&%=5$%$(",12 0, ;$*"2 =,#, #$*!5",0 * =# ) 7, !%, ,5"$#,12 6!(0,%$(",5 (,* %,($&#,* 0$ =$(*,#< ,"!,# $ ,0%&(&*"#,# *$" # =D.5&7 > (,"!#$B, &("$;#,0 #, 0$ " 0 7&75 0$ ;$*"2 < 9!$ 7 ("+% $*"$ &(*"#!%$(" < ,6$", , " 0 * $ "#,(*6 #%, , 7!5"!#, 0,* #;,(&B,1J$*> Z !% =# 7$** 0$ 5 (; =#,B 7 % .$($6A7& * =,#, 6!"!# %$0&," > =,#"&# 0,* $:=$#&8(7&,* 0$ &%=5$%$(",12 0, ;$*"2 =,#, #$*!5",0 * $% ,5;!(* =,A*$*< + = **A)$5 5$),(",# ,* *$;!&("$* 7 (*&0$#,1J$*>
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
;$*"2 =,#, #$*!5",0 * =$#%&"$ &0$("&6&7,# 7 % #$5,"&), 6,7&5&0,0$ ,* 0$.&5&0,0$* 0 *&*"$%, 0$ ;$*"2 < *$% 9!$ &** *&;(&6&9!$ 9!$ *!=$#@I5,* *$?, *!, #$*= (*,.&5&0,0$ $:75!*&),> **&% %$*% < + &(0&*=$(*@)$5 9!$ *$ 7 (?!;!$% !%, *+#&$ 0$ 6," #$* 9!$ =$#%&",% 7 %=#$$(0$# ,* = **&.&5&0,0$* #$,&* 0$ ,),(1 (, &%=5$%$(",12 0$*", 6$##,%$(", $% !% 7$(@#& 0$"$#%&(,0 >
&%=5$%$(",12 0, ;$*"2 =,#, #$*!5",0 * 0$)$ *$# 65$:A)$5< *$% !% % 0$5 #A;&0 , *$# *$;!&0 < ,&(0, 9!$ -,?, !%, 75,#, $*"#!"!#,12 0 =# 7$** 0$ 7#&,12 0$ ),5 # , *$# =# 0!B&0 > #,",I*$ 0$ !% *&*"$%, ,.$#" < 7 % %!&",* ),#&@)$&*< = #",(" < 7,0, ,=5&7,12 0, =# = *", $ 7,0, =# 7$** 0$ &%=5,(",12 *$#2 0&*"&(" * $ $:&; !% 0$*$(- =#E=#& > ,#, 9!$ !* 0, ;$*"2 =,#, #$*!5",0 * *$?, $6$"&) < 7 ()+% 0&*7!"&# ,5;!(* 6," #$* 7#A"&7 * 0$ 8:&" M < RN>
#$*",12 0$ (",* [ 77 !(",.&5&"G\
Conceito de Gestão para Resultados
("# 5$ :"$#( ("# 5$ * 7&,5 0, ;$*"2 =D.5&7, $*"2 $ 7 ("# 5$ 0 =# 7$** 0$ 7#&,12 0$ ),5 # =D.5&7 &75 0$ $*"2 $ ("# 5$ 0, $*"2 # 7$** 0$ #&,12 0$ ,5 # D.5&7 A)$5 #;,(&B,"&) A)$5 7&,5 $ 5A"&7
SV
,N %=# %&** $ ;$*"2 0, %!0,(1,
&%=5,(",12 0, ;$*"2 =,#, #$*!5",0 * 7 %= #", !%, %!0,(1, =# 6!(0, 0, 7!5"!#, ( 7 (?!(" 0, ,0%&(&*"#,12 =D.5&7, $ $% 7,0, #;,(&B,12 (0$ + ,=5&7,0,> !=J$ ",%.+% !%, #$)&*2 0$ " 0 *&*"$%, 0$ ;$*"2 $ *!, ,0,=",12 , $*", ( ), 7!5"!#,> #,",I*$ 0$ !%, "#,(*6 #%,12 =# 6!(0, $ 0$ ;#,(0$ ,57,(7$> (0$=$(0$("$%$("$ 0$ 9!,59!$# !"# 6," #< + ($7$**@#& &(&7&,# =# 7$** , =,#"&# 0$*", =$#*=$7"&), $ 7 % $*"$ 7 %=# %&** >
.N = & $ $() 5)&%$(" 0,* ,!" #&0,0$* = 5A"&7,*
&%=5,(",12 0, ;$*"2 =,#, #$*!5",0 * 0$)$ 7 (",# 7 % !% (A)$5 #,B @)$5 0$ ,= & = 5A"&7 $ 0$ $() 5)&%$(" 0,* ,!" #&0,0$* ( =# 7$** > 5, *$ #&$(", , %$5- #,# , 7,=,7&0,0$ 0,* #;,(&B,1J$* =D.5&7,* =,#, ,57,(7$ 0 * .?$"&) * 0$ ; )$#( < 9!,5 #$9!$# ,= & $ 7 %=# %&** 0 * 6!(7& (@#& * = 5A"&7 * 0 %,&* ,5" (A)$5< * .#$"!0 < =,#, 6 #%!5,# .?$"&) * 9!$ *$?,% )&@)$&* $ %,($?@)$&* %$0&,("$ , ;$*"2 =,#, #$*!5",0 *>
7N (&7&,"&), $ 7 %=# %&** ;$#$(7&,5
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
0N ;$*"2 0 "$%=
* =#,B * =,#, , &%=5,(",12 0, ;$*"2 =,#, #$*!5",0 * 7 % 7!5"!#, $ 6$##,%$(", 0$ ;$*"2 *2 &($)&",)$5%$("$ 5 (; * 0$)&0 , )@#& * 6," #$*K
I , 7 %=5$:&0,0$ 0 "$%, $ , %!5"&=5&7&0,0$ 0$ 6#$("$* 9!$ 0$)$% *$# "#,.,5-,0,*P I , (,"!#$B, 0, %!0,(1, 9!$ + =# = *",P
I 7,#@"$# 7A75&7 $ , 5E;&7, 0$ ,7$#" * $ $## * 9!$ ,7 %=,(-,%P
I , &%=5$%$(",12 +< ( 6!(0 < !% =# 7$** *$% !% 6&(,5 7 (-$7&0 < ?@ 9!$ $*"@ 0&#$",%$("$ $() 5)&0, 7 % , ($7$**&0,0$ 0$ %$5- #,# 7 ("&(!,%$("$ ,* #;,(&B,1J$*< *!,* =$** ,* $ *$!* =# 7$** * 0$ 7#&,12 0$ ),5 #>
&" &** < " #(,I*$ = **A)$5 &0$("&6&7,# 0!,* $",=,* (, &%=5$%$(",12 0 *&*"$%,> =#&%$&#,< $",=, 0$ &%=5,(",12 < = *&7& (, !%, =#&%$&#, )$#*2 0$ " 0 * * 7 %= ($("$* &0$("&6&7,0 * 7 % $**$(7&,&* C ;$*"2 =,#, #$*!5",0 *> *$;!(0,< $",=, 0$ %,"!#,12 $ %$5- #, 7 ("A(!,< 7!=,I*$ 0 ,=# 6!(0,%$(" $ 0$*$() 5)&%$(" 0$ " 0 * $ 7,0, !% 0 * &(*"#!%$(" * $ 0, #$5,12 $("#$ $5$*>
$N 0,=",12 , ,%.&$("$
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
S
6N &*2 ;5 .,5< &%=5,(",12 5 7,5
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
;N $*$() 5)&%$(" $9!&5&.#,0 $ *!*"$("@)$5
0$*$() 5)&%$(" % 0!5,# =# = *" =,#, &%=5$%$(",# , ;$*"2 =,#, #$*!5",0 * = 0$ =# ) 7,# !% 7#$*7&%$(" 0$*$9!&5&.#,0 (0$ ,5;!%,* =,#"$* 0$*$() 5)$%I*$ %,&* 0 9!$ !"#,*< "$(08(7&, 9!$ 0$)$ *$# $)&",0,> ,.$I*$ 9!$ , &%=5$%$(",12 0,* =$1,* $ #$7!#* * 9!$ $*"#!"!#,% , ;$*"2 =,#, #$*!5",0 * = **!$% 0&*"&(" * (A)$&* 0$ 0&6&7!50,0$> 2 + , %$*%, 7 &*, 7 (*"#!&# !% *&*"$%, #1,%$("@#& $ $5,. #,# !% *A"& &(*"&"!7& (,5 (, &("$#($"> $*"#,"+;&, , *$;!&# 7 (*&*"$ $% #&$(",# 0$*$() 5)&%$(" 0, ;$*"2 =,#, #$*!5",0 * $% 0&#$12 C9!$5,* @#$,* (,* 9!,&* *$ $(7 ("#,% %$( * #$*&*"8(7&,*< = **!,% ,* %$5- #$* 6$##,%$(",* $ , %,& # 7,=,7&0,0$ 0$ 0$7&*2 > $)$I*$ "$# $% 7 (", 9!$ , 7,#,7"$#A*"&7, % 0!5,# 0, =# = *", (2 $5&%&(, , ($7$**&0,0$ 0$ *!, ,=5&7,12 &("$;#,5 $ , .!*7, 0$ $9!&5A.#& $% *!,* "#8* 0&%$(*J$* =#&(7&=,&*K ,%.&$("$ &(*"&"!7& (,5 $ * 7&,5< 0$*$() 5)&%$(" #;,(&B,7& (,5 $ 0$*$() 5)&%$(" =# 0!"&) >
-N (@5&*$ $ !* 0, &(6 #%,12
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
&N =#$(0&B,;$% #;,(&B,7& (,5 $ &(0&)&0!,5
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
?N 5,( 0$ "#,.,5- = # #$*!5",0 *
D5"&% 6," # 7#A"&7 9!$ 0$)$ *$# 7 (*&0$#,0 + , ($7$**&0,0$ 0$ *$ $5,. #,# !% =5,( 0$ ,=5&7,12 0, ;$*"2 =,#, #$*!5",0 *< ,&(0, 9!$ (2 $:&*", 7 (*$(* * .#$ *!, &%=5,(",12 > **&%< , "#,(*,12 0$)$#&, *$# .?$" 0$ $:,%$< ,),5&,12 $ #$)&*2 =$#&E0&7 *< 6$#$7$(0 , = #"!(&0,0$ 0$ 0$6&(&# 9!$ 0@ . (* #$*!5",0 * 0 9!$ (2 0@< $ 7 % *$ = 0$#@ %$5- #,# $(6 9!$>
5.1.1 Outputs ou Outcomes?
"+ #$7$("$%$("$< , =$#6 #%,(7$ 0 * =# ;#,%,* $ 0 * ;$#$("$* 0$ =# ;#,%,* $#, ?!5;,0, =$5 * inputs< $% =,#"&7!5,#< (, 6 #%, 7 % * #$7!#* * $#,% ,5 7,0 *> .!# 7#,7&, =D.5&7, 0$) ",), " 0, *!, ,"$(12 , =# 7$** $ C* ,"&)&0,0$* , *$#$% #$,5&B,0,*> ?!*"&6&7,"&), =,#, $**, 6 #%, 0$ 7 ("# 5$< *$;!(0 # *, M N + 9!$ * =,#5,%$(",#$* 9!$#&,% *,.$# (0$ 0&(-$&# =D.5&7 $#, $%=#$;,0 < %,*< “seria essa uma necessidade real dos parlamentares ou uma escapatória confortável, pois, é mais fácil prestar contas do número de pessoal, de lápis ou de créditos para
aquecimento do que da qualidade dos serviços prestados aos cidadãos?” M < K =>
RSN
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outcomes =# 0!B&0 * 7 % ;,*" =D.5&7 < ! *$?,< * .$($6A7& * 9!$ *!#;$% 0, ,"!,12 =D.5&7, , &()+* 0 * =# 7$** * 9!$ *2 !"&5&B,0 *>
)$# 6 7 =,#, outcomes $() 5)$ !%, %!0,(1, (, %,($&#, 0$ =$(*,# $ (, %,($&#, 0$ %$(*!#,#> ** #$9!$# 9!$ * 0&#&;$("$* $ ;$#$("$* "$(-,% $% %$("$ 9!$ $*"2 $(;,?,0 * (,* ,"&)&0,0$* 9!$ =# 0!B$% outputs (2 =,#, *!, *,"&*6,12 &%$0&,",< %,*< =,#, ,57,(7$ 0 * outcomes 9!$ 6 #,% 0$6&(&0 * (, $*"#,"+;&, 0 ; )$#( >
* ,0$=" * 0 * outputs ,#;!%$(",%< 7 ("#, * outcomes ! &%=,7" *< 9!$ $*"$* ;$#,5%$("$ *2 0$6&(&0 * 0$ %,($&#, "2 ;$(+#&7, 9!$ (2 = 0$% *$# %$(*!#,0 * $ 9!$ *$#&, &%= **A)$5 ,"#&.!&# 7!*" * , * %$*% *> !"# ,#;!%$(" !"&5&B,0 + 9!$ * &%=,7" * *2 0$75,#,1J$* 0$ &("$(12 ),;,* $(9!,(" * outputs #$=#$*$(",% =#&%$&# =,** =,#, 7 (-$7&%$(" 0 * #$*!5",0 *< "$(0 $% )&*", 9!$ = 0$% *$# 6&:,0 * .?$"&) * %$(*!#@)$&*>
F@ * ,0$=" * 0 * outcomes ,#;!%$(",% 9!$ )@#&,* ,"&)&0,0$* (2 = 0$% *$# ,(,5&*,0,* $% "$#% * 0$ outputsP 9!$ *E * &%=,7" * 02 !%, &(0&7,12 #$,5 0$ 9!$ * .?$"&) * 6 #,% ,57,(1,0 *P $< 9!$ * &%=,7" * *!*7&",% !%, ( ), 7!5"!#, ( *$" # =D.5&7 < , 7!5"!#, 0, #$*= (*,.&5&0,0$>
* outcomes $*"2 ($7$**,#&,%$("$ &("$#5&;,0 * 7 % *!7$** 0,* = 5A"&7,* =D.5&7,* $5$&",* =,#, *$#$% "#,.,5-,0,* $ " #(,(0 I * $:=5A7&" *< ! *$?,< 0$&:,(0 75,# 9!,&* #$*!5",0 * 0$)$% *$# ,57,(1,0 *< ,!%$(",I*$ , $:&;8(7&, 0$ accountability * .#$ * 0&#&;$("$* 7 % #$5,12 , 9!$ $*"@ *$(0 $("#$;!$ $ , 9!$ 0$)$ *$# $*=$#,0 0, = 5A"&7, =D.5&7, M 33 < N>
# *, M N $5,. # ! !% 9!,0# #$*!% 0,* ),(",;$(* $ 0$*),(",;$(* 0 ;$#$(7&,%$(" ) 5",0 =,#, * outputs $ =,#, * outcomes>
,.$5, ' !,0# #$*!% K outputs $ outcomes ,(",;$(* $*),(",;$(* M ! &(7 ()$(&$("$*N (-$7&%$(" =#@"&7 0 * *$#)&1 * =#$*",0 * $(*!#,12 0 9!$ *$ 6,B %,&* 0 9!$ 9!$ *$ 0$)$#&, 6,B$# $*= (*,.&5&0,0$ 75,#, (7$("#,12 * .#$ 7!#" =#,B %,&* 9!$ ,* $*7 5-,* $("#$ 7!#" < %+0& $ 5 (; =#,B *
!*" * 7,57!5@)$&* $(",5&0,0$ 0$ .$0&8(7&, %,&* 0 9!$ 0$ &( ),12 M6,1 9!$ %$ %,(0,#,% $ (,0, %,&*N Outputs M $#)&1 * #$*",0 *N *=+7&$ 0$ *",(0,#0 %A(&% 0 9!$ 0$)$ *$# 6$&" @ *$("&0 C ,12 0 * 6!(7& (@#& *
* &%=,7" * 6&(,&* *2 0&6A7$&* 0$ %$(*!#,#< $% $*=$7&,5 9!,(0 *2 =# 0!" * 0$ ," #$* ! 0$ 7,!*,* %D5"&=5,*> Z =#$7&* $("2 0$6&(&# &%=,7" * &("$#%$0&@#& * %$(*!#@)$&* $#%&"$ $*",.$5$7$# ,
=$#"&(8(7&, 0 * .?$"&) * $ 0,* $*"#,"+;&,* M%$7,(&*% * 0$ 6$$0.,7LN
#$*= (*,.&5&0,0$ + %,&* 0&6A7&5 0$6&(&# 9!,(0 (2 *$ = 0$ 0$"$#%&(,# !%, =$** , ! !%, $9!&=$ 9!$ "$(-, &(65!8(7&, &%= #",("$ * .#$ &%=,7" ("# 0!B , =$#*=$7"&), 0$ $6$&" * * .#$ 7&0,02 * &%=,7" * (2 = 0$% 6!(7& (,# *$(2 (!% 75&%, 0$ 7 (6&,(1, $("#$ ;$#$("$* $ ,;$("$* $ $("#$ %&(&*"# * $ 6!(7& (@#& * Outcomes M %=,7" *N @ %,&* 7#&,"&)&0,0$ (, $:$7!12 $ = 0$# , * 6!(7& (@#& * 3 ("$K < G5)&$> M K => VVN
$(",(" < , $:=$#&8(7&, =#@"&7, 0$% (*"#, 9!$ 7 (7$&" 0$ outcomes + 0$ 0&6A7&5 =$#,7& (,5&B,12 =,#, , %$(*!#,12 0$ 0$*$%=$(- > Outputs =$#"$(7$% , ) 5!%$ 0$ *$#)&1 * $ = 0$% &(75!&# 7,#,7"$#A*"&7,* 9!,5&","&),*< ",&* 7 % < ,7$** , * *$#)&1 *< , 9!,5&0,0$ 7 % 9!$ * *$#)&1 * *2 =#$*",0 *< , *,"&*6,12 0 * !*!@#& *> Outcomes *2 * &%=,7" * 0,* = 5A"&7,* $ ,1J$* ; )$#(,%$(",&* (, * 7&$0,0$> 7,!*,5&0,0$ $("#$ , = 5A"&7, $ #$*!5",0 + %,&* 6#,7, "$(0 $% )&*", 9!$ * outcomes *$%=#$ 6 #,% =# ) 7,0 * = # 7,!*,* 0&)$#*,*< $*",(0 ,5;!%,* 0$5,* 6 #, 0 7 ("# 5$ ; )$#(,%$(",5>
6 #%, %,&* =# 0!"&),< = #",(" < 0$ 7 %$1,# !% *&*"$%, 0$ ;$#$(7&,%$(" 0$ 0$*$%=$(- + &0$("&6&7,(0 * outputs ! *$#)&1 * *$(0 =# 0!B&0 * ,("$* 0$ 7 %$1,# "$(",(0 0$6&(&# outcomes ,** 7&,0 * , * .?$"&) *>
5.1.2 Incentivos
9!$*"2 0 * &(7$("&) * + 0$ 6!(0,%$(",5 &%= #"Q(7&, 9!,(0 *$ "#,", 0$ ;$*"2 =,#, #$*!5",0 *> !$ &(7$("&) * "8% * ,;$("$* $ * ;$#$("$* =,#, #$,5&B,# * $*6 #1 * *!=5$%$(",#$* $:&;&0 * =$5, % 0$#(&B,12 W !,5 &("$#$**$ 0$5$* $% %!0,#W
**, + !%, 9!$*"2 7 %=5$:, 9!$< %!&",* )$B$*< 0$&:, 0$ *$# $(6#$(",0,< ,7,.,(0 = # 5$),# , 6#,7,** " 0 % 0$5 > ,0, =,A* "$(0$ , ,0 ",# !% *&*"$%, 0$ &(7$("&) *< 0$=$(0$(0 0, 7!5"!#, $:&*"$("$> * =,A*$* ,(;5 I*,:J$* *&*"$%, %,&* ,0 ",0 + 0$ *,(1J$* $ #$7 %=$(*,* $(9!,(" (, 3#,(1, #;!5- =# 6&**& (,5 + %,&* &(7$("&),0 M < N> 9!$ + 7 %!% , * 0&)$#* * =,A*$* + , 7 (*7&8(7&, 0$ 9!$ 0$)$ -,)$# !% $9!&5A.#& $("#$ $*6 #1 $ ,
#$7 %=$(*,< ! , *,(12 > 4@ !%, ;,%, 0$ &(7$("&) * 9!$ = 0$% *$# !"&5&B,0 *< ",&* 7 % < =,#"&5-, 0$ ;,(- * 0$ =# 0!"&)&0,0$< #;!5- =# 6&**& (,5 $ ,!" ( %&, 0$ ,12 < =# ;#$**J$* (, 7,##$&#,< $"7>
5.2 Orçamento por Resultados
40$6&($ #1,%$(" = # #$*!5",0 * 7 % *$(0 , #$5,12 $("#$ , ,5 7,12 0$ #$7!#* * 7 % .,*$ (, %$(*!#,12 0$ #$*!5",0 * $% "$#% * 0$ outputs $ ! outcomes> 5, 0$6$(0$ ,&(0, 9!$ (2 -@ ,=$(,* !% % 0$5 , *$# ,0 ",0 $ 9!$ -@ !%, 0&)$#*&0,0$ 0$ $:=$#&8(7&,* ($**$ *$("&0 >
,#, ,(7 !(0&,5 #1,%$(" = # #$*!5",0 * + !* ,=# =#&,0 0$ &(6 #%,1J$* * .#$ , =$#6 #%,(7$ = # ," #$* 7-,)$* $% 7,0, $*"@;& 0 7&75 #1,%$("@#& )&*,(0 0,# 7 (*&*"8(7&, , *!,* 0$7&*J$* * .#$ , ,5 7,12 0$ #$7!#* * $ =,#, =# % )$# , $6&7&8(7&, 0 !* 0 * #$7!#* *> F@ =,#, 7 "" M VN + "#,.,5- 0$ !% *&*"$%, #1,%$("@#& 9!$ =# % )$ %$5- #&,* ( 0$*$%=$(- = # %$& 0$ *$!* 7 %= ($("$*>
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
9!$ " 0,* ,* "$(","&),* 0$ &("# 0!12 0 #1,%$(" = # #$*!5",0 * "8% $% 7 %!% + , ) (",0$ 0$ ,!%$(",# , &(65!8(7&, 0, ,(@5&*$ 0,* = 5A"&7,* =D.5&7,*< 0,* $*"#,"+;&,* 0$ *!= #"$ ,* 0$7&*J$* $ 0,* &(6 #%,1J$* * .#$ 0$*$%=$(- ( *&*"$%, #1,%$("@#& > =#&(7&=,5 .?$"&) 0 #1,%$(" = # #$*!5",0 * + , %$5- #&, 0, 9!,5&0,0$ 0 ;,*" =D.5&7 = # %$& 0, %$5- # ,5 7,12 0$ #$7!#* *< %,("$(0 , 7 (*&*"8(7&, 7 % * .?$"&) * = 5A"&7 * $ * 7&,&*< ,5+% 0$ %$5- #,# , $6&7&8(7&, 0 !* 0 * #$7!#* *>
(6 #%,1J$* * .#$ 0$*$%=$(- 0,* #;,(&B,1J$* $(7 #,?,% !%, %,& # 8(6,*$ ( =5,($?,%$(" $ 6$#$7$% !%, . , &(0&7,12 0 9!$ $*"@ 6!(7& (,(0 $ 0 9!$ (2 $*"@> *", 6$##,%$(", ",%.+% =$#%&"$ !% ,!%$(" 0, "#,(*=,#8(7&,< 6$#$7$(0 %,&* $ %$5- # &(6 #%,12 =,#, = 0$# 5$;&*5,"&) $ =,#, =D.5&7 >
% 0&" ,("$#& #%$("$< (2 -@ !%, 0$6&(&12 =,0#2 =,#, 9!$ *$?, #1,%$(" = # #$*!5",0 *< ($% * .#$ "&= 0$ &(6 #%,12 9!$ $5$ &(75!& ! $% 9!$ $*"@;& 0 =# 7$** 0 #1,%$(" 9!$ $5, 0$)$ *$# &("# 0!B&0,> 4@ ",%.+% , 9!$*"2 0$ (0$ ,* &(6 #%,1J$* * .#$ 0$*$%=$(- 0$)$% *$# !*,0,* =,#, , " %,0, 0$ 0$7&*2 * .#$ 7 % 0&*"#&.!&# * #$7!#* *>
, )$#0,0$< ,* =#&(7&=,&* 7,#,7"$#A*"&7,* 9!$ 0&6$#$(7&,% #1,%$(" = # #$*!5",0 * 0 * *&*"$%,* #1,%$("@#& * "#,0&7& (,&* *2 K
I %,& # 6 7 0,0 =$5 #1,%$(" = # #$*!5",0 * , ,57,(7$ 0 * .?$"&) * 0 * =# ;#,%,* =D.5&7 * $ *$! ,5&(-,%$(" 7 % ,* = 5A"&7,* ; )$#(,%$(",&*P $
I , 8(6,*$ (, #$*= (*,.&5&B,12 0 * 0&#&;$("$* #$*= (*@)$&* =$5, $("#$;, 0 * *$#)&1 * =D.5&7 *< *$;!&0, 0$ !%, %!0,(1, ( 7 ("# 5$ 0 * ;,*" * =D.5&7 *< 9!$ 0$&:, 0$ *$# ( * &"$(* 0$ 0$*=$*, $ =,**, , *$# ",(" * .#$ * #$*!5",0 * 9!,(" * .#$ !* 0 * #$7!#* * ,5 7,0 *>
2
"$#% Performance Budget !"&5&B,0 (, 5&"$#,"!#, 0$ 5A(;!, &(;5$*, 6 & "#,0!B&0 =,#, = #"!;!8* 7 % [ #1,%$(" = # $*!5",0 *\>
S
, ,(@5&*$ 0,* ,=5&7,1J$* 0 #1,%$(" = # #$*!5",0 * 6 & = **A)$5 0$6&(&# "#8* "&= * 0&)$#* * 0$
%+" 0 M < VNK
I #1,%$(" = # #$*!5",0 * =,#, ,=#$*$(",12 K *&;(&6&7, *&%=5$*%$("$ 9!$ ,* &(6 #%,1J$* * .#$ 0$*$%=$(- *2 ,=#$*$(",0,* ( * 0 7!%$(" * #1,%$("@#& *> * &(6 #%,1J$* = 0$% #$6$#&#I *$ , %$",* ! #$*!5",0 *< ! ,%. *< $ *2 &(75!A0,* 7 % &(6 #%,1J$* 7 %=5$%$(",#$* =,#, , accountability $ 0&@5 ; 7 % = 0$# 5$;&*5,"&) $ * 7&0,02 * &("$#$**,0 *> **,* &(6 #%,1J$* (2 *2 7 (*&0$#,0,* =,#, , " %,0, 0$ 0$7&*2 >
I #1,%$(" 7 % &(6 #%,1J$* * .#$ 0$*$%=$(- K * #$7!#* * *2 &(0&#$",%$("$ #$5,7& (,0 * 7 % 0$*$%=$(- 6!"!# =# = *" ! 7 % 0$*$%=$(- ."&0 > * &(6 #%,1J$* * .#$ 0$*$%=$(- *2 &%= #",("$* ( =# 7$** 0$ " %,0, 0$ 0$7&*2 #1,%$("@#&, %,* (2 0$"$#%&(,% , 9!,("&0,0$ 0$ #$7!#* * ,5 7,0 * $ (2 "8% !% =$* =#$0$6&(&0 (,* 0$7&*J$*> * &(6 #%,1J$* * .#$ 0$*$%=$(- *2 !*,0,* $% 7 (?!(" 7 % !"#,* &(6 #%,1J$* ( =# 7$** 0$ " %,0, 0$ 0$7&*J$*>
I #1,%$(" = # #$*!5",0 * 0&#$" K $() 5)$ , ,5 7,12 0$ #$7!#* * .,*$,0, ( ,57,(7$ 0$ #$*!5",0 *> *", 6 #%, 0$ #1,%$(" = # #$*!5",0 * + !"&5&B,0, ,=$(,* $% *$" #$* $*=$7A6&7 * =,#, !% 5&%&",0 (D%$# 0$ =,A*$* 0, > # $:$%=5 < (D%$# 0$ $*"!0,("$* 9!$ 7 (75!A#,% %$*"#,0 0$"$#%&(,#@ , 9!,("&0,0$ 0$ #$7!#* * , *$# ,5 7,0 =,#, =# ;#,%, 0$ %$*"#,0 0 =#E:&% ,( >
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accoutability>
3&:,0 * * .?$"&) *< * =,A*$* "&)$#,% 9!$ 0$7&0&# 7 % &("$;#,# ,* &(6 #%,1J$* * .#$ 0$*$%=$(- 7 % #1,%$(" $ 7 % *$!* *&*"$%,* 0$ ;$*"2 > 5;!(* =,A*$* &("# 0!B&#,% ,* #$6 #%,* = # %$& 0$ 5$&*< 7 % ( 7,* 0 * *",0 * (&0 *> 5$& ;,#,("$ ,5;!% ;#,! 0$ =$#%,(8(7&,< 6,B$(0 7 % 9!$ *$?, %,&* 6@7&5 =# ?$" 7 ("&(!,# $% 7,* 0$ ,5"$#,1J$* 0 ; )$#( > !"# * =,A*$*< 7 % $&( (&0 < *&%=5$*%$("$ !"&5&B,% #$9!$#&%$(" * 6 #%,&* $ ;!&,* =# 0!B&0 * =$5 * %&(&*"+#& * 7$("#,&*>
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
#1,%$(" + !% *&*"$%, 9!$ =# 0!B $ "# 7, &(6 #%,1J$* =$#"$(7$("$* C* 6&(,(1,* ; )$#(,%$(",&*> ,#, %!0,# , 6 #%, 7 % #1,%$(" + 6$&" < + ($7$**@#& ,5"$#,# *$! 7 ("$D0 &(6 #%,7& (,5 $ *!, $*"#!"!#,> ,#, &%=5$%$(",# #1,%$(" = # #$*!5",0 * + ($7$**@#& &(*$#&# &(6 #%,1J$* * .#$ * #$*!5",0 * ( #1,%$(" $ ,"#$5,# $**,* ( ),* &(6 #%,1J$* 7 % * ;,*" * =D.5&7 *>
#1,%$(" = # #$*!5",0 * + ( #%,5%$("$ $5,. #,0 &("# 0!B&(0 I*$ 0,0 * * .#$ , =$#6 #%,(7$ ( 7 (?!(" 0$ &(6 #%,1J$* ?@ $:&*"$("$* ( #1,%$(" > 9!$ ,7,., 7 ##$(0 + , * .#$7,#;, 0$ &(6 #%,1J$* 0$**$ *&*"$%,> % #1,%$(" + !% =# 7$** 9!$ 0$)$ 7!%=#&# =#,B * 5$;,&*< 6$#$7$# %,&* 0,0 * =,#, ,* =$** ,* 9!$ "#,.,5-,% 7 % $5$ (2 *&;(&6&7, 6$#$7$# %,&* "$%= =,#, 9!$ $5$* "#,.,5-$% ,* &(6 #%,1J$*> **$ + !% =# .5$%, 9!$ 0$)$ *$# #$* 5)&0 >
!"# =# .5$%, + 7!*" 0, &(6 #%,12 < ! *$?,< #1,%$(" = # #$*!5",0 * *$%=#$ ,!%$(", 7!*" 0, ;$#,12 $ 0 =# 7$**,%$(" 0 #1,%$(" > !,(" %,&* ,%.&7& * *&*"$%, 6 #< $% "$#% * 0$ ,.#,(;8(7&,< 6 7 ( * outcomes $ &("$;#,12 0$ *$!* )@#& * 7 %= ($("$* $% !%, $*"#!"!#, 0$ ,),5&,12 0 =5,($?,%$(" &("$;#,0 C =# ;#,%,12 #1,%$("@#&,< %,&* 7,# $5$ *$#@>
% = (" %!&" &%= #",("$ , *$# .*$#),0 + 9!$ =,#, 9!$ ,* &(6 #%,1J$* ;$#,0,* =$5 #1,%$(" = # #$*!5",0 * *$?,% D"$&*< $5,* 0$)$% *$# #$,5%$("$ !"&5&B,0,* 9!,(0 0, " %,0, 0$ 0$7&*2 > 0&*"Q(7&, $("#$ , =# 0!12 $ !* 0, &(6 #%,12 + $*=$7&,5%$("$ ;#,(0$ 9!,(0 0$*$%=$(- $*"@ 7 % =# .5$%,* $ #1,%$(" = # #$*!5",0 * + #,=&0,%$("$ 0$*,7#$0&",0 6,B$(0 7 % 9!$ ,* !(&0,0$* #1,%$("@#&,* =$#7$.,% 9!$ ,* 0$7&*J$* (2 *2 " %,0,* 7 % .,*$ ( * #$*!5",0 * %,* *$;!(0 ( #%,* &(7#$%$(",&*>
% #$*!% < #1,%$(" = # #$*!5",0 * *E *$#@ $6$"&) $% ; )$#( * .$% ;$#$(7&,0 * 9!$ "8% .,&: * (A)$&* 0$ 7 ##!=12 < $5$),0 * (A)$&* 0$ 7 (6&,(1, =D.5&7,< *$#)&1 * =D.5&7 * $6&7&$("$* $ , %A0&, $ ;#!= * 0$ &("$#$**$* =#$ 7!=,0 * 7 % * #$*!5",0 * ; )$#(,%$(",&*> !,(0 $**,* 7 (0&1J$* $*"2 ,!*$("$*< *&*"$%, 0$ #1,%$(" = # #$*!5",0 * (2 "$#@ *!7$** >
Z 6!(0,%$(",5< ",%.+%< $% 9!,59!$# *&*"$%, 0$ ;$#$(7&,%$(" 0$ 0$*$%=$(- < , 0$6&(&12 0 9!$ *&;(&6&7, %$5- #$* #$*!5",0 * $ 0$ 9!,&* ,?!*"$* = 0$% *$# 6$&" * =,#, ,57,(1@I5 *> !,&* *2 ,* %$",* , *$#$% ,57,(1,0,* $ 7 % $5,* 0$)$% *$# 0$6&(&0,*W %,& #&, 0 * $*"!0 * 7 (7 #0, 9!$ + ($7$**@#& !% 7 ("# 5$ (2 0 * inputs, %,* *&%< 0 * outputs $ outcomes> ,* -@ ,9!$5$* 9!$ ,#;!%$(",% 9!$ 7 ("# 5$ 0 * outputs ,&(0, + &(*,"&*6,"E#& 7 % !%, %$0&0, 0$ 0$*$%=$(- = #9!$ = 0$ -,)$# 0&*" #1J$* $ 9!$ * outcomes *$#&,% ,* %$",* 0$*$?@)$&* , *$#$% .*$#),0,*>
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
9!$ 0$)$ 6&7,# 75,# + 9!$ ,=$*,# 0 * 0$*,6& *< * .$($6A7& * = "$(7&,&* 0 !* 0$ &(6 #%,1J$* * .#$ 0$*$%=$(- ( =# 7$** #1,%$("@#& + *&;(&6&7,"&) < = &*< , 8(6,*$ ( * #$*!5",0 * =#$**!=J$ !%, %,& # 8(6,*$ (, 6&:,12 0$ .?$"&) * 0$ 6 #%, 75,#, $ "#,(*=,#$("$ $ , =#$*",12 0$ 7 (",* * .#$ 9!$ $*"@ 6!(7& (,(0 $ 9!$ (2 $*"@>
6.1 Antecedentes
6.1.1 A Reforma Gerencial de 1995
$6 #%, $#$(7&,5 "$% &(A7& < ( #,*&5< 7 % ; )$#( 0 #$*&0$("$ 3$#(,(0 4$(#&9!$ ,#0 * > 7 ("$:" 0, += 7, $*"@ 5&;,0 , =$#A 0 0$ ;5 .,5&B,12 %!(0&,5 $ C 0&**$%&(,12 0, &0+&, 0$ #$6 #%, ;$#$(7&,5 $% )@#& * =,A*$*> =#&(7&=,5 =# =E*&" 0, #$6 #%, + , ,0 12 0$ !% =,0#2 ;$#$(7&,5 ( Q%.&" 0, ,0%&(&*"#,12 =D.5&7,< &(*=&#,0, ( * &0$,&* 0, ), $*"2
D.5&7, M5ew Public Management), $% $*=$7&,5 , 0$*",7,0, #&$(",12 , #$*!5",0 *>
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
D75$ $*"#,"+;&7 K 0$6&(&12 0$ 5$&* $ 0$ = 5A"&7,* =D.5&7,*< $ 7 .#,(1, 0$ *$! 7!%=#&%$(" P
"&)&0,0$* $:75!*&),*K ,9!$5,* 9!$ *2 &(0$5$;@)$&* $ 9!$< =,#, *$! $:$#7A7& < + ($7$**@#& = 0$# 0$ *",0 P
"&)&0,0$* (2 I$:75!*&),*K ,9!$5,* 0$ ,5", #$5$)Q(7&,< $% 9!$ *",0 ,"!, *&%!5",($,%$("$ 7 % !"#,* #;,(&B,1J$* =#&),0,* $ 0 "$#7$&# *$" # (, =#$*",12 0$ *$#)&1 * * 7&,&*P
# 0!12 0$ .$(* $ *$#)&1 * , %$#7,0 K 9!$ 7 ##$*= (0$ , *$" # 0$ &(6#,I$*"#!"!#,< (0$ ,"!,% ,* $%=#$*,*< =D.5&7,* ! =#&),0,*< #$;!5,0,* =$5 ; )$#( < = #",(" 7 % "$(08(7&,* C =#&),"&B,12 >
* .?$"&) * ;5 .,&*< *$;!(0 5,( &#$" # 0, $6 #%, 0 =,#$5- 0 *",0 M < N $#,%K
I ,!%$(",# , ; )$#(,(1, 0 *",0 < ! *$?,< *!, 7,=,7&0,0$ ,0%&(&*"#,"&), 0$ ; )$#(,# 7 % $6$"&)&0,0$ $ $6&7&8(7&,< ) 5",(0 , ,12 0 *",0 =,#, ,"$(0&%$(" 0 * 7&0,02 *P
I 5&%&",# , ,12 0 *",0 C9!$5,* 6!(1J$* 9!$ 5-$ *2 =#E=#&,*< #$*$#),(0 < $% =#&(7A=& < * *$#)&1 * (2 I$:75!*&) * =,#, , =# =#&$0,0$ =D.5&7, (2 I$*",",5< $ , =# 0!12 0$ .$(* $ *$#)&1 * =,#, %$#7,0 =,#, , &(&7&,"&), =#&),0,P
I "#,(*6$#&# 0, (&2 =,#, * $*",0 * $ %!(&7A=& * ,* ,1J$* 0$ 7,#@"$# 5 7,5K *E $% 7,* * 0$ $%$#;8(7&, 7,.$ , ,12 0&#$", 0, (&2 P
T
I "#,(*6$#&# =,#7&,5%$("$ 0, (&2 =,#, * $*",0 * ,* ,1J$* 0$ 7,#@"$# #$;& (,5< 0$ 6 #%, , =$#%&"&# !%, %,& # =,#7$#&, $("#$ * $*",0 * $ , (&2 >
* =#&(7&=,&* %!0,(1,* 9!$ 0$)$#&,% 7 ##$# $#,%K &(*"&"!7& (,5I5$;,&* I , #$% 12 0 * .*"@7!5 * 0$ (,"!#$B, 7 (*"&"!7& (,5 $ 0$ !"# * #0$(,%$(" *P 7!5"!#,&* I , *!.*"&"!&12 0, 7!5"!#, .!# 7#@"&7, 0 %&(,("$ =$5, ( ), 7!5"!#, ;$#$(7&,5P 0$ ;$*"2 I , &%=5$%$(",12 0, #$6 #%, = # %$& 0, ,0 12 0$ ( ) * ,##,(? * &(*"&"!7& (,&*< ( ),* 7 %=$"8(7&,* $ &(*"#!%$(" * ;$#$(7&,&* %,&* ,0$9!,0 *>
* =#&(7&=,&* &(&7&,"&),* #$,5&B,0,* 6 #,%K M,N , $6 #%, (*"&"!7& (,5 7 % , ,=# ),12 0, %$(0, (a 0$ V 9!$ &("# 0!B&!< 0$("#$ !"# *K , 65$:&.&5&B,12 0, $*",.&5&0,0$ 0 *$#)&0 # =D.5&7 < , ,),5&,12 0$ 0$*$%=$(- =$#&E0&7,< ,!%$(" 0 =$#A 0 0$ $*"@;& =# .,"E#& < #$;&%$ 0$ $%=#$; =D.5&7 < , 6&:,12 0$ "$" * #$%!($#,"E#& *< =#&(7A=& 0, $6&7&8(7&,< , ,%=5&,12 0,* ,!" ( %&,* $ , #$7 %$(0,12 0, 7#&,12 0$ $*7 5,* 0$ ; )$#( ( * *",0 *P M.N , &(*"&"!&12 0 &(*"#!%$(" 0 * 7 ("#," * 0$ ;$*"2 7 % , 7#&,12 0,* ;8(7&,* :$7!"&),* M $& (a T 0$ VN $ 0 # ;#,%, ,7& (,5 0$ !.5&7&B,12 9!$ 7#& ! , 6&;!#, 0,* I #;,(&B,1J$* 7&,&* M $& (a TSR 0$ VN> 7,* 0,* ,;8(7&,* *,50 6 & 0$ ,=$(,* !% 7 ("#," 7$5$.#,0 M7 % N $ ( 7,* 0 # ;#,%, 0$ !.5&7&B,12 6 #,% 9!,5&6&7,0,* 7 % < , M 9!$"$ &(" N< ,5;!(* &(*"&"!" * ( Q%.&" 0 &(&*"+#& 0$ &8(7&, $ $7( 5 ;&, ",&* 7 % (*"&"!" ,%&#,!@< , < , !* $ , P M7N , 7#&,12 0 # ;#,%, 0$ !,5&0,0$ $ ,#"&7&=,12 9!$ &(*"&"!& #8%& 0$ !,5&0,0$ 0 )$#( 3$0$#,5P M0N , ), 5A"&7, 0$ $7!#* * 4!%,( * 9!$ =$#%&"&! , #$" %,0, 0$ 7 (7!#* * =D.5&7 *< , #$)&*2 0,* 7,##$&#,* M=,#, 6,7&5&",# #$%,($?,%$(" *N< , #$)&*2 0, = 5A"&7, #$%!($#,"E#&, 0$ (A)$5 *!=$#& # $ !%, ( ), = 5A"&7, 0$ 7,=,7&",12 M#$)&; #,%$(" 0, N>
6.1.2 Diagnóstico do Estado de Minas Gerais
&(A7& 0 * ,( * < , *&"!,12 0, %,& #&, 0 * $*",0 * 6$0$#,0 *< &(75!*&)$ 0$ &(,* $#,&*< $() 5)&, !% ,;#,),%$(" 0, 7#&*$ 6&*7,5< $*; ",%$(" 0 % 0$5 .!# 7#@"&7 $ !% 7#$*7$("$ 0+6&7&" 0$ 0$*$%=$(- $% "$#% * 0$ 9!,("&0,0$ $ 9!,5&0,0$ 0 * *$#)&1 * =#$*",0 * C * 7&$0,0$>
$;!(0 $*"!0 0$*$() 5)&0 =$5 M N< ,* 0&6&7!50,0$* 6&(,(7$&#,* 0 * $*",0 * .#,*&5$&# * "8% &(A7& ( * ,( * V < 9!,(0 ,* 6&(,(1,* $*",0!,&* * 6#$#,% 7 % , #$0!12 (, ,##$7,0,12 < 7 % ,!%$(" 0 * ?!# * $ 7 % , 9!$0, 0 * &()$*"&%$(" * 6$0$#,&* $ 0,* $%=#$*,* $*",",&*> 5,0 0,* 0$*=$*,*< * &(7#$%$(" * ( * ;,*" * 0$ =$** ,5 $ ( 0+6&7&" =#$)&0$(7&@#& *$ #$)$5,#,%< =#&(7&=,5%$("$ (, 0+7,0, 0$ < =#&(7&=,5 6 ("$ 0$ 0$*$9!&5A.#& (,* 7 (",* =D.5&7,* $*",0!,&*>
% 6,7$ 0,* 0&6&7!50,0$* 6&*7,&* $ 6&(,(7$&#,*< 0&)$#*,* %$0&0,* 6 #,% ,0 ",0,* = # ,5;!(* $*",0 * ( &("!&" 0$ %$5- #,# ,* 7 (",* =D.5&7,*> 0,)&,< , "#,?$"E#&, *$;!&0, = # $5$* (2 6 & !(&6 #%$< 7 % ,5;!(* ,),(1,(0 %,&* 0 9!$ !"# *> &(,* $#,&*< ,5+% 0$ (2 "$# 6$&" ,?!*"$* *&;(&6&7,"&) *< * 6#&, = # "$# !%, 0A)&0, %!&" *!=$#& # C %+0&, (,7& (,5> < =,#, =& #,# , *&"!,12 < *$! ,=,#," 0$ =5,($?,%$(" $ 6 %$(" 7 %$1 ! , =$#0$# *!.*"Q(7&, $ $6$"&)&0,0$>
$)&0 , ;#,(0$ $(0&)&0,%$(" $ , $(;$**,%$(" 0,* 0$*=$*,*< =#&(7&=,5%$("$ ( " 7,("$ , 6!(7& (,5&*% $ &(,"&) *< *",0 6&7 ! =#,"&7,%$("$ *$% #$7!#* * =,#, !"# * 7!*"$& * $ =,#, &()$*"&%$(" *< 9!$ ,7,. ! *$(0 !% .*"@7!5 C $6&7&8(7&, 0, %@9!&(, =D.5&7,>
&(,* $#,&* "$#&, 9!$ $(6#$(",# $**, *&"!,12 =,#, 9!$ , #$6 #%!5,12 0, %@9!&(, =D.5&7, =!0$**$ *$# 6$&",> $)$#&, =# % )$# ,?!*"$ $% *!,* 6&(,(1,* =D.5&7,*< #$$9!&5&.#,(0 #$7$&", $ 0$*=$*,< ,09!&#&(0 7,=,7&0,0$ %A(&%, 0$ &()$*"&%$(" $ 7!*"$& < ( 7!#" =#,B < $ $9!,7& (,(0 , * 5!12 =,#, , 7 (", 0 * &(,"&) *> $ &** (2 6 **$ 6$&" < = !7 5-$ #$*",#&, , 6,B$# ( " 7,("$ , 0$*$() 5)&%$(" M < N>
$9!&5A.#& 0,* 6&(,(1,* =D.5&7,* $*",0!,&* + !%, 7 (0&12 ($7$**@#&, =,#, , #$6 #%!5,12 0, %@9!&(, =D.5&7,< %,*< (2 + *!6&7&$("$< ?@ 9!$ *",0 0$)$ #$6 #%!5,#I*$ =,#, ,"$(0$# C* 0$%,(0,* 0 ( ) 0$*$() 5)&%$(" > !"#,* %$0&0,*< = #",(" < 0$)$#&,% *$# 7 ("$%=5,0,*<
R
$("#$ $5,*< , ( ), 0&)&*2 0$ "#,.,5- $("#$ = 0$# =D.5&7 $ =#&),0 P &%=$#,"&) 0, ;$*"2 $6&7&$("$ 0,* 7 &*,* =D.5&7,*P , 0$*7$("#,5&B,12 < $% =,#"$< 0 * *$#)&1 * =D.5&7 *P $ ,* $:&;8(7&,* 0$ ,.$#"!#, 0$ $*=,1 * 0$ =,#"&7&=,12 =,#, , ,"!,12 0 * *$" #$* #;,(&B,0 * 0, * 7&$0,0$ 7&)&5>
$*"$ % 0 < "$%, 0, . , ;$*"2 ,**!%&! =,=$5 #$5$),("$ $ 6 & (0$ *!#;&! , &0+&, 0$ !% 7- 9!$< ! *$?,< !% 7 (?!(" 0$ %$0&0,* 0$ #@=&0 &%=,7" =,#, % 0&6&7,#< 0$ )$B< =,0#2 0$ 7 %= #",%$(" 0, ,0%&(&*"#,12 $*",0!,5< 0$ 6 #%, , ;,#,("&# !%, ;$*"2 %,&* $6&7&$("$< $6$"&),
$ $6&7,B M < TN>