• Nenhum resultado encontrado

TAP’s social networks and social media strategy : cases on marketing strategies

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Share "TAP’s social networks and social media strategy : cases on marketing strategies"

Copied!
82
0
0

Texto

(1)

 

 

 

 

 

 

Cases  on  Marketing  Strategies    

__________________________________________________________________________  

TAP’s  Social  Networks  and  Social  Media  Strategy  

 

Author:  Carlos  Falcato  

 

Instructor:  Prof.  Pedro  Celeste  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Dissertation  submitted  in  partial  fulfillment  of  requirements  for  the  

degree  of  MSc  in  Business  Administration,  at  the  Universidade  

(2)

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS    

 

After   completing   such   an   important   step   in   my   academic   path,   I   realized   how   much  effort,  work  and  perseverance  this  thesis  required.  I  am  grateful  that  I  was   able  to  reach  my  objectives  and  do  the  best  work  I  could,  but  that  would  have  not   been  possible  without  the  help  and  support  of  some  individuals.  

 

First,   I   would   like   to   thank   my   family   for   the   moral   and   brainstorm   support,   as   well  as  my  closest  friends  and  seminar’s  colleagues  for  listening  to  my  concerns,   ideas  and  helping  me  in  whatever  I  needed.  

 

Also,  a  special  thank  you  to  TAP  and  more  specifically  Dr.  Luís  Monteiro  and  Dra.   Gilda  Luís,  from  the  marketing  department,  without  whom  I  would  not  have  been   able  to  have  such  great  insights  and  information  about  TAP.    

 

Finally,   a   grateful   thank   you   to   Professor   Pedro   Celeste,   who   provided   the   guidance   and   feedback   that   was   always   essential   for   the   development   of   the  

(3)

ABSTRACT  

 

Dissertation  title:  “TAP’s  Social  Networks  and  Social  Media  Strategy”  

Author:  Carlos  Falcato  

 

The  airline  industry,  a  fiercely  competitive  one,  is  investing  in  social  media  as  a   way  of  creating  differentiation  and  customer  attachment.  TAP,  the  top  Portuguese   airline,  with  more  than  200  daily  flights  and  millions  of  passengers  every  year,  is   a  pioneer  in  the  social  networks  world.  It  has  more  than  160.000  page  fans,  users   engage   in   conversations   with   the   airline,   and   TAP   had   the   vision   of   not   only   creating   a   new   customer   service   channel,   but   also   a   community   where   one   can   ask   for   some   information   (rapidly   answered   in   a   maximum   of   30   minutes),   do   online  check-­‐in  and  even  book  a  ticket.    

 

The  aim  of  this  thesis  is  for  professors  and  students  to  understand  the  practices   and  the  strategy  that  makes  TAP’s  social  media  successful,  as  well  as  understand   how  its  users  perceive  not  only  the  Facebook  page  but  also  the  effects  that  it  has   on  the  company’s  image.  The  dissertation  is  divided  in  two  main  parts:  the  case   study   (literature   review,   airline   industry   and   TAP   analysis)   and   the   market   research   (where   based   on   an   online   survey,   the   author   reaches   important   conclusions   about   TAP’s   strategy).     At   the   end   of   these   two   parts,   the   author   draws  the  main  conclusions,  limitations  and  suggestions  for  future  research.      

Overall,  thanks  to  the  thesis,  and  by  using  the  teaching  notes,  students  will  be  able   to  realize  the  importance  of  marketing  and  market  research  in  the  development   of  an  accurate  social  media  strategy,  as  well  as  its  effects  in  an  airline’s  customer   perception.     Finally,   the   case   study   presents   as   main   reasons   for   the   airline’s   success:   TAP’s   Facebook   fans   and   high   awareness,   as   well   as   its   congruent   practices  and  strategic  vision.  Thanks  to  their  strategy,  TAP  is  now  seen  as  more   modern,  updated  and  closer  to  its  customers.  

 

 

(4)

RESUMO  

 

Título  da  dissertação:  A  estratégia  de  redes  sociais  e  social  media  na  

TAP.  

Autor  :  Carlos  Falcato  

 

O   sector   dos   transportes   aéreos,   intensamente   competitivo,   está   actualmente   a   investir   em   social   media   como   uma   maneira   de   criar   diferenciação   e   ampliar   o   relacionamento  com  os  clientes.    TAP,  a  maior  companhia  aérea  Portuguesa,  com   mais   de   200   vôos   diários   e   milhões   de   passageiros   por   ano,   é   uma   pioneira   no   mundo  das  redes  sociais.  A  empresa  tem  mais  de  160.000  fãs  no  Facebook,  onde   os   utilizadores   participam   activamente   em   conversações   com   a   companhia   e,     mais   do   que   isso,   a   TAP     teve   a   visão   de   não   apenas   criar   um   novo   canal   de   suporte   ao   cliente,   mas   também   uma   comunidade   onde   os   utilizadores   podem   solicitar   informações   (rapidamente   respondidas   no   prazo   máximo   de   30   minutos),  fazer  o  check-­‐in  online  e  até  mesmo  reservar  um  bilhete.    

 

Esta  tese  permite  a  professores  e  alunos  compreender  as  práticas  e  a  estratégia   para   as   redes   sociais,   que   tornaram   a   TAP   um   caso   de   sucesso,   bem   como   entender  como    é  que  os  utilizadores  percepcionam  a  sua  página  de  Facebook  e  os     efeitos   que   a   mesma   tem   sobre   a   imagem   da   empresa.   A     presente   dissertação   está  dividida  em  duas  partes  principais:  o  estudo  de  caso  (revisão  de  literatura,   análise  do  sector  e  da  TAP)  e  a  pesquisa  de  mercado  (  onde  base  num  inquérito   online  ,  o  autor  chega  a  conclusões  importantes  sobre  a  estratégia  da  TAP).    No   final   destes   dois   pontos,   o   autor   delineia   as   principais   conclusões,   limitações   e   sugestões  para  futuras  pesquisas.    

 

No  geral,  graças  à  tese  e  utilizando  as  notas  de  ensino,  os  alunos  serão  capazes  de   perceber   a   importância   do   marketing   e   da   pesquisa   de   mercado   no   desenvolvimento  de  uma  estratégia  efectiva  de  social  media  ,  bem  como  os  seus   efeitos    ao  nível  da  percepção  do  cliente  em  relação  à  respectiva  companhia  aérea.     Finalmente,   a   dissertação   apresenta   como   principais   razões   para   o   sucesso   da   companhia   aérea   Portuguesa   nos   social   media,   os   (muitos)   fãs   da   TAP   no   Facebook,     o   seu   elevado   reconhecimento   ,   bem   como   as   suas   práticas   congruentes   e   visão   estratégica.   Graças   a   esta   mesma   estratégia,   a   TAP   é   agora   vista     como   mais   moderna,   actualizada   e   mais   próxima   dos   seus   clientes.

(5)

Table  of  Contents  

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS  ...  i   ABSTRACT  ...  ii   RESUMO  ...  iii   1.   Introduction  ...  3   2.   Methodology  ...  5   3.   Literature  Review  ...  6  

3.1   Branding  in  the  digital  age  ...  6  

3.2   Online  Social  Networks  ...  7  

3.2.1   Social  Media  ...  8  

3.2.2   Determine  influential  users  ...  9  

3.2.3   Online  Brand  communities  ...  10  

3.2.4   Marketing  capabilities  gap  ...  11  

3.3   Word-­‐of-­‐Mouth    (WOM)  ...  12  

3.3.1    Word-­‐of-­‐Mouth  Marketing  ...  12  

3.3.2    Managerial  implications  ...  13  

4.   Case  Study:  TAP’s  Social  Networks  and  Social  Media  Strategy  ...  15  

4.1   TAP  –  The  Portuguese  airline  ...  15  

4.1.1   Short  review  of  TAP’s  history  ...  15  

4.1.2   TAP  –  A  leading  carrier  ...  16  

4.1.3   Airline  industry’s  main  trends  ...  18  

4.2   TAP  and  the  social  media  ...  19  

4.2.1   Airline  industry  overview  ...  19  

4.2.2      TAP’s  background  ...  21  

4.2.3      Social  media  practices  at  TAP  ...  22  

4.2.4      TAP’s  social  media  data  and  performed  activities  ...  23  

5.        Market  Research  ...  26  

5.1    Market  Research  Methodology  ...  26  

5.2      Results  Analysis  ...  28  

5.2.1      Sample  Analysis  ...  28  

5.2.2      Are  people  aware  of  TAP’s  Facebook  page?  On  average  how  frequently  is  it   visited?  ...  29  

5.2.3    What  are  the  main  reasons  that  consumers  find  to  visit  TAP's  Facebook  page?  ...  30  

5.2.4  How  do  consumers  perceive  TAP’s  Facebook  page?  What  factors  influence  it   the  most?  ...  31  

5.2.5  Do  TAP's  Facebook  page  help  improve  its  image  and  the  way  consumers  see   it?  What  are  the  factors  that  influence  a  better  evaluation  on  the  change?  ...  33  

6.      Teaching  Notes  ...  36  

6.1.    Case  study  synopsis  ...  36  

6.2.    Target  audience  and  teaching  objectives  ...  36  

6.3    Teaching  plan  ...  36  

6.4      In  class  discussion:  Part  1  ...  37  

6.5.    In  class  discussion:  Part  2  ...  40  

(6)

APPENDIX  ...  46  

Exhibit  1  –  Map  of  TAP’s  destinations  ...  46  

Exhibit  2  –  TAP  Group  chart  ...  46  

Exhibit  3  –  Airline  Industry  five  forces  of  Porter  ...  47  

Exhibit  4  -­‐  Top  Facebook  brand  pages  in  terms  of  fans  ...  48  

Exhibit  5-­‐  TOP  fan’s  nationalities  ...  49  

Exhibit  6  –  Visitants’  demographic  profile  ...  49  

Exhibit  7  –  Visitant’s  geographic  origin  ...  49  

Exhibit  8  –  Top  Tab  views  ...  50  

Exhibit  9  –  TAP’s  Facebook  snapshots  ...  51  

Exhibit  10  –  Online  survey  questions  ...  54  

Exhibit  11  –  Sample  demographic  charts  ...  57  

Exhibit  12  –  Sample  social  platform’s  usage  ...  58  

Exhibit  13  –  Visited  airlines  frequencies  ...  58  

Exhibit  14  –  “Being  a  Fan”  Frequencies  ...  60  

Exhibit  15  –  Crosstab  Fan*Visited  Ryanair  &Visited  Easy  jet  ...  60  

Exhibit  16  -­‐  “Never  Visited”  Frequencies  ...  61  

Exhibit  17  –  Number  of  visits’  frequencies  ...  61  

Exhibit  18  –  Number  of  visits:  regression  analysis  ...  62  

Exhibit  19  –  Crosstab  between  “being  a  fan”  and  frequency  of  visits  ...  63  

Exhibit  20  –  Reasons  to  visit  frequencies  ...  64  

Exhibit  21  –  “Rank  reasons  to  visit”  frequencies  ...  65  

Exhibit  22  –  “Rank  reasons  to  visit”  frequencies  simplified  ...  65  

Exhibit  23  –  Semantic  Differential  Scale  Frequencies  ...  66  

Exhibit  24  –  A-­‐Nova  Analysis  for  Semantic  Differential  Scale  ...  66  

Exhibit  25  –  Regression  Analysis  Semantic  Differential  Scale  ...  68  

Exhibit  26  -­‐  Change  in  image  correlations  ...  70  

Exhibit  27  –  Change  in  image  frequencies  ...  70  

Exhibit  28  –  Change  in  image  matrix  score  card  ...  70  

Exhibit  29  -­‐  Regression  analysis  -­‐  change  in  image  ...  71  

Exhibit  30  –  A-­‐Nova  Change  in  image/fan  ...  74  

Exhibit  31  –  A-­‐Nova  Change  in  image  /  Nº  of  visits  ...  74  

8.      References  ...  75                                      

(7)

1. Introduction  

 

Nowadays,  social  networks  and  social  media  are  everywhere.  It  is  a  way   for  people  to  be  connected  and  updated  about  their  friends’  lives,  to  share  ideas   and  thoughts  and,  overall,  to  communicate.  Furthermore,  it  did  not  take  too  long   for   companies   to   realize   the   opportunities   that   this   new   platform   could   bring,   and   while   consumers   are   having   conversations   and   expressing   their   feelings   about  the  brands,  companies  are  listening  and  trying  to  engage  them.    

Facebook  and  Twitter  are  the  top  social  media  platforms  when  it  comes  to  the   number  of  worldwide  users  and  the  buzz  it  creates.    The  airline  industry  is  one  of   the   most   valuable,   competitive   and   consumer   based   industries   in   the   entire   world.   Therefore,   the   author   decided   to   cross   social   media   (Facebook   and   Twitter)   with   a   top   national   airline   that   was   a   pioneer   in   the   use   of   social   networks,  so  that  several  lessons  could  be  taken  and  a  good  example  would  be   documented  –  the  chosen  company  was  the  Portuguese  TAP.  

Although   TAP   started   quite   gradually   in   the   social   media,   after   a   crisis   management   event   (the   Iceland’s   volcano   ashes   in   March   2010)   the   company   rapidly   invested   resources,   assigned   teams   to   manage   Facebook   and   truly   started   using   it   in   a   strategic   way,   instead   of   just   being   present   like   many   competitors.   TAP   was   an   international   pioneer.   If   one   visits   its   Facebook   page   and,   for   instance,   poses   a   question   in   the   wall,   it   is   promptly   answered   in   a   maximum   of   30   minutes.   Moreover,   it   provides   excellent   customer   service,   its   Facebook   dedicated   promotions   are   successful   and,   foremost,   the   users   do   engage  in  conversations  about  and  with  TAP.    It  is  not  by  chance  that  TAP’s  page   has  more  than  160.000  fans  and  it  is  the  15th  with  the  most  fans  in  Portugal.    

Within  this  case  study,  TAP’s  social  media  “backstage”    -­‐  how  they  achieve   this  success-­‐  will  be  the  object  of  study.  Also,  this  will  be  the  part  that  students   will   have   right   away   access.   On   the   other   part   (given   after   the   students   make   their  own  studies,  due  to  being  the  author’s  personal  analysis),  through  several   research  questions,  the  author  investigates  why  TAP  is  indeed  successful,  while   deeply  studying  its  user’s  profile.  In  order  to  do  these  investigations  and  answer   the   research   questions   stated   bellow,   the   author   conducted   a   quantitative   analysis   based   on   data   from   an   online   survey.     The   results   from   the   market  

(8)

research   offer   important   conclusions   that   help   solving   the   research   questions   and  ultimately  provide  insights  on  the  problem  statement.    

 

Problem  statement  

The  goal  of  this  study  is  to  analyse  why  TAP  is  indeed  successful,  to  understand   how  the  user’s  perceive  the  page  and  ultimately  the  company  after  their  social   media  strategy.  Moreover,  to  learn  more  about  TAP’s  Facebook  users  profile.    

Research  Questions  

1) Are  people  aware  of  TAP's  Facebook  page?  On  average,  how  frequently  is  it   visited?  

2) What  are  the  main  reasons  that  consumers  find  to  visit  TAP's  Facebook  page?   3) How  do  consumers  perceive  TAP's  Facebook  page?  What  factors  influence  it  

the  most?  

4) Do  TAP's  Facebook  page  help  improve  its  image  and  the  way  consumers  see   it?  What  are  the  factors  that  influence  a  better  evaluation  on  the  change?    

The   structure   of   this   case   study   is   made   for   the   reader   to   have   first   a   theoretical  overview,  then  a  deep  analysis  of  the  company  and  its  social  media   strategy  along  with  an  industry  overview,  and  finally  the  market  research  and  its   conclusions.   In   a   more   detailed   view,   the   case   study   will   start   with   the   methodology  chapter,  followed  by  the  literature  review,  company  and  industry   analysis,   market   research   and   finally   the   conclusions,   limitations   and   hints   for   future  research.    

(9)

2. Methodology  

 

The   used   methodology   for   all   the   case   study   was   influenced   by   the   circumstances   and   informational   needs   that   were   appearing   as   the   author   was   conducting  its  analysis.  The  first  principle  was  to  always  have  reliable  sources  of   information  and  material  that  was  current,  as  marketing  and  the  social  media  are   areas   that   change   in   time   and   where   the   up-­‐to-­‐date   data   and   occurrences   are   crucial.  Many  online  sources  were  used  and  will  be  described  in  the  references   chapter.   On   the   other   hand,   it   is   very   important   to   note   the   inside   TAP   information  that  was  provided  by  the  airline’s  marketing  department,  which  was   then  adapted,  studied  and  used  in  the  present  case.  Overall,  the  used  method  was   the  funnel  one,  which  starts  with  theory,  the  industry  and  the  company,  and  then   the  problem  statement.  Thanks  to  this  method,  the  author  was  able  to  gradually   and  efficiently  be  evolved  by  the  theme  while  progressively  gaining  knowledge   that  allowed  the  problem  statement  and  research  questions  to  be  answered  in  a   complete  way.    

The   Literature   review   methodology   will   be   further   explained   in   the   literature   review   chapter,   however   the   main   method   was   to   read   at   least   15   articles   (mostly   from   top   marketing   journals)   while   gathering   the   needed   information.   The   chosen   themes   were:   Branding   in   the   digital   age,   Social   networks  and  Word-­‐of-­‐mouth.    

Finally,  the  methodology  used  for  the  market  research  when  it  comes  to  the   collection  method  was  an  online  survey  and  the  data  analysis  was  performed  on   excel   and   SPSS.   Moreover,   due   to   its   specificity   and   logic   reasons,   the   detailed   market  research  methodology  is  explained  on  the  respective  chapter.    

 

(10)

3. Literature  Review  

 

The  literature  review  is  the  theoretical  basis  for  the  whole  case  study.  In   this  chapter,  the  author  analyses  three  main  themes  that  will  be  further  applied   in  the  rest  of  the  thesis:  Branding  in  the  digital  age,  Social  networks  and  Word-­‐ of-­‐mouth.  The  reason  behind  the  choice  of  these  three  main  topics  comes  from   the  importance  of  studying  the  brand  (TAP)  applied  to  the  digital  age,  the  social   networks   (TAP’s   Facebook   page)   and   all   the   dynamics   following   it,   and   finally   the   importance   of   the   word-­‐of-­‐mouth   for   the   company’s   social   media   and   marketing  strategy.  The  review  will  start  with  the  branding  part,  then  the  social   networks  and  social  media,  on  which  the  determination  of  influential  users  will   also   be   studied.   Furthermore,   online   brand   communities   and   then   word-­‐of   – mouth  will  be  covered  topics.    

Keywords:  Branding;  Social  Networks;  Social  Media;  Brand  Communities;  Online;   Internet;  Word-­‐of-­‐mouth.  

 

3.1 Branding  in  the  digital  age  

 

Brands   represent   for   customers   a   simplified   choice,   the   promise   of   a   certain   quality   level,   trust   and   reduced   risk   (Keller   and   Lehmann   2006).     Branding   relates   to   the   management   of   the   brand   and   to   the   exploration   of   its   value.    However,  thanks  to  the  globalization,  this  is  no  longer  a  local  activity.    As   Levitt   (1983)   has   affirmed   in   the   eighties,   companies   should   operate   as   if   the   world  were  one  single  large  market.    Furthermore,  a  lot  has  changed  in  the  way   consumers  perceive  brands  and  react  with  them.    Actually,  the  Internet,  through   its   new   media   channels,   engaged   consumers   with   the   brands   well   beyond   the   companies’   control.   Indeed,   after   a   purchase,   according   to   their   experience,   consumers   will   remain   attached   to   the   products   by   either   promoting   or   backlashing,   to   the   entire   online   world,   the   brand   (Edelman   2010).   Moreover,   customers  increasingly  perceive  brands  as  shared  cultural  property  rather  than   as   privately   owned,   while   feeling   that   they   belong   to   them   and   not   to   the   companies  that  supposedly  own  them  (Cova  and  White  2010).    

(11)

According  to  Edelman  (2010),  this  digital  age  also  comes  with  opportunities  for   marketers.   Considering   that   customers   are   exposing   themselves   online,   revealing  their  opinions  as  well  as  characteristics,  personality  and  demographics,   this   is   an   opportunity   for   managers   to   collect   information   and   gather   more   insights  about  the  market.  Nevertheless,  it  is  important  to  be  prepared  for  this   vague  of  information  and  to  manage  it,  so  that  instead  of  causing  confusion,  it  is   used  in  a  strategic  way.    

Overall,  brand  management  has  changed  with  the  explosion  of  online  social   networks,   where   its   users   share   and   participate   in   conversations   about   the   brands   they   love   or   hate.   Also,   marketers   have   more   information   to   deal   with,   but   also   new   opportunities   have   arisen.   Therefore,   the   key   is   to   be   ubiquitous   and  never  loose  sight  of  what  is  being  said,  although  in  a  way  that  customers  do   not  feel  too  much  in  control.  

 

3.2 Online  Social  Networks  

 

Technology  has  been  steadily  changing  social  interactions  among  people.   Nowadays,   people   spend   on   average   more   time   communicating   through   technology   platforms   (cell   phone,   VoIP,   e-­‐mail,   online   chat)   and   their   frequent   contacts   are   easily   available   to   the   ones   who   own   these   platforms   (Katona,   Zubcsek   and   Sarvary   2011).     At   the   same   time,   social   network   websites   are   ruling  the  online  world,  with  more  than  90%  of  all  teenagers  and  young  adults  in   the  United  States  being  currently  actively  enrolled  in  them  (Trusov,  Bodapati  and   Bucklin  2010).    

In   a   social   network   website,   users   have   profiles   where   they   display   their   demographics   and   interests,   edited   at   their   own   taste   (Katona,   Zubcsek   and   Sarvary   2011).     The   core   of   a   social   network   website   are   the   connections   between   registered   users   and   the   information   that   they   share   among   them.   Within  this  websites,  the  content  is  entirely  user  generated  and  its  attractiveness   and   vitality   comes   from   the   amount   of   generated   content   and   number   of   participants.   Overall,   users   perform   two   main   activities:   create   new   content   (post   pictures,   share   videos,   new   status)   and   consume   content   that   their   connections  produce.  These  social  websites  are  commonly  free  to  use,  therefore  

(12)

the   most   popular   business   model   is   based   on   advertising,   where   revenue   is   earned   either   based   on   showing   the   advertisements   or   by   the   number   of   each   click/action  on  the  ad  (Trusov,  Bodapati  and  Bucklin  2010).  

3.2.1      Social  Media  

 

  Social  media  relates  to  the  use  of  online  social  platforms  (and  others)  to   create   an   interactive   conversation,   and   its   explosive   growth   has   not   been   indifferent  to  marketers,  who  are  heavily  investing  in  this  new  exciting  platform.   Moreover,  managers  are  interested  in  the  networking  value  when  it  comes  to  the   word-­‐of-­‐mouth  and  the  adoption  or  purchase  of  a  product.    In  a  matter  of  fact,   consulting   firm   McKinsey   &   Company   conducted   a   study,   which   showed   that   word-­‐of-­‐mouth   (nowadays   much   effective   thanks   to   the   social   media)   is   the   primary   factor   behind   20   to   50   percent   of   all   purchase   decisions   (Duboff   and   Wilkerson  2010).  Overall,  social  media  can  increase  brand  awareness,  trial  and   ultimately  sales,  but  most  importantly  it  allows  the  marketer  to  gain  consumer   insights   and   feedback   as   never   before   (Barwise   and   Meehan   2010).     Social   technologies  are  also  changing  the  relationship  between  the  consumer  and  the   brand   (Spenner   2010).   Consumers   feel   like   they   own   the   brands   and   will   proactively   participate   in   their   improvements,   new   launches   and   rising   problems,   while   saying   whatever   is   on   their   minds   through   their   social   platform’s  profiles  (Edelman  2010).      

Although  every  company  should  monitor  brand  reputation  and  be  ready   to   respond   to   any   threat   within   social   media,   not   everyone   should   invest   in   it   (Duboff   and   Wilkerson   2010).     Social   media   makes   it   even   more   urgent   for   companies  to  develop  a  clear  brand  promise  and  to  be  truthful  to  it.  In  such  a  fast   paced   social   media   era,   it   is   too   risky   for   companies   to   disappoint   and   anger   customers,   which   will   most   probably   create   a   costly   backlash   (Barwise   and   Meehan  2010).    

Concerning   the   best   approach,   according   to   Barwise   and   Meehan   (2010)   when   starting  in  the  social  media,  companies  should  have  a  clear  strategy  based  on  the   brand  promise;  use  social  media  primarily  for  insights  (although  there  are  a  lot   of   things   besides   collecting   information,   the   real   value   at   this   first   stage   is   to   learn  about  customers);  strive  to  go  viral  but  protect  the  brand  (viral  campaigns  

(13)

improve  sales  and  excitement  about  the  brand,  however  companies  should  not   do  this  at  any  cost  -­‐  it  is  essential  that  they  are  always  authentic  and  relevant);   engage   but   follow   the   social   rules   (do   not   attempt   to   moderate   or   control   too   much  the  conversations  between  the  users);  participate  only  if  they  allow  it  (too   much   control   or   influence   in   the   conversations   might   have   serious   negative   results).  

3.2.2      Determine  influential  users  

 

  The  success  of  Internet  social  networking  websites  depends  on  the  level   of  activity  and  number  of  its  active  users.  Although  typically  every  user  has  many   connections   (“friends”),   only   a   fraction   influence   the   other   members’   website   usage   (Trusov,   Bodapati   and   Bucklin   2010).     Furthermore,   marketers   believe   that   the   efficient   way   of   using   social   networks   relies   on   influencing   word-­‐   of-­‐ mouth,   through   the   analysis   of   member’s   connections.   The   assumption   behind   this  belief  is  that  this  analysis  of  the  network,  would  help  identify  customers  that   are  influencers  and  therefore  predict  consumer’s  adoption  probabilities  (Katona,   Zubcsek  and  Sarvary  2011).  Therefore,  thanks  to  the  online  social  networks  and   its   easiness   to   track   and   gather   information,   several   authors   conducted   numerous   studies   to   find   who   are   the   influencers   among   the   online   social   network   community.   The   results   are   that   female   members   have   a   greater   influence  than  male;  higher  number  of  “friends”  does  not  mean  higher  influence   power,  instead  it  dilutes  the  individual’s  influential  power;  having  more  “friends”   that  adopted  a  certain  product  increases  the  probability  of  a  potential  adopter  to   adopt;   users   from   the   same   ethnicity   are   more   influencing   and   finally,   older   users  are  less  persuading  (Trusov,  Bodapati  and  Bucklin  2010;  Katona,  Zubcsek   and  Sarvary  2011).  

Overall,  it  is  clear  that  demographics  represent  a  good  factor  to  use  when   identifying  the  influencers  and  that  having  many  friends  in  the  network  does  not   translate   in   high   influencing   power.   Marketers   should   then   try   to   target   their   viral  marketing  campaigns  to  individuals  that  will  spread  easier  and  faster  their   message   (influencers)   and   not   just   to   everyone   or   the   ones   that   have   more   member  connections  (Trusov,  Bodapati  and  Bucklin  2010).    

(14)

3.2.3      Online  Brand  communities  

 

  Very  much  related  to  the  digital  age,  branding  and  social  networks  are  the   brand  communities  that  have  proliferated  online.      

Brand   communities   are   a   specialized,   non-­‐geographically   bound   community   based   on   shared   consciousness,   rituals,   traditions   and   a   sense   of   moral   responsibility  among  the  users  of  a  brand  (  Muñiz  and  O’Guinn  2000).  However,   online   brand   communities   go   a   little   further.   An   online   community   can   be   defined   as   a   group   of   people   who   communicate   and   create   bonds,   through   electronic  means.  These  communities  are  not  constrained  by  time  or  space  and   allow  communication  between  a  large  number  of  participants  (Kim,  Choi,  Qualls   and  Han  2008).  Thanks  to  the  growth  of  online  social  network  websites  and  the   easiness  people  have  to  connect  with  each  other,  communities  are  growing  at  a   fast   pace   and   marketers   are   more   attentive   than   ever.   The   truth   is   that   community   is   a   strong   and   rewarding   strategy   if   managed   the   right   way:   it   increases  customer  loyalty,  lowers  costs,  activates  the  brand,  engages  customers   and  offers  consumer  information  and  insights  (Fournier  and  Lee  2009).  

Within   these   communities,   consumers   create   relationships,   share   feelings,   participate  in  brand  activities,  and  give  ideas.    According  to  Kim,  Choi,  Qualls  and   Han  (2008),  contribution  in  the  community  takes  two  forms:  active  and  passive   participation.    In  the  active  participation  users  provide  information,  whereas  in   the  passive  one,  they  define  what  brings  value  to  the  group.  It  is  important  for   both  the  positions,  that  users  feel  listened  and  recognized  by  their  peers.  Also,  it   is  crucial  that  the  company  who  own  the  brand  does  not  exert  excessive  control,   or   serious   damages   might   occur   (Fournier   and   Lee   2009).   This   is   a   place   for   freedom  of  speech,  where  after  daily  or  weekly  contact,  friendships  and  trust  are   created,  which  might  result  in  the  community,  after  several  years,  dispossessing   itself   and   going   beyond   the   brand   boundaries   (   Schau,   Muñiz   Jr   and   Arnould   2009).    

Overall,   findings   are   that   online   communities   can   assist   a   brand   in   building   strong  relationships  with  customers,  who  are  then  more  likely  to  buy  repeatedly   and   spread   positive   word-­‐of-­‐mouth.   Also,   customers   will   happily   participate   in   activities   promoted   by   the   company   while   giving   feedback   and   opinions   that  

(15)

might  improve  the  corporation  (  Kim,  Choi,  Qualls  and  Han  2008;  Schau,  Muñiz  Jr   and  Arnould  2009;  Cova  and  White  2010).  Nevertheless,  the  organization  should   provide  the  right  means  for  the  community’s  development.    

However,   in   order   for   a   real   community   to   exist,   there   is   the   need   of   having   a   strong  infrastructure  that  allows  its  users  to  interact  with  each  other  in  an  easy   and   fluid   way.   Marketing   managers   should   show   appreciation   for   the   user’s   opinion,  by  rewarding  their  contribution  properly.  Also,  rather  than  attempting   to  control  what  is  being  said,  corporations  should  be  open  to  negative  comments   and  complaints  and  be  really  focused  on  their  consumers’  individual  and  social   needs.    They  should  see  customers  as  co-­‐creators  and  manage  the  group  with  a   light,  open  touch  while  being  committed  to  induce  value  (Kim,  Choi,  Qualls  and   Han  2008;  Fournier  and  Lee  2009).  

Shortly,   online   brand   communities   represent   a   world   of   opportunities.   However,  they  should  be  supported  by  high-­‐level  strategies  that  will  make  them   genuine,  authentic  and  valuable  for  both  the  customers  and  the  company.    

3.2.4      Marketing  capabilities  gap  

 

  Although  very  exciting  and  dynamic,  social  media  is  changing  the  industry   at  two  main  levels:  the  way  companies  deal  with  its  customers  and  the  amount  of   generated   information.   Communication   vehicles   are   augmented,   traditional   brand  management  models  are  starting  to  feel  outdated  and  the  forces  of  market   fragmentation   and   change,   leads   to   the   marketers   struggling   to   keep   up   (Day   2011).    

According   to   Spenner   (2010)   today,   brand   marketers   need   to   be   skilled   to   coordinate   a   variety   of   marketing   and   customer–facing   activities   and   to   be   experts   on   online   social   platforms.     They   need   to   work   on   short   time   frames,   sometimes  with  daily  cycles,  while  searching  to  answer  for  new  opportunities  or   threats.   New   and   updated   talent   is   needed   in   order   to   deal   with   this   fast   changing  environment  and  complexity.  According  to  Day  (2011)  three  adaptive   capabilities   are   needed:   1)   vigilant   marketing   learning   processes   that   will   constantly   update   the   company   with   new   information   and   warn   the   managers   when   change   is   coming;   2)   adaptive   market   experimentation   that   uninterruptedly  learns  from  experiments;  3)  open-­‐marketing  that  creates  bonds  

(16)

with  the  new  media  and  social  networking  technologies  and  activates  the  skills   of  current  partners.      

Generally,  companies  will  need  to  be  attentive  to  the  fast  environmental   change  in  order  to  keep  their  competitive  advantages,  be  protected  from  threats   and  explore  new  opportunities.    

 

3.3 Word-­‐of-­‐Mouth    (WOM)  

 

Word-­‐of-­‐mouth   is   no   recent   theme   in   marketing.   However,   the   Internet   and  its  easy  access,  reach  and  transparency  helped  fuel  the  modern  marketer’s   enthusiasm   in   influencing   and   monitoring   WOM   as   never   before   (Kozinets,   de   Valck,  Wojnicki  and  Wilner  2010).  Moreover,  social  networks  became  one  of  the   top  channels  to  generate  buzz  and  consumers’  conversations.  

3.3.1    Word-­‐of-­‐Mouth  Marketing  

 

Word-­‐of-­‐Mouth   Marketing   (WOMM)   is   the   intentional   and   professional   manipulation   of   consumer-­‐to-­‐consumer   communications   (Kozinets,   de   Valck,     Wojnicki  and  Wilner  2010).    This  marketing  strategy  is  very  appealing  because  it   easily   overcomes   the   clutter   and   consumers’   resistance   not   only   at   a   very   attractive   low   cost,   but   also   in   a   short   period   of   time   (Trusov,   Bucklin   and   Pauwels  2009).  

 Through   time,   three   different   WOMM   models   and   practices   being   perpetuated   within  the  marketing  circles  (Kozinets,  de  Valck,    Wojnicki  and  Wilner  2010)    :  It   all   started   with   Ryan   and   Gross’s   (1943)   diffusion   study   and   their   conclusion   that   the   buyer-­‐to-­‐buyer   communications   had   more   influencing   power   in   the   adoption   than   the   traditional   marketing   undertakings.   According   to   them,   the   exposure  to  mass  communication  aligned  with  the  influence  of  well-­‐established   peers,   is   the   key   to   adoption.   At   this   time,   WOM   was   organic,   with   no   external   influence   or   monitoring.   This   model   is   called   the   organic   inter-­‐consumer   influence  model.  

In  the  second  model  (The  linear  marketer  influence  model),  marketers  realized   the  importance  of  identifying  the  most  influential  and  respected  consumers  (e.g.   market  mavens  (Feick  and  Price  1987)),  which  helped  spread  WOM  and  impact  

(17)

other’s  decisions.  This  attentiveness  came  from  the  interest  in  influencing  these   consumers  through  the  use  of  advertising  and  promotions,  in  order  to  facilitate   mass  adoption  or  purchase.  

The   third   and   modern   overview   is   all   about   directly   affecting   WOM   through   specific  marketing  strategies  and  communication  programs.  The  Internet  is  the   perfect  and  unprecedented  playground,  due  to  the  possibility  of  having  detailed   tracking   information   (Trusov,   Bucklin   and   Pauwels   2009)   that   facilitates   the   management   and   measurement   of   the   whole   marketing   campaign   while   improving  the  word-­‐of-­‐mouth  marketing  knowledge.    

Nevertheless,  when  a  company  stimulates  word-­‐of-­‐mouth,  it  is  no  longer  organic   which   will   probably   affect   its   effectiveness.   Although   there   is   not   much   information   about   its   differences,   one   can   predict   that   the   success   levels   of   “fertilized”   (influenced)   WOM   will   be   lower   than   the   organic   ones   (Trusov,   Bucklin  and  Pauwels  2009).    

 

3.3.2    Managerial  implications  

 

According   to   Kozinets,   de   Valck,   Wojnicki   and   Wilner   (2010),   WOM   communication  is  influenced  by  four  main  factors.  The  first  one  is  the  way  it  is   affected   by   the   placement   into   “character   narratives”   or   enduring   personal   stories   that   might   be   understood   as   being   related   to   a   particular   expressed   character   type.   Second,   WOM   communications   take   place   in   many   diverse   forums   (e.g.   dinner   parties,   bars,   social   networking   websites),   and   managers   should   always   be   attentive   to   their   differences.   The   third   factor   relates   the   changing   norms   when   it   comes   to   the   communication.   Meaning,   some   expressions  and  messages  might  have  different  interpretations  according  to  the   type   of   community,   demographic   characteristics,   and   lifestyles   among   others.     Finally,   the   fourth   factor   relates   to   the   influence   that   the   product/service   characteristics,  brand  equity,  ongoing  promotions  and  the  promotional  WOMM   itself,  might  have  on  the  message  and  the  WOM  communication  meanings.  

When  it  comes  to  the  actual  findings  about  this  topic,  Trusov,  Bucklin  and   Pauwels  (2009)  found  empirical  evidence  that  when  compared  with  traditional   marketing   activities   (events;   media   effects),   WOM   referrals   result   in   a   larger  

(18)

short-­‐term   response   and   a   more   lasting   carryover   effect.     Indeed,   WOM   marketing   is   among   the   most   effective   marketing   strategies.   Nevertheless,   managers  should  not  be  guided  by  common  sense,  especially  when  it  encourages   them   to   magnify   positive   and   minimize   negative   WOM   regarding   their   companies.  In  a  matter  of  fact,  recent  research  has  found  that  successful  WOMM   campaigns   include   more   than   simply   positive   messages   (Schlosser   2005).   Furthermore,  Liu  (2006)  affirms  that  the  volume  of  WOM  mentions  is  far  more   important  in  predicting  a  product’s  success,  than  merely  the  amount  of  positive   messages  versus  negative  ones.    However,  Marketers  should  be  aware  of  the  high   risks  that  come  from  attempting  to  influence  online  WOM  (where  everything  is   spread  a  lot  faster).  Therefore,  the  company  should  invest  in  a  clear,  honest  and   genuine  dialogue  in  order  to  protect  itself  from  backlash.    

     

(19)

4. Case  Study:  TAP’s  Social  Networks  and  Social  Media  

Strategy  

4.1 TAP  –  The  Portuguese  airline  

 

4.1.1  Short  review  of  TAP’s  history  

 

  Founded  in  1945  as  “Transportes  Aéreos  Portugueses”  and  as  a  section  of   the  “Secretariado  da  Aeronáutica  Civil”,  TAP  inaugurated  its  first  flight  in  1946   from   Lisbon   to   Madrid.   In   the   31st   of   December   of   that   same   year,   it   starts  

operating  the  route  Lisbon-­‐Luanda-­‐Lourenço  Marques  (current  Maputo),  which   took   15   days   (round   trip)   and   12   stops   along   the   way,   making   it   the   longest   world  route  operated  with  a  DC-­‐3.    The  first  Boeing  (B727)  then  arrives  in  1967,   while   the   last   Super  Constelation   is   withdrawn   from   the   fleet,   making   TAP   the   first   European   company   working   solely   with   jets.     In   1974,   TAP   served   more   than  40  destinations,  located  in  4  continents,  with  a  fleet  of  32  modern  aircrafts.   TAP   then   became   a   public   company   in   1975   and   in   1979   a   modernization   program   is   implemented   along   with   a   new   company   designation:   TAP-­‐Air   Portugal.    

The  company  creates  its  first  website  in  1996  and  thanks  to  its  operational  work   with   the   A340,   it   gains   from   Airbus   the   Award   for   Operational   Excellence.   The   hub   strategy,   with   the   Lisbon   airport   being   the   centre   of   all   operations,   is   implemented  in  2001.    In  2003  Grupo  Tap  is  created,  while  a  new  institutional   image  for  the  company  is  then  presented  in  2005  along  with  the  integration  in   Star   Alliance,   the   largest   global   airline   association.   Then   in   2007,   the   company   acquires  Portugália  –  Companhia  Portuguesa  de  Transportes  Aéreos,  a  regional   Portuguese  airline  company.  Moreover  in  2008,  TAP  starts  emitting  flight  tickets   solely  in  electronic  format  and  launches  the  innovative  “1  voo,  5  formas  de  viajar   ”(1  flight,  5  ways  of  travelling).  This  program  basically  segments  the  plane  in  5   different  segments  (executive,  plus,  classic,  basic  and  discount)  according  to  the   customer’s   willingness   to   pay   and   comfort/exclusivity   needs.   Finally   in   2009,   TAP   is   the   first   airline   worldwide   to   launch   a   CO2   compensation   program   that  

based   on   the   type   of   flight   (duration,   aircraft,   class),   it   calculates   the   cost   to   compensate  the  produced  carbon  and  buy  a  carbon  credit.    

(20)

 

4.1.2  TAP  –  A  leading  carrier  

 

  TAP  is  the  main  Portuguese  airline  company.  It  is  a  Star  Alliance  member   and  currently  65  destinations  in  31  countries  from  Europe,  Africa,  North,  Central   and  South  America  are  offered  (see  exhibit  1,  p.  49).  The  fleet  is  composed  by  55   airbus  planes  with  an  average  life  of  9,5  years,  that  transport  passengers  to  260   daily  destinies.    

TAP  (that  is  the  focus  of  this  case  study)  is  part  of  the  TAP  Group,  which   also   owns   TAPSer,   PGA,   AERO-­‐LB   and   49%   of   GroundForce,   and   provides   services   such   as   maintenance   and   engineering,   catering,   cargo   and   airport   services   (see   exhibit   2,   p.   49).   TAP   currently   employs   4582   people,   with   more   than  a  half  working  on  air  and  others  on  the  ground.    

The  company  is  the  international  leading  carrier  from  Europe  to  Brazil  and  won,   again,  in  2010  the  Word’s  Leading  Airline  to  South  America  travel  award  along   with  the  Condé  Nast  Traveller  distinction  as  the  world’s  best  airline.    The  airline   has  a  niche  strategy  based  on  customer  focus  and  cost  efficiency.  The  customer   emphasis   is   based   on   making   the   passenger’s   travel   experience   the   best   as   possible,   while   travelling   easily   and   safely.   On   the   other   hand,   cost   efficiency   leads  to  market  competition  and  economic  efficiency,  which  is  highly  needed  in   such  a  fiercely  competitive  industry.    

TAP  offers  five  different  products  to  diverse  segments:  tap  executive,  tap   plus,  tap  classic,  tap  basic  and  tap  discount.  These  products  differ  in  price,  extra   services,  seat  place  and  other.  Basically,  the  basis  for  this  division  is  the  different   willingness  to  pay  and  the  extra  services/exclusivity  needs.  When  it  comes  to  its   target  market,  although  very  broad,  it  has  one  specificity:  their  customers  prefer   to  travel  on  TAP  than  on  a  low-­‐cost  company.  

Currently,   2010   was   a   record   in   terms   of   number   of   passengers   (more   than   9   million)   and   capacity   utilization   (74,5%   of   taken   seats   –   plus   6%   than   2009).  However,  the  costs  of  fuel  (523  millions  of  euros  –  plus  48%  than  2009),   the   eruption   of   the   island   volcano   and   its   ash   cloud,   and   the   air   controllers’   strikes  that  proliferated  across  Europe,  had  a  very  negative  impact  in  what  could   have  been  a  great  year  for  TAP.  As  for  2011,  the  costs  from  the  fuel  should  be  

(21)

even   worst:   TAP   already   reported   for   the   first   semester   of   2011,   fuel   costs   around  325  million  euros  (plus  43%  than  the  same  period  in  2010).      

The  sales  volume  was  about  1.995,3  millions  of  euros  (more  12,4  %  than  2009),   there   were   more   flight   hours   (up   to   229.703   thousands   of   hours   –   more   3,7%   than   2009),   the   net   income   raised   to   62,3   millions   of   euros   (more   2,3   millions   than   in   2009).   The   largest   stake   of   costs   comes   from   the   fuel   and   the   human   resources,  which  have  a  great  power  and  influence  in  the  company.    

When  it  comes  to  the  tickets  sold  in  2010,  the  largest  purchasing  markets  were   Europe  (35,8%  of  all  tickets),  Portugal  (30,8%),  Atlantic  South  (21  %)  and  Africa   (6,6%).   Concerning   the   traffic,   the   Atlantic   South   was   the   one   with   highest   (thanks  to  Brazil),  followed  by  the  Europe  (35,1%)  and  Africa  (  11,3%).    

  The   year   of   2010,   represented   also   an   important   period   for   Marketing,   social   platforms   and   e-­‐commerce.   TAP   launched   its   highly   successful   new   signature  “De  braços  abertos”  (“with  arms  wide  open),  that  is  based  on  the  union   of  the  Portuguese  speaking  cultures.  This  campaign  had  a  song  created  especially   for  it,  which  was  sang  by  the  Portuguese  star  Mariza,  the  Angolan  Paulo  Flores   and  the  Brazilian  Roberta  Sá,  and  rapidly  became  the  anthem  for  the  proximity   and  complement  between  this  cultures.  With  this  campaign,  TAP  became  more   than   a   simple   airline   transportation   company.   It   became   the   link   between   cultures,  while  adding  value  and  meaning  to  it.      

When  it  comes  to  the  e-­‐commerce,  the  online  bookings  generated  196  millions  of   euros,  which  represents  820.000  passengers  and  an  increase  of  28,4%  from  the   year  before.  Moreover,  the  Internet  represents  9%  of  TAP’s  global  sales  market,   with   the   Portuguese   and   Brazilian   markets   representing   the   largest   stake.   Finally,  in  2010  the  Fly  TAP  website  (already  available  in  25  countries)  becomes   available  in  Romaine  and  Greece.    

  For   the   next   few   years,   TAP’s   main   commercial   vectors   are   to   maintain   and   reinforce   the   investments   in   Brazil   and   Africa,   due   to   their   growing   economies   and   TAP’s   top   position,   as   they   did   with   creation   of   new   routes   (   Porto   Alegre,   Brazil;   Bamako,   Mali;   Acra,   Gana;   S.Vicente,   Cape   Verde)   and   increase   of   frequency   to   others   (Argel)   ;   to   continue   focusing   on   the   customer   relationship   and   engagement   through   the   Victoria   program   (   frequent   flyer   “loyalty”     program),   and   keep   the   commercial   model   based   on   the   5   ways   of  

(22)

travelling.    

Lastly,  the  future  of  TAP  is  quite  uncertain,  as  its  privatization  is  expected   to  happen  as  soon  as  in  the  first  semester  of  2012.  However,  the  company  does   not   seem   too   worried   and   keeps   investing   and   working   to   improve   as   never   before.    

4.1.3    Airline  industry’s  main  trends  

 

In  order  to  understand  TAP’s  current  situation  and  what  one  can  expect  for  its   future,  it  is  important  to  analyse  the  main  tendencies  for  all  the  industry.  Overall,   the  main  trends  for  the  airline  industry  will  be:  

• Emerging   economies   like   the   BRIC’s   should   be   where   the   opportunities   for   growth   remain,   thanks   to   their   economic   and   demographic   developments.   Business   passengers   as   well   as   leisure   ones   are   expected   to   grow   as   their   purchasing  power  continues  to  increase  and  the  economy  flourishes.    

• The   liberalization   of   the   aviation   markets   will   also   be   an   important   trend.   Markets  are  starting  to  be  more  open  and,  for  example,  many  countries  made   agreements   that   allows   for   international   companies   to   operate   in   domestic   flights  (e.g.  E.U.  and  the  U.S.).    

• The  growth  of  low  cost  carriers  –  intensively  expanding  into  to  Asian-­‐Pacific   routes   –   is   something   traditional   airlines   need   to   take   into   account.   Consumers  are  more  and  more  informed  about  the  industry,  which  leads  to   high  price  sensitivity.  Therefore  companies  need  to  keep  reducing  their  costs   and  finding  ways  to  differentiate  themselves.    

• The  demand  for  more  fuel  effective  planes  like  the  Boeing  787  Dreamliner  is   also   a   current   trend   as   fuel   prices   are   very   elevated   and   represent   a   great   stake  in  the  operating  costs.  

 

Generally,  the  main  things  to  retain  are  that  airlines  are  fighting  to  keep  low   costs  so  that  they  can  offer  low  prices  and  still  be  competitive;  BRIC’s  should  be   the  future  growth  path  and  advantage  should  be  taken  on  the  more  liberalized   air  markets.    

In  order  to  better  analyse  the  industry,  the  author  also  did  a  five  forces  of  Porter   analysis   (see   exhibit   3,   page   50).   Its   main   conclusions   are   that   the   airline  

Imagem

Figure   1   -­‐   Overall   view   of   the   Facebook   page   
Figure   3   -­‐   The   online   check-­‐in   feature           
Figure   4   -­‐   The   TAP   feature   that   provides   information   about   the   airline                                                                                                   
Figure   1   -­‐   "Never   visited"   frequencies   (%)   
+5

Referências

Documentos relacionados

ABSTRACT - The objectives were to study the combining ability of lines, derived from synthetic maize (Zea mays L.) CMS 53, in a diallel crosses, to identify lines for developing

artístico desde la belleza interior hecha creación humana en las virtudes fran- ciscanas que se hizo vida en san Francisco de Asís y de forma renovada en san Pedro de

•• 20 •• Andinós LAC Camões ICG Freitas LF Santiago CN Gomes CC Avaliação do escoamento e radiopacidade de dois cimentos endodônticos Revista de Odontologia da

Para testar a existência de diferenças significativas em relação às características do habitat ocupado pelos barbos monitorizados entre os períodos de caudal ecológico

De acordo com a análise da potência relativa (W\Kg), constatou-se que não houve diferença estatisticamente significativa (p>0,05) entre o grupo com bandagem (CB) e o grupo

Torna-se preponderante o investimento ao nível da linguagem oral desde tenra idade, na medida em que um aluno que teve a oportunidade de frequentar um ambiente educativo rico

empresa tem uma política na convenção do nome das tabelas que é o seguinte: as tabelas de metadados começam sempre por ‘md’, estas tabelas auxiliares são usadas para armazenar

The results we achieved lead us to conclude that there is a positive relationship between the total amount of own equity, external equity and debt and the probability of