Supremo Tribunal Federal

(1)

Ementa e Acórdão

!

!"# $%&' "()+,' -.' /%0 ! 12 3 4%)++&%& "# 5+ 4% -'

%#4 67 &%

8 %5' %92 %&!+4+&' ! " #:'&' %-4 #+'# %' %&5 -4' &%

-; 7< 7<<= # , & -4

! %4 ->.'8 -' -4%-4'8 %' "#+-,:"+' &% +!" '%*+&%&

+ '-'!+%8 92 # $ ! % %&!+ .' "'# ,'-,2# ' "2)*+,'8 % &+ " - % &'

!"# $%&' & !"# % "()*+,% ',+ &%& & ,'-'!+% !+ 4% 92

"# 4%! #5+>' "()*+,' & 5 # !'4+5%&%8 % $2#%-&' 8 % +!8 92

4%+

"#+-,:"+' 8 ') #5%&'

-' !'! -4' &%92 *% %&!+ .'8

1%!

4%!)?! # " +4%&' "'# ',% +.' &% &+ " - %

!'4+5%>.' &' %4' & &+ " - %8 % +!8 5+ % % # $2%#&%# '

!"# $%&' & 2!% "' :5 * 92 )#% &' "' 42%&' &% +!" '%+&%& "'#

"%#4 &' %$ -4 4%4%* +-5 4+&' &' "'& # & & !+4+#

,2# ' @4#%'#&+-A#+' "%#,+%*! -4 "#'5+&' "%#% %/% 4%# %

%"*+,%>.'8 %' ,% '8 &' %#4 67 &%

8 @+$+-&' 8 -4# 4%-4'8 % !'4+5%>.'

"%#% * $+4+!%# % # ,+ .' 2-+%4 #% &' ,'-4#%4' & 4#%)%*B'

Documento assinado digitalmente conforme MP n° 2.200-2/2001 de 24/08/2001, que institui a Infraestrutura de Chaves Públicas Brasileira - ICP-Brasil. O documento pode ser acessado no endereço eletrônico http://www.stf.jus.br/portal/autenticacao/ sob o número 3649846.

(2)

Ementa e Acórdão

C

+ 4' 8 # *%4%&' &+ ,24+&' 4 %24' 8 %,'#&%! '

+-+ 4#' &'

2"# !' #+)2-%* & #%8 ! .' -A#+%8 ') % # +&D-,+% &'

-B'#

+-+ 4#' E'%92+!

%#)' %8 -% ,'-/'#!+&%& &% %4% &

12*$%! -4' &% -'4% 4%92+$#A/+,% 8 # 1 +4%# 92 4.' & '#& ! &'

"%4#'-' &% # ,'## -4 92 2 ,+4%5% /' 4 / +4' 12*$%&' ! ,'-12-4'

,'! '

FGG H=I8 ,'! # " #,2 .' $ #%* # ,'-B ,+&%

! $2+&%8

,'*B+&' ' 5'4' 5+ 4% &'

+-+ 4#' E'%92+! %#)' % # +& -4 8 ' #+)2-%*

& 2 "#'5+! -4' "%#,+%* %' # ,2# ' @4#%'#&+-A#+' "%#% # ,'-B , # %

+-%"+,%)++&%& &' %#4 67 &%

'- 4+42+>.'

& #%* @+$+# %

- , +&%& & !'4+5%>.' "%#% % "#A4+,% * $:4+!% &' %4' & # ,+ .'

2-+%4 #% &' ,'-4#%4' & 4#%)%B'8 5 -,+&' "%#,+%! -4 '

+-+ 4#'

#'

#%2

%#,' 2#?*+'

%4'# # %12 4'2 "%#,+%! -4 2 5'4'

! $2+&%8 ' #+)2-%* # 1 +4'2 92 4.' & '#& ! &' %&5'$%&' &%

!"# % #% +* +#% & '## +' *?$#%/'

92 2 ,+4%5% /' !

!'&2*%&' ' / +4' &% & ,+ .'

#% :*+%8 HJ & !%#>' & HJ7I

H

C

+ 4' 8 # *%4%&' &+ ,24+&' 4 %24' 8 %,'#&%! '

+-+ 4#' &'

2"# !' #+)2-%* & #%8 ! .' -A#+%8 ') % # +&D-,+% &'

-B'#

+-+ 4#' E'%92+!

%#)' %8 -% ,'-/'#!+&%& &% %4% &

12*$%! -4' &% -'4% 4%92+$#A/+,% 8 # 1 +4%# 92 4.' & '#& ! &'

"%4#'-' &% # ,'## -4 92 2 ,+4%5% /' 4 / +4' 12*$%&' ! ,'-12-4'

,'! '

FGG H=I8 ,'! # " #,2 .' $ #%* # ,'-B ,+&%

! $2+&%8

,'*B+&' ' 5'4' 5+ 4% &'

+-+ 4#' E'%92+! %#)' % # +& -4 8 ' #+)2-%*

& 2 "#'5+! -4' "%#,+%* %' # ,2# ' @4#%'#&+-A#+' "%#% # ,'-B , # %

+-%"+,%)++&%& &' %#4 67 &%

'- 4+42+>.'

& #%* @+$+# %

- , +&%& & !'4+5%>.' "%#% % "#A4+,% * $:4+!% &' %4' & # ,+ .'

2-+%4 #% &' ,'-4#%4' & 4#%)%B'8 5 -,+&' "%#,+%! -4 '

+-+ 4#'

#'

#%2

%#,' 2#?*+'

%4'# # %12 4'2 "%#,+%! -4 2 5'4'

! $2+&%8 ' #+)2-%* # 1 +4'2 92 4.' & '#& ! &' %&5'$%&' &%

!"# % #% +* +#% & '## +' *?$#%/'

92 2 ,+4%5% /' !

!'&2*%&' ' / +4' &% & ,+ .'

#% :*+%8 HJ & !%#>' & HJ7I

H

(3)

Relatório

!

!" #"

"$% !& "' & #()* (&+ () " ,&! & ,"-

., "!

!(-"(

#" & "(&! "

"-/0 1&! 2

+ $&)

$3 #4&+ %)5)(."+ , &1" (#& ,"-

%6!"74&

!,"$( -(8 # ". (!!9#(&! )#(:(#% (! #&

(6%) - %," (& #&

6 -;&

1-!< =>> =>? <

"! & $ #& )4& $&);"$"% #& "$% !& #" ".6 0&! !!") )#&+

". $&)$-%!4&+ @%"

!

"

#!$

% "

&'#

( )

*

+

,!

!

-./

00 1 )023

4 1-< =>> <

"! "

+ 1%)# #& )& < >A=+

+ "+ #

&)! ( %(74&+ -"0 !" &1")!

&! !< B> " >C?+ # ."!.

<

"$& ") " !%! ") + ". !%. + @%"

#"-(6" 74& $" $ # !

!

!" #"

"$% !& "' & #()* (&+ () " ,&! & ,"-

., "!

!(-"(

#" & "(&! "

"-/0 1&! 2

+ $&)

$3 #4&+ %)5)(."+ , &1" (#& ,"-

%6!"74&

!,"$( -(8 # ". (!!9#(&! )#(:(#% (! #&

(6%) - %," (& #&

6 -;&

1-!< =>> =>? <

"! & $ #& )4& $&);"$"% #& "$% !& #" ".6 0&! !!") )#&+

". $&)$-%!4&+ @%"

!

"

#!$

% "

&'#

( )

*

+

,!

!

-./

00 1 )023

4 1-< =>> <

"! "

+ 1%)# #& )& < >A=+

+ "+ #

&)! ( %(74&+ -"0 !" &1")!

&! !< B> " >C?+ # ."!.

<

"$& ") " !%! ") + ". !%. + @%"

#"-(6" 74& $" $ # !

(4)

Relatório

#".(!!D"! !". E%! $ %! $&)! ( %( #( "( & ,& "! (:& # "., "! <

-"0 + . (!+ @%" & ") ")#(.") & 6 (0 #& )& $3 #4& "$& (#& () " 1" "

#( " .") " )

-(6" # #" @%" & #( "( & 6 -;(!

$&)1" "

&!

"., "0 #&! " "., "0 #& "! #" , $ % ". ") " !( 1-< ==A <

#%8+ ()# + @%"+ ".6&

"., "! 0&8" #" $" &! , (:(-/0(&!

$&)1" (#&! F

8")#

G6-($

)& @%" #(8 "!,"( & F (.,");& 6(-(# #"

#" !"%! 6")!+ & , 0 .") & #" #/6( &! ."#( ) " , "$ 3 (&! "

-0%. !

, " &0 (: ! , &$"!!% (! + "!!" 1 &

#

$

#

4 1-< ==> <

-"0 + ". $&.,-".") &+ @%" #(!,")!

!

5 #

5 !

'

!

6 "

!

4 1-< ==B <

. H >> =AAI+ "!

& " ",% &% "'(! ") "

"," $%!!4& 0" - #&

". $&)! ( %$(&) - ". #"6 "+ ". #"$(!4& @%" "$"6"%

!"0%() "

".")

J)07 0 + )+ 7

89+( :&7 1

7 108 07 )

+77 0+1

8;<7 %+1 =

( )01& >1

0:+ 0? )

) 1 @1 :&7 < )+1( 0:&+110 080) ) ( 0

: 00 )

+70 >

AB+ ,@701&7@) > 0 8 -./ ) 1 )023 )+ 1 (

@1C> 0

)

: >0% 1

AD 1 1@%0 0 >

1 & 7

7 @1 )+ 7

@71+ E 7 +7)0>F70+

K 1-< =LH <

&$% #& (

" - #

",G6-($ + ". , "$" !%6!$ ( & ,"-&

%6, &$% #&

" - #

",G6-($

)$(!$& # -6" & 36 "0 + &,()&%

,"-& )4& $&);"$(.") & #& "$% !&<

& "- 3 (&<

=

#".(!!D"! !". E%! $ %! $&)! ( %( #( "( & ,& "! (:& # "., "! <

-"0 + . (!+ @%" & ") ")#(.") & 6 (0 #& )& $3 #4& "$& (#& () " 1" "

#( " .") " )

-(6" # #" @%" & #( "( & 6 -;(!

$&)1" "

&!

"., "0 #&! " "., "0 #& "! #" , $ % ". ") " !( 1-< ==A <

#%8+ ()# + @%"+ ".6&

"., "! 0&8" #" $" &! , (:(-/0(&!

$&)1" (#&! F

8")#

G6-($

)& @%" #(8 "!,"( & F (.,");& 6(-(# #"

#" !"%! 6")!+ & , 0 .") & #" #/6( &! ."#( ) " , "$ 3 (&! "

-0%. !

, " &0 (: ! , &$"!!% (! + "!!" 1 &

#

$

#

4 1-< ==> <

-"0 + ". $&.,-".") &+ @%" #(!,")!

!

5 #

5 !

'

!

6 "

!

4 1-< ==B <

. H >> =AAI+ "!

& " ",% &% "'(! ") "

"," $%!!4& 0" - #&

". $&)! ( %$(&) - ". #"6 "+ ". #"$(!4& @%" "$"6"%

!"0%() "

".")

J)07 0 + )+ 7

89+( :&7 1

7 108 07 )

+77 0+1

8;<7 %+1 =

( )01& >1

0:+ 0? )

) 1 @1 :&7 < )+1( 0:&+110 080) ) ( 0

: 00 )

+70 >

AB+ ,@701&7@) > 0 8 -./ ) 1 )023 )+ 1 (

@1C> 0

)

: >0% 1

AD 1 1@%0 0 >

1 & 7

7 @1 )+ 7

@71+ E 7 +7)0>F70+

K 1-< =LH <

&$% #& (

" - #

",G6-($ + ". , "$" !%6!$ ( & ,"-&

%6, &$% #&

" - #

",G6-($

)$(!$& # -6" & 36 "0 + &,()&%

,"-& )4& $&);"$(.") & #& "$% !&<

& "- 3 (&<

=

(5)

Voto - MIN. RICARDO LEWANDOWSKI

!

"

#

$# %

! & '

" &

& (

"

#

' "

"

)

&

&*)'

+

#

,

'

&

& -

(

. #

&

/

"

) 0# %

+

)

,1

,

% 2 $

3*)'

&'

!

,

&

!

) - 0#

,

&

& -

(

'4

"

,

" &

0#

" 5

&

) '4

! &

'

&

06 &

% 2 $

3*)'

"

%

&

(

)

0#

7 &

' 89:

; /<

) ' &

) '4 ! "

'

+

-

0#

&

& -

&

!

-

,

0# (

<

7/ ; </89:

;

3=

+ ( +

+

+>

; ( ; 3 ; ;

; (

3 3=

+

>

+ ; ;

;

+

(

3 ; ; (

8?(?@(8??<

'

A

( B <9CD8??: / ;7 <C(<<(8??:

/

&

& -

&

&*)'

!

&

&*)'

!

&

'

E

/

'

&

& -

&

'

+

!

"

#

$# %

! & '

" &

& (

"

#

' "

"

)

&

&*)'

+

#

,

'

&

& -

(

. #

&

/

"

) 0# %

+

)

,1

,

% 2 $

3*)'

&'

!

,

&

!

) - 0#

,

&

& -

(

'4

"

,

" &

0#

" 5

&

) '4

! &

'

&

06 &

% 2 $

3*)'

"

%

&

(

)

0#

7 &

' 89:

; /<

) ' &

) '4 ! "

'

+

-

0#

&

& -

&

!

-

,

0# (

<

7/ ; </89:

;

3=

+ ( +

+

+>

; ( ; 3 ; ;

; (

3 3=

+

>

+ ; ;

;

+

(

3 ; ; (

8?(?@(8??<

'

A

( B <9CD8??: / ;7 <C(<<(8??:

/

&

& -

&

&*)'

!

&

&*)'

!

&

'

E

/

'

&

& -

&

'

+

(6)

& &.

)

" &

0#

+ % 2 $

3*)'

!

"

&

+

!

F

'-;32 9@

F

. #

&

& )'

0# !

,

G

&

0 &*)'

!

'

&

! & '

'

-

!

@(HCID:I! "

&.'

&

!

' 1

0 &

'!

&

! &

-&

(

8

4 !

!

' #

& '

. #

-

!

" &

!

'

! FG

G

(

C

+

,

!

"

&

& -

!

&

! &'

/

#

&

% + !

&

&*)'

"

&

0 &*)'

! & "

!

,

F

'-+

!

; <(@98D J!

'(

(

J

9

_{! #}

_#

_'

₀

& '

&

06 ( <:C! K <B!

+

0# 2

'(

&'

(

! -

!

" !

)

- !

L

&

M

$ F 1

' - ,

+

G

%

0# ! &

- $

&

% 2 $

3*)'

' 0# %

) G

%

0# &

&

.

!

'

&

-

,

! & $

&

(

8 ( ,

HH9

2(

C

@?@(@?C/ - D3

@9I(9HC/ - D (

9 ! &

&

!

4 ,

F

!"

!#$

%

&

'

(

)

$ *

&

+ , !"

!#$

%

&

'

-&

. /

8 & &.

)

" &

0#

+ % 2 $

3*)'

!

"

&

+

!

F

'-;32 9@

F

. #

&

& )'

0# !

,

G

&

0 &*)'

!

'

&

! & '

'

-

!

@(HCID:I! "

&.'

&

!

' 1

0 &

'!

&

! &

-&

(

8

4 !

!

' #

& '

. #

-

!

" &

!

'

! FG

G

(

C

+

,

!

"

&

& -

!

&

! &'

/

#

&

% + !

&

&*)'

"

&

0 &*)'

! & "

!

,

F

'-+

!

; <(@98D J!

'(

(

J

9

_{! #}

_#

_'

₀

& '

&

06 ( <:C! K <B!

+

0# 2

'(

&'

(

! -

!

" !

)

- !

L

&

M

$ F 1

' - ,

+

G

%

0# ! &

- $

&

% 2 $

3*)'

' 0# %

) G

%

0# &

&

.

!

'

&

-

,

! & $

&

(

8 ( ,

HH9

2(

C

@?@(@?C/ - D3

@9I(9HC/ - D (

9 ! &

&

!

4 ,

F

!"

!#$

%

&

'

(

)

$ *

&

+ , !"

!#$

%

&

'

-&

. /

8

(7)

&

! '

)

-

41)

!

F ! F

/

F

'

06 "

5 &

&

' $ 0#

&*)'

(

& '

!

- 0# &

'

&

,

-

&*)'

(

H

' 0#

0 ' 7

2 '4 !

/

(

/

!

0 1 &

2 (

1

3

0 /

- ,

(

@

+

&'

'-

06 &' G

&

!

& .&

'!

/ !

'

!

)

#

.

!

:

&

) 0#

' 0#

- !

& -

, 06 !

I

_!

-5

&

-

"

(

,

! &

"

#

$# %

"

H

; 3

!

N'

O

'' ( *

( 88P

( # 3 '

' !

8??Q! &( 99I(

@

7>

2 !

0 '( %

*

CP

(

'( #

3 '

! 8??I! &( <IH(

:

'

&

)

G

"

#

)

,

&

& -

&

'

-

'!

( C:! K QB! +2(

I

06 &

& .&

+

0# (

C

&

! '

)

-

41)

!

F ! F

/

F

'

06 "

5 &

&

' $ 0#

&*)'

(

& '

!

- 0# &

'

&

,

-

&*)'

(

H

' 0#

0 ' 7

2 '4 !

/

(

/

!

0 1 &

2 (

1

3

0 /

- ,

(

@

+

&'

'-

06 &' G

&

!

& .&

'!

/ !

'

!

)

#

.

!

:

&

) 0#

' 0#

- !

& -

, 06 !

I

_!

-5

&

-

"

(

,

! &

"

#

$# %

"

H

; 3

!

N'

O

'' ( *

( 88P

( # 3 '

' !

8??Q! &( 99I(

@

7>

2 !

0 '( %

*

CP

(

'( #

3 '

! 8??I! &( <IH(

:

'

&

)

G

"

#

)

,

&

& -

&

'

-

'!

( C:! K QB! +2(

I

06 &

& .&

+

0# (

C

(8)

(

&

4

1

5

6 %

&

7

8

6

9

5 )

1 :

1 &

!#$ !"

%

& ;

/

,'( 88I (

+

,

! -

!

-

F 1

&

#

!

- '

!

&

!

& "

,

06 FG

! "

F

'

& &

&

0 &*)'

(

,

+

#

) '

&

# "

%

' $ 0#

&

0#

&

'

-

"

& -

,

&

! - ,

" 4G

- 0#

F 1

) '4

!

" '

)

!

&

! &

&*)'

(

& "

,

!

0 !

-0#

! F

/ !

" 5

!

&

1&

&'

( C:

+

2 '(

;

& ' / !

!

-

& '

"

- '

&' G '

& -

-'

%

# (

& ,

)

! -

"

)F

#

& -

&

&*)'

-

&

$

&

1&

&

'

!

&

' -

/

'4

1 '

&

'

G

&

)F

&

0# (

+

& ' & .&

!

# &

9 (

&

4

1

5

6 %

&

7

8

6

9

5 )

1 :

1 &

!#$ !"

%

& ;

/

,'( 88I (

+

,

! -

!

-

F 1

&

#

!

- '

!

&

!

& "

,

06 FG

! "

F

'

& &

&

0 &*)'

(

,

+

#

) '

&

# "

%

' $ 0#

&

0#

&

'

-

"

& -

,

&

! - ,

" 4G

- 0#

F 1

) '4

!

" '

)

!

&

! &

&*)'

(

& "

,

!

0 !

-0#

! F

/ !

" 5

!

&

1&

&'

( C:

+

2 '(

;

& ' / !

!

-

& '

"

- '

&' G '

& -

-'

%

# (

& ,

)

! -

"

)F

#

& -

&

&*)'

-

&

$

&

1&

&

'

!

&

' -

/

'4

1 '

&

'

G

&

)F

&

0# (

+

& ' & .&

!

# &

9

(9)

&*)'

) &

1

5

1

6

6 /

,'( 889 (

!

0#

&

!

' 4

-

0# !

-

& -

&

1 ' " )

&

'

&

'

&

-

'

&

! $# & ' " '

&6 !

&

! #

&

F

&

,

'!

"

-

& -

.

! "

'4

F

&

)

! & "

!

'

,

/

G

& )'

%

# ! ,

G

"

&

! &

F

,

0#

" '"

%

'

-&' G

(

Q

& '

4 2

,

(

5 *

8

6 %;

!#$ <

1 &

(

*

=

1

1 : 6

)

!

/

- , (

<?

Q

)

2 O!

-

;

!

1'

) ( =

8 ( # 3 '

'4

! 8??:(

<?

2>

; !

4 ( %

*

'

$

2. !

8??:! &( 8<9(

H

&*)'

) &

1

5

1

6

6 /

,'( 889 (

!

0#

&

!

' 4

-

0# !

-

& -

&

1 ' " )

&

'

&

'

&

-

'

&

! $# & ' " '

&6 !

&

! #

&

F

&

,

'!

"

-

& -

.

! "

'4

F

&

)

! & "

!

'

,

/

G

& )'

%

# ! ,

G

"

&

! &

F

,

0#

" '"

%

'

-&' G

(

Q

& '

4 2

,

(

5 *

8

6 %;

!#$ <

1 &

(

*

=

1

1 : 6

)

!

/

- , (

<?

Q

)

2 O!

-

;

!

1'

) ( =

8 ( # 3 '

'4

! 8??:(

<?

2>

; !

4 ( %

*

'

$

2. !

8??:! &( 8<9(

H

(10)

#

&

+ '

R

'' ! &

" '

)

&

)

-

"

# '4

&

!

'

!

-

' 0# "

-

5

6

1 >

6

0 1 03:

6 &

?

(

4

7

5 6 6

-

1 &

-

6 *

1

1 &?

5 /

<<

!

,

4

4 -6

: 6

6 -

&

-

&

0 )

@

(

&

4

0

6 &

5 1 &

1

5 /

<<

! + '

R

( %

*

8H

( #

3 '

'4

! 8??I! &( 88?/88<(

@

#

&

+ '

R

'' ! &

" '

)

&

)

-

"

# '4

&

!

'

!

-

' 0# "

-

5

6

1 >

6

0 1 03:

6 &

?

(

4

7

5 6 6

-

1 &

-

6 *

1

1 &?

5 /

<<

!

,

4

4 -6

: 6

6 -

&

-

&

0 )

@

(

&

4

0

6 &

5 1 &

1

5 /

<<

! + '

R

( %

*

8H

( #

3 '

'4

! 8??I! &( 88?/88<(

@

(11)

! &

&

! "

#

G! " !

-

& -

) '

&

( 9<

+

0# 2

'!

" , $

(

S

' "

# !

& 1,

F & 5

&

+

"

,

-

#

'

0 &

-&

&*)'

!

,

&

-

ABA@8 C

;

4 D

%

D

1 $#

%

&

;

<

A

=

$

/

H@<(8C?/ - !

'(

( J '

(

ABA@8 C

2,%<A A

*A

A%,@,B<

B<28

AB=DAE , A28 '<7<* A

4

1

8 %

%78

+!

%

&

1 64 1

(

$#

%

B

&

1 !#$ !"

%

&

(

)

-

&?

6 /

9@H(:I?/ - !

'(

( 7 "

)

(

) ! &

! &

&

! "

2 '

0#

& -

&*)'

&

&*)'

+

' <QD<QQI!

"

!

-

!

:

! &

&

! "

#

G! " !

-

& -

) '

&

( 9<

+

0# 2

'!

" , $

(

S

' "

# !

& 1,

F & 5

&

+

"

,

-

#

'

0 &

-&

&*)'

!

,

&

-

ABA@8 C

;

4 D

%

D

1 $#

%

&

;

<

A

=

$

/

H@<(8C?/ - !

'(

( J '

(

ABA@8 C

2,%<A A

*A

A%,@,B<

B<28

AB=DAE , A28 '<7<* A

4

1

8 %

%78

+!

%

&

1 64 1

(

$#

%

B

&

1 !#$ !"

%

&

(

)

-

&?

6 /

9@H(:I?/ - !

'(

( 7 "

)

(

) ! &

! &

&

! "

2 '

0#

& -

&*)'

&

&*)'

+

' <QD<QQI!

"

!

-

!

:

(12)

, $

F

-

(

<8

) '

&

( 9<

+2!

! -

G

,

!

'

0#

& - !

&

) '

- 0#

&

) '

!

4 &.

0#

- (

<C

T $

"

&

& , '4

#

,

& -

&

) '

"

,

( 9<!

!

-

!

-

"

&

1&

&

'

! )

# &

&*)'

! F

)

&

#

&

(

+

)F

/

)

5 )

! & &

0#

)

#

&

' -

&

-&*)'

! -

/

&

'

-

'

# (

&

' '

&

#

' -

& -

&*)'

!

G!

)

!

'

' -

% )

U

&

1&

$ ) '

( T

" !

-

!

#

&

& G

)

!

&6

)

-

&

0# !

<8

&' ,

ABA@8 C ED F, DAE<BA@8 7 @, ED F, A <@28DGBA@8, %,@FAD8<, AB

DA%GD2, AH8D ,D<@ID<, AB=DAE , =J'7<%,

=D,F KL, AB %,@%GD2,

=J'7<%, @8AD<,D M A% !NONP A28 '<7< A/

!

+!

%

&

:

(

A% " !NONP

4 /

9:8(@IH/ - !

'(

(

J (

<C

2 J>

; ! *

'' ( %

*

# 3 '

'4

!

8??I! &( HQQ(

I

, $

F

-

(

<8

) '

&

( 9<

+2!

! -

G

,

!

'

0#

& - !

&

) '

- 0#

&

) '

!

4 &.

0#

- (

<C

T $

"

&

& , '4

#

,

& -

&

) '

"

,

( 9<!

!

-

!

-

"

&

1&

&

'

! )

# &

&*)'

! F

)

&

#

&

(

+

)F

/

)

5 )

! & &

0#

)

#

&

' -

&

-&*)'

! -

/

&

'

-

'

# (

&

' '

&

#

' -

& -

&*)'

!

G!

)

!

'

' -

% )

U

&

1&

$ ) '

( T

" !

-

!

#

&

& G

)

!

&6

)

-

&

0# !

<8

&' ,

ABA@8 C ED F, DAE<BA@8 7 @, ED F, A <@28DGBA@8, %,@FAD8<, AB

DA%GD2, AH8D ,D<@ID<, AB=DAE , =J'7<%,

=D,F KL, AB %,@%GD2,

=J'7<%, @8AD<,D M A% !NONP A28 '<7< A/

!

+!

%

&

:

(

A% " !NONP

4 /

9:8(@IH/ - !

'(

(

J (

<C

2 J>

; ! *

'' ( %

*

# 3 '

'4

!

8??I! &( HQQ(

I

(13)

F 0

!

) !

'

(

<9

) - 0#

#

.

$6

&'

)

!

&

'

!

,

"

-'

& "

& '

&

A

- '!

F

G

&

'

/ &

!

F !

# (

!

G ' -

% & .&

;

G

;

!

" '

' -

6 &

&

) '

"

G

&

" &

!

"

!

G/' (

-

& '1

"

,

)

!

&

#

&

"

0# !

- !

&*)'

!

)

"

- ' - '

&

'

(

<H

& &.

! '

)

"

Q(:I9DQQ! "

-

&

U )

0# 3*)'

2 '! -

'4

6 !

( H?! " '!

&

+

<QII!

&

,

&

-

QR "

!

#

< :

1 S

$ %& '

&

9

1

1 &?

?

<9

+,(

! 7

)

3 ( ,

(

0 *

# 3 '

'4

! 8??@! &( <HH(

<H

2 V ( '

4 ( A

&

# 3 '

'4

! 8??:! &( QC(

Q

F 0

!

) !

'

(

<9

) - 0#

#

.

$6

&'

)

!

&

'

!

,

"

-'

& "

& '

&

A

- '!

F

G

&

'

/ &

!

F !

# (

!

G ' -

% & .&

;

G

;

!

" '

' -

6 &

&

) '

"

G

&

" &

!

"

!

G/' (

-

& '1

"

,

)

!

&

#

&

"

0# !

- !

&*)'

!

)

"

- ' - '

&

'

(

<H

& &.

! '

)

"

Q(:I9DQQ! "

-

&

U )

0# 3*)'

2 '! -

'4

6 !

( H?! " '!

&

+

<QII!

&

,

&

-

QR "

!

#

< :

1 S

$ %& '

&

9

1

1 &?

?

<9

+,(

! 7

)

3 ( ,

(

0 *

# 3 '

'4

! 8??@! &( <HH(

<H

2 V ( '

4 ( A

&

# 3 '

'4

! 8??:! &( QC(

Q

(14)

/

- ,

(

T

&

,

" !

0#

.

!

#

G

, '

F ,

" '" !

&'

1 ' &

'

#

&

' - '

1 '

'

1 !

&

%

' $

' - '

- (

& '

'

!

1 (

:

1 &?

& /

<@

#

&

,

!

-

) '

&

!

&

-

" !

!

& -

!

&6

'- !

L &' -

M

&

!

" !

$

# ! '

, #

F ! #

! %

)

.

&

' - ' 0#

) '4

(

6 1

U )

&

&*)'

- %

' 0# ! &

&

!

# & ,

F '-

'

,

& ' 3

!

<C?(8?@D3 !

'(

( '

J ' # (

+

/ !

!

#

!

" '!

&

!

' /

)

$6

0# & '1

/

&

G

& -

'(

)

#

4

4 !

'

! )

( + '

'' !

'

06 &

'

&

& '

&

!

"

)

@

1 &

9 & =

<@

;

; ! 7

+ '

( ,

1 &

+

)

'

! <QQ8! &( <9(

<?

/

- ,

(

T

&

,

" !

0#

.

!

#

G

, '

F ,

" '" !

&'

1 ' &

'

#

&

' - '

1 '

'

1 !

&

%

' $

' - '

- (

& '

'

!

1 (

:

1 &?

& /

<@

#

&

,

!

-

) '

&

!

&

-

" !

!

& -

!

&6

'- !

L &' -

M

&

!

" !

$

# ! '

, #

F ! #

! %

)

.

&

' - ' 0#

) '4

(

6 1

U )

&

&*)'

- %

' 0# ! &

&

!

# & ,

F '-

'

,

& ' 3

!

<C?(8?@D3 !

'(

( '

J ' # (

+

/ !

!

#

!

" '!

&

!

' /

)

$6

0# & '1

/

&

G

& -

'(

)

#

4

4 !

'

! )

( + '

'' !

'

06 &

'

&

& '

&

!

"

)

@

1 &

9 & =

<@

;

; ! 7

+ '

( ,

1 &

+

)

'

! <QQ8! &( <9(

<?

(15)

6 :

9 (

(

@

5

5 )

1 &?

&

-

1

1 1 4

1

0

3 &

4 /

( '

J ' # (

6 0?

-

&

(

0 (

6 @

5

4 (

&

(

1 )1

,

(

6

1 &

1

4 5 (

,

4 ? T

:

T

7 ;

D

(

)

!

*

+

+,

-.

/

( + '

'' ! - , (

<<

6 :

9 (

(

@

5

5 )

1 &?

&

-

1

1 1 4

1

0

3 &

4 /

( '

J ' # (

6 0?

-

&

(

0 (

6 @

5

4 (

&

(

1 )1

,

(

6

1 &

1

4 5 (

,

4 ? T

:

T

7 ;

D

(

)

!

*

+

+,

-.

/

( + '

'' ! - , (

<<

(16)

&

!

,

" &

0#

#

!

$

% ) '

&

1 ' )

&

N 7

2 !

) "

&

,

, A

F

0 C

&

A

5

4

5 (

- )

5

1 1 &

(

4 *

/

<:

# &

&

!

1 "

&

& '

+

&

0# !

, -

G

#

'

! 4

&

&'

' )

'4 "

* !

G

!

' $ 0#

!

! %

5 &

( T

& " !

&

-

'

4 2

0 !

0

4

5 &

,

1 &

5 &

(0

&

"

,

/

- , (

<I

<:

2 !

N 7

( *

U

(

&

<P

(

8??8 ! CP ( +

) 7 G! 8??9( &( <@?(

<I

&(

( &( <8?(

<8

&

!

,

" &

0#

#

!

$

% ) '

&

1 ' )

&

N 7

2 !

) "

&

,

, A

F

0 C

&

A

5

4

5 (

- )

5

1 1 &

(

4 *

/

<:

# &

&

!

1 "

&

& '

+

&

0# !

, -

G

#

'

! 4

&

&'

' )

'4 "

* !

G

!

' $ 0#

!

! %

5 &

( T

& " !

&

-

'

4 2

0 !

0

4

5 &

,

1 &

5 &

(0

&

"

,

/

- , (

<I

<:

2 !

N 7

( *

U

(

&

<P

(

8??8 ! CP ( +

) 7 G! 8??9( &( <@?(

<I

&(

( &( <8?(

<8

(17)

W -

' # !

"

&

&'

0# ! %

&

!

&

1&

) -

( C:

+

- !

'

%

&

'

! F

&

"

,

! "

&

- 0#

&

-&*)'

! F

0# ! F

' -

(

&

! & '

!

4 0

G

'4

&

' &

&

,

&'

0# !

!

( 9<

+2!

-

/

0# &

' -

# '

'

) '4 (

<C

W -

' # !

"

&

&'

0# ! %

&

!

&

1&

) -

( C:

+

- !

'

%

&

'

! F

&

"

,

! "

&

- 0#

&

-&*)'

! F

0# ! F

' -

(

&

! & '

!

4 0

G

'4

&

' &

&

,

&'

0# !

!

( 9<

+2!

-

/

0# &

' -

# '

'

) '4 (

<C

(18)

Debate

Documento assinado digitalmente conforme MP n° 2.200-2/2001 de 24/08/2001, que institui a Infra-estrutura de Chaves Públicas Brasileira - ICP-Brasil. O documento pode ser acessado no endereço eletrônico http://www.stf.jus.br/portal/autenticacao/autenticarDocumento.asp sob o número 4484406

(19)

Debate

(20)

Debate

Documento assinado digitalmente conforme MP n° 2.200-2/2001 de 24/08/2001, que institui a Infra-estrutura de Chaves Públicas Brasileira - ICP-Brasil. O documento pode ser acessado no endereço eletrônico http://www.stf.jus.br/portal/autenticacao/autenticarDocumento.asp sob o número 4484406 Documento assinado digitalmente conforme MP n° 2.200-2/2001 de 24/08/2001, que institui a Infra-estrutura de Chaves Públicas Brasileira - ICP-Brasil. O documento pode ser acessado no endereço eletrônico http://www.stf.jus.br/portal/autenticacao/autenticarDocumento.asp sob o número 4484406

(21)

Debate

Documento assinado digitalmente conforme MP n° 2.200-2/2001 de 24/08/2001, que institui a Infra-estrutura de Chaves Públicas Brasileira - ICP-Brasil. O documento pode ser acessado no endereço eletrônico http://www.stf.jus.br/portal/autenticacao/autenticarDocumento.asp sob o número 4484406 Documento assinado digitalmente conforme MP n° 2.200-2/2001 de 24/08/2001, que institui a Infra-estrutura de Chaves Públicas Brasileira - ICP-Brasil. O documento pode ser acessado no endereço eletrônico http://www.stf.jus.br/portal/autenticacao/autenticarDocumento.asp sob o número 4484406

(22)

Debate

(23)

Debate

(24)

Debate

(25)

Debate

(26)

Voto - MIN. EROS GRAU

Supremo Tribunal Federal

!

!

!

!"# $%&' "()*+,' -.' /%0 ! 12 3 4%)+*+&%& "# 5+ 4% -'

%#4 67 &%

8 %*5' %92 * %&!+4+&' ! " #:'&' %-4 #+'# %' %&5 -4' &%

-; 7< 7<<= # , & -4

! %4 ->.'8 -' -4%-4'8 %' "#+-,:"+' &% +!" '%*+&%&

+ '-'!+%8 92 # $ ! % %&!+ .' "'# ,'-,2# ' "2)*+,'8 % &+ " - % &'

!"# $%&' & !"# % "()*+,% ',+ &%& & ,'-'!+% !+ 4% 92

"# 4%! #5+>' "()*+,' & 5 # !'4+5%&%8 % $2#%-&' 8 % +!8 92

4%+

"#+-,:"+' 8 ') #5%&'

-' !'! -4' &%92 *% %&!+ .'8

1%!

4%!)?! # " +4%&' "'# ',% +.' &% &+ " - %

!'4+5%>.' &' %4' & &+ " - %8 % +!8 5+ % % # $2%#&%# '

!"# $%&' & 2!% "' :5 * 92 )#% &' "' 42*%&' &% +!" '%*+&%& "'#

"%#4 &' %$ -4 4%4%* +-5 4+&' &' "'& # & & !+4+#

,2# ' @4#%'#&+-A#+' "%#,+%*! -4 "#'5+&' "%#% %/% 4%# %

%"*+,%>.'8 %' ,% '8 &' %#4 67 &%

8 @+$+-&' 8 -4# 4%-4'8 % !'4+5%>.'

"%#% * $+4+!%# % # ,+ .' 2-+*%4 #%* &' ,'-4#%4' & 4#%)%*B'

C

+ 4' 8 # *%4%&' &+ ,24+&' 4 %24' 8 %,'#&%! '

+-+ 4#' &'

2"# !' #+)2-%* & #%*8 ! .' * -A#+%8 ') % # +&D-,+% &'

-B'#

+-+ 4#' E'%92+!

%#)' %8 -% ,'-/'#!+&%& &% %4% &

12*$%! -4' &% -'4% 4%92+$#A/+,% 8 # 1 +4%# 92 4.' & '#& ! &'

"%4#'-' &% # ,'## -4 92 2 ,+4%5% /' 4 / +4' 12*$%&' ! ,'-12-4'

,'! '

FGG H=I8 ,'! # " #,2 .' $ #%* # ,'-B ,+&%

! $2+&%8

,'*B+&' ' 5'4' 5+ 4% &'

+-+ 4#' E'%92+! %#)' % # +& -4 8 ' #+)2-%*

& 2 "#'5+! -4' "%#,+%* %' # ,2# ' @4#%'#&+-A#+' "%#% # ,'-B , # %

+-%"*+,%)+*+&%& &' %#4 67 &%

'- 4+42+>.'

& #%* @+$+# %

- , +&%& & !'4+5%>.' "%#% % "#A4+,% * $:4+!% &' %4' & # ,+ .'

2-+*%4 #%* &' ,'-4#%4' & 4#%)%*B'8 5 -,+&' "%#,+%*! -4 '

+-+ 4#'

#'

#%2

%#,' 2#?*+'

*%4'# # %12 4'2 "%#,+%*! -4 2 5'4'

! $2+&%8 ' #+)2-%* # 1 +4'2 92 4.' & '#& ! &' %&5'$%&' &%

!"# % #% +* +#% & '## +' *?$#%/'

92 2 ,+4%5% /' !

!'&2*%&' ' / +4' &% & ,+ .'

#% :*+%8 HJ & !%#>' & HJ7I

H

C

+ 4' 8 # *%4%&' &+ ,24+&' 4 %24' 8 %,'#&%! '

+-+ 4#' &'

2"# !' #+)2-%* & #%*8 ! .' * -A#+%8 ') % # +&D-,+% &'

-B'#

+-+ 4#' E'%92+!

%#)' %8 -% ,'-/'#!+&%& &% %4% &

12*$%! -4' &% -'4% 4%92+$#A/+,% 8 # 1 +4%# 92 4.' & '#& ! &'

"%4#'-' &% # ,'## -4 92 2 ,+4%5% /' 4 / +4' 12*$%&' ! ,'-12-4'

,'! '

FGG H=I8 ,'! # " #,2 .' $ #%* # ,'-B ,+&%

! $2+&%8

,'*B+&' ' 5'4' 5+ 4% &'

+-+ 4#' E'%92+! %#)' % # +& -4 8 ' #+)2-%*

& 2 "#'5+! -4' "%#,+%* %' # ,2# ' @4#%'#&+-A#+' "%#% # ,'-B , # %

+-%"*+,%)+*+&%& &' %#4 67 &%

'- 4+42+>.'

& #%* @+$+# %

- , +&%& & !'4+5%>.' "%#% % "#A4+,% * $:4+!% &' %4' & # ,+ .'

2-+*%4 #%* &' ,'-4#%4' & 4#%)%*B'8 5 -,+&' "%#,+%*! -4 '

+-+ 4#'

#'

#%2

%#,' 2#?*+'

*%4'# # %12 4'2 "%#,+%*! -4 2 5'4'

!"# $%&' "()+,' -.' /%0 ! 12 3 4%)++&%& "# 5+ 4% -'

8 %5' %92 %&!+4+&' ! " #:'&' %-4 #+'# %' %&5 -4' &%

!"# $%&' & 2!% "' :5 * 92 )#% &' "' 42%&' &% +!" '%+&%& "'#

"%#% * $+4+!%# % # ,+ .' 2-+%4 #% &' ,'-4#%4' & 4#%)%*B'

2"# !' #+)2-%* & #%8 ! .' -A#+%8 ') % # +&D-,+% &'

+-%"+,%)++&%& &' %#4 67 &%

2-+%4 #% &' ,'-4#%4' & 4#%)%B'8 5 -,+&' "%#,+%! -4 '

%4'# # %12 4'2 "%#,+%! -4 2 5'4'

2"# !' #+)2-%* & #%8 ! .' -A#+%8 ') % # +&D-,+% &'

+-%"+,%)++&%& &' %#4 67 &%

2-+%4 #% &' ,'-4#%4' & 4#%)%B'8 5 -,+&' "%#,+%! -4 '

%4'# # %12 4'2 "%#,+%! -4 2 5'4'