : %+ 1 >$ ; , 33 - % * % ,*%

%, ; % C' # 01I 0&

;& ; , 333- : , * %, , ' # : 2

' #

E1 %$C ? , <JJ- / , ), , %, , *% < , , 7 *

=* , 1 ) 3 % ' # I ' # :

1 2 , 33 - A # #

" <=D* <<=B /, * *. : % ,), >*)) =4*

4 ' I + + #

1C2+? , 33/- A+ # C ' % ` > ?

# # # B 2 ? C

% 44 0

0 '$0)&+ U 0 ! : ?$ ) 2$C$ , - , 33 - ( , % *.* < ,

%, , *% ( , % C , D ,, E 3 ) # ( ; I

# 0

0 '$0)&+ U 1 ;&C >1 , <</- %, , *% < , ' ) % ,

( /, * I 0

0 '$0)&+ U 1 ;&C >1 , 33/- , ' ) % , ( /, *

< , F: , .* % I C #

(32)

3

, *G %* * %*, * *)* 89, ) X I & +1H'+ 1 D* 4J

0$? &+ , 33 - A% # # # I

B % , %, , *% * * >

' # I ' # :

0$C1?%d , 33 - A1 # # ' I

# B I ? ! . C 2 , - ) *, : * 1 5 * ( , %

/ ) C2 ' ) ( # + D D= *J J

0$C1?%d , 33 - A+" # ' I " B

' A+" # C C # I # #`B # ! &0

& 0 <* 3 4

0$C1?%d . 1 &1 0 , 33 - A X ' I

" W B .* %, , @ / *) D J4*</

$'10 $ U 1 1CC1 0 1 , 33D- A+" # % % # I 2

' % # > 2 <=3B /

%, , *% < , * ; * 1 / )) , 3 * 2 *% 2 # '

1';+'$* $ +Y 1 ;&C >1 , 33J- A !

# 1 B 0, ) , (, +

= * %, , *% < , -I / *JJ

1 01 , 33 - A I ' 0 " 1 # 7 9.

) ! 7 9 E 0 7 9B * >* 5 . ),

%, , *% ; *U ' # , # - 1

1 01 , 33 - A * ! %

% B $ U 1 , - / )) , 3 * 2 *% 5 . ),

+' 1'*> ) (

12&?+ & , <= - % ) / %, , *% < , F : , *% ) ,

5 *% , ) , *, ' # I ' # :

12&?+ & , << - % ) %, , *% 5 *% H : , , %, , *%

/, ; % , I 3 * ' # I ' # :

$ $P P $ +C$P&'; P , 33 - A1 # " #

# # B ? + 2 0 C

C1U1 1 &C1?1 2 1 ;:E$C1 1 , 33 - A' " #

I 1 1 B : , ) %, , $"

1

C1Y&? $ '$ &?2 2 , <<4- AC +" # C 0 # B

(33)

C$%C&E % , 334- AC +" # C + I + B

U E 2 ; : % U

C$2 U , 333- 5 . ), : , %, , *% , < , 1 1 I

: 0 #

C$2 U , 33 - A ! # B U 0 C

0 , - 4* % /, * *. * 5 . ), * /, * I

C #

21';2 U >1C?+C 1 J <<D- A? # B

?)+C D <= %

21C?$ 1T $C 0 , 33 - : %, , *% , % ' # I

' # :

;&C >1 1 , <4<- A "

# B ' % *, ) ) 3 ., , K ) .*

=

>1%+ C , <<3- <,. * > %, , *% , ,) , ,. *

2 * * * )* *, :

>&U?)+C +? 2 , <=/- A % I `B %, , *% 0, )

</ 4 0

>& &102$? U , <<J- : % )* % * ) , ,

/ *) /,), * ) & > # %'

$

>& &102$? U , 33 - A+" # B &

% # ( 0 ? T (

>$C % )1?E , << - : 2 * * %) %, , *% , )*% ,)*% $"

: ?T

Y1; +C C , <<=- A+ ) ' X W ' \