CONSULTORIA PÚBLICA: ANÁLISE E ALTERNATIVAS PARA A MELHORIA DOS CMEIS

(1)

CONSULTORIA PÚBLICA: ANÁLISE E ALTERNATIVAS PARA A

MELHORIA DOS CMEIS

PUBLIC CONSULTATION: ANALYSIS AND ALTERNATIVES FOR

THE IMPROVEMENT OF CMEIS

Eder Gustavo de Oliveira !"#$%&'%(&)*+*#,"-./$%0123*4-5%6+*7'"#*&-&'%8'&'"-3%&'%9-7"-#%:689(; '&'"4-+&'*-#)<=>$,)-*3?4$) Gabriela Francine de Oliveira Silva !"#$%&'%(&)*+*#,"-./$%0123*4-5%6+*7'"#*&-&'%8'&'"-3%&'%9-7"-#%:689(; <-2"*'3-@"-+4*+'ABC=>$,)-*3?4$) Paula Nogueira Rodrigues !"#$%&'%(&)*+*#,"-./$%0123*4-5%6+*7'"#*&-&'%8'&'"-3%&'%9-7"-#%:689(; D-!3-+$<!'*"-"$&"*<!'#=>$,)-*3?4$) !"!#$!%&!'!()#%*+,-./+0 !"#$%&'%(&)*+*#,"-./$%0123*4-5%6+*7'"#*&-&'%8'&'"-3%&'%9-7"-#%:689(; "#7=-&)D!23*4-?!E-?2"

Resumo: ! "#$%&'(#)*+! ,-.'*"+! /! 01! (#0+! *2,#)(3$"*+! ,+)+! 1$(1$01)2#%! #! 4&$"*#$+21$(#! 0+! 1%()&(&)+!

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

!"!#$!%&'(!#): Consultoria, instituição, serviço público.

*+%,$!',-.The public consultation is all important to understand the functioning of the organizational structure, recognizing the failures, assisting in the search for development of organizations through new practices and methodologies improvements. The study aims to describe a consulting performed in a public institution (CMEI) in order to close to see the actual operation of the services, searching for !"#$!%&%$ "&'( '$(#%)*# !"#*'+,$-. '"(#')# !"#/&0%)'1% '/)#%)*#2&/2/(')0#(/3"#&"4"$ '/)(#/)#%$ '/)(# /# improve the functioning of this. A case study was conducted with unstructured interview, observation and documentary analysis. As a strong point of this study highlight the possibility of analyzing a public institution and try to contribute to it.

/)0.12$3%: Consulting, institution, public service

Introdução

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

(2)

'#,/$%D-##-+&$%D$"%&*H4!3&-&'#5%P!-+,$%D-"-%-P!'3-#%P!'%&'#'L-)%-7-+.-"%D$"%+$7$#%4-)*+>$#%'5% ,-)2O)%-#%P!'%&'#'L-)%4$+>'4'"%&',-3>-&-)'+,'%$#%D"$4'##$#%&-%#!-%$"<-+*I-./$?

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

Referencial Teórico

(% D$!4-% P!-+S&-&'% &'% 7-<-#% ')% 4"'4>'#% ,$"+-% $% #'"7*.$% D123*4$% &'% '&!4-./$% )!*,$% &'H4*,R"*$5%$+&'%!)-%<"-+&'%&')-+&-%&'%4"*-+.-#%+/$%O%-,'+&*&-%D$"%@-3,-%&'%3!<-"5%'%D$"%'##'% )$S7$%-#%@-)U3*-#%H4-)%')%3$+<-#%'%4-+#-S7-#%>$"-#%W%'#D'"-%&'%'+4$+,"-"%!)-%7-<-%D-"-%#'!#% H3>$#5%'##'%@-,$%@-I%4$)%P!'%$4$""-)%<"-+&'#%H3-#%&'%'#D'"-#?%T'%-4$"&$%4$)%X$+\#%:]B^_;5%4*,-&$% D$"%T!-",'%'%0*+,$%:`aaB;b

-% ,'$"*-% &-#% H3-#% O% -% -2$"&-<')% P!-+S,-S7-% W% -+R3*#'% &'% #*#,')-#% P!'% *+43!*% 3*+>-#% &'% '#D'"-5% $!% H3-#?% (#% 3*+>-#% &'% '#D'"-%D$&')%#'%@$")-"5%-*+&-5%P!-+&$%$%#*#,')-%:*+#,-3-./$;% S7'"%4-D-4*&-&'%#!H4*'+,'5%')%)O&*-5%D-"-%#!D"*"%-%&')-+&-?% Y#,$%D$"P!'%$%,')D$%&'%4>'<-&-%'%$#%,')D$#%&'%#'"7*.$%D-"-% $#%43*'+,'#%#/$%-3'-,G"*$#%'%7-"*R7'*#?%%:T6(cdM%e%0Yfdg5%àaB5% D?hC;? 0-"-%K-""',$%'%iR%-#%)-,"*4!3-#%O%$!,"$%*,')%)!*,$%D"'$4!D-+,'%+-%'&!4-./$%)!+*4*D-35%$#% '#D-.$#%j#*4$#%#/$%D'P!'+$#5%P!-+&$%4$)D-"-&$%-%"'&'#%'#,-&!-*#%&'%'+#*+$? g%+1)'"$%&'%'#4$3-#%+/$%O5%D$"O)5%D"$D$"4*$+-3%W%P!-+S&-&'% &'% )-,"U4!3-#% ')% 4-&-% '#,-2'3'4*)'+,$% &'% '+#*+$5% D$"P!'% $% ,-)-+>$% &-#% !+*&-&'#% '#4$3-"'#% O% )!*,$% 7-"*-&$% k???l?% (#% '#4$3-#% )!+*4*D-*#% #/$5% D$"% 'Q')D3$5% P!-#'% P!-,"$% 7'I'#% )-*#% +!)'"$#-#% &$% P!'% -#% '#,-&!-*#5% '+,"',-+,$% $% ,$,-3% &'% )-,"U4!3-#% +-#% "'&'#% )!+*4*D-*#% O% -D'+-#% 3*<'*"-)'+,'% #!D'"*$"% -$% &-#% "'&'#% '#,-&!-*#5% D$*#% '+,"'% -#% '#4$3-#% &-#% D"'@'*,!"-#% >R% )!*,-#% P!'% #/$% )!*,$% D'P!'+-#% $!% -*+&-% !+*&$4'+,'#?%:K(ccMdg%e%XYdc69Yi5%àa]5%D?]``;? T'%-4$"&$%4$)%Z$3&"-m%:àaB;%4*,-&$%D$"%i$!I-%:à]a;5%O%+'4'##R"*$%$%'#,-2'3'4*)'+,$%&'% D"*$"*&-&'#5%n-%*)D3-+,-./$%&'#,'%D-##$%#*)D3'#%@-I%4$)%P!'%-%4$+@!#/$%+$%E!Q$%&'%$D'"-.J'#%"'&!I-% 4$+#*&'"-7'3)'+,'5%$%'1+0!>21%&*)*+!-%'%$%&'#')D'+>$%&'%'+,"'<-%:TTM;%#!2-%"-D*&-)'+,'o? % i$2"'%Z'#,/$%&'%T')-+&-5%X'3$%'%(34-+,-"-%:à]];%4$+43!')%P!'%-%<'#,/$%&'7'%'P!*3*2"-"% -#%+'4'##*&-&'#%&$#%43*'+,'#%4$)%-#%4-D-4*&-&'#%&-%$"<-+*I-./$?% 0$",-+,$5%-%<'#,/$%&-%&')-+&-%O%!)%4$)D$+'+,'%*)D$",-+,'% D-"-% $% #!4'##$% &-% <'#,/$% &-% 4-&'*-% &'% #!D"*)'+,$#?% 6)-% *)D3')'+,-./$% 2')% 4$+&!I*&-% &$% D"$4'##$% D$&'% )'3>$"-"% $% +U7'3% &'% #'"7*.$% D"'#,-&$% -$% 43*'+,'% '% <'"-"% 2'+'j4*$#% #!2#,-+4*-*#%D-"-%$#%"'#!3,-&$#%H+-+4'*"$#%&-%')D"'#-%4$)$5% D$"%'Q')D3$5%-%"'&!./$%&$#%+U7'*#%&'%'#,$P!'5%)'3>$"*-%&-%

(3)

!S3*I-./$%&$#%-S7$#%'%)'3>$"*-%+-%&*#D$+*2*3*&-&'%&$%D"$&!,$?% :XM9g%e%(9 (fdc(5%`a]]5%D?%^aBN^`h;? 0-"-%$%-!,$"%i*37'*"-%p"?%03-+'L-)'+,$%'#,"-,O<*4$%O%$%D-##$%)-*#%*)D$",-+,'%&'%P!-3P!'"%SD$% &'%$"<-+*I-./$5%#'L-%'3-%D123*4-%$!%D"*7-&-?%0'+#-+&$%+$%#',$"%D123*4$%$%D3-+'L-)'+,$%O%&'%,$,-3% *)D$",q+4*-%D-"-%P!'%#'%,'+>-%!)-%4$+S+!*&-&'%+-%D"'#,-./$%&$#%#'"7*.$#%D123*4$#%4$)%P!-3*&-&'% '%,-)2O)%4$)%'H4*r+4*-? g%D3-+'L-)'+,$%'#,"-,O<*4$%4$+#S,!*N#'%+-%!S3*I-./$%&'%!)% -"4-2$!.$% &'% ,O4+*4-#% &*"'4*$+-&-#% D-"-% -% '3-2$"-./$% &'% !)-% -+R3*#'% -)2*'+,-3% *+,'"+-% '% 'Q,'"+-% &-#% $"<-+*I-.J'#5% -%&'H+*./$%&'%)*##/$5%@$")!3-./$%&'%$2L'S7$#%'#,"-,O<*4$#5% P!'2"-%'%HQ-./$%&'%+$7$#%D-"-&*<)-#5%&'H+*./$%&$%D'"H3%&'% +'<G4*$%'%R"'-#%&'%+'<G4*$5%<"!D$#%&'%43*'+,'#%'%D"$&!,$#%$!% #'"7*.$#5%@$")!3-./$%&'%D$3US4-#%'%&*"',"*I'#%'%&',-3>-)'+,$% &'#,-#% ')% D"$L',$#% '% -.J'#% '#,"-,O<*4-#?% :iY9sMYc(% p6fYgc5% ]BBC5%D?%`B;?

g%03-+'L-)'+,$%M#,"-,O<*4$%i*,!-4*$+-3%:0Mi;%O%!)-%)',$&$3$<*-%4"*-&-%D'3$%'4$+$)*#,-% 4>*3'+$% -"3$#%X-,!#?%T'%-4$"&$%4$)%t!'",-#%:`aah;%4*,-&$%D$"%K*"4>-3%:`a]`;5%D3-+'L-"%#*<+*H4-% D'+#-"%-+,'#%&'%-<*"5%D'+#-"%#*#,')-S4-)'+,'5%4$)%)O,$&$5%'QD3*4-+&$%4-&-%!)-%&-#%D$##*2*3*&-&'#% '%-+-3*#-+&$%#!-#%"'#D'4S7-#%7-+,-<'+#%'%&'#7-+,-<'+#?%

% 0-"-% c*'<% '% ("-!L$% 8*3>$% :`aa`;5% $% 0Mi% D$&'% #'"% #!2&*7*&*&$% ')% P!-,"$% )$)'+,$#% )$#,"-&$#5%+-%H<!"-b%$%'QD3*4-S7$5%P!'%2!#4-%L!#SH4-"%$#%D$"P!r#%&-%#*,!-./$%-,!-3u%$%+$")-S7$5% +$%P!-3%#'%'#,-2'3'4'%$%P!'%#'%&'#'L-%@-I'"u%$%'#,"-,O<*4$5%P!'%-+-3*#-%-%7*-2*3*&-&'%&-#%$D'"-.J'#% D3-+'L-&-#u%'%$%,RS4$N$D'"-4*$+-35%P!'%4!*&-%&-%*)D3')'+,-./$%&-#%$D'"-.J'#%+$%&*-N-N&*-?% Figura 1 N%g#%P!-,"$%)$)'+,$#%&$%0Mi? T'%-4$"&$%4$)%Z!*)-"/'#%:`aaa;5%-#%-7-3*-.J'#%&'%P!-3*&-&'%+$#%#'"7*.$#%D123*4$#%&'7')% "'#D'*,-"%&!-#%-2$"&-<'+#%-#%-#4'+&'+,'#%'%&'#4'+&'+,'#?%(%D-"S"%&'##-#%-2$"&-<'+#%O%D$##U7'3% 7'"*H4-"%4$)$%-%-7-3*-./$%D$&'%)$&*H4-"%,$&$%!)%4$+,'Q,$%$"<-+*I-4*$+-3%'%4$)%*##$%)'3>$"-"% ,$&$#%$#%-#D'4,$#5%#'L-)%'3'#%j#*4$#5%'%-,O%)'#)$%$%4$)D$",-)'+,-3%&$#%#'"7*&$"'#%D123*4$#? k???l%'##'%)$&'3$%D$&'%#'"%#!2&*7*&*&$%')%&!-#%-2$"&-<'+#b% -#4'+&'+,'% '% &'#4'+&'+,'?% (% D"*)'*"-% '#,R% "'3-4*$+-&-% -% ,')-#%4$)$%&'#'+7$37*)'+,$%'%-D"'+&*I-<')%$"<-+*I-4*$+-*#% '% -% @$")-#% &'% <'#,/$% 2-#'-&-#% +$% -!,$&'#'+7$37*)'+,$% '% +-% D-"S4*D-./$5% *+43!*+&$% !)-% r+@-#'% +-% <'#,/$% &-% 4!3,!"-%

(4)

$"<-+*I-4*$+-3% '% +-% -7-3*-./$% &'% &'#')D'+>$% 4$)% 2-#'% ')% "'#!3,-&$#?% (% -2$"&-<')% &'#4'+&'+,'% "'4$+>'4'% -% 7-3*&-&'% 3*)*,-&-% &-% D'"#D'4S7-% -#4'+&'+,'% '% D"*7*3'<*-% $% D-D'3%&-%3*&'"-+.-%+-%4$+&!./$%&$#%D"$4'##$#%&'%)!&-+.-?% Y+43!*%$%<'"'+4*-)'+,$%&-%)!&-+.-%4!3,!"-35%-%!S3*I-./$%&'% @$")-#% 4-"*#)RS4-#% &'% 3*&'"-+.-5% -% r+@-#'% ')% D"$<"-)-#% &'% ,"'*+-)'+,$% '% 7-3$"*I-./$% &-% )-"4-% 4$"D$"-S7-5% $% '#,-2'3'4*)'+,$%&'%!)-%)*##/$5%&'%!)-%'#,"-,O<*-%'QD3U4*,-% &'%4$)!+*4-./$5%'%-%7-3$"*I-./$%&-%@!+./$%"'4!"#$#%>!)-+$#?% :Z6YX(cvMi5%`aaa5%D?w;?

Análise e discussão dos resultados

g%'#,!&$%&'%4-#$%-4$+,'4'!%')%!)% XMY%3$4-3*I-&$%')%!)-%4*&-&'%&'%)O&*$%D$",'%&$%#!3% &'%X*+-#%Z'"-*#?% $)%$%3'7-+,-)'+,$%&'%&-&$#%*&'+SH4-)$#%P!'%$% XMY%'#,!&-&$%-,'+&'%!)% +1)'"$%D'P!'+$%&'%4"*-+.-#5%+/$%#'+&$%#!H4*'+,'%D-"-%-,'+&'"%-%&')-+&-%3$4-3u%#/$%$@'",-&-#%_a% 7-<-#%+$%,$,-35%D-"-%4"*-+.-#%4$)%*&-&'%'+,"'%x%)'#'#%-%w%-+$#5%"'4'2'+&$N-#%+$%D'"U$&$%*+,'<"-3% &-#%a_>aa%W#%]_baa%>$"-#?%0-"-%$%*+<"'##$%+-%*+#S,!*./$%+/$%'Q*#,'%!)%4"*,O"*$%,O4+*4$%'#D'4*H4$?%g% 4"*,O"*$%!#-&$%O%2-#'-&$%')%n$"&')%&'%4>'<-&-o5%-$+&'%+-%+$*,'%-+,'"*$"%-%)-,"U4!3-%$#%@-)*3*-"'#% 7/$%4>'<-+&$%'%#'%$"<-+*I-+&$%')%H3-#%-,O%#'%'#<$,-"')%-#%7-<-#?%(%D-"S"%&-%$4!D-./$%&$%,$,-3% &-#%7-<-#5%+/$%#'%7'"*H4-%!)-%3*#,-%&'%'#D'"-%D-"-%+/$%4"*-"%n'QD'4,-S7-#o%&'%$4!D-./$%&'%7-<-?%%

M##-% *+#S,!*./$% D$##!*% !)% P!-&"$% &'% `a% @!+4*$+R"*$#% P!'% -,'+&')% &'% @$")-% D"'4*#-% -#% 4"*-+.-#5%'+,"',-+,$%@-3,-%!)%D"$H##*$+-3%&'%'&!4-./$%j#*4-5%7*#,$%P!'%2$-%D-",'%&-#%-S7*&-&'#%#'% 4$+4'+,"-%+$%"'4$+>'4*)'+,$%4$"D$"-3?%g#%4!*&-&$#%7/$%&'#&'%-%-3*)'+,-./$5%#'+&$%$@'"'4*&-#% &'%w%-%h%"'@'*.J'#%&*R"*-#5%#')D"'%4$)%$%4$+,"$3'%&'%+!,"*4*$+*#,-#5%-,O%-%-##*#,r+4*-%$&$+,$3G<*4-% "'-3*I-&-%D'3$%0i8%:0"$<"-)-%i-1&'%&-%8-)U3*-;?

(#% &*H4!3&-&'#% &$% XMY% #!"<')% +$% &'4$""'"% &-#% -S7*&-&'#% "'-3*I-&-#% 4$)% -#% 4"*-+.-#?% (,O%$%)$)'+,$%+!+4-%>$!7'%!)-%k&*H4!3&-&'l%)!*,$%#O"*-%4$)$5%D$"%'Q')D3$5%!)-%P!'&-%+$% D-"P!*+>$5%$!%D"$23')-#%&'%#-1&'?%M##'#%-4$+,'4*)'+,$#%&'*Q-)%)-"4-#%D"$@!+&-#5%+/$%#$)'+,'% +-#%4"*-+.-#5%)-#%,-)2O)%+$%D#*4$3G<*4$%&-#%@!+4*$+R"*-#u%LR%$#%)$)'+,$#%&'%#!4'##$#%#/$%P!-+&$% -%4$)!+*&-&'%D-"S4*D-%'%#'%'+7$37'%+-#%-S7*&-&'#%'#4$3-"'#5%4$)%-%D-"S4*D-./$%')%@'#,-#5%'7'+,$#% '%"'!+*J'#?%(D'#-"%&'%#'"%D'P!'+$%$%'+7$37*)'+,$%&-%4$)!+*&-&'%+-#%@'#S7*&-&'#%&-%$"<-+*I-./$? % g%D"*+4*D-3%#'"7*.$%D"'#,-&$%'%$%$2L'S7$%&-%*+#S,!*./$%O%'&!4-"%'%4!*&-"%&-#%4"*-+.-#5% D-"-%*##$%$%P!-&"$%&'%@!+4*$+R"*$#%O%4$)D$#,$%D$"%D'&-<$<-#%P!'%D-##-)%D$"%D"$4'##$%#'3'S7$% '%4$+4!"#$%D123*4$5%-3O)%&'%4$I*+>'*"-#5%-L!&-+,'#%&'%#'"7*.$%<'"-*#%'%D$",'*"$?%g%#'"7*.$%-%4-&-% -+$%D-##-%D$"%"'@$")!3-.J'#5%LR%P!'%#'%-&'P!-%D$"%4-!#-%&-%43*'+,'3-%P!'%O%"$,-S7-?%s'"*H4-)N#'% D-&"$+*I-./$%+-#%@!+.J'#%&'%-3*)'+,-./$5%4!*&-&$#%4$)%-%>*<*'+'%'%3*)D'I-?%g3>-+&$%D-"-%$%3-&$% &'%4$+,-,$%4$)%-#%4"*-+.-#%#'%+$,-%4!*&-&$#%'#D'4*-*#%'%-&'P!-&$#%-%4-&-%-3!+$5%D$*#%+/$%#'%D$&'% D"'7'"%'%+')%)-+*D!3-"%$#%-,$#%&-#%4"*-+.-#? (%,'4+$3$<*-%D"'#'+,'%#'%'+4$+,"-%+$%P!-&"$%-&)*+*#,"-S7$5%$+&'%#'%!S3*I-%&'%4$)D!,-&$"'#% '%#$yz-"'#%'#D'4UH4$#%D-"-%4$+,-2*3*I-"%&-&$#%"'@'"'+,'#%-$#%4-&-#,"$#%&'%-3!+$#%'%P!-&"$%&'% @!+4*$+R"*$#?%(#%4"*-+.-#%@-I')%!#$%&-%,'4+$3$<*-%-D'+-#%+-%@$")-%&'%7U&'$%'%#$)?

g% D3-+'L-)'+,$% O% @'*,$% &'% @$")-% *+,!*S7-% '% 2-#'-&$% ')% D'"4'D.J'#% &-% 4$$"&'+-&$"-5% &'%)-+'*"-%*+@$")-3?%(#%-S7*&-&'#%P!'%7*#-)%$%D3-+'L-)'+,$%#/$%"'-3*I-&-#%&'%-4$"&$%4$)%-#% +'4'##*&-&'#% D"'7*#,-#5% D$&'+&$% #'"% D3-+'L-&-#% )'+#-3)'+,'5% #')-+-3)'+,'% '% -,O% )'#)$% &*-"*-)'+,'5% -,"-7O#% &'% "'!+*J'#% 4$)% $#% @!+4*$+R"*$#% P!'% &*#4!,')% -#% D"$D$#,-#% &'% '+#*+$% '% -#%4$3$4-)%')%D"RS4-%4$)%$#%-3!+$#?%d$&$%D3-+'L-)'+,$%O%-4$)D-+>-&$%+$%)$)'+,$%&'%#!-% 'Q'4!./$5%7*#,$%P!'%-%4$$"&'+-&$"-%D-"S4*D-%&-#%',-D-#%&$#%D"$4'##$#?%(%-7-3*-./$%&$#%"'#!3,-&$#%O% *)'&*-,-%'%P!-+&$%#'%'+4$+,"-)%@-3>-#%O%@'*,$%!)-%-!,$4$""'./$5%@-I'+&$%4$)%P!'%,$&$%$%#*#,')-% ,'+>-%!)%@''&2-4\%#*)!3,q+'$?%g%1+*4$%SD$%&'%4$+,"$3'%@'*,$%D$"%D3-+*3>-%O%$%4$+,"$3'%*+,'"+$%&'% D"$&!,$#%&'%+'4'##*&-&'#%2R#*4-#%:>*<*'+'5%3*)D'I-%'%-3*)'+,-./$;? (%-7-3*-./$%&-%P!-3*&-&'%&$%#'"7*.$%$@'",-&$%D$&'%#'"%"'-3*I-&-%-D'+-#%D'3$#%@-)*3*-"'#5% D$*#%&'%@$")-%&*"',-%$%#'"7*.$%+/$%D$&'%#'"%-7-3*-&$%D'3$%43*'+,'5%D$"%#'%,"-,-"')%&'%4"*-+.-#%&'%x% )'#'#%-%w%-+$#?%g#%D"*+4*D-*#%4"*,O"*$#%&'%L!3<-)'+,$%#/$%4$)$%-#%4"*-+.-#%#/$%,"-,-&-#%'%4$)$%#/$% '+,"'<!'#%-$%H+-3%&$%&*-?%% (%*+#S,!*./$%-&$,-%-$%H)%&'%!)%4*43$%3'S7$%!)-%@$")-%&'%"')-,"U4!3-%D-"-%$#%-3!+$#%P!'%

(5)

LR%'#,/$%)-,"*4!3-&$#%'%-%*+43!#/$%&'%+$7$#%-3!+$#%O%@'*,-%D$"%$"&')%&'%4>'<-&-5%+/$%$4$""'+&$% 3*#,-#%&'%'#D'"-%'%+/$%$4-#*$+-+&$%n@-3#-#o%'#D'"-+.-#%D-"-%$#%@-)*3*-"'#%&-#%4"*-+.-#%P!'%+/$% 4$+#'<!*"-)%-%7-<-?%(%1+*4-%@$")-./$%&'%H3-%'Q*#,'+,'%O%+$%)$)'+,$%&-#%)-,"*4!3-#5%$+&'%$#% D"GD"*$#%@-)*3*-"'#%#'%$"<-+*I-)?

0'"4'2'N#'% P!'% !)% &$#% D"*+4*D-*#% D"$23')-#% '+@"'+,-&$% +-#% *+#S,!*.J'#% &'% '+#*+$% O%$%+1)'"$%&'%7-<-#%$@'",-&-#%P!'%+/$%O%#!H4*'+,'%D-"-%-,'+&'"%-%&')-+&-%&-%4$)!+*&-&'?% p!+,-)'+,'%4$)%*##$%#'%7'"*H4-%!)-%@-3,-%&'%4"*,O"*$#%,O4+*4$#%D-"-%-#%)-,"*4!3-#u%+')%#')D"'%-#% @-)U3*-#%P!'%)-*#%D"'4*#-)%#/$%-,'+&*&-#5%-#%7-<-#%#/$%D"''+4>*&-#%&'%)-+'*"-%-3'-,G"*-%#')%#'% '#,-2'3'4'"%!)-%$"&')%D-"-%P!'%-P!'3'#%P!'%+/$%@$"-)%-,'+&*&$#%4$+#*<-)%$%#'"7*.$%+$%@!,!"$5% D$*#%+/$%>R%-%@$")-./$%&'%!)-%H3-%&'%'#D'"-? g% 03-+'L-)'+,$% O% &'% ,$,-3% *)D$",q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u%*##$%,$"+-%$%-4$)D-+>-)'+,$%&$%#'"7*.$%)!*,$%*+@$")-35%#'+&$%P!'%$%#'"7*.$%&'7'%#'"% $%)-*#%@$")-3%D$##U7'3%7*#,$%P!'%O%D-"-%$%4$3'S7$?

1$-#/)!(2!3%4#%30$5670%403%8/0'$#9!3

Falta de critérios técnicos para matrículas:

(%4-!#-%&'#,'%D"$23')-%O%-%@-3,-%&'%4$)!+*4-./$%'+,"'%-#%#'4"',-"*-#%)!+*4*D-*#5%@-3,-%&'% )'*$#%D-"-%-+-3*#-"%4-#$%-%4-#$%'%$#%4"*,O"*$#%,O4+*4$#%+/$%*+,'"'##-)%-$#%<'#,$"'#5%*)D$",-+&$% #$)'+,'%4$)%-%P!-+S&-&'%&'%)-,"U4!3-#?%(%#$3!./$%'+4$+,"-&-%@$*%,"-2-3>-"%')%4$+L!+,$%4$)% G"</$#%&-%D"'@'*,!"-%P!'%@$"+'.-%&-&$#%#$4*$'4$+{)*4$#%:7!3+'"-2*3*&-&'%#$4*-3;%D-"-%-L!&-"%+$% D"''+4>*)'+,$|#'3'./$%&-#%)-,"U4!3-#?

:0/9!670%4#%;$!3<

(%4-!#-%&'#,'%D"$23')-%O%$%'Q4'##$%&'%&')-+&-5%@-3,-%&'%*+@"-'#,"!,!"-%D-"-%$@'"'4'"%)-*#% 7-<-#u%@-3,-%&'%D3-+'L-)'+,$%+-%>$"-%&-%4$+#,"!./$%&$% XMY%'%$%+1)'"$%"'&!I*&$%&'%@!+4*$+R"*$#?% (%#$3!./$%'+4$+,"-&-%O%-%4$+#,"!./$%&'%+$7-#%!+*&-&'#%-H)%&'%#!D"*"%-%&')-+&-5%7*#,$%P!'%+/$% 'Q*#,'%!)-% XMY%D-"-%-,'+&'"%4-&-%2-*""$?% 4!",!.3). (%4-!#-%&'#,'%D"$23')-%O%-%@-3,-%&'%!)%D3-+'L-)'+,$%@$")-3%@!+&-)'+,-&$%')%)',-#%'% $2L'S7$#%43-"$#5%#'+&$%2-#'-&$#%')%D-"q)',"$#%D$##U7'*#%&'%-7-3*-./$5%@-3,-%&'%4$)!+*4-./$%'+,"'% $#%'+7$37*&$#%+$%#'"7*.$5%@-3,-%&'%)$S7-./$5%@-3,-%&'%@!+4*$+R"*$#5%@-3,-%&'%,"'*+-)'+,$%P!-3*H4-&$%'% #$2"'D$#*./$%&'%,-"'@-#?%(%#$3!./$%'+4$+,"-&-%O%-%!S3*I-./$%&'%4"*,O"*$#%D-"-%P!-+SH4-"%'%P!-3*H4-"% $%#'"7*.$u%,"'*+-)'+,$%'%4-D-4*,-./$%D-"-%$%D'##$-3?

Falta de avaliação de qualidade:

(% 4-!#-% &'#,'% D"$23')-% D$&'% #'"% *+1)'"-5% )-#% ,'+,-)$#% *&'+SH4-"% -3<!+#% D$+,$#% P!'% D$&')% #'"% "'3'7-+,'#5% '+,"'% '3'#b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b%

(6)

• &*#4!S"%,')-#%D-"-%'3-2$"-./$%&'%D"$L',$#u%

• )$)'+,$#% &'% '#,!&$#% D'3$% <"!D$% &'% '&!4-&$"'#% '|$!% -,"-7O#% &-#% +'4'##*&-&'#% -D"'#'+,-&-#%D-"-%'Q'4!./$%&'%D"$L',$#u • "'<*#,"$%&-%D"RS4-%D'&-<G<*4-%'%-D"'+&*I-<')%&$#%-3!+$#u • -7-3*-"%D"RS4-#%D'&-<G<*4-#%'%-S7*&-&'#%&'#'+7$37*&-#%+$%D"$4'##$%&$%#'"7*.$u • ,"$4-#%&'%'QD'"*r+4*-#%:'+,"'%'&!4-&$"'#;u • $"<-+*I-"%)$)'+,$#%&'%#$4*-3*I-./$5%'+,"'%$#%#'"7*&$"'#? $+43!U)$#%P!'%'#,-#%-.J'#%#'"*-)%-#%)'3>$"'#%)-+'*"-#%&'%#$3!4*$+-"%-#%D"$23')RS4-#5% D$*#% #/$% )$&$#% "RD*&$#% &'% 'Q'4!./$% '% 'H4*'+,'% +$% #'!% $2L'S7$5% +/$% 4-!#-+&$% {+!#% D-"-% -% $"<-+*I-./$?%

&0$5670%403%8/0'$#9!3%4#%9!)#+/!%0'=#(2!

(% #$3!./$% &$#% D"$23')-#% &'7'% -4$+,'4'"% &'% @$")-% D3-+'L-&-% '% $"<-+*I-&-5% 2!#4-+&$% $% -!QU3*$%&'%,$&$#%$#%)')2"$#%&-%#$4*'&-&'5%D"*+4*D-3)'+,'%&-%i'4"',-"*-%&-%M&!4-./$%'%$!,"$#%G"</$% &$%<$7'"+$%)!+*4*D-35%4$)$%-%i'4"',-"*-%&'%(##*#,r+4*-%i$4*-35%P!'%D$&'%@-I'"%!)%)-D'-)'+,$% &-% 4$)!+*&-&'5% *&'+SH4-+&$% P!-*#% #/$% -#% @-)U3*-#% P!'% )-*#% +'4'##*,-)% &$% -,'+&*)'+,$% '% -% i'4"',-"*-%&'%03-+'L-)'+,$5%P!'%D$&'%2!#4-"%D-"4'"*-#%D123*4-#%D"*7-&-#%$!%2!#4-"%)-*#%$".-)'+,$% D-"-%4$+#,"!./$%&'%)-*#% XMYi5%-,'+&'+&$%-##*)%!)%)-*$"%+1)'"$%&'%4"*-+.-#%'%&*)*+!*+&$%-% demanda. s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

Plano de ação

T'%-4$"&$%4$)%$%-!,$"%&$%3*7"$%ng#%`]%'""$#%43R##*4$#%&-%<'#,/$%&'%D"$L',$#o5%M3*%c$&"*<!'#5% &'H+'% 03-+$% &'% (./$% 4$)$% !)-% @'""-)'+,-% D-"-% -4$)D-+>-)'+,$% &'% -S7*&-&'#5% -!Q*3*-+&$% +-%4$$"&'+-./$%&-#%'P!*D'#5%D$*#%'QD3*4*,-%P!')%O%"'#D$+#R7'3%D$"%4-&-%-S7*&-&'5%-#%&-,-#%&'% '+,"'<-%'%-+$,-.J'#|4$)'+,R"*$#%#$2"'%$%D"$<"'##$?%F%D$##U7'3%-D"'#'+,-"%@R4*3%'%"-D*&-)'+,'%$% -+&-)'+,$%&'%-S7*&-&'#5%-#%,RS4-#%!S3*I-&-#5%P!')%'Q'4!,$!5%P!-+&$5%'+,"'%$!,"-#%*+@$")-.J'#?

% g%)$&'3$%'#4$3>*&$%D-"-%-%$"<-+*I-./$%@$*%$%nX$&'3$%i*)D3'#o?%M#,'%)$&'3$%-D"'#'+,-% -D'+-#%-#%*+@$")-.J'#%)-*#%2R#*4-#%4$)$%n$%P!'%@-I'"[o5%n4$)$%@-I'"[o%n}!-+&$%@-I'"[o5%nD-"-% P!')[o% M% nD$"% P!')[o?% c$&"*<!'#% :`a]w;% -4"'&*,-% P!'% '#,'% )$&'3$% D$##!*% -% 7-+,-<')% &'% #'"% #*)D3'#%'%D$&'%#'"%)$+,-&$%"-D*&-)'+,'%D$"%P!-3P!'"%D'##$-?%

:0/9!3%4#%,0)-/0$#%8!/!%2#/+;,!/%0%8$!)0%4#%!670%#%!%/#30$5670%403%

problemas

(DG#%&'H+*"%&',-3>-&-)'+,'%4$)$%#'"R%@'*,$%$%D3-+$%&'%-./$%O%+'4'##R"*$%P!'%#'%,'+>-% !)%)'4-+*#)$%&'%4$+,"$3'%D-"-%$%)'#)$?%T'##-%@$")-%D$&'"R%*&'+SH4-"%#'%$%D3-+$%'#,R%#'+&$% '@'S7$%+-%*+#S,!*./$%'%,-)2O)%#'%$#%D"$23')-#%@$"-)%"'#$37*&$#%$!%-*+&-%D'"#*#,')%+$% XMY?% ]~%0-##$b%(DG#%-D"'#'+,-./$%&$%"'#!3,-&$%&-%4$+#!3,$"*-5%&'7'N#'%@-I'"%!)-%-7-3*-./$%')% 4$+L!+,$%4$)%-%'P!*D'%D'&-<G<*4-%&-%'#4$3-%D-"-%-7-3*-"%$#%"'#!3,-&$#%'%-+-3*#-"%-%7*-2*3*&-&'%&-% D"$D$#,-?%M%&*-+,'%&*##$%'#,-2'3'4'"%!)%4$+L!+,$%&'%)',-#%'%)!&-+.-#%D-"-%#'"')%*)D3')'+,-&-#% +$%4!",$%D"-I$5%D$"%)'*$%&'%!)-%D3-,-@$")-%&*<*,-3%&'%4$)D-"S3>-)'+,$%&'%*+@$")-.J'#?%T'##-% )-+'*"-%-%4$$"&'+-&$"-%&'7'%@-I'"%!)%"'3-,G"*$%)'+#-35%&',-3>-+&$%$%P!'%@$*%@'*,$%'%4$)$%'#,R% sendo as mudanças, se melhorou ou não o serviço.

`~% 0-##$b% c'-3*I-./$% &'% !)-% "'!+*/$% 4$)% -% 4$$"&'+-./$% &$% XMY% '% 4$)% "'#D$+#R7'*#% &-#%#'4"',-"*-#%)!+*4*D-*#b%+'#,-%"'!+*/$%#'"R%*+#'"*&-%-%D"$D$#,-%&'%-7-3*-.J'#%*+#S,!4*$+-*#%'%

(7)

'Q,'"+-#%D-"-%)$+*,$"-"%$%&'#')D'+>$%&$#%D"$H##*$+-*#%&-% MXMYi%'%,-)2O)%4"*-"%&$4!)'+,$#% D-"-%+$%3$+<$%D"-I$%,'")$#%!)%2-+4$%&'%&-&$#%D-"-%@!,!"-#%4$)D-"-.J'#?%T'##'%)$&$5%-3O)% &-#%-7-3*-.J'#%P!-+S,-S7-#%D$&')$#%4"*-"%)'4-+*#)$#%D-"-%-7-3*-.J'#%P!-3*,-S7-#5%4$)%2-#'%+-#% 'QD'"*r+4*-#%LR%$4$""*&-#%'%,-)2O)5%4$)$%+/$%#'"R%!)-%2-#'%&'%&-&$#%"'#,"*,-%-%4-&-% MXMY5% #'"R% !)-% 2-#'% &'% &-&$#% )!+*4*D-35% D$&'"R% #'"% -7-3*-&-% -% 7*-2*3*&-&'% &'% @!,!"$#% 2"-*+#,$")'#5% 4$+#'P!'+,')'+,'%$%4$+,"$3'%&$#%*+&*4-&$"'#%#'%&-"R%D'3$%2-+4$%&'%&-&$#%)!+*4*D-3?

w~% 0-##$b% 8$"+'4'"% ,"'*+-)'+,$5% 4!"#$#5% -##'##$"-)'+,$#b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d-)2O)% #'"/$% *)D3')'+,-&-#%"'!+*J'#%)'+#-*#%4$)%-%D-!,-%&'%4!"#$#%&'%4-D-4*,-./$%D-"-%$#%D"$H##*$+-*#5%'#,'#% 4!"#$#%&'7')%#'"%'#,-2'3'4*&$#%4$+@$")'%-%&')-+&-%&$#% XMYi?%6)-%D3-,-@$")-%LR%&*#D$+U7'3% D'3$% XM % #/$% $#% 4!"#$#% N)#*$4+$>'! 1! F%,1"*+'*6+;B#! 12! F0&"+;B#! G$4+$>'?! (% -+R3*#'% &'##'% SD$% &'%4-D-4*,-./$%&'7'"R%#'"%)'&*&-%D$"%!)%SD$%&'%D"$7-%'#4"*,-%$!%-,O%)'#)$%!)-%-7-3*-./$%&'% &'#')D'+>$%@'*,-%D'3-%4$$"&'+-&$"-5

0$"% H)% -% "'-3*I-./$% &'% $H4*+-#% D-"-% 7'"% 4$)$% '#,R% #'+&$% +-% D"-S4-% -% 4-D-4*,-./$?% (#% $H4*+-#% ,-)2O)% #'"/$% "'-3*I-&-#% 4$)$% @$")-% &'% ,"'*+-)'+,$% '% 4-D-4*,-./$?% (% -7-3*-./$% #'"R% @'*,-%')%<"!D$5%$+&'%4-&-%D"$@'##$"%-D"'#'+,-"R%D-"-%#'!#%4$3'<-#%#!-#%D"$D$#,-#5%*+#S<-+&$%-% -D"'+&*I-<')%'%)!&-+.-%4$)D$",-)'+,-3%&'%,$&$#?%

>0)3+4#/!6?#3%;)!+3

% (DG#%7*#*,-"%$% XMY%@$*%D$##U7'3%D'"4'2'"%$#%&'#-H$#%'%@-3>-#%D"'#'+,'#%+'##-%$"<-+*I-./$?% 0$#,$% *#,$5% 3*#,-)$#% $#% D"*+4*D-*#% D"$23')-#5% P!'% +'#,'% 4-#$% @$"-)% -% @-3,-% &'% D3-+'L-)'+,$5% $% 'Q4'##$%&'%&')-+&-5%-%@-3,-%&'%4"*,O"*$#%D-"-%-#%)-,"U4!3-#%'%-%@-3,-%&'%-7-3*-./$%&'%P!-3*&-&'?% d-)2O)% D"$D$)$#% D$##U7'*#% #$3!.J'#% D-"-% '#,'#% D"$23')-#5% ,-*#% 4$)$% ,"'*+-)'+,$#5% 4!"#$#% '% -##'##$"-)'+,$#%D-"-%$#%@!+4*$+R"*$#%'+7$37*&$#u%4"*-./$%'%&*#,"*2!*./$%&'%#'+>-#%D-"-%-#%)-,"U4!3-#5% 7*#-+&$%-%+/$%4$+4'+,"-./$%&'%H3-#%D-"-%-#%)-,"U4!3-#5%&*7*&*+&$N-#%'+,"'%&*-#%-3,'"+-&$#%D-"-%4-&-% +U7'3%'#4$3-"u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i%+$%M#,-&$%&'%X*+-#%Z'"-*#5%D$##*2*3*,-+&$%-##*)%!)%)-*$"%4$+>'4*)'+,$%&'##-#% $"<-+*I-.J'#?%

Referências

K(ccMddg5%M32-%i*P!'*"-%&'%iRu%XYdc69Yi5%M3'+?%:`aa];?%nd"-L',G"*-%'%&'#-H$#%&$#%4*43$#%'#4$3-"'#% +$%0-U#o?%Estud?%-7?%k$+3*+'l?%7$3?]C5%+?h`5%DD?%]awN]ha?%

KYc t(95% 8-2*-+$% 8'"+-+&'#% i'""-+$u% (XK(9TM5% (+&"O% 9!*I% e% KMcXMpg5% 0-!3$% t'+"*P!'% &'% i$!I-?%:à]`;?%03-+'L-)'+,$%'#,"-,O<*4$%#*,!-4*$+-3%-D3*4-&$%W%#'<!"-+.-%D123*4-%')%9-7"-#%:XZ;? Rev. Adm. Pública5%c*$%&'%p-+'*"$5%7?%hx5%+?%`5%D?%C`wNChC?%T*#D$+U7'3%')%>mDb||zzz?#4*'3$?2"| #4*'3$?D>D[#4"*D,#4*A-"m'Q,eD*&iaawhN_x]`à]àaaàaaaBe3+<D,e+")*#$?% (4'##$% ')b%% ``%+$7?%%à]C?%%

(8)

&-#%H3-#%-$%d*)'NT"*7'+%(K %X$&'3b%!)-%-+R3*#'%&-%4-D-4*&-&'%$4*$#-?%Enfoqueb%c'E'Q/$% $+,R2*35% 7?%`^5%+?%]5%D?%haNCw?

Z6YX(cvMi5% d$)R#% &'% (P!*+$?% :`aaa;?% (% +$7-% -&)*+*#,"-./$% D123*4-% '% -% -2$"&-<')% &-% 4$)D',r+4*-?%Revista de Administração Pública5%7?%wh5%+?%w5%)-*$|L!+?

XM9g5%T-+*'3-%&'% -#,"$%e%(9 (fd(c(5%c$#-+'%914*-% >*4-"'33*?%:à]];?%(%<'#,/$%&-%&')-+&-%')% 4-&'*-#%&'%#!D"*)'+,$#b%!)-%-2$"&-<')%-3O)%&-%D"'7*#/$%&'%7'+&-#? Gest. Prod?5%i/$% -"3$#5%7?% ]^5%+?%h5%D?%âBN^`h?%%%T*#D$+U7'3%')%>mDb||zzz?#4*'3$?2"|#4*'3$?D>D[#4"*D,#4*A-"m'Q,eD*&ia]ahN Cwaà]]aaahaaaaBe3+<D,e+")*#$?%(4'##$%')b%%``%+$7?%%à]C?%

cYMZ5%T'+*#'%9!4*-+-%e%(c(6pg%8Y9tg5%d-"<*+$%&'?%:àa`;?%g%!#$%&-#%)',$&$3$<*-#%n03-+'L-)'+,$% M#,"-,O<*4$% i*,!-4*$+-3o% '% nX-D'-)'+,$% $<+*S7$o% ')% !)-% #*,!-./$% 4$+4"',-b% $% 4-#$% &-% D"GN "'*,$"-%&'%'Q,'+#/$%&-%68i -"? Gest. Prod.5%i/$% -"3$#5%7?%B5%+?%`5%D?%]xwN]_B?%T*#D$+U7'3%')%>mDb|| zzz?#4*'3$?2"|#4*'3$?D>D[#4"*D,#4*A-"m'Q,eD*&ia]ahNCwaàaàaaàaaaCe3+<D,e+")*#$?% (4'##$%')b%%``%+$7?%%à]C?%%

cgTcYZ6Mi5%M3*?%Os 21 erros clássicos da gestão de projetos: descubra o que NÃO fazer, de uma "0/9!%8/@(,!%#%'#9AB590/!4!?%c*$%&'%p-+'*"$b%K"-#D$",5%`a]w5]hhD?

iY9sMYc(%pfYgc5%(3&'"?%Planejamento estratégico como instrumento de mudança organizacional. T*##'",-./$%:X'#,"-&$%')%(&)*+*#,"-./$;%N%6+*7'"#*&-&'%&'%K"-#U3*-5%]BBC5%K"-#U3*-?

ig6(5%8'"+-+&$%K'"+-"&*%&'%e%K(0dYid(5%t!)2'",$%c$##'?%0"$D$#,-%&'%-7-+.$%D-"-%$%)O,$&$% d-)2$"N0!3)/$N $"&-%i*)D3*H4-&$%-D3*4-&$%')%-)2*'+,'#%&'%D"$&!./$%#$2%'+4$)'+&-? Gest. Prod.5% i/$% -"3$#5% à]a5% 7?% ]_5% +?% h5% D?% _wCN_hx?% T*#D$+U7'3% ')% >mDb||zzz?#4*'3$?2"|#4*'3$? D>D[#4"*D,#4*A-"m'Q,eD*&ia]ahNCwaà]aaaahaaaaê3+<D,e+")*#$?%(4'##$%')b%%``%+$7?%% à]C?%%

c'4'2*&$%')%`w%&'%L-+'*"$%&'%`a]_? (D"$7-&$%')%]w%&'%)-".$%&'%`a]_?