ABSTRACT
Shor
tC
ommunication
CONTEXT: Wide varieties of approaches are employed in dealing with low anal fistula. However,thesimplemethodoflayingopenthe fistulatract(fistulotomy)isstillconsideredtobe thefavoredone.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: A modified ap-proach to the procedure of fistulotomy is discussed.Thisstudydescribestheprocedure, which used a technique of radiofrequency surgery,anditsoutcomein232patientswith lowanalfistula.Thepatientswerefollowedfor aperiodof15months.
RESULTS:Thepatientsweredischargedonthesame dayastheprocedure.Themeanperiodoffwork was four days. The average healing time re-cordedwas67days.Fourwoundcomplications intheformofprematureclosureoftheexternal wound were noted, which required trimming oftheedges.Twoofthesewoundsremained unhealed.Therecurrenceratewas1.7%.
CONCLUSION:Inthiserawhentheemphasisison criterialiketheminimizationofhospitalstay,re-ductionofpostoperativepain,earlyresumption ofworkandlowandcomparablerecurrence rates, there is a future for the procedure of radiofrequencyfistulotomy.
KEY WORDS: Rectal fistula. Recurrence. Anus. Radiowaves.Colorectalsurgery.
Radiofrequencyfistulotomy:
abetteralternativefor
treatinglowanalfistula
FineMorningHospitalandResearchCenter,Nagpur,India
•PravinJaiprakashGuptaINTRODUCTION
Theclassiclay-opentechniqueisstillthe mostfavoredprocedureforanalfistula.Slitting thecompletetract,startingfromtheexternal openingandproceedingtotheinternalopen-ing,isthebasisfortraditionalfistulotomy.1
However, this conventional procedure at timesencountersbriskbleedingfromthecut surfaces.Thedissectioncausesunpredictabletis-suetrauma,therebyaggravatingthepostoperative painandedema,delayingthereturntoworkand necessitatingintakeofstrongerdosesofanalgesics forlongerperiods.Theriskofwoundcomplica-tionslikeinfection,delayedwoundhealingand recurrencearebutafewoftheotherareasofcon-cernaccompanyingthetraditionalmethod.
Instead of using the scalpel, we have employed radiofrequency waves to perform the same lay-open procedure for treatment oflowanalfistula(lowtrans-sphinctericand intersphinctericfistula).Thesurgicalprinciple inradiofrequencysurgeryisthattheoffending tissueobstructingthepathofthehigh-pow-eredradiowavesisdestroyed.Theintracellular tissuewaterthatprovidestheresistanceinthe processisinstantlyvaporizedwithoutcausing heatanddamage,unlikewhattakesplacein electrosurgery.This tissue vaporization also resultsinsignificanthemostasiswithoutactu-allyburningthetissue.2Inaddition,thereis
nodangerofthepatientsufferinganyshock orburnintheprocess.Theradiofrequency-generatingunitisprovidedwithaterminalto whichdifferentelectrodescanbeattachedto suittheexactrequirementoftheprocedure. Wehaveusedaballelectrodeforcoagulation, aneedleelectrodetoincisethefistulatractand
aroundloopelectrodetoshavethetracttissue inourprocedures.Thesurgicalradiofrequency generatorthatwehavebeenusingisthedual frequency4MHzunitfromEllmanInterna-tional(Hewlett,NewYork).
METHODS
Thestudyincluded232consecutivepatients withlowanalfistula.Alowanalfistulawastaken tobeonewithatractthatdoesnotextendabove theleveloftheanalcryptsandusuallyopensat thislevelintotheanalcanal.Allofthesepatients werefollowedoveraperiodaveraging15months (range:14-18months).Thefollowingtypesof fistulawereexcludedfromthestudy:hightrans-sphinctericfistulaswithorwithouthighblind tract,supra-sphincteric,extra-sphinctericand horseshoefistulas,aswellasfistulasassociated withinflammatoryboweldisease.
Radiofrequencyfistulotomyprocedure
All the patients were operated on under short-durationgeneralanesthesia.Thestep-by-stepapproachtoourprocedurewasasfollows: 1. Injectionofmethylenebluedyewithhydro-genperoxide3intotheexternalopeningof
thefistula.Thishelpedinobtainingaclear displayofthemainfistulatract.Italsoopened upthesecondaryorsidetractsifpresent. 2. While viewing through the anoscope, a
directionalprobewasgentlypassedthrough theexternalopeninguntilitcameoutfrom theinternalopening,whichwasdemarcated bytheblueindentationofthedye. 3. Theskinoverlyingtheprobeinthefistula
tract was coagulated by moving the ball electrodeoveritscompletelength.Thiswas
SãoPauloMedicalJournal—RevistaPaulistadeMedicina
173
foundtoreducetheamountofbleeding whenthetractwasslitopenedthereafter. 4.Thetractwascutopenedalongthelineofthe
probewiththehelpoftheneedleelectrode, switchedtothe‘cutandcoagulation’mode. This reduced the bleeding while cutting andmadethedissectionsmoothenough toavoidanydragonthetissues. 5.Thewoundedgeswerecoagulatedwiththe
ball electrode kept in the ‘coagulation’ mode.Thisobviatedthepossibilityofany oozefromthewoundsurface.
6.Thetract,alongwiththesurroundinginfect-edfibrotictissuewascurettedwiththeloop electrodeinthe‘cutandcoagulation’mode. Ascuttingandcoagulationwereachieved simultaneously, the brisk bleeding often encounteredintheconventionalknifeand scissorsdissectionwasavoided.
7.Finally,theedgesofthewoundwereshaved, usingtheloopelectrodetocreateapear-shapedwoundtaperingtowardstheanus. The patients were discharged on the eveningoftheprocedure.Theywereaskedto takeatabletcontaining50mgofdiclofenac sodiumand10mgofserratiopeptidasetwicea dayforsevendaysand,thereafter,asandwhen theyfeltpain.Thepostoperativecareconsisted oftheapplicationofantisepticcreamoverthe woundtwiceadayafterawarmsitzbath.
RESULTS
Themeanproceduretimewas13min-utes.Thiswasrecordedbyanindependent observer,andwascalculatedasthetotaltime required from inserting the probe in the fistula tract to the application of dressing overthewound.
Thepatientsweredischargedassoonas theybecamefullymobilizedwithouttheneed
forassistancefromanurseforpersonalhygiene anddressing.Astheprocedurewascarriedout undershort-durationgeneralanesthesia,most ofthepatientswereabletogohomewithin eighthoursoftheprocedure.
Theperiodoffworkisdefinedasthetotal timetakentoreturntotheusualactivityof domesticandsociallifeatthepatient’sdiscre-tion.Patientsoperatedonviaradiofrequency fistulotomyprocedureswereabletoresume theirroutinewithinaweekoftheprocedure (ameanof4days).
A mean of 18 doses of analgesic were required,whereonedoseequaledonetablet ofthecombinationofdiclofenacsodium50 mgandserratiopeptidase10mg.
Thewoundhealingtimewastakenasthe periodneededforcompleteepithelizationof the fistulotomy wound.The average time takenforwoundstohealwas67days,ranging from42to75days.
Fourpatientsfromourstudywerefound to have premature closure of the proximal wound while the distal end remained un-healed.The healed edges of the proximal part of the wound were slit opened under localanesthesia.Followingthis,thewounds healedintwoofthesepatients.However,in theremainingtwo,theyfailedtoheal.These twocasesweretermed‘failureofwoundheal-ing’ratherthanrecurrence(0.8%).
Noneofthepatientshadanyinterference withcontinence.Withafollow-upofatleast 15months,therecurrenceratewasaslowas 1.7%(4outof232patients).
Complications
No major complications were encoun- teredwiththeradiofrequencydevice.How-ever, failure to monitor the exact power requirement from the unit, in a few of the
initial cases, resulted in the use of higher power rates than necessary, thereby causing smokeandcharring.Thiswasrectifiedinthe subsequentprocedures.
DISCUSSION
Radiofrequencysurgeryusesaveryhigh frequency radio wave.4The tissue damage
caused by radiofrequency is superficial and iscomparablewiththeresultsfromthehar-monicscalpelandlaser.
Radiofrequencysurgerycreatesminimalcol-lateralheatdamageinthetissue,thusresultingin rapidhealingandleavingnouglyscar.5Theunit
doesnotrequireanyrecurringmaintenanceexcept forthenormalcareduringitshandlinganduse.
In comparison with other treatment techniques for anal fistula, our study pro-duced results that were equal to or even betterthanobtainedusingtheseothers,such as marsupialization,6,7 sphincter preserving
procedures,8 coring-out technique,9
instil-lationoffibringlue,10-12flapprocedures,13,14
excision of fistula and closure of internal opening,15 incision, and lay-open16 using
rubber seton17 or medicated seton.18The
improvementcameintermsofwoundheal-ing,woundcomplications,interferencewith continenceandrecurrence(Table1).
CONCLUSION
Thefistulotomyprocedureusingaradio-frequency technique has distinct advantages like a short operation time, minimal blood loss,earlyreturntonormalactivityandalow recurrencerate.Wefoundfromourstudythat thismethodcanserveasausefuladditionfor improvingontheresultsfromtheconventional procedurefortreatinglowanalfistula.
Table1.Comparativeresultsfromradiofrequencyfistulotomyandothertreatmenttechniquesforanalfistula
Observations Ourseries Otherseries
Timeforwoundhealing 67days Marsupialization:42days6
Lay-open:70days6
Failureofwoundhealing 0.8% Fibringlue:29%7–100%8
Flap:36%9
Recurrence 1.7% Sphincterpreservingprocedure:5%10
Marsupialization:10%11
Seton:22%12
Flap:33%13
Fibringlue:40%14
Incontinenceforflatus None Lay-open:10%16
Marsupialization:20%6
Incontinenceforliquids None Excisionoffistulawithclosureofinternalopening:11%15
Delayedhealing None Opencoring-out(function-preserving)technique:15%17
Abscessformation None Medicatedseton:3-5%18
SãoPauloMedicalJournal—RevistaPaulistadeMedicina
174
Fistulotomia por radiofreqüência: uma alter-nativamelhorparaotratamentodafístula analbaixa.
CONTEXTO:Umagrandevariedadedemétodos podeserutilizadanomanejodafístulaanal baixa. No entanto, o simples método de aberturaeexposiçãodafístula(fistulotomia) éaindaconsideradoomelhordeles.
MATERIAISEMÉTODOS: Ummétodomodi- ficadoparaaabordagemdefistulotomiaédis-cutido.Esteestudodescreveoprocedimento, emquefoiusadaumatécnicadecirurgiapor radiofreqüência,eoseuresultadoem232paci-entescomfístulaanalbaixa.Ospacientesforam acompanhadosporumperíodode15meses.
RESULTADOS:
Ospacientestiveramaltanomes-modiadoprocedimento.Amédiadetempo semtrabalharfoidequatrodias.Amédiade tempoparacicatrizaçãofoide67dias.Quatro complicaçõesdaferida,caracterizadasporfe-chamentoprematurodaáreaexternadaferida, foramobservadas,exigindoincisõesdaregião daperiferia.Duasdestasferidaspermaneceram abertas.Oíndicederecorrênciafoide1,7%.
CONCLUSÃO:Nestaépocaemqueaênfaseé dadaacritérioscomomínimapermanência nohospital,reduçãodadorpós-operatória, retorno precoce ao trabalho e índices de recorrênciabaixosecomparáveis,existeum futuroparaoprocedimentodefistulotomia porradiofreqüência.
PALAVRAS-CHAVE: Fístula retal. Recidiva. Cirurgiaretal.Ânus.Ondasderádio.
PUBLISHINGINFORMATION
PravinJaiprakashGupta,MS(GeneralSurgery). Fine Morning Hospital and Research Center, Nagpur, India.
Sourcesoffunding:None
Conflictofinterest:None
Dateoffirstsubmission:June11,2003
Lastreceived:October23,2003
Accepted:December22,2003
Addressforcorrespondence:
Dr.PravinJ.Gupta GuptaNursingHome, D/9,Laxminagar, Nagpur-440022 India.
Tel.(+91)7122231047 Fax.(+91)7122547837 E-mail:[email protected]
COPYRIGHT©2004,AssociaçãoPaulistadeMedicina
RESUMO
1. García-AguilarJ,DaveyCS,LeCT,LowryAC,Rothenberger DA.Patientsatisfactionaftersurgicaltreatmentforfistula-in-ano.DisColonRectum.2000;43(9):1206-12.
2. Pfenninger JL, Zainea, GG. Common anorectal conditions: PartII.Lesions.AmFamPhysician.2001;64(1):77-88 3. GunawardhanaPA,DeenKI.Comparisonofhydrogenperoxide
instillationwithGoodsall’sruleforfistula-in-ano.ANZJSurg. 2001;71(8):472-4.
4. PlantRL.Radiofrequencytreatmentoftonsillarhypertrophy. Laryngoscope.2002;112(8Pt2):20-2.
5. RexJ,RiberaM,BielsaI,ParadeloC,FerrándizC.Surgical managementofrhinophyma:reportofeightpatientstreated withelectrosection.DermatolSurg.2002;28(4):347-9. 6. HoYH,TanM,LeongAF,Seow-ChoenF.Marsupializationof
fistulotomywoundsimproveshealing:arandomizedcontrolled trial.BrJSurg.1998;85(1):105-7.
7. Ereifej S, Lestár B, Hornok L, Ritter L, Kiss J. Az analis
fistula kezelése. [Treatment of anal fistulas]. Magy Seb. 2000;53(6):263-6.
8. IwadareJ.Sphincter-preservingtechniquesforanalfistulasin Japan.DisColonRectum.2000;43(10Suppl):S69-77. 9.
HongoY,KurokawaA,NishiY.Opencoring-out(function-preserving) technique for low fistulas. Dis Colon Rectum. 1997;40(10Suppl):S104-6.
10. SentovichSM.Fibringlueforanalfistulas:long-termresults. DisColonRectum.2003;46(4):498-502.
11. AitolaP,HiltunenKM,MatikainenM.Fibringlueinperianal fistulas-apilotstudy.AnnChirGynaecol.1999;88(2):136-8. 12. ChanKM,LauCW,LaiKK,etal.Preliminaryresultsofusing
acommercialfibrinsealantinthetreatmentoffistula-in-ano.J RCollSurgEdinb.2002;47(1):407-10.
13. SonodaT, HullT, Piedmonte MR, Fazio VW. Outcomes of primary repair of anorectal and rectovaginal fistulas us-ing the endorectal advancement flap. Dis Colon Rectum.
2002;45(12):1622-8.
14. Mizrahi N, Wexner SD, Zmora et al. Endorectal advance-mentflap:aretherepredictorsoffailure?DisColonRectum. 2002;45(12):1616-21.
15. GustafssonUM,GrafW.Excisionofanalfistulawithclosure oftheinternalopening:functionalandmanometricresults.Dis ColonRectum.2002;45(12):1672-8.
16. MaloufAJ,BuchananGN,CarapetiEA,etal.Aprospective auditoffistula-in-anoatSt.Mark’shospital.ColorectalDis. 2002;4(1):13-9.
17. TheerapolA,SoBY,NgoiSS.Routineuseofsetonsforthetreat-mentofanalfistulae.SingaporeMedJ.2002;43(6):305-7. 18. MohiteJD,GawaiRS,RohondiaOS,BapatRD.Ksharsootra
(medicatedseton)treatmentforfistula-in-ano.IndianJGastro-enterol.1997;16(3):96-7.
REFERENCES