! " # $%&# $'# $%()*%''# $+ $ '(%(
!" # $ %% %
!"
! " # $ %
&
' #
' (
'
)
$ %& ' ( " ( " * + (
, ( ,
- . . .
# - # / 0
1
. # 0 .
+ !
-# .
# ( # 0
# . . . #
0
# # .
) *+ %( " ( " + ( 2 .
! " # $%&# $'# $%()*%''# $+ $ '(%(
, - %.$(/$'((/ 0 .($(1$'(%(
2 - " - 3 4
# " 5
# 6 " 5
-+ #
6 7 -4 # # 5 # $8
3 $ 7%/).8# 6
" # 6 3 - 6 3 #
6 " # "
3 $ 9 # 6 # " 5 :6
$ 9 6 ; "" 7%/)<# $ &8
0
=$$$> 6 :6 6
6 " $ ? 3 - :6
# # #
6 $ :6 @6 A
# B # 6 # $
=$$$> 0
# "6 #
:C # 6
:6 :6 " 36 $
D - 93 E 7%//)# $ %&&8 :6 @ 6
B 6 6
# 6 # 6 6 "F
6 A$ ; 7%/)/8%# D - 93 E 7%//)# $ %&&8#
@6 "6 :6
" 6 - "
6 " # # - #
6 36 A$ G #
7%//1# $ .<.8# @ 6 6 6 #
6 # 6 B "
6 " # 6 :6 3
F 6 A$
H 0 # 4 3 6
# " $
6 # " 6
" 5 $ 0 6 6 6
6 6 6 6 # :6
# - $ 0
" "6 " B 5 6
1
! " # $%&# $'# $%()*%''# $+ $ '(%(
# :6 " " # # #
* " 5 6 :6
$ ? # 3
" I 6 3 #
6 # "
- $
? * :6 6 3
-46 :6 6 6 6 6 B 6
6 $ # - :6
6 6 6 # :6
:6 # "
6 $
9 - * :6 -4 6
:6 # #
# 6 6 " #
-"
" $ 0 6 # :6
I # 6 5
" 5 # 6 6 $
!
36
# :6 - " I 6 6 :6
3 - B 6 " $ ? * :6
" - $ 9
- # :6 " J
- " 6 6
" $ 0 # - :6 #
6 " 6 " #
B $ H ; "" 7%/)1# $ &8# B
- :6 #
# " $ K :6 6 6
# 6 6 # $
! # # F 6
" B #
B $ 0 - "
6 :6 "
F $
L "6 5 "
" 5 :6 " * 3 # :6
" :6 " 5 " " $
9 6 7%//.# $ ..8# 6 6 3
36 6 6 6 6 3 :6 #
- $ 0 6
6 6 " # 6 "
! " # $%&# $'# $%()*%''# $+ $ '(%(
6 6 3 5
M $ 6 6 3 B
-4 # 6 # - # 6 6 -6 #
:6 I 6 6 6 3 $ N :6
# 6 6 5 #
" 5 I 6 6 B # 6 6 6
6 6 $
? 3 M # :6 2; 6
7%//&# $ O8 " 6 * $
#
# - 6 - 70 2?# %//%# $ %.8$
6 6 5 36 #
3 F 6 :6 F " 3
-F 6 # :6 " 3
6 " $ 0 36
6 M # :6
5 $
0 "6 5 7 8
" # :6 "6 :6 :6 "
6 J 7-8 B 5 6
"6 6 # :6 6 5 J 7 8
6 I # 3
" 6 - # "
" 5 4 7 2H!?J , 99# %//18$
"
!
9 6 P 3 7'(('# $ 1<8# "
-3
6 F" :6 :6 6 6
- $ * :6
* - " 5 7 3
-6 5 8 " 5
7 8#
6 # # :6 :6
$
# :6 6
6 :6 5 #
" B 6
- $ #
" 6 :6 5 $
? * :6 - 6 " " $ H
0 # 6 # 6 5 #
3 B F"
# :6 5 6
" " $ 2 # :6 6F 6 6
-4 # :6
! " # $%&# $'# $%()*%''# $+ $ '(%(
* # # # 6
6 # 6 6 # 3
D 6 7%/&18$
7%//1# $ .1%8# 6
" 6 6 QQ# :6
6 #
6 # '(# R6 7%/'(8# 6
6
7%8 - - F # :6 6
- - :6 - 3 6 F
6 J
7'8 B # :6 6 5 " F
- J
7.8 # :6 # - # 6
3 6 :6
6 $ * # - # :6
" 6 3
$
0 6 6 :6
B F 6 # # "$ H 6 # 3 #
2 . . # 4 0 5 + . + # ! # L90# 6 6
" * #
'((1# " :6 B
5 - - F $ 0 # F 6 #
7:6 3
F 8 7:6
- S 8$ * # #
$
"#
$
H 9 3 7%/)%# $ ''8# 6
-36 6 $ ? " " #
0 J B "
:6 R6 7%/'(8 - - $ K
0 # " 6
$ 2 :6 :6 6 " " # :6
6 F" - # 6 6 #
6 '(# - 6 6 0 #
" 6 4 F
6" # :6 - #
6 $
0 0 6
3 :6 " 6 $ ? # "
! " # $%&# $'# $%()*%''# $+ $ '(%( "
36 - 3 B :6
$ 0 "
6 - $ 0 #
:6 # 6 4 # " 6
36 # 6 " 36 #
36 # # - #
6 6 " * 6 6 $ 0 "
6 B " - *
- 6 $ - 6
46 :6 -4 # 6 B # :6 B - F
6" :6 " J :6 B
-F * - # - #
- # 6 " 6 $ G :6
- 6 6 # F
S :6 - $ 0 #
# :6 6 6 6 B
6 # 64 " " $ T6
3 :6 # F"
6 -6 $ 96 3 :6
3 6 F" # @ A 7 "
) ' 8# 6 7 8
@ A 7 " ) 6 2
- - 3 " "
# G 7%/&'8$ 2 6 :6 6
6 46 -6 " #
:6 3 6 $ 0 46
-6 :6 " 6 - :6
# B # :6 46 :6
- :6 # 6 4 # 6 S B :6
" $
T6 7%/1/# $ 'O%8 " :6 6
-M 1( <(
6 " 6 B U
$ - 6 B 6
F 6" # -
6-:6 " F :6 " 6
6 # 6 4 @ 6 6 A#
F :6 5
# :6 # " 6 6 # 3 36
" 6 #
-6 6 $
0 F "
9 3 7%/)%8 " "
7 8 - $ ! 6
S " #
! " # $%&# $'# $%()*%''# $+ $ '(%( %
6 6
- 5 J
7-8 6 -6 " 6 F $ K
- 6 3 -6 " #
36 * - 3 # 3
-- - J
7 8 7 6 46 -6 8 B
6 7:6 - 8$ H :6 "
" :6 6 6 6 6 # 6
- 3 :6 6 $
0 F # - *
6 # :6 # S 6
6 # :6 " 6 #
- 3 #
-- %/'( %/<( 79 !KRJ 2H!?#%/)%# $ '.8$
6
7%8 # :6 6
J 6 " 5 :6 *
6 I:6 $ B #
3 6 F" V G * 6
F 6 3 6 # 6 46
" 5 :6 6 F" $ *
- :6 F" # # J
3 6 F J 3 6
F" J
7'8 F " 6
6 :6 6" 6 #
" $ L -4 :6 #
3 6 M 6 6 6 " 6 " 3
6 M 6 J 6 " " #
" 6 6 M 6 $ T6 :6 6 M 6
# B # 3 # :6 6
3 * # " F
6 I:6 J
7.8 6 # * :6
6- 6 F 6 * $
T6 :6 6 -4 6 F :6
" 3 6 @ A# B # - :6 #
- # F " @" A# @ A
6 @ A$
0 6 6
3 # 6 6
-F $ ? * # 6 # :6 6 6
S 6 - # 6
# # :6 # #
! " # $%&# $'# $%()*%''# $+ $ '(%( &
- 3 6
:6 $
; "" 7%/)<# $ 18 :6 6
6 6 F # # :6 " :6
6 6 - $ H " # #
$ 2 #
# 6 " :6 # 6
3 F $
0 6 -4 5 - - "
9 3 7%/)%# $%1'8
7%8 B 46 7 :6
:6 6 5 F " 8J
7'8 B "6 7 "F #
:6 6 5 :6 F " 6
3 :6 6 6- 8J
7.8 6" " F "
$
6 - 6 B
7%8 " " 7 :6 6
S - F " 8J
7'8 3 " " F J
7.8 6 F # J
7O8 - :6 # I # 46
7 6
-8 6 :6 6 6
$
D 2W ; P 7%//(# $ ''/8 " 6 F
7%8 6 "
6 J
7'8 # :6
6 46 F #
$
H 5 6 # * :6
" 3 "
6 :6
6 46 -6 $ ? * :6 #
6 " 5 6 # " "
# " -6 :6 "
# 6 :6
! " # $%&# $'# $%()*%''# $+ $ '(%( '
- # 6
36 -6 :6 " $
"# $
(
H 2W ; P 7%//(8# K "
" B "
" -6 $ 9 6 6 3W 7'(('# $ <.8 F
- 6" #
:6 @ A
:6 # $ ? # 6
6 " 5 -6 :6 "
F - # # B # @
:6 A$ 0 # 6 # B 6
F :6 - 6 # 6
6 F :6 6
6 - 6 J
- 6 $
G 2 , 3 :6 " 6 6
:6 :6 $ H 6 - 3 <(#
6 - :6 #
" :6
- 6 # 36 - B "
3 :6 6 7, 9 R# %/<&J %/<)8$ F
"6 6 :6
$ L
-6 - :6 6 6 -6
6 # :6 5
-B 5 $ 2 6 # 6
B 6 :6 :6 3
6 - S F
:6 # 6 # 3 6 F 7 6
36 8 " $ H
# 6 6
F # 6 " 5 $ L
-6 6"
6 $ 6 6
# 6 :6 # M - #
3 # :6
-F $ L B 6
F :6 6 3 6 6 6 J :6 "
" 3 6 :6 4
" - 6 7 6
F" 6 B 8 7 0,H?2,# %//1# $ .1&8
, 3 7%/<&8 :6 :6
! " # $%&# $'# $%()*%''# $+ $ '(%( )
:6 F 6 :6 6
- # -6 6
-$ 2 6 # 46 :6
- 6 :6 " 6 M 6 6
6 6 $ 0 # 6 6
# 6 3 $
9 6 P - 7%//(8#
-6
7 8 6 6 6 F J
7-8 6 6 B
6 6 6 I J
7 8 " 6 J
7 8 - 6
6 J
7 8 3 6 " 6 -
-6 J
7"8 F #
- $
H # 3 F # 6
# 6 6
-6 # " $
? # -4 " 6
# 7 " 6
3 - # 6 # B 8#
# "6 7 " 6 3
# 6 # B 8$ 0
-6 # * #
-# :6 " 6 6
B 6 $
F
2W ; P 7%//(# $ '.&8
%$ 0 F 6 6 6 - 6 J
'$ ? 3 6 46 -6
6" 6 6 $
2 - 3 6 46 -6 #
6" 6 J
.$ 6
- 6 #
# B # @" 6 A
@ AJ
O$ B 6
6 :6 6 $ 2B 6
! " # $%&# $'# $%()*%''# $+ $ '(%(
&$ 0 " B 6
-6 6 -4
J
1$ 0 # 6 6 3 :6 #
F 6 # - # 6- #
B # @" 6 A# @ 4 A @ 4 A$ 9 6 , 3
7%/<)8 F " 3
6 6 46 $
2B 6 6 :6
:6 3 :6
36 :6 - 6 F
$ B # - 3
-6 2 , 3 7%/<&8# :6 "
"
$ 0 6 6 6 6 S 6
$ ? 26 #
B # 3 6 :6
6 $ 2 # # 6 *?
6 F #
, 3 7, 9 R# %/<.J %/<&8 %/<(#
6 :6
6 " $ 0 :6 " 3
" # " 3 :6 6F :6 - 3
# " 6 :6 3 6
@=$$$> " 6 " 6-4
-" " CF A 7R2!H2,# %/<'# $ '(8$
0 :6 - # "
:6 - 6 # # :6
" - # :6 6
- 6 6 F #
3 6 S F $ G
- :6 - " #
46 " 6 # 64 - "
* $
2 " 6
- 6 # 6 $
B # " @ A @6 6 #
:6 6 AJ - F 7 # #
6 8 " :6 - F 7
6 # :6 - 6 :6 8 79 !KR#
%/<)J 9 !KRJ 2H!?# %/)%8$ 6 F # *
:6 - F
:6 64 :6 - 6
! " # $%&# $'# $%()*%''# $+ $ '(%(
7%8 - 6 :6
- F # "
M J
7'8 - F 6
-" :6 - F $
6 , 3 7%/<&8 B
:6 3 " F
$ - F 6 3 "
# 3 6 6 36 -6
B $
0 6
# 6 F :6
6- 6F* $ 2W ; P 7%//(# $ './8 6
F
-7%8 F F #
# 6 6 J
R 7%/)%8 B 6 :6
-" 6 :6 6 B - 6 6 6
6 # @6 A# @6 A @6 A$ !
6 B " B - 6
- # " J
7'8
3 :6 6 - 5
$ B # # 6
@ A# - - :6 :6
6 :6 4 :6 6 $ 2 - *
:6 6 -6 " :6 6 J
7.8 B :6
$ 0 B " :6 6
3 # 6 4 #
6 :6 -6
6 $ # :6 3 4 S
# I " :6 6 6
- -6 3 # :6 # #
$
6 F - 9 3 7%/)%8 :6
6 :6 B
:6 B 7 B #
@ B :6 A8 $
2 6 5 6 3F- # :6
6 6 6 # 3
:6 - 6
" 7 0,H?2,# %//1# $ .1<8$ ?
-9 3 7%/)%# $&&8# 6 3F- :6 @
! " # $%&# $'# $%()*%''# $+ $ '(%(
6
-36 A
%
*
+
0 " 6
:6 $ 9 - * :6 #
3 :6 :6 # 6 I 6 6 #
6 * :6 5
3 5 $ 0 " 6 B
:6 # :6 :6 6
" :6 # * 6 $
3 :6 3
3 6 # - :6 "
6 6 " 6 :6 6 "
$ - 4 :6 5
" #
:6 I " # " " U
B # :6 -4 $
0 B 5
" $ Y 6 "F - 3
:6
" $ 6 # " 6
B " J 6 #
B " #
6 4 # :6 " :6 4 $
K " 6 6
" $ :6 B :6 :6 3
6 # $ L 6
3F-- 6 "
"
6 $ 0 6 # 6 #
# 6 :6
# :6 6 - B 5
" 6 $
& , +
-0 2?# $ $ 3 " "
$ 1 + 0 # 7 # 8 . $ '1# $.*
.<# %//%$
,L?2,# D$ 9$J 0L9K!?# $ 1 . # / $ ? E Z ; [ W# %/&1$
!?9# 0$ $J TL! !0?# $ ,$ , " W$
! " # $%&# $'# $%()*%''# $+ $ '(%(
2P L?H# D$ " + , # .
# # 0 $0 0 $ H F
\3 ++ $ 6$ 6$ 6+ + 6 E -/&+ +3W B + ; 6 +
B$3 ]$ 0 %& $ '(('$
2Z92?P# $ [J P20?2# $ K$ " + . . 6 ^ 3 - ;$
6 2 - 6 0 # %//($
G,2 2# $ " $ ! 20 R# $J 0 P# $ 72 8$
- # 0 # 9 : B"
;E # %/&'$
0,H?2,# R$ 1 + * 6 3 6
$ 9 6 2HL9 # %//1$
R0 K ?# D$ 0 " 3 6 " - $ , .
; # $ # $%O/*%&1# %/)%$
R2!H2,# 2$ ,$ L W$ < #
= 2 . .# $ /.# $%(*'(# %/<'$
RL # $ $ T6 " 3 6 " $ 2
, $ .)# $%'.# $%*)1# %/'($
D0 # 2$ P$J 9R0[# H$ 9 $
1 + 0 # 7 # 8 .# $ ..# $ %.%*%)&#
%//)$
P 2! 2,# $ > ' . & = $
L G # %//($
P R# !$ $ X$ 3 + = 9 6 #
'(('$ %1) $
0P GG# $ ? # E +
3 K3 L W " 3 # %/)<$
0,P 0?# 2$ $ " #
$ - # 0 !K # %/)/$
2H!?# H$ J , 99# $ R$ " + . .$ ' $ G 3 [ 3
R 6 6- 3 #%//1$
2,X!9# $ $J 0K !?# D$J , 9 R# 2$ , 3 * "*
B # W # E " :6 W$ @ #
2 . 8 .# $ # $ .# $ ').*')O# %/<1$
,2!,0# $ 0$ 1 4 + / $
9 0 $ 0 # , !GLG, 9# %//.$
L, RZ# $ $ - / # $ - !K # '(('$
9 2,9 ?# H$ ?$J 9 !KR# 2$ 2$ 3 :6 W " W 3 W
3 W " $ " # $ /# $ .&*&)# %/)%$
!2H0H2# $ 0$ ,$ 7 A # $ , 4
! " # $%&# $'# $%()*%''# $+ $ '(%(
, 9 R# 2$ ? 6 $ " + 2 . . $ O# $ .')*.&(#
%/<.$
, 9 R# 2$ " $ < #
= W 3 W # $ %(O# $ %/'*'..# %/<&$
, 9 R# 2$J 2,X!9# $ $ G W - 6 3
6 6 " $ " + 2 . . $ <# $ &<.*1(&# %/<&$
, 9 R# 2$ 2 # $ ! , 9 R# 2$J Z H# $ $
72 $8$ " $ R # ?$D$ 2 - 6 #%/<)$
, 9 R# 2$J Z H# $ $ 72 $8$ " $ R #
?$D$ 2 - 6 #%/<)$
,L992 # $ A History of Western Philosophy# 0 _ L E #
%/O1$
9 !KR# 2$ 2$ K3 " W$ ! 29K29# [$ P$ 72 $8$
B / # + $ #
2 - 6 #%/<)$
9 !KR# 2$ 2$J 2H!?# H$ $ " $ - #