dix II). Lopping of trees affects the growth and quality of trees due to the constant
4.4.3 Perceptions of forest management
The
perceptions
of localpeople
arebiasedagainst
theforestry
program and the activities in thestudy
area. This is because all therespondents
areherders/farmers whodepend
on88
cattlefortheirlivelihood, andrecentforest
plantations
have affectedtheir cattleherding
in oneway oranother.
Although
theirperceptions
mayseembiased, they strongly
reflectthefact that local
people
werenotinvolvedorconsultedduring
thepreparation
of the for¬estryprogram.As
such,
the localpopulation
doesnotseemtobereceptive
of theforestry
programs, as their needs and
aspirations
arenotincluded intheprogram, and the programobjectives
oftenconflict with the needs of localpeople.
Forexample,
localpeople
consid¬er
forage
and fuelwoodasthemostimportant commodities,
but theforestry
programcon¬siders this tobe timber
production.
Localpeople
claim that theforestry plantations
havelimited theiraccess to
grazing grounds,
and blame theforestry
program fordegradation
of forestresources.
5.1 The current status of forest
planning
5.1.1
Planning system
and the main contents of ForestManagement
Plans
Current forest
planning
isaone-levelplanning system by
the ForestManagement
Unit(FMU), whereby management plans
areprepared
with little interaction outside the forest¬ry domain
during
theplanning
process(Figure 5.1).
The size of the FMU varies from 1000 hato30,000
ha(Riehen
and Määttä1992)
andcurrently, management plans
forabout
289,923
haof forests have beenprepared, corresponding
to about 32% of the oper¬able forests. The
plans
for anFMU areprepared
foraperiod
of 10 years. Untilrecently,
thedetailsof the
planning
levelwithinFMUsdifferedfromoneforestunittoanother de¬pending
onwhichagencies/projects prepared
theplans.
The Swiss- andAustrian-assistedprojects prepared
theplans
atstand level, whereas theplans
ofthe ForestResource De¬velopment
Section(FRDS)
ofthe Forest Services Division(FSD)
withsupport
from FAO/UNDP,prepared
theplans
atthe forest level, followedby operational plans.
Forest Services Division
Areaidentification of FMU
Forestinventory
Dataanalysis
Plandrafting
Planre\iew
±
Planapproval
Operational planpreparation
Plan implementation
Divisional ForestOfficer recommendation
Meeting mainly
consists of forest
policy
makers,plannersand practitionersMinistry of Agriculture
Figure5.1 Thepresentforestplanning process.
TheForest
Inventory
andManagement Workshop
in 1992 resolved that FMUplanning
shouldbecarried out at thestratum
level1,
followedby
thepreparation
ofoperational
90
plans
thatwill be valid for 1-2years.Management plans
are of theconventionalforestry
type, inwhichsilviculture,
the allowable annual cuts(AAC)
andharvesting
schedules of theproduction
forestform the maincontents(as
summarizedinTable5.1).
1CURRENT SITUATION
• Location of the unit and physicalfeatures
• Climate
• Socio-economics
• Infrastructure, transportand equipment
• Historical background
• Forestresourceassessment
• Land use, vegetation, foresttypes, growing stock,annual increment.
II FUTURE MANAGEMENT
1, Objective: The main
objective
ofthe forestmanagement plan is to producewood for localpeopleand industries and at the sametime conserve and improveforest resources.
2. Management priorities: Management prioritiesdifferfromone unit to anotherdepending
ongeophysical and socio-economicenvironments of the FMU. In general, theprioritiesof managementaretoensureregenerationofharvestedareas, to undertake soundharvesting practices, to improvedegraded forestareas and toconserveand protectwatersheds, wild¬
life and nature.
3. Management strategy: Production forest, protectionforest, watershed management, na¬
tureconservation, wildlife,community forest and social forestry.
4. Planned interventions:
Yield
regulation
in productionforest• Annual allowablecut determination
•
Working
groups Silviculture• Silviculturalsystemsfordifferent
working
groups• Afforestation Harvesting
• Annual harvestingsystem
• Annual operationcoupes
• Tree marking rules
Infrastructure
• Road construction
•
Building
construction and maintenance 5. Staffand labor6. Financial aspects
7. Implementation and control
• Operation plan
• Responsibility
Table5.1 A summary of the maincontentof thecurrentforestmanagementplan, adaptedfrom Dhital and Pushparajah (1992)and Slavicky
(1992).
1. Correspondstoforest typesdependingondominanttreese.g. in conifer FMU--fir,spruce, bluepine,mixed conifer.Oak(Q. semecarpifolia)arethe stratum.
5.1.2 Status of forest
inventory
In
principle,
forest inventories in Bhutan arecarriedout onthree levels:•
National/regional
leveltogenerate
informationonforestresources.Thisguides
the de¬cision-makers in the
strategic planning
oflanduses, andwhendeciding
on new invest¬ments. Itisa
periodical
exercise undertakenmainly through donor-supported projects.
An
inventory
of all forests in Bhutanwas undertaken in the 1970sby
thePre-InvestSurvey
of Forest Resources(PIS),
assistedby
the Indiangovernment.
The forestareas of Bhutanwere assessed with the aid of satelliteimages by Negi (1983)
andGupta (1991),
and covered the forests of all theDzongkhags.
•
Management
Unit leveltocollect information of theforestunitsforthe forestplanners.
This allows themtomake decisionson landuse, allowable annual cutandvarious op¬
erations in theunit for forestmanagement
plans.
The forestinventory
is carriedoutby
theForestServices Division
(FSD)
and is aregular
meansofcollecting
forestresourceinformation formanagement
planning
in the FMU. Datacollection is orientatedto¬wards conventional
forestry
andplaces
mostemphasis
on theinformation ofgrowing
stock and timber
production (Table 5.2)
•
Operational
leveltocollectinformationfor foresters(DFO),
toplan
andimplement
in¬dividual
operations
within the unit.1. Areasofthe inventory unitsdivided into land use andforesttypes.
2. Environmental dataon soil, slopes, flora and fauna.
3. Volume of thegrowingstock broken down into foresttype classes; speciesand diameter classes and timber assortments.
4. Annual increment of the growing stock divided into foresttype, speciesand diameter classes.
5. Aforestmapshowing differentforesttypes basedon
geographical
location andecologicalclasses.
Table 5.2 Basicoutputs fromtheforest
inventory
in FMU (Rinchen and Määttä 1992).5.2 Goals of broadleaf forest
management
Broadleaf forests arevital resourcesthat
provide long-term
basicneeds,
such aswood, food,
shelter andfuel,
as well asprotection
ofwatersheds,
soil and fields.Therefore,
thegoal
of broadleaf forestmanagementistoprovide
these diversefunctionsandproducts
inperpetuity by
carefulutilization within thelimitsofsustainability.
Thegoals
of theforest¬rysectorasstated in the "Forest
Policy
of Bhutan 1991" arefar-reaching,
andencompass both economical and social interests. Basedon thegoals
of theforestry
sector, thelong-
term
goals
for thebroadleafforests can be summarized as follows:• Goal 1: Conservation of
biodiversity,
water resources, soil, land anddegraded
foreststhrough
propermanagementpractices
based on theprinciples
ofsustainability
andbiodiversity
maintenance.• Goal2:Production oftimberfor domestic andindustrialuses
through
sustainableman¬agementof broadleaf forests.
• Goal 3: Sustainable
production
offodder,
fuelwood andnon-woodforestproducts by
pursuing
multi-use concepts in themanagement
of broadleaf forests.92
• Goal 4: Contributionto the