即時群播遠距教育教學發展之研究 Study of Instructional Development under the Telecommunication Distance Education Environment

ｖｾＧＮＭｾ

ＭｾＭＭＮＧＢ＠

ｾＧｩ Ａｦ Ｂ＠

Ｑ Ｎ ＳＸＭＷＰ

Study of Instructional Development under the

Telecommunication Distance Education Environment

C haoyun C

Jr

Li

38

A$sociwe Professof

Dtparlmem ｯｦｬｴｩｦｯｭｷｬｩ ｃｯｮｲｮｷｮ

YUQI1 Ü Uni"ersÍlY

Too-l1um. Tai

,,

ｅＮ Ｂ ｡［ｬ Ｚｩ｣｣ｽＧ ｬｩ｡Ｂ ＮｳｕＯ ｵｭＮＮＢｾｵＮｬｷ＠

AhSlr ''':1

Along w;lh Ihe ､･ＧＭ･ｬｯｰｭ･ ｯ ｦ ｭｦｯｲｭ｡ ｬￍ ｯｮ Ｎ ｬ｡ｮ｣･ educat;on has eme red into a neW "nl. While ｭｯ ｲ･ｬ｡ ＼ ｡ｲ｣ｨ focus on syslcm dC'sign and hard

ware developmem. rew o f lhem ｃ＼ｬ ｮ｣･ｮｴｲ ･ on ｬｮｳｬｲｵ ｩｯｮ｡ｬ DcvelQpme m(lD) activi

ｉｉ＼ Ｚｓ ｮ･ＮＮ､ｳ ｲｳ･ ､･ｳｩｧｮ ｩｶｩｬｹ arrangemem. ｡ ｲｋｩ ｩ ｡ ｡ｰ ｰｬ ｩ｣

ｮ lhis un iq ue environment. Through thc queSlÎonnaire survey and ｩｮＭ､･ｰｴｨ

ｨ ｉｨＮ ｣ｨ･ｲｳ ｵ､･ｮｴｳ and s.aff involved. thi s ｲ｣ｳ･ ｨ ;5 airned al describing cu

r-r<:m ｓ ｬ｡ｬｵ ｵ ｭＺｯｶ･ｲｩｮｧ problems. and ･ ｮｮｧ ･ ＧＧＧＵＰ ｩｯｮｳ of ｬ ｴ ＢＢｾ ｬ･｣ｯｭ

Ｑ ｓｬ｡ｮ｣｣ ｩ ｯｮ ;n ｔ｡［ｷｾ ｮ Ｎ＠ 8ascd uJ>On lhc rcscarch

…

｣ｯｭ ｊ＾ｏ ｏｃ ｮｬｓ ［ｮｳｵ ｜ｬ ｣ｬ［ｯｮ｡ｬ ｰ ｊ＾ｏ ｲｴｓ Ｆ ［｣｣ｳＮ class Ｑ ｣｡ｲｳ｡ｬＮ and

Ｂ ＱＱ ＢＮ＾ＰＮ ｡ｲ｣ ￌｬ ｣ d;ffercnl from lht' ｬｲ｡､ｩ ｩｯｮ｡ｬ mooe. cspcc ial1y lhe

faclor ｯｦ ｯｮ ｡ｬ ｡､ｭｩｮｩ ｳ ｬｦＳＱｩｯｮ ＰＰ Ｑ ｔｨ ｣ rcsuhs of lhis rcsearch can ｉ

on ly be applicd in ｩ ｧ ｬｨ｣ ｉＮｬｹ of ､ｩｳ ｨｕｬ also ｨｮｶ｣ Ｕ Ｑ ｮｧ

ｩｯｮＵＱ ｲ､ ｬｨ ｢ｯｲ｡ｬｩｯｮＮ facuhy ､･ｶ｣ｬｯ ｰｭ ｦｦ lraining. and ｰＮ ｓ

Ｂ Ｑ praclicc in lhc ficld of dislancc educalion

ｋ ｲｹ Ｎ

ｉｬ : ｉＡ ₃₉

ｋＴｊＴ

ｲ ＢＢ

ＱＱＱ Ｗ

ｉｾ

ｊｬＡＱ￟

ＡＧｕｉｊ

Ｈ￧ｯｲｲ ｰｯｮ､･ ｮ ￧･Ｉ

Ｔ ｊ ｊｴ

ＨＭＩ

ＧＱ

ｬ ｬ ｊＡＩ Ｑ ｝

Ｑ ＱＱＱＰ

ｊＺ￈ ｉＡ ｮ ｅ

ＸＳ Ｘ ｊＨ

ｎｉｉ Ｉ ＸＳ

ＱＲ ｊ

ｻ Ｉ ＸＴ Ｗ

Ｇｦｪ Ａｴ ｭＧｬ

ｅ ＸＵ Ｒ ＸＷ Ｘ

ｦ Ｑｊｩ ｲＡｬ

ｊ ｬＧ ＨＩ

ｈ Ａｉ

Ｈａ ｔｍ ｉ ｓ ｄ ｎＩ ｮｮ￸

“

ｦｬｬｬ Ｑｍ Ｉ

Ｈｗｯｲ ｬ ､ Wide Web. ｗｗｗＩ Ｇ￫

ｦｩＧ ｊ ［ｩ

ｻ ＱＱ Ｈｖｩ､･ｯ On Demand. ｖｏｄＩ ｩ •

.tI

ｉｓｄｎ

ｬ

［

Ｑ ＧＢＧ

ｦ ＸＵ

Ｈ ￸ ｬ Ｎ Ｚｈ

ｪ ｊＡ

ｉＡ Ｗ

ＱＭ Ｑ ｲＢ

ｻ ｽ Ｑ ｲＢ

ｻ Ｑｉ ｲＢ

ｪ ｊｬ

ｉｊｊｉ ｦ

ＮＮＮ

"

ｉＱ

Ｍ

Ｎｊ［ｊ

ｬ ｊｬ

ｈ

Ｈ ｢ ＵＺｾ

ｉｗ ａｔｍ ＱＱｓｄｎ

Ａ ｉｉｉ ｉ

Ａｉ

ｊ ｲ ＺｧＺ ｊ

ｾｉＡ＼

Ａｉ ｴ

Ｂ Ｈ ｊ ｩ ｬ

ｬ

ｊｬｴｻ

ＴＡ Ｎ

Ａｉ￭ Ｇｉｊ

Ｑ ￟ｮ ｲ ｉ ｕ ｉｩ

ｉＱ Ｈ ￁Ｉ

ｊｈＱＡ ｬ ｬ Ｎｬ

Ｍｊ

ｊ

_Ｇ

t

ｊｍ ｩｪ［｜ Ｎ

.-

.

"

Ｑ Ｒ

ｾｉｬｩ Ｂｲ

ｉＧｊｾ ｅ

ｉｊｉ

Ｂ ＱＰ Ｑ

Ｂ

ｊｬ ｖ ｊＡ ｲ

ｊ ｔｩｩｬ ＱＱ ｊ ｊＡ

ｅ

ｊ

￱ｓＺｊｴｾＹＺｊｴ

ｉＱＱＱ ｉｬｩ

ｩｈｫ ｧ

ＱＱ

:

"

ｦ ｊｬＡ ｔ

h Ｑ ｉ

ｭ ｉ ｓ ｄｎ ＳＴ Ｘ ｋ

ｉ

Ｗ

Ｂ ｉＡＱｊ Ｖ Ｑｉ

ｻＱｉｉ ｉｉｕ

Ｈ Ｉ

Ｈ ｒＧｉ

ＱＱ｜ ＧＱ ｚ

Ｗ

tiJF

ｦ ｉ

ｅ Ｏ Ｑ ｪ ｊＡ

ｾｊｉｉ ｕ ｈＢ ｾ ｴ ｉ ｴ

ＧＢ ＱＧ ｙｕ ｉｴ

ＱＧＢ Ｇ ｊ ｊ ﾧ

ｻＩ

ｦ ｩ ｊ Ｈ ｴｩ Ｉ

ｉｩ

Ｍ

Ｈ ｉ ｮ ｳ ｬｲｵ ｣ ｬ ｮ｡ ｬ

Syslems Developm e nL IS D)(

｜ｬｉ Ｑ Ｈ ｉ ｮ ｳ ｴｲｵ ｃ ｬｩ ｯ ｮ｡ｬ ｄ ･ ｶ ･ ｬ ｯ ｰｭ ･ ｮｴ ＩＮ ＢＱｉｬ

-L

ｾＮＮＮｾ＠

"

ｉｩｬｨＡ

Ｈｴｩ Ｉ

ｉＨ

ｦ ｴｴ

Ｑ ｊｖｉ

Ｉｂｲ ｡ ｮｳｯｮ Ｈｩｬ Ｉ • Lesh in et ｡ ｌｻ ｩｬ

Oick & Carey ＨＫＭＩ

ｋ･ｭ ｰ Ｈ ｩｩｾＧ［ＮＩ ｾ ｋ･ｭｰ

Ｑ ＡｩＱＨ ｵ ＨＴＹ Ｉ

Ｒ ＿ＨＩ Ｓ ＨＩ

Ｔ ＱＱ ＨＩ

Ｗ ＡＮ｜

｛ｻ

Ｑ

ｭＺ

ｉ ｉ ｅ

Ｒ ｊＱｕｩ Ｍ

ｉｬ ＧＱ

ＡＭｴ

ｉｊ ｉＺｉＱ Ｍ

ｲＦ

Ｓ

ＧＢ ｩ

"

ｩｦｦ ｬｊＡ ＰＧ Ａｾ

ＨＩ Ｎ

ｊＹＺＲｴ

Ｔ

ｦｦＮｾ Ｑ

5.

Ｑ

Ｑ ＰＧ ｬ ｾｔ

Ｖ

Ｊ ￱

ｾＺｾ［ｾ

, Ｗ ｦｲｅ

ＡｉＡＧ

Ｗ

ｮｔｈ ｬｬＡＱｊＡ Ｑ ＱＧｬ

ｅ

Ｗ Ｎｪｬ ｉｾ

ｻｭＺ Ｇｾｉｪ［

Ｘ ｮ Ｑ

Ｇ Ｑ Ｑ ａ ￭ｾ

＿

ｊｴ

Ｙ ｾ

"

ＱＰ

Ｕ ｊｪ

￱Ｚｬ ｅ Ｗ

ｴ

ｋ･ｭｰ

ｩ｜ Ｎ

Ｕ ＼Ｑ＾Ｆ

Ｇ ｦ

￱

ｋ･ｭｰ

Ｗ

Ｑ

ｬＡ ｐ ［

"

Ｉ

ｬ ＱＱ

ＨＩ

ｋ･ｭｰ

ｊ［Ｑ ｊ ｊＡ

ＮＰ

Ｍ

ｅ ｋ ･ｭｰ

ｬｾ

ｲｬ

ｅ ｩＱ￭ＱＡ ｋ･ｭｰ

Ａｬ

Ｑ Ａｉ Ｑ

ｬ ｉＡ

ＮｴｊＡ ￎｉ

Ｑｦｴ

Ｗ

ｅ

Ｒ

Ｇ ｴ ｩ Ｆ ｅ

ＷＱ

Ａｬ

ＮＰ

ｦ､

"

Ａｆ

Ｍ ｬ

Ｎ ｢

［ｅ

Ｗ

ｅ Ｗ

ｨｦｴ ｊｒ

Ｔ

ＢＱ Ｕ

ｅ

ｬｦｊ

ｅ ｾｾ

ＡＡＺ

Ｕ

ｅ

Ｎ ｵｦ Ａｉ ｩ

ｴ｜ｩＡ ＱＺＱ

Ｖ ｬＧ

ｦ Ｇｩ

ｮｮ ｔ

ｾ

Ｗ

t

e

ｾＮｩＧＺ［ＧｊＮｪ＠

,

ｆ･ｆａａ

Ｂ Ｑ

"

Ｗ

ｩ

Ｑ

ｋ ･ ｭｰ

ｉ ｊｬ Ａｴ

ＱＡ Ａｊｊｬｼ ｋ ･ｭ ｰ

Ｗ ｉＱ ｋ ･ｭｰ

ＸＶ Ｒ

ｙｩ ＿ ｾｉ Ａｴ

ｅ ｬｊｪ

Ｑｉ ＡＶ

Ｗ

ｬ

ｔ

ｈＡＤ

ＧＱ Ｗ ＱＮ Ｑ ＱＱ

Ｎ ＱＱ ｴｬｗ｜ ｩＱＡｴＡｩ

ｅ ＱＢ Ｑ Ｒ ＢＧＱ

ｾｾ ＺＮＭ

ａＺＺＮｪＺｾ＠

ｷ ｅｆ

'0 Ｋ Ｈｓ｣ｰｴ｣ｲｮ｢｣ｲ 1999)

ｋ･ｭｰ

Ｈｾ

Ｈ ＭＩＡￕ

Ｑ ｅ ｾ

ｭｾ

ｮ ｬｴ ｮＺ

Ｈ ＱＩ Ｔ Ｑ Ｓ Ｈｕｕ

ｉｬｾｬ ＧＢｪ

ｪ ｴｦ［ Ｔ Ｔ

ＨＲＩ Ｗ ｦ

ＱＱ ｕ ｈ

［ｊＮ｜Ａ

ｗＺ ｉＡ ｵ｡ Ｚｲ ｮ

"

ＡＱ ￱

ｅ ｬｴ

ｬ

Ｓ

ｅｩ ｬ ａＧｉ

ｂ

￟ｉ

ＱＱ Ｎ

Ｔ

［

ｬｉｩ

ｩ ｴ Ｗ［ Ｇｉｦ

Ｍ

ｅ ｉｧｬ Ｔ Ｗ ｊｲ ｅ

ｅ ＧＱ ＱＧＱ ｬ

Ｕ

ｬ ｊ￭ ｩ

Ｓ ｬ

Ｑｾ［｟［ｾ

…

52 Ｎ Ｋ ｭ Ｍ ｊｉＱｉ ｻｓ ｬ･ｭ｢｣ｲ Ｑ Ｂ

ｂｂｓ ｅＭ ｭ ｡ ｩ ｬ

Ｖ

Ｇｬ ＨＱＩ

ＨＲＩ

ｉｩｬｾ ｴ

ｩ

Ｚｴｊ ＨＳＩ

ＡＡ

Ｗ

ＸＱＱ

￱

ｬｉｩ Ｗ

Ｕ ｬＨ

ｊｉ

Ｘ

Ａｬｉ ｂ ｈｈ

ｊ ｭ Ｗ Ｇｃ

ＮＮ ｬ ｊｬｊｦｪ Ｓ ｩ Ａｉｬ

ＱＱＱ

r

ｊ ｪＧｪ Ａｉ

ｌｆ ｾ

ｾＺ￠ｾ

,'1."

ＧＢ Ｂ ｩ

"

Ｂｊ Ｑ

ｉＱ

ＨＩ

ＸＶ Ｕ Ｕ Ｕ ｍ

ＵＲＶ Ｓ Ｐ Ｓ ＵＷＮＶ ＲＹＸ

ＵＶＮＷＥ Ｎ ＹＷ ＱＴＹ

ｴｊ ｦＱ ＱＸＳ

ｬ ＱＱＵ ＲＰＲ ｈ

ｦｈ ｻ ＷＰ ＸＳ ＶＶ

ＷＹ ｅ

ＲＷＰ ＲＴ

ＸＱ Ｑ

ｬ

ｼ ｈ ｉ ｐ _{Ｒ Ｂ}

ｴ ｽ

Ｑ ｼ 3.88 3.97 3.75 _ＲＲ Ｒ ＮＳ ＰＮＰＲＲ

+

ｅ ＱＱ 3.48 3.61 ).28 _ＳＳ 2.871 _{0, "}

•

ｼ 3.92 4.01 3.77

Ｂ

•

Ｂ 3.80 3.89 3.65

Ｂ

+

Ｑ Ｂ

Ｎ ｩｩｾ P<O.O! ' Ｋ ｐ＼ｏＮＰＵＨ ｆＮｽ

ｾＮｲＢ

ｭ ￟ｊ

ｩ ｬ ｪ Ｚｔ

ｊ • ｊｴ ｊ

ｲｴ ｊ ｦ ｬ

ｊ Ｑ ｯｊ ｭｾ

gg

"

1999)

Ｒ Ｑ

ｉＡｾ ｊ

!l.

ＦｉＡ Ｑ Ａ

Ｒ

ｐ

Ａ _{3.39 ).)1} ).42 -0.05 -0.368 0.713

3.19 Ｓ ＠ 3.5 0.' -3.805 0

Ｒ

ｅ

Ｓ

ｱ

ｉｉＡ

www

Ｂｏ ｓ 91 95.6 99.'

ｅＮ ｍ｡ｩｬ 90.9 91.8 89.6

ＱｬＧＱｉｉＱＱｬＺ 87.2 85.2 90'

ＰＯ＼Ｎ Ｔ Ｑｴ

Ｒ _Ｗ

u

o

Ｚ 7.0 6.0 '.7

［ 76.5 82.0 67.8

Ｒ 12.8 ' .7 19.1

＿

ＷＲ

Ｑ

ＧＢ ｴｴ

:

"

ｴ ｉｬＡｬｉｩ ￭ｾ

ＧｦＣ Ｍ

Ｕ

Ｅ

54.0 59.0 46.1

ＧＢ 19.8 25.1 IU

15.1 10.4 22.6

ｪ 17.4 15.3 20.9

74.5 72.7 77.4

L7 1. 1 2.6

ｴ

ｲＧｬ

Ｍ

ｬ

ｉｱ ｬ

ｅ

Ｖ ｦ

ｊ ｊ

-

ｊ ｊ

ｊ ｉ Ａｉ ｅ ｊ

'.&.

ｊ ＱＩ ｼ ｉ ｉＴ ｊ

.&.

ｊ ＧＱ Ａｉｉｩ ｭ

ｺ

ｾ｣ＢＧＮＮ ｟＠

ｈ

"

､＼Ｖ Ｔ

､ ｩＱ ｰ

ＱＰ

ｾ ｩ Ｓ 3.71 3.56 0.15 1.454 0.147

Ｂ

3"

ＱＱＱＱ

3.77 ₃

“

. . 3.77

3.62

ＮＮＮＮ ＳＸ3.86

3.70 3.23

ＱＱ 1.178 0.24 0.63 6.042 0

Ｎ Ｓ 4.09 4.15 4.0] 0.14 L661 0.098 •

Ｂ

ＮｾＮＡｩ ｧ 3.31 3.38 3.19 0.19 1.463 ＰＮＱ

ｾ 3.54 3.63 3.39 0.24 1.928 0.055

ｾ 3.82 3.89 ).70 0.19 2.125 0.034

+

Ｔ ＢｴｬＡ 3.81 387 Ｓ＠ 0.15 ＱＮ Ｕ Ｓ 0.124

Ｇ Ｑｩｬｬｊ

ｅ 3.30 ).36 3.20 0.16 1.262 0.208

ｶＺ

Ｎ ｐ ＼ｏ Ｎｏ｝ , Ｋ ｐ ＼ｏ Ｎｏｓ • Ｎ ＱＧ ＼ＰＮ ＱＨｽ

Ｗ

ｴ ｆ

Ｂ

ＢＮ 3.72 3.74 3.68 0.06 0.528 0.598

ＺＢ

ｾ ).57 3.62 3.50 0.12 1.014 0.312

Ｘ ＱＱ

Ｎ p

",

Ｎ

ｉｴ 2.79

ｩ 2.88

ｮ 3.52

2.95 ＳＵ＠ 3.65 2.53 2.59 3.30

3.172 &

4

‘

0.46 3.822 0

0.35 2.947 ＰＰＳ＠

ｗ［ ＱＡ ｐｂＮ ［ ｮ ｾ

"

Ｑｮ

ｊ

ｭ

Ｍ

ｂ ￆ ｊ

Ｑ ＺＱ

ＱＱ

ｉ ＡＧ￟

ＡｈＡ

Ｙ ｚ

Ｅ Ｅ ｬ

Ｒ ｴ 79.5 92.3 59.1

ＱＺＺ 20.5 1.1 40.9

ｩｏ 9.8

o

14.8

o

49.2 50.0 48.9

52.5 21.4 61.7

ｼ 45.9 Ｗ ＮＶ 36.2

8.2 10.6

ｊ ' ｲ ｊ ｲｩ

Ｑ ｊ ｾ

ｩｾ ｲｾ

ｊ

ｪｪＩＨ

ｦｬＧ

Ｚｰｊ ｣ＮＮ

"

ＱＰ

ＢＮＮＮＮ

Ｅ

63.1 ＷＲ ＴＸ ＮＷ

36.9 27.9 51.3

,k

Ｄ

ＦＰ 13.6 19.6 8.'

40.0 ＴＳ 37.3

38.2 37.3 ＳＹＮ

Ｈａｩ 1.3

o

Ｂ

21.8 Ｎ 27.]

ｊ

ｬｉ￮Ａｩｩ

ｩ

ＷＱ

Ｂ

Ｑ Ｒ

Ｅ Ｅ .. Ｅ

]4.8 85.2 18.0 82.0 9.6 90.4 Ｅ

49.2 45.3 54.8

10.6 Ｗ 16.3

..

Jl 0.1 6.1

Ｂ 20.1 22.0 17.3

ＱＴ

Ｅ Ｅ Ｅ

ｮｴｊ ＧＢ Ｕ

ＢＺ ＡＡｮ｡ ＧＢ

"

ＱＵ

Ｅ Ｅ

44.8 28.6

379 .57.1 ＰＮＰ

Ｑ 13.8 21.4 0.7

103 71 13.3

44.8 >0.0 10.0

0.9 71

"

ＱＶ

Ｅ

61.1 68.3 49.6

\0.1 10.9 8.7

18.5 10,9 30.4

7.0 7.7 6. 1

"

ＱＷ

Ｅ

ｒ ｭ 13.1 18.0 5.2

ｒ ｊｊｊ 13 2.2

82.6 77.6 90 ..

1.3 2.2

ＱＱ

o

17

o

Ｘ

ｊＮＡｗＡｊ

Ｑ

ｊ

Ｍ ｊ

ｮｸ

,~t,L

ｧ ｰ Ｍ

60 Ｋ Ｈｓ･ｰｴ･ｭ｢･ｲ ｝ＹＹＧ

ＧＢ

Ｑ

ｊＧ｜｜ ｲ ｊ

Ｂ

Ｑ Ｘ ｦＮ ｴ

Ｅ Ｅ

Ｔ Ｇｊｉｕ 74.5 77.6 69.6

ＧＢ 25.5 22.4 30.4

Ｂ 18.4 12.2 25.7

Ａ 60.5 63.4 57.1

Ｂ 22.4 22.0 22.9

32.9 26.8 40.0

5.' '.9 5.7

Ｔ

Ｅ

ＮＢＮ _6U 59.6 63.5

38.9 40.4 36.5

15.5 16.2 14.3

ＧＢ _{9.5 12.2 '.8}

ｅ 58.6 55.4

Ｂ

ｬ 21.6 20.3 23.8

12.9 12.2 14.3

Ｓ

ｊ

［｣ＭＮＧ＼Ｈ［＠

ＮＧＺ［Ｂ

"

ＲＰ ｴｴ ｊＡ ｰｬｬ ｊｴ

ｱ Ｑ ｐ

3.28 3.17 ).4) _ＲＵ ＭＲ Ｔ 0.028

ＱＱ 3.30 ).25 3.311 .0.13 .1.128 _ＲＶ

ｉｕｉ

Ｂ 3.28 ).30 3.25 0.05 _{ＲＶＷ ＷＹ}

Ｋ ｐ ＼ｏ ＮＰＵＨ ｽ

4

,

Ｑ Ｅ

ｾＡｬ

93.0 7.0 97.3 2.7 Ｘ ＮＱ 13.9

ｪｱ ＺＮＱＺ ＩＮ ｭｬ ＱＱ

ＱＱＱ ＸＱ Ｑ ＧＱＧ Ｎ ＲＲ ｊ｛ ＧＢ

･ｦｬｩ ｅ

Ｅ Ｅ

8

2

86.3 13.7

ＷＳ＠

ＲＷ＠

ｾＲＳ

Ｅ

16.1 12.0 19.4

ｬ ｬ 20.0 12.9

42.9 24.0 Ｕ Ｑ

25.0 24.0 25.8

ｅ ｴＲ

2

"

ＨＩ •

ｊ Ｑｍ ｊ

ｩｉｉ ｊ ｊ Ｎ

ｊ

Ｑ ｭ

.fc

Ｅ Ｃ Ｅ

Ｑ ＮＷＶＥ 76.5 85.8 61.1

ＷＵＭＵ Ｑ Ｙ 20.2 13.1 31.3

Ｕ ＰＭ ＲＶＥ 3.0 1.1 6.1

ＤＲＵＭＱＥ _{Ｓ Ｙ}

ＧＰＥ

o

ＨＩ

ｋ･ｭｰ

Ｓ ＿

Ｑ

Ｍ

Ｔ

"'.,,,

ＱＲ

Ｈ ｒ

Ｉ •

ｾｩｬ ｛ Ｈ

ＧｬｬＮＩ

Ｓ

Ｈ

Ｉ

ＯＮＱ

Ｔ ｬｉ￭

Ｍ

Ｕ

｛Ｉ

ｅ Ｈ ｗｊ

ｽ

ｴ Ｈ Ｉ •

Ｑ ＨＩ

ＨｬｬＮｴＡｪ Ｉ

Ｈ

ｽ

ｊ

"

［

ＫＨｓ･ ｰｴ｣ｭ｢･ｲ 1999)

Ｖ

ＧＱＱ

Ｈ

Ｉ •

ｾｪＡＨ

ｬ ｮＱ ･ｲｮ･ｬ Ｉ

Ｂ Ｒ Ｍ

Ｗ

Ｎ［ｬＧｾ ｆ ｬ￯ ｩＯ

ｗｉ ＧＩＨ

Ｉ

Ｚ￭Ｇｬｻ Ｑ ｊｬＯ ｊ

Ｉ •

Ｘ

ｊｾ＿ ｪＮ ｬ

ｬ￬ｉ ｬ ￱

Ｈ

ＯｬＮｦ Ｉ •

ｩ Ｉ

ｾ ｭ ＱＱＡＭ

Ｙ ｪｩＧ［

"

ｩ ｗｊ Ｍ

ＱＰＮ Ｇ ｻ

ｩ Ｍ ｬ ｬＮ ｾ

ｬｬｉ ｩＨＩ

ｻ ｬ Ｉ

Ｈ

Ｉ

ｪ Ｈ

Ｉ

ｬ

Ｆｮｩ

ＢＮｊＡＧ ｊ

ＲＵ

ＧＱ

ｩ ＧＢ

ＧＢＧＢ

ＢＧ ｩ ＢＧ ｴ

ｬＡ ｭ

ＢＮ

ＧＢＢ

Ｆ

ｬｩｈＮＮ

ｚ

ｴ｡Ｂ Ｂ Ｒ ｾＢ

ｬ

'"

［＿

“

1999)

ＱＺｉ Ｑ ｮＧＡ

Ｎ

ＧＮ

Ｇ, ＮｴＡｬｩｋｬｬｉ

ＭＭ［ＩＯＱＱｾＧｉＧ

ＮＢ

ｦ ＱＱ

A Ｑ ｉｴ ＧＢＡｉｬ ＧＱ

Ｎ ｩｬＡＡｬＡ

ＮｎＡ ｾ￟

ｚ Ｑ

Ｒ

ＱＱＡ Ｒ Ａ

Ｂ

Ａ｣ ｾ ｉ

ｉｱ ｾｗｽ

ｪ＼

ＱＧＱ ｉｩｴ

ｫ

Ｑ Ｍ Ｑ

Ｎ

ｉＣｉｊｉ ｋ ･ｭｰ

Ａｶ

ｅｅｔ

Ｂ ｈＧｊￆ 61

Ｓ Ｔｾ

ｊ

ｊｴ Ｗ ｴｴ ｬｬｩ ｊｴ ｅ

ＶＱ Ｏ Ｈ

Ｉ Ｈ

Ｉ

ｊ ｆＡ Ｍ

ｋ ･ｭｰｦｍｩ ＮＱｴ ｱｬ

￰ｓｾＯ Ｑ Ｑ ｋ ･ｭｰ ｦｊ

ｉ ｊ ｊ

'

ｊ ｪ ｊ

..&

ｬ ｬ ＱＱ ｬ ｩｉＡ

ｅｒ

Ｑ

68 ＢｴｉＱＡｪＡ Ｋ Ｈｓ･ｰ Ｎ ･ｭ｢･ｲ 1999)

ｬ

ｪ ｦ＼ ｅ

Ｑ

ＱｾＮ

Ｒ Ｑ｜

ｊ Ｗ ＧＢ

Ｑ Ａｉ

ＱＩＱ

Ｓ

Ｑ

Ｗ ｲＢＱ ｩ

ＩＯＱ ｬ

ＨＩ

Ａ

ＧＱ ＱＱ Ｑ

Ｑ ｩ

ｊｬｦ Ａｉ Ｍ

ｬｪｉ

Ｚ

4

ＱＡＡｬ ｂＮ＿ｦｴ ó9

Ｉ ＧＨＲＩ ｭ Ｈｾｬ Ｉ ' (3)

ＨＩ ＧＨＴＩ ＱｉｬＡＨ

Ｉ , ＨＵＩ Ｈ ｬ Ｉ 0

Ｒ

Ｇｈｉ ｬｬ￭ Ｈ

ｊｬｉ ｪ ＡＩ Ｍ ＺＶＺＺＨ

Ｉ

ｅ

Ｑ

Ｓ Ｒ

Ｆｩ ｭ

ｉ ｃｉ

ＯＱ

ü-

Exp/indcx.hlrn

38 0

ＮＮ］Ｎ ｩＡＢＨ ＸＵ Ｑ 0

ｕ ｮＨｾ ｩＡＢｻ ＸＷ Ｑ 0

Ｍ

ｊｩ ￁ ＱＰＱ ＿ ｦｦ＾ ＨＢｽ

Ｑ R. Kaufman.

&

( ｅｮｧｬ･ｷ ､ Cliffs. NJ:Educ3lional Tcchnology Public3Iions.1979)

ü-!: C.B. Leshin. J. Pollock. & C.M. Rcigelulh. ＡＱＱＵＱｭ ［ＰＱＱＱＱＱ Desigll Ｕ ｲＮ ｬ･ｧｩ･ｳ＠ flml

TaclÍcs Ｈｅｮｧ Ｑ･ ｷｯ ｩｦｦｳＮ NJ:Educallonal Tcchnology Publicalions.1992)

llA ｉｩｩＧ ＼Ｑ Ｑ Ｂ ＧＢＸｊＩＺ 13-]7 •

 ｆＮｇＮ Knirk. & K.L. ｇｵｳｬ｡ｦｳｯｮＮｬｬｬｮｲｵ ｃｬ ｩ ｔＯ Tecllllology:A ｾＧｹｓｬ･ｭ Ｈｬ ｬｩ｣＠ ｬｬｰｰｲＨ ｨ

ｴ＿

Ｎ

70 ｦｦ Ｎ Ｋ Ｈｓ･ｰｬ ｬ Ｙ

Ｂ

Ｒ Ｍ W. Dick. & L. Carey. Tlre ｓｹｾｬ･ＧＢ＠ Ðe$;8" of hwmclÍon, 3rd Edition (Londofi England: SCOI1. Foresman & Company. 1990)

ｊ ＮｅＮ Kemp. Tlre IlISfrl/criolJlll DC';8" Process (Ncw Yorlc : Harper & Row