Heterotic parametrization for economically important traits in popcorn

Damião Cruz

, Antonio Teixeira do Amaral Júnior

and Carlos Alberto Scapim

1

Universidade Estadual de Maringá, Av. Colombo, 5790, 87020-900, Maringá, Paraná, Brazil. 2Universidade Federal de Viçosa, Viçosa, Minas Gerais, Brazil. 3Universidade Estadual do Norte Fluminense Darcy Ribeiro, Campos dos Goytacazes, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. *Author for correspondence. E-mail: cascapim@uem.br

!! ! " # $ %

" # " " & ! ' " & " ' &

!! (" " # ! ' #! )

" " ! * + * , - .

- ' ! " ! ! !

(" " "! & && & " & ! " " & " " " & !! &

! & ! ! & " !

" " " && & ! " (" # # & ! %

" ! & & " !!

! & " &! & # ! " !

& ! # # # ! !

" ! & ! ! #

!"# $ % !! ! " # ! /

& '( ) *" + ,- ." " / 0 " 1 %" *0 2 " 3*

"* * 4. 0 0 !" & ' 0 !1!

# +2 $ "3# % 4 ! ' +2 " 5

3 6 7 "3# & !

! #! 8 +9 * + * ,

-: . - ! 8 1 ! % ! 3

! 2 2 ; & ! &

" 1 ! ! 0

3 & & & +2

! 2 0

0 & " ! !" # +9

2 &

< 2 " ! &

" 3& # ! & &! 8 =

# ! 2 3 . " ! = 2

2 2 # ! ' +2

! 0 2 ! +2

3

) 4 5 . " ! ! " 2 = # ! /

(" ' ) " > ! &

! - ' ! " $? @

; ! ! AB1!

C # " " " # D E F &

! " # D , -, G.:/

H%* - 2 * + " !! I

& " !! & ! #!

! " A F <E ! @ D %,:E(

CJGE7, ! @D G(7 ! >D <:,:E,

! KD , G.:/ ! KD *E/:/ ! KI

F " ! &

- ' ! " && " !

" ! & " # # #!

& "

& "

& G " " # A& ! <@ K

<@ K ;( <@ K <@ <@ $I - ' !

# ) L )

! " " " #

" M A N B OE

! D P ,7 ! D %,:E(

CJGE7, ! @D , G.:/ ! >I

/ " " " & &

" " )

0 #! " " # & !

" # " ! & " - ' !

A GP, P:

! D F <E ! @#D E, GP !

KD G(7 ! KI "

& . - ' ! )

! # " & " & !

! ! ; " & "

. && ! &

" ) & !

E " " !

" # & ! & &

) ! - ' ! A,EFFE !

> #D E/* ! >I 0 ! &

A 7(:,/: ! KI &

A*:GP,H F7/7 ! D *E:E, !

I A<:,:E, ! @D KD

P GP7/EGE ! KD *E/:/ ! KD

E/* ! I " & #

AP ,7 ! #D %,:E( CJGE7,

! @D *E G ! >D , G.:/ ! KD

,7P7* /;7 ! KD G(7 ! KD

,G;7/P ! D %,:E( CJGE7, !

I

E & " " " & # ! & ) !

!! & " ! ) &

" # " #

! # ! & " ! &

" # & ! ! !

#! & ! ! % "

" !! ! ! ! !& #!

! " " # &

! " " AF,HB ! D %,:E(

CHGE7, ! @D F <E ! @ D

E, GP ! KI

- " & !! ! !

& - ' ! % ! B

A K I ! ' !! ! & !

& " & " &

/ ! A I

# ! & " & "

E " !! ! A F <E ! I

!! ! !

< " " ! #

" , ! & !

! - " !

!

& " # ! & !

! & " " ! # # !

! ! A @ I #

! & ! "

! !! !

" # !! #! #

" G " & < N " "

#Q & " # &

! #

& " " "

" ! & ! # -,

G.:/ F !! " !

& ! !

" "

E " % CR ! A @I

! " # # ! &

& & " # & ! !

!! ! ,

C - ' ! (" ! "

HG- H F -, G.:/ HG- H F

* + H%* & ! # " !

& ! # " # #

<, : ! -, G.:/ HG- H F

-, G.:/

! A KI ) " ! &

!! ! " &

& " # AE F B1! I

" !! A,

-I ! S I - ' ! "

" # ! &

! ! ! D I

" # ! - ' !

! " !! " ! &

&& & ! D I

! # && ! # ! " #

! & ! ! # " "

& &

" " Q &

&& & A<:,:E, D , /

CJGE7, D E 7G ! D %,:E(

CJGE7, ! @D , G.:/ ! >I #

" # ! && ! #

" & !

" ! ! - ' ! E " *

A I % CR ! A @I , !

! A KI ) " - ' ! !

& " " & # # !

# " ! &

! " && & "

# ! !! # #

N " " & #

" !! ! " "

- ' ! ! "

!

" $

" # % !! !

" & !

!! # ! &

" '

& A

I

!! ! # $ % " # #

" ! % #! " " " #

# " @

!! # !

& # #

! &! !

& #! " && 0 &

" # " & "

O & # !! " !!

& " !!

; # !

" &

. S * , - * + D

" : "

A " & & " # I

' #! ) " "

! <! & &

! A #

I " " & ! ' "

$ ) & K AG < 7$ O 7I ! ) &

! G ! & ("

" ! #

(" & !! ! S ! " "

A<;I D " " A:;I D ! A.LI

) " D " & AN:ID & "

A I D A<:I <:

! " T " &

" !! &

> UF " ! # : #

E +2 " ) !

& $ ! # "

/ " ! &

& ) ! " ! &

" !

(" ! & & "

& " ! T & # # ! # "

% (" O T &

# # ! "

" ! & " ! &

" & ! ! & .

:# " A @@I & "

(" ! Q ! &

& .:G: & AF,HB

@I

F " " % A V $I

! " & 0

& " ! ! & !!

#! " & " Q !

" "

& && " 0 &

" & # % A V I

Q ! !! " & " 0

# " && A

" I ! "

! " && "

" # & !! A V I E & " "

&& !

! & #!

& #

(" & " " ' "

0 & " && & !

" " " ! " ! "

0 & " " &

A V I E " !

" & 0 " # #!

# & ! " &

" ! " - "

& && & ! & "

&& "

& 0 " " ! &

" & 0 " ! ! &

! " "

! A I ) " !! ! &

& & &

! E <

- ' ! ! # & &

" && & ! " "

" ! & ! & "

- " ! ! # #!

" ! " " #! #

" " & "

# & " # & " E ! ! &

" ) " ! &&

! ! - C ! A @I " ! &

! ' # !! ! ! & " !

" " & !

' # % "

" !! " " "

" !) ! E & " "

! ) ! # #!

!) ! (" " & "

! # ! & ! "

" ' - !! "

" " ! # "

AF7E -, ! I "

# " & " & !

(" ! !! " " #

& " & && & &

" A V I " " ! "

A V $I && " ! ! &

" & 0 !

(" & " " &

&& & " ! & "

A V I !

& 0 " " & "

&& # " " &

& 0 !! && "

! ! & & 0 ! #

" ! !

F "

& & " 0 V & !

& " # " " " "

A V $I # ! & "

* ) F ' A K I &

0 & " &

! &

! & " ! " "

0 & " " ! &

(" ! & " ! &

" " #! ! #

" ! # "

& ! " !! !

F " 0 & " "

& " ! " " &

A V I & " 0 &

! & " ) #!

" " & & & " "

! EE A. ,PG:,D :-:,; ,( @@D F,HB

! I 7 " " " " ! E*

#! & " " &

. :# " A @@I ! A I

F ' ! A I

: & " &&

A( #! I ! " " " ! &

v

! " " & " !

E " " !

!! & ("

&& & " " " M

& (" " "

" " & " & " "

j

v

ˆ

("

v

! " ! S

" " " " & ("

! ! " & " "

& # &

F " A.L

<:I ! " !

! &

v

! A( #! I

(" & " ! &

! # # "

! !! & " !

0 & " && "

" " &! &

/ " - # ) A I <

! CR A I ! A I

! A I % CR ! A @I

, ! ! A >I #

!! ! &

v

ˆ

74" : & " " A

v

" A P I # ! &

! !! ! "

(

* <; :; .L N: G:

$> $ $ $ > >>

K > K $ @ >

@ K $ $$ K>>

@ K K$ > K>

@K K $@$ KK >

K K$ K

P Avi−vjI @ K $@ K

K > >K $@$ $K K >

<;S ! " " :;S " " .LS ! N:S " & G:S # & S & "

74" : & " " A

v

&& " A P I #

! & A<:I "

" %M" #

.

* E EE EEE

$@$ @@ >

$ $ >

$ >> @

K@$ @ >

@$ $> K

@$ > $

P Avi−vjI > @ K

$ @$ @>

ES " & ! * + EES "

! * , - EEES "

! * +

(" "

v

! E

! E

" "

" " ! & "

v

! !! ! "

& ! & " & &

* + * , - "

& " " " " &! !

" & # ! !

& ! ! & !

" !

" F" A K$I "

& " #

&& " " !

" "

-( #! " # ! "

! & !! "

!!

v

A $ I N: A KKI G: A$ @I A@ @ I <: & "

" & ! * +

A I <: & " "

! * , - A >I

<: & " "

! * + A I

: & " # "

" ! ! "

" # " !

! " ( #!

; # " ! & " 0 &&

& " & 0 # !

" ! ! & (" "

" # !

! ! & : "

" #! "

! # &

# " & "

# ' "

& ! &

A*:GF7* OLD F,HB K D F <E !

D F,HB ! D F,HB $I

<

Q "

W ! & ! " "

" " ! " &

" & " " " "

&! " & & " 7 !

" # A I " ! & "

Q

"W & # & &

! # "

&! & " && 7 " " "

ij

hˆ ! Q !

& & " "

# ! " & "

" & " #

" & " " ! " & "

& " A( #! I

! ! & " & "

"

! & "W_Q !! !

" # !

&! " & # " A( #! I

74" : & " ! " # "

" ! ! " A P I

# " # " ! ! &

! & & %M &

!! ! "

(

; # <; :; .L N: G:

K$ $ >$ $ K$ K

$ >$ $ $ >>$

$$ $ $ $ >$

$ $ $ $ $ > K $

@ $ K $@$ @ $

$ $ $ @ $ @@ $

>$ K $ @ > $

$ $ $ $ $ @ $ >$ K

@ $ $ $ $ > $ > $

$ $ > K@ $>$ $

$ K @$ @ $ > $ $

@ @ $ $ @@$ K$

$ $ @$ @ $@$

@ K$ >@$ K>$

$ @ >$ $@$ $

P A_{h h}

ij− klI $ K > @

P A_{h h}

ij− jkI @ $ > $ >

S S S S $S @S <;S !

" " :;S " " .LS ! N:S " & G:S # & S & "

74" : & " ! " # " "

A P I # " # " ! !

& A<:I "

& & %M & !! ! "

. ; #

E EE EEE

@ $

K $

K$ $@$ $

$ > $$ >

@ @$ $

$ $ K$

K$ K$

$ @@$ >@$

@ $ @$ $

$ @@$

$ @ $ KK

@ $ @ $

$ K $ @$

@ $ K >

$ @ >$ K $

P A_{h h}

ij− klI @K

P A_{h h}

ij− ikI @ @>

S S S S $S @S ES "

& ! * + EES " ! *

, - EEES " ! * +

(" ! " ! # #

! A I ! A I *

A I E& " ! ) # '

& & #!

" " !! #!

' " & ! "

# E & " "

& ! #

' A N B OE !

D P ,7 ! #I

" !

# ! ' & E & " " "

# & ' #

! E "

! " " #

! & ! # ! !

" # #!

& " ! & ' # & "

#! & " " " && #

" " ! ! &

" ! ! ("

# " " !

# " ! & &

& " /

E ! ! " " " &

" ! # " " #

" " #

" " ! (" " "

! & "W_QX " 0 !! #

#

A( #! I ! " " # "

& ! !

# #

! # ! & "

!!

" ' " "

&& " !!

" & !

, " A( #! I "

" #

" ! & "

& !! ! A( #! I

! " !! " # &

! # " &

v

& & " !

& ! " " #

# " " ("

! # A I "

" !! !

A( #! I

(" # " # & !

" # 0 ! & &

- " " !

# & # &

# & # " #

" " & ! ! " "

!! " " ! " ) &

&& & ! " A( #! I " & &

" # "

" " ! &

" & A( #! I

" ! & " & " #

# & " & "

" !

" " ("

" " " S_ii

(" " & ! " &

$K ± @ ) " > ± K )

" " " " " & " !

A( #! $I (" ! "

" "

" # " " " # ! & " # " #

! " & #

" " && & ! "

E & & & " 0 &

" ! " & # &

A V I "

" ! & ! " Ah_jI

& "

& " E ! " &

" " ! #

& hj KK

! "

) #! " " ! !

& !! S I " & ! "

" ! & "W_Q " "

D I "

& # "

7 " " "

" !

" (" " & ' "

! && ! " " 0

& " # & "

& & ' & #

" " "

74" : & " && & AhI ! Ah_jI

" A P I & & !

!! ! "

(

* .L N: G:

$ K K > K

K $$$

>

$K $ $ $

>K @

$K>

P A_{h h}

i− jI >

h $K > $K

P AhI @ K $

.LS ! N:S " & G:S # & S &

"

F " "

& "

A& !

* + I - " "

A ! * , - I

" " & "

! A( #! @I E

" & &&

" " " # # !!

" && & !

M & "

#! F " "

&& " &

" " ! " &

A/ ,E ;D -,:N- O:, D <:,:E, D

, / CJGE7, D F <E ! D

%,:E( CJGE7, ! @D , G.:/ !

KI " "

& #

! " " && ! "

! &

74" : & " && & AhI ! A_h

jI

" A P I #

! & A<:I "

" %M" #

.

* E EE EEE

> @

K >

@ $ @

$ K @ @>

> $ $$

P A_{h h}

i− jI @ $

h > @ @>

P AhI $ > $ K

ES " & ! * + EES "

! * , - EEES "

! * +

(" " &

! " !! ! "

" " " " "

" A( #! @I 7 "

" " ! " ! "

A( #! @I " # "

! ! # ( #!

& " & " #

" & " A( #!

>I & ! " " #

" " " " ! &

s

ˆ

" " " # "

" " " & #! && &

s

I &

# !! " # &

, " & " " #

"

! # & #

! " ' # "

"

s

"

& s_ij ! !!

! & A( #! KI

" ! # !

& " # " " " " "

& " & !

74" 8 & & & " AsijI

A P I & & ! & &

" # & !! ! "

(

; # .L N: G:

K$ K $ K@

K K@ @

@ @ > >

$ @ $ >$ @

@ K > $

@ $ >K

K KK

$ > K $

@ > > @@

$ > @

$ $ $> @$@

@ $ @@ $> K

$ $$ > >

@ @ @ >@

$ @ $ @ > @$

P A_{s s}

ij− ikI >

P A_{s s}

ij− klI @ K

S S S S $S @S .LS !

N:S " & G:S # & S & "

74" : & & " AsijI

A P I # " # & & &

" # & !! ! "

. ; #

E EE EEE

K$ > @

K $ $

@ K

$ >

@ >$K K K

@ $ @ @

K >>> K

$ K > K

@ @ $$

$ $

$ K @

@ @ @

$ >>K K

@ @ > K

$ @ K >$ $

P A_{s s}

ij− ikI @ $

P A_{s s}

ij− klI K@$ > > K

S S S S $S @S ES "

& ! * + EES " ! *

, - EEES " ! * +

(" & " " # "

! # ! ! &

# & !

! & "

(" " & - ' ! " Q !

& !

& ! " " # ! ! "

! !

" !

! ! !

F " ! & "

# ; !! :# " A > I

# " & "

! # # & !! # "

#

# ! " # ! #

# ! !

& " " #

% " & - ' ! " Q ! &

! &

! #

! !

(" " "

# && ! " "

(" & " & !

"

" & # !

" & & "

& & "

! & !

# # #

! !

GP, P: , D F,HB F P D F <E F D

E/*Y,E7 / D <EG(7 , C - D (7G:( !

!1! # 5

!" " 9* *#

>

,G;7/P : D *E G C D E/* , . D 7,

% :& 8 ! 1 ! +2 & 3!

= !" " 9*

*# >

F7E -, , , D E, GP . * D F,HB F P D

*E G C F ! +9

! +2 !" P%( , # 2 "

" " K >K > $

F,HB F P D ,:. BBE C D F ,G:E,7 < F

( %"4 7 *: 04 % *"4. *"

" : * + S H%*

F,HB F P ) 10 %" " : ;9

* + S H%* $

F,HB F P ) * " "S 2 S !

! 1 3 * + S H%* @

P GP7/EGE ( D F <E F D , /

CJGE7, ( D G.7/EG F D F; P7

% < D 7(( D /7<: P .

! # !! ) 0

""% % 004 "% " . 4 # K

K

P ,7 D , / CJGE7, ( D <:,:E,

. D G(7 % D . -,E:/ < F D F <E F D

%,:E( CJGE7, < D E/*Y,E7 / ,

! # & ! " 4

@ @ @ @

P ,7 D , / CJGE7, ( D <:,:E,

. D G(7 % D F <E F D %,:E(

CJGE7, < D P ;:, , % D Z*E/ ,

F ! +9 6 !

! +2 !" < 9 4

$ K #

%,:E( CJGE7, < D , / CJGE7, ( D

<:,:E, . D F,HB F P D F <E F

F # 5 !"

! ! ! )" ;9 0" 9= 4"

$ @ > @

%,:E( CJGE7, < D , / CJGE7, ( D

, G.:/ , D *E G < .

# & !! # ! 0 ""% %

004 "% " . 4 # >

. ,PG:, F 7 D :-:,; ,( !

& " !! ! !

! *" $ @@

; // H:, , D :-:,; ,( , ! & !!

# ! 0 " " $ @ >

CE ; F D F;7 C N D L O N ( P !! ! !

& ! " " ! ' A / I

> 9 4 ? ." @ 94 # ? 94 9 " $

K @

/ ,E ; / / - D -,:N- O:, C / P !! ! ! &

! ( #%

> K

E, GP . * D 7HB / * D . /*[7 C F F D

.HE ,[: / C D :/7 * D G(7 E F

. # ! " & - ' !

! &90.# @ K

7(:,/: / D F <E F D -, FFEGE /

,7P7* /;7 D - ,,:(7 , , E &! 8

"3 # " "3#

!" < " " 4 @

K K > K

<:,:E, . D , / CJGE7, ( :

& # "

0 ""% % 004 "% " . 4 #

<:,:E, / O D G.7/EG F D F <E F D

< F;:F7 F < D -7G (7 F D F; P7

% < ! " ' &

! & " !& # ! & F

A / I ( #% $ $@ $@@ @

<:,:E, / O D F <E F D G.7/EG F D

F; P7 % < D < F;:F7 F < D 7,

% ; ' & !! " !& # !

? " . 4 # K $ K

, G.:/ , D , / CJGE7, ( D *E G

< D %,:E( CJGE7, < < &

" # 0 ""% %

004 "% " . 4 # > K> $ >

, G.:/ , D , / CJGE7, ( D F <E

F D %,:E( CJGE7, < D <:,:E, .

. " # & !

!! ! A" " % ( 4" 94 " " .

> K

,EFFE . F / D E/* G D < ./E ,EGE D

F <E F - " A / I

A" " % ( 4" 94 " " . @ >

>

,EFFE . F / D E/* G D < ./E ,EGE D

F <E F # ! &

A / I A" " % ( 4" 94

" " . @ K >#

,7P7* /;7 D 7, % D G(7 : D

F <E F D ,G;7/P : ! " # ! @

& ! & " S - "

" " " / $ $$ @ K

G(7 % D , / CJGE7, ( D %,:E(

CJGE7, < D , G.:/ , D <:,:E, .

< +2 " 1 3 ! +2

! +2 !" HG- H # ! +2

@@ K >

G(7 % D , / CJGE7, (D %,:E(

CJGE7, < D , G.:/ , D F <E F D

7, % . & " "

! ! !

" 9* *# $ @$ @$K K

N B OE : D F (,7 C / D . //7 < - D

< (:,GE G : . B D E/* , D /HP:, ,

, < ! "3# !"

' ! E F "

4" %" ( 4. " @ >

F <E F D < F;:F7 F < D (7G:( D

-, FFEGE / D <EG(7 , C - ! !1!

" ! +9 !"

@

F <E F D <EG(7 , C - D , / CJGE7, ( D P GP7/EGE ( F # # ! & "

! 0 ""% % 004 "%

" . 4 # @ @ @

F <E F D -, FFEGE / D <EG(7 , C - D

, / CJGE7, ( D ,7P7* /;7 D E/*

, D 7(:,/: / F 1 1

2 ! +9 !"

< 9 4 @ @ @#

E/* % < ( - D /7<: : % D < ./E ,EGE

D F <E F :&& & "

0 ""% %

004 "% " . 4 # > @ >

E/* ( D <EG(7 , - C D F <E F D

G.7/EG F D F; P7 % < D

F ,* /;7 G .

!! # !) PG

0 ""% % 004 "% " . 4 #

@

E 7G . D F <E F D < F;:F7 F < D

<EG(7 , C - D -, FFEGE / D (7G:(

P 2 ! +9 !"

@ $$ @

EG.; , O D F; HP; ,L - P *" 4

*" . % ;9 " " " 4# G P !" S

O ! < #! " K$

*:GF7* OL , D F,HB F P F +2 !

1 ! !1! " 4" %"

A" : $ K K

*:GP,H F7/7 : F . D F <E F D

< F;:F7 F < D 7/E*:E, * , D -, FFEGE

/ D .7GF /*: *EPE. / F # !

# ! ! !" 2

! - ! )" ;9 0" 9= 4" @

*E G C D (( % < ! & !

& # # ! & !

! !& A" " % ( 4" 94

4 # @ @$ >

*E G C D (:E\:E, - D / :EP , * D

F <E F D * /:G(EGE / , ! &

& " ! &

& ! 0 ""% % 004 "% " . 4 # > > K >

*E:E, , D ,7P7* /;7 D F <E F D

(: GG P C D , / CJGE7, ( D

-E.G7((7 / P " 6

"3# !" G :

< - ! " 9* *#

@

*E/:/ % 7 D , / CJGE7, ( D <:,:E, . D F <E F D *E G < D %,:E( CJGE7, < :&& & ! " # ! & "

HG- H ! , <P )

" 9* *# $ K

B G:((: * ! # ! 1

! +9 !" A / IS "

2 2 *

94 %" " $ > K K

! " #$$%

& '( #$$(

/ & S (" ! # " & "

F F # / " " #