Indicadores de Desempenho

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

,#, !, M N * &(0&7,0 #$* (2 *2 *&%=5$*%$("$ 0,0 *< %,* !%, .,5,(1, 9!$ ( * =$#%&"$ =$*,# * 0,0 * ! !%, #+;!,< 9!$ ( * =$#%&"$ ,6$#&# * 0,0 * $% "$#% * 0$ 9!,5&0,0$< #$*!5",0 < &%=,7" < $"7>< 0 * =# 7$** * $ 0 * .?$"&) * 0 * $)$(" *> * &(0&7,0 #$* *2 %$0&0,*< ! *$?,< *2 !%, ,"#&.!&12 0$ (D%$# * , .?$" *< ,7 ("$7&%$(" * ! *&"!,1J$*< 0$ ,7 #0 7 % 7$#",* #$;#,*>

$;!(0 M N * &(0&7,0 #$* 0$ 0$*$%=$(- *2 %$0&0,* 9!$ 0$*7#$)$% 9!2

.$% $*"2 *$ 0$*$() 5)$(0 * .?$"&) * 0$ !% =# ;#,%,< !% =# ?$" $ ! , ;$*"2 0, &(*"&"!&12 >

% &(0&7,0 # = 0$ *$# $("$(0&0 7 % !%, $:=#$**2 9!$ *&("$"&B, &(6 #%,12 9!,("&","&), $ ! 9!,5&","&), * .#$ ,5;!% 6$(X%$( #$5$),("$> &(0&7,0 # &(0&7, ! *&(,5&B,< =$#%&"&(0 7,#,7"$#&B,# ,1J$*< ,"&)&0,0$*< $6$&" * 9!$ 0$)$% *$# 0$*7#&",* $% !% =# 7$** 0$ % (&" #,%$(" $ ,),5&,12 M / < N>

*$" # =D.5&7 < 0$ !%, 6 #%, ;$#,5< * &(0&7,0 #$* = 0$% *$# )&*" * 7 % 6$##,%$(",* 9!$ $("#$;,% &(6 #%,1J$* 9!,("&","&),* , #$*=$&" 0 (A)$5 0$ *!7$** ,57,(1,0 = # !% =# ;#,%, =D.5&7 < = 0$(0 7 .#&# ,*=$7" * 9!,("&","&) * ! 9!,5&","&) *> Z !%, $:=#$**2 9!$ $*",.$5$7$

!%, #$5,12 $("#$ 0!,* ! %,&* ),#&@)$&*< 9!$ 7 %=,#,0,* 7 % =$#A 0 * ,("$#& #$*< =# 0!" * *&%&5,#$* ! 7 % !%, %$", =#+I$*",.$5$7&0, =$#%&"$ ,),5&,# 0$*$%=$(- >

(6 #%$ $:=5&7&",0 =$5 %,(!,5 0$ &(0&7,0 #$* 0$ 0$*$%=$(- ( *$" # =D.5&7 M < N< * Q%.&" * 0$ 7 ("# 5$ = **A)$&* 0$ *$#$% %$(*!#,0 * 7 % !* 0$ &(0&7,0 #$* *2 * &(*!% * MinputsN< * =# 7$** *< * =# 0!" * MoutputsN< * #$*!5",0 * 6&(,&* MoutcomesN>

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

* &(0&7,0 #$* 0$ =# 0!" * % *"#,% * .$(* $ *$#)&1 * =# 0!B&0 * 0$ %,($&#, 9!,("&","&),> Z #$*!5",0 0$ !%, 7 %.&(,12 $*=$7A6&7, 0$ &(*!% * 9!$ ;$#,% * #$*=$7"&) * =# 0!" *> # *& *E !% &(0&7,0 # 0$ =# 0!" (2 0@ 7 (", 0$ 7 (6&#%,# ,57,(7$ 0 * .?$"&) * 0 =# ;#,%, ! , 9!,("&0,0$ 0$ #$7!#* * &()$*"&0 * (, ;$#,12 0 * %$*% *>

* &(0&7,0 #$* 0$ #$*!5",0 * 6&(,&* M ! &%=,7" *N *2 #$*!5",0 * #$5,7& (,0 * 7 % =# =E*&" ! 6&% D5"&% 0, $("#$;, 0$ .$(* $ *$#)&1 * $ *&;(&6&7,% !%, %$5- #, *&;(&6&7,"&), (,* 7 (0&1J$* ! 7,#,7"$#A*"&7,* 0, = =!5,12 > % #$*!5",0 6&(,5 + !% .$($6A7& 0$ %+0& $ 5 (; =#,B ."&0 =$5, = =!5,12 ,"$(0&0,>

%$0&12 0, ;$*"2 0$ !%, &(*"&"!&12 #$9!$# 0$*$() 5)&%$(" 0$ !% 7 (?!(" -,#%X(&7 $ *&*"$%@"&7 0$ &(0&7,0 #$* 9!$ ,.,#9!$%< 7 % !% ,0$9!,0 7 (-$7&%$(" 0$ *!,* = **A)$&* &("$#I#$5,1J$*< ,* 0&%$(*J$* 0$ $7 ( %&,< $6&7&8(7&,< $6&7@7&, $ 9!,5&0,0$ 0 *$#)&1

M 4 < SN>

$7 ( %&, $*"@ #$5,7& (,0, 7 % , 7,=,7&0,0$ 0$ , &(*"&"!&12 ;$#,# $ % .&5&B,# ,0$9!,0,%$("$ * #$7!#* * 6&(,(7$&# * 0$ ,7 #0 7 % *!, %&**2 &(*"&"!7& (,5> ,0%&(&*"#,12 0$ #$7!#* * $:&;$ *$%=#$ %@:&% 0$ 0&*7&=5&(, $ 7!&0,0 ( %,($? 0 7,&:,< 0 #1,%$(" < 0, =#$*$#),12 0 =,"#&%X(& $ 0, 7,=,7&0,0$ 0$ ;$#,12 0$ #$7$&",>

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

S

9!,5&0,0$ 0 *$#)&1 + !%, 0&%$(*2 $*=$7A6&7, 0 7 (7$&" 0$ $6&7@7&, 9!$ *$ #$6$#$ C 7,=,7&0,0$ 0, &(*"&"!&12 0$ #$*= (0$# 0$ 6 #%, #@=&0, $ 0&#$", C* ($7$**&0,0$* 0 * !*!@#& *> 2 $5$%$(" * 0, 9!,5&0,0$ , = #"!(&0,0$< , ,7$**&.&5&0,0$< , =#$7&*2 $ , 7 ("&(!&0,0$ (, $("#$;, 0 * *$#)&1 *> %, 6 #%, 0&#$", 0$ )$#&6&7,# $**, 0&%$(*2 + = # %$& 0, ,=5&7,12 0$ 9!$*"& (@#& * =$#&E0&7 * , * !*!@#& *>

,#, ,?!0,# (, " %,0, 0$ 0$7&*J$*< &(6 #%,(0 * .#$ * #$*!5",0 * ,57,(1,0 * = # 0$"$#%&(,0, ;$*"2 < 0$ %,($&#, D"&5 $ 7 %=#$$(*A)$5< + $**$(7&,5 9!$ 7 (?!(" 0$ &(0&7,0 #$* $*7 5-&0 * =$#%&", ,),5&,# , " ",5&0,0$ 0,* 0&%$(*J$* 0 0$*$%=$(- M$6&7@7&,< $6&7&8(7&,< $7 ( %&, $ 9!,5&0,0$N $ 9!$ ,),5&$%< ",%.+%< * 0&6$#$("$* Q%.&" * 0$ 7 ("# 5$ 0 =# 7$** =# 0!"&) M&(*!% *< =# 7$** *< =# 0!" * $ #$*!5",0 * 6&(,&*N>

* =#&(7&=,&* ,"#&.!" *< *$;!(0 !, M N< 9!$ !% &(0&7,0 # 0$)$ "$#< =,#, *$ " #(,# )&@)$5 $ =#@"&7 < *2 K

0,=",.&5&0,0$ ' 7,=,7&0,0$ 0$ #$*= *", C* %!0,(1,* 0$ 7 %= #",%$(" $ $:&;8(7&,* 0 * 75&$("$*> * &(0&7,0 #$* = 0$% " #(,#I*$ 0$*($7$**@#& * , 5 (; 0 "$%= $ 0$)$% *$# &%$0&,",%$("$ $5&%&(,0 * ! *!.*"&"!A0 * = # !"# * 0$ %,& # !"&5&0,0$>

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

&%=5&7&0,0$ ' 6,7&5&0,0$ 0$ *$# 7 %=#$$(0&0 $ ,=5&7,0 ",(" =$5 * $:$7!" #$* 9!,(" ' $ =#&(7&=,5%$("$ ' =$5 * 9!$ #$7$.$#2 *$!* #$*!5",0 *> * ( %$* $ $:=#$**J$* 0$)$% *$# 7 (-$7&0 * $ $("$(0&0 * = # " 0 * * $() 5)&0 * 0$ 6 #%, - % ;8($,< ;,#,("&(0 ,%=5, ),5&0,0$ = # " 0, , #;,(&B,12 >

,*"#$,.&5&0,0$ ' 6,7&5&0,0$ =,#, &0$("&6&7,12 0, #&;$% 0 * 0,0 *< *$! #$;&*"# $ %,(!"$(12 > $%=#$ 9!$ = **A)$5< 0$)$I*$ "#,(*6 #%,# * #$*!5",0 * $% ;#@6&7 * =,#, !% ,7 %=,(-,%$(" %,&* =#$7&* < 9!$ =$#%&"$ , 7 %=,#,12 7 % 0$*$%=$(- * ,("$#& #$*>

&*= (&.&5&0,0$ ' 6,7&5&0,0$ 0$ ,7$** =,#, 7 5$",< $*",(0 0&*= (A)$5 , "$%= < =,#, ,* =$** ,* 7$#",* $ *$% 0&*" #1J$*< *$#)&(0 0$ .,*$ =,#, 9!$ 0$7&*J$* *$?,% " %,0,*> $ (,0, ,0&,(",#&, &(6 #%,1J$* ,"#,*,0,* $ 0$*,"!,5&B,0,*< $%. #, 7 ##$",*< ! &(6 #%,1J$* ,"!,&* $ 7 ##$",*< %,* =,#, , =$** , $##,0,>

7 ( %&, ' (2 0$)$ *$# ;,*" "$%= 0$%,&* =# 7!#,(0 0,0 *< %!&" %$( * =$*9!&*,(0 ! ,;!,#0,(0 ( ) * %+" 0 * 0$ 7 5$",> * .$($6A7& * "#,B&0 * 7 % * &(0&7,0 #$* 0$)$% *$# %,& #$* 9!$ * 7!*" * &(7 ##&0 * (, %$0&12 > ,* 7 ("#@#& < $% = !7 "$%= , #;,(&B,12 $*",#@ %$0&(0 *!, =#E=#&, 6,58(7&,>

#,"&7&0,0$ ' ;,#,("&, 0$ 9!$ #$,5%$("$ 6!(7& (, (, =#@"&7, $ =$#%&"$ , " %,0, 0$ 0$7&*J$* ;$#$(7&,&*> ,#, &** < 0$)$ *$# "$*",0 ( 7,%= $< *$ ($7$**@#& < % 0&6&7,0 ! $:75!A0 >

*",.&5&0,0$ ' ;,#,("&, 0$ 9!$ + ;$#,0 $% # "&(,* 0$ =# 7$** $ =$#%,($7$ , 5 (; 0 "$%= < =$#%&"&(0 , 6 #%,12 0$ *+#&$ -&*"E#&7,>

* &(0&7,0 #$*< 0$ 6 #%, ;$#,5< 0$)$% 7 .#&# " 0 * * ,*=$7" * %,&* *&;(&6&7,"&) * 0, ;$*"2 < =#&)&5$;&,(0 * =#&(7&=,&* .?$"&) * 0, #;,(&B,12 < ( $(",(" < *$! (D%$# (2 = 0$ $:7$0$# , 7,=,7&0,0$ 0$ ,(@5&*$ 0,* =$** ,* 9!$ &#2 !"&5&B@I5 *> %$0&12 0$ &(0&7,0 #$* 0$)$ 0,# 7 (", 0, ,"&)&0,0$< =# 0!"&)&0,0$ $ 9!,5&0,0$ 0 *$#)&1 9!$ =#$*", 7 (?!(" 0$ 7,0, !%, 0,* !(&0,0$*< &(*"&"!&1J$* ! #;,(&B,1J$* 0 *$" # =D.5&7 >

Z &%= #",("$< ,&(0,< 0$*",7,# 9!$ 6," 0$ =# ?$",# $ &%=5,(",# !% *&*"$%, 0$ %$0&12 0$ 0$*$%=$(- < =,**,(0 , 7 5$",# $ ,#%,B$(,# 0,0 * ,=$(,*< (2 .,*",> Z ($7$**@#& ,;#$;,# ),5 #

S

, $**$* 0,0 *< "#,(*6 #%,(0 I * $% &(6 #%,1J$* 9!$ = **&.&5&"$% , " %,0, 0$ 0$7&*2 > ,(@5&*$ 0,* %$0&0,* #$,5&B,0,* $ * feedbacks 0$7 ##$("$* *2 7#!7&,&* =,#, , &(0!12 0, %$5- #&, 7 ("A(!,>

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

4.3 Contratos de Gestão

4.3.1 A história dos contratos de gestão

% )&%$(" 0$ b7 ("#,"!,5&B,12 b )$% *$ 6 #",5$7$(0 < ( * D5"&% * ,( *< 7 % &%= #",("$ %$7,(&*% 0$ $6$"&),12 0, ;$*"2 = # #$*!5",0 *< ",(" ( (A)$5 &("$#(,7& (,5 7 % ( (,7& (,5> %. #, * 7 ("#," * 0$ ;$*"2 "$(-,% *!, ,=5&7,12 #$% (",(0 , 6&(,5 0 * ,( * *$**$(", (, 3#,(1,< 6 & , =,#"&# 0, 0+7,0, 0$ V 9!$ &(*"#!%$(" =,** ! , *$# 0$ !* ;$($#,5&B,0 > &%=5&6&7,0,%$("$ *&;(&6&7, =,7"!,# #$*!5",0 * $("#$ =,#"$* &("$#$**,0,*> ,&* $*=$7&6&7,%$("$ + , $:=#$**2 0 [relacionamento negociado entre os diversos atores do aparelho do Estado e, eventualmente, entre estes e a sociedade civil\ M < < => N> # *, M N ),& ,5+% $ ,#;!%$(", 9!$ % 0$5 7 ("#,"!,5 *&"!,I*$ (!%, = *&12 &("$#%$0&@#&, M$< %$*% $) 5!"&),N $("#$ % 0$5 -&$#@#9!&7 < .,*$,0 ( 7 %,(0 $ 7 ("# 5$ M E#;2 *!=$#)&* #< #$*= (*@)$5 =$5, 6 #%!5,12 0, = 5A"&7, =D.5&7, 0$7&0$ $ *!=$#)&*& (,0 7!%=#$ 0$"$#%&(,0 N $ % 0$5 0, 0$5$;,12 ,%=5, M (0$ *!=$#)&*& (,0 "$% " ",5 ,!" ( %&, $ =$#, 0$ 6 #%, ,!"X( %, $ 0$*)&(7!5,0, 0, $("&0,0$ *!=$#)&* #,N> 5 7,0 0$*", 6 #%, 7 ("#," #$7 (-$7$ ,* 5&%&",1J$* 0$ ,%. * % 0$5 * $ *$ *&"!, (!%, = *&12 &("$#%$0&@#&,< (0$ * 0 &* (A)$&* *$ ,** 7&,% $ *$ 7 %=# %$"$% %!"!,%$("$> , )$#0,0$ "#,",I*$ 0$ !% 7 %=# %&** M($; 7&,0 $("#$ =,#"$*N 9!$ #$;!5, ,* #$5,1J$* $("#$ (D75$ $*"#,"+;&7 M6 #%!5,0 # 0$ = 5A"&7,*N $ ,* $("&0,0$* 0$*7$("#,5&B,0,* M$:$7!" #,*N>

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

S

$("#$ !% %&(&*"# $ !% E#;2 *!. #0&(,0 , $5$> * 7$("# * 0$ #$*= (*,.&5&0,0$< 9!$ 7 %$1,#,% , *$# 7#&,0 * , =,#"&# 0$ < $% 7,#@"$# $:=$#&%$(",5< *2 E#;2 * 9!$ *$ .$($6&7&,%< = # %$& 0, 7$5$.#,12 0$ !% 7 ("#," < 0$ 65$:&.&5&B,1J$* 0 7 ("# 5$ ,0%&(&*"#,"&) * .#$ *!, ;$*"2 < , %$*% "$%= $% 9!$ *$ =# =J$% , ,0 ",# 0$"$#%&(,0 * =# 7$0&%$(" * $ 7 %=# %&** * M < SN>

#2I #$",(-, ",%.+% )$% !"&5&B,(0 5,#;,%$("$ $*"$* &(*"#!%$(" * , =,#"&# 0$ VV< 9!,(0 0, &%=5,(",12 0 =# ;#,%, 5ext Steps 9!$ 0$! #&;$% C 7#&,12 0,* ;8(7&,* :$7!"&),* $ &("# 0!B&! !%, ( ), 7!5"!#, 0$ 7 ("# 5$ ;$#$(7&,5 M%,& # 8(6,*$ $% 0$*$%=$(- 0 9!$ (, 7 (6 #%&0,0$ ( #%,"&),N .,*$,0, $% ,),5&,1J$* ,(!,&* 0$ %$",* $ ,!%$(" 0,* ,!" ( %&,*> &(*"#!%$(" ,0 ",0 6 & 0$( %&(,0 Framework Documents & 0 7!%$(" 9!$ 7 ("+% ,* #$*= (*,.&5&0,0$* 0$ 7,0, ,;8(7&,< $:=5&7&",(0 , = 5A"&7, , *$# *$;!&0,< #1,%$(" $ !"# * #$7!#* * 7 (7$0&0 * C ,;8(7&,< .$% 7 % * .?$"&) * $ #$*!5",0 * , *$#$% ,57,(1,0 *< (, 6 #%, 7 % 6 #,% ($; 7&,0 * 7 % %&(&*"+#& "!"$5,#>

!*"#@5&, $ ), ^$5Q(0&, ",%.+% ,0 ",#,% %$7,(&*% * 0$ 7 ("#,"!,5&B,12 0$ #$*!5",0 * ( . ? 0$ *!,* $:=$#&8(7&,* #$7$("$* 0$ #$6 #%,> ,#,)&, M N 0$*",7, , $:=$#&8(7&, 5,"&( I ,%$#&7,(,< $% =,#"&7!5,# , 5$),0, , 7,. =$5, 5A)&, , =,#"&# 0$ 7 % * 7-,%,0 * 7 ("#," * 0$ #$(0&%$(" 7$5$.#,0 * 7 % ,* $%=#$*,* $*",",&*>

4.3.2 Os contratos de gestão no Brasil

#,*&5 , $:=$#&8(7&, 0$ ,0 12 0$ 7 ("#," * 0$ ;$*"2 #$% (", * ,( * &"$(",> $;!(0 ,#,)&, M N< , =#&%$&#, =# = *", 0$ 7 ("#," 0$ ;$*"2 6 & $5,. #,0, =$5, $0$ 3$## )&@#&, 3$0$#,5 $% VS> % 5< , %=,(-&, ,5$ 0 & 7$ ' (, += 7, $%=#$*, $*",",5 I ($; 7& ! $ 6&#% ! !% 7 ()8(& 0$ 0$*$%=$(- 7 % &(&*"+#& 0, (6#,$*"#!"!#,> *"$ &(*"#!%$(" "&(-, 7 ("$D0 * *$%$5-,("$* , * 0$ !% 7 ("#," 0$ ;$*"2 > *"$#& #%$("$< ,

($; 7& ! 7 ()8(& * 0$ 0$*$%=$(- 7 % ,* *!,* *!.*&0&@#&,* $ @#$,* 0$ ($;E7& *> $*"$ %$*% ,( 0$7#$" a SR &(7 #= # ! 7 ("#," 0$ ;$*"2 , * %$7,(&*% * $*",.$5$7&0 * =$5 # ;#,%, 0$ $*"2 0$ %=#$*,* *",",&* ,%=5&,(0 < ,**&%< 7 ("$D0 0 0$7#$" 0$ a 0$ 6$)$#$&# 0$ 9!$ 7#& ! %&"8 0$ ("# 5$ 0,* %=#$*,* *",",&*> % 7 (*$9]8(7&, ,

$"# .#@* 7$5$.# ! *$! 7 ("#," 0$ ;$*"2 7 % , (&2 =,#, =$#A 0 ' T>

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

3 &< ",%.+%< $%.5$%@"&7 7 ("#," ,**&(,0 =$5, 3!(0,12 & ($&#,* 7&,&*< $("&0,0$ 0$ 0&#$&" =#&),0 < 9!$ ,**!%&! , ;$*"2 0 * - *=&",&* ,#,- /!.&"*7-$L M #&;&(,5%$("$ !%, $("&0,0$ $*",",5N>

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

,**!(" < ( $(",(" < ;,(- ! !%, ( ), 0&%$(*2 ( Q%.&" 6$0$#,5< 9!,(0 0, $5,. #,12 0 5,( &#$" # 0, $6 #%, 0 =,#$5- 0 *",0 M#$6 #%, ;$#$(7&,5 ( ; )$#( 34 N< 9!$ $*",.$5$7$! 0&#$"#&B$* =,#, !%, ( ), ;$*"2 #&$(",0, =,#, #$*!5",0 * $ 7 % 65$:&.&5&0,0$*

SS

,0%&(&*"#,"&),* "$(0 7 % .,*$ % 0$5 * 7 ("#,"!,&* M,;8(7&,* $:$7!"&),* $ #;,(&B,1J$* * 7&,&*N> ,#,)&, M N 0$*",7, 9!$ , %$(0, (*"&"!7& (,5 (c 0$ V M,#">Sc< < d VN 0$"$#%&( ! 9!$ [, ,!" ( %&, M>>>N 0 * E#;2 * $ $("&0,0$* 0, ,0%&(&*"#,12 =D.5&7, 0&#$", $ &(0&#$", = 0$#@ *$# ,%=5&,0, %$0&,("$ 7 ("#," < , *$# 6&#%,0 $("#$ *$!* ,0%&(&*"#,0 #$* $ = 0$# =D.5&7 < 9!$ "$(-, = # .?$" , 6&:,12 0$ %$",* 0$ 0$*$%=$(- MeN< 7,.$(0 C 5$& 0&*= # * .#$K ' =#,B 0$ 0!#,12 0 7 ("#," P ' * 7 ("# 5$* $ 7#&"+#& * 0$ ,),5&,12 0$ 0$*$%=$(- < 0&#$&" *< .#&;,1J$* $ #$*= (*,.&5&0,0$ 0 * 0&#&;$("$*P ' , #$%!($#,12 0 =$** ,5\>

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

# $**$* $ !"# * % "&) *< 7,(0&0,",* , ,;8(7&,* $:$7!"&),* 6 #,% #$7!,(0 (,* ($; 7&,1J$*< =,**,(0 , 0$*,7#$0&",# 9!$ * 7 %=# %&** * *$ " #(,#&,% .&5,"$#,&* , 7!#" =#,B = # (2 7 ("$#$% , 65$:&.&5&B,12 &%$0&,", 0$ 7 ("# 5$* 7 (*&0$#,0 * 5&%&",0 #$* 0, $:$7!12 0 7 ("#," $ 0$*=# )&0 * 0$ $*"A%!5 * C =# 0!"&)&0,0$ 0 =$** ,5> 7 ("#," (2 5-$* =,#$7$! ,7#$*7$(",# 7 ("#&.!&12 #$5$),("$ =,#, !%, %,&* $6&7,B ;$*"2 0 E#;2 M Z< N>

Z &%= #",("$< ( $(",(" < #$7 (-$7$# 9!$ - !)$ *!.=# 0!" * &%= #",("$* 0,* ($; 7&,1J$* 0 * 7 ("#," * 0$ ;$*"2 < ",&* 7 % < ,* &(&7&,"&),* 0$ 0$*.!# 7#,"&B,12 < ,* #$)&*J$* 0, $& 0$ &#$"#&B$* #1,%$("@#&,* $ 0, $& #1,%$("@#&, (!,5< 9!$ 6,7&5&" ! #$%,($?,%$(" (, $:$7!12 0,* 0$*=$*,*< %!0,(1,* =,#, , 65$:&.&5&B,12 (, 5$& (a VTTT S 9!$ =$#%&"$% C* ,;8(7&,* $:$7!"&),* , 7 %=#, 0$ .$(* $ *$#)&1 * = # #$;!5,%$(" =#E=#& >

S

!#,("$ ,* D5"&%,* 0+7,0,*< *",0 =,** ! , 0$*$%=$(-,# !% =,=$5 7-,)$ 7 % =# 0!" # 0$ ),5 # =D.5&7 < =#& #&B,(0 , 7#&,12 0$ 7 (0&1J$* =,#, 0$*$() 5)&%$(" $ .$%I$*",# * 7&,5 $ =,#, , =# 0!12 0$ *$#)&1 * $ &(6#,I$*"#!"!#,> *", %!0,(1, ( =,=$5 0 *",0 < $:&;&0 7,0, )$B 7 % %,&* 7 ("!(08(7&, =$5 * 7&0,02 * 9!$ 7!=,% # 5 0$ !*!@#& * 0 * *$#)&1 *< "#,(*6 #% ! )@#&,* 6#$("$* 0, ,0%&(&*"#,12 =D.5&7,>

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

,**, , *$# 6!(0,%$(",5 6 #($7$# &(6 #%,1J$* * .#$ , $6$"&)&0,0$ 0, ,"!,12 0 *$" # =D.5&7 =,#, ,"$(0$# C ($7$**&0,0$ 0, * 7&$0,0$ 0$ *,.$# 9!$ $*"@ ,7 ("$7$(0 > 6 #($7&%$(" 0$ &(6 #%,1J$* *&;(&6&7,"&),* $ $% "$%= #$,5 * .#$ 0$*$%=$(- 0 *$" # =D.5&7 ",%.+% $(7 #,?, !%, %,& # 8(6,*$ ( =5,($?,%$(" $< ,5+% 0&** < 6$#$7$ . ,* &(0&7,1J$* 0 9!$ $*"@ #$,5%$("$ 6!(7& (,(0 $ 9!$ (2 $*"@>

;$*"2 =,#, #$*!5",0 * + !% 0 * 5$%,* 9!$ %$5- # ,"$(0$ , $**$ ( ) 0$*,6& > 2 *&;(&6&7, 9!$ (2 &("$#$**, ,; #, 7 % ,* 7 &*,* *2 6$&",*< %,* *&% 9!$ 7 %$1, , *$# %!&" %,&* #$5$),("$ 9!$ *$ 6,B =,#, .$% 0, 7 %!(&0,0$>

;$*"2 =,#, #$*!5",0 * 0$ 0$*$() 5)&%$(" + !%, $*"#,"+;&, 0$ ;$*"2 6 7,0, ( 0$*$() 5)&%$(" 0, =$#6 #%,(7$ $ $% %$5- #&,* *!*"$("@)$&* 0 * &%=,7" * 0,* = 5A"&7,* 0$ 7,0, =,A*> 5, =# = #7& (, !%, $*"#!"!#, 7 $#$("$ =,#, 0$*$() 5)&%$(" $6$"&) ( 9!,5 ,* &(6 #%,1J$* * .#$ , =$#6 #%,(7$ *2 !*,0,* =,#, ,=$#6$&1 ,# =# 7$** 0$ " %,0, 0$ 0$7&*2 < ,5+% 0&** < &(75!& 6$##,%$(",* =#@"&7,* =,#, =5,($?,%$(" $*"#,"+;&7 < , ;$*"2 0$ #&*7 *< % (&" #,%$(" $ ,),5&,12 0 * &%=,7" * M / 4< N>

;$*"2 =,#, ,57,(7$ 0$ #$*!5",0 * 0$ 0$*$() 5)&%$(" *&;(&6&7, !% %,& # 6 7 ( * $6$&" * 7 (7#$" * $% " 0,* ,* 6,*$* 0 =# 7$** 0$ 0$*$() 5)&%$(" (,7& (,5 M I Joint Venture on Managing for Development Results< VN>

;$*"2 =,#, #$*!5",0 * $*"@ 7,#,7"$#&B,0, = #K

I !%, $*"#,"+;&, (0$ *2 0$6&(&0 * * #$*!5",0 * $*=$#,0 * = # !%, &(*"&"!&12 =D.5&7, 7 % #$5,12 C %!0,(1, * 7&,5 $ C =# 0!12 0$ .$(* $ *$#)&1 *P

I !%, 7!5"!#, $ !% &(*"#!%$(",5 0$ ;$*"2 #&$(",0 * , %$5- #,# , $6&7@7&,< $6&7&8(7&,< =# 0!"&)&0,0$ $ $6$"&)&0,0$ ( !* 0 * #$7!#* * 0 *",0 =,#, %$5- #,# * #$*!5",0 * 0$ 0$*$%=$(- 0,* #;,(&B,1J$* $ 0 * *$#)&0 #$* =D.5&7 *P

I *&*"$%,* 0$ &(6 #%,12 9!$ ,!:&5&$% (, " %,0, 0$ 0$7&*J$* 0 * ," #$* 9!$ =,#"&7&=,% 0 * =# 7$** *P

I =# % 12 0, 9!,5&0,0$ 0 * *$#)&1 * =#$*",0 * , * 7&0,02 * = # %$& 0$ !% =# 7$** 0$ %$5- #,%$(" 7 ("A(! P

I *&*"$%,* 0$ 7 ("#,",12 0 * 0&#&;$("$* =D.5&7 * 7 % )&*",* , ,=# 6!(0,# *!, #$*= (*,.&5&0,0$< 7 %=# %&** $ 7,=,7&0,0$ 0$ ,12 P

I *&*"$%,* 0$ &(6 #%,12 9!$ =$#%&",% % (&" #,# , ,12 =D.5&7,< 6 #($7$(0 &(6 #%,1J$* =,#, , * 7&0,02 * * .#$ * #$7!#* * !"&5&B,0 *>

S

“A gestão para resultados é um marco conceitual cuja função é de facilitar para as instituições públicas a direção efetiva e integrada do processo de criação de valor público, a fim de otimizá&lo assegurando a máxima eficácia, eficiência e efetividade em seu desempenho, a consecução dos objetivos de governo e a melhora contínua

das instituições” M < RN>

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

;$*"2 =,#, #$*!5",0 * 5$), C &("$;#,12 0$ 0&)$#* * 7 (7$&" * $ 6$##,%$(",* ,0%&(&*"#,"&),* 7 % < = # $:$%=5 < 7 ("# 5$ 0, ;$*"2 < , 0&#$12 = # .?$"&) *< , ;$*"2 $*"#,"+;&7,< , ;$*"2 0$ 0$*$%=$(- < , ,),5&,12 $ % (&" #,%$(" $ , %$0&12 0$ #$*!5",0 *> #,",I*$< = #",(" < 0$ !% &(*"#!%$(" 0$ ;$*"2 = 5A"&7, $ ;$#$(7&,5 7!?, 6&(,5&0,0$ *2 * #$*!5",0 * 9!$ ; )$#( 5$;&"&%,%$("$ 0$*$?, ,57,(1,#>

* =#&(7A=& * 9!$ ( #"$&,% , ;$*"2 =,#, #$*!5",0 *< 0$6&(&0 * (, $;!(0, $*, $0 (0, * .#$ $*!5",0 * #$,5&B,0, $% ,##,L$*- $% < 6 #,%K

' % " 0,* ,* 6,*$* ' 0 =5,($?,%$(" $*"#,"+;&7 ,"+ , &%=5$%$(",12 ' 6 7 0 0&@5 ; 0$)$ *$# ( * #$*!5",0 *< ",(" &("$#(, 9!,(" $:"$#(,%$("$> , ;$*"2 =,#, #$*!5",0 * + &%= #",("$ "$# !%, ,=# :&%,12 7 $#$("$ $("#$ " 0,* ,* 6,*$* 0 =# 7$** K M,N ex ante< (, 6,*$ 0, $*"#,"+;&, $ =5,($?,%$(" < 9!,(0 #$*!5",0 * $*=$#,0 * *2 0$6&(&0 * $ , =# ;#,%,12 0$ 7!*" * $ 0$ &%=,7" * , *$#$% ,57,(1,0 * *2 ,(,5&*,0 *P M.N 0!#,("$ , &%=5$%$(",12 0 =# ;#,%, =# ?$" < 9!,(0 % (&" #,%$(" + ($7$**@#& =,#, 0$"$#%&(,# =# ;#$** $ &0$("&6&7,# , ($7$**&0,0$ 0$ 7 ##$1J$* ( %$& 0 7,%&(- P M7N ex post< ,=E* , 6&(,5&B,12 0 =# ;#,%, =# ?$" < 9!,(0 * #$*!5",0 * ,57,(1,0 * *2 7 %=,#,0 * 7 % * .?$"&) * &(&7&,&*P M0N ,=E* !% 7$#" "$%= 0, 7 (75!*2 0 =# ;#,%, =# ?$" =,#, )$#&6&7,# *!, *!*"$(",.&5&0,0$>

' 5&(-,# , =# ;#,%,12 < % (&" #,%$(" $ ,),5&,12 0,* ,"&)&0,0$* 7 % * #$*!5",0 * $*=$#,0 *> !,(0 " 0,* ,* &(*"&"!&1J$* $() 5)&0,* 6 7,% *!,* ,"&)&0,0$* ( * #$*!5",0 * $*=$#,0 * $ ,** 7&,% &(0&7,0 #$* 0$ #$*!5",0 * ,* %$*%,*< $5,* = 0$% ,5&(-,# %$5- # , =# ;#,%,12 M&(75!&(0 , 6&(,(7$&#,N< % (&" #,%$(" $ ,* ,),5&,1J$* 7 % * .?$"&) * , *$#$% ,57,(1,0 *>

S ' ,("$# * *&*"$%,* &(6 #%,7& (,&* * .#$ * #$*!5",0 * %,&* *&%=5$* = **A)$5< 7 % 7!*" .$($6A7& $6$"&) $ ,%&;@)$5 , * !*!@#& *> $*"#!"!#, 0$ &(0&7,0 #$* $5,. #,0, =,#, ,7 %=,(-,%$(" 0 * #$*!5",0 * 0$)$ *$# *&%=5$*< &("$;#,0, , * !"# * *&*"$%,* $:&*"$("$*< =$#%&"&(0 , ,=#$(0&B,;$% $ , accountability $< 0$)$ %&(&%&B,# * 7!*" * "#,(*,7& (,&* $ 6,7&5&",# ,* ,(@5&*$* 7 %=,#,"&),*>

' ;$*"2 0$)$ *$# =,#, #$*!5",0 * $ (2 = # #$*!5",0 *> $*"2 =,#, #$*!5",0 * $() 5)$ !%, %!0,(1, 0$ 7 %=#$$(*2 ' , &()+* 0$ *$ 7 %$1,# 7 % * &(=!"* $ ,1J$* =5,($?,0 * $ 0$= &* *$;!&# $% 0&#$12 , * =# 0!" * $ &%=,7" *< 0$)$I*$ 6 7,# ( * =# 0!" * $ &%=,7" * 0$*$?,0 * $ 0$= &* &0$("&6&7,# 9!,&* *2 * &(=!"* $ ,1J$* ($7$**@#&,* =,#, *$ 7-$;,# 5@>

' * &(6 #%,1J$* * .#$ * #$*!5",0 * 0$)$% *$# !"&5&B,0,* =,#, $(#&9!$7$# , ;$*"2 0 7 (-$7&%$(" $ =,#, * =# 7$** * 0$ " %,0, 0$ 0$7&*2 < ,**&% 7 % =,#, , =#$*",12 0$ 7 (",* $ accountability> * &(6 #%,1J$* * .#$ * #$*!5",0 * 0$)$% $*",# *$%=#$ 0&*= (A)$&* , =D.5&7 >

ST

5;!%,* 7 (0&1J$* *2 #$9!&*&" * ($7$**@#& * =,#, , &%=5$%$(",12 0, ;$*"2 =,#, #$*!5",0 *< ",&* 7 % < 6 #($7&%$(" 0$ &(6 #%,1J$* D"$&* * .#$ #$*!5",0 * ,57,(1,0 * $ 0$*$%=$(- 0,* &(*"&"!&1J$* 9!$ 0$)$% *$# !"&5&B,0 * (, " %,0, 0$ 0$7&*J$*P , ;$*"2 =,#, #$*!5",0 * 0$)$ *$# #$=,**,0, =,#, " 0 * * E#;2 * $ $("&0,0$* 0 ; )$#( < 7-$;,(0 C* @#$,* 6&(,5A*"&7,*P , 7 (7$**2 0$ 65$:&.&5&0,0$ ,0%&(&*"#,"&), =,#, * E#;2 * $ $("&0,0$* =,#, 9!$ * %$*% * = **,% ,57,(1,# * #$*!5",0 * $*=$#,0 *>

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

$;!&(0 *!, $) 5!12 7 (7$&"!,5< 0$*0$ * = (" * 0$ )&*", 0$ *!, 0$6&(&12 $ 0$ *!, =#@"&7,< = 0$I*$ .*$#),# 9!$ , ;$*"2 =,#, #$*!5",0 * "$% ,* *$;!&("$* 0&%$(*J$*K

I Z !% %,#7 7 (7$&"!,5 0$ ;$*"2 #;,(&B,7& (,5< =D.5&7, ! =#&),0,< (0$ 6," # #$*!5",0 < ,=5&7,0 , " 0 =# 7$** 0$ ;$*"2 < *$ 7 ()$#"$ (, #$6$#8(7&, 7-,)$>

I Z !% %,#7 0$ ,9!&*&12 0$ #$*= (*,.&5&0,0$ 0, ;$*"2 = # %$& 0, )&(7!5,12 0 * 0&#&;$("$* , #$*!5",0 ."&0 >

I Z !% %,#7 0$ #$6$#8(7&, 7,=,B 0$ &("$;#,# * 0&*"&(" * 7 %= ($("$* 0 =# 7$** 0$ ;$*"2 ?@ 9!$ *$ =# =J$% , &("$#7 ($7"@I5 * =,#, "&%&B,# *$! 6!(7& (,%$(" >

I $=#$*$(",< $*=$7&,5%$("$ ( Q%.&" 0 *$" # =D.5&7 < !%, =# = *", 0$ 7!5"!#, #;,(&B,7& (,5< 0&#$"&), $ 0$ ;$*"2 = # %$& 0, 9!,5 + 0,0, 8(6,*$ ( * #$*!5",0 * $ (2 ( * =# 7$** * $ =# 7$0&%$(" *>

0,* $**,* 0&%$(*J$* *&"!,% , ;$*"2 =,#, #$*!5",0 * 7 % !%, 6$##,%$(", 7!5"!#,5< 7 (7$&"!,5 $ =$#,"&), 9!$ *$ #&$(", , =#& #&B,# #$*!5",0 $% " 0,* ,* ,1J$*< $ =$#%&"$ , "&%&B,12 0 0$*$%=$(- ; )$#(,%$(",5> #,",I*$< = #",(" < 0$ !% $:$#7A7& 0$ 0&#$12 0,* &(*"&"!&1J$* =D.5&7,* 9!$ .!*7, 7 (-$7$# $ ,"!,# * .#$ " 0 * * ,*=$7" * 9!$ ,6$"$% ! % 0!5$% * #$*!5",0 * 0, #;,(&B,12 >

Z &%= #",("$ 9!$ , 0&6$#$(7&,12 $("#$ 7 ("# 5$ $:"$#( $ ;$*"2 =,#, #$*!5",0 * *$?, 6$&",< = &*< %$*% *$(0 $**, D5"&%, !%, . , .,*$ =,#, !%, %$5- # =#$*",12 0$ 7 (",* $ !%, %,& # "#,(*=,#8(7&,< *!, 6!(12 =#&(7&=,5 (2 + *$#)&# 7 % &(*"#!%$(" 0$ 7 ("# 5$ 0, ,"!,12 0 * 0&#&;$("$* =D.5&7 *< %,* *&%< =# = #7& (,# , $5$* !% %$& 0$ % (&" #,%$(" $ #$;!5,12 =,#, ;,#,("&# 9!$ $:$#1,% *!,* #$*= (*,.&5&0,0$*>

SR

3&;!#, T I $*"2 =,#, $*!5",0 * ( U%.&" D.5&7

3 ("$K M RN