h tt p : / / w w w . b j m i c r o b i o l . c o m . b r /
Medical
Microbiology
Antimicrobial
resistance
in
Enterobacteriaceae
in
Brazil:
focus
on
-lactams
and
polymyxins
Jorge
Luiz
Mello
Sampaio
a,b,∗,
Ana
Cristina
Gales
c,∗aUniversidadedeSãoPaulo,FaculdadedeCiênciasFarmacêuticas,DepartamentodeAnálisesClínicaseToxicológicas,SãoPaulo,
SP,Brazil
bFleuryMedicinaeSaúde,Sec¸ãodeMicrobiologia,SãoPaulo,SP,Brazil
cUniversidadeFederaldeSãoPaulo,EscolaPaulistadeMedicina,DepartamentodeMedicinaInterna,SãoPaulo,Brazil
a
r
t
i
c
l
e
i
n
f
o
Articlehistory:
Received7October2016 Accepted7October2016 Availableonline25October2016 AssociateEditor:MarinaBaquerizo
Keywords:
ESBL KPC NDM
Extendedspectrum-lactamases NewDelhimetallo--lactamase Klebsiellapneumoniae carbapenemase PolymyxinB Colistin Antimicrobialresistance Carbapenemases Brazil Enterobacteriaceae
a
b
s
t
r
a
c
t
Duringthelast30yearstherehasbeenadisseminationofplasmid-mediated-lactamases
inEnterobacteriaceaeinBrazil.Extendedspectrum-lactamases(ESBL)arewidely
dissem-inated inthehospitalsettingandaredetectedina lowerfrequencyinthecommunity setting.CefotaximasesarethemostfrequentlydetectedESBLtypeandKlebsiellapneumoniae
isthepredominantspeciesamongESBLproducers.Klebsiellapneumoniae carbapenemase-producingEnterobacteriaceaebecamewidelydisseminatedinBrazilduringthelastdecade andKPCproductioniscurrentlythemostfrequentresistancemechanism(96.2%)in car-bapenem resistant K. pneumoniae.To dateKPC-2is the onlyvariant reportedin Brazil. PolymyxinBresistanceinKPC-2-producingK. pneumoniaehascometoanalarmingrate of27.1%in2015inSãoPaulo,thelargestcityinBrazil.NewDelhimetallo--lactamasewas detectedinBrazilin2013,hasbeenreportedindifferentBrazilianstatesbutarenotwidely disseminated.AntimicrobialresistanceinEnterobacteriaceaeinBrazilisaveryserious prob-lemthatneedsurgentactionswhichincludesbothmorestrictadherencetoinfectioncontrol measuresandmorejudicioususeofantimicrobials.
©2016SociedadeBrasileiradeMicrobiologia.PublishedbyElsevierEditoraLtda.Thisis anopenaccessarticleundertheCCBY-NC-NDlicense(http://creativecommons.org/
licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
ThefirstreportsonantimicrobialresistanceinGram-negative rods from Brazil, available at PubMed, were restricted to community-acquiredinfections.Thesereportswereon sul-fadiazineresistanceinEscherichiacoli,ShigellaandSalmonella
anddatedfrom1968.1,2 In1971chloramphenicol resistance
wasreportedinSalmonellaTyphidetectedinvarious Brazil-ianstates3 andShigella resistant tomultipleantimicrobials
∗ Correspondingauthors.
E-mails:sampaio@usp.br(J.L.Sampaio),ana.gales@gmail.com(A.C.Gales).
were reported from RiodeJaneiro.4 Atthat time,-lactam
resistancewasonlyreportedforampicillin.
The
rise
of
extended-spectrum
-lactamases
Thirdgeneration cephalosporinsbecameavailablefor clini-caluseinBrazilinearly1980s.Inourmedicalpractice,we
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.bjm.2016.10.002
1517-8382/©2016SociedadeBrasileiradeMicrobiologia.PublishedbyElsevierEditoraLtda.ThisisanopenaccessarticleundertheCC BY-NC-NDlicense(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
haveobservedresistancetothird-generationcephalosporins amongEnterobacteriaceae since 1985, but the first report of thisfindinginBrazilianhospitalswaspublishedonlyin1994, describinga52%cefepimeresistancerateamong ceftazidime-resistantEnterobacteriaceae.5Thiswasthefirstpublishedclue
onthepresenceofextendedspectrum-lactamases(ESBLs) inBrazil.In1997,the firstconfirmationofESBLproduction
inEnterobacteriaceaefromBrazilcameout.Theauthors
doc-umentedthepresenceofESBLsin72K.pneumoniaeclinical isolates,fromprivateandpublictertiaryhospitalslocatedin RiodeJaneiroandSãoPaulo,byclavulanicacidinhibition.Of note,theyalsoreportedalowsusceptibilityratesforamikacin (41.4%)andgentamicin(29.6%)butallisolateswerestill sus-ceptible toimipenem.6 A subsequent work,also published
in1997,including982consecutiveisolatesfrom18hospitals, fromfourdifferentstatesandsevendifferentcities,wasthe firstpublicationthatcouldbeusedtoestimatetheESBLrate amongEnterobacteriaceae.Assumingthat resistancetothird generationcephalosporinswasonlyduetoESBLproduction,
16%and5%ofK.pneumoniaeandE.coli,respectively,wouldbe
classifiedasESBLproducersatthattime.7
The first molecular studies on ESBLs from Brazil came outin2000,evidencingthepredominanceofblaCTX-Mgenes and describing the CTX-M-8 enzymein strains other than
K. pneumoniae from Rio de Janeiro.8 The same group of
researchersdescribedtheBES-1andtheCTX-M-16enzymesin strainsfromthesamecity.9,10Subsequentsurveillancestudies
evidencedagrowingESBLproductionratesamong
Enterobacte-riaceaecollectedfrominpatients.In2000,theESBLproduction
rateinK.pneumoniaecollectedfromintensivecareunitswas
59.2%,whiletheseratesinEnterobacterspp.andE.coliwere 19.5%and14.6%,respectively.11Themostrecentstudyonthe
diversityofESBLtypesinEnterobacteriaceaeisolatedfromBrazil refersto1827isolates collectedduring theperiod between August2003andMarch2008inthecity ofCuritiba,Paraná. CTX-M-2wasthemostfrequentlydetectedESBLinall
Entero-bacteriaceaespecies,exceptinEnterobacteraerogenes,inwhicha
CTX-M-59-producingclonewaspredominant.12Recent
stud-ieshavereportedthatESBL-producingEnterobacteriaceaeare nowdetectedinasignificantrateinoutpatientspresenting cystitis.InapublicinstitutionlocatedinBrasilia,theESBL pro-ductionrateinE.colicollectedfromJuly2013toApril2014was 7.1%.13WhenwereviewedallpublicationfromBrazilabout
ESBLs,CTX-M-2wasthemostfrequentlydetectedenzymeand wasalsodetectedinthelargestnumberofdifferent
Enterobac-teriaceaespecies(Table1).
Plasmid-mediated
AmpCs
FOX-5-like andCMY-2-like werethe first plasmid-mediated AmpCs(pAmpC)reportedinBrazilianisolates.Bothenzymes were detected inE. coli.42,43 TheFOX-5-like encodinggene
was detected during the DNA sequencing of a 41-kb con-jugative plasmid that harbored a qnrA gene and a class 1 integronwiththeaadBandcatB3genecassettes.43The
CMY-2-like enzyme was detected in four carbapenem-resistant
E.coli strains,which alsopossessed alterationin theouter membrane proteins, isolated from a single patient.42 Dias
and colleagues studied the prevalence of pAmpC among
Table1–Extendedspectrum-lactamasesdetectedin
EnterobacteriaceaeinBrazil.
Enzyme Species
BES-1 Serratiamarcescens9
CTX-M-1 K.pneumoniae14
CTX-M-2 Enterobacteraerogenes12,15;Enterobactercloacae12,16; Escherichiacoli12,16–22;Klebsiellapneumoniae14,16,21,23–29; K.oxytoca21;Morganellamorganii16,21;Proteus mirabilis8,17,21;Providenciastuartii16,21,30;Salmonella typhimurium31;S.marcescens17
CTX-M-3 E.coli22
CTX-M-8 Citrobacteramalonaticus8;Enterobactercloacae8;E. aerogenes8;E.coli12,16,22;K.pneumoniae14
CTX-M-9 Citrobacterfreundii16;E.cloacae10,12;E.coli10,12,16,20;K. pneumoniae16
CTX-M-14 E.coli18,32
CTX-M-15 E.aerogenes12;E.cloacae12,33;E.coli18,22,32,34;K. pneumoniae27,33,35
CTX-M-16 E.coli10;E.cloacae10 CTX-M-28 K.pneumoniae24;K.oxytoca21
CTX-M-59 E.aerogenes15;E.cloacae15;E.coli20,21,27;K. pneumoniae21,23,27 CTX-M-74 E.cloacae16 CTX-M-75 P.stuartii16 CTX-M-131 P.stuartii36 GES-1 K.pneumoniae37 GES-7 K.pneumoniae38 PER-2 E.cloacae12,15 SHV-2 K.pneumoniae;E.coli22 SHV-4 K.pneumoniae39
SHV-5 E.cloacae16;E.coli16,19,21;K.pneumoniae16
SHV-12 E.aerogenes12,15;E.cloacae12,15;K.pneumoniae21,25,35 SHV-27 K.pneumoniae21,40 SHV-28 K.pneumoniae21,41 SHV-31 K.pneumoniae35 SHV-38 K.pneumoniae35 SHV-40 K.pneumoniae38 SHV-45 K.pneumoniae21 SHV-55 K.pneumoniae21 SHV-108 K.pneumoniae41 SHV-122 K.pneumoniae41 TEM-15 K.pneumoniae21 TEM-115 K.pneumoniae21 TEM-116 K.pneumoniae38 TEM-135 E.cloacae12
Enterobacteriaceae isolated from a teaching hospital in Rio
de Janeiro. In that study pAmpC encodinggenes were not detectedand the multidrugresistancephenotypeobserved in five E. coli strain was attributed to hyperexpression of chromosomallyencodedAmpC.44Veryfewstudiesdescribed
the frequency of pAmpCs in Enterobacteriaceae in Brazil, althoughpAmpCs areofepidemiologicalimportance,since carbapenem resistancecan occur instrainswith concomi-tantpermeabilityalterationsandpAmpCexpression.Astudy conducted in a public tertiary hospital from São Paulo included41E.coli,fiveKlebsiellaoxytoca,65Klebsiella
pneumo-niae,18P.mirabilis,andfourSalmonellaspp.detectedduring
the periodfrom January and July 2006 and found a 0.75% plasmid-mediatedAmpCproductionrateandasingleisolate producing aCMY-2-likeenzymewasidentified.45 Themost
recentstudyonpAmpCsinBrazilevaluatedthefrequencyof plasmid-mediatedAmpCsinE. coliisolated fromurine cul-tures from bothoutpatientsand inpatients. Thefrequency
Table2–KPC-producingspeciesdetectedinBrazil.
Species Location(City,State) MLST
C.freundii AL59;DuquedeCaxias,RJ60;GO59;RJ59 – E.aerogenes CE59;DF59;PE59
E.cloacae CE59;DF59;GO59;MG59;PortoAlegre,RS60,61;Riode Janeiro59,62
–
E.gergoviae Recife,PE63 –
E.hormaechei RiodeJaneiro64 –
E.coli BA59;DF59;MG59;Recife,PE59,65;RiodeJaneiro,RJ59,66 ST259;ST3959;ST4359;ST30559;ST47959;ST50265; ST62959;ST63059;ST63159;ST63259
K.pneumoniae AL67;AM67;Brasília,DF67;CampoGrande,MS68,69; CE67;ES67,70;Florianópolis,SC67,71;Franca,SP60; GO67,70;JoãoPessoa,PB72;Lageado,RS73;MA67; MG67,70;PE67,70;PI67;PortoAlegre,RS61,73,74;Recife, PE28,56,65,67,75;RibeirãoPreto,SP26,60;RiodeJaneiro, RJ14,60,67,76;SãoPaulo,SP27,77–80 ST1126,60,67,70,80;ST1367;ST1667,70;ST1767;ST1967; ST2567,70;ST5567;ST7070;ST10170;ST13867;ST25860; ST32367;ST34067,75;ST42370;ST43760,67,72,80;ST44270; ST44370;ST75667;ST75767;ST75867;ST75967; ST76067;ST83767;ST83867;ST83967;ST84067; ST84167;ST84267;ST85567 K.oxytoca Recife,PE81;RJ59;MG59 –
K.georgiana PortoAlegre,PA82 –
M.morganii MG59 –
P.agglomerans RJ59 –
P.mirabilis Recife,PE83 –
P.stuartii Recife,PE84;MG59 –
S.marcescens DuquedeCaxias,RJ60;PortoAlegre,RS61;Recife, PE59,85;Dourados,MS52
–
ThefollowingabbreviationscorrespondtoBrazilanStates:AL,Alagoas;AM,Amazonas;BA,Bahia;DF,DistritoFederal;ES,EspíritoSanto;GO, Goiás;MA,Maranhão;MG,MinasGerais;MS,MatoGrossodoSul;PB,Paraíba;PE,Pernambuco;RJ,RiodeJaneiro;RS,RioGrandedoSul;SC, SantaCatarina;SP,SãoPaulo.
of plasmid-mediated AmpC was 0.46% in outpatients and 1.8%ininpatients.Thefullnucleotidesequenceswere deter-minedandblaCMY-2wasthemostfrequentlydetectedgene, butblaCMY-4wasalsodetected.46
The
rise
of
carbapenemases
in
Brazil
Imipenemhasbeen availableforclinicaluseinBrazilsince the end of the 80s. In 1989 a surveillance study, carried outwith1231isolates,mainlyfrominpatientsfromfive dif-ferent medicalcenters from São Paulo, Riode Janeiro and Salvador,reporteda1%imipenemresistancerateforE.coli,
whilethisratewas6%forEnterobactersp.butresistant iso-lates were also found among K. pneumoniae.47 In 1998, a
cefpiromesusceptibilitystudyalsoreportedimipenem resis-tance inEnterobacteriaceae. Using commercial microdilution plates,349Enterobacteriaceaefromtertiaryhospitalsfromfour differentstateswereevaluated.48 Imipenem resistancerate
amongEnterobacterspeciesvariedfrom2to8%,whilethisrate amongK.pneumoniaewas7%,butunfortunately,nofurther studieswerepublishedonthosestrains.In2005,almost20 yearsaftertheintroductionofcarbapenemsinclinicalusein Brazil,thefirstreportofanEnterobacteriaceaeproducinga car-bapenemasecameout.TheworkofLincopanetal.described thepresenceofIMP-1inaK.pneumoniaestraindetectedina patientfromauniversityhospitalfromSãoPaulo,locatedat theSoutheastofBrazil.49ThesameIMP-1-producingK.
pneu-moniaestrainwasdetectedinsixdistincthospitalsofthecity
ofSãoPaulobetweentheyears2003and2005.50Inoneofthese
hospitals,it wasresponsible forcausing anoutbreak inan intensivecareunit.51IMP-1wasalsodetectedinaP.rettgeri
isolatethatwasco-producerofCTX-M-like,and SHV-like.50
Theco-production ofIMP-10and KPC-2was detectedinS.
marcescenscausinganoutbreakinatertiary,teachinghospital
inDourados,MS.52
GES-5,anenzymeoftheGESfamilywithspectrumtoward carbapenems,wasinitiallydetectedinBrazilinaK.pneumoniae
isolatedfromarectalsurveillanceswabofanelderlypatient admittedtoaprivatehospitalinSãoPaulo,in2008.Thisisolate alsoshoweddeletionsonompK35andompK36genes.53GES-5
wasalsodetectedinthreegeneticallyrelatedKluyvera
inter-mediathatwereisolatedfromonesinkandtwodistincttaps
ofanintensivecareunitofatertiary-carehospitalinPorto Alegre,inMay2013,duringanenvironmentalsurveillancefor NDM-1-producingisolates.54Althoughonlyreportedin2014,
GES-5wasalsorecoveredfromthebloodofanadultpatient admittedtoauniversityhospitalinPortoAlegre,in2011.The patienthadacutemyeloidleukemiaandhadrecentexposure tomultipleantibiotics.55
Thefirst reportonthe detectionofKlebsiellapneumoniae
carbapenemase(KPC)inBrazilwaspublishedin2009,56 and
describedthedetectionofKPC-2in2006,tenyearsafterthe firstdetectionofKPC-2inworld,in1996,inNorthCarolina, intheUnitedStatesofAmerica.57,58Theworkdescribedthe
detectionofKPC-2inK.pneumoniaeinfourpatientsfromthe cityofRecife,locatedattheNortheastofBrazil.Earlier dissem-inationofKPC-2productionwaslaterreportedinSãoPaulo. Subsequently,KPC-2wasdescribedinmanyEnterobacteriaceae
speciesandlocationsalloverBrazil(Table2).Todatethisis the onlyvariantreported fromBrazil,although23 variants
(
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pathogens/beta-lactamase-data-resources/)havebeendescribedworldwide.
KPC-2-producingEnterobacteriaceaearenowdisseminated alloverBrazilbutK.pneumoniaeisthemostfrequentspecies. Among this species, ST11 and ST437, which belong to the
clonalcomplex258,arethemostfrequentlydetectedclonal groups(Table2).Arecentpublicationanalyzed3085K. pneumo-niaeisolatescultivatedfrompatientsfrom10privatehospitals fromthegreatSãoPaulourbanarea,duringtheperiodfrom January2011 to December 2015. Most ofthe isolates were recoveredfrombloodcultures.Theworkshowedanamazing increaseinthecarbapenemresistancerate,from6.8%in2011 to35.5%in2015;ofnote,KPC-2wasdetectedin96.2%ofthe carbapenem-resistantisolates,andtherewereboth interhos-pitalandintrahospitalclonaldissemination.80
NewDelhimetallo--lactamase(NDM)wasfirstlydetected inBrazilin2013,inProvidenciarettgeri,from apatientfrom PortoAlegre,acitylocatedattheSouthofBrazil.86This
detec-tionoccurredfouryearsaftertheinitialdetectioninaST14
K. pneumoniaestrain causing urinary tract infection and in
anE.colistrainfromfecesfromaSwedishpatientofIndian origin.87ComparedtowhathappenedwithKPC,whichwas
detectedinBrazil10yearsaftertheinitialdescription, NDM-1-producingstrainsweredetectedmuchearlier,whichindicates agreatpotentialformoreefficientdisseminationinBrazil.
ThisP.rettgeristrainwaslatershowntohaveheterogeneous
carbapenem resistance, which could make its detection a challengingtask.88 Subsequently,expressionofNDM-1was
reportedinE.hormaecheifromthesamecitywherethefirst casehadbeendetected.89E.cloacaecomplexstrainsand
Mor-ganellamorganiiexpressingNDM-1werealsoreportedbyother
researchgroupfromPortoAlegre.90Inthesameyearof2013,
thefirstcomplete nucleotidesequences ofblaNDM-1-bearing plasmids from Brazil were described, in E. coli and E.
hor-maecheicultured fromthe samerectal swabfromapatient
fromRiodeJaneirowhohadneverbeenexposedto carbapen-ems.TheblaNDM-1genewasfoundtobelocatedonaIncFIIk
inE.hormaecheiandonaIncX3plasmidinaST2E.coli,but
bothplasmidscontainedanewstructuredesignatedTn3000, thatcouldpossiblymediatethetranspositionoftheblaNDM-1 gene.91Subsequently,coproductionofNDM-1andKPC-2was
describedinP.rettgeriandE.cloacaefromRiodeJaneiro.62,64
Morerecently,anewclassAcarbapenemase,designated BrazilianKlebsiellacarbapenemase(BKC-1)wasdescribed in Brazil.92TodateithasonlybeenfoundinK.pneumoniaeina
lowfrequency,possibleduetothefactthattheblaBKC-1geneis locatedinasmalltransferable,non-conjugativeplasmid.92,93
Polymyxin
resistance
in
carbapenem-resistant
K.
pneumoniae:
a
nightmare
Thefirstreportonpolymyxin-resistanceinBrazilian
Entero-bacteriaceae came out in 2006.94 At that time, with a low
colistinandpolymyxinBclinicaluse,thepolymyxinB resis-tance rate was 0.5% in E. coli, 1.8% in K. pneumoniae and 16.7% in Enterobacter spp. In a subsequent publication the samegroupevidenceda3.0%resistancerateamongK.
pneu-moniae in Latin America.95 In 2013, Pereira et al. reported
a 15% polymyxin resistance rate amongKPC-producing K.
pneumoniaefrom diverseBrazilianstates.67 Polymyxin
resis-tanceinE.cloacaeandK.pneumoniaestrainswasalsoreported fromPorto Alegre,south ofBrazil.61,96 Todate,interruption
ofmgrBgenebyinsertionsequencesormissensemutations isthemostfrequentmechanismofpolymyxinresistancein
K.pneumoniaeinBrazil.93,97Themostrecentevidenceofthe
amazingpolymyxinresistanceprobleminBrazilcamefroma reportfromSãoPaulo,thelargestcityinLatinAmerica.The authorsdescribeda35.5%carbapenemresistanceratedueto KPC-2production,amongK.pneumoniaecausinginfectionsin 2015,andalsofoundanincreaseinpolymyxinBresistance amongKPC-producingK.pneumoniae,from0%in2011to27.1% in2015.80 Thisincreasecoincidedwiththeincreaseduseof
polymyxinsasempirictherapytotreatsevereinfectiouswhen Gramnegativesarepossibleetiologicagentsinintensivecare units. Moreconcerningwasfindinginterhospitaland intra-hospitalclonaldisseminationandthefactthatmostisolates includedinthestudyweredetectedfrombloodcultures.This isatherapeuticnightmare,sinceintravenousfosfomycinand ceftazidime-avibactamarestillnotavailableinBrazil.
Recently,the mcr-1(mobile colistinresistance) genewas detectedinaclinicalstrainofE.coliST101fromtheNortheast ofBrazil.98Theauthors foundthegene locatedon aIncX4
plasmid,andconsequentlytheselectivepressurerepresented bytheoveruseofpolymyxinscouldhavecontributedtothe disseminationofthisresistancemechanism.
Insummary,antimicrobialresistanceinEnterobacteriaceae
inBrazilisaveryseriousproblemthatneedsurgentactions which includes more strict adherence to infection control measures, more judicioususe of antimicrobials inhuman and animal husbandriesand fast approvalofold and new antimicrobialslikefosfomycinandceftazidime-avibactamfor clinicaluseinBrazil,inordertodecreasethepolymyxin con-sume.Ifthesemeasuresarenotappliedtogether,therelease ofceftazidime-avibactamwillbeapartialmeasurethatwill beprobablyfollowedbydisseminationofNDM-1producersin Brazil.
Conflicts
of
interest
Theauthorsdeclarenoconflictsofinterest.
r
e
f
e
r
e
n
c
e
s
1.FernandesMR,TrabulsiLR.Infectiousresistancein
pathogenicentericorganismsisolatedinSaoPaulo,Brasil
(preliminaryreport).RevInstMedTropSaoPaulo.
1968;10(1):52–53.
2.ZulianiME,TrabulsiLR.Invitrosensitivityof166Shigella
strainsisolatedinSaoPaulo,Brazil,tosulphadiazineand
fiveantibiotics.RevInstMedTropSaoPaulo.1968;10(2):70–77.
3.CostaGA,HoferE.Resistancetochloramphenicolof
SalmonellatyphisamplesisolatedinvariousstatesofBrazil.
Hospital(RioJ).1971;79(2):229–242.
4.PalmeiraML,BatalhaPP,GomesVL.Ontheappearanceof
multipleresistancetoantibioticsandchemotherapeutic
agentsofShigellastrainsisolatedinRiodeJaneiro.MemInst
OswaldoCruz.1971;69(1):145–152.
5.JonesRN,MarshallSA.Antimicrobialactivityofcefepime
testedagainstBushgroupIbeta-lactamase-producing
strainsresistanttoceftazidime.Amultilaboratorynational
andinternationalclinicalisolatestudy.DiagnMicrobiolInfect
Dis.1994;19(1):33–38.
6.GalesAC,BolmstromA,SampaioJ,etal.Antimicrobial
extended-spectrumbeta-lactamase(ESBL)isolatedin
hospitalsinBrazil.BrazJInfectDis.1997;1(4):196–203.
7.SaderHS,MimicaI,RossiF,etal.Evaluationoftheinvitro
activityofcefepimecomparedtootherbroad-spectrum
cephalosporinsagainstclinicalisolatesfromeighteen
BrazilianhospitalsbyusingtheEtest.DiagnMicrobiolInfect
Dis.1997;28(2):87–92.
8.BonnetR,SampaioJL,LabiaR,etal.AnovelCTX-M
beta-lactamase(CTX-M-8)incefotaxime-resistant
EnterobacteriaceaeisolatedinBrazil.AntimicrobAgents
Chemother.2000;44(7):1936–1942.
9.BonnetR,SampaioJL,ChanalC,etal.AnovelclassA
extended-spectrumbeta-lactamase(BES-1)inSerratia
marcescensisolatedinBrazil.AntimicrobAgentsChemother.
2000;44(11):3061–3068.
10.BonnetR,DutourC,SampaioJL,etal.Novelcefotaximase
(CTX-M-16)withincreasedcatalyticefficiencydueto
substitutionAsp-240–>Gly.AntimicrobAgentsChemother.
2001;45(8):2269–2275.
11.MendesC,HsiungA,KifferC,etal.Evaluationoftheinvitro
activityof9antimicrobialsagainstbacterialstrainsisolated
frompatientsinintensivecareunitsinbrazil:MYSTIC
AntimicrobialSurveillanceProgram.BrazJInfectDis.
2000;4(5):236–244.
12.NogueiraKdaS,ConteD,MaiaFV,etal.Distributionof
extended-spectrumbeta-lactamasetypesinaBrazilian
tertiaryhospital.RevSocBrasMedTrop.2015;48(2):162–169.
13.GoncalvesLF,deOliveiraMartins-JuniorP,deMeloAB,etal.
Multidrugresistancedisseminationbyextended-spectrum
beta-lactamase-producingEscherichiacolicausing
community-acquiredurinarytractinfectioninthe
Central-WesternRegion,Brazil.JGlobAntimicrobResist.
2016;6:1–4.
14.PeiranoG,SekiLM,ValPassosVL,etal.
Carbapenem-hydrolysingbeta-lactamaseKPC-2inKlebsiella
pneumoniaeisolatedinRiodeJaneiro,Brazil.JAntimicrob Chemother.2009;63(2):265–268.
15.NogueiraKdaS,PaganiniMC,ConteA,etal.Emergenceof
extended-spectrumbeta-lactamaseproducingEnterobacter
spp.inpatientswithbacteremiainatertiaryhospitalin
southernBrazil.EnfermInfeccMicrobiolClin.2014;32(2):87–92.
16.MinariniLA,PoirelL,TrevisaniNA,etal.Predominanceof
CTX-M-typeextended-spectrumbeta-lactamasegenes
amongenterobacterialisolatesfromoutpatientsinBrazil.
DiagnMicrobiolInfectDis.2009;65(2):202–206.
17.AndradeLN,MinariniLA,Pitondo-SilvaA,etal.
Determinantsofbeta-lactamresistancein
meningitis-causingEnterobacteriaceaeinBrazil.CanJ
Microbiol.2010;56(5):399–407.
18.BermanH,BarberinoMG,MoreiraEDJr,etal.Distributionof
straintypeandantimicrobialsusceptibilityofEscherichiacoli
isolatescausingmeningitisinalargeurbansettinginBrazil.
JClinMicrobiol.2014;52(5):1418–1422.
19.MinariniLA,CamargoIL,Pitondo-SilvaA,etal.Multilocus
sequencetypingofuropathogenicESBL-producing
EscherichiacoliisolatedinaBraziliancommunity.Curr Microbiol.2007;55(6):524–529.
20.QueirozML,AntunesP,MouraoJ,etal.Characterizationof
extended-spectrumbeta-lactamases,antimicrobial
resistancegenes,andplasmidcontentinEscherichiacoli
isolatesfromdifferentsourcesinRiodeJaneiro,Brazil.Diagn
MicrobiolInfectDis.2012;74(1):91–94.
21.DropaM,BalsalobreLC,LincopanN,etal.Complexclass1
integronsharboringCTX-M-2-encodinggenesinclinical
EnterobacteriaceaefromahospitalinBrazil.JInfectDev
Ctries.2015;9(8):890–897.
22.PeiranoG,AsensiMD,Pitondo-SilvaA,etal.Molecular
characteristicsofextended-spectrum
beta-lactamase-producingEscherichiacolifromRiodeJaneiro,
Brazil.ClinMicrobiolInfect.2011;17(7):1039–1043.
23.deOliveiraGarciaD,DoiY,SzaboD,etal.Multiclonal
outbreakofKlebsiellapneumoniaeproducing
extended-spectrumbeta-lactamaseCTX-M-2andnovel
variantCTX-M-59inaneonatalintensivecareunitinBrazil.
AntimicrobAgentsChemother.2008;52(5):1790–1793.
24.LopesAC,VerasDL,LimaAM,etal.bla(CTX-M-2)and
bla(CTX-M-28)extended-spectrumbeta-lactamasegenes
andclass1integronsinclinicalisolatesofKlebsiella
pneumoniaefromBrazil.MemInstOswaldoCruz.
2010;105(2):163–167.
25.RamosPI,PicaoRC,AlmeidaLG,etal.Comparativeanalysis
ofthecompletegenomeofKPC-2-producingKlebsiella
pneumoniaeKp13revealsremarkablegenomeplasticityanda
widerepertoireofvirulenceandresistancemechanisms.
BMCGenomics.2014;15:54–69.
26.AndradeLN,VitaliL,GasparGG,etal.Expansionand
evolutionofavirulent,extensivelydrug-resistant
(polymyxinB-resistant),QnrS1-,CTX-M-2-,and
KPC-2-producingKlebsiellapneumoniaeST11international
high-riskclone.JClinMicrobiol.2014;52(7):2530–2535.
27.BuenoMF,FranciscoGR,O’HaraJA,etal.Coproductionof16S
rRNAmethyltransferaseRmtDorRmtGwithKPC-2and
CTX-Mgroupextended-spectrumbeta-lactamasesin
Klebsiellapneumoniae.AntimicrobAgentsChemother.
2013;57(5):2397–2400.
28.CabralAB,MeloRdeC,MacielMA,etal.Multidrugresistance
genes,includingbla(KPC)andbla(CTX)-M-2,amongKlebsiella
pneumoniaeisolatedinRecife,Brazil.RevSocBrasMedTrop.
2012;45(5):572–578.
29.DoCarmoFilhoJR,SilvaRM,CastanheiraM,etal.Prevalence
andgeneticcharacterizationofblaCTX-MamongKlebsiella
pneumoniaeisolatescollectedinanintensivecareunitin
Brazil.JChemother.2008;20(5):600–603.
30.ZavasckiAP,CarvalhaesCG,daSilvaGL,etal.Outbreakof
carbapenem-resistantProvidenciastuartiiinanintensivecare
unit.InfectControlHospEpidemiol.2012;33(6):627–630.
31.FernandesSA,PatersonDL,Ghilardi-RodriguesAC,etal.
CTX-M-2-producingSalmonellatyphimuriumisolatedfrom
pediatricpatientsandpoultryinBrazil.MicrobDrugResist.
2009;15(4):317–321.
32.Cergole-NovellaMC,GuthBE,CastanheiraM,etal.First
descriptionofbla(CTX-M-14)-andbla(CTX-M-15)-producing
EscherichiacoliisolatesinBrazil.MicrobDrugResist.
2010;16(3):177–184.
33.SekiLM,PereiraPS,deSouzaConceicaoM,etal.Molecular
epidemiologyofCTX-MproducingEnterobacteriaceae
isolatedfrombloodstreaminfectionsinRiodeJaneiro,
Brazil:emergenceofCTX-M-15.BrazJInfectDis.2013;17(6):
640–646.
34.PeiranoG,vanderBijAK,FreemanJL,etal.Characteristicsof
Escherichiacolisequencetype131isolatesthatproduce
extended-spectrumbeta-lactamases:globaldistributionof
theH30-Rxsublineage.AntimicrobAgentsChemother.
2014;58(7):3762–3767.
35.TollentinoFM,PolottoM,NogueiraML,etal.Highprevalence
ofbla(CTX-M)extendedspectrumbeta-lactamasegenesin
Klebsiellapneumoniaeisolatesfromatertiarycarehospital:
firstreportofbla(SHV-12),bla(SHV-31),bla(SHV-38),and
bla(CTX-M-15)inBrazil.MicrobDrugResist.2011;17(1):7–16.
36.DropaM,GhiglioneB,MatteMH,etal.Molecularand
biochemicalcharacterizationofCTX-M-131,anatural
Asp240GlyvariantderivedfromCTX-M-2,producedbya
ProvidenciarettgericlinicalstraininSaoPaulo,Brazil.
AntimicrobAgentsChemother.2015;59(3):1815–1817.
37.CorreaL,MartinoMD,SiqueiraI,etal.Ahospital-based
riskfactorsassociatedwithcarbapenem-resistantKlebsiella pneumoniaeinfection.BMCInfectDis.2013;13:80–87.
38.DropaM,BalsalobreLC,LincopanN,etal.Emergenceof
Klebsiellapneumoniaecarryingthenovelextended-spectrum
beta-lactamasegenevariantsbla(SHV-40),bla(TEM-116)and
theclass1integron-associatedbla(GES-7)inBrazil.Clin
MicrobiolInfect.2010;16(6):630–632.
39.MendesC,KifferC,SeguraA,etal.Klebsiellapneumoniaewith
multipleantimicrobialresistance.BrazJInfectDis.
2004;8(1):109–111.
40.CorkillJE,CuevasLE,GurgelRQ,etal.SHV-27,anovel
cefotaxime-hydrolysingbeta-lactamase,identifiedin
KlebsiellapneumoniaeisolatesfromaBrazilianhospital.J AntimicrobChemother.2001;47(4):463–465.
41.VerasDL,AlvesLC,BraynerFA,etal.Prevalenceofthebla
(SHV)geneinKlebsiellapneumoniaeisolatesobtainedfrom
hospitalandcommunityinfectionsandfromthemicrobiota
ofhealthyindividualsinRecife,Brazil.CurrMicrobiol.
2011;62(5):1610–1616.
42.PavezM,NevesP,DropaM,etal.Emergenceof
carbapenem-resistantEscherichiacoliproducingCMY-2-type
AmpCbeta-lactamaseinBrazil.JMedMicrobiol.2008;57(Pt
12):1590–1592.
43.CastanheiraM,PereiraAS,NicolettiAG,etal.Firstreportof
plasmid-mediatedqnrA1inaciprofloxacin-resistant
EscherichiacolistraininLatinAmerica.AntimicrobAgents Chemother.2007;51(4):1527–1529.
44.daSilvaDiasRC,Borges-NetoAA,D’AlmeidaFerraiuoliGI,
etal.PrevalenceofAmpCandotherbeta-lactamasesin
enterobacteriaatalargeurbanuniversityhospitalinBrazil.
DiagnMicrobiolInfectDis.2008;60(1):79–87.
45.CampanaEH,BarbosaPP,FehlbergLC,etal.Frequencyof
plasmid-mediatedAmpCinEnterobacteriaceaeisolatedina
BrazilianTeachingHospital.BrazJMicrobiol.
2013;44(2):477–480.
46.RochaDA,CamposJC,PassadoreLF,etal.Frequencyof
plasmid-mediatedAmpCbeta-lactamasesinEscherichiacoli
isolatesfromurinesamplesinSaoPaulo,Brazil.MicrobDrug
Resist.2016;22(4):321–327.
47.deGodoyCV,MendesCM,MimicaI,etal.Invitro
susceptibilitytoanewantimicrobialagent(imipenem)of
pathogensisolatedfrominpatientsatvariouscenters.Rev
InstMedTropSaoPaulo.1989;31(3):169–176.
48.SaderHS,MendesCM,MontelliA,etal.Invitro
antimicrobialactivityofcefpiromecomparedtoother
broad-spectrumbeta-lactamdrugsagainst804clinical
isolatesfrom9Brazilianhospitals.RevAssocMedBras(1992).
1998;44(4):283–288.
49.LincopanN,McCullochJA,ReinertC,etal.Firstisolationof
metallo-beta-lactamase-producingmultiresistantKlebsiella
pneumoniaefromapatientinBrazil.JClinMicrobiol.
2005;43(1):516–519.
50.LincopanN,LeisR,VianelloMA,etal.Enterobacteria
producingextended-spectrumbeta-lactamasesandIMP-1
metallo-beta-lactamasesisolatedfromBrazilianhospitals.J
MedMicrobiol.2006;55(Pt11):1611–1613.
51.PenteadoAP,CastanheiraM,PignatariAC,etal.
Disseminationofbla(IMP-1)-carryingintegronIn86among
Klebsiellapneumoniaeisolatesharboringanewtrimethoprim
resistancegenedfr23.DiagnMicrobiolInfectDis.
2009;63(1):87–91.
52.SilvaKE,CayoR,CarvalhaesCG,etal.CoproductionofKPC-2
andIMP-10incarbapenem-resistantSerratiamarcescens
isolatesfromanoutbreakinaBrazilianTeachingHospital.J
ClinMicrobiol.2015;53(7):2324–2328.
53.PicaoRC,SantosAF,NicolettiAG,etal.Detectionof
GES-5-producingKlebsiellapneumoniaeinBrazil.JAntimicrob
Chemother.2010;65(4):796–797.
54.RibeiroVB,ZavasckiAP,RozalesFP,etal.Detectionof
bla(GES-5)incarbapenem-resistantKluyveraintermedia
isolatesrecoveredfromthehospitalenvironment.Antimicrob
AgentsChemother.2014;58(1):622–623.
55.RibeiroVB,FalciDR,RozalesFP,etal.Carbapenem-resistant
GES-5-producingKlebsiellapneumoniaeinSouthernBrazil.
BrazJInfectDis.2014;18(2):231–232.
56.MonteiroJ,SantosAF,AsensiMD,etal.Firstreportof
KPC-2-producingKlebsiellapneumoniaestrainsinBrazil.
AntimicrobAgentsChemother.2009;53(1):333–334.
57.YigitH,QueenanAM,AndersonGJ,etal.Novel
carbapenem-hydrolyzingbeta-lactamase,KPC-1,froma
carbapenem-resistantstrainofKlebsiellapneumoniae.
AntimicrobAgentsChemother.2001;45(4):1151–1161.
58.QueenanAM,BushK.Carbapenemases:theversatile
beta-lactamases.ClinMicrobiolRev.2007;20(3):440–458,table
ofcontents.
59.TavaresCP,PereiraPS,MarquesEdeA,etal.Molecular
epidemiologyofKPC-2-producingEnterobacteriaceae
(non-Klebsiellapneumoniae)isolatedfromBrazil.Diagn
MicrobiolInfectDis.2015;82(4):326–330.
60.AndradeLN,CuriaoT,FerreiraJC,etal.Disseminationof
blaKPC-2bythespreadofKlebsiellapneumoniaeclonal
complex258clones(ST258,ST11,ST437)andplasmids
(IncFII,IncN,IncL/M)amongEnterobacteriaceaespeciesin
Brazil.AntimicrobAgentsChemother.2011;55(7):3579–3583.
61.RibeiroVB,AndradeLN,LinharesAR,etal.Molecular
characterizationofKlebsiellapneumoniae
carbapenemase-producingisolatesinsouthernBrazil.JMed
Microbiol.2013;62(Pt11):1721–1727.
62.QuilesMG,RocchettiTT,FehlbergLC,etal.Unusual
associationofNDM-1withKPC-2andarmAamongBrazilian
Enterobacteriaceaeisolates.BrazJMedBiolRes.
2015;48(2):174–177.
63.AlmeidaAC,deCastroKK,FehlbergLC,etal.
Carbapenem-resistantEnterobactergergoviaeharbouring
blaKPC-2inBrazil.IntJAntimicrobAgents.2014;44(4):369–370.
64.PereiraPS,BorghiM,AlbanoRM,etal.Coproductionof
NDM-1andKPC-2inEnterobacterhormaecheifromBrazil.
MicrobDrugResist.2015;21(2):234–236.
65.AlmeidaAC,deSaCavalcantiFL,VilelaMA,etal.
EscherichiacoliST502andKlebsiellapneumoniaeST11sharing
anIncWplasmidharbouringthebla(KPC-2)geneinan
IntensiveCareUnitpatient.IntJAntimicrobAgents.
2012;40(4):374–376.
66.D’AlincourtCarvalho-AssefAP,LeaoRS,daSilvaRV,etal.
EscherichiacoliproducingKPC-2carbapenemase:firstreport
inBrazil.DiagnMicrobiolInfectDis.2010;68(3):337–338.
67.PereiraPS,deAraujoCF,SekiLM,etal.Updateofthe
molecularepidemiologyofKPC-2-producingKlebsiella
pneumoniaeinBrazil:spreadofclonalcomplex11(ST11,
ST437andST340).JAntimicrobChemother.2013;68(2):312–316.
68.ChangMR,BibergCA,LopesFA,etal.Thefirstreportof
infectionwithKlebsiellapneumoniaecarryingthebla(kpc)
geneinStateofMatoGrossodoSul,Brazil.RevSocBrasMed
Trop.2013;46(1):114–115.
69.BibergCA,RodriguesAC,doCarmoSF,etal.
KPC-2-producingKlebsiellapneumoniaeinahospitalinthe
MidwestregionofBrazil.BrazJMicrobiol.2015;46(2):501–504.
70.SekiLM,PereiraPS,deSouzaMdaP,etal.Molecular
epidemiologyofKPC-2-producingKlebsiellapneumoniae
isolatesinBrazil:thepredominanceofsequencetype437.
DiagnMicrobiolInfectDis.2011;70(2):274–277.
71.ZavasckiAP,ZoccoliCM,MachadoAB,etal.KPC-2-producing
KlebsiellapneumoniaeinBrazil:awidespreadthreatin
waiting?IntJInfectDis.2010;14(6):pe539–pe540.
72.FehlbergLC,CarvalhoAM,CampanaEH,etal.Emergenceof
Paraiba,NortheasternBrazil.BrazJInfectDis.
2012;16(6):577–580.
73.ZavasckiAP,MachadoAB,deOliveiraKR,etal.
KPC-2-producingEnterobactercloacaeintwocitiesfrom
SouthernBrazil.IntJAntimicrobAgents.2009;34(3):286–288.
74.RodriguesPerezLR,DiasCG.Emergenceofinfectionsdueto
apolymyxinB-resistantKPC-2-producingKlebsiella
pneumoniaeincriticallyillpatients:whatistheroleofa
previouscolonization?InfectControlHospEpidemiol.
2016;37(2):240–241.
75.MartinsWM,AlmeidaAC,NicolettiAG,etal.Coproduction
ofKPC-2andQnrB19inKlebsiellapneumoniaeST340isolatein
Brazil.DiagnMicrobiolInfectDis.2015;83(4):375–376.
76.LeaoRS,PereiraRH,FolescuTW,etal.KPC-2
carbapenemase-producingKlebsiellapneumoniaeisolates
frompatientswithcysticfibrosis.JCystFibros.
2011;10(2):140–142.
77.PavezM,MamizukaEM,LincopanN.Earlydisseminationof
KPC-2-producingKlebsiellapneumoniaestrainsinBrazil.
AntimicrobAgentsChemother.2009;53(6):2702.
78.BeiraoEM,FurtadoJJ,GirardelloR,etal.Clinicaland
microbiologicalcharacterizationofKPC-producingKlebsiella
pneumoniaeinfectionsinBrazil.BrazJInfectDis.
2011;15(1):69–73.
79.BergamascoMD,BarrosoBarbosaM,deOliveiraGarciaD,
etal.InfectionwithKlebsiellapneumoniaecarbapenemase
(KPC)-producingK.pneumoniaeinsolidorgan
transplantation.TransplInfectDis.2012;14(2):198–205.
80.BartolletiF,SecoBM,CapuzzoDosSantosC,etal.Polymyxin
Bresistanceincarbapenem-resistantKlebsiellapneumoniae,
SaoPaulo,Brazil.EmergInfectDis.2016;22(10):1849–1851.
81.AlmeidaAC,CavalcantiFL,MartinsWM,etal.First
descriptionofKPC-2-producingKlebsiellaoxytocainBrazil.
AntimicrobAgentsChemother.2013;57(8):4077–4078.
82.RibeiroVB,ZavasckiAP,NodariCS,etal.Detectionof
blaKPC-2inacarbapenem-resistantKluyverageorgiana.J
AntimicrobChemother.2012;67(11):2776–2777.
83.CabralAB,MacielMA,BarrosJF,etal.DetectionofblaKPC-2
inProteusmirabilisinBrazil.RevSocBrasMedTrop.
2015;48(1):94–95.
84.AiresCA,AlmeidaAC,VilelaMA,etal.Selectionof
KPC-2-producingProvidenciastuartiiduringtreatmentfor
septicemia.DiagnMicrobiolInfectDis.2016;84(1):95–96.
85.MargateE,MagalhaesV,FehlbergLC,etal.KPC-producing
Serratiamarcescensinahome-carepatientfromRecife,Brazil.
RevInstMedTropSaoPaulo.2015;57(4):359–360.
86.Carvalho-AssefAP,PereiraPS,AlbanoRM,etal.Isolationof
NDM-producingProvidenciarettgeriinBrazil.JAntimicrob
Chemother.2013;68(12):2956–2957.
87.YongD,TolemanMA,GiskeCG,etal.Characterizationofa
newmetallo-beta-lactamasegene,bla(NDM-1),andanovel
erythromycinesterasegenecarriedonauniquegenetic
structureinKlebsiellapneumoniaesequencetype14from
India.AntimicrobAgentsChemother.2009;53(12):5046–5054.
88.ZavasckiAP,FalciDR,daSilvaRC,etal.Heteroresistanceto
carbapenemsinNewDelhi
metallo-beta-lactamase-1-producingisolates:achallengefor
detection?InfectControlHospEpidemiol.2014;35(6):751–752.
89.Carvalho-AssefAP,PereiraPS,AlbanoRM,etal.Detectionof
NDM-1-CTX-M-15-,andqnrB4-producingEnterobacter
hormaecheiisolatesinBrazil.AntimicrobAgentsChemother.
2014;58(4):2475–2476.
90.RozalesFP,RibeiroVB,MagagninCM,etal.Emergenceof
NDM-1-producingEnterobacteriaceaeinPortoAlegre,Brazil.
IntJInfectDis.2014;25:79–81.
91.CamposJC,daSilvaMJ,dosSantosPR,etal.Characterization
ofTn3000,atransposonresponsibleforblaNDM-1
disseminationamongEnterobacteriaceaeinBrazil,Nepal,
Morocco,andIndia.AntimicrobAgentsChemother.
2015;59(12):7387–7395.
92.NicolettiAG,MarcondesMF,MartinsWM,etal.
CharacterizationofBKC-1classAcarbapenemasefrom
KlebsiellapneumoniaeclinicalisolatesinBrazil.Antimicrob AgentsChemother.2015;59(9):5159–5164.
93.MartinsWM,Cordeiro-MouraJR,RamosAC,etal.
Comparisonofphenotypictestsfordetecting
BKC-1-producingEnterobacteriaceaeisolates.DiagnMicrobiol
InfectDis.2016;84(3):246–248.
94.GalesAC,JonesRN,SaderHS.Globalassessmentofthe
antimicrobialactivityofpolymyxinBagainst54731clinical
isolatesofGram-negativebacilli:reportfromtheSENTRY
antimicrobialsurveillanceprogramme(2001–2004).Clin
MicrobiolInfect.2006;12(4):315–321.
95.GalesAC,JonesRN,SaderHS.Contemporaryactivityof
colistinandpolymyxinBagainstaworldwidecollectionof
Gram-negativepathogens:resultsfromtheSENTRY
AntimicrobialSurveillanceProgram(2006–09).JAntimicrob
Chemother.2011;66(9):2070–2074.
96.PerezLR.Evaluationofpolymyxinsusceptibilityprofile
amongKPC-producingKlebsiellapneumoniaeusingEtestand
MicroScanWalkAwayautomatedsystem.APMIS.
2015;123(11):951–954.
97.AiresCA,PereiraPS,AsensiMD,etal.MgrBmutations
mediatingpolymyxinBresistanceinKlebsiellapneumoniae
isolatesfromrectalsurveillanceswabsinBrazil.Antimicrob
AgentsChemother.2016;60(11):6969–6972.
98.FernandesMR,McCullochJA,VianelloMA,etal.Firstreport
ofthegloballydisseminatedIncX4plasmidcarryingthe
mcr-1geneinacolistin-resistantEscherichiacolisequence
Type101isolatefromahumaninfectioninBrazil.Antimicrob