A legitimação concorrente na ação civil pública e nos remédios constitucionais

(1)

! " # $ %

# &' ( ) #

% * + ,

- . *

, &* * /

(2)

! " # $ %

# &' ( ) #

% * + ,

- . *

) 33333 4 33333 4 0112

5 # 67

33333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333

, &* * /

33333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333

&* 8 9 6: 8 9

33333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333

(3)

(4)

= . *

: & *

* 6 >

& *

? @ > ) > ; =

> > ; ? > *

? @ :'

'& *

> > ' >

: A B & C*

)D " : ) *

> # E @ E "

& > *

& . < - >

* % ' F *

) )

*

G # > #

% >H E @ E ) : )

*

G # I )

*

(5)

K

& &' ( ) #

% ) *

>

> : $ ) *

& B !

" (#4 % ) & *

& L 6 %

> *

B) B & L 6

% *

& > $ *

) " - E

F ? #') *

"

(6)

AM ) < ) <

* < < ) & E

& ) * M

& ) *

& B *

< B

& ) ? ) I

' , F : $

) C*N

8 5 9

N

(7)

> Q ! )< B

F )

F B

< * > < ) ) ) '

* ! '

B

*

' E F '

' E E

R Q &

& ) <

& * : B ) ?

) B R ? ) < F

' < & $ & ? * '

! <

F

F ) ) ) L <

' : $ <

! ) ' < )

) & *

' ) ) @ # )

L F $ *

' < ) & L

& B ) >

F $ ) :

: @ S T*POT42K $

< ! ) * ) <

) '

B ? B ' B

(8)

2

& ! > <

* ' ! Q &

: * E > ! < B&

*

, @ * % * <

* ) L * - ) *

(9)

@ E

E && ? )

) ) U ?

E E * @ E V ) ) >

U E *

E ? ?

E ?

? ? * E &&

? W E

> E ) )

? U &

EE && )) ?

& E ?* @ ?

) E ? ) V

U ) & U & E *

EE ? E

E > U E

U E EE ) ) U E )

> V )

U ! ) > > )

EE & E *

) ) @ U E # )

E *

? ) &

& E ) E

? E ) U

E @ S T*POT42K E

E ! ) * @ ? ) V

U U ) > E

U

(10)

N1

& EE

E * E & *

EE E ) U & &

*

! "@ ?* % E * % E E *

E ) * - ) *

(11)

# $ %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%$& ' %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%$( '%$ %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%$( '%' %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%'& '%& %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%') '%) * %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%'+ '%, - %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%'( & %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%&,

&%$ . / 0 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%&,

&%' 0 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%)$

&%& . %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%)&

&%) . 1 2 3

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%)4

&%, - %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%,4

&%4 - %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%45

&%6 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%4$

&%6%$ 7! %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%4$ &%6%' ! %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%4'

&%+ - 3 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%4&

&%+%$ 8!9: ! ;8! 7 < %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%4, P*2*N*N % : **********************************************************************************XT P*2*N*0 B ) *********************************************************************************XT &%+%' =7 8!9: ! ;!98! 7 < %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%4+

) > # %4(

)%$ > # %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%6$

)%$%$ ?!7!@!8 8 =7 8!9: ! A7B9 @ AC 8!9 8 ;8 ! 8 <%%%%%%%%6$

)%$%' ?!7!@!8 8 =7 8!9: ! A7B9 @ = A ! 9 97 %%%%%%%%%6&

)%$%& ?!7!@!8 8 =7 8!9: ! A7B9 @ 9 97 D !@: !

AC !8!: ! %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%6)

)%' %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%6,

(12)

N0

, %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%('

,%$ 3 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%('

,%' - 3

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%(& ,%'%$ ?!7!@!8 8 9 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%(& ,%'%' ?!7!@!8 8 9 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%(, ,%'%& ?!7!@!8 8 9 @ 98 8 8 ?A 9E %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%(, ,%'%) ?!7!@!8 8 9 EF D DA %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%$5( ,%'%, ?!7!@!8 8 9 @ 98 8 8 !9HA9EF %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%$$&

4 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%$$+

4%$ 3 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%$$+

4%' %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%$',

4%'%$ ! !7 !98! !8A ! @ ?I9 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%$&$ 4%'%' ! !7 7! %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%$&, 4%'%& ! !7 8!JA %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%$&+

4%& %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%$))

4%&%$ A9!F K 7 8 K 8! 7 !7 J 8 @A9! LD! %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%$)6

4%&%' A7 MA! K @D DNC ! K JA98 EF A ! 8 8 8

9 @! @! 7 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%$)( 4%&%& ! EO %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%$,5 4%&%) !9! 7G ! NC ! %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%$,+ 4%&%, J 9 ! NC ! %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%$4&

6

-%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%$4) 6%$ 3 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%$4)

6%' P

- %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%$44

6%& . - Q

-%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%$6'

+ %%%%%%%%%%%%%$+&

+%$ - R %%%%%%%%%%$+6

+%' 0 Q - # %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%$(&

+%&

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%$(+

( 3 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%'56

- S #- %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%'$6

(13)

$

) $ B :

F & ) &

)B F ' F

: & B 0 )<

F $ * &

P

A B < &B

& C*

&

& $ &

B )R

& E ) :

B & F *O

) ) ) Z & Z

& >

F ' F ' *K

# ' ) >

& Q

& ) * < &

& R & Q !

* )

0

% @ )' * 5 * F ) * , #=

"B # ; @ > EE 8 *9* F

) Q 011X * NX*

P

6@ * NYTY * 1P*

O

% @ )' * 5 * * 0111 * OO!K*

K

5 [ -- : ) * @ ) , # B

6 Y2*XKK! %* , 6 .\ " ; ] 5 6 - ) 8# *9*

(14)

NO

& ) & *X

<

& < B F

< *T < <

) *2

: & &

) & & & ) Y F

A & E

F C*N1 >B !

> : *

$ E ] > >

D

) ' / ) 5H ^

Q ? Q & )

) *

) F

)' > F )

$ : & "

*NN / ,

X

- 6 " * ! "

* 011K * TN*

T

@ 6 # + ) *# * 011P * 010*

2

- ! = [ .L

A , Q ) C* $

011O *

Y

6@ * NYTY * P1*

N1

5 [ -- : ) * @ ) , B

6 Y2*XKK! %* , 6 .\ " ; ] 5 6 - ) 8# *9*

* 011O * 0K*

NN

(15)

NK

_***` ! * 6:

& ) !

&

, F 'E

E E EB! & $! _***`*N0

: & E

) ? ?

> # NP

: *

NO

B

) $ # # ) & E & $

: & & E <

Q 8 * 0XT # #9*NK 6 &

! & E )

,

J : & E

> & ; : > *

# ! @ < :

> * < ) ?

? ? A C < F ' *

* XS < E

< < <

; , : A C F <

& < > *NX

#

& ) < B! E !

F ' B & > F

*

N0

%% % / * % *$ & 011O * X0!21*

NP

# 6 > *' * NYY2 * 0T*

NO

# & " * @ , A > )

E C* 8@( % " * # * 0111

* 0119*

NK

6@ * NYTY * NON*

NX

(16)

NX

> Q ! )< B F

$ < *

) 5 -<

8 5 -9 < ) ) ) '

< F *

! '

B

*

' E F '

' E

E R Q

& & )

< & ?

B : B ) ?

: B *

J ? : B ) ? )

B R ? ) > <

' <

& ! $ & ? *

! ' ? B

< F

F )

) ) L *

H$ ' : < ? ) L

! : $ & &

(17)

NT

) ' < ) )

& > F )

& < ) *

' ) ) @

# ) L 8@ S T*POT42K9 F < L ;

& L ; ( 6 " ' ;

L & ;

F ' >B N 8 9

@ ) &

? D ? ) $

D ' < > ' ' * 6 &

F $ *

' < ) & L

& ) >

F $ ) :

: @ S T*POT42K* 6 '& ) & !

$ < ! ) & $ ?

) $ B *

) < ) '

B

? B ' B 8 B : B 9

? ) & !

> B <

R & F & *

" ' : !

? Q & : *

> < E < < <

> ) <

(18)

N2

(19)

' 3

> D ! )< B

F

$ <

Q ) ) $ &

) L *

&

& E! B Q

' ! > <

F ' ' < & ) )

*

)

&

F ) B) ) ) )B *

) E <

Q & ? : $

B ? ) F < F

> : *

= & R

> ) <

$

E F 'E ) &

B

F ' & *

Q :

(20)

01

E F 'E :

E E ! F 'E *

F & ,

D @

E & F ' & >

; $ F '

" # E ) > F

F ' F ' *

F & >

E &

< & * & )

B > <

, A C ) A7C $! F 'E a

)

$ F

Q < * 8

9 E ? : $ ? ) ;

8 Q 9 & ! ? : $ 8 < 9 !

F ' F E

& E F 'E *

=B B & >

$ Q < < * #

Q

& < )

: *

Q

& ) F <

: )

(21)

0N

)

> & Q $ B

< *

&' F

* < >B F E

) E*

J ) !

) & F E )

) & , > & >

& E$! *

? ) & Q

* E

Q ) ) & * >

( E Q <

&

< & >

) ) ) * 6 & Q !

B

: B ) : B *

J ? : B ) *

: B ) D

) : B

*

< @ &

: B ) FB :

(22)

00

6 : B D

: B . 'E

B $ *

: B D ) : )

* # : ) >

<

E )

F @ *

: B D &

B B * B < : B

F E

B * B

: B B ?

B F : B F E

B : & E$! E

B) < *

& : ?

) F *

>

: B *

: B ) E < E D

< < &

: B < L *

# < $ : B

F 'E F

(23)

0P

) : B D

: ) )< ; D

8 B B 9 :

; : B &

*

< )

& *

&

FB < &

& > *

# D

) ) > B

* 6 B > )

B! : Q *

) F )

) ) )< B!

) & '

*

# E : B

) D : B

) $

*

-B 8 9 Z ' Z )

B *

) & B

(24)

0O

=B

: '

F E Q ; ) F

' *

< ')

> ) : >

)

F ) L *

# & ) L F & )

? F B & ?

) : E F ' *

! : $ & & )

& ) ! $ <

! ) F & )

) > $ < ) )

& > F )

& < *

@ # ) L 8@ S T*POT42K9 )

< L ; & L ; ( 6

" ' ; L &

; F

' >B N 8 9 @ )

& ?

D ? ) $ D ' < >

' ' * =B

F $ : '

(25)

0K

) F < '

F ' * .B ? F < '

' B # *

E !

& . B 8 * KS 777 #"4229*

? F < * E

: ) < L)

B & ) ? F < L * =B

) & E E *

! & *

: ) :

) ? F *

' ? F ? F 8 * KS

777 #"4229 $ F ' 8 * KS @77

#"4229 &

L 8 * NPO NPK #"4229 ) ?

F *

:

E ) ? F

) '

. *

) @ S NN*OO241T &

L F E ) Q ) L &

E ) & F '

? & ) *

& L ) &

(26)

0X

KS 777 #"422 F ) )

& L & &

*

! & L

Q ) FB ) # Q 6 :

# 6 . FB & E & Q

' @ # S 214YO*

& L B <

) 8 & ) ) > $ 9

F B $ B ?

& *

B

) & : & L @

# ) <

# " NY22 & ? & L &

F ' & 8 * NPO 4 * KS

@77 #"4229*

) F $ F B

R > Q

) ' ! $

) L : <

& B! * - ' ) ?

) & L *

@ ) & : ? & L

F E ) L & E ) A C

*

B) > B <

(27)

0T

) & : F # # )

) &' B * F < &

& # # ) <

) . !

E 011O F

& < . *

) ! 5 <

? ) ) , N9 ; 09

F ' ) ; P9

L *

& ! & Q

) < ') & F B

) >B D 8 B E E

9 : )

8 : B 9

8 B E F 'E

F ' 9 F ) 8 )

! 9*

F $ $ &

: ) * % )

) ! $ E Q ) B

: & B

: B ! ? Q

F ) ? ) *

) B

& ) < D

*

& ! & D B E

(28)

02

D : F

? : ; <

B B! ? ) :

& *

) E

F ) F &

' ) &

? Q ) ) ! ) *

> B

: B F A ! ) C

< F ) D : ) B F