Direito ao processo qualificado : o processo civil na perspectiva do estado constitucional

(1)

(2)

! " #

$ % # # & '

(3)

$*+ $ ) , )

%

- ) , ) $ # . / 0 1223#

432 #

$ % & ' ( ) #

5 6 .

# 1223 / 0 , 7 #

4# # 1# # 8# # *#

# 9# ( ) & ' # 99#

# # 999#

( #

(4)

8

! " #

/ ;;;;; ;;;;;;;;;;;;;;; ;;;;;;#

$ 9 <$ =>/ 9?/ $ /%

;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;

# # & ' ( )

;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;

# # ' 0 "

;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;

(5)

/ ! "# $ %$ "$ &"'&%(&

/ ) A7 A A

)

7 ) 0 ! A #

" ' @

# 7 '

B C ' A " @

A #

" D ' E C #

@ ' )

# / ) '

' "' "A

) " ) #

/ " ) # ) )

(6)

F ) )*& #

/ ! +,& G 0 E

#

/! ($-'$( .$(& &) " 0H @ #

/ $(%&/ %-%0%& 0

G " " ) "

) #

/ # 1%

%/2& - - 3 $4&( 0& ""%"3 (1 5 / 1$(1 $ /&- !6$ &7 &%-$" "

G ) C #

/ # 1% %/2& - - 3 &/% & '%$ &// 3

0 0 " #

(7)

$ "C " % # ( 7

7 "C C

I I # /

7

! ' G #

) '

" = 7

'

I # = 0

" C D

" # ) 0 "C

J 7 C

C " #

) ' E @ # / 7

J "C "C # ?

0 '

& G

E E 0 7 G

# = ' E E !

C @ # ( 7

= C

@ A % K C K #

7 '

@ "

0 E % 0 #

(8)

() LM ) ) 0) % ) 0) # () )

L ) 0 ) 0 0 " 0 0 0 " )

) ) # ) N

0) ) ) N " ) ) ) )

L ) ) ) L# O L@ ) )

) ) 0) " ) ) )

7 ) N P ) 0 ) )

) 0) L # 9 )

E ) ) , @

N ) 0) , @

# 0 ) 0 "C ) L ) ) 0) 0

0 L # () ) ) L

E ) 0) ) ) L 0) N # 9 Q

L@ ) ) 0) 0) "C "C

# 9 ) ) ) ) ) ) 0) L

0) ) & L N N) )

) 0) ) ) 0) L )

# () E N ) ) E ) 0

) "L ) ) ) 0) # () ) L

"L ) ) C N) ) " L ) @

) ) ) % L# L )

" 0

P L " ) N 0 E N%

L#

(9)

;

<= 42

> <= 3 4*

4#4 / =S$T U<$ $ 9 =9($ $ = /T 9S9T , / 9T=9 $ = = / $

=($ $TV 9 $ % / 9? T W? 9/ / T( / = / => = 9W? 9/ $, = $

$ = $##############################################################################################################################4*

> > > $?%") @ 6 %(, &-%") A 4+ > > %&(-% %,%") 6 ,&""6$/%") 43 > > B ("- 6)&(-$/%") 1:

4#1 9 =?(9 9 /? $ / $ =?(= T( /9 $?(= $ X?=/ ################82

> > "-$0 ("-%-6,% ($/ 82 > C"8 "%-%.%") @ 6 & , ("-%-6,% ($/%") A 8* > B ,$D* 0& "" &) $ $ $ !6 %"0%D* 8: > E ? $("* 0$ -%.%0$0& !6 %"0%,% ($/ F $/ %7$D* 0 " %(,G % " ("-%-6,% ($%" H ? $("* 0$ !6 %"0%D* ("-%-6,% ($/ 83 > I (,/6"J&" $ ,%$%" *4

4#8 R / ($ = (Y 9$ $ 9 =9($ $ = /T 9S9T% $ $?(= $ X?=$

Z($ $ = =? / =?($###############################################################################################*8

[4

1#4 $ =T$ $? (9( 9$?/T $ $ = $ 9S9T , / 9T=9 $ #######################[4

1#1 $ 9 =9($ /$ $ = $ $ $ 9? \ 9$7 \?(= = $ $ =T$

$? (9( 9$?/T $ $ = $ 9S9T , / 9T=9 $ ###############################################[+

1#8 / =S$T U<$ $ 9 =9($ /$ $ = $ ?/ $? (9( 9U]=

(10)

1#* / $ (/ 9 $($ 9/ =?( = $ 9 =9($ /$ $ = $ =S9 ($ ?/

$? (9( 9U<$ = $ 9 =9($ /$ $ = $ 9? / $? (9( 9$?/T ################:2

1#[ / (=$ 9/ $, = $ 9 =9($ /$ $ = $ ?/ $ = /T\ (9 / ########:1

1#^ / /U<$ ?/ = = (9S/ $ 9 =9($ ? / =?(/9 % $ ( /($ $

9 =9($ /$ $ = $ ?$ Z($ $ = =? / =?($ $?(= $ X?=$ $

9 =9($ $ = /T 9S9T ############################################################################################::

1#: , =S= $? 9 = /U]= $, = $ 9 =9($ ? / =?(/9 % = 9 /

9 = 9? \S=9 /$ =?(=? 9 =?($ / /U<$ $, / = = (9S/

$?(= $ X?=/ ##############################################################################################################:+

K > %1(%0$0& 0$ &"" $ 6)$($ , ) $/ 6(0$)&(-$/ 0$ 0&) ("-%-6,% ($/ :+ K % &%- " 6(0$)&(-$%" )$%" & $-& %$%" :3 K B 6 /$ & " &,-%.$ 0 " % &%- " 6(0$)&(-$%" +2 K E /$""% %,$D* 0 " % &%- " 6(0$)&(-$%" +1 K I " % &%- " ( )$-%. " 0 ,&"" %.%/ ( 0&/ ("-%-6,% ($/ $"%/&% 0& ,&"" +[

1#+ =(=? <$ $ = /T = 9 =9($ /$ $ = $ ##########################################3+

1#3 9 =9($ /$ $ = $% (= 9?$T$ 9/ / $(/ /#########################################422

1#42 9 =? <$ $,&=(9S/ $ 9 =9($ /$ $ = $ ###########################################42[

1#44 9 =? <$ ,&=(9S/ $ 9 =9($ /$ $ = $#########################################441

B 3 ! < <=

; 8

443

8#4 $ 9 =9($ = /U<$ /$ $ = $ R /T9 9 / $ ########################################443

8#1 $? 9 = /U]= (= 9?$TV 9 / ####################################################################412

8#8 $?(=_ $ $ $ = $ R /T9 9 / $############################################################411

(11)

8#[# & (9U/ #########################################################################################################################481

8#^ / =R /U<$#################################################################################################################48:

B L > " #,%&" 0& 0&M6$D* 48: B L 0&M6$D* 1(%-%.$ 4*4 B L B 0&M6$D* 0$" )$" 0& 6-&/$ !6 %"0%,% ($/ 0 " % &%- " 4*8

8#: $ $ = $ R /T9 9 / $ $ $ =(/ 9(Z 9$ = 9?(= =(/U<$

/ ?$ / $ = /9 ##########################################################################################4*+

B K > ) & $-%. "3 $(DJ&" & ,&"" 4*+ B K (-& &-$D* 0$" )$" ,&""6$%" & " 0& /N6"6/$" & $%" 4[2 B K > ) -O(,%$ 0 " ", " 0 ,&"" ($ (-& &-$D* 0$" )$" ,&""6$%" 4[1 B K E &16%(0 (- & $ & )&(P6-%,$ & ,&"" %.%/ &-%.%0$0& & &16 $(D$ , )

2 & %(,G % " 0 ,&"" %.%/ 4[^ B K I 6$/% %,$D* 0 ,&"" & 0$ &" (0&(-& 6-&/$ !6 %"0%,% ($/ , )

&-$, %-# % " 0& (-& &-$D* 0$" )$" 0& ,&"" %.%/ 4[3

4^1

(12)

44

<=

$ D '

I ! @ = 4#

( 7 " G C

@ 7

. "' 0 G

8 #

/ A D

" 7 I # $ 7 0 * E ' 7 ' G0

A = #

? 0 7 `a###b

" a###bc[ 7 D

# $ @

E " C

" # / "C ' 0% &%- $ ,&"" # / 7

0

4

d/ =,=T ef # / 0% %-- )%-&# ( % = 4331# # 127[^#

1

? % $?(= = 9 /? / # )&(-N % " R ("-%-6%D* 0&

> LK# % ( " 43:4# # [ # 42[#

8

? % / 9?$?9 T @ ) # 6 " 0& ,&"" ,%.%/% 0 # % ( " 122^# # 4 # 12[#

*

$?(= = 9 /? / # (-&" & &. /6D* 0 0% &%- ,%.%/ 2 $"%/&% # 1#

# & % 43+4# # 2471^ 2472[#

[

, =?$ G # `$ c% 0

G 0 J # &.%"-$ 0& ,&""

(13)

41

" " ' G

G7 =

^ #

$ ' =

# =E G G 0

C @

7 )

"'

K G #

7 A

' !

0A 0 ) #

? )G 0 = 7 5

6 '

"' "

A 0 " ' :# ? @

E @ C B

"' K

0 G 0 G

"' 0

# $ @ E 0 7

` A " c+ "

0 3#

^

/ E `= c ' @ 0 "

@ ? # Z E

D = G

C HA G E #

5 / ,$?=TT 0 # = " # 9 % ;;;;;; 5$ 0#6# & G$ 0&/

(& , ("-%-6,% ($/%") % L 0 # % ( 122:# # 237416

:

/ % =9(/ & @# "62"-$(,%$/ %(, ("-%-6,% ($/%0$0& 0$ /&% %(S6"-$# % S @ K / 0 % = 9 43+3# # 4:788#

+

9TT/ " OL # T # ( #

# , / % = 43*[# # *:#

3

(14)

48

$ C '

I 0 7 7

@ " I

HA " 42#

? G ! C

44

0 7 C 7

" 0 D @

! E 0A = #

$ ! C E

@

" A %

-&) &"-%.%0$0&3 S6"-%D$ & $0&M6$D*

G 7 0 A

C G G7 =

# = 7& @

C ' '

@ #

/ !

' D 0

E 41 % "&16 $(D$ & & &-%.%0$0&48 7

0% &%- " 6(0$)&(-$%" ( ,&"" ,%.%/% D #

/ 0 % T / 0 1223# # [8K /TS/ $ = $T9S=9 / / " # / 0

# &.%"-$ 0$ $,6/0$0& 0& % &%- 0$ (%.& "%0$0& &0& $/ 0 % $(0& 0 6/ / 0 # 4[ # 48 433+#

42

? % 9?/ / $ I 0 # 6(0$)&(- " 0 ,&"" ,%.%/ ) 0& ( # *# # % ) 1224# # 1 # +237+44#

44

? % / 9?$?9 T @ ) # #,(%,$ ,&""6$/ & -6-&/$ 0 " 0% &%- "# 1# # % ( " 122+# # 1[#

41

/ 0 E % / / /T

) @@ # 6) %)&(- & &?&,6D* 0$ "&(-&(D$ " 2 C-%,$ 0 )$/%") 8.$/ $-%. #

/ 0 % T / 0 122+# # *:7:+#

48

/ " % /TS/ $ = $T9S=9 /

/ " # $ ! ! 0 I #

(15)

4*

) 4*

G C ! # $

" 0

C #

= '

= "C

#

4*

/ % YS9T/ g " # & %$ 0 " %(,G % "%

! C # 3# # % ) 1223 # 4887

(16)

4[

? @ ) J

" 0 " ) G I #

%

4# ' # S

' )

C

! K

1# ' 0

) '

J 0 0 0 ' @

C

K

8# "

C K

*# G0 G

C G ' E 5

6# ( "' '7 '

A K

[# "

5 6# ( 7 G0 @

A 0 =

"C D" K

^# G0 ' # ( 7

@ I

# Z G0

0 ! C

(17)

4^

:# I @ G0

" ' = # / E ' 0

= J J

= '

= K

+# E ! =

, ' 43*^# ( 0A

43^* G

= K

3# @ " 7

"' 0 =

' C

" 0 7 5 "'

) 6# ( 7

= E #

= K

42# I ' C A # ?

C & G J

! K

44# "' @ ) E

C C " J C

@ # Z @

)

E C K

41# , " =

E 0

@ K

A C

H E C K

48# I

'

(18)

4:

G G 0

C @ ' ' 0 A #

Z 7

' C K

4*# ' )

' A

0 0 # ( "' " B 7

5 C 6

@ #

4[# $ C N ' "

" C 5 6 7

C ) " C 7

K

4^# C

J

" K

4:# ` c `

c ' ) I G !

, K

4+# 5

6 " 0 %

@ K J C K

0 @ C G K

C K

43#

, C '

K

12# ` c 0 414[ 0 ) T " "

E ) ` N ) c )

B E

(19)

4+

= >9S 0

T N " " K

14# C 0

7 C " CG

E @ " 0

43++K

11# ! @

' 0

G K

18# C

0 G E

E

" "

! 0 K

1*#

43*^ 0

C 7" K

1[# >>>S # [h

43++ @

E % E E ` c

" "' ! K E

` c @ 7 !

K 1^#

# ( 7

@ @ J

G T " " @

0A

) @ K

1:# '

B "

A O ) ) #

% ! C K

(20)

43

1+# 0 " T "

A J )

E K

13# ' =

'

E K

82#

0 )

C K

84#

# / "

J @ C 7 "C

@ "C

E 0

G @ B C

E 0 " G

K 81#

J # = "

J 5 " 0 !

! 0 @ 6 5

J 6K

88# 0 A @ # ( 7

! G

0 ) 0 # D

K

8*# C E

@ 7 @ =

K

8[# # [h >>>S @ "C D"

E & G

# $ E

(21)

12

C @ '7 K E

K

8^# E G ! !

# $ ' E 0 ' # / "

E ! C ! @

J K

8:# 0

>>>S # [h # $ 7 E

` c ) B C

E ' 0 0 7

C " 0 I

K

8+# "C

" @ 0 @

E @ K

83# E

' "C

! @ K

*2# "C E 0

@

0 @

0 K

*4#

"C D

"

"' 0 A

'

J J G

0 K

*1# @ C

' E 0

C E 0

(22)

14

*8# '

" A G K

**# G E

>>>S # [h " A

G0 % $ )

' ' @

C G K 0 CG

' @

E " @ ' J

)

K G7 I C

" ' E 0

"' 0 "

@ #

= G0 K

*[# 0 >>>S #

[h 0 @ E

J "C J E 0

0G7 0 K

*^#

E @

7 5 ' 6

K

*:# @ G ' "

0

C @ 0

C K

*+# C @ A

' % 5 6 K 5 6

E K 5 6

K

*3# G7 " A ' %

(23)

11

[2# 5 0 6

5 6K

[4# ' 0

E A @ C 0

E E 0A

EG7 K

[1# @ A

5 C 6 ' 7

C "

(24)