UNIVERSIDADE ESTADUAL DE CAMPINAS
SISTEMA DE BIBLIOTECAS DA UNICAMP
REPOSITÓRIO DA PRODUÇÃO CIENTIFICA E INTELECTUAL DA UNICAMP
Versão do arquivo anexado / Version of attached file:
Versão do Editor / Published Version
Mais informações no site da editora / Further information on publisher's website:
http://www.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_pdf&pid=S0021-75572017000600639
DOI: 10.1016/j.jped.2017.03.005
Direitos autorais / Publisher's copyright statement:
©2017
by Sociedade Brasileira de Pediatria. All rights reserved.
DIRETORIA DE TRATAMENTO DA INFORMAÇÃO Cidade Universitária Zeferino Vaz Barão Geraldo
CEP 13083-970 – Campinas SP Fone: (19) 3521-6493 http://www.repositorio.unicamp.br
JPediatr(RioJ).2017;93(6):639---648
www.jped.com.br
ORIGINAL
ARTICLE
Variants
in
the
interleukin
8
gene
and
the
response
to
inhaled
bronchodilators
in
cystic
fibrosis
夽,夽夽
Larissa
Lazzarini
Furlan
a,
José
Dirceu
Ribeiro
b,
Carmen
Sílvia
Bertuzzo
c,
João
Batista
Salomão
Junior
d,e,
Dorotéia
Rossi
Silva
Souza
f,
Fernando
Augusto
Lima
Marson
b,c,∗aFaculdadedeMedicinadeSãoJosédoRioPreto,SãoJosédoRioPreto,SP,Brazil
bUniversidadeEstadualdeCampinas(Unicamp),FaculdadedeCiênciasMédicas,DepartamentodePediatria,Campinas,SP,Brazil cUniversidadeEstadualdeCampinas(Unicamp),FaculdadedeCiênciasMédicas,DepartamentodeGenéticaMédica,Campinas,
SP,Brazil
dFaculdadedeMedicinadeSãoJosédoRioPreto,HospitalUniversitário,DepartamentodePediatria,SãoJosédoRioPreto,SP,
Brazil
eFaculdadedeMedicinadeSãoJosédoRioPreto,HospitalUniversitário,DepartamentodePneumologiaPediátrica,SãoJosédo
RioPreto,SP,Brazil
fFaculdadedeMedicinadeSãoJosédoRioPreto,CentrodePesquisadeBioquímicaeBiologiaMolecular,Departamentode
BiologiaMolecular,SãoJosédoRioPreto,SP,Brazil
Received2August2016;accepted9January2017 Availableonline15July2017
KEYWORDS CFTR; Diseaseseverity; Interleukin8; Lungfunction Abstract
Objective: Interleukin8proteinpromotesinflammatoryresponses,eveninairways.The pres-enceofinterleukin8genevariantscausesalteredinflammatoryresponsesandpossiblyvaried responses to inhaled bronchodilators. Thus, this study analyzed the interleukin 8 variants (rs4073,rs2227306, andrs2227307) andtheir associationwiththeresponsetoinhaled bron-chodilatorsincysticfibrosispatients.
Methods: Analysisofinterleukin8genevariantswasperformedbyrestrictionfragmentlength polymorphismofpolymerasechainreaction.Theassociationbetweenspirometrymarkersand theresponsetoinhaledbronchodilatorswasevaluatedbyMann---WhitneyandKruskal---Wallis tests. The analysisincludedall cysticfibrosis patients, andsubsequently patientswith two mutationsinthecysticfibrosistransmembraneconductanceregulatorgenebelongingtoclasses ItoIII.
夽 Pleasecitethisarticleas:FurlanLL,RibeiroJD,BertuzzoCS,SalomãoJuniorJB,SouzaDR,MarsonFA.Variantsintheinterleukin8gene
andtheresponsetoinhaledbronchodilatorsincysticfibrosis.JPediatr(RioJ).2017;93:639---48.
夽夽StudyconductedatUniversidadeEstadualdeCampinas(Unicamp),Campinas,SP,Brazil. ∗Correspondingauthor.
E-mail:fernandolimamarson@hotmail.com(F.A.Marson).
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jped.2017.03.005
0021-7557/©2017SociedadeBrasileiradePediatria.PublishedbyElsevierEditoraLtda.ThisisanopenaccessarticleundertheCCBY-NC-ND license(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Results: This study included 186 cystic fibrosis patients. There was no association of the rs2227307variantwiththeresponsetoinhaledbronchodilators.Thers2227306variantwas asso-ciatedwithFEF50%inthedominantgroupandinthegroupwithtwoidentifiedmutationsinthe
cysticfibrosistransmembraneconductanceregulatorgene.Thers4073variantwasassociated with spirometrymarkersinfour genetic models:co-dominant (FEF25---75% andFEF75%),
domi-nant(FEV1,FEF50%,FEF75%,andFEF25---75%),recessive(FEF75%andFEF25---75%),andover-dominant
(FEV1/FVC).
Conclusions: Thisstudyhighlightedtheimportanceofthers4073variantoftheinterleukin8 gene,regardingresponsetoinhaledbronchodilators,andoftheassessmentofmutationsinthe cysticfibrosistransmembraneconductanceregulatorgene.
©2017SociedadeBrasileiradePediatria.PublishedbyElsevierEditoraLtda.Thisisanopen accessarticleundertheCCBY-NC-NDlicense(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/ 4.0/).
PALAVRAS-CHAVE
CFTR;
Gravidadedadoenc¸a; Interleucina8; Func¸ãopulmonar
Variantesnogenedainterleucina8earespostaabroncodilatadoresinalatórios nafibrosecística
Resumo
Objetivo: Aproteínainterleucina8promoverespostasinflamatórias,oqueincluisuaatuac¸ão nas vias aéreas. A presenc¸a de variantes no gene da interleucina 8causa respostas infla-matóriasalteradasepossivelmenterespostasvariadasaousodebroncodilatadoresinalatórios. Assim,esteestudoanalisouasvariantesdainterleucina8(rs4073,rs2227306,rs2227307)esua associac¸ãoàrespostaabroncodilatadoresinalatóriosempacientescomfibrosecística.
Métodos: Foifeitaanálisedasvariantesgenéticasdainterleucina8porrestrictionfragment lengthpolymorphismdareac¸ãoemcadeiadapolimerase.Aassociac¸ãoentreosmarcadoresda espirometriaearespostaabroncodilatadoresinalatóriosfoifeitapelostestesdeMann-Whitney e Kruskal-Wallis.A análise incluiu todosos pacientes com fibrose císticae posteriormente pacientescomduasmutac¸õesnogenecystic fibrosistransmembraneconductanceregulator
pertencentesàsClassesIaII.
Resultados: Esteestudo incluiu186pacientescomfibrose cística. Nãohouveassociac¸ãoda varianters2227307àrespostaabroncodilatadoresinalatórios.Avarianters2227306foi associ-adaaFEF50%nogrupodominanteenogrupocomduasmutac¸õesidentificadasnogenecystic fibrosistransmembraneconductanceregulator.Avarianters4073foiassociadaamarcadores daespirometriaem quatro modelosgenéticos:codominante(FEF25-75% eFEF75%),dominante
(VEF1,FEF50%,FEF75%eFEF25-75%),recessivo(FEF75%eFEF25-75%)eoverdominante(VEF1/CVF). Conclusões: Esteestudodestaca,principalmente,aimportânciadavarianters4073dogeneda interleucina8,narespostaabroncodilatadoresinalatórios,concomitantementeaogenótipo dasmutac¸õesnogenecysticfibrosistransmembraneconductanceregulator.
©2017SociedadeBrasileiradePediatria.PublicadoporElsevierEditoraLtda.Este ´eumartigo OpenAccesssobumalicenc¸aCCBY-NC-ND(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4. 0/).
Introduction
Theresponsetoinhaledbronchodilators(BD)incystic fibro-sis(CF)(OMIM:n.219700)isquitevariableanddependson the cystic fibrosis transmembrane regulator (CFTR) geno-type,pulmonary symptoms,andmainly, onvariantsinthe modifier genes, such as the beta-2-adrenergic receptor (ADRB2).1Sofar,onlyafewstudieshaveinvestigatedsuch response.
MutationsintheCFTRgenecauseCF,duetodeficiency,
dysfunction,orabsenceoftheCFTRprotein.2CFis
characte-rizedbyacontinuouscycleofchronicairwayinflammation,
which can be exacerbated by interleukin-8 (IL-8), a key
pro-inflammatorymediator.IL-8isresponsibleforinitiating
andincreasingtheinflammatory responsein thepresence
of specific pathogens, causing activation and migration
of neutrophils from peripheral blood to tissues.3 Chronic
airway inflammation isthe final commonpathway oflung
injury.Itisresponsibleforincreasedvascularpermeability,
contributingtointerstitial,alveolar,andairwayedema.
The treatment of CF lung disease includes
anti-inflammatory drugs, inhaled corticosteroids, antibiotics,
mucolytic,hypertonicsaline,andphysiotherapy.Amongthe
possible therapies, thereis little evidence supporting the
role of BD in CF.4,5 However, BD is often prescribed for
a longer period due to wheezing and dyspnea episodes
in CF.6 BDreduces theliberation of mediators,which are
responsibleforrecruitingandactivatinginflammatorycells,
activatingcholinergicneurotransmissionandimproving
vas-cularpermeability.Italsoincreasesmucociliaryclearance,
leadingtoreducedlunginflammation.7TheresponsetoBD
IL-8andinhaledbronchodilatorsincysticfibrosis 641
theADRB2proteintopromotebroncodilatation.8
Spirome-tryistheprimarymethodtoassesslungfunction,severity
andprogressionofthedisease,aswellasresponsetoBD.
Intenseneutrophilinflammationandlowbronchial
hyper-responsiveness are commonly observed characteristics in
CF.9Moreover,theresponseofgeneticvariantstoBDislittle
known.1TheroleofIL-8intheneutrophiliccomponentofCF
lungdiseasecanbepointedout.Genesthatmightbe
associ-atedwiththeseverityofCFandpossiblywiththeresponse
toBDhavebeen reportedin thepresent studyandin the
literature.1,10---12 The IL-8geneshouldbehighlighted, asit
hasadirectinfluenceonlunginflammationandcanbe
effec-tiveintheresponsetoBD.Therefore,thisstudycompared
thers4073,rs2227306,andrs2227307IL-8genevariantswith
theresponsetoBDinCFpatients,usingspirometry.
Methods
Patients
Across-sectional studywasconductedin 186CF patients, selectedintwouniversityreferralcenters(MedicalSchool ofSãoJosédoRioPretoandUniversidadeEstadualde Cam-pinas)forCFtreatment,from2013to2015.Thestudywas approvedbytheResearchEthicsCommitteeofthe Univer-sidadeEstadualdeCampinas,Brazil(underNo.528/2008). Allparticipantswere informedof thestudy andsignedan informedconsentform.Forpatientsunderthe ageof 18, the informed consent form was signed by the parents or guardians.Thestudyfollowedtherecommendationsofthe DeclarationofHelsinki.
The diagnosis of CF was confirmed by the presence of two altered concentrations of sodium and chloride in sweat(chloridelevelhigherthan60mEq/L).Furthermore, no patient underwent initial immunoreactive trypsinogen (IRT)measurement.In agroupof 91patients, therewere twomutationsinthe CFTRgenebelongingtoclassesI,II, and/orIII(associatedwithgreaterdiseaseseverity,dueto theabsenceornon-functionalityoftheCFTRprotein)13;60
patientsdidnotpresentanidentifiedmutationoftheCFTR
gene,orhadtwomutationsbelongingtoclassesIV,V,orVI;
and35 patientshad amutationin theCFTRgene
belong-ingtoclassesI,II,orIII,andanon-identifiedmutation,or
belongingtoclassesIV,V,orVI(Table1).
Clinicalvariables
The following variables were analyzed: clinical scores (Shwachman-Kulczycki, Kanga, and Bhalla); body mass index (BMI) for patients older than 18 years, using the formulaBMI=weight/(height)2,theAnthroprogramversion
3.0.1(WorldHealthOrganization[WHO],2006)wasusedfor childrenunderfiveyearsofageandtheAnthroPlusversion 1.0.2 (World Health Organization [WHO], 2007) was used forpatientsagedbetweenfiveand18years;patient’sage and age at diagnosis; first clinical symptom (one general symptom, pulmonary and digestive symptoms); period until the first colonization with Pseudomonas aeruginosa; microorganisms identified in the routine sputum culture (mucoid and non-mucoid P. aeruginosa, Achromobacter xylosoxidans, Burkolderia cepacia, and Staphylococcus
aureus); transcutaneous arterial hemoglobin oxygen-saturation (SaO2); spirometry; and comorbidities (nasal
polyps, osteoporosis, meconium ileus, diabetes mellitus, andpancreaticinsufficiency).
Spirometrywasperformedin patientsoversevenyears ofage,usingtheCPFS/Dspirometer(MedGraphics---Saint Paul,Minnesota,USA).DatawererecordedinthePFBREEZE softwareversion3.8BforWindows95/98/NT(American Tho-racicSociety),andassessedinpercentagepredictedvalues for:forcedvitalcapacity(FVC),forcedexpiratoryvolumein 1s(FEV1),FEV1/FVCratio,forcedexpiratoryflowat25%of
FVC(FEF25%),forcedexpiratoryflowat50%ofFVC(FEF50%),
forcedexpiratoryflowat75%ofFVC(FEF75%),forced
expira-toryflowbetween25%and75%ofFVC(FEF25---75%),maximum
forcedexpiratoryflow(FEFmax),andexpiratoryreserve
vol-ume(ERV). Spirometrydata wereshown in percentageof the predicted value according to the Polgar and Promad-hat(1971), Pereiraetal.(2007),andDuarteetal.(2007) equations.14---16
In all patients undergoing spirometry, the test was
performed before and 15min after administration of BD
(albuterol--- C13H21NO3[400mg]).PatientsunderBDtherapy
wereinstructedtointerruptthemedicationeighthoursprior
tospirometry,iftheywereundershort-actingBDtreatment;
and48hours,iftheywereunderlong-actingBDtreatment.
Thepost-BDpercentagechangewasusedforthestatistical
analysis.TheBDresponsecriteria,definedasanincreaseof
>12%and200mLofinitialFEV1,wasusedasasecondmodel
toevaluatetheassociationbetweentheIL-8genevariants
andBDresponse.
DNAextractionandgenotyping
GenomicDNAwasextractedfromperipheralbloodsamples using standard phenol-chloroform method and quantified by GE NanoVueTM spectrophotometer (GE Healthcare
Bio-sciences--- Pittsburgh,USA).Inthisstudy,thefinalsample concentrationwassetat50ng/L.
Mutations of the CFTR gene were analyzed by poly-merasechainreaction(PCR;F508del)followedbyenzymatic digestion (G542X, R1162X, R553X, G551D, and N1303K). Other mutations in the CFTR gene were identified by sequencingorwiththeuseoftheSALSAMultiplex Ligation-dependentProbeAmplification(MPLAmethod)KitP091-C1 CFTR-MRC-Holland S4X, 2183A>G, 1717-G>A, I618T with MegaBace1000® (GE Healthcare Biosciences --- Pittsburgh, USA),andABI3500(AppliedBiosystems---ThermoFisher Sci-entific---SãoPaulo,Brazil).17
IL-8 gene variants were analyzed by PCR followed by
restriction enzyme digestion. For the rs4073 variant, the
primers5-CCATCATGATAGCATCTGTA-3and5-CCACAA
TTTGGTGAATTATTAA-3,andtheAseIrestrictionenzyme
wereused;for thers2227306 variant, primers5-CTC TAA
CTCTTTATA TAGGAATT-3 and5-GAT TGATTT TATCAA
CAGGCA-3,aswellastheEcoRIrestrictionenzyme;andfor
thers2227307variant,primers5-TAAAGGTTTGATCAATAT
AGA-3 and5-CTTCCTTCTAATTCCAATATG-3,aswellas
theScrFIrestrictionenzyme.18,19Theproductsofthe
enzy-maticrestrictionweresubmittedtoelectrophoresisona12%
polyacrylamidegel,or4%agarosegel,18,19andstainedwith
Table1 DistributionofcysticfibrosispatientsfortheCFTRgenotypeandclassesofidentifiedmutations.a
Genotype n % Groupofpatients
---/--- 55 29.6
Patientswithoutknownmutationin theCFTRgene,orwithoneortwo classesIV,VorVICFTRmutations
V562I/--- 1 0.5 I507V/--- 1 0.5 D110H/V232H 1 0.5 G576A/R668C 1 0.5 p.Glu528G>A/TG11-5T 1 0.5 F508del/--- 23 12.4
PatientswithoneclassesI,IIorIII
CFTRmutation,andone
non-identifiedmutationorIV,VorVI
CFTRmutation G542X/--- 4 2.2 F508del/3272-26A>G 1 0.5 F508del/P205S 1 0.5 G542X/P205S 1 0.5 G542X/R334W 1 0.5 3120+1G>A/L206W 1 0.5 622-2A>G/711+1G>T 1 0.5 R1162X/- 1 0.5 G542X/I618T 1 0.5 F508del/F508del 49 26.3
PatientswithtwoclassesI,II,and/or IIICFTRmutations (CFTR-Bgroup) F508del/G542X 12 6.5 F508del/N1303K 5 2.7 F508del/R1162X 3 1.6 F508del/R553X 3 1.6 F508del/1584-18672pbA>G 1 0.5 F508del/c.1717-1G>A 2 1 3120+1G>A/R1066C 1 0.5 F508del/2183AA>G 1 0.5 F508del/2184insA 1 0.5
F508del/6Bto16exonduplication 1 0.5
F508del/G85E 1 0.5 F508del/S549R(T>G) 1 0.5 F508del/S4X 1 0.5 G542X/2183AA>G 1 0.5 G542X/R1162X 1 0.5 A561E/A561E 1 0.5 F508del/R1066C 1 0.5 R1070Q;S466X/G542X 1 0.5 F508del/1812-1G>A 2 1 2183AA>G/2183AA>G 1 0.5 3120+1G>A/3120+1G>A 1 0.5
n,samplesize;CFTR,cysticfibrosistransmembraneregulator.
aAllpatientsassessedinthisstudyhavebeenincluded(CFTR-Agroup).
Statisticalanalysis
Statistical analyses were performed using Statistical Package for the Social Sciences version 22.0 (SPSS Inc. --- Chicago, USA). The GPower software version 3.1.9.220
wasused to calculate the sample power, considering the
genotypeoftheanalyzed variantsandadoptingpower for
value above 80%. The following conditions were applied
tocalculate the sample power: analysis of variance test,
in place of Kruskal---Wallis test considering that analysis
of variance is a stronger test (effectsize=0.25, ˛=0.05,
power=0.80,numerator degreeoffreedom=2,numberof
groups=3, ideal n=158); two-tailed Mann---Whitney test
(effect size=0.5, ˛=0.05, power=0.80, allocation ratio
N2/N1=1,idealn=134);chi-squaredtest(effectsize=0.3,
˛=0.05,power=0.80,degreeoffreedom=2,idealn=108).
The Mann---Whitneyand Kruskal---Wallistests wereused
forthecomparisonbetweendifferentgenotypesandgroups
ofIL-8genevariantsandtheresponsetoBD.Incaseof
signif-icantdifferencesbetweenthegroupsfortheKruskal---Wallis
test,furtheridentificationandevaluationofthedifferences
betweengenotypeswereperformedwithMedCalc®software
for Windows, version 16.1 (MedCalc® Software --- Ostend,
Belgium).
Thechi-squared test andFisher’sexacttest wereused
forthecomparisonbetweendifferentgenotypesandgroups
ofIL-8genevariants,aswellastheresponsetoBD,defined
IL-8andinhaledbronchodilatorsincysticfibrosis 643
For the identification of mutations in the CFTR gene,
patients were analyzed based on two contexts:
CFTR-A, all CF patients, regardless of gene mutations (n=186
patients);andCFTR-B,patientswithtwomutations
belong-ing toclasses I,II, and/or III (n=91 patients). As for the
variants,fouranalysismodelswereadopted:(i)co-dominant
(Kruskal---Wallis test); (ii) recessive (Mann---Whitney test);
(iii) dominant (Mann---Whitney test); (iv) over-dominant
(Mann---Whitney test), applied in association with clinical
variables.Forallanalyses,thealphavaluewassetat0.05.
Table2 Descriptiveanalysisofclinicalandlaboratorymarkersofcysticfibrosispatients.
Variables Distributiona
Gender(male) 92/186(49.5%)
Ethnicity(White) 169/180(93.9%)
Age(months) 169;201.41±171.98;143(7to932)
Onsetofsymptoms(months) 159;38.23±114.03;3(0to720)
Diagnosis(months) 171;87.90±158.39;20(0to833)
Onsetofdigestivesymptoms(months) 140;41.2±112.61;3(0to720)
Onsetofpulmonarysymptoms(months) 156;46.33±123.64;6(0to720)
Bodymassindex(Kg/m2) 178;17.28±4.08;16.28(6.5to35.67)
Nasalpolyposis(presence) 28/162(17.3%)
Diabetesmellitus(presence) 32/164(19.5%)
Osteoporosis(presence) 25/162(15.4%)
Pancreaticinsufficiency(presence) 130/162(80.2%)
Meconiumileus(presence) 23/162(14.2%)
1stPseudomonasaeruginosa 121;103.03±171.74;31(0to872)b
MucoidP.aeruginosa(presence) 74/173(42.8%)c
Non-mucoidP.aeruginosa(presence) 99/173(57.2%)c
Achromobacterxylosoxidans(presence) 17/174(9.8%)
Burkolderiacepacia(presence) 25/174(14.4%)
Staphylococcusaureus(presence) 131/174(75.3%)
SaO2 159;94.87±4.28;96(66to99) Bhallascore 113;8.9±5.77;8(0to25) Kangascore 118;18.78±5.82;17.5(10to40) Shwachman-Kulczyckiscore 143;65.97±16.78;65(20to95) FVC 142;72.13±23.86;77(19to126) FEV1 141;60.99±25.75;63(17to116) FEV1/FVC 144;79.08±14.99;81(39to113) FEF25% 119;61.28±31.71;60(7to138) FEF50% 119;46.2±31.25;40(3to126) FEF75% 116;36.32±28.77;27.5(4to142) FEF25---75% 140;47.16±32.51;39(5to150) FEFMax 114;75.54±25.59;73.5(25to137) ERV 112;80.96±52.39;69(3to248)
Responsetoinhaledbronchodilator
FVC 117;1.74±8.19;1(−17to32) FEV1 117;3.51±8.0;3(−12to48) FEV1/FVC 111;2.14±7.43;2(−19to32) FEF25% 99;9.99±24.41;5(−45to110) FEF50% 99;13.08±26.06;9(−41to114) FEF75% 99;20.93±46.47;16(−64to235) FEF25---75% 99;12.28±27.77;9.5(−51to117) FEFMax 116;2.63±14.48;3(−42to69) ERV 100;23.04±101.08;0(−90to670)
SaO2,transcutaneousarterialhemoglobinoxygen-saturation;FVC,forcedvitalcapacity;FEV1,forcedexpiratoryvolumein1sofFVC;
FEF25%,forcedexpiratoryflowat25%ofFVC;FEF50%,forcedexpiratoryflowat50%ofFVC;FEF75%,forcedexpiratoryflowat75%of
FVC;FEF25---75%,averageforcedexpiratoryflowbetween25%and75%ofFVC;FEFmax,maximumforcedexpiratoryflow;ERV,expiratory
reservevolume.Spirometrydataareshowninpercentageofthepredictedvalue.Allevaluatedpatientsaredescribed.
a Thedatawithcategoricaldistributionarepresentedasfollows:nofvariable/ntotal(percentage);datawithnumericdistribution
arepresentedasfollows:samplesize;mean±standarddeviation;median(minimumtomaximum).
b MissingvaluesforfirstP.aeruginosacorrespondtocysticfibrosispatientsthatneverpresentedaP.aeruginosapositiveculture. c OnecysticfibrosispatientshowedapositivecultureforP.aeruginosa,withnegativevaluesforP.aeruginosaantigenspecificIgGand
Table3 Distributionofgenotypes,allelesandhaplotypeofIL-8gene variants(rs4073,rs2227306andrs2227307)incystic fibrosispatients.
Variants Genotype Number(%) Allele Number(af) 2 p-Valuea
rs4073 AA 54(29.2) A 187(0.51) 3.94 <0.05 AT 79(42.7) T 183(0.49) TT 52(28.1) Total 370 Total 185 rs2227306 CC 70(38) C 211(0.57) 8.21 <0.05 CT 71(38.6) T 157(0.43) TT 43(23.4) Total 368 Total 184 rs2227307 GG 31(17.4) G 139(0.39) 1.48 >0.05 TG 77(43.3) T 217(0.61) TT 70(39.3) Total 356 Total 178 rs4073/rs2227306/rs2227307 Frequency Percentage(%) AACCGG 3 1.7 AACCGT 5 2.8 AACCTT 24 13.6 AACTGG 3 1.7 AACTGT 4 2.3 AACTTT 7 4 AATTGG 2 1.1 AATTGT 2 1.1 AATTTT 3 1.7 ATCCGT 13 7.3 ATCCTT 7 4 ATCTGT 30 16.9 ATCTTT 10 5.6 ATTTGG 5 2.8 ATTTGT 6 3.4 ATTTTT 3 1.7 TTCCGG 2 1.1 TTCCGT 5 2.8 TTCCTT 8 4.5 TTCTGG 4 2.3 TTCTGT 6 3.4 TTCTTT 3 1.7 TTTTGG 12 6.8 TTTTGT 5 2.8 TTTTTT 5 2.8 Total 177 100
IL-8,interleukin8;%,percentage;2,chi-square;af,absolutefrequency.
a2andp-valuesrefertothecalculationofHardy---Weinbergequilibrium.Significantdataareshowninboldtype.Therewasweak
correlationamongtheIL-8genevariantsinthecysticfibrosispatientsenrolledinthestudy.Thereisnolinkagedisequilibrium.
ForanalysisoftheHardy---Weinberg equilibrium(HWE), theOnlineEncyclopediasoftwareforGeneticEpidemiology Studies(OEGE)wasused.
The falsediscoveryrate (FDR)test wasappliedto cor-rectthe multiple test comparison.FDR is an approach to the multiple comparisons problem. Instead of controlling thechanceofanyfalse,FDRcontrolstheexpected propor-tionoffalsepositivesamongsuprathresholdvoxels.AFDR thresholdisdeterminedfromtheobservedp-value distribu-tion,andhenceisadaptive totheamount ofsignalinthe
data.21Thep-valueandcorrectedp-value(pc)wereshown
inthemanuscript.The linkagedisequilibriumanalysiswas
performedinHaploviewsoftwareversion4.2.
Results
ClinicalandlaboratorydataofCFpatientsaredescribedin Table2.Table3describesthegenotypeandallelefrequency
IL-8andinhaledbronchodilatorsincysticfibrosis 645
A
D
G
J
K
M
L
H
I
B
E
F
C
8 5 25 20 15 10 5 0 –5 –10 4 3 2 1 0 –1 –2 35 50 40 30 20 10 0 –10 –20 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 –5 –10 AA+AT CC AA+AT AA AT AA+AT AA AA+TT AA+AT TT TT TT AA+AT AA AA+TT TT TT CT AA AT TT CT+TT CC+TT AA+AT AA+AT rs4073 + 2 CFTR mutations rs2227306 + 2 CFTR mutations rs4073 + 2 CFTR mutations rs4073 + 2 CFTR mutations rs4073 + 2 CFTR mutations rs4073 + 2 CFTR mutations rs4073 rs4073 rs4073 rs2227306 + 2 CFTR mutations rs4073 rs4073 + 2 CFTR mutations rs4073 + 2 CFTR mutationsForced expiratory volume on 1st sec. of forced vital capacity
Forced expiratory flow 50%
Forced expiratory flow 75%
Forced expiratory flow -
25-75% of forced vital capacity
Forced expiratory flow -
25-75% of forced vital capacity
Forced expiratory flow -
25-75% of forced vital capacity
Forced expiratory flow -
25-75% of forced vital capacity
Forced expiratory flow 75% Forced expiratory flow 75% Forced expiratory flow 50% Forced expiratory flow 75%
Forced expiratory volume on 1
st sec.
forced vital capacity
Forced expiratory flow 50%
TT AT TT 6 4 2 0 –2 –4 25 20 15 10 5 0 –5 –10 –15 –20 40 35 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 –5 –10 –15 30 20 10 0 –10 –20 50 30 20 15 10 5 0 –5 –10 25 20 15 10 5 0 –5 –10 –15 50 40 30 20 10 0 40 30 20 10 0 –10 –20
Figure1 Associationofrs4073andrs2227306variantsofIL-8(interleukin-8)withtheresponsetoinhaledbronchodilatorsincystic fibrosispatients.(A)Associationbetweenforcedexpiratoryvolumein1s(FEV1)offorcedvitalcapacity(FVC)andrs4073,dominant
modelandtwoidentifiedmutationsintheCFTRgene(cysticfibrosistransmembraneregulator)belongingtoclassesI,II,and/orIII (CFTR-Bgroup)(p=0.028;pc=0.112).(AA+AT)n=39;meanof4.77±8.95;medianof4(rangingfrom−9to48).(TT)n=21;mean
andcorrectedp-valuesforassociationofthethreeIL-8gene variants,consideringthefourmodelsofanalysisproposed andthegenotypeoftheCFTRgene.
Thers2227307variantwasnotassociatedwithresponse to BD in any of the studied models; in turn, rs2227306 wasassociatedwithFEF50% for patients withCC genotype
(dominant model; p=0.05; pc=0.083) and CT genotype
(over-dominantmodel;p=0.033;pc=0.083)intheCFTR-B
group(Fig.1DandE).
Specialemphasisshouldbegiventothers4073variant,
whichwasassociatedwiththefollowingspirometry
varia-bles:FEV1,FEV1/FVCratio,FEF50%FEF75%,andFEF25---75%.The
lowest response toBD wasobserved for the TT genotype
(dominantmodel)andpatientsoftheCFTR-BgrouptoFEV1
(Fig.1A), FEF50% (Fig. 1C), FEF75% (Fig. 1G), and FEF25---75%
(Fig.1K).ThesamewasobservedfortheCFTR-Agroupfor
FEF75%(Fig.1H)andFEF25---75%(Fig.1L).Intheco-dominant
analysis,theTTgenotypepresentedalowerresponsetoBD
forFEF75%(Fig.1F)andFEF25---75%(Fig.1J),respectively,inthe CFTR-AandCFTR-Bgroups.ForthemarkerFEV1/FVC,theAT
genotypeinpatientsfromtheCFTR-Bgroupshowedlower
responsetoBD(Fig.1B).Finally,inpatientsfromthe
CFTR-AandCFTR-BgroupstheAAgenotype(recessivemodel)for
rs4073showedhigherresponsetoBDforFEF75%(Fig.1I)and
FEF25---75%,respectively(Fig.1M).
The haplotypedistributionfor theIL-8genevariantsis
presentedinTable3.
ForthecomparisonbetweenIL-8genevariantsandthe
responsetoBD,definedasanincreaseof>12%and200mL
ofinitialFEV1,nopositiveassociationwasfound(p>0.05).
Discussion
TheinfluenceofdifferentIL-8genevariantsintheclinical severity of CF has been previously demonstrated.22 This
studyshowedtheassociationofdifferentIL-8genevariants
andtheirmodulationtoBDresponse,assessingtheimpact
of the drug on pulmonary function. The variability of
responsestoBDisdeterminedbymultiplefactors,suchas
inflammationandpulmonaryobstruction,23 bacteria,24 and
lungsymptoms,25 aswell asmodifiergenes.26 However,no
studies sofar have investigatedthe roleof IL-8asa
pro-inflammatorymediatorofCFanditsrelationshiptoBD,and
whetherthe IL-8genevariants mayexplaintheindividual
response to BD in CF. It is believed that the short-acting
and long-acting beta-2-agonists may be beneficial for CF
patientswithpositivebronchialhyperresponsiveness.6
Inprogressivelungdiseases,differentmarkershavebeen
assessed;theuseofBDappearstoprovidebetterresponse
toFEF25---75%,whencomparedwithothermarkers,which
indi-catesinvolvementofsmallercaliberairwaysinCF.27Inthe
presentstudy,inagreementwiththereferenceliterature,
an association was observed between the rs4073 variant
andthe FEF25---75% markerin thedominant (forboth
CFTR-A and CFTR-B groups), co-dominant (CFTR-B group), and
recessive models(CFTR-B group).Therewasimprovement
inseveral othermarkers ofspirometryforrs4073,suchas
FEV1,FEV1/FVC,FEF50%,andFEF75%,whichshowsimpacton
breathingpatternsofpatients.
ThestudybyHillianetal.(2008)foundanassociationof
rs2227307andrs4073IL-8genevariantsandseverityof
pul-monarydisease.28 Inthatstudy,patientsweredividedinto
twocohorts:(1)homozygousF508delpatients;(2)patients
with other genotypes of the CFTR gene. In cohort 1, the
rs4073,rs2227306,andrs2227543variantswerenot
associ-atedwithlungdisease,andanassociationwasobservedfor
rs22227307,regardlessofgender.Incohort2,thers4073and
rs2227306variantswereassociatedwithlungdisease
sever-ityinmales.Thus,thegenderofthepatient,genotypeofthe
CFTRgene,andmodifiergenesmaymodulatetheseverityof
thelungdisease.28Inthisstudy,thers2227307genotypedid
nothaveanimpactonthevariabilityoftheresponsetoBD.
Thissuggeststhatalthoughthisgenotypeisassociatedwith
CFTR-Bgroup(p=0.029;pc=0.116).(AA+TT) n=30;mean of1.17±7.36;medianof0(rangingfrom−12to23).(AT)n=29;meanof 4.76±7.58;medianof4(rangingfrom−9to32).(C)Associationofforcedexpiratoryflowof50%(FEF50%)ofFVCwithrs4073,dominant model,andCFTR-Bgroup(p=0.046;pc=0.184).(AA+AT)n=37;meanof17.38±24.18;medianof16(rangingfrom−20to89).(TT)n=21; meanof4.95±20.8;medianof−2(rangingfrom−19to55).(D)AssociationofFEF50%withrs2227306,dominantmodel,andCFTR-Bgroup (p=0.05;pc=0.083).(CC)n=15;meanof1.47±17.22;medianof0(rangingfrom−20to29).(CT+TT)n=44;meanof15.84±25.04; medianof10.5(rangingfrom−28to89).(E)AssociationofFEF50%withrs2227306,over-dominantmodel,andCFTR-Bgroup(p=0.033; pc=0.083).(CC+TT)n=33;meanof6.06±20.27;medianof4(rangingfrom−20to55).(CT)n=23;meanof19.96±26.43;medianof 19(rangingfrom−28to89).(F)Associationofforcedexpiratoryflowof75%(FEF75%)ofFVCwithrs4073,co-dominantmodelregardless ofidentifiedmutationsintheCFTRgene(CFTR-Agroup)(p=0.044;pc=0.058).1 /= 3.(AA)n=28;meanof29.93±39.98;medianof30 (rangingfrom−47to142).(AT)n=42;meanof24.81±53.57;medianof14(rangingfrom−58to235).(TT)n=28;meanof9.14±36.95; medianof2.5(rangingfrom−35to119).(G)AssociationofFEF75%withrs4073,dominantmodel,andCFTR-Bgroup(p=0.024;pc=0.096). (AA+AT)n=38;meanof33±55.23;medianof16(rangingfrom−27to235).(TT)n=21;meanof5.43±35.93;medianof2(rangingfrom −35to119).(H)AssociationofFEF75%withrs4073,dominantmodel,andCFTR-Agroup(p=0.034;pc=0.058).(AA+AT)n=70;meanof 26.86±48.34;medianof18(rangingfrom−58to235).(TT)n=28;meanof9.14±36.95;medianof2.5(rangingfrom−35to119).(I) AssociationofFEF75%withrs4073,recessivemodel, andCFTR-Agroup(p=0.04;pc=0.058).(AA)n=28;meanof29.93±39.98;median of30(rangingfrom−47to142).(AT+TT)n=70;meanof18.54±47.95;medianof10(rangingfrom−58to235).(J)AssociationofFEF between25%and75%(FEF25---75%)ofFVCwithrs4073,co-dominantmodelandCFTR-Bgroup(p=0.012;pc=0.024).TT /= AAandAT.(AA) n=9;meanof25.78±23.14;medianof30(rangingfrom−21to57).(AT)n=29;meanof18.38±29.04;medianof14(rangingfrom−33to 117).(TT)n=21;meanof2.14±23.74;medianof0(rangingfrom−51to65).(K)AssociationofFEF25---75%withrs4073,dominantmodel,and CFTR-Bgroup(p=0.007;pc=0.024).(AA+ATT)n=38;meanof20.13±27.64;medianof18.5(rangingfrom−33to117).(TT)n=23;meanof 2.14±23.74;medianof0(rangingfrom−51to65).(L)AssociationofFEF25---75%withrs4073,dominantmodel,andCFTR-Agroup(p=0.029; pc=0.1).(AA+AT)n=82;meanof15.48±27.2;medianof15(rangingfrom−40to117).(TT)n=33;meanof5.94±27.33;medianof0 (rangingfrom−51to76).(M)AssociationofFEF25---75%withrs4073,recessivemodel,andCFTR-Bgroup(p=0.047;pc=0.063).(AA)n=9; meanof25.78±23.14;medianof30(rangingfrom−21to57).(AT+TT)n=50;meanof11.56±27.89;medianof8(rangingfrom−51to 117).Thedotcorrespondstomedianvaluesandthebarcorrespondstothe95%confidenceinterval.
IL-8andinhaledbronchodilatorsincysticfibrosis 647
lung diseaseinhomozygousF508del patients,itsresponse
toBDisnotrelevant.
ThetargetofBDistheADRB2protein,whichisexpressed
intheairwaysmoothmuscle.VariantsofADRB2are
associ-atedwithresponsetothemedication.Althoughthisprotein
hasbeenwidelystudiedinasthma,itwasveryseldom
stud-ied in CF. The effectiveness of the response to BD and
inhaled corticosteroids tomanageairway inflammation in
asthmahasbeen confirmed,anddependsontheArg16Gly
(rs1042713; c.46A>G) and Glu27Gln (rs1042714; c.79C>G)
ADRB2genevariants.29TheGln27Gluvariantconfers
resis-tancetotheADRB2proteininBD response.The46*G and
79*Gallelesareprotectiveagainstasthma,reducingtherisk
by27%.29BothvariantsoftheGalleleinducechangesinthe
regulation of the receptor due toincreased susceptibility
toproteindegradation.ThisstudyfoundthattheArg16Gly
andGln27Glu ADRB2genevariants influencethe response
toBDinCF.Inspirometryandinothermarkersofseverity,
theArg16Glyvariantshowedapositive association,unlike
Gln27Glu. The Arg/Arggenotype for the Arg16Glyvariant
was associated with better values of FEV1 and FEF25---75%.
The responsetoBDin theanalyses ofhaplotype was
pos-itiveintheabsenceofGly16GlyandGlu27Glugenotypesfor
FEV1/FVCratio.
VariantsofADRB2,diffusingcapacityofthelungsfor
car-bon monoxide,alveolar capillary membraneconductance,
volume of blood in the alveolar capillary, and SaO2 were
evaluatedintheresponsetoBDin18patientsand20healthy
controls,beforeandaftertheadministrationofsalbutamol
(30,60,and90min).Healthysubjectsshowednochangesin
markersassessedfortheGlu27Gluvariant.However,inCF,
thisvariantinfluencedtheresponsetoBD:thebestresponse
wasfoundinthepresenceofatleastoneallele27Glu.There
wasadifferenceinpulmonarydiffusionandperipheralSaO2
accordingtothevariationoftheADRB2geneatposition27,
andthedosageofthedrugshouldbeprescribedaccording
tothisvariation.30
Most studies focus on the ADRB2 gene variants in the
response to BD. However, this study demonstrated that,
evenindirectly,theIL-8genevariants(andpossiblyinother
genes,whichmodulatetheinflammatorylungresponse)may
potentiateorminimizetheeffectofBDandalsoinfluence
theresponsetothemedication.
Regarding the HWE, as previously discussed by this
group,22 twovariants (rs4073 and rs2227306) were notin
balance.ItisimportanttorememberthattheHWEassumes
anidealpopulation,withouttheinterferenceof
evolution-aryfactors.However,ingenesasthoseinvolvedinimmunity,
inflammation, and infection control, the HWE imbalance
mayappearsecondarilyassociatedwiththeselection
mech-anismsthatfavoredaparticularallelethatcanbringamore
effectiveresponse.The disequilibriumdoes notinvalidate
theassociationstudysincethegroupsarepartofthesame
population.
The limitations of the present study include (i)
cross-sectional dataset (BD response wasevaluated at a single
time); (ii) numerous missing data considering the
prob-lemstoachieveinformationintherecords;(iii)whetherBD
responsediffers based onbaseline FEV1, mainlyin health
subjects;(iv)potentialconfounderstotheresults,suchas
diseaseseverity,currenttherapies,medicationadherence,
andadequatepulmonaryfunctiontesteffort.
Inconclusion,IL-8genevariants(rs2227306andspecially
rs4073)can beassociatedwith theresponse toBDduring
spirometry.Thisdrugmaybean alternativefor the
treat-mentofthedisease,mostlyamongpatientswithairwaysof
smallercaliber.Studies involvingdosageandcombinations
ofdrugs shouldbe furtherconducted,in orderdetermine
thebesttreatmentaccording toCF patientgenotype,the
CFTRgene,aswellasmodifiergenes.
Funding
FALM: Fundac¸ão de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado de São Paulo(FAPESP)forsupportingtheresearches #2011/12939-4, #2011/18845-1, #2015/12183-8, and #2015/12858-5; FundodeApoioàPesquisa,aoEnsinoeàExtensãoda Uni-versidadeEstadualdeCampinasforsupportingtheresearch #0648/2015; JDR: FAPESP for supporting the research #2011/18845-1and#2015/12183-8.LLF:FAPESPfor suppor-tingtheresearch#2013/19052-0.
Conflicts
of
interest
Theauthorsdeclarenoconflictsofinterest.
Acknowledgements
ToLucianaMontesRezende, LucianaCardosoBonadia,and StephanieVilla-NovafortheirtechnicalsupportduringDNA extraction and identification of mutations of the CFTR gene. To Marcela Augusta de Souza Pinhel, Michele Lima Gregório,RafaelFernandesFerreira,GracieleDomitila Ten-ani,andHeloisaCristinaCaldasfortheirtechnicalsupport duringstandardizationofIL-8genotyping.ToMariaÂngela Gonc¸alves de Oliveira Ribeiro for conducting pulmonary functiontests(LAFIP/Ciped/Unicamp).ToRafaellaMaionchi PereiraMartinsforhertechnicalsupporttodetermine clini-calscores.ToMariadeFátimaCorrêaPimentaServidonifor promotingalinkbetweenbothUniversities.
References
1.MarsonFAL,BertuzzoCS,RibeiroAF,RibeiroJD.Polymorphisms
inADRB2genecanmodulatetheresponsetobronchodilators
andtheseverityofcysticfibrosis.BMCPulmMed.2012;12:50---9.
2.VankeerberghenA,CuppensH,CassimanJJ.Thecystic
fibro-sistransmembraneconductanceregulator:anintriguingprotein
withpleiotropicfunctions.JCystFibros.2002;1:13---29.
3.HaradaA,SekidoN,AkahoshiT,WadaT,MukaidaN,Matsushima
K.Essentialinvolvementofinterleukin-8(IL-8)inacute
inflam-mation.JLeukocBiol.1994;56:559---64.
4.Halfhide C,Evans HJ,Couriel J. Inhaled bronchodilators for
cysticfibrosis.CochraneDatabaseSystRev.2005;19:CD003428.
5.GangellCL,HallGL,StickSM,SlyPD,ArestCF.Lungfunction
testing inpreschool-aged children withcysticfibrosis inthe
clinicalsetting.PediatrPulmonol.2010;45:419---33.
6.Halfhide C,Evans HJ,Couriel J. WITHDRAWN:inhaled
bron-chodilators for cystic fibrosis. Cochrane Database Syst Rev.
2016;2:CD003428.
7.BarnesPJ.Biochemicalbasisofasthmatherapy.JBiolChem.
2011;286:32899---905.
8.MauryaN,AwasthiS,DixitP.AssociationofCFTRgenemutation
9.RegameyN,TsartsaliL, HilliardTN,FuchsO, TanHL,ZhuJ,
et al.Distinct patternsofinflammationintheairway lumen
andbronchialmucosaofchildrenwithcysticfibrosis.Thorax.
2012;67:164---70.
10.LimaCS,OrtegaMM,MarsonFAL,ZulliR,RibeiroAF,Bertuzzo
CS.CFTRmutationsandGSTM1andGSTT1deletionsinBrazilian
cysticfibrosispatients.JBrasPneumol.2012;38:50---6.
11.MarsonFA,BertuzzoCS,HortencioTD,RibeiroJD,BonadiaLC,
RibeiroAF.TheACEgeneD/Ipolymorphismasamodulatorof
severityofcysticfibrosis.BMCPulmMed.2012;12:41.
12.MarsonFA,BertuzzoCS,RibeiroAF,RibeiroJD.Polymorphisms
intheglutathionepathwaymodulatecysticfibrosisseverity:a
cross-sectionalstudy.BMCMedGenet.2014;15:27.
13.Marson FA, Bertuzzo CS, Ribeiro JD. Personalized drug
ther-apyincysticfibrosis:fromfictiontoreality.CurrDrugTargets.
2015;16:1007---17.
14.PolgarG,PromadhatV.Pulmonaryfunctiontestinginchildren:
techniquesandstandards.Philadelphia(PA):WBSaunders
Com-pany;1971.
15.Pereira CA, Sato T, Rodrigues SC. New reference values for
forcedspirometryin whiteadultsin Brazil.JBrasPneumol.
2007;33:397---406.
16.DuarteAA,PereiraCA,RodriguesSC.ValidationofnewBrazilian
predictedvaluesforforcedspirometryinCaucasiansand
com-parisonwithpredictedvaluesobtainedusingotherreference
equations.JBrasPneumol.2007;33:527---35.
17.Bonadia LC, Marson FA, Ribeiro JD, Paschoal IA, Pereira
MC, Ribeiro AF,et al. CFTR genotype and clinicaloutcomes
of adult patients carried as cystic fibrosis disease. Gene.
2014;540:183---90.
18.HeinzmannA,AhlertI,KurzT,BernerR,DeichmannKA.
Associ-ationstudysuggestsoppositeeffectsofpolymorphismswithin
IL-8onbronchialasthmaandrespiratorysyncytialvirus
bron-chiolitis.JAllergyClinImmunol.2004;114:671---6.
19.Scarel-CaminagaRM,KimYJ, VianaAC,CurtisKM,Corbi SC,
SogumoPM,etal.Haplotypesintheinterleukin8geneandtheir
association withchronicperiodontitis susceptibility. Biochem
Genet.2011;49:292---302.
20.FaulF,Erdfelde E,LangAG,Buchner A.GPower3:aflexible
statistical power analysis program for the social,
behav-ioral,andbiomedicalsciences.Behav ResMethods.2007;39:
175---91.
21.BenjaminiY.Discoveringthefalsediscoveryrate.JRStatSoc
SerB(StatMethod).2010;72:405---16.
22.FurlanLL,MarsonFA,RibeiroJD,BertuzzoCS,SalomãoJunior
JB,SouzaDR.IL8geneasmodifierofcysticfibrosis:
unravel-ingthefactorswhichinfluenceclinicalvariability.HumGenet.
2016;135:881---94.
23.ParkHY,LeeH, KohW, KimS,Jeong I,KooHK,et al.
Asso-ciationof blood eosinophils and plasmaperiostin with FEV1
responseafter3-monthinhaledcorticosteroidandlong-acting
beta2-agonisttreatmentinstableCOPDpatients.IntJChronic
ObstructPulmDis.2016;11:23---30.
24.ShawJG,VaughanA,DentAG,O’HarePE,GohF,BowmanRV,
et al. Biomarkers of progression of chronic obstructive
pul-monarydisease(COPD).JThoracDis.2014;6:1532---47.
25.DunnRM,LehmanE,ChinchilliVM,MartinRJ,BousheyHA,Israel
E,etal.Impactofageandsexonresponsetoasthmatherapy.
AmJRespirCritCareMed.2015;192:551---8.
26.DuanQL,Lasky-SuJ,HimesBE,Qiu W,Litonjua AA,Damask
A, etal. A genome-wideassociationstudy ofbronchodilator
responseinasthmatics.PharmacogenomicsJ.2014;14:41---7.
27.Muramatu LH, Stirbulov R, Forte WC. Pulmonary function
parametersanduseofbronchodilatorsinpatientswithcystic
fibrosis.JBrasPneumol.2013;39:48---55.
28.HillianAD,LondonoD,DunnJM,GoddardKA,PaceRG,Knowles
MR,etal.Modulationofcysticfibrosislungdiseasebyvariants
ininterleukin-8.GenesImmun.2008;9:501---8.
29.ThakkinstianA,McEvoyM,MinelliC,GibsonP,HancoxB,Duffy
D,etal.Systematicreviewandmeta-analysisoftheassociation
between2-adrenoceptorpolymorphismsandasthma:aHuGE
review.JEpidemiol.2005;162:201---11.
30.TraylorBR,WheatleyCM,SkrentnyTTJr,Foxx-LupoWT,Phan
H,PatanwalaAE,etal. Influenceofgeneticvariationofthe
2-adrenergicreceptoronlungdiffusioninpatientswithcystic