Estudo genético-clínico de pacientes com o espectro da neuropatia auditiva = Genetic-clinical evaluation of patients with auditory neuropathy spectrum

Texto

(1).'"/+,",-.%&)"', .%"h'",&R",. ."%!+&&!(+/%!(. $%& <% !%$ $!%# &# !%&%'. %'&% !%%$(%&% #* &# !%*$!%#&. &)"',

(2) .

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c/+,d("'%-,'")%( %.'( ."%!+& &!( +/%!( (+"'-( )% )+( + "%j",+-(+-(. &)"',.

(4) .

(5) $JrQFLD V

(6) GHIRPHQWRHQ V

(7) GHSURFHVVR V

(8) &$3(63 25&,' KWWSRUFLGRUJ. )LFKDFDWDORJUiILFD 8QLYHUVLGDGH(VWDGXDOGH&DPSLQDV %LEOLRWHFDGD)DFXOGDGHGH&LrQFLDV0pGLFDV 5RVDQD(YDQJHOLVWD3RGHURVR&5%. &H. &DUYDOKR*XLOKHUPH0DFKDGRGH &DU(VWXGRJHQpWLFRFOtQLFRGHSDFLHQWHVFRPRHVSHFWURGDQHXURSDWLDDXGLWLYD *XLOKHUPH0DFKDGRGH&DUYDOKR±&DPSLQDV63>VQ@ &DU2ULHQWDGRU(GL/~FLD6DUWRUDWR &DU7HVH GRXWRUDGR

(9) ±8QLYHUVLGDGH(VWDGXDOGH&DPSLQDV)DFXOGDGHGH &LrQFLDV0pGLFDV &DU7UDQVWRUQRVGDSHUFHSomRDXGLWLYD3HUGDDXGLWLYD,PSODQWHV FRFOHDUHV1HXURSDWLDKHUHGLWiULDPRWRUDHVHQVRULDO6XUGH],6DUWRUDWR (GL/~FLD,,8QLYHUVLGDGH(VWDGXDOGH&DPSLQDV)DFXOGDGHGH &LrQFLDV0pGLFDV,,,7tWXOR. ,QIRUPDo}HVSDUD%LEOLRWHFD'LJLWDO 7tWXORHPRXWURLGLRPD*HQHWLFFOLQLFDOHYDOXDWLRQRISDWLHQWVZLWKDXGLWRU\QHXURSDWK\ VSHFWUXP 3DODYUDVFKDYHHPLQJOrV $XGLWRU\SHUFHSWXDOGLVRUGHUV +HDULQJORVV &RFKOHDULPSODQWV +HUHGLWDU\VHQVRU\DQGPRWRUQHXURSDWK\ 'HDIQHVV ÈUHDGHFRQFHQWUDomR2WRUULQRODULQJRORJLD 7LWXODomR'RXWRUHP&LrQFLDV0pGLFDV %DQFDH[DPLQDGRUD (GL/~FLD6DUWRUDWR>2ULHQWDGRU@ $JUtFLR1XELDWR&UHVSR &DUORV5REHUWR6LOYHLUD&RUUHD 0LJXHO$QJHOR+\SSROLWR -RVp(GXDUGR/XWDLI'ROFL 'DWDGHGHIHVD 3URJUDPDGH3yV*UDGXDomR&LrQFLDV0pGLFDV.

(10) ) #$ &% # . ()) . # $. ,) )) . -) ))

(11) . .) )) . /) )) . 0) )) . & %

(12)

(13) ! & . % (,/*+1*-+,1.

(14) %D# c D@E?8 =8D[C@8 <D <JG<:@8C 8F D<L G8@ #FVF C98EF 8IM8C?F < D@E?8DV<&8IK8&8:?8;F;<8IM8C?FG<CF@E:<EK@MF8F<JKL;F<O<DGCF;< ;<;@:8WVF < 8GF@F HL< D< ;<I8D <D KF;8 D@E?8 M@;8 G<JJF8C < 8:8;ZD@:8 C<J HL< GFI DL@K8J M<Q<J =@Q<I8D D<LJ JFE?FJ J<I<D 8 GI@FI@;8;< ;<C<J ;<;@:FKF;FD<L8DFI:8I@E?FI<JG<@KF<<K<IE@;8;< cD@E?8<JGFJ8-8DDP & -8B8I8HL<<JKSJ<DGI<8FD<LC8;F <J<;<;@:88FJEFJJFJGIFA<KFJ:FD8DFI<:8I@E?F <;@:F 8@E;8 T KF;8 D@E?8 =8D[C@8 <O<DGCF ;< :FDG8E?<@I@JDF 8D@Q8;<8DFI<=<Q;<D@DHL<DJFL?FA< <;@:F<JK8K<J<8<LJ<8=XHL<EFJ=8Q<DD8@J=FIK<J . " !# #%% %. " $ .

(15) !# $""#%%#. " ! !# !$& "%& ".

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

(17) FI IK?LI&<E@EF8JK@C?F<8FI 08CK<I;I@8EF@8E:?@E@HL< G8:@<EK<D<EK< D< 8AL;8I8D <D D@E?8 =FID8WVF FKFC\>@:8 8 ;<J<EMFCM@8J<GFIKF;FJ<EJ@E8D<EKFJ KF;FJ GIF=<JJFI<J DX;@:FJ 8JJ@JK<EK<J ;8 @J:@GC@E8 ;< (KFII@EFC8I@E>FCF>@8 ;8 .E@:8DG HL< @E:<EK@M8D F D<L ;<J<EMFCM@D<EKF :@<EK[=@:F < 8GI<E;@Q8><D ;<EKIF ;8 (KFII@EFC8I@E>FCF>@8 <D <JG<:@8C F )IF= I +<@E8C;F #FI;VF. LJDVF F )IF= I #FI>< +@QQ8KF )8J:?F8C F I . %<FGFC;F'@Q8D)=<@CJK@:B<I<8)IF=8 I8 LCSC@8,8B8EF KF;8 <HL@G< ;F @DGC8EK< :F:C<8I J8_;< 8L;@K@M8 ;8 .E@:8DG < ;F !FJG@K8C +<>@FE8C ;< @M@EFCUE;@8 ('+ HL< D< 8LO@C@8I8D E8 @;<EK@=@:8WVF;FJG8:@<EK<J<:FC<K8;FJ<O8D<J><EXK@:FJ<=FIE<:@D<EKF;FJ ;8;FJ:C[E@:FJ KF;FJ FJ =LE:@FESI@FJ ;F J<IM@WF ;< (KFII@EFC8I@E>FCF>@8 ;8 .E@:8DG8D9LC8K\I@F:<EKIF:@I_I>@:FJ<:I<KSI@8J<IM@WFJF:@8C<D<JG<:@8C 8 E=8 ,FE@8 &8I@8 8M@E8KKF < 8 <E@J< ! ;8 ,@CM8 ,<IM@WF ,F:@8C ! .'"&) FJ :FC<>8J ;< I<J@;ZE:@8 DX;@:8 < 8D@>FJ HL< 8LO@C@8D EF ;<J<EMFCM@D<EKF ;< KI898C?FJ :@<EK[=@:FJ < KFIE8D GFJJ[M<C 8 I<8C@Q8WVF ;< DL@KFJKI898C?FJ:@<EK[=@:FJ KF;FJ=LE:@FESI@FJ<GIF=<JJFI<J;8)\J I8;L8WVF;88:LC;8;< ;<@ZE:@8J&X;@:8J;8.E@:8DGHL<J<DGI<D<8AL;8I8D<8GF@8I8DE<JJ< GIFA<KF .

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eI8J@C)IF:<JJFE`

(19) )

(20) -8@J@EJK@KL@W^<JK<D >I8E;<I<C<MUE:@8G8I8F;<J<EMFCM@D<EKF;<:FE?<:@D<EKFE8:@FE8C<;<M<D J<I@E:<EK@M8;8J<M8CFI@Q8;8J FJ G8:@<EK<J < =8D@C@8I<J HL< :FEKI@9L[I8D < :FC89FI8D E8 <O<:LWVF<:<;<I8D<JJ<J;8;FJ:@<EK[=@:FJ 8FLKIFJEVFD<EFJ@DGFIK8EK<JD8JHL<EVF=FI8D:@K8;FJ -$,(*$"(.

(21) #$& JLI;<Q X 8 ;F<EW8 J<EJFI@8C D8@J GI<M8C<EK< <D ?LD8EFJ K<E;F <K@FCF>@8 ><EXK@:8<8D9@<EK8C G<I;88L;@K@M8EVFJ@E;I]D@:8)',I<GI<J<EK88KX ;FJ :8JFJ ?<I<;@KSI@FJ J<E;F 8J =FID8J 8LKFJJ]D@:8J I<:<JJ@M8J + 8J D8@J =I<HL<EK<J ?<K<IF><E<@;8;<;8)',+X<OKI<D8D<EK<<C<M8;8<

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

(23) ><E<! 8LKFJJ]D@:F;FD@E8EK<<.'1

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

(26) $%#% <8=E<JJ @J K?< DFJK GI<M8C<EK J<EJFIP ;@J<8J< @E ?LD8EJ N@K? ><E<K@: 8E; <EM@IFED<EK8C :8LJ<J 'FEJPE;IFD@: ?<8I@E> CFJJ )', I<8:?<J =FI FM DFI< =I<HL<EK 8J I<:<JJ@M< 8LKFJFD8C + =FIDJ -?< ?<K<IF><E<@KP F= )', + @J <OKI<D<CP ?@>? 8E;

(27) CF:@ 8E; ><E<J?8M<9<<E@;<EK@=@<; L;@KFIP'<LIFG8K?P'@J8KPG<F=J<EJFI@E<LI8C ?<8I@E>CFJJK?8K:FEJ@JKJF=8:?8E><@EK?<:FE;L:K@FEF=K?<8L;@KFIPJK@DLCLJ ;L<KF@EMFCM<D<EKF=K?<@EE<I?8@I:<CCJ8L;@KFIPE<IM<FIJPE8GJ<J9<KN<<E K?<D "K @J :?8I8:K<I@Q<; 9P 89J<E:< FI 8CK<I8K@FE F= K?< N8M<J F= 9I8@EJK<D 8L;@KFIP <MFB<; GFK<EK@8CJ N@K? GFJ@K@M< FKF8:FLJK@: <D@JJ@FEJ 8E; FI @;<EK@=@:8K@FEF=:F:?C<8ID@:IFG?FE< KK?<DFD<EKCF:@I<JGFEJ@9C<=FIEFE JPE;IFD@:'N<I<D8GG<;' % ><E<8E;'!'><E< 8JJF:@8K<;N@K?K?<+=FID.'

(28) ! ><E<8LKFJFD8C;FD@E8EKE; .'1

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

(31) $%#'%&#$$$ $@G8I<C?F8L;@K@MF;<DGC@=@:8WVF,FEFI8"E;@M@;L8C )I\K<J<J8L;@K@M8J #eLKFJJ]D@:F+<:<JJ@MF #!%e)FK<E:@8CMF:8;FL;@K@MF;<-IFE:FE:<=SC@:F e"DGC8EK<F:C<8I e!FJG@K8C;8JC[E@:8J @&@:IF=FE@JDFF:C<8I % $+=;3A<<3<=/.+</;/<8;9=387873C+=387%36/ 05312= +<<$9/-=;86/=;B e'<LIFG8K@88L;@K@M8 e(KF<D@JJ^<J:_JK@:8J $(I>8E@Q8WVF&LE;@8C;8,8_;< % (KF=<IC@E8. . !$e)<I;8L;@K@M8'VF,@E;I]D@:8 &!.E@M<IJ@;8;<JK8;L8C;<8DG@E8J.

(32) & "$. . . .

(33) "!"%!! $!"!% "!%. . ' ! !$ !! $! "!% "!%!"

(34) "!! ' "!% "!% #"! ! . ' ! !!! $! "!% "!%!" ' ! ! $! "!% "!%

(35) !

(36) ' "!% "!% !" "! $. . $.

(37) . %.

(38) . !. . . . . .

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

(40) < 8:FI;F :FD F @E[:@F ;8 G<I;8 8L;@K@M8 <JK8 GF;< JZE@K8 8;HL@I@;8 FL K8I;@8 ,< <JK@ML8><D 8 G<I;8 8L;@K@M8 GF;< JL8C <.

(41) . . HL8E;F J< D8E@=<JK8 8G\J 8 8HL@J@WVF ;8 C@E>L8><D G\JC@E>L8C "KF /= +5

(42) JLI;<QGF;<8@E;8J<I;<=@E@;8;<8:FI;F:FDFJ<L>I8L:FDFC<M< ;< 8 ; DF;<I8;8 ;<

(43) 8 ; J<M<I8 ;<

(44) 8 ; FL GIF=LE;8 8:@D8 ;< ; 8M@J ,@CM<ID8EE

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

(46) . . EKI<K8EKF EF I8J@C FJ =8KFI<J 8D9@<EK8@J JLG<I8D FJ ;< FI@><D ><EXK@:8)LGF<K8C 8C?SL/=+5

(47)

(48) :I<;@K8DFJHL<@DGC8EK8;8J D<C?FI@8JEFJ<KFI;<J8_;<<:FDF8M8EWF<8GIF=LE;8D<EKFEFJ<JKL;FJ ><EXK@:FJ I<C8:@FE8;FJ TJ G<I;8J 8L;@K@M8J 8 GIFGFIWVF ;< :8LJ8J ><EXK@:8J K<E;<88LD<EK8I 8;FJ<JK8K[JK@:FJ@EK<IE8:@FE8@JDFJKI8DHL<

(49) <D:8;8

(50) I<:XD E8J:@;FJ 8GI<J<EK8 G<I;8 8L;@K@M8 -<B@E /= +5

(51) ,:?I@AMC@8

(53) 'F <EK8EKF <JJ8 =I<HLZE:@8 M8I@8 ;<G<E;<E;F ;8 8DFJKI8 < I<>@VF <JKL;8;8 GF;<E;F 8 JLI;<Q <JK8I GI<J<EK< <D 8 G8I8 :8;8

(54) I<:XDE8J:@;FJ,@D^<J&8:@<C L<II8

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

(58) 0@C:FO<O

(59) (>I8E;<E_D<IF;<. .

(60) . . ><E<J <OGI<JJFJ E8 :\:C<8 I<=C<K< 8 :FDGC<O@;8;< ;FJ D<:8E@JDFJ DFC<:LC8I<J<EMFCM@;FJE<JK<\I>VF;<@EKI@E:8;8E8KLI<Q8!<CC<I/=+5

(61) (J ;@=<I<EK<J 58-3 FL I<>@^<J :8E;@;8K8J 8 8GI<J<EK8I<D ><E<J 8JJF:@8;FJ T JLI;<Q EVFJ@E;I]D@:8 I<:<9<D F GI<=@OF ' ;F @E>CZJ ./+07/<< J<>L@;F ;< LD E_D<IF HL< @E;@:8 8 FI;<D <D HL< =FI8D ;<J:F9<IKFJ J DLK8W^<J ><EXK@:8J :FE?<:@;8J HL< C<M8D T JLI;<Q GF;<D J8;88F1'1FLD@KF:FE;I@8CIFIMI8?8D JLI;<Q EVFJ@E;I]D@:8X8D8@J:FDLD<F:FII<<D8KX ;<?<I<;@KSI@FJ!@C><IK /=+5 9 D. I<C8WVF. 8FJ. D<:8E@JDFJ. ;<. ?<I8EW8. <JK@D8J<. HL<. 8GIFO@D8;8D<EK< 8 ;FJ :8JFJ ;< JLI;<Q ><EXK@:8 EVFJ@E;I]D@:8 J<A8D;<?<I8EW88LKFJJ]D@:8I<:<JJ@M8 8 8LKFJJ]D@:8;FD@E8EK<< :<I:8;<

(62) 8 C@>8;88F:IFDFJJFDF1 CXD;@JJF8=I<HLZE:@8;8?<I8EW8 D@KF:FE;I@8C X <JK@D8;8 <D

(63) $FBFK8J /= +5 !@C><IK /= +5 9 ,D@K?/=+5

(64) ?<K<IF><E<@;8;< ;8 ;<=@:@ZE:@8 8L;@K@M8 EVFJ@E;I]D@:8 8LKFJJ]D@:8 I<:<JJ@M8 X <OKI<D8D<EK< <C<M8;8 G8I8 8 HL8C

(65) 58-3 =FI8D ;<J:I@KFJ < ><E<J =FI8D @;<EK@=@:8;FJ 8KX F DFD<EKF /8E 8DG ,D@K? !<I<;@K8IP !<8I@E>%FJJ!FD<G8>< @JGFE[M<C<D?KKG. ?<I<;@K8IP?<8I@E>CFJJ FI> (;@8>E\JK@:FDFC<:LC8IX:FDGC@:8;F;<M@;F8>I8E;<?<K<IF><E<@;8;< ><EXK@:8 &LK8W^<JEFJ><E<J < HL<:F;@=@:8D8J:FE<O@E8J < I<JG<:K@M8D<EK< EF 58->< '

(66) JVF I<JGFEJSM<@J GFI D8@J ;< ;< KF;FJ FJ :8JFJ ;< G<I;8 8L;@K@M8 8LKFJJ]D@:8 I<:<JJ@M8 <C 8JK@C?F /= +5 .

(67) . . !@C><IK/=+5 8 'F<EK8EKF8:FEKI@9L@WVF;<DLK8W^<J<DFLKIFJ ><E<J 8@E;8 <JKS J<E;F @EM<JK@>8;8 < F <JKL;F X :FDGC@:8;F G<CF =8KF ;8 <G@;<D@FCF>@8 ><EXK@:8 ;8 G<I;8 8L;@K@M8 EVFJ@E;I]D@:8 J<I 8DGC8D<EK< M8I@SM<C <EKI< 8J GFGLC8W^<J )<K@K /= +5

(68) I@<;D8E . I@==@K? . )<K<IJ<E0@CC<DJ -*(),$-$,$. E<LIFG8K@8 8L;@K@M8 ' X LD K@GF ;< G<I;8 8L;@K@M8 EVFJ@E;I]D@:8 HL< :FEJ@JK< E8 GFJJ[M<C 8CK<I8WVF ;8 :FE;LWVF ;F <JK[DLCF 8L;@K@MF GFI 8:FD<K@D<EKF;8J:XCLC8J:@C@8;8J@EK<IE8J;FE<IMF8L;@K@MFFL;8JJ@E8GJ<J <EKI<<C<J R:8I8:K<I@Q8;8G<C88LJZE:@8FL8CK<I8WVF;8JFE;8JEF<O8D<;< GFK<E:@8@J <MF:8;FJ 8L;@K@MFJ ;< KIFE:F <E:<=SC@:F :FD 8 GI<J<EW8 ;< <D@JJ^<J FKF8:_JK@:8J ( < FL D@:IF=FE@JDF :F:C<8I& ,K8II /= +5

(69) C8 X I<JGFEJSM<C GFI

(70) ;FJ :8JFJ ;< JLI;<Q <D :I@8EW8J ,@E@E><EXK@:FJ < 8D9@<EK8@J :FDF ?@G<I9@C@IIL9@E<D@8 GI<D8KLI@;8;< 8E\O@8 <OGFJ@WVF 8 ;IF>8J FKFK\O@:8J @E=<:W^<J <EKI< FLKIFJ *L8EKF T <K@FCF>@8 <JK@D8J< HL< 8GIFO@D8;8D<EK< ;FJ :8JFJ J<A8D ?<I<;@KSI@FJ

(71) 8JJF:@8;FJ 8 =8KFI<J K\O@:FJ D<K89\C@:FJ @DLEFC\>@:FJ < @E=<::@FJFJ ;IF>8J FKFK\O@:8J 8E\O@8 ?@G<I9@C@IIL9@E<D@8 ;<JD@<C@E@Q8WVF @E=<:W^<J M@I8@J < @;@FGSK@:FJ,K8II/=+5 E<LIFG8K@88L;@K@M8HL<:FDF;<J:I@KF8:@D88:FEK<:<E8D8@FI@8;8J M<Q<J :FDF LD J@E8C :C[E@:F @JFC8;F ;< =FID8 EVF J@E;I]D@:8 GF;< <D GFL:8JJ@KL8W^<J<JK8I8JJF:@8;88FLKIFJ;@JK_I9@FJ=8Q<E;FG8IK<;FJJ@E8@J :C[E@:FJ ;< ;F<EW8J J@E;I]D@:8J < FL E<LIF;<><E<I8K@M8J J@JKZD@:8J :FDF 8 .

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

(73) C< <JKS CF:8C@Q8;F EF 58->< ' E8 I<>@VF :IFDFJJ]D@:8 G ?8@9/=+5

(74) (><E<:FEKXDXOFEJ<:F;@=@:8D_CK@GC8J@JF=FID8J;< GIFK<[E8J CFE>8J < :LIK8J GFI <953-371 8CK<IE8K@MF :FD9@E8;F :FD F LJF ;< MSI@FJ J[K@FJ ;< @E@:@8WVF KI8EJ:I@:@FE8C 28JLE8>8 /= +5 FKF=<IC@E8 X <OGI<JJ8E8:\:C<8M<JK[9LCF<:XI<9IF28JLE8>8/=+5

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

(76) . . ,:?L>/=+5 +FLO/=+5 28JLE8>8/=+5

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

(78) D<O@:8EF 8I><EK@EFJ < <D

(79) G8:@<EK< @E>CZJ +<PEFJF/=+5 +FL@CCFE/=+5 /8I>8/=+5 )FIXD<C8EVF XLD8:8LJ8=I<HL<EK<;<JLI;<QE8GFGLC8WVF9I8J@C<@I8(C@M<@I8/=+5 +FD8EFJ/=+5 . .

(80) . . D =F@ D8G<8;F <D LD8 =8D[C@8 8D<I@:8E8 D8@J LD 58->< .'

(81) E8 I<>@VF :IFDFJJ]D@:8

(82) H

(83) H 8JJF:@8;F T E<LIFG8K@8 8L;@K@M8 G\JC@E>L8C ;< ?<I8EW8 8LKFJJ]D@:8 ;FD@E8EK< $@D /= +5 J<E;F F ><E< :FII<JGFE;<EK< ! @;<EK@=@:8;F GFJK<I@FID<EK< ,:?F<E /= +5

(84) 08E><:FC <D D8G<8I8D.'1

(85) LDEFMF58-><I<C8:@FE8;FT E<LIFG8K@88L;@K@M8GFIXD;<JJ8M<Q;<?<I8EW8C@>8;88F:IFDFJJFDF1E8 I<>@VF 1H H <D LD8 =8D[C@8 :?@E<J8 08E> /= +5 ( ><E< :FII<JGFE;<EK<8@E;8EVF=F@@;<EK@=@:8;F &8@J I<:<EK<D<EK< =F@ @;<EK@=@:8;F FLKIF ><E< 8JJF:@8;FJ T ' ;< ?<I8EW88LKFJJ]D@:8I<:<JJ@M8 (><E<!''CF:8C@Q8;FE8I<>@VF :IFDFJJ]D@:8 H

(86)

(87) H

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

(89) ;FJ :8JFJ 8GI<J<EK8M8D <D@JJ^<J .

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

(91) 'F <EK8EKF 8:I<;@K8J< HL< 8C>LD8J DLK8W^<J EF ><E< GF;<D :8LJ8I 8CK<I8W^<J E8J :XCLC8J :@C@8;8J @EK<IE8J < K<ID@E8W^<J E<IMFJ8J ;8J. .

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

(93) . . HL< FJ I<JLCK8;FJ GF;<D J<I =8:@CD<EK< 8E8C@J8;FJ GFI LD <80=@+;/ 8LKFD8K@Q8;F LK =F@ @E@:@8;F <D

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

(95) . . JVF :8C:LC8;8J 8KI8MXJ ;F fK<DGF ;< MFFg -( HL< I<=C<K< F K<DGF HL< F :FDGFJKFC8J<I@FE@Q8;F<8:<C<I8;FI<HL<IG8I8J<IC<M8;F8KI8MXJ;FKL9F

(96) 8 D ;< :FDGI@D<EKF ;F 8E8C@J8;FI -( < 8C:8EW8I F ;<K<:KFI ;F @EJKILD<EKF 'F;<K<:KFIFJ:FDGFJKFJ@FE@Q8;FJ><I8DLDJ@E8C<CXKI@:FHL< =@:8 >I8M8;F GFI LD J@JK<D8 ;< ;8;FJ < X =@E8CD<EK< :FEM<IK@;F <D LD <JG<:KIF ;< D8JJ8 "IN@E I<JFCLWVF ;8 8KL8C ><I8WVF ;< <JG<:KI]D<KIFJ ;< D8JJ8 G<ID@K< 8 =S:@C ;@JK@EWVF ;8 JL9JK@KL@WVF ;< EL:C<F98J<J :FD M8I@8WVF ;< D8JJ8 ;<

(97) 8 B8 F HL< :FII<JGFE;< 8F K8D8E?F;<';<8 EL:C<F98J<J LK

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

(99) . . %' $. ,3.92:50.7+4 ( F9A<K@MF ;F GI<J<EK< <JKL;F X G<JHL@J8I 8CK<I8W^<J DFC<:LC8I<J EF ><E< ;8 FKF=<IC@E8 % < FLKI8J 8CK<I8W^<J DFC<:LC8I<J : ;<C ><E< ;8J ;<C<W^<J ;<C

(100) ,

(101) < ;<C

(102) ,

(103) EF ><E< < ;8 DLK8WVF D@KF:FE;I@8C 6

(104)

(105)

(106) EF ><E< %## < :FII<C8:@FE8I FJ 8:?8;FJ :FD 8J :8I8:K<I[JK@:8J :C[E@:8J ;<JJ< >ILGF ;< G8:@<EK<JGFIK8;FI<J;<E<LIFG8K@88L;@K@M8 . ,3.92:58.86.-=/2-58 )<JHL@J8I 8CK<I8W^<J DFC<:LC8I<J EF ><E< ;8 FKF=<IC@E8 % <D G8:@<EK<J :FD ;@8>E\JK@:F ;< E<LIFG8K@8 8L;@K@M8 < ;<J<EMFCME\JK@:F DFC<:LC8I ;8 E<LIFG8K@8 8L;@K@M8 LK@C@Q8E;F <JG<:KIFD<KI@8;<D8JJ8G8I88><EFK@G8><D "EM<JK@>8I 8 GI<J<EW8 ;8 DLK8WVF : ;<C < FLKI8J 8CK<I8W^<J EF ><E< ;8J ;<C<W^<J ;<C

(107) ,

(108) < ;<C

(109) ,

(110) EF ><E< <;8DLK8WVFD@KF:FE;I@8CD

(111) EF><E<%## <K<ID@E8I 8 =I<HLZE:@8 ;8 DLK8WVF G * 1 EF XOFE ;F ><E< % <D@E;@M[;LFJ9I8J@C<@IFJ:FDE<LIFG8K@88L;@K@M8 /<I@=@:8I 8 F:FIIZE:@8 ;< FLKI8J 8CK<I8W^<J ><EXK@:8J 8KI8MXJ ;F J<HL<E:@8D<EKF:FDGC<KF;F><E< % )8;IFE@Q8I F DXKF;F ;< ><EFK@G8><D LK@C@Q8E;F F J@JK<D8 +<<##*D .+$/:>/786G8I8F;@8>E\JK@:FDFC<:LC8I;8E<LIFG8K@88L;@K@M8:FD8J GI@E:@G8@J DLK8W^<J <E:FEKI8;8J E8 GFGLC8WVF 9I8J@C<@I8 < E8 GFGLC8WVF DLE;@8C .

(112) . . %' $ !## #% . "EM<JK@>8I 8J 8CK<I8W^<J DFC<:LC8I<J EF ><E< % <D G8:@<EK<J :FD. E<LIFG8K@8 8L;@K@M8 < ;<J<EMFCME\JK@:F DFC<:LC8I ;< E<LIFG8K@8 8L;@K@M8 LJ8E;F <JG<:KIFD<KI@8 ;< D8JJ8 G8I8 ><EFK@G8><D "EM<JK@>8I8GI<J<EW8;8DLK8WVF: ;<C <FLKI8J8CK<I8W^<JEF><E< JLGI<JJ^<J ;<C $ < ;<C $

(113) EF ><E< <FD

(114) DLK8WVFD@KF:FE;I@8C EF><E<%## <K<ID@E8I 8 =I<HLZE:@8 ;8 DLK8WVF G * 1 EF XOFE ;F ><E< % <DG8:@<EK<J9I8J@C<@IFJ:FD' /<I@=@:8I. 8. F:FIIZE:@8. ;<. FLKI8J. 8CK<I8W^<J. ><EXK@:8J. GFI. J<HL<E:@8D<EKF;F><E< % :FDGC<KF )8;IFE@Q8I F DXKF;F ;< ><EFK@G8><D LK@C@Q8E;F F J@JK<D8 +<<##*D $/:>/786 G8I8 F ;@8>E\JK@:F DFC<:LC8I ;< ' :FD 8J DLK8W^<J HL< F:FII<D GI<;FD@E8EK<D<EK< <D GFGLC8W^<J 9I8J@C<@I8J < DLE;@8@J .

(115) %' $ $& #% . E8C@J8IFG8;IVF;<I<C8WVF:C[E@:8<EKI<FJG8:@<EK<J:FD;@8>E\JK@:F. :C[E@:F:FDF<JG<:KIF;8E<LIFG8K@88L;@K@M8<:FII<C8:@FE8I:FDDLK8W^<J;F ><E< .

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

(117) . . !C%& &#. $%&*. . !%%$. (%. &% #*. &# !%* -%$21($ ',3!$. +7:+415 +8DFJ )38JK@C?F & L@D8IV<J ,8IKFI8KF % &FC<:LC8I JKL;P F= G8K@<EKJ N@K? 8L;@KFIP E<LIFG8K?P &FC &<; +<G

(118)

(119)

(120)

(121) ;F@

(122) DDI

(123) )* + ',21( & ('"* ++(+'$('$+ $', *'$('$+ . LIFG<8E !LD8E. <E<K@:J FE=<I<E:<

(124) &8P

(125) #LE< .

(126) &@C8E"K8CPG]JKP 0FIBJ?FG

(128) L>

(129) ,<G ,?<==@<C; .E@K<;$@E>;FDG]JKI<JJFI8J@C<@IF;<(KFII@EFC8I@E>FCF>@8<@ILI>@8XIM@:F 8:@8C

(130)

(131) 8

(132) ;< EFM<D9IF )FIKF C<>I< I8J@C 8GI<J<EK8WVFFI8C . .

(133) 02/(&8/$50(',&,1(5(32576. . 0ROHFXODUVWXG\RISDWLHQWVZLWKDXGLWRU\QHXURSDWK\ *8,/+(50(0$&+$'2'(&$59$/+235,6&,/$=21=,1,5$026$57+850(1,12&$67,/+2 $/(;$1'5(&$,;(7$*8,0$5®(6DQG(',/Ô&,$6$5725$72 . 2WRORJ\$XGLRORJ\DQG,PSODQWDEOH(DU3URVWKHVHV(DU1RVH7KURDWDQG+HDGDQG1HFN6XUJHU\'HSDUWPHQW +XPDQ0ROHFXODU*HQHWLFV/DERUDWRU\0ROHFXODU%LRORJ\DQG*HQHWLF(QJLQHHULQJ&HQWHU&%0(* 6WDWH8QLYHUVLW\RI&DPSLQDV 81,&$03

(134) 6mR3DXOR%UD]LO 5HFHLYHG$XJXVW$FFHSWHG-DQXDU\ '2,PPU. $EVWUDFW$XGLWRU\QHXURSDWK\LVDW\SHRIKHDULQJORVVWKDW FRQVWLWXWHVDFKDQJHLQWKHFRQGXFWRIWKHDXGLWRU\VWLPXOXVE\ WKHLQYROYHPHQWRILQQHUKDLUFHOOVRUDXGLWRU\QHUYHV\QDSVHV ,WLVFKDUDFWHUL]HGE\WKHDEVHQFHRUDOWHUDWLRQRIZDYHVLQWKH H[DPLQDWLRQRIEUDLQVWHPDXGLWRU\HYRNHGSRWHQWLDOVZLWK RWRDFRXVWLFDQGRUFRFKOHDUPLFURSKRQLFLVVXHV$WSUHVHQW IRXUORFLDVVRFLDWHGZLWKQRQV\QGURPLFDXGLWRU\QHXURSDWK\ KDYHEHHQPDSSHG$XWRVRPDOUHFHVVLYHGHDIQHVV>')1% WKH RWRIHUOLQ 272)

(135) JHQH@ DQG DXWRVRPDO UHFHVVLYH GHDI QHVV>')1%WKHSHMYDNLQ 3-9.

(136) JHQH@DVVRFLDWHGZLWK DXWRVRPDOUHFHVVLYHLQKHULWDQFHWKHDXWRVRPDOGRPLQDQWDXGL WRU\QHXURSDWK\JHQH>$81$WKHGLDSKDQRXV ',$3+

(137) JHQH@DQG$81;OLQNHGWRFKURPRVRPH;)XUWKHUPRUH PXWDWLRQVRIFRQQH[LQ>WKHJDSMXQFWLRQ ơ *-%

(138) JHQH@ KDYHDOVREHHQDVVRFLDWHGZLWKWKHGLVHDVH272)JHQHPXWD WLRQVH[HUWDVLJQLÀFDQWUROHLQDXGLWRU\QHXURSDWK\,QH[FHVV RISDWKRJHQLFPXWDWLRQVKDYHEHHQLGHQWLÀHGLQLQGLYLGXDOV ZLWK QRQV\QGURPLF GHDIQHVV LQ SRSXODWLRQV RI GLIIHUHQW RULJLQVZLWKDQHPSKDVLVRQWKHS4;PXWDWLRQZKLFK ZDVIRXQGLQaRIFDVHVRIGHDIQHVVLQWKH6SDQLVKSRSXOD WLRQ7KHLGHQWLÀ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

(139) 9LWDO %UD]LO 6WUHHW 6mR3DXOR%UD]LO (PDLOJXLPDFKDGRFDUYDOKR#JPDLOFRP .H\ ZRUGV DXGLWRU\ QHXURSDWK\ VSHFWUXP GLVRUGHU HYRNHG DXGLWRU\EUDLQVWHPUHVSRQVHRWRDFRXVWLFHPLVVLRQV*-%KHDULQJ ORVV. DQGWKHFGHO*PXWDWLRQLQWKH*-%JHQHZDVLGHQWLÀHGLQ WKUHHKRPR]\JRXVSDWLHQWVDQGWKHKHWHUR]\JRXVSDUHQWVRI RQHRIWKHVHFDVHV$GGLWLRQDOO\272)JHQHPXWDWLRQVZHUH WUDFNHGE\FRPSOHWHVHTXHQFLQJRIH[RQVDOWKRXJKWKHVH UHVXOWV DUH VWLOO SUHOLPLQDU\ 6WXG\LQJ WKH JHQHWLF EDVLV RI DXGLWRU\QHXURSDWK\LVRIXWPRVWLPSRUWDQFHIRUREWDLQLQJD GLIIHUHQWLDOGLDJQRVLVGHYHORSLQJPRUHVSHFLÀFWUHDWPHQWVDQG PRUHDFFXUDWHJHQHWLFFRXQVHOLQJ ,QWURGXFWLRQ +HDULQJORVVLVWKHPRVWSUHYDOHQWVHQVRU\GLVHDVHLQKXPDQV LWLVFDXVHGE\DYDULHW\RIJHQHWLFDQGHQYLURQPHQWDOIDFWRUV :KHUHDVHQYLURQPHQWDOIDFWRUVLQFOXGHH[SRVXUHWRIUHTXHQW KLJKLQWHQVLW\VRXQGDFRXVWLFWUDXPDLQIHFWLRQVDQGRWRWR[LF GUXJVDPRQJRWKHUVJHQHWLFIDFWRUVDUHFDXVHGE\PXWDWLRQV LQGLIIHUHQWJHQHVRUUHJXODWRU\HOHPHQWVLQYROYHGLQWKHSURSHU GHYHORSPHQWVWUXFWXUHDQGIXQFWLRQRIWKHHDU

(140) ,Q GHYHORSHG FRXQWULHV ! RI DOO FDVHV RI KHDULQJ LPSDLUPHQWUHVXOWIURPJHQHWLFFDXVHV

(141) +RZHYHULQ%UD]LO HQYLURQPHQWDOIDFWRUVRXWZHLJKWKRVHRIJHQHWLFRULJLQ

(142) &RQVLGHULQJ WKDW LPSURYHPHQWV DUH EHLQJ LPSOHPHQWHG LQ WKHKHDOWKVHFWRUDQGZLWKWKHDGYDQFHPHQWVEHLQJPDGHLQ JHQHWLFVWXGLHVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKKHDULQJORVVWKHSURSRUWLRQRI JHQHWLFFDXVHVWHQGVWRLQFUHDVH ,QWHUQDWLRQDO VWDWLVWLFV UHYHDO WKDW RQH LQ HYHU\ QHZERUQVKDVKHDULQJORVV

(143) ,Q%UD]LOWKHIUHTXHQF\ LVHVWLPDWHGDWIRXUSHUELUWKV

(144) +RZHYHUWKLVRIWHQ YDULHV'HSHQGLQJRQWKHVDPSOHDQGVWXG\DUHDLWPD\EH SUHVHQWLQSHUQHZERUQV

(145) 5HFHQW \HDUV KDYH ZLWQHVVHG VLJQLILFDQW DGYDQFHV LQ UHVHDUFK RQ WKH PROHFXODU EDVLV RI WKH DXGLWRU\ V\VWHP HQDEOLQJ WKH LGHQWLILFDWLRQ DQG FKDUDFWHUL]DWLRQ RI VHYHUDO JHQHVDQGSURWHLQVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKKHDULQJ7KHLQFUHDVLQJ NQRZOHGJH DERXW WKHVH JHQHV FRQWULEXWHV QRW RQO\ WR DQ LPSURYHGXQGHUVWDQGLQJRIWKHPHFKDQLVPVRIKHDULQJEXW DOVRWRWKHPROHFXODUEDVLVRIKHDULQJLPSDLUPHQW7KLVEDVLF UHVHDUFKLVDSUHUHTXLVLWHIRUWKHGHYHORSPHQWRIPROHFXODU GLDJQRVWLFVDQGQRYHOWKHUDSLHVIRUGHDIQHVV

(146) 2QHRIWKHELJJHVWREVWDFOHVLQWKHVHDUFKIRUJHQHVLQYROYHG LQKHDULQJORVVLVWKHGLIÀFXOWDFFHVVWRWKHFRFKOHDDQGRWKHU LQQHUHDUVWUXFWXUHV7KHFRQVWUXFWLRQRIDF'1$OLEUDU\RI IHWDOFRFKOHDUHTXLSPHQWDOORZHGWKHLVVXHRIFDQGLGDWHJHQHV WREHDGGUHVVHGXVLQJDWLVVXHVSHFLÀFDSSURDFK

(147) 7KH.

(148) . '(&$59$/+2HWDO$8',725<1(8523$7+<$1'02/(&8/$5(9$/8$7,21. ODUJHQXPEHURIJHQHVH[SUHVVHGLQWKHFRFKOHDUHÁHFWVWKH FRPSOH[LW\ RI WKH PROHFXODU PHFKDQLVPV LQYROYHG LQ WKLV RUJDQRILQWULFDWHQDWXUH

(149) 0RVW FDVHV RI KHUHGLWDU\ KHDULQJ ORVV a

(150) DUH QRQV\QGURPLF'LIIHUHQWORFLRUUHJLRQVWRVXEPLWFDQGLGDWH JHQHVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKQRQV\QGURPLFGHDIQHVVUHFHLYHWKH SUHÀ[')1 IURPGHDIQHVV

(151) IROORZHGE\DQXPEHULQGLFDWLQJ WKHRUGHULQZKLFKWKH\ZHUHGLVFRYHUHG7KHNQRZQJHQHWLF PXWDWLRQVWKDWOHDGWRGHDIQHVVPD\EHDXWRVRPDOUHFHVVLYH ')1%

(152) DXWRVRPDOGRPLQDQW ')1$

(153) ;OLQNHG ;')1

(154) RU PLWRFKRQGULDO

(155) 5HJDUGLQJWKHPHFKDQLVPVRILQKHULWDQFHLWLVHVWLPDWHG WKDW RI FDVHV RI QRQV\QGURPLF JHQHWLF GHDIQHVV DUH DXWRVRPDO UHFHVVLYH DUH DXWRVRPDO GRPLQDQW DQG DUH OLQNHG WR WKH ; FKURPRVRPH ,Q DGGLWLRQ WKH IUHTXHQF\ RI PLWRFKRQGULDO LQKHULWDQFH LV HVWLPDWHG DW

(156) 7KHKHWHURJHQHLW\RIQRQV\QGURPLFDXWRVRPDOUHFHVVLYH KHDULQJORVVLVKLJKIRUZKLFKORFLKDYHEHHQGHVFULEHGDQG JHQHVKDYHEHHQLGHQWLÀHGWRGDWH

(157) $XGLWRU\ QHXURSDWK\ $1

(158) LV D W\SH RI VHQVRULQHXUDO KHDULQJORVVFRQVLVWLQJRIDXGLWRU\VWLPXOXVDOWHUDWLRQDVD UHVXOWRIWKHLQYROYHPHQWRILQQHUKDLUFHOOVRUDXGLWRU\QHUYH V\QDSVHV,WLVFKDUDFWHUL]HGE\WKHDEVHQFHRUDOWHUDWLRQRI ZDYHVLQWKHH[DPLQDWLRQRIWKHEUDLQVWHPDXGLWRU\SRWHQWLDO UHVSRQVH LQ WKH SUHVHQFH RI RWRDFRXVWLF HPLVVLRQV DQGRU FRFKOHDUPLFURSKRQLVP

(159) ,WLVUHVSRQVLEOHIRURIWKHFDVHVRIKHDULQJORVVLQ FKLOGUHQDQGPD\EHFDXVHGE\DQXPEHURIJHQHWLFDQGHQYL URQPHQWDOIDFWRUVLQFOXGLQJK\SHUELOLUXELQHPLDSUHPDWXULW\ DQR[LD H[SRVXUH WR RWRWR[LF GUXJV DQG LQIHFWLRQV DPRQJ RWKHUV5HJDUGLQJHWLRORJ\LWLVHVWLPDWHGWKDWaRIFDVHV DUH KHUHGLWDU\ DUH DVVRFLDWHG ZLWK WR[LF PHWDEROLF LPPXQRORJLFDO DQG LQIHFWLRXV IDFWRUV HJ RWRWR[LF GUXJV DQR[LDK\SHUELOLUXELQHPLDGHP\HOLQDWLRQDQGYLUDOLQIHF WLRQV

(160) DQGDUHLGLRSDWKLF

(161) 7KH$1PD\EHDVVRFLDWHGZLWKRWKHUGLVRUGHUV V\QGURPLF

(162) DVSDUWRIWKHFOLQLFDOVLJQVRIV\VWHPLFQHXURGHJHQHUDWLYH GLVHDVHVLQFOXGLQJ&KDUFRW0DULH7RRWKGLVHDVH)ULHGUHLFK V DWD[LD*XLOODLQ%DUUpQHXURSDWK\DQGPLWRFKRQGULDOGLVHDVHV RUWKHUHPD\EH QRQV\QGURPLF

(163) LVRODWHGFOLQLFDOVLJQV

(164) *LYHQWKHSHFXOLDUFKDUDFWHULVWLFVRISDWLHQWVZLWK$1WKH WUHDWPHQWRIWKHVHLQGLYLGXDOVLVDFKDOOHQJH7KHUHLVDQHHG WRJDLQDQLPSURYHGXQGHUVWDQGLQJRIWKHSDWKRSK\VLRORJ\RI WKLVGLVHDVHDQGVWXGLHVRQJHQHWLFDQGPROHFXODUDVVHVVPHQW FDQSURYLGHLPSRUWDQWFROODERUDWLRQ2YHUWKHFRXUVHRIWKH ODVWGHFDGHWKHLGHQWLÀFDWLRQRIJHQHVUHVSRQVLEOHIRU$1 KDYHFRQWULEXWHGJUHDWO\WRWKHGLDJQRVLVDQGLPSURYHGXQGHU VWDQGLQJRIWKHPHFKDQLVPVLQYROYHGLQWKHGLVHDVH 7KHRWRIHUOLQ 272)

(165) JHQHLVRQHRIWKHJHQHVDVVRFL DWHGZLWKDXWRVRPDOUHFHVVLYHQRQV\QGURPLFKHDULQJORVV,W LVORFDWHGLQWKHORFXV')1%FKURPRVRPDOUHJLRQS 7KHJHQHFRQWDLQVH[RQVDQGHQFRGHVPXOWLSOHLVRIRUPV RISURWHLQVJHQHUDWHGYLDORQJDQGVKRUWDOWHUQDWLYHVSOLFLQJ HYHQWVFRPELQHGE\XVLQJGLIIHUHQWWUDQVFULSWLRQDOLQLWLDWLRQ VLWHV272)LVH[SUHVVHGLQWKHFRFKOHDYHVWLEXOHDQGEUDLQ DQGLVLQYROYHGLQWKHH[RF\WRVLVRIV\QDSWLFYHVLFOHVIURP LQQHUKDLUFHOOV

(166) 0XWDWLRQVLQWKH272)JHQHDUHUHVSRQVLEOHIRUDSUHOLQ JXDOIDLUO\KRPRJHQRXVSKHQRW\SHRISURIRXQGKHDULQJORVV. . ZLWKRXWDVVRFLDWHGGHIHFWVLQWKHLQQHUHDU+RZHYHUQXPHURXV DIIHFWHGLQGLYLGXDOVKDYH$12YHUSDWKRJHQLFPXWDWLRQV KDYHEHHQLGHQWLÀHGLQLQGLYLGXDOVZLWKQRQV\QGURPLFGHDI QHVVLQSRSXODWLRQVRIGLIIHUHQWRULJLQV

(167) ,Q DQRWKHU ORFXV $81$ ZDV PDSSHG LQ DQ $PHULFDQ IDPLO\ LQ WKH FKURPRVRPDO UHJLRQ TT DVVRFLDWHG ZLWK DXWRVRPDO GRPLQDQW SRVWOLQJXDO $1 DQG WKHFRUUHVSRQGLQJJHQHGLDSKDQRXV ',$3+

(168) ZDVVXEVH TXHQWO\LGHQWLÀHG

(169) 7KH$81;JHQHZDVPDSSHGLQDQRYHOORFXVDVVRFL DWHGZLWK$1DOWKRXJKWKLVWLPHOLQNHGWRWKH;FKURPRVRPH LQWKH;TTUHJLRQLQD&KLQHVHIDPLO\LQKHULWDQFH7KH FRUUHVSRQGLQJJHQHKDVQRWEHHQLGHQWLÀHG

(170) 0RUH UHFHQWO\ DQRWKHU QHXURSDWK\ DVVRFLDWHG ZLWK WKH DXWRVRPDO UHFHVVLYH JHQH ZDV LGHQWLILHG 7KH JHQH 3-9. ')1%

(171) ORFDWHG LQ FKURPRVRPH UHJLRQ TT HQFRGHVSHMYDNLQ 3-9.

(172) DSURWHLQRIWKHDIIHUHQWDXGLWRU\ SDWKZD\LQYROYHGLQVLJQDOLQJIURPKDLUFHOOVDQGQHXURQV +RZHYHUPXWDWLRQVLQWKLVJHQHDUHQRWDIUHTXHQWFDXVHRI $1LQ%UD]LODVDUHPXWDWLRQVLQWKH272)JHQH

(173) )XUWKHUPRUH PXWDWLRQV LQ FRQQH[LQ >WKH JDS MXQF WLRQ ơ *-%

(174) JHQH@ KDYH DOVR EHHQ DVVRFLDWHG ZLWK $1 7ZRGLIIHUHQWVWXGLHVKDYHLGHQWLÀHGFDVHVZLWK$1DPRQJ LQGLYLGXDOVZLWKKHDULQJORVVZKRKDGPXWDWLRQVLQWKH*-% JHQH

(175) &XUUHQWO\LWLVNQRZQWKDWFKDQJHVLQFRQQH[LQLQWHU IHUHZLWKWKHLRQLFKRPHRVWDVLVRIWKHLQQHUHDUOHDGLQJWRWKH DFFXPXODWLRQRIH[WUDFHOOXODUSRWDVVLXPZKLFKUHVXOWVLQFHOO GHDWK7KXVLWLVOLNHO\WKDWRWRDFRXVWLFHPLVVLRQVREVHUYHGLQ SDWLHQWVLQWKHVWXGLHVFLWHGDERYHUHSUHVHQWUHVLGXDODFWLYLW\RI DIHZRXWHUKDLUFHOOVWKDWUHPDLQHGDOLYHLQWKHDSLFDOSDUWRI WKHFRFKOHD+RZHYHULWLVFRQVLGHUHGWKDWFHUWDLQPXWDWLRQVLQ WKH*-%JHQHPD\FDXVHFKDQJHVLQWKHLQQHUKDLUFHOOVDQG QHUYHHQGLQJVRIWKHKDLUFHOOV

(176) 7KHUHIRUHIXUWKHUVWXGLHVDUHUHTXLUHGWRFODULI\WKHDVVRFLD WLRQEHWZHHQ$1DQG*-%JHQHPXWDWLRQV

(177) $SUHYLRXV VWXG\KDVDOVRLQYHVWLJDWHGFRQQH[LQVDQGJDSMXQFWLRQVVXFK DVRQHLQYROYLQJWKHJDSMXQFWLRQơ *-%

(178) JHQH

(179) ZKLFK PD\EHDVVRFLDWHGZLWKQRQV\QGURPLFKHDULQJORVV 7KHUHDUHVHYHUDOZD\VWRGHWHFWFKDQJHVDQGRUPXWDWLRQV LQWKHJHQRPHDQGUHFHQWO\KLJKWKURXJKSXWWHFKQRORJLHV KDYHHPHUJHGDVDQLQWHUHVWLQJDOWHUQDWLYH*HQRW\SLQJXVLQJ WKH0DVV$55$<V\VWHP 6HTXHQRP,QF6DQ'LHJR&$ 86$

(180) ZLWK WKH PDWUL[DVVLVWHG ODVHU GHVRUSWLRQ LRQL]DWLRQ WLPHRIÁLJKWPDVVVSHFWURPHWULF 0$/',72)06

(181) WHFK QLTXHDQGL3/(;WHUPHG*ROG$VVD\PD\EHFRQVLGHUHG DSRZHUIXOWRROZLWKDQDWWUDFWLYHDSSURDFK*HQRW\SLQJLV FRQVLGHUHGDPHWKRGIRUREWDLQLQJDQDYHUDJH\LHOGDQGDOORZV WKHJHQRW\SLQJRIXSWRVLQJOHQXFOHRWLGHSRO\PRUSKLVPV 613V

(182) VLPXOWDQHRXVO\XVLQJVDPSOHVTXLFNO\DQG DWORZFRVW

(183) $OOHOLFGLVFULPLQDWLRQLVDFKLHYHGXVLQJ0$/',72)06 ZKLFKKDVEHHQZLGHO\XVHGIRUDQDO\]LQJPXOWLSOH[SURGXFWV DQGGLIIHUHQWJHQRW\SHVEDVHGRQGLIIHUHQFHVLQWKHPROHFXODU ZHLJKWVRIQXFOHRWLGHV

(184) 7KHUHIRUH06FXUUHQWO\UHSUHVHQWVDSRZHUIXODQGYHUVD WLOH DQDO\WLFDO PHWKRG WKDW SURYLGHV YDOXDEOH LQIRUPDWLRQ DERXWWKHFRPSRVLWLRQDQGVWUXFWXUHRIPROHFXOHVDQGDOVR VKHGVOLJKWRQWKHTXDQWLW\RIVSHFLÀFDQDO\WHVLQPL[WXUHV 7KLVPHWKRGSURYLGHVDQDWWUDFWLYHVROXWLRQIRUWKHJHQRW\SLQJ.

(185) 02/(&8/$50(',&,1(5(32576. RI613VSDUWLFXODUO\VLQFHLWDOORZVGLUHFWDQGUDSLG'1$ PHDVXUHPHQWUDWKHUWKDQRQO\GHWHFWLQJDPDUN UDGLRDFWLYH RUÁXRUHVFHQW

(186) DQGWKHUHVXOWVPD\EHHDVLO\DQDO\]HGE\DXWR PDWHGVRIWZDUH

(187) 0$/',72)06ZDVÀUVWHPSOR\HGLQE\.DUDV DQG+LOOHQNDPS

(188) DVDUHYROXWLRQDU\PHWKRGIRUWKHLRQL]D WLRQ DQG PDVV DQDO\VLV RI QXPHURXV ELRPROHFXOHV 7KHVH UHVHDUFKHUVGHPRQVWUDWHGWKDWLUUDGLDWLRQRIFU\VWDOVIRUPHG E\VXLWDEOHVPDOORUJDQLFPROHFXOHV FDOOHGPDWUL[

(189) ZLWKD VKRUWSXOVHODVHUFDXVHGDQHQHUJ\WUDQVIHUDQGGHVRUSWLRQ SURFHVVSURGXFLQJWKHPDWUL[LRQVLQWKHJDVSKDVH2IHYHQ JUHDWHULPSRUWDQFHWKH\GHWHUPLQHGWKDWLIDORZFRQFHQWUD WLRQRIDQRQDEVRUEHQWDQDO\WHVXFKDVDSURWHLQRUQXFOHLF DFLGPROHFXOHLVDGGHGWRWKHPDWUL[VROXWLRQDQGHPEHGGHG LQWKHVROLGPDWUL[RIFU\VWDOVIRUPHGE\GU\LQJWKHPL[WXUH QRQDEVRUEHQWLQWDFWPROHFXOHVRIWKHDQDO\WHDOVRZRXOGEH VHQWWRWKHJDVSKDVHDQGLRQL]HGODVHUIDFLOLWDWLQJLWVPDVV DQDO\VLV

(190) 7KHEDVLFFRPSRQHQWVRIDPDVVVSHFWURPHWHUFRQVLVWRI DQLRQL]DWLRQVRXUFH 89ODVHU

(191) DQDQDO\]HUDQGDGHWHFWRU )RUDQDO\VLVWKHELRORJLFDOVDPSOH QXFOHLFDFLGPL[WXUH

(192) LV DGGHGWRDPDWHULDO PDWUL[

(193) XVXDOO\DORZPROHFXODUZHLJKW RUJDQLFDFLGZLWKDVWURQJDEVRUSWLRQDWWKHODVHUZDYHOHQJWKLQ EORFNVRIRQHVLOLFRQFKLSVXUIDFH7KH0$/',72)SURFHVV LV WKHQ LQLWLDWHG E\ ODVHU GHVRUSWLRQ RI DQ DQDO\WHPDWUL[ PL[WXUH6XEVHTXHQWSK\VLFDOSURFHVVHVUHVXOWLQWKHSUHGRPL QDQW IRUPDWLRQ RI HLWKHU SRVLWLYHO\ FKDUJHG RU QHJDWLYHO\ FKDUJHGLRQV7KHVHLRQVDUHH[WUDFWHGXVLQJDQHOHFWULFÀHOG DQGVHSDUDWHGDFFRUGLQJWRWKHLUPROHFXODUPDVVHVDQGWKHLU FKDUJHV

(194) 7KHPDVVHVRIQXFOHLFDFLGFRPSRXQGVDUHFDOFXODWHGXVLQJ 72)ZKLFKUHÁHFWVWKHWLPHWKDWWKHODVHULRQL]HGFRPSRXQG UHTXLUHVWREHFDUULHGWKURXJKWKHÁLJKWWXEH WRPOHQJWK

(195) 72) DQDO\]HU DQG UHDFK WKH LQVWUXPHQW GHWHFWRU $W WKH GHWHFWRUWKHLRQL]HGFRPSRXQGVJHQHUDWHDQHOHFWULFDOVLJQDO WKDWLVUHFRUGHGE\DGDWDV\VWHPDQGLVÀQDOO\FRQYHUWHGLQWR DPDVVVSHFWUXP7KHUHVROXWLRQRIWKHFXUUHQWJHQHUDWLRQ RI0$/',PDVVVSHFWURPHWHUVHQDEOHVHDV\GLVWLQFWLRQRI QXFOHREDVHUHSODFHPHQWVZLWKDPDVVYDULDWLRQRIWR 'D ZKLFK FRUUHVSRQGV WR D '1$ VL]H IURP WR QXFOHREDVHV

(196) 7KHLGHQWLÀFDWLRQRIJHQHWLFDOWHUDWLRQVUHVSRQVLEOHIRU$1 LVRQHRIWKHFKDOOHQJHVWKDWFRQWULEXWHWRWKHXQGHUVWDQGLQJ RIWKHPROHFXODUEDVLVRIWKHGLIIHUHQWVHURW\SHVRIKHDULQJ ORVVSKHQRW\SHV)XUWKHUPRUHWKHXVHRIQRYHOPROHFXODUWRROV WKDWHQDEOHDPRUHUDSLGDQGHIIHFWLYHGLDJQRVLVLVRIJUHDW LQWHUHVWIRUWKHVHSDWLHQWV7KXVWKHVHIDFWRUVDUHLPSRUWDQWIRU DGLIIHUHQWLDOGLDJQRVLVDVZHOODVIRUGHYHORSLQJPRUHVSHFLÀF WUHDWPHQWVDQGDPRUHDFFXUDWHJHQHWLFFRXQVHOLQJ 7KHSUHVHQWVWXG\DLPHGWRLQYHVWLJDWHPROHFXODUFKDQJHV RI WKH 272) JHQH LQ SDWLHQWV ZLWK $1 DQG WR GHYHORS D '1$FKLSIRUWKHPROHFXODUGLDJQRVLVRI$1XVLQJ06IRU JHQRW\SLQJVSHFLÀFDOO\L

(197) 7RLQYHVWLJDWHWKHSUHVHQFHRIWKH PXWDWLRQFGHO*DQGRWKHUFKDQJHVLQWKH*-%JHQHWKH GHOHWLRQVGHO *-%'6