rev bras hematol hemoter. 2015;37(3):150–152
w w w . r b h h . o r g
Revista
Brasileira
de
Hematologia
e
Hemoterapia
Brazilian
Journal
of
Hematology
and
Hemotherapy
Scientific
Comment
The
compound
state:
Hb
S/beta-thalassemia
夽
Maria
Stella
Figueiredo
∗UniversidadeFederaldeSãoPaulo(UNIFESP),SãoPaulo,SP,Brazil
Sickle cell disease (SCD) results from a single amino acid substitution in the gene encoding the -globin subunit (6Glu>Val) that produces the abnormal hemoglobin (Hb) namedHb S.SCD hasdifferent genotypeswithsubstantial variationsinpresentationandclinicalcourse(Table1).1,2The combinationofthesicklecellmutationandbeta-thalassemia (-Thal)mutationgivesrisetoacompoundheterozygous con-ditionknownasHbS/thalassemia(HbS/-Thal),whichwas firstdescribedin1944bySilvestroniandBianco.3
ThepolymerizationofdeoxygenatedHbS(sickling)isthe primaryeventinthe molecularpathogenesisofSCD. How-ever,thisevent ishighlydependentontheintracellularHb composition;inotherwords,itisdependentonthe concen-trationofHbS,andtypeandconcentrationoftheothertypes ofHb.Therefore, themajorprimarygeneticdeterminantof theseverityofSCDisthegenotype.2,4–6
Many different -Thal mutations have been associated withHbS,andthemolecularbasisofthethalassemiainHb S/-Thalindividualsreflectsthespectrumof-Thalmutations observedinaparticularpopulation.5,7–12Theheterogeneityof the-Thalmutationsleadstoquantitativelydifferent-globin synthesisandconsequentlytodifferentamountsofHbA.This factresultsinvariableclinicalmanifestations,rangingfrom nearlyasymptomatictoasevereconditionsimilartosicklecell anemia(homozygousHbS).3,13Thereisnoconsensusabout theclassificationofHbS/-Thal,butitisusuallyclassifiedin twotypes:HbS/0-ThalandHbS/+-Thal.2,4
Hb S/0-Thal, inwhich the productionof Hb Ais abol-ished, is often clinically indistinguishable from sickle cell anemia. The thalassemia acts on sickled red blood cells, inducing microcytosis, hypochromia, and sometimes Hb F iselevated.Thisresultinanimprovementofthecirculatory competenceofthesecells,areductionofhemolysis,and a
DOIoforiginalarticle:http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.bjhh.2015.03.010. 夽
SeepaperbyBelisárioetal.onpages198-201.
∗ Correspondingauthorat:RuaDr.DiogodeFaria,824,3◦andar,CEP:04037-002,VilaClementino,SãoPaulo,SP,Brazil.
E-mailaddress:stella.figueiredo@unifesp.br
smallincreaseinHbconcentrationandinpackedcellvolume. However,theseeffectsarenotaccompaniedbyanyreduction invaso-occlusiveevents,probablyduetothegreatnumberof HbS-containingredblood cellsresultinginincreasedblood viscosity.4,5
A confusing diagnostic problem is the differentiation of Hb S/0-Thal from sickle cell anemia associated with ␣-thalassemia. Table 2 shows that hematologic and elec-trophoreticstudiesareunabletodistinguishbetweenthetwo conditionsandsofamilystudiesandDNAanalysisareneeded toconfirmthediagnosis.5
InHbS/+-Thal,variableamountsofHbAdiluteHbSand consequently inhibit polymerization-induced cellular dam-age.TheHbAlevelsvaryfrom<5%to45%ofthehemolysate and higher levels of Hb A are usually associated with a milderphenotype.5,8,12–15However,becauseofthe confound-inginfluencesofothergeneticmodifiers,suchas␥-globingene expression and ␣-thalassemia, arigid genotype–phenotype correlationisdifficulttoestablish.5
AclassificationofHbS/+-ThalintoTypesI(HbA:1–7%), II(HbA:7–14%),orIII(HbA:14–25%)accordingtothelevelof HbAhasbeenproposed.3,14However,thisclassificationisnot widelyacceptedandcouldbeconsideredoflittleutility. Nowa-daysit ispossibletodefinethe-Thalmutationexactlyby molecularbiologytechniques,anddeterminetherelationship betweenmutationandclinicalmanifestations.5
Thedeterminationofthe-ThalmutationinHbS/+-Thal individualswasperformedbyBesilarioetal.Theseauthors studiedfourpatientswithanHbAconcentrationabove38% andaverymildformofthedisease,andidentifiedtwo muta-tions for the first time in the Brazilian population.16 It is importanttopointoutthatthesecasescouldbewrongly inter-pretedassicklecelltrait,sincetheyhadnoanemia,despite
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.bjhh.2015.02.008
revbrashematolhemoter.2015;37(3):150–152
151
Table1–Sicklecelldiseasegenotypes.
Severesicklecelldisease
Sicklecellanemia(HbS/S) 6Glu>Val/6Glu>Val Themostcommonform
HbS/0thalassemia Multiplemutations Mostprevalentintheeastern
MediterraneanregionandIndia
SevereHbS/+thalassemia Multiplemutations Mostprevalentintheeastern
MediterraneanregionandIndia HbS/OArab 6Glu>Val/121Glu>Lys NorthAfrica,theMiddleEast,andthe
Balkans
HbS/DPunjab 6Glu>Val/121Glu>Gln PredominantinnorthernIndia
HbS/CHarlem 6Glu>Val/6Glu>Val/,73Asp>Asn Veryrare
Moderatesicklecelldisease
HbS/C 6Glu>Val/6Glu>Lys 25–30%casesofsicklecelldiseaseof
Africanorigin
ModerateHbS/+thalassemia Multiplemutations MostintheeasternMediterraneanregion
Mildsicklecelldisease
MildHbS/++thalassemia Multiplemutations MostlyinpopulationsofAfricanorigin
HbS/E 6Glu>Val/26Glu>Lys HbEpredominatesinsoutheastAsia
Verymildsicklecelldisease
HbS/HereditaryPersistenceofFetalHemoglobin Largedeletionsofthe-globingenecomplex
Source:ModifiedfromReesetal.1
Table2–Laboratorydifferentiationofsicklecellanemia,sicklecellanemia/␣-thalassemia,andHbS/0-thalassemia.
Diagnosis Levelvariation MeanHbF(%)
Hemoglobin(g/dL) MCV(fl) HbA2(%)
SCA 7–8 85–95 2.5–3.5 5
SCA/␣-thalassemia 8–10 70–85 3.5–4.5 5
HbS/0-thalassemia 8–10 65–75 4–6 9
Source:ModifiedfromSteinbergetal.5
SCA:sicklecellanemia;MCV:meancorpuscularvolume;HbA2:hemoglobinA2;HbF:hemoglobinfetal.
alittlemicrocytosis,andthatthisincorrectdiagnosiswould reflectinthegeneticcounselingprovided.Insummary,this studyreinforcestheimportanceofmolecularstudiesinour population,inordertoenhanceourknowledgeaboutthe dis-easeinBrazilandconsequentlyimprovegeneticcounseling, followup,andtreatment.
Conflicts
of
interest
Theauthordeclaresnoconflictsofinterest
Acknowledgments
TheauthorwishestothankCoordenac¸ãodeAperfeic¸oamento dePessoaldeNivelSuperior(CAPES)andConselhoNacionalde DesenvolvimentoCientíficoeTecnológico(CNPq)forfinancial support.
r
e
f
e
r
e
n
c
e
s
1. ReesDC,GibsonJS.Biomarkersinsicklecelldisease.BrJ Haematol.2012;156(4):433–45.
2. StuartMJ,NagelRL.Sickle-celldisease.Lancet. 2004;364(9442):1343–60.
3.DacieJ.Thehereditaryhaemolyticanaemias.3rded.New York:ChurchillLivingstone;1988.
4.TheinSL.Geneticmodifiersofsicklecelldisease. Hemoglobin.2011;35(5-6):589–606.
5.SteinbergMH.Compoundheterozygousandothersickle hemoglobinopathies.In:SteinbergMH,ForgetBG,HiggsDR, NagelRL,editors.Disordersofhemoglobin:genetics, pathophysiology,andclinicalmanagement.1sted.
Cambridge,UK:CambridgeUniversityPress;2001.p.786–810. 6.ForgetBG,BunnHF.Classificationofthedisordersof
hemoglobin.ColdSpringHarbPerspectMed. 2013;3(2):a011684.
7.RiganoP,RodgersGP,RendaD,RendaMC,AquinoA,Maggio A.Clinicalandhematologicalresponsestohydroxyureain SicilianpatientswithHbS/beta-thalassemia.Hemoglobin. 2001;25(1):9–17.
8.SchmuggeM,WayeJS,BasranRK,ZurbriggenK,Frischknecht H.TheHbS/beta+-thalassemiaphenotypedemonstratesthat theIVS-I(−2)(A>C)mutationisamildbeta-thalassemia
allele.Hemoglobin.2008;32(3):303–7.
9.LacanP,PonceauB,AubryM,FrancinaA.MildHb
S-beta(+)-thalassemiawithadeletionoffivenucleotidesat thepolyadenylationsiteofthebeta-globingene.Hemoglobin. 2003;27(4):257–9.
10. BoletiniE,SvobodovaM,DivokyV,BaysalE,CurukMA, DimovskiAJ,etal.Sicklecellanemia,sicklecell beta-thalassemia,andthalassemiamajorinAlbania: characterizationofmutations.HumGenet.1994;93(2):182–7. 11.Gonzalez-RedondoJM,KutlarA,KutlarF,McKieVC,McKie
152
revbrashematolhemoter.2015;37(3):150–152beta-thalassemiainAmericanblacks.AmJHematol. 1991;38(1):9–14.
12.DivokyV,BaysalE,SchiliroG,DibenedettoSP,HuismanTH.A mildtypeofHbS-beta(+)-thalassemia[−92(C→T)]ina
Sicilianfamily.AmJHematol.1993;42(2):225–6.
13.KinneyTR,WareRE.Compoundheterozygousstates.In: EmburySH,HebbelRP,MohandasN,SteinbergMH,editors. Sicklecelldisease:basicprinciplesandclinicalpractice.1st ed.NewYork:RavenPressLtd.;1994.p.437–51.
14.SerjeantGR,SerjeantBE,FraserRA,HambletonIR,HiggsDR, KulozikAE,etal.HbS-beta-thalassemia:molecular, hematologicalandclinicalcomparisons.Hemoglobin. 2011;35(1):1–12.
15.SerjeantGR.Thenaturalhistoryofsicklecelldisease.Cold SpringHarbPerspectMed.2013;3(10):a011783.