Resumo
Objetivos:DYDOLDUDXWLOLGDGHGRFRPSULPHQWRFHUYLFDOXOWUDVRQRJUi¿FRSDUDDSUHGLomRGRSDUWRHPJHVWDQWHVFRP FRQWUDo}HVXWHULQDVSHUVLVWHQWHVHEROVDtQWHJUDMétodos:UHDOL]RXVHHVWXGRREVHUYDFLRQDOSURVSHFWLYRGRWLSRFRRUWHQR TXDOIRUDPLQFOXtGDVJHVWDQWHVLQWHUQDGDVHPQRVVDLQVWLWXLomRHQWUHDa e a 34aVHPDQD8OWUDVRQRJUD¿DWUDQVYDJLQDO GRFRORIRLUHDOL]DGDXPD~QLFDYH]DSyVFRPSOHWDGRXPFLFORGHWRFyOLVHHQGRYHQRVDFRPDIHULomRGRFRPSULPHQWR FRQIRUPHFULWpULRVGHVFULWRVSUHYLDPHQWH2VDFKDGRVXOWUDVRQRJUi¿FRVQmRIRUDPXWLOL]DGRVSDUDRGLDJQyVWLFRRXFRQGXWD REVWpWULFD2GHVIHFKRHVWXGDGRIRLDRFRUUrQFLDGHSDUWRSUpWHUPRVHPDQDV$DQiOLVHHVWDWtVWLFDIXQGDPHQWRXVH HPPpWRGRGHUHJUHVVmRORJtVWLFDXQLYDULDGDSDUDGHWHUPLQDUDVLJQL¿FkQFLDGRFRPSULPHQWRFHUYLFDOSDUDDSUHGLomRGR SDUWRSUpWHUPR2QtYHOGHVLJQL¿FkQFLDDGRWDGRIRLGHSHRLQWHUYDORGHFRQ¿DQoDIRLGH,& Resultados:DLQFLGrQFLDGHSDUWRSUpWHUPRIRLGH2FRPSULPHQWRFHUYLFDODVVRFLRXVHGHIRUPDVLJQL¿FDWLYD DRGHVIHFKRGDJHVWDomRS$SyVFRQVWUXomRGHFXUYDFDUDFWHUtVWLFDRSHUDWyULDGRUHFHSWRUXPFRPSULPHQWR FHUYLFDOGHPPUHYHORXVHFRPRPHOKRUSRQWRGHFRUWHSDUDDSUHGLomRGRSDUWRSUpWHUPRVHQVLELOLGDGH HVSHFL¿FLGDGHYDORUSUHGLWLYRSRVLWLYRHYDORUSUHGLWLYRQHJDWLYR$iUHDFDOFXODGDDEDL[RGDFXUYD
FDUDFWHUtVWLFDRSHUDWyULDGRUHFHSWRUIRLGH,&SConclusões:QDVPXOKHUHVFRPFRQWUDo}HV
XWHULQDVSHUVLVWHQWHVHEROVDtQWHJUDHPWUDWDPHQWRSDUDWUDEDOKRGHSDUWRSUpWHUPRXPFRPSULPHQWRFHUYLFDOLQIHULRU DPPGHPRQVWURXPDLRUSUREDELOLGDGHGHSDUWRSUpWHUPR$XOWUDVRQRJUD¿DWUDQVYDJLQDOSRGHPHOKRUDUDDFXUiFLD GLDJQyVWLFDHPJHVWDQWHVVLQWRPiWLFDV
PALAVRAS-CHAVE:*UDYLGH]7UDEDOKRGHSDUWRSUHPDWXUR&RORGR~WHURXOWUDVRQRJUD¿D
Abstract
Purpose:WRDVVHVVWKHUROHRIXOWUDVRQRJUDSKLFFHUYLFDOOHQJWKLQSUHGLFWLQJSUHPDWXUHODERULQSDWLHQWVSUHVHQWLQJSHUVLVWHQW XWHULQHFRQWUDFWLRQVDQGLQWDFWPHPEUDQHVMethods:DSURVSHFWLYHREVHUYDWLRQDOFRKRUWVWXG\ZDVSHUIRUPHGLQ ZRPHQDGPLWWHGWRRXUKRVSLWDOEHWZHHQDQGZHHNVRIJHVWDWLRQ7UDQVYDJLQDOVRQRJUDSKLFHYDOXDWLRQRIWKHFHUYL[ ZDVSHUIRUPHGRQFHLQWKHZRPHQZKRKDGFRPSOHWHGDFRXUVHRISDUHQWHUDOWRFRO\VLV7KHFHUYLFDOOHQJWKZDVREWDLQHG DFFRUGLQJWRFULWHULDUHSRUWHGSUHYLRXVO\&HUYLFDOVRQRJUDSKLF¿QGLQJVZHUHQRWXVHGLQGLDJQRVLVDQGPDQDJHPHQW 2XWFRPHYDULDEOHZDVWKHRFFXUUHQFHRISUHWHUPGHOLYHU\ZHHNV6WDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLVFRQVLVWHGRIXQLYDULDWHPHWKRG
5HFHELGRHP $FHLWRFRPPRGLÀFDo}HVHP
8OWUDVRQRJUDÀDWUDQVYDJLQDOGRFRORSDUDDSUHGLomRGRSDUWRSUpWHUPR
HPSDFLHQWHVVLQWRPiWLFDVFRPEROVDtQWHJUD
7UDQVYDJLQDOXOWUDVRXQGRIWKHFHUYL[IRUSUHGLFWLQJSUHPDWXUHGHOLYHU\LQV\PSWRPDWLFSDWLHQWV ZLWKLQWDFWPHPEUDQHV
/tYLD7HUHVD0RUHLUD5LRV0DUtOLDGD*OyULD0DUWLQV25RV\$QHGH-HVXV%DUURV3*LVHOO\'XDLOLEH-DQVHQ4
&ODXGLR5RGULJXHV3LUHV55RVLDQH0DWWDU6
7UDEDOKRGHVHQYROYLGRQR6HUYLoRGH2EVWHWUtFLDH*LQHFRORJLDGR+RVSLWDO8QLYHUVLWiULRGD8QLYHUVLGDGH)HGHUDOGR0DUDQKmR²8)0$²6mR/XtV 0$²%UDVLO
0pGLFD8OWUDVRQRJUDÀVWD&RRUGHQDGRUDGD&OtQLFDGH,PDJHPGR6HUYLoRGH2EVWHWUtFLDH*LQHFRORJLDGR+RVSLWDO8QLYHUVLGDGH)HGHUDOGR0DUD QKmR²8)0$²6mR/XtV0$²%UDVLO
3URIHVVRUD$GMXQWDGD'LVFLSOLQDGH2EVWHWUtFLD'HSDUWDPHQWRGH0HGLFLQD,,,&KHIHGR6HUYLoRGH2EVWHWUtFLDH*LQHFRORJLDGR+RVSLWDO8QLYHUVL
-WiULR)HGHUDOGR0DUDQKmR²8)0$²6mR/XtV0$²%UDVLO
3URIHVVRUDGR'HSDUWDPHQWRGH0HGLFLQD,,,0pGLFDGR6HWRUGH0HGLFLQD)HWDOGR6HUYLoRGH2EVWHWUtFLDH*LQHFRORJLDGR+RVSLWDO8QLYHUVLWiULRGD 8QLYHUVLGDGH)HGHUDOGR0DUDQKmR²8)0$²6mR/XtV0$²%UDVLO
0pGLFD8OWUDVRQRJUDÀVWDGD&OtQLFDGH,PDJHPGR6HUYLoRGH2EVWHWUtFLDH*LQHFRORJLDGR+RVSLWDO8QLYHUVLWiULRGD8QLYHUVLGDGH)HGHUDOGR0D
-UDQKmR²8)0$²6mR/XtV0$²%UDVLO
3URIHVVRUGR'HSDUWDPHQWRGH2EVWHWUtFLDGD'LVFLSOLQDGH0HGLFLQD)HWDOGD8QLYHUVLGDGH)HGHUDOGH6mR3DXOR²81,)(63²6mR3DXOR63²%UDVLO &RRUGHQDGRUDGD3yV*UDGXDomRGR'HSDUWDPHQWRGH2EVWHWUtFLDGD8QLYHUVLGDGH)HGHUDOGH6mR3DXOR²81,)(63²6mR3DXOR63²%UDVLO &RUUHVSRQGrQFLD/tYLD7HUHVD0RUHLUD5LRV
ZLWKWKHSXUSRVHRIGHWHUPLQLQJWKHVLJQL¿FDQWFRQWULEXWLRQRIFHUYLFDOOHQJWKWRWKHSUHGLFWLRQRISUHWHUPGHOLYHU\7KH
DGRSWHGVLJQL¿FDQFHOHYHOZDVSDQGWKHFRQ¿GHQFHLQWHUYDOZDV&,Results:WKHLQFLGHQFHRI
SUHWHUPGHOLYHU\ZDV&HUYLFDOOHQJWKZDVVLJQL¿FDQWO\DVVRFLDWHGZLWKWKHRXWFRPHS5HFHLYHU RSHUDWLQJFKDUDFWHULVWLFFXUYHDQDO\VLVVKRZHGWKDWDFHUYLFDOOHQJWKRIPPZDVWKHEHVWFXWRIILQSUHGLFWLQJSUHWHUP GHOLYHU\VHQVLWLYLW\VSHFL¿FLW\SRVLWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXH7KH
FDOFXODWHGDUHDXQGHUWKHFXUYHZDV&,SConclusions:DPRQJZRPHQZLWKSHUVLVWHQWXWHULQH
FRQWUDFWLRQVDQGLQWDFWPHPEUDQHVWUHDWHGIRUSUHWHUPODERUDFHUYLFDOOHQJWKRIOHVVWKDQPPGHPRQVWUDWHGDKLJK OLNHOLKRRGRISUHWHUPELUWK7UDQVYDJLQDOXOWUDVRXQGPD\LPSURYHWKHDFFXUDF\RIGLDJQRVLVLQV\PSWRPDWLFZRPHQ KEYWORDS3UHJQDQF\2EVWHWULFODERUSUHPDWXUH&HUYL[XWHULXOWUDVRQRJUDSK\
,QWURGXomR
$LQFLGrQFLDGHUHFpPQDVFLGRVSUHPDWXURV HP GLIHUHQWHV SDtVHV SHUPDQHFH LQDOWHUDGD Ki GpFDGDV DSHVDU GRV LPSRUWDQWHV DYDQoRV QRV FXLGDGRV SHULQDWDLV 0DQWpPVH HQWUH H YDULDQGRHQWUHDVSRSXODo}HVHPIXQomRGRVIDWRUHV
GHULVFRSUHVHQWHV1
(QWUHHGRVSDUWRVSUpWHUPRVVmR HOHWLYRVSRULQGLFDo}HVPDWHUQDVHVSHFLDOPHQWH KHPRUUDJLDV GR WHUFHLUR WULPHVWUH H VtQGURPHV
KLSHUWHQVLYDVRXDJUDYRVIHWDLV$VSULQFLSDLVDIHF
-o}HV PDWHUQDV GHWHUPLQDQWHV GD SUHPDWXULGDGH ´HVSRQWkQHDµ VmR R WUDEDOKR GH SDUWR SUpWHUPR HDUXSWXUDSUHPDWXUDSUpWHUPRGHPHPEUDQDV
GHHOHYDGDSUHYDOrQFLDHGHGLItFLOSUHYHQomR2$
SULPHLUDUHVSRQGHSRUDSUR[LPDGDPHQWHPHWDGH HDVHJXQGDFRQWULEXLFRPGRVSDUWRVDQWHV
GHVHPDQDVGHJUDYLGH]3
$FUHGLWDVH TXH R PHFDQLVPR UHVSRQViYHO SHODLQVWDODomRHVSRQWkQHDGRWUDEDOKRGHSDUWR
HQWUHDaHDaVHPDQDVHMDPXOWLIDWRULDO$JLQ
-GRVLQHUJLFDPHQWHHVVHVIDWRUHVID]HPFRPTXHDV FRQWUDo}HV XWHULQDV LPSURGXWLYDV SUHVHQWHV QD
JUDYLGH]WRUQHPVHSURGXWLYDVGHWHUPLQDQGRGL
-ODWDomRFHUYLFDOFRPFRQVHTHQWHH[SXOVmRIHWDO4
1DSUiWLFDREVWpWULFDRGLDJQyVWLFRGRWUDED
-OKRGHSDUWRSUpWHUPRpUHFRQKHFLGRSHODSUHVHQoD GHFRQWUDo}HVXWHULQDVSHUVLVWHQWHVHPRGLÀFDo}HV
QRFRORDSDJDPHQWRHGLODWDomR5$DIHULomRGRFROR
QHVVDFLUFXQVWkQFLDpVXEMHWLYDHQDPDLRULDGDV
YH]HV GLÀFXOWDGD SHOD PXGDQoD GH SRVLomR IUH
-THQWHGXUDQWHDJUDYLGH]DOpPGLVVRHPPXLWDV PXOKHUHVRFRORpGHGLItFLODFHVVLELOLGDGHDRH[DPH
YDJLQDO6(VVDVOLPLWDo}HVUHGX]HPRVHIHLWRVGRV
FXLGDGRVLQLELGRUHVGRWUDEDOKRGHSDUWR
0XLWRVHVWXGRVWrPGHPRQVWUDGRTXHPDLV
GHGDVPXOKHUHVFRPDPHDoDGHSDUWRSUpWHU
-PRQmRSURJULGHPSDUDWUDEDOKRGHSDUWRHSDUWR
5HVVDOWDPDLQGDTXHRSDUWRSUpWHUPRRFRUUHHP PHQRV GH GDV PXOKHUHV VLQWRPiWLFDV FRP EROVDtQWHJUD(VVHTXDGURHQFRQWUDMXVWLÀFDWLYD
QDFDUrQFLDGHFULWpULRVFOtQLFRVFRQÀiYHLVSDUDR
GLDJQyVWLFRGHWUDEDOKRGHSDUWRSUpWHUPR
$OpP GR WRTXH YDJLQDO D XOWUDVRQRJUDÀD WUDQVYDJLQDOGRFRORUHDOL]DGDDSyVHVYD]LDPHQWR YHVLFDOVXUJHFRPRLPSRUWDQWHPpWRGRDX[LOLDU DRSRVVLELOLWDUDJHUDomRGHLPDJHQVREMHWLYDVTXH
SHUPLWHPUHYLVmRHSDGURQL]DomR
$WUDYpVGDPHGLGDGRFRPSULPHQWRGRFROR YLD XOWUDVRQRJUDÀD YDJLQDO Ki SRVVLELOLGDGH GH FRQÀUPDomRGRDSDJDPHQWRFHUYLFDODQWHVGRWRTXH YDJLQDOMiTXHDGLODWDomRGRRULItFLRLQWHUQRVyp LGHQWLÀFDGDQHVVHPpWRGRTXDQGRDDEHUWXUDHVWi
FRQVLGHUDYHOPHQWHDYDQoDGD12
1RVFDVRVHPTXHDPHGLGDXOWUDVRQRJUiÀFD GRFRPSULPHQWRGRFRORIRLLQIHULRUDPPD
HYROXomRSDUDSDUWRRFRUUHXGHQWURGHWUrVVHPD
-QDV$VHQVLELOLGDGHQDXWLOL]DomRGHVVHOLPLDUIRL
GHSRUpPDHVSHFLÀFLGDGHIRLGH4,13
2XWURVDXWRUHVGHVWDFDUDPTXHXPFRPSULPHQWR FHUYLFDOLQIHULRUDPPpSUHGLWLYRSDUD
SDUWRSUpWHUPRDSHVDUGDWHUDSLDWRFROtWLFD(V
-WXGRVPDLVUHFHQWHVGHPRQVWUDUDPDUHOHYkQFLDGR OLPLDUGHPPSDUDDSUHGLomRGRSDUWRGHQWUR
GHVHWHGLDVHPJHVWDQWHVVLQWRPiWLFDV
(PERUDVHUHFRQKHoDDPHGLGDXOWUDVRQR
-JUiÀFDGRFRPSULPHQWRFHUYLFDOFRPRLPSRUWDQWH YDULiYHO DX[LOLDU DR GLDJQyVWLFR GR WUDEDOKR GH SDUWR SUpWHUPR FRQWULEXLQGR SDUD PLQLPL]DU
SRVVtYHLVLQWHUQDo}HVGHVQHFHVViULDV4KiFRQWUR
-YpUVLDVHQWUHRVHVWXGRVTXDQWRDRSRQWRGHFRUWH DVHUDGRWDGRSDUDDSUHGLomRGRSDUWRSUpWHUPR HVSRQWkQHRHPJHVWDQWHVFRPFRQWUDo}HVXWHULQDV
SHUVLVWHQWHVHEROVDtQWHJUD
0pWRGRV
5HDOL]RXVHHVWXGRREVHUYDFLRQDOSURVSHFWL
-YRGRWLSRFRRUWHFRPDPRVWUDFRQVHFXWLYDQDTXDO IRUDPLQFOXtGDVWRGDVDVJHVWDQWHVFRPFRQWUDo}HV XWHULQDV SHUVLVWHQWHV EROVD tQWHJUD H JHVWDomR
~QLFDHQWUHDaHDDVHPDQDLQWHUQDGDVSDUD
WUDWDPHQWRHVSHFLDOL]DGRQD&OtQLFD2EVWpWULFDGR 6HUYLoRGH2EVWHWUtFLDH*LQHFRORJLDGR+RVSLWDO 8QLYHUVLWiULRGD8)0$HQWUHGHQRYHPEURGH HGH]HPEURGH
)RUDPH[FOXtGDVDVJHVWDQWHVTXHDSUHVHQWD
-UDPGLODWDomRFHUYLFDOVXSHULRUDFPVDQJUDPHQ
-WRYDJLQDOSROLGUDPQLDPDOIRUPDomRFRQJrQLWD FHUFODJHPSUpYLDVLQDLVGHFRULRDPQLRQLWHFOtQLFD HUHVWULomRGHFUHVFLPHQWRLQWUDXWHULQR
$VJHVWDQWHVVHOHFLRQDGDVDVVLQDUDPRWHUPR GHFRQVHQWLPHQWROLYUHHHVFODUHFLGRHHPVHJXLGD IRUDPVXEPHWLGDVDHVWXGRXOWUDVRQRJUiÀFR
2V REVWHWUDV DVVLVWHQWHV GHWHUPLQDUDP D KRVSLWDOL]DomR H R WUDWDPHQWR PHGLFDPHQWRVR
TXHFRQVLVWLXHPWRFyOLVHFRPWHUEXWDOLQDHQGRYH
-QRVDSRUKRUDVHFRUWLFRWHUDSLDDQWHQDWDOFRP GH[DPHWDVRQDPJGLDLQWUDPXVFXODUGXUDQWH KRUDV
$ LGDGH JHVWDFLRQDO IRL GHWHUPLQDGD SHOD KLVWyULD PHQVWUXDO DQiOLVH GH XOWUDVRQRJUDÀDV
DQWHULRUHVGLVSRQtYHLVSUHIHUHQFLDOPHQWHSHODPH
-GLGDGRFRPSULPHQWRFDEHoDQiGHJDVQRSULPHLUR WULPHVWUHHSHODELRPHWULDFRUUHQWH6HKRXYHVVH GLVFUHSkQFLDVXSHULRUDGH]GLDVHQWUHDKLVWyULD PHQVWUXDOHRVH[DPHVXOWUDVRQRJUiÀFRVDLGDGH JHVWDFLRQDOXOWUDVRQRJUiÀFDHUDDGRWDGD
$VJHVWDQWHVIRUDPVXEPHWLGDVDHVWXGRXO
-WUDVRQRJUiÀFRHPPpGLDKRUDVDSyV DLQWHUQDomRQDHQIHUPDULDGHJHVWDQWHVGHDOWR ULVFR DSyV FRPSOHWDGR QR PtQLPR R SULPHLUR FLFORGHWRFyOLVHHQGRYHQRVDVHQGRHVWHRPDUFR ]HURGHHQWUDGDGDJHVWDQWHQDFRRUWH8P~QLFR H[DPLQDGRU UHDOL]RX R H[DPH XOWUDVRQRJUiÀFR SDUDDIHULUELRPHWULDPRUIRORJLDHYLWDOLGDGHIHWDLV DOpPGRFRPSULPHQWRGRFROR
2HVWXGRXOWUDVRQRJUiÀFRGRFRORIRLUHDOL
-]DGRSHODYLDYDJLQDODSyVFRPSOHWRHVYD]LDPHQWR
YHVLFDO$JHVWDQWHIRLFRORFDGDHPSRVLomRJLQHFR
-OyJLFDHPGHF~ELWRGRUVDOFRPDVSHUQDVDEGX
-]LGDV'HSRLVGHUHFREHUWRSRUSUHVHUYDWLYRHVWpULO QmROXEULÀFDGRFRQWHQGRSHTXHQDTXDQWLGDGHGH JHOWUDQVPLVVRUHPVHXUHVHUYDWyULRHVREUHVXD H[WUHPLGDGH R WUDQVGXWRU IRL LQWURGX]LGR OHQWD H FXLGDGRVDPHQWH DWp R IyUQLFH YDJLQDO DQWHULRU HPDQWLGRQRWHUoRGLVWDOGRFDQDOYDJLQDODÀP
GHVHREWHUYLVWDVDJLWDOGRFRORFRPPXFRVDHQ
-GRFHUYLFDOHYLGHQFLDGDDRORQJRGRFDQDOFHUYLFDO WRPDQGRVHRFXLGDGRQHFHVViULRSDUDQmRH[HUFHU
SUHVVmRVREUHRFRORDORQJDQGRRLQGHYLGDPHQWH )RUDPLGHQWLÀFDGRVRVRULItFLRVH[WHUQRHLQWHUQR RFDQDOFHUYLFDOHDPXFRVDHQGRFHUYLFDO
&DVRRRULItFLRLQWHUQRHVWLYHVVHIHFKDGRD PHGLGDOLQHDUGRFRPSULPHQWRHUDHIHWXDGDGHVGH DiUHDWULDQJXODUGRRULItFLRLQWHUQRDWpDLQFLVXUD HP IRUPD GH ´9µ GR RULItFLR H[WHUQR 4XDQGR R RULItFLRLQWHUQRVHHQFRQWUDYDDEHUWRFRPPDLVGH PPRFRPSULPHQWRGRFRORIXQFLRQDOGHÀQLGR FRPR GLVWkQFLD GD SRUomR RFOXtGD UHVLGXDO HUD PHQVXUDGRVHPPDQREUDGHFRPSUHVVmRI~QGLFD RXVXSUDS~ELFD)LJXUD)RUDPUHDOL]DGDVWUrV
PHGLGDVQDDXVrQFLDGHPXGDQoDFHUYLFDOGLQk
-PLFDVHQGRDPpGLDGDVPHGLGDVGRFRPSULPHQWR UHJLVWUDGD HP PLOtPHWURV &DVR IRVVH YHULÀFDGD SUHVHQoDGHPXGDQoDFHUYLFDOGLQkPLFDGXUDQWHR H[DPHWUrVRXWUDVPHGLGDVHUDPUHDOL]DGDVDSyV VXDFHVVDomRFRPPpGLDDQRWDGD2WHPSRPpGLR GHH[DPHSDUDRHVWXGRXOWUDVRQRJUiÀFRFHUYLFDO IRLGHVHWHPLQXWRV
2UHVXOWDGRGRH[DPHXOWUDVRQRJUiÀFRGR FROR YLD YDJLQDO QmR IRL GLVSRQLELOL]DGR j HTXLSH PpGLFDDVVLVWHQWHTXHREWHYHDSHQDVLQIRUPDo}HV
XOWUDVRQRJUiÀFDVURWLQHLUDVDUHVSHLWRGHSDUk
-PHWURVELRPpWULFRVHPRUIROyJLFRVIHWDLVDOpPGDV FRQGLo}HVGREHPHVWDUIHWDO
$V JHVWDQWHV IRUDP REVHUYDGDV DWp R SDUWR
LGHQWLÀFDQGRVHTXDLVGHODVSDULUDPDQWHVGDVH
-PDQDRXDWHUPRREMHWLYDQGRFRPSDUDo}HVTXDQWR DYDULiYHOLQGHSHQGHQWHGRFRPSULPHQWRFHUYLFDO
2WDPDQKRGDDPRVWUDIRLHVWLPDGRHP
JHVWDQWHVGLVWULEXtGDVLJXDOPHQWHHPFDGDJUX
-SRDGPLWLQGRVHXPDGLIHUHQoDGHPPHQWUH PpGLDVSDUDDYDULiYHOFRPSULPHQWRFHUYLFDOQRV GRLVJUXSRVPXOKHUHVTXHSDULUDPDQWHVGD VHPDQDHPXOKHUHVTXHSDULUDPDWHUPR2GHVYLR SDGUmRDGRWDGRSDUDDIHULUDGLVSHUVmRGDVPpGLDV
Figura 1 ±0HGLGDXOWUDVRQRJUi¿FDGRFRPSULPHQWRGRFRORYLDYDJLQDO&RPRRRULIt
IRLGHPP2SRGHUGRWHVWHXWLOL]DGRHRQtYHO GHVLJQLÀFkQFLDǂIRUDPÀ[DGRVHPH UHVSHFWLYDPHQWHSDUDXPDDQiOLVHELFDXGDO
$SyV WHVWDU D QRUPDOLGDGH GDV YDULiYHLV
TXDQWLWDWLYDVUHDOL]RXVHUHJUHVVmRORJtVWLFDXQL
-YDULDGD REMHWLYDQGR LGHQWLÀFDU D VLJQLÀFkQFLD HVWDWtVWLFDGDDVVRFLDomRGRFRPSULPHQWRFHUYLFDO DRSDUWRSUpWHUPR2QtYHOGHVLJQLÀFkQFLDǂGH
IRLDGRWDGRSDUDUHMHLWDUDKLSyWHVHGHLQGHSHQ
-GrQFLDHQWUHHVVDVYDULiYHLV
3DUDGHÀQLUXPSRQWRGHFRUWHSDUDRFRP
-SULPHQWR FHUYLFDO REVHUYRXVH LQLFLDOPHQWH D PHGLDQD(PVHJXLGDSDUDGHÀQLURPHOKRUOLPLDU IRLFRQVWUXtGDFXUYDGHFDUDFWHUtVWLFDRSHUDWyULDGR
UHFHSWRU52&DSyVPHGLGDVGRVtQGLFHVVHQVL
-ELOLGDGHHHVSHFLÀFLGDGHDGRWDQGRVHRSRQWRGH PHOKRUFRQWUDEDODQoRHQWUHHOHV
3DUD DYDOLDU R GHVHPSHQKR GR PpWRGR XO
-WUDVRQRJUiILFR FRPR WHVWH GLDJQyVWLFR IRUDP PHQVXUDGRVVHQVLELOLGDGHHVSHFLÀFLGDGHYDORUHV SUHGLWLYRVHDFXUiFLD
(VWDSHVTXLVDIRLDSURYDGDSHOR&RPLWrGHeWLFD HP3HVTXLVDGR+RVSLWDO8QLYHUVLWiULRGD8)0$
5HVXOWDGRV
)RUDPLQFOXtGDVJHVWDQWHVFRPFRQWUDo}HV XWHULQDVSHUVLVWHQWHVHEROVDtQWHJUDLQWHUQDGDVQD
&OtQLFD2EVWpWULFDGR6HUYLoRGH2EVWHWUtFLDH*L
-QHFRORJLDGR+RVSLWDO8QLYHUVLWiULRGD8)0$1R VHJXLPHQWRSHUGHUDPVHVHWHJHVWDQWHV$DPRVWUD ÀQDOGHVWHHVWXGRIRLGHPXOKHUHV
1R PRPHQWR GD HQWUDGD QD FRRUWH KRXYH
PDLRUSHUFHQWXDOGHPXOKHUHVFRPLGDGHJHVWD
-FLRQDOHQWUHDHDVHPDQDPXOKHUHV
(QWUHWDQWRGHQWUHDVSDFLHQWHVTXHSD
-ULUDPSUHPDWXUDPHQWHQmRKRXYHGLIHUHQoDSUR
-SRUFLRQDOHQWUHDVTXHSDULUDPDWpDaVHPDQD
RXHQWUHDDHDaVHPDQD4XDQWRjSDULGDGH
SUHGRPLQDUDPPXOKHUHVFRPXPRXPDLVSDUWRV DQWHULRUHVPXOKHUHVVHPKLVWyULDGH SDUWRSUpWHUPRDQWHULRUPXOKHUHV
$ PDLRULD GDV SDFLHQWHV SHUPDQHFHX LQ
-WHUQDGD SRU XP SHUtRGR LQIHULRU D GH] GLDV PXOKHUHV2SDUWRSUpWHUPRRFRUUHXHP
PXOKHUHV VHQGR QR SH
-UtRGR GD KRVSLWDOL]DomR HP LGDGHV JHVWDFLRQDLV TXHYDULDUDPHQWUHHVHPDQDV'HVWDVVHLV SDFLHQWHV UHFHEHUDP DOWD KRVSLWDODU DSyV WHPSR PpGLRGHSHUPDQrQFLDKRVSLWDODUGHGLDV HVXEVHTHQWHPHQWHIRUDPUHDGPLWLGDVHSDULUDP
DQWHVGDaVHPDQD
(QWUHRVDVSHFWRVFOtQLFRVGHFDGDJUXSRVH
-JXQGRRGHVIHFKRSDUWRSUpWHUPRRXSDUWRDWHUPR QmRVHREVHUYRXGLIHUHQoDVLJQLÀFDQWH6LJQLÀFkQFLD HVWDWtVWLFD IRL YHULÀFDGD QD LGDGH SRU RFDVLmR GR SDUWRHQRLQWHUYDORDGPLVVmRSDUWR7DEHOD
2FRPSULPHQWRFHUYLFDODVVRFLRXVHGHIRUPD
VLJQLÀFDWLYD DR GHVIHFKR GD JHVWDomR 8P FRP
-SULPHQWRGHFRORLQIHULRUDPPSUHYDOHFHXHP GDVJHVWDQWHVTXHSDULUDPSUHPDWXUDPHQWH HQTXDQWRGDVJHVWDQWHVTXHSDULUDPDWHUPR WLYHUDPFRPSULPHQWRFHUYLFDOLJXDORXVXSHULRUD PPS
$ )LJXUD PRVWUD D FXUYD 52& GR FRP
-SULPHQWR FHUYLFDO QD DPRVWUD HVWXGDGD $ iUHD FDOFXODGD DEDL[R GD FXUYD IRL GH ,& S2YDORUTXHFRQWHPSODPDLRU
VHQVLELOLGDGHVHPDXPHQWDUDWD[DGHIDOVRVSRVL
-WLYRVHVWiUHSUHVHQWDGRQRRPEURGDFXUYD52&H FRUUHVSRQGHDPP
Tabela 1 -&DUDFWHUtVWLFDVFOtQLFDVGDVJHVWDQWHVFRPFRQWUDo}HVXWHULQDVSHUVLVWHQWHVHEROVDtQWHJUDVHJXQGRRFRUUrQFLDGHSDUWRSUpWHUPR
Parto pré-termo
p
Sim (n=23) Não (n=22)
Idade (anos)* 23 (16-31) 24 (17-37)
Paridade (n)**
1XOtSDUD
8PRXPDLVSDUWRV
,GDGHJHVWDFLRQDOVHPDQDV
1DDGPLVVmR
1RSDUWR
,QWHUYDORDGPLVVmRSDUWRGLDV
3HUPDQrQFLDKRVSLWDODUGLDV
*Valor de p obtido pelo teste binomial.
$7DEHODH[SUHVVDRVYDORUHVGRVtQGLFHV GLDJQyVWLFRVVHQVLELOLGDGHHHVSHFLÀFLGDGHSDUD GLIHUHQWHVSRQWRVGHFRUWHGRFRPSULPHQWRFHUYLFDO 2EVHUYRXVHTXHRPHOKRUFRQWUDEDODQoRRFRUUHX TXDQGRVHDGRWRXROLPLDUGHPPDOFDQoDQGR VHVHQVLELOLGDGHGH,&>@H HVSHFLÀFLGDGH,&>²@
2EVHUYRXVHTXHXPFRPSULPHQWRFHUYLFDOLQ
-IHULRUDPPIRLSUHGLWLYRGHSDUWRSUpWHUPR FRPYDORUSUHGLWLYRQHJDWLYRGHDVVRFLDQGRVH DXPDVHQVLELOLGDGHGHHDXPDHVSHFLÀFLGDGH GH3RURXWURODGRDSUHGLomRQHJDWLYDGH
IRLDOFDQoDGDFRPFRPSULPHQWRFHUYLFDOLJXDORXVX
-SHULRUDPPOLPLDUTXHFRPELQRXVHQVLELOLGDGHGH HHVSHFLÀFLGDGHGHQDDPRVWUDHVWXGDGD FRPYDORUSUHGLWLYRSRVLWLYRGH7DEHOD
'LVFXVVmR
2GLDJQyVWLFRGRWUDEDOKRGHSDUWRSUpWHUPR IUHTHQWHPHQWHWRUQDVHXPGLOHPDFOtQLFR(VVH
TXDGURHQFRQWUDMXVWLÀFDWLYDQDFDUrQFLDGHFRQ
-Comprimento cervical
100- Especificidade 100
80
60 40
20
0 0
20 40 60
80 100
15
20 25
_
_
_
_
_
_
_
_ _
_
_ _
_ _ _
_ _ _
_ _
_
_ _ _ _
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
Figura 2&XUYDGHFDUDFWHUtVWLFDRSHUDWyULDGRUHFHSWRUGRFRPSULPHQWRFHUYLFDO
SDUDDSUHGLomRGRSDUWRSUpWHUPRÈUHDFDOFXODGDDEDL[RGDFXUYD,& S
Tabela 3 -9DORUHVSUHGLWLYRVHDFXUiFLDGRFRPSULPHQWRFHUYLFDOGHJHVWDQWHVVLQWRPiWLFDVSDUDDSUHGLomRGRSDUWRSUpWHUPR
Comprimento cervical (mm) Valor preditivo positivo (%) Valor preditivo negativo (%) Acurácia (%)
<30
<25
<20
<15
<10
Tabela 2 -ËQGLFHVGLDJQyVWLFRVGRFRPSULPHQWRFHUYLFDOGHJHVWDQWHVVLQWRPiWLFDVSDUDDSUHGLomRGRSDUWRSUpWHUPR
Comprimento cervical (mm) Sensibilidade (IC 95%) (VSHFLÀFLGDGH,&
<10 ± ±
<15 ± ±
<20 ± ±
<25 ± ±
<30 ± ±
FRUGkQFLDGHGHÀQLo}HVRXGHPpWRGRVFRQÀiYHLV
SDUDGLDJQRVWLFiOR
$ PDLRULD GRV HVWXGRV UHDOL]DGRV HP JHV
-WDQWHVVLQWRPiWLFDVH[FOXLRVFDVRVFRPDYDQoDGR WUDEDOKR GH SDUWR SUpWHUPR QRV TXDLV QmR Ki G~YLGD GLDJQyVWLFD RX SURJQyVWLFD 3DUD WDQWR HYLWDVHDLQFOXVmRGHJHVWDQWHVQDVSULPHLUDV KRUDVGDKRVSLWDOL]DomR$JLQGRGHVVDPDQHLUD UHVWDUmR RV FDVRV GXYLGRVRV FXMR FRPSULPHQWR FHUYLFDOXOWUDVRQRJUiÀFRSRGHVHUIUXWtIHURVHQGR
XPGLIHUHQFLDOQDUHGXomRGDWD[DGHIDOVRSRVLWL
-YR&RPHVVHSURFHGLPHQWRWDPEpPDGRWDGR
HP QRVVR HVWXGR D UHDOL]DomR GR H[DPH XOWUD VRQRJUiÀFRVyIRLHIHWLYDGDDSyVSHORPHQRVD WRFyOLVH HQGRYHQRVD LQLFLDO $OWHUQDWLYDPHQWH DFUHGLWiYDPRVHVWDUPLQLPL]DQGRXPSRVVtYHOYLpV GHDIHULomRMiTXHDPHGLFDomRWRFROtWLFDUHGX]DV FRQWUDo}HVXWHULQDVSHUPLWLQGRDDYDOLDomRGHXP FRORPHQRVSURSHQVRDPRGLÀFDo}HVGHWHUPLQDGDV
SHODDomRFRQWUiWLOPLRPHWULDOHPERUDUHFRQKH
-oDPRVTXHVRPHQWHXPHVWXGRSDUHDGRDIHULQGR RFRPSULPHQWRGRFRORDQWHVHGHSRLVGDWRFyOLVH SRGHULD GHPRQVWUDU D H[LVWrQFLD GH GLIHUHQoDV HVWDWLVWLFDPHQWHVLJQLÀFDQWHV
(PQRVVDFDVXtVWLFDDLQFLGrQFLDGHSDUWR
SUpWHUPRIRLGH(VVDRFRUUrQFLDLQWHUPH
-GLiULDIRLUHODWDGDHPHVWXGRVDQWHULRUHV
HPERUD RXWUDV SHVTXLVDV UHVVDOWHP TXH R SDUWR SUpWHUPRRFRUUHHPPHQRVGHGDVPXOKHUHV
VLQWRPiWLFDVFRPEROVDtQWHJUDTXHQmRpVXEV
-WDQFLDOPHQWHGLIHUHQWHGDLQFLGrQFLDHVSHUDGDQD
SRSXODomRDVVLQWRPiWLFD14
3DUDDGHÀQLomRGRPHOKRUSRQWRGHFRUWH SDUDDSUHGLomRGRSDUWRSUpWHUPRQDVJHVWDQWHV
FRPFRQWUDo}HVXWHULQDVSHUVLVWHQWHVHEROVDtQ
-WHJUDQDVTXDLVRWUDEDOKRGHSDUWRSUpWHUPRp XPGLDJQyVWLFRSODXVtYHOHDLQWHQomRpHYLWDUQD PHGLGDGRSRVVtYHOXPUHVXOWDGRIDOVRSRVLWLYR
DGRWDPRVDHVWUDWpJLDGHPHOKRUDUDHVSHFLÀFLGD
-GHHPGHWULPHQWRGDVHQVLELOLGDGHVHPSHUGHURV FDVRVGHYHUGDGHLURSRVLWLYR$VVXPLPRVHQWmRR YDORUGHPPFRPRSRQWRGHFRUWHPHVPROLPLDU
DGRWDGR SRU RXWURV SHVTXLVDGRUHV13 (QWUHWDQWR
RXWURV HVWXGRV QmR XWLOL]DUDP HVVH FULWpULR SRU SULRUL]DUHP D VHQVLELOLGDGH H XP YDORU SUHGLWLYR
QHJDWLYRDOWRHOHYDQGRRSRQWRGHFRUWH
9HULÀFDPRV TXH XP FRPSULPHQWR FHUYLFDO LQIHULRUDPPRFRUUHXHPGDVJHVWDQWHV TXH SDULUDP SUHPDWXUDPHQWH $ DGRomR GHVVH SRQWRGHFRUWHGHPRQVWURXVHQVLELOLGDGHGH HVSHFLÀFLGDGHGHYDORUSUHGLWLYRSRVLWLYRGH YDORUSUHGLWLYRQHJDWLYRGHHDFXUiFLD GH1RVVRVtQGLFHVGLDJQyVWLFRVHRVYDORUHV
SUHGLWLYRVIRUDPGLVFRUGDQWHVGRVREWLGRVHPSHV
-TXLVDVDQWHULRUHVQDVTXDLVRVYDORUHVDOFDQoDGRV
IRUDPPDLVEDL[RV&RQYpPVDOLHQWDUTXHHVVHV
SHVTXLVDGRUHVUHDOL]DUDPRHVWXGRXOWUDVRQRJUiÀ
-FRDLQGDQDDGPLVVmRFRPRWHVWHGHUDVWUHDPHQWR DGMXYDQWHDQWHVGDKRVSLWDOL]DomRHGRLQtFLRGD WRFyOLVHHQGRYHQRVD
(PQRVVRWUDEDOKRXPFRPSULPHQWRFHUYLFDO GHPPDSUHVHQWRXVHFRPRRYDORUTXHDVVRFLD VHQVLELOLGDGHGHHHVSHFLÀFLGDGHGH
FRPYDORUSUHGLWLYRSRVLWLYRGHHYDORUSUH
-GLWLYRQHJDWLYRGHOLPLDUMiVXVWHQWDGRHP
RXWURVWUDEDOKRV12,21,22FXMRVUHVXOWDGRVGHPRQVWUD
-UDPtQGLFHVGLDJQyVWLFRVHYDORUHVSUHGLWLYRVVHPH
-OKDQWHV(VWXGRVSUpYLRVDGRWDQGRRPHVPROLPLDU
GLDJQyVWLFRHQFRQWUDUDPUHVXOWDGRVGLIHUHQWHV
3RVVtYHOH[SOLFDomRSDUDHVVDGLVSDULGDGHUHVLGH QDXWLOL]DomRGHDPRVWUDPLVWDJHVWDo}HV~QLFDV HJHVWDo}HVJHPHODUHV
+RXYHHYLGrQFLDVLJQLÀFDWLYDGHDVVRFLDomR HQWUHDPHGLGDOLQHDUGDSRUomRFHUYLFDORFOXtGD HRGHVIHFKRGDJHVWDomRQHVWHHVWXGR3RUWDQWR
DYLJLOkQFLDFXLGDGRVDGHJHVWDQWHVFXMRFRPSUL
-PHQWRGRFRORVHDSUHVHQWDLQIHULRUDPPDSyV
RSULPHLURFLFORGHWRFROtWLFRVHQGRYHQRVRVpSUX
-GHQWH6HPG~YLGDRPDLRUEHQHItFLRGRPpWRGRp DUHGXomRGHLQWHUYHQo}HVGHVQHFHVViULDVQDTXHODV FRPFRPSULPHQWRFHUYLFDOVXSHULRUDPP
'RSRQWRGHYLVWDGHSHVTXLVDVHULDFRQYH
-QLHQWH GHWHUPLQDU VH D PHGLGD GR FRPSULPHQWR FHUYLFDOGHYHULDVHUUHDOL]DGDDQWHVQDDGPLVVmR RX GHSRLV DSyV WRFyOLVH RX DLQGD HP RXWURV LQWHUYDORV WHPSRUDLV VHTHQFLDLV %DVHDQGRVH QHVVDSUHPLVVDGHFLGLUVHLDSHODKRVSLWDOL]DomR HDGPLQLVWUDomRGHWRFROtWLFRVHFRUWLFRVWHUyLGHV HP IXQomR GRV FXVWRV RSHUDFLRQDLV H GRV ULVFRV PDWHUQRIHWDLVUHVSHFWLYDPHQWH
Agradecimentos
$JUDGHFHPRV j SURIHVVRUD 'UD $OFLRQH 0LUDQGDHD&DUORV6HUUDSHODVFRQWULEXLo}HVQD UHDOL]DomRGHVWHPDQXVFULWR
5HIHUrQFLDV
5R]HQEHUJ3*LOOHW$9LOOH<7UDQVYDJLQDOVRQRJUDSKLF H[DPLQDWLRQRIWKHFHUYL[LQDV\PSWRPDWLFSUHJQDQW ZRPHQUHYLHZRIWKHOLWHUDWXUH8OWUDVRXQG2EVWHW *\QHFRO
7XFNHU-0*ROGHQEHUJ5/'DYLV52&RSSHU5/ :LQNOHU&/+DXWK-&(WLRORJLHVRISUHWHUPELUWK LQ D LQGLJHQW SRSXODWLRQ LV SUHYHQWLRQ D ORJLFDO H[SHFWDWLRQ"2EVWHW*\QHFRO 2GLER $2 8UDO 6+ 0DFRQHV *$ 7KH SURVSHFWV
D FHQWUDO UROH" 8OWUDVRXQG 2EVWHW *\QHFRO
,DPV -' &HUYLFDO XOWUDVRQRJUDSK\ 8OWUDVRXQG 2EVWHW*\QHFRO
*RQLN%&UHDV\5.3UHWHUPODERULWVGLDJQRVLVDQG PDQDJHPHQW$P-2EVWHW*\QHFRO 0LFKDHOV:+0RQWJRPHU\&.DUR-7HPSOH-$FHU
-2OVRQ-8OWUDVRXQGGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQRIWKHFRPSHWHQW IURPWKHLQFRPSHWHQWFHUYL[SUHYHQWLRQRISUHWHUP GHOLYHU\$P-2EVWHW*\QHFRO 0DFRQHV *$ 6HJHO 6< 6WDPLOLR '0 0RUJDQ 0$
3UHGLFWLQJ GHOLYHU\ ZLWKLQ KRXUV LQ ZRPHQ WUHDWHG ZLWK SDUHQWHUDO WRFRO\VLV 2EVWHW *\QHFRO
.LQJ -) *UDQW $ .HLUVH 0- &KDOPHUV , %HWD PLPHWLFV LQ SUHWHUP ODERXU DQ RYHUYLHZ RI WKH UDQGRPL]HGFRQWUROOHGWULDOV%U-2EVWHW*\QDHFRO
7VRL ( $NPDO 6 5DQH 6 2WLJEDK & 1LFRODLGHV .+ 8OWUDVRXQG DVVHVVPHQW RI FHUYLFDO OHQJWK LQ WKUHDWHQHG SUHWHUP ODERU 8OWUDVRXQG 2EVWHW *\QHFRO
$QGHUVHQ +) 1XJHQW &( :DQW\ 6' +D\DVKL 5+ 3UHGLFWLRQ RI ULVN IRU SUHWHUP GHOLYHU\ E\ XOWUDVRQRJUDSKLF PHDVXUHPHQW RI FHUYLFDO OHQJWK $P-2EVWHW*\QHFRO
%HUJKHOOD9.XKOPDQ.:HLQHU67H[HLUD/:DSQHU 5-&HUYLFDOIXQQHOLQJVRQRJUDSKLFFULWHULDSUHGLFWLYH RI SUHWHUP GHOLYHU\ 8OWUDVRXQG 2EVWHW *\QHFRO
0XUDNDZD + 8WXPL 7 +DVHJDZD , 7DQDND . )X]LPRUL5(YDOXDWLRQRIWKUHDWHQHGSUHWHUPGHOLYHU\ E\ WUDQVYDJLQDO XOWUDVRQRJUDSKLF PHDVXUHPHQW RI FHUYLFDOOHQJWK2EVWHW*\QHFRO ,DPV -' *ROGHQEHUJ 5/ 0HLV 3- 0HUFHU %0
0RDZDG$'DV$HWDO7KHOHQJWKRIWKHFHUYL[DQG WKHULVNRIVSRQWDQHRXVSUHPDWXUHGHOLYHU\1(QJO -0HG
7VRL()XFKV,%5DQH6*HHUWV/1LFRODLGHV.+ 6RQRJUDSKLF PHDVXUHPHQW RI FHUYLFDO OHQJWK LQ WKUHDWHQHG SUHWHUP ODERU LQ VLQJOHWRQ SUHJQDQFLHV ZLWKLQWDFWPHPEUDQHV8OWUDVRXQG2EVWHW*\QHFRO
+ROVW50-DFREVVRQ%+DJEHUJ+:HQQHUKROP 8% &HUYLFDO OHQJWK LQ ZRPDQ LQ SUHWHUP ODERU ZLWK LQWDFW PHPEUDQHV UHODWLRQVKLS WR LQWUD DPQLRWLFLQÁDPPDWLRQPLFURELDOLQYDVLRQFHUYLFDO
LQIODPPDWLRQ DQG SUHWHUP GHOLYHU\ 8OWUDVRXQG 2EVWHW*\QHFRO
/HLWLFK + %UXQEDXHU 0 .DLGHU $ (JDUWHU & +XVVOHLQ3&HUYLFDOOHQJWKDQGGLODWLRQRIWKHFHUYLFDO RVGHWHFWHGE\YDJLQDOXOWUDVRQRJUDSK\DVPDUNHUV IRUSUHWHUPGHOLYHU\DV\VWHPDWLFUHYLHZ$P-2EVWHW *\QHFRO
+RQHVW+%DFKPDQQ/0&RRPDUDVDP\$*XSWD-. .OHLMQHQ-.KDQ6$FFXUDF\RIFHUYLFDOWUDQVYDJLQDO VRQRJUDSK\LQSUHGLFWLQJSUHWHUPELUWKDV\VWHPDWLF UHYLHZ 8OWUDVRXQG 2EVWHW *\QHFRO
&UDQH -0 9DQ GHQ +RI 0 $UPVRQ %$ /LVWRQ 5 7UDQVYDJLQDOXOWUDVRXQGLQWKHSUHGLFWLRQRISUHWHUP GHOLYHU\ VLQJOHWRQ DQG WZLQ JHVWDWLRQV 2EVWHW *\QHFRO
5DJHWK -& .HUQHQ % 6DXUHQPDQQ ( 8QJHU & 3UHPDWXUH FRQWUDFWLRQV SRVVLEOH LQIOXHQFH RI VRQRJUDSKLF PHDVVXUHPHQW RI FHUYLFDO OHQJWK RQ FOLQLFDO PDQDJHPHQW 8OWUDVRXQG 2EVWHW *\QHFRO
*RPH]5*DODVVR05RPHUR50D]RU06RURNLQ < *RQoDOYHV / 7UHDGZHOO 0 8OWUDVRQRJUDSKLF H[DPLQDWLRQ RI WKH XWHULQH FHUYL[ LV EHWWHU WKDQ FHUYLFDO GLJLWDO H[DPLQDWLRQ DV D SUHGLFWRU RI WKH OLNHKRRG RI SUHPDWXUH GHOLYHU\ LQ SDWLHQWV ZLWK SUHWHUPODERUDQGLQWDFWPHPEUDQHV$P-2EVWHW *\QHFRO
&HWLQ0&HWLQ$7KHUROHRIWUDQVYDJLQDOVRQRJUDSK\ LQ SUHGLFWLQJ UHFXUUHQW SUHWHUP ODERXU LQ SDWLHQWV ZLWKLQWDFWPHPEUDQHV(XU-2EVWHW*\QHFRO5HSURG %LRO
9HQGLWHOOL ) 0DPHOOH 1 0XQR] ) -DQN\ ( 7UDQVYDJLQDOXOWUDVRQRJUDSK\RIWKHXWHULQHFHUYL[ LQ KRVSLWDOL]HG ZRPHQ ZLWK SUHWHUP ODERU ,QW -*\QDHFRO2EVWHW
,DPV -' 3DUDVNRV - /DQGRQ 0% 7HWHULV -1 -RKQVRQ))&HUYLFDOVRQRJUDSK\LQSUHWHUPODERU 2EVWHW*\QHFRO
,DPV-'3UHGLFWLRQDQGHDUO\GHWHFWLRQRISUHWHUP ODERU2EVWHW*\QHFRO