A Statistical Comparison of Nine Rock Failure Criteria

!

σ σ σ

₁

>

₂

>

₃"

#

$ % & '

( &

)

*) ,&

+

,

-./ 0 + -1/

2

-./ -1/

3 & 4, !&,"

40 40 1551 0&6 & !.378" &

!.38." ( 49 !(9" & : , !&:" & % !&%"

: %

$

-./ -1/

ANALELE UNIVERSITĂłII

“EFTIMIE MURGU” RE IłA

2.

! "

& 4, !&,"

-;/ $ ! "

max

τ

<2 !."*

i n

S

µ

σ

τ

=

0

+

_!."

:

S

₀

µ

₀

'

τ

τ

+ &

<2 !1"*

3 0

1

σ

σ

=C +q

!1"

:

)

2

4

(

tan

]

)

1

[(

µ

2

+

.5

+

µ

2

=

2

π

+

φ

=

_{i i}

q

!;"

1

σ

#

σ

₃

,5

ϕ

2 a t a n (µ₀)

2

# $ !%

m

s

0 -=/

<2 !="*

s C m

C +

+ =

0 3 0 3 1

σ

σ

m

s

#

1

σ

σ

3

:

m

$

1

s

=

$

s

=

0

->/

& # $' $ !% (' )) *

+ 0 ->/

1

σ

σ

3 *

a ci b

s

m

)

(

3 3

1

=

+

_σ

+

σ

σ

σ

!>"

b

m

m

_i <2 !7"*













−

−

=

D

GSI

m

m

_{b i}

14

28

100

exp(

!7" ci

σ

s

a !<2 !8" ! ?""

@ *













−

−

=

D

GSI

s

3

9

100

exp(

!8"

           − −      − + = 3 20 exp( 15 (exp( 6 1 2 1 GSI

a

!?"

!A' "

$ 2

5 ! " . ! "

+ # $%

0&6 + 0

+ & 6 !&6" -7/

) (

,HB t

c

HBMN q LM p p

f = − −

!3"

: 3 3 , = ₊ f f

M_cHB

and

3 2 3 , = ₊ f f

M _eHB

!.5"

3

3

, + +σ

= f

HB Mc

f

p_t

!.."

% .

δ

=

M

_{e M C,}

/

M

_{c M C,} -.;/*

ϑ

δ

δ

δ

θ

cos 1 1 2 3 ) (

2_{− +}

=

L

_!.1"

                >         + − − + − − = <         + − − + − = 0 ) 3 ( sin ) 1 ( 2 ) 1 ( 27 1 arccos 6 1 3 0 ) 3 ( sin ) 1 ( 2 ) 1 ( 27 1 arccos 6 1 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 θ θ δ δ δ δ π ϑ θ θ δ δ δ δ ϑ for for !.;"

θ

        ₋ = 5 . 1 2 3 2 3 3 arcsin 3 1 J J

θ

!.=" 2

J J₃

, - ./0 '

& -8/

!_{σ1 >σ2 =σ3}"

!_{σ1 =σ2 >σ3}" !σ₁ >σ₂ >σ₃ = 0"

+ +

: !

1 2

(σ −σ ) / 2 (σ1+σ2) / 2

oct

τ

(σ1 +σ2 +σ3) / 3!

!

1 2 3

(σ +Bσ +σ ) / 3"

! !

1 3

(σ +σ ) /" !(σ1+σ2 +σ3)""

* &

<2 !.>"*

] 2 / ) [(

2 / )

(σ₁−σ₃ = f₁ σ₁+Bσ₂ +σ₃

!.>"

β

.

1

f <2 !1."

2 b

σ

2

σ

1

arcsin( )

B

/ - .0 '

& -8/

!& .38. -1./" &

*













₊

=

2

3

1

σ

σ

τ

_oct

f

_!.7"

9

τ

_oct

,2

(

1 3

) / 2

m

σ

=

σ

+

σ

-1/ &

*

   

  + + =

2

3 1

σ

σ

τ

_oct a b

!.8"

,

1 3

q =σ −σ

τ

_oct

=

2 / 3

q

&

a

b

,

φ

=

cos

3

2

2

c

a

,

=

φ

sin

3

2

2

b

!.?"

0 1 !2

-& !.3"*

2

2

k

j

=

!.3"

k

&

( 49 -?/

& 2

( 9

1 2

1

2

k

j

j

=

+

α

(20)

: _α k

α

k

1

j

1/ 2 2

(j )

α

k _{( 49}

& 4, :

α

=

0

B <2 !1="

C &

3 4 "

D -3/ ,

( 49 ! "

: ,

D

2 1 1 2

1

2 A Bj Cj

j = + + !1." :

) (

) 3 / 1

( _{1 2 3}

1= × σ +σ +σ

j

!11"

2 1 3 2 2 3 2 2 1 2

1

2 (( ) ( ) ( )

6

1

_σ

_σ

_σ

_σ

_σ

_σ

− + − + − =

1

j

1/ 2 1/ 2

2 (3 / 2 ) o c t

j = τ B

oct

τ

0 ,

<2 !.=" !

2 3

σ =σ " !

1 2

σ =σ "

. 5

% < -.5/ (

< *

η

+

=

27

/

)

(

I

₁' 3

I

₃'

!1=" :

) ( ) ( )

( _{1 2 3}

'

1 S S S

I = σ + + σ + + σ + !1>"

)

)(

)(

(

_{1 2 3}

'

3

S

S

S

I

=

σ

+

σ

+

σ

+

!17"

S

η

'

η

& 4,

S

₀

ϕ

& 5 1 6

' -../

* %

m

! !

σ

₃"

n

i

j

i

<2!18"*

∑

− =

j

test j calc

j i

n

s 1 (σ_1, σ_1, )2

!18"

1,

test j

σ

j

σ

_1,calc_j

$

∑

=

i i

s

m

s

1

!1?"

+ - 1

E 0 (

' ' F

-./ -1/

,

A :

+

. . >

# "

) ( ' ' F E 0

&, >7 ;8 .. .; ..;

& !.378" =1 . 13 ? .; 1 .5 ; 3> 1

& !.38." 18 3 .3 = .= . .. > ..1 7

G 0 >7 1 ;8 = ? 8 .; ?3 3

0!1551" >7 ;8 3 .; ?3

0&6 0 . /+

&% 18 1; .; .; 35

&: 18 1> .1 .1 87

- / % > !&9 "

/

0&6 2

0 0!1551" 0

&, , &,

0 2

&, 0 & !.38." 0&6

q p−

A 0&6

&

0&6

.

-./ , %0 D &(

) & & ' 1551 73>4813

-1/ 0 + ' ) 2

) & H & ' !=>"

155? ..874..?7

-;/ , , 6 A : D ) : $ )

& $ < 0 9 1558

-=/ < ' ')& 6 1!1" .33=

=4.7

->/ # ( ' ) 9 ' +

' , * 9 , ' ) & , <

( ''6 .=.5 3>;5 C .; 6 1 15.. 8> ?.

-7/ & 6

I &

( .3?1 1>;47;

-8/ & # ) : D ) &

, ) &

H & ' =1 155> =;.4=;3

-?/ ( ( 9 : '

J & .3>1B.5*.>847>

-3/ : A , 6

) & & ' > .37? >134=3

-.5/ % 9 ( <

A < ( C .5. 6 .5

-../ ' & & 9

> : 9 $ 15.;

*

• 9 ( A

+ I * K3? 53;>>138175B

# L +

• 9 ( + I