CriticaI Restorative Justice

(1)

CriticaI Restorative Justice

Edited by

Ivo Aertsen and Brunilda Pali

·HART·

PUBlISHING

OXFORD AND PORTLAND, OREGON 2017

STJ00105848

(2)

11ZZ'6~~

Han Publishing

An imprint of Bloomsbury Publishing Pie Han Publishing Ltd Bloomsbury Publíshing Pie

KempHouse 50 Bedford Square

Chawley Park London

CumnorHill WCIB3DP

Oxford OX2 9PH UK

UK

www.hartpub.co.uk www.bloomsbury.com

Published in North America (US and Canada) bv

Han Publishing .

cio International Specialized Book Serviçes 920 NE 58th Avenue, Suíte 300

Ponland, OR 97213-3786 USA

www.isbs.com

HART PUBLISHING, the Han/Stag logo, BLOOMSBURY and ^the Diana logo are trademarks of Bloomsbury Publishing Pie

First published 2017

The editors and contríbutors have asserted tIleír right under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 to be identilied as Autllors of this work.

Ali rights reserved. No pan of this publícation may be reproduced or transmitted in any form ar byany means, electronic or mechanícal, induding photocopying, recording, or any ínformation

storage or retrieval system, without prior perflÚssion in writing from tIle publishers.

While every care has been taken to ensure the accuracy of tIlis work, no responsibility for loss or damage occasioned to any person acring or refraining from action as a result of any statement

in it can be accepted by tIle authors, editor. or publisher•.

Ali House of Lords and House of Commons informatíon used in tIle work is Parlíamentary Copyríght ©.

This informatíon is reused under tIle terms of tIle Open Government Licence v3.0 (http://www.

nationalarchives.gov.ukldoc/open-govemment-licence/versi0013) except where otllerwise stated.

Ali Eur-Iex material used in the work is © European Unioo, hnp:lleur-lex.europa.eul, 1998-2017.

Brítish Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data A catalogue record for this book 1s ava1Jable from the British Library.

ISBN: HB: 978-1-50990-664-2 ePDF: 978-1-50990-662-8 ePub: 978-1-50990-663-5 Library of Coogeess Catalogrng-in-Publication Data Names: Aensen, Ivo, editor. I Pali, Brunilda, editor.

Title: Crítical restorative justice I edited by Ivo Aertsen and Brunilda Pali.

Desçription: Oxford [UK] ; Portland, Oregon : Harr Publishing, 2017.

Includes bibJiographícal referenees and indexo

Identiliers: LCCN 2017029130 (print) I LCCN 2017031523 (ebook) I ISBN 9781509906635 (Epub) I ISBN 9781509906642 (hardback: alk. paper)

Subjects: LCSH: Restorarive justíce. I Reparation (Criminal justice)

Classilication: LCC K970 (ebook) I LCC K970 .C79 2017 (priot) I DDC 364.6/8-<1c23 LC record avaílable at https:/llccn.loc.gov/2017029130

Typeset by Compuscript Ltd, Shannon

Printed and bound in Great Britaio by Lighming Source UK Led

To lind oue more about our autllors and books visit www.harrpublishing.co.uk. Here you will f1nd extracts, author information, details of fortllcoming events and the option to sigo up for our newsletters.

STJ00105848

(3)

~1 '6~'-I

'u blishing P lc omsbury Publishing Pie

50 Bedford Squa re London WC1B3DP

UK

~k :om

and Canada) by Book Services mte 300 3786

, BLOOMSBURY and lhe ,sbury Publishing Pk 17

severally 2017

eir right under lhe Copyright, ed as Authors of this work.

,duced or transmitted in any form or by a ny ,ying, recording, or an)' informarion on in wriring from rhe pubJishers.

,s work, no responsibíliry for loss or damage acrion as a result of an)' statement

~ditors or pubJishers.

ltion used in lhe work is Crown Copyrighr ©.

Govemmenr Lioence v3.0 (http://www.

'rsion/3) except where olherwise srated.

'n, http://eur-Iex.europa.eul, 1998-2017.

ublication Data e from me British Library.

90-664-2 90-662-8 90-663-5 ,Publication Data i, Brunilda, editor.

) Aertsen and Brunilda Pali.

: Hart PubJishing, 2017.

:es and indexo

:CN 2017031523 (ebook) I

~906642 (hardback : alk. paper) ,aration (Criminal justice)

!O17 (prim) I DDC 364.618-dc23 :.govI2017029130

, Shannon

~hming Source UK Ltd

~artpublishing.co.uk. Here you wíll find d the option to sign up for our newsletters.

List of Contributors ... vii

Introduction: Restorative Justice and Criticai Social Theory ... 1 Brunilda Pali and Ivo Aertsen

Part I: Bridging the Theoretical Gap and Sharpening the Criticai Edge

1. Is a Crítica I Model of Restoratíve Justíce Possíble? A Penal

Abolitíonist Approach ... 13 Daniel Achutti

2. Deconstructíng Empowerment in Restorative J ustice ... 29 Daniela Bo/ívar

3. Restorative Justice and the Decísion-makíng Process: Beyond

Deliberative Democracy? ... 47 Raffaella da Porciuncula Pallamolla

4. Doíng Restorative Justíce 'Otherwise': Decolonising Practices

in the Global South ... 61 Harry Blagg

5. Outlíning a Historical and Criticai Ontology of Restorative

Justice ... 79 Giuseppe Maglione

6. Restorative Justíce ís Not a Panacea Against Ali Social Evils ... 95 Lode Walgrave

7. Restorative Justice, Procedural Justice and Care ... 111 Josep Tamarit Sumalla

Part 11: Applying Analytical Tools and Frameworks to Research and Practice

8. Restorative Justice and Democratic Citizenship: A New Social

Pedagogy or Back to 'Social Defence'? ... 127 Leo Van Garsse

9. Old Goffman as a New Research Strategy in Resrorative justice ... 143 Ida Helene Asmussen

STJ00105848

(4)

VI

CriticaI Restorative Justice