FUMEC UNIVERSITY LAW MAGAZINE

(1)

MERITUM MAGAZINE  Belo Horizonte  v.15  n.1  p. 01-370  Jan./Apr. 2020  ISSN 2238-6939

FUMEC UNIVERSITY

LAW MAGAZINE

(2)

MERITUM MAGAZINE • v.15 • n.1 • Jan./Apr. 2020

RECTORY Rector:

Prof. Fernando de Melo Nogueira Graduation Pro-Rector:

Prof. João Batista de Mendonça Filho

Pro-Rector Of Planning And Administration:

Prof. Márcio Dario da Silva

Pr-Rector Of Post Graduation, Research And Extension:

Prof. Henrique Cordeiro Martins

MINING FOUNDATION OF EDUCATION AND CULTURE Chairman of the Board of Trustees:

Prof. Antônio Carlos Diniz Murta

Vice-Chairman of the Board of Trustees:

Prof. João Carlos de Castro Silva President of the Executive Council:

Prof. Air Rabelo

FACULTY OF HUMAN, SOCIAL AND HEALTH SCIENCES General Director:

Prof. Rodrigo Suzana Guimarães Coordination of the Law Course:

Prof. Daniel Firmato de Almeida Glória Profa. Silvana Lourenço Lobo

Coordinator of the Master’s Program in the concentration area Social Institutions, Law and Democracy:

Prof. Sérgio Henriques Zandona Freitas

FACULTY OF HUMAN, SOCIAL AND HEALTH SCIENCES - FUMEC Rua Cobre, 200, Cruzeiro Belo Horizonte/MG – CEP 30310-190

Tel (31) 3228-3090 – Site: www.fumec.br MERITUM MAGAZINE

EDITORIAL COORDINATION:

Prof. Sérgio Henriques Zandona Freitas

TECHNICAL RESPONSIBLE OF MERITUM MAGAZINE:

Prof. Adriano da Silva Ribeiro (Adjunct Editor and Technical Responsible) Bel. Cláudia Márcia Magalhães (Secretary of PPGD FUMEC)

ENGLISH REVIEWER AND TRANSLATOR Profa. Marina Araújo Campos Cardoso

Prof. Ronan Cardoso Naves Neto

Site: http://www.fumec.br/revistas/meritum/

E-mail: revistameritum@fumec.br FUMEC UNIVERSITY LIBRARY:

Priscila Reis (Area Coordinator, PhD student in SIGC) GRAPHIC PROJECT

Rodrigo Tito Moura Valadares Leonardo Ferreira Costa DESKTOP PUBLISHING

Tecnologia da Informação / Produção Multimídia PRINTING: online

(3)

Meritum: Law Journal of the FUMEC University / FUMEC University, Faculty of Human, Social and Health Sciences.

- v. 15, no. 1 (Jan./Apr. 2020) -.- Belo Horizonte: FUMEC University, 2006-

v. ; 21 x 29,7cm Quarterly ISSN 2238-6939

1. Right. I. FUMEC University. Faculty of Human, Social and Health Sciences.

CDU:34

Catalog form prepared by the University Library-FUMEC

Concepts issued in signed articles are the sole and exclusive responsibility of their authors.

(4)

Editorial Board

Adolfo Ingácio Calderón, Pontifícia Universidade Católica de Campinas (PUC Campinas)

Arno Dal Ri Jr, Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina (UFSC)

César Augusto Baldi, Universidad Pablo Olavide (UPO), Sevilha, Espanha Daniel Firmato de Almeida Glória, Universidade FUMEC

David López Jiménez, Universidade de Huelva, Espanha

Deissy Motta Castaño, Universidad Autónoma, Bogotá, Colômbia Dídima Rico Chavarr, Universidad Autónoma, Bogotá, Colômbia Erica Palmerini, Scuola Superiore Sant’Anna (SSSUP), Pisa, Itália

Fernando Antonio de Carvalho Dantas, Pontifícia Universidade Católica do Paraná (PUC/PR)

Profª Flávia de Avila, Universidade Federal de Sergipe. UFS Gladston Gomes Mamede da Silva, Universidade FUMEC Haroldo Duclerc Verçosa, Universidade de São Paulo (USP) Jan Peter Schmid, Instituto Max Planck (MPI), Alemanha

Jean-Christophe Merle, Faculdade de Filosofia da Universidade de Saarbrücken, Alemanha

José Filomeno de Morais Filho, Universidade de Fortaleza (UNIFOR) Joaquim Carlos Salgado, Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais (UFMG) Jorge Renato dos Reis, Universidade de Santa Cruz do Sul (UNISC) Karine Salgado, Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais (UFMG)

Kennedy Kihangi Bindu, Université Libre des Pays des Grands Lacs (ULPGL) – República Democrática do Congo

Manuel David Masseno, Instituto Politécnico de Beja (IPBeja), Universidade de Porto (UP), Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina (UFSC)

Nattan Nisimblat, Universidad del Rosario, Bogotá, Colômbia

Otavio Luiz Rodrigues Junior, Instituto de Educação Superior de Brasília (IESB) Paula Nunes Correia, Universidade de Macau (UM), Macau, China

Raymundo Juliano Rego Feitosa, Universidade Federal de Pernambuco (UFPE)

(5)

EDITORIAL

The FUMEC University Law Graduate Program (master’s degree) presents the Meritum Magazine to the academic community, with the mission of being an effective instrument for the dissemination of scientific works developed in Brazil and abroad, in line with the research lines

“Private Autonomy, Regulation and Strategy”, “Public Sphere, Legitimacy, Control”.

The upward profile and quality of the Master’s Program in Law at the FUMEC University were attested by the last evaluation carried out by the Coordination for the Improvement of Higher Education Personnel - CAPES (quadrennium 2013/2016), in which it obtained grade 4 (four).

Revista Meritum, in this context of academic production quality, is a traditional journal and a reference in Law, being classified with extract B1 by the Coordination for the Improvement of Higher Education Personnel - CAPES, through the set of procedures called Qualis Periódicos.

Therefore, it is characterized by disseminating the knowledge generated from investiga- tions that contribute to the formation of professionals with critical legal conscience, qualified not only for the exercise of legal technique, but also for thinking about the Law in its scientific, philosophical, historical, sociological and political.

As of Volume 15, Number 1, of 2020, Revista Meritum started to adopt the four-monthly periodicity (3 issues per year), with the receipt of articles for evaluation in a continuous flow. In addition, it is internationalized, through DOI, that is, it has a digital object identifier, which allows the publication to be identified in a unique and persistent way in the Web environment.

Meritum Magazine is also pleased to announce that it has introduced the English version of articles written in Portuguese and the MP3 audio version. A new permanent section of Dis- sertations of PPGD FUMEC was created with the objective of giving visibility to the dissertations defended by the master’s students.

Articles submitted to Revista Meritum vol. 15, n. 1, were evaluated by the Editorial Coordina- tion, which examined the suitability for the journal’s editorial line, elementary formal and metho- dological aspects, among others. Subsequently, each text was sent to at least two reviewers, by the double blind peer review system, for analysis of form and content, as well as the issuance of the opinion.

Critically, autonomously and plurally, in this vol. 15, n. 1, several issues and problems in the legal universe related to the Democratic Rule of Law and the enforcement of rights are addres- sed. It seeks to analyze and debate perspectives that help to critically interpret our contempora- neity and the challenges that arise from it.

Happy reading to all!

Prof. Dr. Sérgio Henriques Zandona Freitas Prof. Dr. Adriano da Silva Ribeiro Editorial Coordination

(6)

SUMMARY

Articles

THE UNAVAILABILITY OF PUBLIC INTEREST: CONTENT, LEGAL NATURE, NORMATIVE

FOUNDATION AND IMPACTS ON BRAZILIAN ADMINISTRATIVE LAW ...9 A INDISPONIBILIDADE DO INTERESSE PÚBLICO: CONTEÚDO, NATUREZA JURÍDICA,

FUNDAMENTOS NORMATIVOS E IMPACTOS NO DIREITO ADMINISTRATIVO BRASILEIRO

Luzardo Faria

DISCHARGING: ACQUISITION OF PROPERTY IMPOSED BY THE EXTRAJUDICIAL

USUCAPTION PROCEDURE ...30 DESJUDICIALIZAÇÃO: AQUISIÇÃO DA PROPRIEDADE IMÓVEL PELO

PROCEDIMENTO DE USUCAPIÃO EXTRAJUDICIAL

Gilberto Ferreira Marchetti Filho Ana Julia Muniz Lemes

THE AUTOPOIESE OF LAW AND THE TRANSPARENCY OF THE SOURCES

OF FINANCING OF THE BNDES ...50 A AUTOPOIESE DO DIREITO E A TRANSPARÊNCIA DAS FONTES DE FINANCIAMENTO DO BNDES

Gabriela Eulalio de Lima

EL CUIDADO COMO ESTRATEGIA DE SUPERVIVENCIA HUMANA: Discapacidad, género y salud ...69 CUIDADOS COMO ESTRATÉGIA DE SOBREVIVÊNCIA HUMANA: Deficiência, gênero e saúde

Daniela Verónica Maza

PERSONAL TRAINER’S CIVIL LIABILITY ...81 RESPONSABILIDADE CIVIL DO PERSONAL TRAINER

Fabrício Germano Alves Mayara Vívian de Medeiros

PRECEDENTS: BETWEEN CLOUDS AND CLOCKS ...96 PRECEDENTES: ENTRE NUVENS E RELÓGIOS

Luís Gustavo Reis Mundim

PHISHING AND SOCIAL ENGINEERING: BETWEEN CRIMINALIZATION AND THE USE OF SOCIAL

MEANS OF PROTECTION ...117 PHISHING E ENGENHARIA SOCIAL: ENTRE A CRIMINALIZAÇÃO E A UTILIZAÇÃO DE MEIOS SOCIAIS DE PROTEÇÃO

Mateus de Oliveira Fornasier Norberto Milton Paiva Knebel Fernanda Viero da Silva

THE JUDICIAL ACTIVISM AND THE WEAKNESS OF POLITICAL POWER:EFFECTIVE CRISIS OR

PARADIGMATIC CHANGE? ...132 O ATIVISMO JUDICIAL E O ENFRAQUECIMENTO DO PODER

POLÍTICO: CRISE EFETIVA OU MUDANÇA PARADIGMÁTICA?

Celio Roberto Correa Doacir Gonçalves de Quadros

THE PROCESS OF DEMARCATION OF TRADITIONAL INDIGENOUS LANDS IN THE

SOUTHERN REGION OF BRAZIL: AN ANALYSIS OF LEGAL AND POLITICAL OBSTACLES ...151 O PROCESSO DE DEMARCAÇÃO DAS TERRAS TRADICIONAIS INDÍGENAS NA REGIÃO

SUL DO BRASIL: UMA ANÁLISE DOS OBSTÁCULOS JURÍDICOS E POLÍTICOS

Pedro Luis locks Justi

(7)

MERITUM MAGAZINE • v.15 • n.1 • Jan./Apr. 2020 Daniel Ribeiro Preve

ACCESS TO THE JURISDICTION OF JUSTICE IN COMPLEX CONFLICTS: CONTRIBUTION OF THE ROMAN EXPERIENCE TO SOLUTIONS BY JUDICIAL PUBLIC HEARING OR EXTRAJUDICIAL

PUBLIC HEARING ...168 ACESSO À JURISDIÇÃO DA JUSTIÇA NOS CONFLITOS COMPLEXOS: CONTRIBUIÇÃO DA EXPERIÊNCIA

ROMANA NA SOLUÇÕES POR AUDIÊNCIA PÚBLICA JUDICIAL OU EXTRAJUDICIAL DELIBERATIVA

José Isaac Pilati Orides Mezzaroba

SOCIAL EUTHANASIA, RIGHT TO HEALTH AND PERSONALITY RIGHTS: A LOOK ON EXTREME

POVERTY ...182 EUTANÁSIA SOCIAL, DIREITO À SAÚDE E OS DIREITOS DA

PERSONALIDADE: UM OLHAR SOBRE A POBREZA EXTREMA

Dirceu Pereira Siqueira Bruna Caroline Lima de Souza

HERMENEUTICS OF THE FAMILY USUCAPTION: ANALYSIS OF THE PRESUPPOSITIONS OF

FAMILY USUCAPTION ACCORDING TO SYSTEMIC INTERPRETATION ...203 HERMENÊUTICA DA USUCAPIÃO FAMILIAR: ANÁLISE DOS PRESSUPOSTOS DA

USUCAPIÃO FAMILIAR A PARTIR DE UMA INTERPRETAÇÃO SISTÊMICA

Hugo Rios Bretas

AN INTRODUCTION TO ECONOMIC ANALYSIS OF LAW ...218 UMA INTRODUÇÃO À ANÁLISE ECONÔMICA DO DIREITO

Rogerio Borba

Rafael de Oliveira Mônaco

FOSTERING INNOVATION FOR MICRO AND SMALL COMPANIES THROUGH ANGEL

INVESTMENT CONTRACTS ...229 FOMENTO ÀS MICRO E PEQUENAS EMPRESAS INOVAÇÃO POR

MEIO DOS CONTRATOS DE INVESTIMENTO-ANJO Elisa Mara Coimbra

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA AND BRAZIL: A STUDY OF THE COMPARATIVE LAW ON THE

IMPLICATIONS IN THE CONSTITUTIONALITY CONTROL ...246 ESTADOS UNIDOS DA AMÉRICA E BRASIL: UM ESTUDO DE DIREITO COMPARADO

SOBRE AS IMPLICAÇÕES NO CONTROLE DE CONSTITUCIONALIDADE

Alexandre Coutinho Pagliarini Amanda Viega Spaller

PRAXIS, SOCIAL MEDIA AND POLITIZATION PROCESS: AN ANALYSIS OF THE NEW SOCIAL

MANIFESTS IN THE LIBERAL DEMOCRACIES ...265 PRÁXIS, REDES SOCIAIS E PROCESSO DE POLITIZAÇÃO: UMA ANÁLISE DAS

NOVAS MANIFESTAÇÕES SOCIAIS PERANTE AS DEMOCRACIAS LIBERAIS

Elísio Augusto Velloso Bastos Bruna Luísa Batista de Barros

CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE POSSIBILITY OF APPLYING RESTORATIVE JUSTICE BY THE

PUBLIC MINISTRY OF LABOR ...284 ANÁLISE CRÍTICA ACERCA DA POSSIBILIDADE DE APLICAÇÃO DA JUSTIÇA

RESTAURATIVA PELO MINISTÉRIO PÚBLICO DO TRABALHO Sandoval Alves da Silva

Camille de Azevedo Alves João Renato Rodrigues Siqueira

(8)

ONTOLOGY OF PRIVACY...307 ONTOLOGIA DA PRIVACIDADE

Sthéfano Bruno Santos Divino

THE MASTER PLAN AND DEMOCRATIC PARTICIPATION IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF PUBLIC

POLICIES FOR THE CITY ...326 O PLANO DIRETOR E A PARTICIPAÇÃO DEMOCRÁTICA NO

DESENVOLVIMENTO DE POLÍTICAS PÚBLICAS PARA A CIDADE Juliana Castro Torres

Juvêncio Borges Silva Paula Martins da Silva Costa

EXECUTIVE TECHNIQUE IN THE CIVIL PROCESS CODE AND ITS LIMITS ...342 A TÉCNICA EXECUTIVA NO CÓDIGO DE PROCESSO CIVIL E SEUS LIMITES

Mateus Schwetter Silva Teixeira

PPGD–FUMEC Dissertations

CONTROLE DE CONSTITUCIONALIDADE E A ILEGITIMIDADE DEMOCRÁTICA DAS

DECISÕES DO SUPREMO TRIBUNAL FEDERAL À LUZ DA TEORIA DE JEREMY WALDRON ...368 Marcelo Matos de Oliveira

O CONTRATO DE NAMORO NA FAMÍLIA EMPRESÁRIA COMO INSTRUMENTO

DE GOVERNANÇA ...369 Uyara Vaz da Rocha Travizani

A POSSIBILIDADE DE CUMULAÇÃO DOS ADICIONAIS DE INSALUBRIDADE

E PERICULOSIDADE ...370 Vítor Ricardo Bhering Braga Junior