amp; ' &amp

!

!

" # $ % & ' & $ ( ! ) * + $ # , $ ( - ! . ( / * 0 1 # 2 ! 3 0 0 4 , & $ 1 & 4 ( ! 5 6 7 . 8 3 9 ! : ! ; < ; ; ! 7 ! ) 1 # - - 1 !7 = ! : ! = $ 0 > & ( + 1 4 ( ? ! @ 8 ! A B B C D ! E > 4 ( - ! F ; ! 5 A B A 9 ! G B D H G A I I ! : ! J $ K ! F ; ! 5 A B A 9 ! < L < H G M C D ! : ! N $ 0 > & ( + 1 4 ( O * ( & , $ P , 4 Q P R # ! : ! N N N P * ( & , $ P , 4 Q P R # S T 7 !

!

!

!

U,14R-#!M?!ABBI!

!

!

V.3!TWT8XYU7.8!@TW.VTYZ!

!

8'-#[!4\!1>-!"4$#/!

3&#!Y-04*#,-0!"4$#/!!

;BB;!.!)1#--1!

)$,#$Q-(14?!8$'&\4#(&$!IGM;L!

!

Y-\-#-(,-]! !"#$%&'($)*#"'$+',-./*#'012*/2.*/*)3'$+'4$&*+*"&'5"6)'2%&'012*/2.*/*)3'$+'' ' ' ' ' 0&&*)*$%2/'7$#-8"%)9'2%&':%+$;82)*$%')$':8</"8"%)')="'>$?'@2;.$%'A-"/''

' ' ' !)2%&2;&'

!

X4!=>4Q!.1!^$2!84(,-#(]!

!

X>-!"#$%&'&$(!)*+$#,$(-!.(/*01#2!3004,&$1&4(!567.839!N-',4Q-0!1>-!4__4#1*(&12!14!R#&-\'2!

,4QQ-(1!&(!0*__4#1!4\!1>-!_#4_40-/!Q4/&\&,$1&4(0!14!1>-!#-+*'$14#2!1-K1!$(/!$//&1&4($'!

&(\4#Q$1&4(!$`$&'$R'-!\4#!8$'&\4#(&$a0!_#4_40-/!W4N!8$#R4(!J*-'!)1$(/$#/!5W8J)9P!!X>-0-!

,4QQ-(10!-K_$(/!4(!4*#!_#-`&4*0!,4##-0_4(/-(,-!4(!1>-!'&\-,2,'-!,$',*'$1&4(0!4\!0*+$#,$(-!

-1>$(4'!0*RQ&11-/!R2!'-11-#0!/$1-/!3_#&'!;D?!3*+*01!;I?!$(/!)-_1-QR-#!AG?!ABBIP!.(!0>4#1?!

67.83!0*__4#10!1>-!_#4_40-/!Q4/&\&,$1&4(0!$(/!#-,4QQ-(/0!1>-2!R-!\&($'&%-/!$1!1>-!-$#'&-01!

4__4#1*(&12!+&`-(!1>-!1>4#4*+>!4__4#1*(&1&-0!\4#!_*R'&,!,4QQ-(1!$(/!#-`&-N!_#4`&/-/!14!/$1-P!

!

3Q4(+!1>-!\*-'!_$1>N$20!,4Q_'-1-/!\4#!*0-!&(!1>-!W8J)!$#-!1>#--!_$1>N$20!\4#!_#4/*,&(+!

-1>$(4'!\#4Q!"#$%&'&$(!0*+$#,$(-]!4(-!*0&(+!$`-#$+-!_#4/*,1&4(!_#4,-00-0!4('2?!4(-!1>$1!

&(,'*/-0!Q-,>$(&%-/!>$#`-01&(+!$(/!-'-,1#&,&12!,4H_#4/*,1!,#-/&1?!$(/!4(-!N&1>!-'-,1#&,&12!,4H _#4/*,1!,#-/&1!R*1!(41!Q-,>$(&%-/!>$#`-01&(+P!!

!X>-!'$1-#!1N4!_$1>N$20!$#-!,*##-(1'2!0*Rb-,1!14!_*R'&,!#-`&-N!$0!Q&(4#!_#4_40-/!Q4/&\&,$1&4(0!

14!1>-!4#&+&($'!_#4_40-/!W8J)!#-+*'$1&4(P!X>-!_*R'&,!>$0!R--(!+&`-(!$/-c*$1-!(41&,-!4\!$(/!

4__4#1*(&12!14!,4QQ-(1!4(!1>-0-!_$1>N$20!1>#4*+>!$!CBH/$2!,4QQ-(1!_-#&4/!>-'/!\#4Q!d*'2!

AB?!ABBI?!*(1&'!3*+*01!;I?!ABBI?!$(/!1>-!,*##-(1!;GH/$2!,4QQ-(1!_-#&4/!1>$1!-(/0!U,14R-#!M?!

ABBIP!!X>-0-!_$1>N$20!$#-!$'04!0*\\&,&-(1'2!#-'$1-/!14!1>-!4#&+&($'!_#4_40-/!#*'-?!N>&,>!#-,-&`-/!

$!0-_$#$1-!LGH/$2!,4QQ-(1!_-#&4/!$(/!$Q_'-!_*R'&,!>-$#&(+!/&0,*00&4(0P!!.(!$//&1&4(?!1>-0-!

_$1>N$20!$#-!0*__4#1-/!R2!$!#4R*01!-(`&#4(Q-(1$'!$($'20&0?!#-\'-,1-/!&(!1>-!#*'-Q$[&(+!#-,4#/P!!

"-,$*0-!1>-0-!_$1>N$20!>$`-!R--(!-01$R'&0>-/!1>#4*+>!$(!$/-c*$1-!_*R'&,!_#4,-00?!$(/!$#-!

N-''H0*__4#1-/!R2!1>-!R-01!$`$&'$R'-!0,&-(,-?!N-!R-'&-`-!1>-!8$'&\4#(&$!3&#!Y-04*#,-0!"4$#/!

53Y"9!>$0!\*''!$*1>4#&12!14!\&($'&%-!1>-Q!$1!1>-!-$#'&-01!_400&R'-!4__4#1*(&12?!$(/!#-,4QQ-(/!

3Y"!/4!04P!

!

UNICA Comments on LCFS Second 15-day Comment Period! ! Page 2

!

"#!$%&!'&()'*!#%)+#,!$%&!$%'&&!#-./'(/0&!&$%/0)1!2/$%+/3#!%/4&!5&&0!&#$/516#%&*!$%')-.%!/!

')5-#$!2-516(!2')(&##7!!8)'!9:!*/3#,!$%&!";<!=/*&!/4/61/51&!$)!$%&!2-516(!$%&!606$6/1!2')2)#&*!

'&.-1/$)'3!1/0.-/.&!/0*!$%&!>?$/@@!;&2)'$A!B06$6/1!?$/$&=&0$!)@!;&/#)0#!CB?D;E!@)'!F')2)#&*!

;&.-1/$6)0!$)!B=21&=&0$!$%&!G)+!H/'5)0!8-&1!?$/0*/'*,I!+%6(%!2'&#&0$#!$%&!'/$6)0/1&!/0*!

5/#6#!@)'!$%&!2')2)#&*!'&.-1/$6)0!/0*!6*&0$6@6&#!$%&!*/$/,!'&2)'$#,!/0*!60@)'=/$6)0!'&16&*!-2)07!!!

J%&#&!=/$&'6/1#!60(1-*&*!60@)'=/$6)0!/5)-$!/11!$%'&&!#-./'(/0&!&$%/0)1!2/$%+/3#7!?2&(6@6(/113,!

$%&!B?D;,!=/*&!2-516(!60!K/'(%!:,!+/#!&L216(6$!60!60*6(/$60.,!60!J/51&!M?NO!>8-&1!F/$%+/3#!P0*&'!

Q&4&1)2=&0$!@)'!P#&!60!$%&!GH8?,I!$%/$!$%&!";<!+/#!+)'R60.!)0!$+)!/**6$6)0/1!2/$%+/3#!@)'!

#-./'(/0&!&$%/0)17!!

!

D0!"2'61!ST,!SUUV,!@)11)+60.!$%&!606$6/1!9:N*/3!2&'6)*,!";<!6##-&*!;&#)1-$6)0!UVNTW,!/22')460.!

$%&!GH8?!'&.-1/$6)07!!";<!/1#)!/22')4&*!=)*6@6(/$6)0#!$)!$%&!'&.-1/$6)0,!60!/(()'*/0(&!+6$%!/!

K/'(%!:,!SUUV!?$/@@!;&2)'$7!!"=)0.!$%&#&!=)*6@6(/$6)0#,!$%&!?$/@@!-2*/$&*!$%&!G))R-2!J/51&#!

$)!60(1-*&!/!2/$%+/3!@)'!&$%/0)1!@')=!#-./'(/0&7!!B0!/**6$6)0,!";<!60*6(/$&*!$%/$!$%&!@60/1!GH8?!

'&.-1/$6)0!+)-1*!#2&(6@3!/**6$6)0/1!(/'5)0!60$&0#6$3!C>HBIE!4/1-&#!@)'!*6'&($!2/$%+/3#!@)'!

<'/X616/0!#-./'(/0&!/#!*&&=&*!+/''/0$&*!53!$%&!ML&(-$64&!D@@6(&'7!!J%&'&@)'&,!$%&!2-516(!%/#!

5&&0!2-$!)0!0)$6(&!#60(&!/$!1&/#$!K/'(%!:,!SUUV,!$%/$!";<!2')2)#&*!$)!60(1-*&!$%&!$%'&&!

#-./'(/0&!&$%/0)1!2/$%+/3#!60!$%&!@60/1!'&.-1/$6)07!!

!D0!Y-13!SU,!SUUV,!$%&!/.&0(3!(6'(-1/$&*!$%&!=)*6@6&*!GH8?!'&.-1/$6)0!/0*!'&1/$&*!/0/13#&#,!

+%6(%!2')46*&*!*&$/61#!)0!$%&!$%'&&!#-./'(/0&!&$%/0)1!2/$%+/3#7!!J%&!=)*6@6&*!'&.-1/$6)0#!/0*!

'&1/$&*!'&()'*!=/$&'6/1#!+&'&!=/*&!/4/61/51&!@)'!/!TUN*/3!2-516(!()==&0$!2&'6)*,!-0$61!"-.-#$!

WV,!SUUV7!!J%&!/**6$6)0/1!=/$&'6/1#!60(1-*&!/!Y-13!SU,!SUUV!'&2)'$!)0!#(&0/'6)#!@)'!#-./'(/0&!

&$%/0)1!$)!/(()-0$!@)'!6=2')4&*!%/'4&#$60.!2'/($6(&#!/0*!$%&!&L2)'$!)@!&1&($'6(6$3!@')=!

#-./'(/0&!&$%/0)1!21/0$#!60!<'/X61!-#60.!&0&'.3!@')=!5/./##&7!

!

J%&!#-./'(/0&!&$%/0)1!2/$%+/3#!2')2)#&*!60!$%&!'&.-1/$6)0#!(6'(-1/$&*!)0!Y-13!SU,!SUUV,!/'&!

#-@@6(6&0$13!'&1/$&*!$)!$%&!)'6.60/1!2')2)#&*!'-1&7!!J%&3!'&2'&#&0$!=60)'!'&.-1/$)'3!

=)*6@6(/$6)0#!$%/$!%/4&!5&&0!#-5Z&($!$)!/0!/22')2'6/$&!1&4&1!)@!2-516(!'&46&+7!!?2&(6@6(/113,!$%&!

$%'&&!HB!4/1-&#!@)'!#-./'(/0&!&$%/0)1!60!$%&!1/$&#$!4&'#6)0!)@!$%&!2')2)#&*!GH8?!'-1&!/'&!

>#-@@6(6&0$13!'&1/$&*!$)!$%&!)'6.60/1!$&L$![#-(%\!$%/$!$%&!2-516(!+/#!/*&]-/$&13!21/(&*!)0!0)$6(&!

$%/$!$%&!(%/0.&!()-1*!'&#-1$!@')=!$%&!)'6.60/113!2')2)#&*!'&.-1/$)'3!/($6)07I!!!""!^)47!H)*&!_!

WWT9O7`C(E7!!B0*&&*,!PaBH"b#!"2'61!WO,!SUUV!()==&0$#!*6#(-##&*!$%&!-#&@-10&##!@)'!=-1$621&!

#&2/'/$&!2/$%+/3#!@)'!#-./'(/0&!&$%/0)1!60!)'*&'!$)!/((-'/$&13!'&@1&($!$%&!'&/16$6&#!)@!$%&!@/#$!

(%/0.60.!#-./'(/0&!60*-#$'37!D0!$%&!.')-0*!60!<'/X61,!$%&'&!6#!#6.06@6(/0$!-#&!)@!=&(%/06(/1!

%/'4&#$60.!/0*!5/./##&!@)'!&1&($'6(6$3,!/0*!$%&#&!2')(&##&#!/'&!0)$!=-$-/113!&L(1-#64&7!!B0!#%)'$,!

$%&!6##-&!)@!+%&$%&'!/0*!%)+!/1$&'0/$64&!2/$%+/3#!=6.%$!5&!*&4&1)2&*!@)'!=&(%/06(/113!

%/'4&#$&*,!0)0N5-'0&*!#-./'(/0&!&$%/0)1!/0*!$%&!/*)2$6)0!)@!=)'&!&@@6(6&0$!().&0&'/$6)0!

$&(%0)1).6&#!+/#!#]-/'&13!2'&#&0$&*!53!$%&!606$6/1!2')2)#&*!'-1&7!!J%&!$%'&&!2/$%+/3#!#&$!@)'$%!

60!$%&!Y-13!SU,!SUUV!4&'#6)0!)@!$%&!'&.-1/$6)0!+&'&!$%&'&@)'&!#-@@6(6&0$13!'&1/$&*!$)!$%&!)'6.60/1!

2')2)#/17!!!

!

"#!#-(%,!$%&!TUN*/3!()==&0$!2&'6)*!%&1*!60!Y-13!/0*!"-.-#$!)@!SUUV!+/#!=)'&!$%/0!/*&]-/$&7!!

B0!@/($,!5&(/-#&!$%6#!(%/0.&!+/#!#-@@6(6&0$13!'&1/$&*!$)!$%&!$&L$!)@!$%&!GH8?!'&.-1/$6)0!/#!6$!+/#!

UNICA Comments on LCFS Second 15-day Comment Period! ! Page 3

!

)'6.60/113!2')2)#&*,!$%&!/.&0(3!+/#!)013!'&]-6'&*!$)!2')46*&!/0!/**6$6)0/1!W:N*/3!()==&0$!

2&'6)*7!!!""!^)47!H)*&!_!WWT9O7`C(E7!J%&'&@)'&,!0)!/**6$6)0/1!2-516(!()==&0$!6#!'&]-6'&*7!

a)$/513,!&4&0!6@!";<!+/#!'&]-6'&*!$)!%/4&!(6'(-1/$&*!/11!$%'&&!#-./'(/0&!&$%/0)1!2/$%+/3#!@)'!/!

@-11!9:N*/3!()==&0$!2&'6)*,!6$!%/#!0)+!*)0&!#)7!!B0!/**6$6)0!$)!$%&!)'6.60/1!9:N*/3!()==&0$!

2&'6)*,!$%&!2-516(!%/#!5&&0!2')46*&*!/!$)$/1!)@!/0!#$$%&%'(#)!9:!*/3#!C$%&!TUN*/3!()==&0$!

2&'6)*,!21-#!$%&!)0.)60.!W:N*/3!()==&0$!2&'6)*E!$)!()0#6*&'!/11!$%'&&!2')2)#&*!#-./'(/0&!

&$%/0)1!2/$%+/3#,!/0*!#-5=6$!()==&0$#7!!K)'&)4&',!$%&!/.&0(3!%/#!=/*&!$%&!#-22)'$60.!

/0/13#6#!@)'!$%&#&!2/$%+/3#!/4/61/51&!@)'!()0#6*&'/$6)0!53!$%&!2-516(7!

!

860/113,!/=)0.!$%&!=)#$!'&(&0$!'&46#6)0#!$)!$%&!2')2)#&*!GH8?!'&.-1/$6)0,!H";<!%/#!2')2)#&*!/!

=60)'!(%/0.&!$)!)0&!)@!$%&!#-./'(/0&!&$%/0)1!2/$%+/3#7!!J%&!G))R-2!J/51&!(/'5)0!60$&0#6$3!

C>HBIE!4/1-&!@)'!$%&!2/$%+/3!@)'!2')*-(60.!&$%/0)1!@')=!<'/X616/0!#-./'(/0&!+6$%!/4&'/.&!

2')*-($6)0!2')(&##,!=&(%/06X&*!%/'4&#$60.,!/0*!&1&($'6(6$3!()N2')*-($!('&*6$!+/#!60()''&($!*-&!

$)!/!#16.%$!=/$%&=/$6(/1!&'')'7!!J%&!*6'&($!&=6##6)0#!HB!4/1-&!C.HDS&cKYE!@)'!$%6#!2/$%+/3!+/#!

16#$&*!/#!WS7SU,!60#$&/*!)@!WS79U7!!a)0&!)@!$%&!/##-=2$6)0#!-0*&'1360.!$%6#!HB!4/1-&!%/4&!

(%/0.&*d!$%&!0&+!4/1-&!6#!#6=213!/!$&(%06(/1,!0)0N#-5#$/0$64&!()''&($6)0!)@!$%&!)'6.60/113N (6'(-1/$&*!$&L$7!!J%6#!(%/0.&!6#!$%-#!60#6.06@6(/0$!/0*!*)&#!0)$!+/''/0$!/03!@-'$%&'!2-516(!

2')(&##7!

!B0!#-=,!$%&!2-516(!0)$6(&!/0*!()==&0$!2')(&##!$%/$!";<!%/#!2')46*&*!@)'!$%&!GH8?!'&.-1/$6)0!6#!

()0#6#$&0$!+6$%!H/16@)'06/!/*=606#$'/$64&!2')(&*-'&!1/+7!

!

;&#2&($@-113!?-5=6$$&*,!

!

!

!

Y)&1!e&1/#()!

H%6&@!;&2'&#&0$/$64&!N!a)'$%!"=&'6(/!

!