On the technique of legal expertise of the essence of changes in legislation

Д 343.148:340.6

. . ,

к ю и и ки а к, ,

. . ,

а и а

, . ,

А

Щ

А

А

Ц : ,

, .

: - , - , ,

.

: .

, ,

, ( )

. .

5 2013 . № 173- «

« ,

» 11 2009 . № 538- ( . 29 2011 . № 873- ).

: .

: ,

-, .

: ; ; ; ; ; ; ;

; ; ; .

А А

А

А

. .

« »,

« ,

-, », ,

-, [1, . 352].

« »

( ,

, , ,

)

. ,

,

, .

.

-,

,

щ

.

, ,

,

( )

.

1.

--

(

– ), :

1.1.

( , , ),

( , ,

) , ,

. 1.2.

(

-, , ).

1.3. , ,

,

, ,

,

-.

1.4.

,

, ,

.

2.

,

( . 1). 2.1.

.

. 1 2

2 (« »)

(

) ( )

-, 3 (« »)

2 .

, ,

-,

, ,

, ,

,

, : «

» « ».

2.2. 1 2 3 (« »)

,

-,

( , ,

)

( ) ( ) (

-) .

3 (« »)

3

1 2 : 1)

( , ,

) 2)

,

-:

,

, .

2.3. 1 2 4 (« »)

( 1, 2, 3

. . )

-, , (

-), ,

( ) (

) ( )

.

3 (« »)

4

1 2

-,

( )

( ) ( ).

2.4. 1 2 5 (« »)

( ) ( )

( )

.

(

), 5

–

, –

-,

-.

( )

1 2 5.

-,

, «

».

3 (« »)

5

1 2

.

2.5.

( . 3.2.2).

2.6. ,

( )

-,

. Э ,

( )

,

, .

3. Э

.

3.1. 4 (« ») 3

-,

-, , .

.

-, ,

,

-.

3.2. 4 (« ») 4

-,

-, , .

-:

3.2.1. ( )

. 1 4 (« »)

-« ».

, . .

.

.

,

.

3.2.2. ( )

-,

. 1

4 (« »)

«

-». 1 4 (« »)

« ».

(

4

.

-, . .

.

, . .

.

,

( )

,

,

. . .

,

, . .

.

3 4 (« »)

«

» « ».

,

,

-.

3 4 (« »)

«

».

. 3.2.3.

3.2.3. ( )

( ) ,

-.

1 4 (« »)

« ».

, . .

.

« »

.

4

-.

-, . .

-.

-.

,

(

)

,

-, . . .

«

-» « ».

3.3.

,

.

.

3.3.1. ,

( ),

-, ,

,

,

-.

( ) ,

, .

.

. –

(

). –

,

, ,

,

-, .

« »

,

– ,

, .

3.3.2.

(

-) ,

-.

, ,

.

-- ,

,

,

-. 3.3.3.

,

-,

-,

.

3.3.4. (

),

, ,

-, -.

,

.

3.4.

( ) .

4. Э

( -)

,

-,

-,

-,

.

1*

№

/ 1 2 3 4

1 ( )

2 : : _

3 : :

4 : :

5 : :

* И : .

5 2013 .

1 2 3 4 ( ) : , : , , , ; , -, , - -, ; - , .

. 1–4 . 3 ( . 29.11.2011 № 873- )

: , : , , , ; , , , - -, ; - , -. . 1–4 . 1 . 3 ( . 05.03.2013) :

,

30000 .

- , ,

.

, , ,

30 .

, ,

,

, .

30000 .

-, .

. .1–3, 5 . 3 ( . 29.11.2011).

:

,

30 -

-, ,

.

, , ,

30 .

, ,

,

, .

30 .

-, .

. Ч. 1 3 . 3 ( . 05.03.2013) ...

1

2

1 2 3 4

( )

: .

( . 29.11.2011 № 873- )

: , , ( ) - - , -, .

Ч. 2 . 2 ( . 05.03.2013) :

.

( . 29.11.2011 № 873- )

: , , 30 - , , . , , -, 30 . Ч. 1 3 . 3 ( . 05.03.2013)

, -, ( ) . . 4.1 ...

1 2 3 4

( )

: .

( . 29.11.2011 № 873- ).

:

, PhD, DPhil .

Ч. 3 . 2 ( . 05.03.2013) :

.

( . 29.11.2011 № 873- )

:

,

. № 2.

Ч. 1 . 208 ( . 27.07.2010). : . 2 3

, ,

-,

, PhD,

DPhil ,

( ) - -. . 4.1 : .

( . 29.11.2011 № 873- )

:

1) ;

2) ,

Web of Science ( ) Scopus. Ч. 3 . 2 ( . 05.03.2013)

3

. 1. 5 2013 .

№ 173- « «

, »

11 2009 . № 538- ( . 29 2011 . № 873- )*

: , («

, ,

-» – .6 )

.

-. :

– , , .

. 1, 2 -, .

( . 3.). ,

,

( . 3.1).

( . 3.3).

-,

, . . .

( . 3.2)

.

-.

[2, . 35].

-:

, ,

-, ,

[3, . 27]. ,

.

. 3.2.1 ,

.

-, ( . 3.2.3)

,

-.

,

, . . ,

-.

. 3.2.2 –

. 81

( – )1_.

(

-), . 1–14 . 1 . 81.

,

« ».

-.

« »,

-,

,

.

, ,

. 81 ,

-,

. 1–14 . 1 . 81.

3

2012 . № 231- . 1 . 81 . 7.1

,

-.

.

,

(

,

, ( )

-, ,

. .),

,

. 7.1 . 1 . 81 .

1 ₃₀

2001 . № 197- (

02.04.2014). URL: http://www.consultant.ru/popular/tkrf/

30 2006 . № 90- . 12 . 1 . 81 («

,

»)

(

). Э

. . 3.2.3

( ) ,

( ) ( ) ( . 3.2.2)

. 81 .

,

. « » . 6 . 1 . 81 («

-,

( , ,

)

»),

-: 1)

, 2) (

, , )

.

-.

, ,

-,

,

, .

30 2006 .

№ 90- . « » . 6 . 1 . 81

: «

,

( ,

, )

-».

:

-.

,

-. ,

,

.

,

,

,

, . .

.

. ,

-№ 440058-6

« -

»,

-,

, :

1)

;

2)

-;

3)

-;

4)

.

1. . . : – – :

. ., 1999. 712 .

2. . ., . . :

. ., 2012. 240 .

3. . .

: . ., 2004. 336 .

В 15.05.14

, , , ,

: 614990, . , . ,15, .: (342)293-38-61 -mail: psb59@rambler.ru

, ,

: 614990, . , . ,15, .: (342)293-38-61 -mail: titov.rf@mail.ru

: . ., . .

// . 2014. № 2 (30). . 111–119.

S. B. POLYAKOV,

Doctor of Law, Associate Professor,

N. S. TITOV,

Post-graduate student

Perm State National Research University, Perm, Russia

ON THE TECHNIQUE OF LEGAL EXPERTISE OF THE ESSENCE OF CHANGES IN LEGISLATION Objective: to create algorithms for the study of normative legal acts and their drafts in order to solve the problem, in favor of which legal subjects the changes in the legal regulation of the relations are implemented.

Methods: universal dialectic-materialistic, formal dogmatic, comparative, analysis and synthesis.

Results:the method of legal expertise of changes in the legislation is proposed. The method is used to obtain an objective and verifi able con-clusions about what social groups, associations, state agencies and their offi cials (legal entities) benefi t from the changes introduced into the legal regulation of relations with their participation. Comments to the method are given. The analysis is described of the legal expertise of the Law of the Perm region of March 5, 2013 № 173-PK "On amendments to the Law of the Perm region "On additional measures of social support of certain categories of people awarded with the degree of Doctor of science" of November 11, 2009, № 538-PK (law edition of 29.11.2011 № 873-PK).

Scientifi c novelty: a new type of legal examination of normative legal acts and their drafts is proposed.

Practical value: the technique allows to make objective and verifi able conclusions about in whose favour the legal regulation of social rela-tions is changed, as well as to to reveal the real objectives of the authors of normative legal acts drafts.

Keywords: logical rule of law; rule addressee; law; obligation; prohibition; hypothesis; disposition; sanction; actual composition; legal posi-tion; content and volume of the notion.

References

1. Alekseev, S. S. Pravo: azbuka – teoriya – fi losofi ya: opyt kompleksnogo issledovaniya (Law: the ABC – theory – philosophy: experience of a complex research). Moscow, 1999. 712 p.

2. Kirillov, V. I., Starchenko, A. A. Logika: uchebnik dlya vuzov (Logic: textbook for universities). Moscow, 2012. 240 p.

3. Mikhalkin, N. V. Logika i argumentatsiya v sudebnoi praktike: uchebnik dlya vuzov (Logic and argumetation in the court practice: textbook for universities). Saint-Petersburg, 2004. 336 p.

Received 15.05.14

Information about the authors

Polyakov Sergey Borisovich, Doctor of Law, Associate Professor, Professor of the Chair of Theory and History of State and Law, Perm State National Research University

Address: 15 Bukirev Str., 614990, Perm, tel.: (342)293-38-61 -mail: psb59@rambler.ru

Titov Nikolay Sergeyevich, Post-graduate student of the Chair of Theory and History of State and Law, Perm State National Research University Address: 15 Bukirev Str., 614990, Perm, tel.: (342)293-38-61

-mail: titov.rf@mail.ru

How to cite the article: Polyakov S.B., Titov N.S. On the technique of legal expertise of the essence of changes in legislation.

Aktual’niye problemy ekonomiki i prava, 2014, no. 2 (30), pp. 111–119.